Public Records Request No. 19-372 Page 1 of 2 Barbara Burns - -- .. ~--------- From: Barbara Burns Sent: Thursday, April 01, 2010 8:49 AM To: 'Jack Goldberger' Cc: Michael McAuliffe Subject: RE: Epstein I shared your latest email with Mr. McAuliffe and we both agree that it is our position that he needs to honor his commitment and complete his community control as agreed. If you feel it necessary to file a motion to modify or early terminate on behalf of your client just let me know so I can have enough time to get the Det. and victims notified so they can appear for the hearing. Thanks! From: Jack Goldberger [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, March 31, 2010 5:03 PM To: Barbara Burns Subject: Epstein Barbara It is obvious you have spent a lot oftime on my request for my client and I sincerely appreciate the thoroughness and the attention. As my clients case seems to lend itself to misunderstandings and miscommunications by others, I thought it important to clarify some facts assumed in error. I have spoken to Mr. Gaines at probation and he confirmed the following: Yes termination of supervision on a sex offender is unusual, however a modification to probation from Community control is not uncommon when the probationer has been in compliance without violation. In fact the department's current policy on re-entry to the community dictates that an offender be stepped down as soon as possible. He was also under the misimpression, as others might have been, that Epstein's charges called for sex offender probation. They do not, he is eligible for normal probation. As with many of the issues in my clients case, sterile questions that may have been asked tend to lead to answers that though well meaning are not applicable. As for the timeliness of the police reports of the attempted breakins, I wanted you to be aware that I confirmed with Wackenhut that they called the police each time and spoke to the captain on duty, there should be a record. I said to you it was my advice to the client that he not file a formal report. You have suggested that to resolve all the issues my client move to transfer his community control and that your office would support his transfer. I appreciate that and spoke to Mr. Gaines about that and he doesn't believe that would be possible to New York. Mr. Gaines suggested an agreement to allow Mr. Epstein to travel for business purposes without the present 48 hour limitation but strictly at the discretion and with the approval of probation for the remaining short portion of his supervision would be appropriate. He advised me that the department would not object to such a modification. This to me is the fairest way to deal with the issues, and to insure Mr. Epstein is treated like others, Let me know and I can prepare some proposed language that I think would work for everyone Jack Goldberger 561-659-8300 Phone 561-835-8691 Fax 4/1/2010

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Box ID o{'Special ID Our-Ticket Numl)er A BETTER COPY CENTER - • "Serving the legal & business communities in Palm Beach County and beyond since 1r ""'~ with all their document production, display enlargements, and color reproduction nee,

Public Records Request No. 19-372 R~: 'ri~~ibJe \JoP ( ?>/ ,q/ (J(j) , I

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Page 2 of2 P. Please note: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from state officials regarding state business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communications may therefore be subject to public disclosure. 4/1/2010

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Barbara Burns From: Michael McAuliffe Sent: To: Thursday, April 01, 2010 8:31 AM Barbara Burns Subject: RE: Epstein I think, as you suggest, the defendant simply needs to finish his sentence as it was agreed to in the initial resolution. Thanks. MM -----Original Message----- From: Barbara Burns Sent: Thursday, April 01, 2010 08:25 AM Eastern Standard Time To: Michael McAuliffe; Paul Zacks Subject: FW: Epstein This dragon just keeps raising its ugly head! May I tell him to just file his motion to modify with the Court? I don't know how to convey to him anymore than I already have that his client is a registered sex offender that was fortunate to get the deal of the century, fortunate enough, even as a sex offender, to be granted work release while serving his jail sentences (I am not aware of that ever happening before) and certainly fortunate to plea at a time when it was not required by statute that he be placed on sex offender probation with all of the restrictive conditions that the vast majority of individuals in his similar situation would have been subjected to. Please advise. From: Jack Goldberger [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, March 31, 2010 5:03 PM To: Barbara Burns Subject: Epstein Barbara It is obvious you have spent a lot of time on my request for my client and I sincerely appreciate the thoroughness and the attention. As my clients case seems to lend itself to misunderstandings and miscommunications by others, I thought it important to clarify some facts assumed in error. I have spoken to Mr. Gaines at probation and he confirmed the following : Yes termination of supervision on a sex offender is unusual, however a modification to probation from Community control is not uncommon when the probationer has been in compliance without violation. In fact the department's current policy on re-entry to the community dictates that an offender be stepped down as soon as possible. He was also under the misimpression, as others might have been, that Epstein's charges called for sex offender probation. They do not, he is eligible for normal probation. As with many of the issues in my clients case, sterile questions that may have been asked tend to lead to answers that though well meaning are not applicable. As for the timeliness of the police reports of the attempted breakins, I wanted you to be aware that I confirmed with Wackenhut that they called the police each time and spoke to the captain on duty, there should be a record. I said to you it was my advice to the client that he not file a formal report. 1

Public Records Request No. 19-372 You have suggested that to resolve all the issues my client move to transfer his community control and that your office would support his transfer. I appreciate that and spoke to Mr. Gaines about that and he doesn't believe that would be possible to New York. Mr. Gaines suggested an agreement to allow Mr. Epstein to travel for business purposes without the present 48 hour limitation but strictly at the discretion and with the approval of probation for the remaining short portion of his supervision would be appropriate. He advised me that the department would not object to such a modification . This to me is the fairest way to deal with the issues, and to insure Mr. Epstein is treated like others, Let me know and I can prepare some proposed language that I think would work for everyone Jack Goldberger 561-659-8300 Phone 561-835-8691 Fax Please note: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from state officials regarding state business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communications may therefore be subject to public disclosure. 2

Public Records Request No. 19-372 . ,Iv f~' 6 hJ~c,t I - - - - - - - - - - ()f PJ:V',e,i.d'f),. t~ ;.~ -P/3 PD ,; 3 ; ~_Jef 1 ~:JJi'jJt,S f . 7. F -- s. 6, 1 ~ -f;G (!.~ ~ /}01Jq,, -- ,_ ____ _ ,~~/, ~ i/2;n / ~~~et/ _ Dy Ulom,'JIJ. l)DC.. @f<! i uJn 1~, u. _ ~ - & (_oo l~d JaM . ~~:,L_?) ( ll~if ~_!21,,0/;~ ___ ___..l)DC Oh.. Cmnes BufR. __ b -i' ----------- ,..;...._ ____ , __ _ /4/ fJ lj h-f ? {,:,~ wl<. ~/21. ~ f)~oo/1 ,i, d~ C/J/tf/~ke ~oo .. l'/2~/6e~~ - ...:;___----=-=;.:L;= - =- ** aJ- #,,_ h~of dMI of 1r11yo,;~. {()IJl</J~ ~6oJ Of<ltt!aid- 11 if~ uio/~:1. ( V/J I ~ ,yhdJ I I j I (l) ~ l di~ fuJ} _f le cl;is 0(J &1mf l'ln1j e»-def/@~; ------! - { ,./ff(Ju:s2- &t-J11-e.Jf) j_ . -11

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Confidential Page 1 of 2 Barbara Burns --- --- - --- ·---~ From: Barbara Burns Sent: Friday, March 26, 2010 9:02 AM To: Michael McAuliffe Subject: FW: Confidential As per your request I am forwarding the following summary: Re: The Burglary/Attempted Burglary allegations, the Palm Beach PD were surprised to hear this and indicated that there has never been such complaint(s) since Epstein was place on Community Control. I spoke further with Jack Goldberger and he indicated that Epstein employs private security through Wackenhut and they intercepted this person who was dressed in black like a Ninja and hiding in some bushes. They chased him to a dark Chrysler 300 and took down the tag info. From there they were able to find out that it was registered to a Pl that has been associated/linked to Atty. Rothstein and the Gambino family. I spoke with DOC Community Control Supervisor, Ofc. Gaines, and he advised me that late last week Epstein informed him of a similar incident. Ofc. Gaines went on to say that he spoke with Epstein in late Sept. or possibly Oct. of last year and explained to him that he received "the best deal ever heard of for someone in his situation" and that he warned him to follow every condition by the letter so as not to get violated. If violated, he could very well be put on an ankle bracelet which would be even more of a restriction to him. Re: Similar defendants on community control and early termination, drawing from my experience (8 ½ yrs. of doing these cases), Daliah Weiss, Chief of SVU, and DOC there is no known case where a Sex Offender on Community Control has ever been given early termination of Community Control by agreement from our office or DOC. There have been rare instances where a person who has been on a very long probation has been given early termination of probation after serving a considerable number of years on probation. Re: The position of the U.S. Attorney's office on early termination of the State's case against Epstein, I again spoke with AUSA Villafana and inquired specifically of any knowledge that she had in reference to representations made by her or anyone associated with her office regarding Epstein's efforts to early term his Community Control on the State charges. She indicated that she had not made any such representations however her boss, interim U.S. Atty. Sloman may have. After checking she sent me a portion of the last letter sent to Epstein's attorneys. I have forwarded that to you by attachment. Please let me know ifthere is anything else that I can provide to you. From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS) [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, March 25, 2010 4:20 PM To: Barbara Burns Subject: Confidential Hi Barbara - Here is the relevant portion of the last letter to JE' s attorneys regarding the termination of superv1s1on: In light of Mr. Acosta's prior statements to Mr. Epstein's counsel that Mr. Epstein would be eligible for any benefit available to other similarly-situated state defendants, the Office agrees that Mr. Epstein may apply for early termination or modification of community control in accordance with Fl. Stat.§§ 948.05 and 948.10(4), assuming that Mr. Epstein has completed "the sanctions imposed in the community control plan." The Office takes no position regarding such an application; it is entirely within the discretion of the State Attorney's Office and the Palm Beach County Circuit Court Judge as to whether it is in "the best interests of justice and the welfare of society" to allow Mr. Epstein to terminate prematurely his community control. Mr. Epstein and his counsel may not make a 3/26/2010

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Confidential Page 2 of2 representation to the State Attorney's Office, the Court, or any victim that the U.S. Attorney's Office agrees with, joins in, or does not oppose such a motion. In light of prior erroneous statements in court filings, we respectfully request that a copy of any court filing be provided to our office. If such a motion is made, in accordance with your proposal, the U.S. Attorney's Office will notify the federal victims that the application was filed and, if a hearing is scheduled, the date, time, and location of such hearing. The communication will consist merely of a notification and will neither encourage nor discourage attendance or submission of materials related to the application. A. Marie Villafana Assistant U.S. Attorney 500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 Phone 561 209-104 7 Fax 561 820-8777 Please note: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most writtE>n communications to or from state officials regarding state business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communications may therefore be subject to public disclosure. 3/26/2010

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Barbara Burns From: Sloane, Carmen ([email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, February 24, 2010 11:41 AM To: Barbara Burns Subject: RE: J. Epstein Yeah - lot less stress From: Barbara Burns (mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, February 24, 2010 11:34 AM To: Sloane, Carmen Subject: RE: J. Epstein Ok, thanks!!! I hope that was a good thing for you! From: Sloane, Carmen [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, February 24, 2010 11:32 AM To: Barbara Burns Subject: RE: J. Epstein Hi, Page 1 of 1 His term date is 7-21-2010. I was recently transferred to the downtown office. If you have any further questions, you can contact his new officer Candice Elkins (Community Control Officer at 154 Lake Worth 434-3960). If you have any questions regarding his past supervision, please email or call me at 837-5175. Carmen From: Barbara Burns [mai1to:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, February 24, 2010 11:19 AM To: Sloane, Carmen Subject: J. Epstein Good morning Carmen. I need to know what you have as the termination date of Mr. Epstein's community control. Thanks!!! Please note: Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from state officials regarding state business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail communications may therefore be subject to public disclosure. 3/24/2010

Public Records Request No. 19-372 December 3, 2009 Barbara Burns, Esquire State Attorney's Office 401 North Dixie Highway West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 RE: State of Florida v. Jeffrey Epstein Case No. 2008CF009381A Dear Barbara, PA. ·•·· JOSEPH R.ATTERBURY •·r JACKA.GOLDBERGER * JASON S. WEISS Board Certified Criminal Trial Attorney Member of New Jersey & Florida Bars Pursuant to our telephone conversation of November 30, 2009 and your subsequent email to me, I am providing the following information to you concerning Jeffrey Epstein's air travel from May 1, 2009 through November 30, 2009. As you know, Mr. Epstein was in the custody of the Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office until July 22, 2009. I have confirmed that since Mr. Epstein's release from custody, he has traveled twice by air. The first trip was on September 14, 2009 when he traveled by helicopter to Miami to meet with counsel. He returned that day from Miami to Palm Beach County by automobile. Larry Visoski was the pilot and Nadia Marcinkova was the only other passenger. Both the trip and the mode of transportation were pre-approved by probation. On August 27, 2009 Mr. Epstein flew on a single engine Cessna aircraft to Sikorsky Helicopters in northern Pa!m Beach County. LarryVisoski and Nadia Marcinkova accompanied Mr. Epstein on this short flight. Once again the trip and the method of transportation were pre-approved by probation. There have been no other aircraft flights taken by Mr. Epstein during the time period. I am told there are not flight logs kept for the helicopter but I am enclosing the fuel receipt for the Miami helicopter trip as well as another document confirming the September 14, 2009 Palm Beach - Miami helicopter flight. I am also enclosing documents for the August 27, 2009 Cessna flight to Sikorsky Helicopters. On another note, there appears to be false information being presented to either the State Attorney's Office or the Probation Office about Mr. Epstein allegedly violating the terms of his probation. None of this is true and in fact Mr. Epstein has an unblemished record with probation without any violations since his being placed on supervision. I note that many of the false allegations against Mr. Epstein have been brought by the Scott Rothstein law One Clearlake Centre, Suite 1400 250 Australian Avenue South West Palm Beach, FL 33401 p561.659.8300 {561.835.8691 www.agwpa.com

Public Records Request No. 19-372 firm which has since filed bankruptcy as a result of massive fraud by one of its partners. It is alleged that they used their civil cases filed against Mr. Epstein as one of their more lucrative devices to perpetrate this fraud. Based on what I have learned and read, there have been false filings, forged judge's signatures, and forged Eleventh Circuit Opinions. It is also possible that other third parties have engaged in this conduct by falsely alleging Mr. Epstein has violated the terms of his probation. With this in mind, It appears that Mr. Epstein could be a victim of fabricated attacks designed to do nothing more than question his compliance with his probation and community control requirements. I truly want my client, as I am sure you do, to complete his probation without continued false accusations being made against him. I would suggest a meeting so we may discuss these problems. Given the fact that false accusations are being made against my client, I would take the unusual step of producing my client for such a meeting if you think it would be helpful. Please give me a call with your thoughts on this and whether those documents satisfy your request. JAG/slm

Public Records Request No. 19-372 ,., ______ _ "'·~---------···· _____ ,.. 2633 ~a Road oflke 4 Suit 42 Lantaaal Fl 33462 561-96~-8821 .... , ~www - .p...;._ ,fli_gbt._com __ ,.__--------1-0~,. y.r BlllTo l •· --ri I • I Certificate Nurr er I Type I ttemt I n.l.....i...tl Qty -r ""'on N243SW t Fuel SurchatJe 01 U ?-- ~3$WG10001'r. SIP.I 1.8 F cl Surcharge for ,~ CH2 &: Cl?l Aircraft ' i ' ! Due: to thr: ~al iDc:rea$e in lbe cosc ota a&lon fuel, Palm Beach ,fligbt Toiming will be forml to • d a. fuel ~wt(k:b m'll~of. ... ' .. .. :• ... .. ' ! ; ZOO 'd Invoice Date Invoice# & 27/).009 73137 BFR ~ Date MEDJSPC DUE DATE ~ tOll S btotal Rah 13S.00 s.oo s es Tax (• .5%) Web Ste Amount 2-43.00T ' 9,00T S2S2.00 $l6J8 $268.38 Wd 6! :10 GJM 600Z-ZO-J~a

Public Records Request No. 19-372 AIRCRAFT MODEL BERIALNO. B '-fo1 PILOT TOTAL FOR THE DAY: AIRCRAFT & efGIN■ FLIGHT HRS I CYCLES/ RIN - TOTAi.$ ■ROUGHT FORWARD: TOTAL.$ POR TODAY: ACCUMULATIY& TOTAL: NEXT SCHEDULED INSPlCTIDN DUE: TYPE INSPECTlON (50, 100, &TC.) ANNUAL INSPETlON DUEDAT&: 8U$1NliSS PR00S • (817) 275-3922 . ,. 7 .t> _MNl ' N'f1lflN\ 558847 ACFT'. HRS. ~G. STARTS TORQUE LANDINGS flOW&R l!NG. 1 ENG. 2 EN~. 1 ENG. 2 EVENTS ASSURANCE ., ; TOI\QUE TOTIITT N1 NZ OAT PA.. I C■RTIFY TNA1' THE DAll-V INSP&CTION WAS COMPLETED L ~~ 'S'"sl:1. PILOTS AND MAINTENANCI: RECORD PILOTS ENTER DISCREPANCIES - MEbHANICS &NTER ALL MAINTENANCE l'ERFORMED CORRICTIVE ACTION 5

Public Records Request No. 19-372 ?J 1· ,_ /Y/1 /hv/ / 1/r1/07 Jlf too ·d ------- ---.. . . ·-·-- __ ,.. .. ·--- - -·- -- ·-- ·····- SIGN TURE FLIGHT SUPPORT ' MIAMI Invoice: 2022 Aircraft; N491GM Opened; 09/14/09 08 : 19:36 Closed: 09/14/09 08:28:46 Customer: N/A Eruployee; CLARA M HANDLI G C·HARG 3101 65.000 Ref; M D HEU 1 LANDIN FE'E 3000 17.700 , RAMP P RKING 3204 44.000 Subt tal: --12a:100 7.0 l ALES TAX 3.080 ________ .... Tota : 129.78 Auth 1 145803 AMER1CAN EXP 129.78 ******:J****5014 f~if~fi;-~ii~ii~i;------- I agree ~o the credit card amount shown and tc perform the obligati n$ set forth in the ter~s of the cardholder's agreemen with the issuer. Your fee back is appreciated. Teli us ow we did today by 1-ogg-i 119 n-·t o www.signtureflight.com/survey and entering Access Code: Thank you for usin9 Signature Flight Support. We put our name on the line. Worldwide. Every d y,

Public Records Request No. 19-372 One Clearlake Centre, Suite 1400 250 Australian Avenue South West Palm Beach, FL 33401 Barbara Burns, Esquire State Attorney's Office 401 North Dixie Highway West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 045,)83095852 ~ en 0 Q.. 0 Q) C .. :;.o:i::j,:-i i ·t:C1---::::::i;::. i-·:-r:=-: i I,, IJ,,, lj 11 I,, 1!1111111 lJ, I, ,Jul1 I), I,,, I),, I, I,, I, i 1,f111 ,/ -- UJ (!) <( 1-- (/) 0 0.. Cl) ::) -~-

Public Records Request No. 19-372 You have been ;,:::rn ignad and r eturn this f,:,.rm ·' REQJJE:.i'l' i<'()f< AS St (;':'-1.MEN'l' 01!' HIVES'l'IGATOR 'n. fl 9 D.ate: th'? above matter. compl>:st ion of th i.e assignm,.mt, tr::, youc :::upervi:3e>t: '"'J.t.:h y,:::,111 memo, if i::equin➔d. asstgnment 1 , elate . :SERVE OR LOCATI; COMPL.ET"l NON SERVICE E'ORM other, Date: Mileage: nemo suu sign, date, Compl8ted

Public Records Request No. 19-372 vs. (" I HC U! T C JI N A'ND r )R . ALM BEAC JEH RF E f P ··1 _ N TO: L t I Vist,ski DUCES TECUM: 1t·ligh1. Logs OF THI!: Jfllf'J'EE'N'rH JUDICIAL J-; , • 1 r II i ,z DIVISION) C NO. YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED t :-, l and pe r before the S'rATE ATTORNEY h Assistant, in and fat' 1 rn r , ,r f . . j .1 t f , , -y 1. Highway, es !all!! Bach, Flolida 401, ,n Mond~y, I t ~bet 14, ZOO<I 1n:ou .:s , f-r the f U l p ·, .. E" 1 C, 1 t. 1 l<?C-1 .• ~ m I" 11 r n•J Jl!.-YFREY E l!":PS'I'IUN is the Defendant. You are commanded to bring with you the complete -, r • 1. al 1 > 1 , l'1 ~ 1 l 4 > concerning at}}' and l flights JEFFREY E. EP ..;'I'EUl. l· il u l' to r,rn l with subpoena .. ul, 1 • , .1 to l!;; di t _; l . B,,, l~o. ov , b•:?t 30, .r l •~ 1 thi.:s _(_L!_ i ,) wi tnt~ss in h I J j I 1 I ll l • c, " ~ the within lm. ~e ch, Sa C 1 F L "" ed

Public Records Request No. 19-372 ntr.M' TA OE 'ro• rcy V i D ight Logs t 30, 200 DIVIS 0 to 8 t., 1n • D I p ncerning any and hiS ub-~-- will /

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Florida D.A.V.I.D. Individual Summary Page Page 1 of2

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Florida D.A.V.I.D. Individual Summary Page Page 2 of2

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Mastet Caee: 2008CF00938J»m 'l'o: IW!:STl~'fIO'NS From: BARBARA J. BUlUIS State Ya. JEFJ".REY E EPSTEIN Caae: 2008C!'009381AMB suu In¥~st;gatiy~ .GaAe--jo.: - .21..L.. ... ., • :').,.____, -- << REQU!:S'J.' FO'R ASSIGNMENT OJF IW\11:STIGATOR >> Date: Noveiaber 30, 2009 Phone: (561)355-7100 Div: Judge: Jeffrey Colbath Charge: PROCURE PERSOlJ UllDER AGI!: 18 FOR PROSTI'rUTIOW .,....-------... ....... . Request For: Subpoena Duoes TeoWI Service /"_' ---------- • ( Witness Locate )_ Otherr \nate·~~-Bee.'- 1, 2009 lraaer Larry Vinoaki (Belicopter pilot to Jeffrey Epstein) } To: Investigator l!'roa: Supervisor Date: You have been assigned the above matter. Upon CODlpletion ot this assignment, sign, date, and return this foi:a to your $Upe~visor with your aellO, if required. Coapleted aasignaent, reviewed date. inveati cvisor: :., ;; ;;rm. •• _ • ~- ~=·:=:===========··=-=~:,•=:-,=-=-==·""~.!:.=============--===-..:::;:;-== Date Cocpleted: ' 7 t • 0 r, If no aasignaent ••o required; f hours fSubpoena(s)served: _____ _ #lfot served: ------- #Posted: ---- << rr U'JIABLE TO SZRVE (')R LOCATE COMPLET.F. - 'JIOB snv:ra FORM >> other, completed as required ________ .. ____ .. ____ _ Investigator:C,~~/1/.~· ·--- Mileage: _________ _ ff -:: 70,, l 1,20c(\ ?0 1 1, ,~e c:,(. , , 1 r, , . o . - I,/ oc;] / Date: Meao attached: ( X ---------

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Case No: SA09003537, Defendant: EPSTEIN, JEFFREY E Case No Date Note SA09003537 12/01/2009 01 :36 PM LOCATED CURRENT ADDRESS FOR LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR.;W/M, 2-25-1960: 1131 PINE POINT ROAD WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33404-2251 Relationship LITTLES, ERIC case_note_list Note Type *

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN: Page 1 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN: Page 2 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN: Page 3 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LA WREN CE PAUL VI SO SKI JR SSN: Page 4 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LA WREN CE PAUL VI SO SKI JR SSN: Page 5 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LA WREN CE PAUL VI SO SKI JR SSN: Page 6 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN: Page 7 of20 h

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN: Page 8 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN:

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN: - Page 10 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN: Page 11 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN: Page 12 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN:

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN:

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN: Page 15 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN Page 16 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN:

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LA WREN CE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN: Page 18 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LA WREN CE PAUL VI SO SKI JR SSN: Page 19 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FACTS Report for Subject: LA WREN CE PAUL VISOSKI JR SSN Page 20 of20

Public Records Request No. 19-372 NOV-20-09 15:12 FROM·LEOPOLlrvKUVIN, P.A. 15615151401 LM a,,,11111 LEOPOLD~KUVIN.,. Friday, November 20, 2009 Maureen Hackett Office of the State Attorney 401 N. Dixie Highway West Palm Beach. FL 33401 CONSUMER JUSTICE ATTORNEYS lte: B.B. v. JEFFREY EPSTEIN OUR FILENO.: 080303 Dear Ms. Hackett, As we discussed. J have agreed to cancel the deposition of ASA Daliah Weiss at this time. Based on the conversations with Ms. Weiss and you, I do not foresee the need at this time to reset this deposition, but I cannot completely foreclose the possibility of deposition in the future pending further discovery in the Epstein cases. As I mentioned to you, if r believe there is additional infonnation that develops in these cases that would require me to reset Mrs. Weiss for deposition. I will provide you with notice prior resening this deposition so that you will have an oppornmity to address the court in a timely manner. Should you have any additional questions please do not hesilate to contact me at your converuence. 2825 PGA fki11Javarc-J Sulla 200 Palrn Beanh C:',FJrc:lar,s Flcrldc1 33'110 561.515.1-100 /r,x 561,515, 1401 JanpnJC'lK1ivin.r.nm CRASI-IWull.TI-IINI::--:, • MANAliH1 CARI: ,\IIUSI:: • L.'(JN,'l!JMl:I{ t:I A:tS ACTIONS· PERSONAL JNIURY • WllONGFLIJ. Dl:ATI I

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Dear Lanna Belohlavek, I am at a lost K-r words, and trying to hold the tears back, after rea mg a out t e sickening details of billionaire Jeffrey Epstein's case. I have to say in this instance, your office along with the entire judicial system, failed the people miserably, by not adequately punishing a chronic child molester a ... d rapist. This man of wealth and prestige preyed on innocent, poor, GJRLS and systematically raped them at his wi11. He lived his life and continues to live his life, above the law, and once again has proven the corrupt nature of our system. If this happened to Tyrone from Dade County, he would be facing the death penalty. How can a person who molested one, let alone hundreds of girls, receive this joke of a jail sentence, and now be a free man?! How?!! Because he is rich? Just the thought of him being in his million dollar mansion, sexually raping these girls makes me sick. Now, I understand the pressure of taking on a powerful person with unlimited legal defense funds. Sometimes the premise, that any conviction is better than none can be appropriate, this was not that time. You did NOT need his cooperation nor did you need to strike a deal. Even without his testimony, and just the victims, your office could have put this monster away for at least 20 years, if not life. I'm sure you have read Conchitta Sarnoff's piece on the Daily Beast detailing this monsters actions. If your office has not read the piece, you should by all means use it as a cautionary tale on how not to prosecute a rich child abuser and human trafficker. Now, I do not know the side story- your investigation, legal technicalities, how much hush· money was paid out, ect ect. But I do know that aftc:r people such as Jeffery Epstein have raped the entire country of their retirement savings, he shouldn't be allowed to do the same thing to young children. I do sincerely hope, you, and your office did ALL you legally could have to put this man in prison. However after researching the case, it seems you failed to come down with any authority or justice. I only hope, the Palm Beach DA's office and the US DA can find further evidence, to re try him and put him away for good! It would do our s0<;iety much good, and set a standard that no one person is above the justice system, especially child molesters. I would hope that as a lawyer, that is suppose to defend the public, you have a change of heart, and imagine if that was your little sister or daughter, and do ALL you can to bring this to a full trial with no deals. The American people deserve better, and so do the children that were abused. I hope you understand the anger and frustration being expressed and absorb it to the fullest. Because you and the whole DA's office neerl to know this- that monster doesn't deserve freedom! -A Concerned Patriot p.s. I eagerly await ANY type ofresponse at- johngoes [email protected]

Public Records Request No. 19-372 ...1 U"""' u-vc::._ _!,,, , :2.; \~@'7\ \: 1-1 .E\v~ 1 \,,, ~ \-; ce . ., C A 9 \ \ \ \ '·'°"'r p1.'f' I \a11I , ,..; J 1,...\/ .,,J \\ ----;~:--;4c1 t - .6?~~-3 o'~ ""I '\ '-\ \ \ \ I J.. l. ... 4;,_~,KtA~O; C,.(!\. 946- 3'.:l :Yt.tL 2CH:.tl r~r+ -0• • '"if .; ~ ~- D.A. Lanna Belohlavek 500 Australian Ave., Fourth Floor West Palm Beach, FL 33401 -j 11 Uu ,llu \11 IU111u,111H1111U11l1I~, II, l,1u\ 1\111111,1 ;.,: .....

Public Records Request No. 19-372 U.S. Department of Juslice United States Attomey SoutMm District of Florida 500 .4&rtmlian Aw .. Stdte 400 Wuf Pabn Buch. FL 33401 Offlcilll e._ Ponaky far PrnMe Uoo s:HIO ~~~---~------ ~· State Attorney's Office 401 N. Dixie Highway West Palm Beach, FL 33401-4209 ■ .l¢"POs14-. ~ ftu:d== ::, ~.._PITNEYBO 02 1P $ 000.8 0006899490 AUG 04 2 . MAILED FROM ZIP CODE 3 3

Public Records Request No. 19-372 OFFICE OF THE STATE ATTORNEY INTER-OFFICE MEMORANDUM TO: Chief Michael Waites FROM: Investigator Glenn Wescott RE: State Attorney's Investigation 09-002456 DATE: August 24, 2009 ***************************************************************** On 08/21/09 I was assigned to obtain copies of the security cameras and log in sheets for 1 Clearlake Plaza in West Palm Beach, FL which is the business address for Jeffrey Epstein. On 08/21/09 I received the copies of the log in sheet and noted that Mr. Epstein's name does not appear on the log in sheet which he would only be required to do if he were in the building after 1900 per the Property Manager, Mrs. Michelle Horn. On 08/24/09 I received the security camera videos which were formatted to DVD. I could not discern Mr. Epstein on the CD's but the camera angle is poor and does not allow one to see the entire area, just the door area. The DVD's and Log In Sheets were TOT ASA Burns per her request. Investigator Glenn A. Wescott Office of the State Attorney 15 th Judicial Circuit 401 North Dixie Highway West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-355-7118

Public Records Request No. 19-372 11111 <1/21-ito 7, 1-' cf? £9 i1-fr, '"l t .,/ t . DATE NAME FIRM ADDRESS TO SEE t s/19 ~!&C,/CJ-5 STREET CITY STATE 8/19 STREET CITY STATE 'i/tq STREET ~ ( (__ _j_c1t0Q CITY STATE >l~r; t(G-K STREET C-~ CITY STATE TIMEIN TIMEOUT (vcA5 , 'i/tq wl'/2 STREET CITY STATE TIMEOUT . V'<s¼ r/1c; eS ,·v STREET \'<\(, \lc~vic- q")..., CITY STATE TIMEIN TIMEOUT f/11 STREET <?s.~ C, (CL~ (IJYYe~ 1- , ... , .,.. CITY STATE TIMEIN TIMEOUT ,. ~/tq ~ Pa.~~h~ STREET 1: tf6 CITY STATE TIMEIN K/19 ~Jc) STREET ;l tJ ,-lL-- CITY STATE TIME IN 9 . .5,-u 'i/f<i t. N~'•A ~~d~,-' 1.~~t~ • STREET '1!S'i 10.·03 Jt: CITY STATE TIMEIN TIMEOUT t/19 0~u ,ol STREET , 0 'I</ Jl.rzT CITY STATE TME IN t i/rq S-;l~ +ro-{2_ STREET /d; 'i-- STATE TIMEIN I CITY ~ly ~ \U~ STREET CITY STATE t/tr STREEl CITY STATE t/{~ STREET /\. ota 6;--Jq iO- -S-3 </ ·l?·-t ( --.S CITY STATE TIMEIN TIME OU (

Public Records Request No. 19-372 • • DATE NAME • ~(19 W, u_1,..,uJ Ji. • : ?i(fC, 7rl ~~ztedltt • ~111 ' E~ /vrAel • 'i/Jci' L\'t le~~ <; I . • i(f{{ (Lo c_,/e, • ; 51/f Cj ~~)(d -' • 'i/ff j /4;/4 /; ~o~•,f : ~/ff Ge. kl, L e6,WA i l ~ 2{/Cj . ~fu~ r~~- ► 6iJJvt-~k. • ~(If ~ I ~{(1 /(e v / ~ ;J t, t,I\ ~ ·' I I S/{f ~~u ri ,~e- r 1{(~ f{ be,\ N\cnjcvr o.-rz 8/(q ~~ M~l 0/11 - f• ~; {v\ \ fZl~ FIRM ~ tZJ, I, M ~ ft< L- D~~s7 ?u\ C'\ J'o (C{A '('-i--""°"''\. ~ I•· J fl1tllk [\ ~'( {7~ . 3uJ11.,lcjLr ~ r_((, Cl=-M rx 't)\ v,;,u-. j /;)0~ EfY f--rY ADDRESS TO SEE STREET CITY STATE Ti/(JN f } I TIME OUT STREET CITY STATE 0;571 T'E IN ' TIME ouT STREET l \: ,S: 1 11 : \) 't"" CITY STATE TIME IN TIMEOUT STREET ll ~ 3-;-, I j;;J,07 CITY STATE TIME IN TIME OUT STREET CITY STATE LI; if'~ T E IN I TIME OUT STREET 11:rs- CITY STATE TIME IN I f'?_ _:; r TIME OUT STREET CITY STATE /4.i..1,. I TIM N TIMEOUT STREET ( 2'. S.o- I TIME OUT CITY STATE TIME IN STREET 12:5( I TIMEOUT CITY STATE TIME IN STREET I CITY STATE I Z, 1./ 'f\'! I TIME IN TIME OUT f STREET tc.'f -r ' CITY STATE TIMEIN I TIME OUT . STREET . I l "5'1 1 100 ., CITY STATE TIMEIN TIMEOUT STREET . CITY STATE 1,0d prn , , .• 5 i tin TIME IN TIME OUT ·' 11 u STREET i : TIME IN I ~ sz.1 TIME OUT CITY STATE ' STREET j nsz_ I I I CITY STATE TIME IN • TIME OUT ~ AT-A-GLANCE TM j

Public Records Request No. 19-372 DATE NAME 5 l , J <jJf FIRM STREET CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY ,, 1 ,1· STREH ~ CITY Lt-tw tY }V1L.G t~ 'ff I J-03 1:Jqc» f?/r15t f l,~17 STREET CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY . STREET CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY ADDRESS STATE STATE Z,! .. d)__,;:;. 2-:y ,. TIME IN TIME OUT - 3 t ~-, ~ ~~-r:t STATE TIME IN TIME OUT 'Z'.l STATE TIMEIN TIME OUT STATE STATE STATE TIME IN TIME OUT STATE STATE STATE STATE STATE TIME $/5 2 TIME OUT STATE TIME IN TIME OUT STATE 6.!c>=f b!jO TIME IN TIME OUT ·5 :1:s STATE TIMEIN TIMEOUT

Public Records Request No. 19-372 NAME FIRM STREET B CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY ~ STREET CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY ' t ~ 4/vAffJ ~,-cz STREET CITY STREET CITY STREET CITY ADDRESS STATE STATE STATE STATE STATE STATE STATE STATE STATE STATE STATE STATE STATE STATE STATE TO SEE tf'.'..., 0 TIME IN TIME OUT TIME~ ·l3 TIME OUT 0:i7 TIMEQi{' TIMEIN TIME OUT TIME IN TIME OUT Cft/Z TIMEllf TIME OUT i 17 l TIMEOUT /,J

Public Records Request No. 19-372 - <Vi:iilo,z,:i' cl? Efjl:ifr,,z, • • DATE NAME FIRM ADDRESS TO SEE • 0 • % STREET t\lu.il STATE TIMEIN TIME OUT • CITY % STREET • ~ CITY STATE TIMEIN TIME OUT • ~ f+r,,v/J)-eMC¥- • ~-IL STREET rl• I b J /) b . j,: - e-c I CITY STATE TIME IN "ME OUT ~ /?,,-7 C /-Jc"X, STREET • Ae1JP61 1 ~ '.2--j CITY STATE TIMEIN TIMEOUT ~ ~I J\. ~ w kop p fr! vh e- '"I- STREET /(Jl.)_S -- CITY STATE TIME IN~ TIMEOUT ~ ~~~~ STREET l4\.)jl l'C,..Q_ ~<£,!(;( (0-'3 it);-5~~ l•-AJJ <i.v'l CITY STATE TIME IN • l Tl E OUT ~ ~i~tte\ ~f~f f }~oJ-- STREET ti 13d \-l'()j • r,;~ ~ ~ {_( CITY STATE TIME IN TIMEO ~ (c£J I STREET ?t> { CITY STATE ?J tJ~ {i) STREET '2C) CITY STATE ~ €_ \.~0-~t.,))o STREET ~ L\'~~'(Y'-0-1 CITY STATE TIMEIN TIME OUT ~ ~ ~ )Cff12-~ STREET :22? CITY STATE TIME IN TIME OUT ~ STREET Zt? ;:JJ STATE E IN CITY ~ Sear1 STREET ll,,U/{j I <.31 LO CITY STATE TIMEIN TIME OUT v ~(We_ ar~r STREET ?O M,r~ STATE TIME IN /1 :i(O TIME OUT CITY ~ STREET .P'-'A..-A STATE TIMEIN TIMEOUT CITY

Public Records Request No. 19-372 TOWN OF PALM BEACH MEMORANDUM TO: The File VIA: Direct FROM: Capt. George Frick RE: Jeffrey Epstein ·,. ~- DATE: 08/20/09 On 8/19/09, at approximately 1635 hours, I was advised that Jeffrey Epstein was walking northbound on South Ocean Blvd in the area of Brazilian Avenue. Based on my prior conversations with Probation Supervisor Gladstone, I made contact with him to discuss the possibility that this was a violation of Epstein's order of community control. I made contact with Gladstone who advised in his opinion that this was a violation and that based on FSS 948.06, we should arrested Epstein. I advised Gladstone that I needed a copy of his Order of Community Control in hand prior to making this arrest. At 1642, this order was e-mailed to my office computer. I reviewed and printed the order and responded to the area. At approximately 1653, I observed Epstein walking southbound on South Ocean Blvd near the intersection of Barton Avenue. At 1655 I requested a marked unit respond to Clarke Avenue and South Ocean Blvd as I was making contact with Epstein. Epstein was wearing dark sweat pants and a white t-shirt. He was sweating profusely. As he approached, I identified myself and began my on- scene investigation. This was documented in the CAD system, CAD #092310146, attached. At that time, Epstein advised that his probation officer, Carmen Sloan, had advised him he was allowed to walk to and from work, and that he was now en-route to work. He further advised that his work address was on Australian Avenue in West Palm Beach. I questioned Epstein as to why he was not on a direct route to his work, and why he was now walking south when he had just been walking north. He stated that he had walked to the area of the North Bridge, but considered it too busy, therefore he was returning to the Middle Bridge to cross into West Palm Beach. 345 South County Road• Palm Beach, Florida 33480 • (561) 838-5454

Public Records Request No. 19-372 8/20/09 11:00:01 HTE CAD CAD CALL INFORMATION PAGE 1 092310146 Call Number: 092310146 SI Call Type.: 124 INVESTIGATIVE Entry Day/Tm: 8/19/09 16:55:01 124 INVESTIGATIVE Police Police CmnN: Location ... : 100 CLARKE City ...... : PALM BEACH Intersectn. : OCEAN Caller Name: Last: Address ... : City/State: Call Taker.: Dispatcher. : dlO requested 9003 MARK 9003 MARK NA R for a marked Agency ......... : 001 Police Dept AV Apt: INTERSECTN Block#: 100 Loe ID: I Mapr: 16N First: Phone#: R A T I unit at TYLER TYLER V 8 clarke COUNTY Mid: See Caller: Apt: Source: SI PDC02A PDC02A and the ocean 16:55:19 D10 Unit Status History Information 8/19/09 16:55:02 4 Dispatched D 7636 FRICK,RON 8/19/09 16:55:02 6 At Scene AT 8/19/09 16:55:02 11 Assigned as Primary PR 8/19/09 17:14:18 16 Reset Unit Time Chee RS 8/19/09 17:26:47 20 Available AV D3 Unit Status History Information 8/19/09 16:55:03 4 Dispatched D 8806 GUELLI,JOS 8/19/09 16:55:04 6 At Scene AT 8/19/09 17:14:09 20 Available AV 109 Unit Status History Information 8/19/09 16:55:06 4 Dispatched D 8141 KEEHAN,MIC 8/19/09 16:55:10 6 At Scene AT 8/19/09 17:14:18 16 Reset Unit Time Chee RS 8/19/09 17:14:47 20 Available AV D I S P O S I T I O N S 1 022 No Rpt/Asmt Comp Case# 1 - 00-000000 Unit: 010

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Driving Directions from 358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, FL to 250 S Australian Ave, We ... Page 2 of 2 Evernia St Cl arlali.-, Barton A,<e PrimaVera Way c, (ke P,'ve 0 0 atm Beach t St "' E' warkSt 1l :i Fie!: St Claremore Dr£ l ArdmCfe Rd •5. :9 Rd § £ -li Bel\ledere Rd Gruber Pl f ~) 1 ' , ~ ) dirdova Ad Valene Rd Su 5"e ~d Austral1ari Ave Chilian AYe Wl)Ftli A~I INian Ave L.. &er!Jlades <Jo!f course Atlantic Ocean Cl 2009 MapOum.!ric, Map Data -g:,2o09NAVTEQ or TeleAtlas All rights reserved. Use subject to License/Copyright Map Legend Directions and maps are informational only. We make no warranties on the accuracy of their content, road conditions or route usability or expeditiousness. You assume all risk of use. MapQuesl and ils suppliers shall not be liable to you for any loss or delay resulting from your use of MapQuest. Your use of MapQuesl means you agree lo our Terms of Use http://www.mapquest.com/maps?lc=Palm+Beach&ls=FL&la=358+El+Brillo+Way&1z=... 8/20/2009

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Driving Directions from 358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, FL to 250 S Australian Ave, We ... Page 1 of 2 ~~~lffilM~s-~Yfj~ Te,l!J .. ~·-· --·····----· . . A: 358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, FL 33480-4730 ~ ~ ~ ~ tft ~ ~ 1. Start out going EAST on EL BRILLO WAY toward • TRAVERS WAY. 2: Turn LEFT onto S COUNTY RD/FL-A1A N. 3. Turn LEFT onto ROYAL PALM WAY/FL-704 W. • Continue to follow FL-704 W. 4: Merge onto S AUSTRALIAN AVE/FL-704A N. 5: 250 S AUSTRALIAN AVE is on the RIGHT. B: 250 S Australian Ave, West Palm Beach, FL 33401-5018 Total Travel Estimates: 8 minutes/ 3.32 miles 0.1 mi 0.9 mi 1.7 mi 0.6mi 0.0 mi http://www.mapquest.com/maps?lc=Palm+Beach&ls=FL&la=358+El+Bri1lo+Way&lz=... 8/20/2009

Public Records Request No. 19-372 ... ---.lib Ma5ter Case: 2008CF009381.AMB To: INVESTIGATIONS ~A-/ZA '--:2 ~s From : !llilliWI: I I ~ State VS. JEFFREY E EPSTEIN Case: 2008CF009381AMB Investigative Case No.: Qo/C{je:2,__ 7'~ << REQUEST FOR ASSIGNMENT OF INVESTIGATOR>> Date: August 21, 2009 Phone: (561)355-7100 Judge: SANDRA K. MCSORLEY Charge: PROCURE PERSON UNDER AGE 18 FOR PROSTITUTION Request For: PLEASE SERVE ATTACHED SUBPOENA OUCES TECUM ( t?itness Information/Locate] Other: Date Required: 8/21/09 Name: 1 CLEARLAKE CENTRE LLC C/O WG COMPASS 250 AUSTRALIAN BLVD SUITE 105 WEST PALM BEA.SH!~ ,. ' To: Investigator From: Supervisor I You have been ass igne,t e and return this form to assignment, reviewed date. #Subpoena(s)served: #Posted: __ _ ca matter. Upon completion of this assignment, sign, date, your supervisor w.ith your memo, if required. Completed -···- ~ Investigative Supervi.sor If nc, assignment memo required, #Not served: _______ _ OR LOCATE CCMPLETE - NON SERVICE FORM>>

Public Records Request No. 19-372 OFFICE OF THE STATE ATTORNEY INTER-OFFICE MEMORANDUM TO: Chief Michael Waites FROM: Investigator Glenn Wescott RE: State Attorney's Investigation 09-002456 DATE: August 24, 2009 ***************************************************************** On 08/21/09 I was assigned to obtain copies of the security cameras and log in sheets for 1 Clearlake Plaza in West Palm Beach, FL which is the business address for Jeffrey Epstein. On 08/21/09 I received the copies of the log in sheet and noted that Mr. Epstein's name does not appear on the log in sheet which he would only be required to do if he were in the building after 1900 per the Property Manager, Mrs. Michelle Horn. On 08/24/09 I received the security camera videos which were formatted to DVD. I could not discern Mr. Epstein on the CD's but the camera angle is poor and does not allow one to see the entire area, just the door area. The DVD's and Log In Sheets were TOT ASA Burns per her request. Investigator Glenn A. Wescott Office of the State Attorney 15 th Judicial Circuit 401 North Dixie Highway West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561-355-7118

Public Records Request No. 19-372 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF TBE FH"J'.II:ENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA (CRIMINAL DIVISION) STATE OF FLORIDA vs. JEFFREY .E EPSTEIN TO: 1 CLEARLAKE CENTRE LLC C/O UJG COMPASS 250 AUSTRALIAN BLVD SUITE 105 WEST PALM BEACH, FL CASE NO. 2008CF009381AMB DIVISION: W DUCES TECUM: COPY OF SIG& Ill SHEET AS WELL AS THE DVR VIDEO FOR THE DATES OF 08/18/09 TO 08/20/09 YOU MAY COMPLY WITH THIS SUBPOENA BY MAILING 'l'HE INFORMATION TO THE STATE ATTORliEY' S OFFICE, C/O BARBARA BURNS, 401 NORTH DIXIE HIGHWAY, WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33401. IF YOU HAVE ANY QUES'I'IONS, PLEASE CALL ASSISTANT STATE ATI'ORNEY LANNA BELOHLAVEK AT (561) 355- 7100. You are hereby commanded to comply 'Nith the request in the Subpoena in this case, on INSTA'NTOR, wherein the State of Florida is the Plaintiff and JEFFREY E EPSTEIN is the Defendant. Failure to comply will subject you to contempt of Court. aJa Assistant Stat_. Fla. Bar No. 0 August 21, 2009 ~ =========-==========:=.=========·,.. :--y 1 - ·===== ~ ·===-========================="--=== R~j-ved this s ~ oena on the 2t__ day of .L::/iJJ 7 , 2009, and executed the same on the _LJ __ day of ~~ ' 2009, by delivering a ' e Copy thereof to the within named witness in the Couno/1 of Palm Beach, State of F id . A B CH OUNTY

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Ill '1B CIRCUIT COURT O!" TSE CIRCUIT I'N AND H CO I FLORIDA (CRIMI'HAL D STAT ... vs. DA c· NO. 200BCF009381AMB DIVISIO : TO: l c~ .... -~ _"""": ~~ LLC . IQ ~-uc .. L.11S 250 AUSTRALIAN BLVD SUITE 10!> '"T FL DOOliS ~c : COPY OF SIGN I SH or o&/18/09 TO oa/20/09 iOU Mi\Y CCMPLl' WITH TBIS SUBPOE'NA BY I • H DVR C/O BARBARA BUR11S, 401 DIXIE .HIGHWAY, liEST Y QUESTIOllS, PLEASE CALL ASSIS'l'AliT STATE ATTORNEY 0 R TO THE STATE ATTORXEY' S BEACH, FL 33401. IF !OU BELOHLAVEK AT (561) 355- You .are hereby . anded to ply with the request in the Subpoena in this cue, on IllSTAXTOR, ...iierein the State of Florida is the Plaintiff and JEFFREY EPSTEIW is the Defendant. Failure to c ply will subject you to con pt of Court. J. . l r , C1 _a Lu~ ~~ ''- v :81'RBARABURlfS /; 1'ssi8tant Stat{e Attorney - 1a. Bar Bo. 00865354 August 21, 2009

Public Records Request No. 19-372 PRIVILEGED & CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT MEMORANDUM DATE: December 20, 2006 FROM: Gerald B. Lefcourt Sheryl E. Reich Faith A. Friedman TO: Jeffrey Epstein FILE SUBJECT: Impeachment Material LAW OFFICES OF GERALD B. LEFCOURT, P.C. (212) 737-0400 Set forth below is some of the information that demonstrates (a) that the Palm Beach Police Department ("PBPD") made a materially incomplete and materially inaccurate presentation of the facts in both the probable cause affidavit and in its release to the public of the Police Reports, and (b) why the State Attorney's decision to proceed as it did with respect to the bringing of any charges against Jeffrey Epstein ("Epstein") was not inappropriate. 1 Note, though the Police Reports are on various dates, since they were released to the public with continuous pagination, we refer here simply to the "Police Report" and use the numbering provided in the version disclosed to the public. I. Inaccuracies and Material Omissions from the Police Reports 1. Polygraph Examination and Report. On May 2, 2006, Epstein submitted to a polygraph examination in which he was asked (a) whether he had "s. contact with (b) whether he "in anyway threaten[ ed] - ( c) whether he was told by "that she was 18 years old"; and (d) whether he "believed as 18 years old". As set forth in the Report of the examination, t e term sexual contact" was given an extremely broad meaning in order to capture any inappropriate conduct that could have occurred. 2 The results of the examination confirmed that ( a) no such conduct occurred; (b) Epstein never threatened - told Epstein she was 18 years old; and ( d) Epstein believed ~ 1 This memo is not exhaustive of facts of which the defense is aware. Nor is it exhaustive of Epstein's defenses to the accusations. 2 The definition included: "sexual intercourse, oral sex acts (penis in mouth or mouth on vagina), finger penetration of the vagina, finger penetration of the anus, touching of the vagina for sexual gratification purposes, touching of the penis for sexual gratification purposes, masturbation by or to another, touching or rubbing of the breasts, or any other physical contact involving sexual thoughts and/or desires with another person".

Public Records Request No. 19-372 years old. Though the results of the examination were given to the PBPD and the PBPD was given an opportunity to meet with the polygraph examiner in order to satisfy itself as to the bona fides of the exam, representatives of the PBPD inexplicably declined to attend the meeting and no information concerning the fact of the exam or the results appeared in the Police Report; the probable cause affidavit; or the public release. 2. Meetings with the State Attornev's Office. On multiple occasions, defense counsel met with prosecutors and investigators in the State Attorney's Office. Though there is vague reference to one or more meetings with defense counsel (see, e.g., pages 64 and 87 of the Police Report), virtually no information provided or evidence from witnesses proffered is included in the Police Report or probable cause affidavit. Instead, there are misleading or false references to such meetings. So, for example, at page 64 of the Police Report, Det. Recarey claims he attempted to reach ASA Dahlia Weiss on December 20, 2005, but she was unavailable that day and for the entire week. In fact, on December 19, 2005, Det. Recarey met with ASA Weiss and Epstein defense attorney Alan Dershowitz - a meeting at which Dershowitz provided evidence impeaching (see below). This evidence included excerpts from - MySpace.com webpage, which is not only unnoted in the Police Report, but credited as having been found by Det. Recarey. (Police Report at page 65.) In another example, the briefest reference is made to a conversation Det. Recarey had on June 1, 2006, with ASA Belohlavek regarding a meeting earlier that day between representatives of the State Attorney's Office and defense attorney Jack Goldberger (Police Report at page 87). Omitted are the facts of the meeting (Report at 87): In addition to the presence of other defense counsel, there was in attendance both the polygraph expert who administered the examination and a psychiatrist who had performed a rigorous psycho-sexual evaluation of Epstein and who concluded that Epstein was healthy. Both men were made available for questioning by the State Attorney and the PBPD; unfortunately, the PBPD failed to attend the meeting. Nor is there any mention of the presentat~ ense counsel in which the claims being made with respect to- (by then, the sole focus of any potential prosecution) were rebutted. 3. The Video Surveillance Equipment Located in Epstein's Office and Garage. Both the Police Report (page 43) and the probable cause affidavit (page 18) make particular mention of the PBPD having "discovered" video surveillance equipment, or "covert (hidden) cameras" (as the PBPD refers to them), at Epstein's Palm Beach residence, specifically in Epstein's garage and library/office. By its placement in the probable cause affidavit, it is clear that the reader is intended to assume a link between this equipment and "sex objects" and that the cameras were used for an improper purpose. As the probable cause affidavit states: Det. Recarey "located a wood colored armoire beside Epstein's bed that contained a bottle of 'joy jelly', which is used to provide a warm massage. Several massage tables were located throughout the second floor of the residence, including a massage table found in Epstein's bedroom ... " Indeed, much is made of the presence of this equipment, noting 2

Public Records Request No. 19-372 that it captured images of~ d others. (See probable cause affidavit at page 18). In particular, the probable cause affidavit notes that "on the first floor of the Epstein residence ... [was] found two covert cameras hidden in clocks. One was located in the garage and the other located in the library area behind Epstein's computer .... the computer's hard drive was reviewed which showed several images o~ and other witnesses interviewed. All of these images appeared to come from the camera positioned behind Epstein's desk". (Id.) Omitted from the Police Report and the probable cause affidavit is the fact that the PBPD had known since 2003 about the presence of the cameras, and the specific reason for their installation. The cameras were installed in 2003 after Epstein discovered that large sums of cash were missing from his home. Indeed, not only were the cameras installed at the suggestion of the PBPD, but the PBPD initially provided equipment that did not work and thereafter assisted in the installation of the equipment Epstein purchased. The cameras ultimately served their purpose and captured the image of former employee Juan Alessi, removing cash from Epstein's briefcase after unlawfully entering the house. The recording of Alessi was turned over to the PBPD - indeed, to Det. Recarey himself. The characterization of the video equipment either as a surprise to the PBPD or as playing a part in the alleged sexual activity in Epstein's home (even though none of the complainants ever made any mention of such equipment, or ever placed any activity in the locations of the cameras), is false and misleading and suggests an intention to portray the facts to suit a particular goal. 4. Broken "Sex Toys" in Epstein's Trash. The Police Report details police finding in Epstein's trash what is described as pieces of "sex toys" and that these "discoveries" purportedly corroborate witness statements. Omitted from both the Police Report and the probable cause affidavit is the fact that during the course of executing the search warrant on Epstein's home, the police realized that a key "sex toy" was in fact the broken handle of a salad server. Though the "sex toys" play a prominent role in the Police Report and probable cause affidavit, the Police Report was never amended to reflect the discovery of this new and highly relevant evidence. 5. Failure to Consider Exculpatory or Impeaching Evidence. Other exculpatory and impeaching evidence known by the PBPD was omitted from the Police Report and probable cause affidavit by, in our view, manipulating the date the investigation was allegedly closed. According to the Police Report (at page 85), Det. Recarey "explained [to ASA Belohlavek] that the PBPD had concluded its case in December of 2005". That assertion, which is false, conveniently resulted in the omission of all information adduced subsequent to that date. Thus, though the Police Report in fact contains information obtained after December 2005, the PBPD escaped having to consider, or even to include in the Police Report, the probable cause affidavit, or what it released to the public, all the exculpatory and impeaching evidence presented on behalf of Epstein, most of which was provided after December 2005. That evidence is listed below. 3

Public Records Request No. 19-372 II. Unreported Criminal Histories and Mental Health Problems of the Witnesses Relied on in the Police Report and Probable Cause Affidavits. Virtually every witness relied on to support the Police Report and the probable cause affidavit has a background that casts significant doubt on whether the witness is sufficiently credible to support a finding of probable cause, let alone to sustain what would be the State's burden of proof at a trial. (Indeed, nearly all the witnesses, and certainly those deemed complainants, were friends, which undercuts any claim that one story corroborates another.) Though this evidence was submitted to the PBPD, none of it was included in the Police Report, the probable cause affidavit, or released to the public. Below we address solely the omitted criminal histories. Following that, we list other factors that make each witness unworthy of belief and incapable of withstanding cross-examination at trial - all of which was previously provided to the PBPD but omitted from the Police Report, the probable cause affidavit and the public disclosure. 6. Juan Alessi: While the Police Report (at page 57) and the probable cause affidavit (at page 21) contain assertions by Alessi which allegedly support the bringing of criminal charges, omitted is the evidence revealing Alessi' s evident mental instability; prior criminal conduct against Epstein; and bias towards Epstein. As the PBPD well knew, in 2003, Alessi was filmed taking money from Epstein's home. After being caught on videotape unlawfully entering Epstein's home and stealing cash from a briefcase, Alessi admitted to the PBPD that he entered the house unlawfully on numerous occasions, stealing cash and attempting to steal Epstein's licensed handgun (which in fact went missing). Officers assigned to the investigation prepared a report detailing Alessi's confession. Also known to the PBPD, but omitted from the Police Report, is that Alessi claimed he intended to steal the gun in order to kill himself. Though this information is clearly material to any determination of credibility, and was specifically known to Det. Recarey at the time the Police Report and probable cause affidavits were written, it was omitted. 7. While the Police Report and robable cause affidavit rely the father o omitted is evidence, known to the PBPD, that casts doubt on credibility and sustainability as a witness. Omitted from the Police Report and probable cause affidavit is ederal fraud conviction, which defense investigators discovered and turned over to the PBPD during the course of the investigation. ~ erved 21 months in federal prison for his offense. 8. While the Police Report and probable cause affidavit rely on statements of the step-mother of omitted is evidence, known to the PBPD that casts doubt on her credibility. Omitted from the Police Report and the probable cause affidavit is- state conviction for identity fraud - criminal use of identification information. This information, uncovered by defense investigators, was also turned over to the PBPD during the course of the investigation. 4

Public Records Request No. 19-372 III. 9. was the source of the vast majority of the allegations made about Epstein. While the Police Report and probable cause affidavit rely on- numerous assertions, all but omitted is any reference to the facts known about her by the PBPD, specifically, that at the time was making these assertions 10. - ile the Police Report and probable cause affidavit contam numerous assertions of- omitted is reference to her long history of contacts with la~ ·Among those are multiple runaway complaints by her parents and her assignment to a special high school for drug abusers. In addition to the prior criminal history of each of these critical witnesses, all of which was omitted from the Police Report and probable cause affidavit, significant additional material information concerning the credibility of these key witnesses was provided to the PBPD but never included in the Police Report, the probable cause affidavit or the public release. 11. "came forward" (as the probable cause affidavit characterizes it at pages 10-11 ), claiming she had knowledge of "sexual activity taking place" at Epstein's residence and misconduct by Epstein. Thus, it becomes clear thatlllllllllissertions of misconduct by Epstein were likely motivated by a strong desire to avoid the repercussions of her , which should have been taken into account when assessing her credibility as a witness. 12. - Was 18 at the Time She Inaccuratelv Alleges to Have Engaged in Sexual Conduct with Epstein. Epstein denies he ever had sex with - However, even if he did, irrefutable evidence, in the form of a credit card receipt, was presented to the PBPD and the State Attorney's Office which demonstrates that any such encounters occurred at a time when Ill was already 18 years of age. (Indeed, it is our understanding that it was this information, combined with the character and credibility problems presented by the facts noted herein, that led the State Attorney's Office to conclude that ~ as neither credible nor a proper complainant.) This information, though ~ n to the PBPD, was omitted from the Police Report, the probable cause affidavit and the public release. 13. Steals From a An investigation by private investigators working for the defense revealed that in late 2005- 5

Public Records Request No. 19-372 14. 15. 16. was employed at a in Florida. On October 28, 2005, some three days aft was caught by a manager asllllattempte eave t e store wit mere an ise in he~ e, the security tag still attached. (According to a report of the incident_..,as found "kneeling on the floor digging through her purse". As the manager approached,- 'pulled out a pair of black SLT panties that had the sensor on them".) Seeing the manager, . claimed "someone is trying to set me up". Following an internal investigation, which disclosed additional thefts from both the store and a customer, she was fired. (In addition to the theft above, she was seen by co-workers with store merchandise in her car; she was believed to have engaged in a fraudulent "return scheme"; and she obtained a pair of shoes from another store in the same mall by exchanging them for a pair of just purchased men's shoes inadvertently left behind by a customer). In a recorded interview by a Loss Prevention manager, llll"admitted to merchandise theft of $209 [ and asserted] "that her reason for stealing was that she understood she was not getting paid enough and was struggling financially". This information and supporting documentation was duly presented to the PBPD, but was never included in the Police Report or probable cause affidavit, and never released to the public. Lies on M vS ace About ermination. Also uncovered by defense mves 1ga ors was dissembling version of the debacle on her "MySpace" webpage. The~ announced that she " ... forgot to let everyone know I quit my job atlllllll('Tfiey said they suspected me of 'causing losses to their company' - which by the way is bullshit. I was 'by the book' on EVERYTHING!!! ... I got so fed up in that office that I handed the Loss Prevention lady back my keys and walked out". That story is not reconcilable with the taped confession. This information and supporting documentation was provided by the defense to the PBPD, but was not included in the Police Report or probable cause affidavit and never released to the public. ies on her lication. Additional information on MySpace webpage located by defense investigators casts further doubt on her credibility and undermines her ability to be a witness. For- xam le she boasts to having engaged in a fraudulent scheme to get hired by explaining, "Oh, it was so funny- I used [ my boyfriend] as one o my re erences for m • ob and the lady called me back and told me that ave me such an outstanding reference that she did not need t ca yone e se back, ... heiii t me the job! Just like that .. .I lied and said he was the old stock manager a she bought it. .. " This information and supporting documentation s prov1aed by the defense to the PBPD, but was not included in the Police Report or probable cause affidavit and never released to the public. Boasts About Her Marruana Use. Also on her MySpace we page can e found admissions o~ hasing and using marijuana and marijuana paraphernalia. Specifically,- states she is "19 years old" 6

Public Records Request No. 19-372 IV. 17. and "can't wait to buy some weed!!! ... I can't wait!!! ... (Hold on: let me say that again) I can't wait to buy some weed!!! ... I also want to get a vaporizer so I can smoke in my room because apparently there are 'narcs' everywhere" ... also posted a photograph of a marijuana signature and labeled it "what heaven looks like to me". This information and supporting documentation was provided by the defense to the PBPD, was not included in the Police Report or probable cause affidavit and never released to~ ublic (although there is both a fleeting reference in the Police Report to - use of marijuana with her boyfriend (at page 67) and in the probable cause affidavit to - marijuana - at pages 10-11)). Lies Alie in Defense Investi ators Im ersonated Police 1cers. During the course of the investigation by the PBPD and the State's Attorneys Office, the defense was notified that a witness claimed that defense investigators had impersonated police officers in an effort to get her statement. The defense subsequently concluded that these accusations were made by- (A reference to this accusation was included in the Police Report (at page 67) and the probable cause affidavit). Defense counsel immediately questioned the investigators and learned the accusation was baseless. The investigators' notes, which describe the investigators' conversation with- efute any claims of police impersonation. These notes, which were freely reproduced for the PBPD, demonstrate that the investigators gavelllllla business card clearly identifying them as private investigators. The notes provide contemporaneous evidence that - initially declined to speak to the investigators because she said she "does not speak to cops", to which the investigators responded they were not "cops". Despite having this information from defense counsel, the PBPD failed to include it in the Police Report or probable cause affidavit, including only- antastic, and false, claims and that defense counsel was investigating ~ gations. 18. olice Contacts -Dru s Alcohol Runnin Awav From Home. has a history of running away/turning up missing from her parents' various homes; of using drugs and alcohol· and of associating with unsavory individuals. For example, a Report details ho ming to Florida from - to live with her father, on olice were called to the home after her fathe~ ed tha ere missing. As it turned out, the- had voluntarily absented themselves. They stayed out all night and were returned home, drunk and h~ helpful "drug dealer". This event coincided by a few days with - having been found ~ ropriate location" by - police who this time were called by - mother because of yet another unexplained absence. Although this information, material to determining credibility, was provided by the defense 7

Public Records Request No. 19-372 19. and known to the PBPD, it was never included in the Police Report or probable cause affidavit or released to the public. e States She is 18 Drinks Smokes Does rugs, ets mto Trouble, Has Beaten Someone Up, Shoplifts, Has Skinny Dipped, Has lost her Virginity. Earns $250,000 or More, and Contains Naked and Provocative Photo ra hs. Defense investigators also found that on MySpace.com. The first image seen on the webpage, the hoto hose to represent her, is that of a naked girl (presumably provocatively lying on the beach. As late as July 2006, well after commencement of the PBPD investigation- was ( evidently) falsely representing herself on the website as being 18 years old. This evidently false representation corroborates ~ assertions ( confirmed by the polygraph examination), that - specifically represented t~ t she was 18 years old. The illuminating webpage also contains- ssertions that of all her body parts, she "love[ s] her ass", she drinks to excess, smokes, uses drugs, "gets into trouble", has beaten someone up, has shoplifted "lots", "already lost" her virginity, earns "$250,000 and higher", and has no regrets in life because "you only live once". As with the other impeaching information, this material, vital to determining credibility, was provided by the defense to the PBPD but was never included in the Police Report or probable cause affidavit and never released to the public with the other details of the case. V. Juan Alessi 20. Juan Alessi Admitted Burglarizing Epstein's Home and Mental Health Issues. As touched on above, in 2003, Epstein noticed that significant amounts of cash were missing from his Palm Beach residence. In an effort to identify the thief, Epstein had video surveillance equipment installed in the library/office and garage. Caught on tape was former employee Juan Alessi breaking in and stealing cash. The video evidence was turned over to none other than PBPD Det. Recarey. After being confronted, Alessi admitted to that break-in and claimed he was suicidal and wanted to steal a gun (which Epstein maintained a license and permit for) with which he could kill himself. He took cash instead. However, Alessi also admitted that he had repeatedly entered the home unlawfully in order to steal money. Although these facts were known to the PBPD, and in particular by Det. Recarey, Alessi's criminal history and evident mental instability were not included in the Police Report or the probable cause affidavit or released to the public. 21. Juan Alessi Lied. Alessi is significant, of course, because the Police Report includes a statement by Alessi that "the bed would almost always have to be made after the massage[s]" (at page 57). The implication being that Epstein (and presumably the masseuse) used the bed during the massages. Though the Police Report is devoid of any accusation by any woman that any activity ever occurred on the bed, no evidence concerning Alessi' s motive to lie, his 8

Public Records Request No. 19-372 criminal history, his mental instability or the factual lapses appears in the Police Report, the probable cause affidavit or the public disclosure. 9

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Meeting with Epstein's attorneys Page 1 of 1 Claudette Hughes From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS) [[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, September 20, 2007 6:17 PM To: Barry Krischer Cc: Lanna Belohlavek Subject: RE: Meeting with Epstein's attorneys Hi Barry -1 just left a voicemajl for Claudette, but figured I would send this to you, too. Our plea negotiations are not going very well, and I have given the defense a deadline of tomorrow afternoon to provide me with a signed agreement. If we cannot reach such an agreement, then I need to indict the case on Tuesday and I will not budge from that date. During my last phone call with defense counsel, he told me that they have changed their minds again, and they only want to plead to state charges, not concurrent state and federal. I said that is fine, but we will need a signed non-prosecution agreement (between the defense and us) by tomorrow afternoon, and an agreement at least verbally worked out with your office by Monday. I just think that Mr. Epstein is having second thoughts about spending time in jail and paying damages to the girls. I know you are out tomorrow, but if sometlting comes up, I will call Claudette and e-mail you. Thanks. A . .lvf arie Villafana Assistant U.S. Attorney 500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 Phone 561 209-1047 Fax 561- 820-8777 .. 9/21/2007

Public Records Request No. 19-372 One Clearlake Centre, Suite 1400 250 Australian Avenue South West Palm Beach, FL 33401 £0tr"7 \<,\'St~(;\,-- ;,I _ ,_ __________________ _

Public Records Request No. 19-372 FDR 1~· c. DATE f, ~ :za_ J ·• ~ M s::::::ftPM::« l,,lQUA, l,,lUl,.i( B □F-----,-::=:,r----c=:-:,,-=--=---- PH□NE /Q?/.•· g300 •" , .. ~-~ EXTENSION ~ 'CAME TD Sl!E~YDU WAMB TO SEE '«ll.J MESSAGE ~ « r<«4~ ... SIGNED .... FORM40□9 M ADE IN U.S.A. l ·1 I

Public Records Request No. 19-372 P.A. ~ c:._ 0 -s-\ C-\ l _s JOSEPH R.ATTERBURY JACK A. GOLDBERGER JASON S. WEISS Ek,ar d CPrt fie j C,iminar ria, Attorney M • h 'r of "J w , ~ , & f , tr t'.--'\'.r--' v--'""~ \..e ~«> ~ Jv') , l,,e_( <\,~ )l2 'j °{ ~ .I; \.ow-\1.. , ~l\'l)V-' 'f ._, ... ,J 0. (. c)\ ---tv I,_ I .r---- 4'J -\' i-.:: \ lJ? One Clearlake Centre, Suite 1400 250 A • ·--··- --- ustrahan Avenue South West"fl:,rf,n Beach, FL 33401 P 561 · 659. 8300 f 561 835 8691 · · WWW .agwpa.com

Public Records Request No. 19-372 JEFFREY EPSTEIN Jeffrey Epstein is a person who, having been raised in modest, lower middle class circumstances in New York City, parlayed an aptitude for Mathematics, a teaching experience in a private school, and a chance referral to a Wall Street executive into a unique, niche business to the wealthy which in turn has made him a wealthy person. While this represents Jeffrey's outward achievement in life, it is hardly the measure of the man. To those who have known him long or intimately, he is a loyal and unselfish friend who has a playful sense of humor. To those in the scientific, education, wellness, and civic communities who have benefited from his largesse, he is an unparalleled patron seeking nothing for himself. Finally, and mnst importantly, to those who work for him at every level, and to many of those ordinary citizens he has learned of, he has been an extraordinarily generous and understanding person, mentor, andftiend. Personal History Jeffrey Epstein was born in the Coney Island section of Brooklyn, New York in 1953. One of two sons born to Seymour and Paula nee Stolofsky Epstein, Jeffrey was raised in modest lower middle class circumstances in a longstanding Jewish neighborhood: Jeffrey's father supported the family as a laborer for the New York City Parks Department. Jeflrey' s mother was a housewife until Jeffrey and his brother were in high school when she went to work for an insurance agency. Jeflrey recalled that, during· his youth, the family often played a card game called "Concentration" for entertainment from which he may have developed his early acumen for numbers. Jeffrey described a normal family upbringing in which he felt economically and emotionally secure. Jeffrey attended public schools where his aptitude in mathematics became evident early on. He skipped the third grade at P.S. 188 and was subsequently placed in a special program which resulted in his skipping the eighth grade at Mark Twain Junior High School. After his family moved to Seagate, Jeffrey was graduated from Lafayette High School in 1969 at the age of sixteen. Thereafter, continuing to live at home, Jeffrey attended Cooper Union in Manhattan for two years where he studied Math and Physics. Jeffrey dropped out of Cooper Union and took independent courses at New York University. During this period, Jeffrey drove taxicabs summers in New York City for spending money. 1

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Around 1974, Jeffrey decided to try his hand at teaching and obtained a teaching position in mathematics with an annual salary of $12,000 at the Dalton School, a highly respected private school in uptown Manhattan which caters to the wealthy. Children in his classes included, for example, those of Robert Redford, Joel Grey and those of wealthy financiers. This was a social class to which Jeffrey had not previously been exposed. As a teacher, Jeffrey was commended for being lively, interesting, and uniquely gifted in presenting the material in a way which challenged the students. As matters would turn out, Jeffrey's experience at the Dalton School would become life- altering on a number of different levels. As Jeffrey recounts the key event, he was urged by a student to attend an art gallery opening which he reluctantly agreed to do. While there, Jeffrey was approached by a parent of one of his students who had been told that Jeffrey was an especially talented mathematics teacher. The parent asked him if he had ever considered working on Wall Street (Jeffrey states that at the time he did not even know where Wall Street was), and referred Jeffrey to Alan Greenberg, then a high level executive at Bear Stearns. During his subsequent interview with Mr. Greenberg, Jeffrey admitted that he did not know what a stock or a bond was. Mr. Greenberg explained that he had detected a sea change in the stock and bonds market from qualitatively based valuation to quantitatively based valuation. Based on Jeffrey's mathematics aptitude, Mr. Greenberg offered him a job on the spot. Jeffrey agreed and started with the firm at the end of the school year. Jeffrey utilized his mathematics expertise in becoming an adept options trader, and came to know a number of successful investors. His success in the position is reflected in the fact that by 1980 he had become the youngest limited partner in the firm. Believing, however, that he could do better on his own on the outside, he decided to resign from Bear Stearns in 1981. Capitalizing on his knowledge of and experience investing in esoteric financial instruments at Bear Stearns, combined with his exposure to the unique family and financial problems of the "hyper-rich" gained from his experience at both Bear Stearns and the Dalton School, Jeffrey started a business called J. Epstein & Company (now Financial Trust Company) wherein he acts as a family advisor to the "hyper-rich." The services he provides consist of a broad array of financial advice ( on investment, trusts, estates, asset allocation, etc.) and organization and management of the 2

Public Records Request No. 19-372 client's family office. The premise for the business is simple, if counter-intuitive: extreme wealth brings a host of unique and often intractable problems to its possessor, i.e., family, security, investment, tax planning, estate planning, etc. Jeffrey has studied families possessing such wealth, offers advice in all of these areas and, in the process, insulates the family head from the passions and emotions of other family members affected by the decisions of the family head. 1 In essence, Jeffrey offers new potential clients the scenario of "no longer having to worry about their money." Jeffrey continues in this unique "niche" business to this day. The business is currently based in the U.S. Virgin Islands, with New York City being the base of his charitable operations. Jeffrey's business and personal interests currently employ approximately 160 people. Of these, however, he is the only income-producing person. Jeffrey is single, having never married or fathered any children. He has shied away from becoming a parent because the demands of his business would not allow him the kind of time and presence needed to be a good parent. During his adulthood, Jeffrey has had two long-term relationships: the first with Eva Andersson from 1981 to 1990, and the second with Ghislaine Maxwell from 1991 to 2000. (These will be treated in greater detail below.) Jeffrey currently maintains residences in New York City; West Palm Beach, Florida; the Virgin Islands; Santa Fe, New Mexico; and Paris, France; as he was enrolled as a visiting fellow at Harvard, he also has a rented apartment in Cambridge, Massachusetts. Jeffrey has always been shy socially but is articulate and engaging in person. He has preferred to maintain his privacy despite his business associations with many wealthy and well-known people in New York City and elsewhere. In 2005, Jeffrey agreed to accompany and fly former President Bill Clinton on his AIDS Initiative journey to Africa. While Jeffrey does not regret his decision to do so because of the great good that it did, it has also had the collateral effect of raising Jeffrey's profile in the media and otherwise impacting the quiet life he has sought to live. 1Jeffrey offered the following example. The daughter of a client becomes engaged. Because of the difficulty of knowing whether her suitor is motivated by love or by money, a pre-nuptial agreement is called for. Were the client to insist on this with his daughter, he might well incur her wrath because of the implicit questioning of the motivation of her betrothed. With Jeffrey as the family advisor to the client, however, it would be he who would deliver the news to the daughter, and it would be he who would inc11r and absorb her wrath, thus insulating the client from these unpleasantries. 3

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Personal Characteristics Friendships. Despite his worldly success, Jeffrey has maintained close relationships with several of his friends from his boyhood on Coney Island. Each of these friends attest to the loyalty, generosity, and accessibility Jeffrey has always accorded them. Kathleen Lindman of New York City, for example, wrote as follows: It's difficult to express how much Jeffrey's friendship has meant to me over the course of my life, but he is nothing short of being my guardian angel. I have been blessed with a lifelong friend who regardless of the stresses of his own work and life, always makes time to listen and talk to me with gentleness, wisdom and humor. I've watched Jeffrey grow from boyhood into one of the hardest working, responsible, and generous men I know. For instance, when the time came to send my son to kindergarten, I wanted him to get the best possible education but our local public school was a failure and my husband and I couldn 't afford to send him to an independent school. Jeffrey understood how much I valued education, and empathetically volunteered to cover the costs of our son 's education. This past June, our son graduated from Columbia University with honors, and it would not have been possible without Jeffrey's long term commitment and generosity. Terry B. Kafka of Dallas, Texas, another friend who has known Jeffrey since 1958, wrote: From the time we were junior high school students, when it seemed I was always in need of math and science tutoring until today, when I frequently call upon him for business advise, Jeffrey has always dropped what he was doing to listen and help . ... I am aware of Jeffrey 's contributions to charitable causes and programs. that he believes will make a difference to mankind and society - many of which are frankly over my head. On a personal level, I can attest that he is also caring when it comes to his friends. I recall a few years ago when he spent a good amount of on-on-one time with my 19 year old son Philip to help him sort out academic problems he was having. Warren Eisenstein, O.D., also of Dallas, Texas, another long-time friend from Jeffrey's youth, recalled a number of jointly shared experiences from their younger days, including the fact that they both drove New York City taxicabs during college summer 4

Public Records Request No. 19-372 breaks. Eisenstein related a story from their youth which attests to the playful side of Jeffrey's nature: In high school, although we both were excellent academically, we were jokers in physical education. We were in great physical shape, but we just didn't take the class seriously. One month before graduation, our phys-ed teacher called us into his office and informed us that even though we were "two smart boys", we would not graduate because we would get a failing grade in phys-ed We asked what we could do to turn it around, he said it was too late. After 10 minutes of negotiating with our teacher, Jeff convinced him that we would do anything he asked us to do until graduation. Well, Jeff managed to volunteer us to not only lead gym class every day, but we both had to double every exercise that the rest of the class did ... including track. Our gym teacher gave us "C" and we graduated. Eisenstein summarized the nature of his longstanding friendship with Jeffrey in the following words: Over the years, his genius has taken him to achieve levels of success unattainable by anyone I've ever met. No matter how busy he ever is, no matter where on earth he is, whenever I needed advise, or just talk to Jeff, he was always there. As we 've gotten older, our lives have become more complicated, • but we have never missed calling each other on our birthdays. It's a small, silly thing, but how many childhood friends do you know, who have never forgotten your birthday? The most important thing to me is that as vast a difference [ as] our worlds are, our long-term, deep seated friendship is the strongest lifelong friendship one could ever have; it's just not like recently acquired friends, business associates, or even family. People who are fortunate to have these kind of .frie,uls are the only ones who could comprehend this special relationship. Jeffrey has had two long-term intimate relationships with women during his adulthood. In about 1981, Jeffrey met Eva Andersson (now Andersson-Dubin), then 20, who was a Swedish model and former Ms. Sweden. They developed a long and still enduring friendship. The relationship endured for eleven years as an intimate one. During that time, Jeffrey encouraged Eva to fulfill her dream of becoming a doctor. He encouraged her and set about to pay her expenses at medical school in Sweden. She reported that he frequently flew over to see her and ensure that she was keeping up with her studies. When she continued her medical studies in California, Jeffrey was there to cheer her on and pay her expenses. She successfully completed medical school and presently works in New York City as a well-regarded internist. 5

Public Records Request No. 19-372 When it became clear, however, that the demands of Jeffrey's life could not include staying in one place and having a family, Eva and he realized that they had no future as a family unit. They parted amicably. Eva eventually married and has had three children. This notwithstanding, they have continued to speak with each other nearly every day (as does her oldest daughter, Celina), having missed only a dozen times or so in the 26 years they have known each other. She described their current relationship as follows: Today [Jeffeey] is a very close and important friend to my family. He is the godfather of my three children and is close friend of my husband as well. Whenever Jeffrey is in New York, he will always come over in the evening and visit with us, help the children with their math homework, and conduct science Q & A at the dinner table. He will always remember the children's birthdays and he is constantly on the lookout for educational games for the kids. Four years ago when I had a cancer scare, Jeffrey was extremely supportive in visiting me everyday in the hospital. I could not ask for a better friend or godfather to my children. Jeffrey has enjoyed an especially close relationship with Celina, 12. Celina wrote glowingly of their weekly science lesson when "Uncle Jeff," as she calls him, takes time from his personal and business schedule to go over to her apartment and discuss science and mathematics lessons she is learning at school. They might talk about such things, for example, as why the sky is blue or how fast light travels. After their lesson is over, they then spend some time at the piano where "Uncle Jeff' helps her work on her singing voice (even though, as she knows, "Uncle Jeff' does not have any real expertise in this area). The closeness of their relationship is perhaps best suggested, however, by an incident Celina related in her letter: One of the nicest things anyone has ever done for me happened about 2 years ago when I was at ballroom dancing class. It was father-daughter dance day and unfortunately my father was stuck in a business meeting. I didn't know what 1 would do because you had to bring your father to the dance class. I got to the class alone, but then soon enough a quick phone call to Uncle Jeff didn't leave me standing there, alone for more than I 0 minutes. Uncle Jeff substituted for my father that night, and the way he rushed to the class felt exactly like having my father there. After Eva and Jeffrey decided to put their relationship on a platonic basis, Jeffrey entered into another significant relationship with Ghislaine Maxwell, then 29, beginning 6

Public Records Request No. 19-372 in 1991. Ghislaine reported that she had come to New York City at a very dark time of her life. Her father, Robert Maxwell, a well-known publisher, had been found dead floating in the Atlantic Ocean, having gone overboard from a yacht. Her two brothers were involved in subsequent criminal proceedings related to the death, for which they were eventually acquitted. Ghislaine had no close friends in New York City at the time. Ghislaine met Jeffrey through mutual friends. She found the friendship immediately rewarding, as he engaged her in intellectually stimulating conversation. Moreover, Jeffrey understood that there were few bright spots for her during that period, and he never allowed her to become despondent. He understood that there were practical things he could do for her. He gave her books to read - good novels, scientific studies - containing issues to challenge her mind. Then they would discuss the issues and, in the process, take her outside of her personal concerns. Jeffrey had the insight to take her to comedy clubs on a weekly basis. This she found enormously palliative in relieving her depression. She believes that without Jeffrey at that time, she would have likely fallen into a deep depression. Jeffrey also offered to arrange for Ghislaine to secure a loan that would help her get a foothold in the business world. She explained that Jeffrey's way of helping friends with his money is always with a view toward maintaining their dignity. He would never just give out money as it is too demeaning to the recipient. When he gives money to people he does not know, it is always anonymously so that the recipient feels no need to give it back. These gifts are meant to allow the recipient to continue the work that Jeffrey finds interesting and useful. In the case of Ghislaine, Jeffrey arranged for the loan, which she subsequently paid back. In this way, she was able to maintain her self-respect. Over time, their relationship became intimate. However, as with Eva, it ended amicably around 2000 upon the realization that the nature of the demands of his work, i.e., the long hours and the frequent travel to maintain contacts around the world, precluded a good married life with children. Ghislaine and Jeffrey remain friends to this day. She wrote of their relationship: .My experience of Jeffrey, is of a thoughtful, kind, generous loving man, with a keen sense of humor and a ready smile - a man of principles and values and a man of his word If he made a promise, he would always follow through. In fact, I never saw him break a promise. He is 7

Public Records Request No. 19-372 disciplined in business and conscientious. A man always quick to help someone who is down, or to offer an opportunity to someone to pursue a dream or a goal. Generosity to Educational. Wellness, Civic and Scientific Organizations. Jeffrey has been extraordinarily generous to a host of educational, wellness, civic, and scientific organizations. Between 2000 and 2006 he donated personally, through his business and interests, and through foundations he had established,2 a total exceeding $16,000,000. The good generated by his largesse is suggested in the following examples. Jeffrey has been a benefactor to a number of educational institutions, but perhaps none more so than Harvard University. One example arose out of a need of the Jewish community at Harvard to have a new Hillel Center built to foster Jewish social and religious life at the university. Toe fundraising campaign was having difficulties when Henry Rosovsky, then Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences, decided to approach Jeffrey. Rosovsky wrote: At this point I approached Jeffrey and suggested that a $2 million gift would allow him to have his name on the building. It seemed to me a tempting proposition. To get your name on a Harvard building is a rarity and the cause was worthy. I do not remember all the subsequent details, but in essence this is what happened Jeffrey told me that he would raise the naming gift and that he certainly did not want his name on the building. Leslie Wexner would also participate and he did not want his name on the building. Indeed, he had decided - by himself or jointly with Wexner - that my name should be on the building because I had been associated with the institution for such a long time. I.fully recognized the generosity and modesty of this suggestion and greeted it with mixed feelings. I did not feel deserving of this honor but without the Epstein-Wexner participation there would have been no building. In truth, without Jeffrey's intervention there would have been no new building and that would have been an enormous loss to the community. The building that now stands on the Harvard campus is the Riesman Center for Harvard- Radcliffe Hillel at Rosovsky Hall. This example is instructive because it also suggests a noteworthy aspect of Jeffrey's giving: to the extent that it is possible, Jeffrey wants his 2 The Jeffrey Epstein Virgin Islands Foundation, Inc. and the C.O.U.Q. Foundation. 8

Public Records Request No. 19-372 gifts to be anonymous. Where this is not possible, he nonetheless does not seek the spotlight and makes it clear that nothing in return is expected. Jeffrey has also been an important benefactor to the Scholar Rescue Fund of the Institute of International Education. This fund is designed to provide support and safe haven to scholars who would otherwise be silenced, imprisoned, or even killed in such places as Iraq, Iran, Rwanda, and Sudan. Jeffrey has also been one of the major sponsors over the last several years of the "Female Economist of the Year" award offered by the Stockholm School of Economics. Jeffrey and one of the foundations he has created were the original sponsors and creators of "The Prize for Promise," a national award program designed to "identify post-graduate women of exceptional ability, ambition, brilliance, courage, dedication, and vision'' to encourage them to pursue their chosen fields of endeavor to make improvements in the world. Yet another example of Jeffrey's generosity in the educational arena arose during his trip through Africa with former President Clinton. Jeffrey approached the President of Rwanda and offered to pay the room, board, and tuition for two worthy Rwandan students to earn an undergraduate degree in the . United States. Jeffrey has made good on this promise through the Clinton Foundation, and the two students are currently enrolled at the City University of New York where they are expected to graduate in 2008. Jeffrey has also been a generous contributor to a number of wellness organizations. In particular, he has donated significant sums to the Ovarian Cancer Research Fund, the Alliance for Lupus Research, the Michael J. Fox Foundation, the Continuum Center for Health & Healing, the Institute for Music and Brain Science, and the Center for Health and Healing. Jeffrey has also been a long time benefactor of a number of civic organizations in both New York City and the Virgin Islands. With respect to the former, he has been a major contributor to the Robin Hood Foundation, whose purpose is to target poverty in New York City by finding, funding, and partnering with the most effective poverty fighting programs to maximize results. In the Virgin Islands, Jeffrey has donated money to literally dozens of civic organizations in need. These have included educational, sports, environmental, governmental, crisis intervention, children's advocacy and women's groups. One noteworthy example is the Antilles School in St. Thomas which 9

Public Records Request No. 19-372 in 2005 recognized Jeffrey's generosity in assisting 27 students from 24 families to attend the school who otherwise would not have been able to. Perhaps the most unique area of Jeffrey's philanthropy is his no-strings attached support of scientists and mathematicians who are conducting "bleeding edge" research. As previously noted, Jeffrey has always had a deep interest in mathematics and science, and is particularly attracted to research which focuses on the mathematical foundation of life. By his own admission, he actively searches out scientists who are in the forefront of such research, enjoys meeting and talking with them, and often supports their research financially with the only proviso that they keep doing what they are doing. One example of this is Murray Gell-Mann of the Santa Fe Institute, the Nobel Prize winning physicist who predicted the existence of the quark and who later collaborated with colleagues at the institute on what has become known as Chaos Theory. Another particular example is Martin A. Nowak, Ph.D., Director of the Program for Evolutionary Dynamics at Harvard University. Dr. Nowak recently wrote: Over the years Jeffrey has taken a great interest in my research work, which deals with a mathematical description of biological processes. I have had many fruitful discussions with him. Often he would ask questions, which are surprising for me. Often I feel that none of my scientific colleagues would have asked that question, because we are too engaged in our own narrow perspective. Jeffrey's questions and proposals are highly original and always surprising. Many of his questions an.d ideas have led to highly successful research projects. For example, many years ago Jeffrey asked me about group selection, which led me to the discovery of the first precise mathematical theory of that topic. A bit later Jeffrey made me think about interaction networks between people. The result was 'evolutionary graph theory', which is new field of mathematical biology. Most recently, Jeffrey discussed with me complicated ideas about the origin of life and the transition from chemistry to biology. The discussion also resulted in a highly successful and completely new research project. . .. Jeffrey has also financially supported my research projects. He has donated $500,000 to the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, where I have worked as Head of Theoretical Biology from 1998 until 2003. In 2003, Jeffrey donated $6,500,000 to Harvard University, where I work as Director of the Program for Evolutionary Dynamics and Professor of Mathematics and Biology. Both donations were meant to support my basic research work without any strings attached 10

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Generosity to Employees and Others. While it might be commonplace to say that a particular business person treats his employees as family, Jeffrey's history clearly reflects this fact on both financial and emotional levels. Jeffrey is a wealthy man who is quick to share his largesse. But he is also a man who engages personally and emotionally those who work for him and those he knows. Once he learns of and determines through conversation a need or an aspiration of an employee, he explores this with the employee, treats it in almost mathematical terms as a problem in search of a solution, and then sees to it that, without strings attached, the solution happens. The issues may be accommodations that an employee needs to address pressing personal or family problems; tuition payments that an employee or employee family member needs to better himself or herself; or assistance, both financial and professional, an employee needs to address the vexing and often tragic problems that life presents human beings. In this capacity, he is a benefactor but quite often also a mentor. Examples abound. One particularly poignant one was recounted by Darren K. Indyke, general counsel to Jeffrey: Two years ago, a building workman approached Jeffrey with news that the workman's wife needed a kidney transplant and that the workman's sister- in-law was a willing donor. Unfortunately, the sister-in-law was a citizen of Colombia and the workman did not have the financial resources or know how to get the sister-in-law into the country for the surgery. Jeffrey arranged for immigration counsel to expedite a visa for the sister-in-law and sponsored and purchased the plane tickets for the sister-in-law's visit to the United States. The surgery was a success and both patients recovered completely. The sister-in-law flew back to Colombia at Mr. Epstein 's expense. Last year, the workman and his wife celebrated the high school graduation of their oldest daughter, whose college education is now being funded by Mr. Epstein. There have been many instances of accommodations Jeffrey has made for employees so that they could address significant issues of their personal lives. Several examples follow: A father of one of Jeffrey's employees in the Virgin Islands was recently diagnosed with cancer. Jeffrey is personally paying the medical bills for the father's treatment and has given the employee financial support and complete flexibility to take time off from work whenever required in order to fly to Florida to attend to the employee's father. 11

Public Records Request No. 19-372 Lesley Groff, a personal assistant to Jeffrey, reported a number of accommodations Jeffrey has made, i.e., purchase of a vehicle for her commute, extended maternity leave, a reduced work week and permission to work from home, which have strengthened her family life. Lauren Kwintner, another New York City-based employee, told of accommodations from 2003 to 2005 that Jeffi-ey made for her to attend to her father, who had been diagnosed with multiple myeloma, at both Sloane Kettering Memorial Hospital and subsequently the Hospital for Joint Diseases, until his passing. Bella Klein, also a New York City-based employee, was a single mother whose son was accepted to Cornell University; Jeffrey has paid up to 70% of his tuition expenses; the son now has his Master's Degree and· is working on his Ph.D. Harry Beller, a sixteen-year employee, is an orthodox Jew who is required to be home prior to sundown on Fridays and on all Jewish holidays. Jeffrey has always accommodated his religious commitments, on occasion permitting pressing Friday transactions to take place on the following Monday. Mr. Beller also told of Jeffrey's assistance in making available any of his contacts in the medical field and to take any necessary time off when one of his sons was diagnosed with Retinoblastoma. Jeffrey has been especially generous in funding the educational pursuits of his employees (and their family members) as a way of assisting them to better themselves and achieve their full potential. Mr. Indyke has written that over the last six years, Jeffrey has funded literally hundreds of thousands of dollars in tuition assistance to many individuals (some of whom Jeffrey has no connection with whatsoever) from the pre- school to the post-graduate levels. Mr. Beller, mentioned above, for example, has been the recipient of tuition assistance for all six of his children! Another employee, Emad Hanna, who was hired by Jeffrey at a particularly trying time of his adult life, told of Jeffrey's sponsorship of his son's AAU baseball team and of the tuition assistance for his son: Jeffrey Epstein has paid out of his pocket my son's high school tuition/or 2 years now totaling around $20,000 and has given him the opportunity to get a top notch education at a private all boys catholic high school and my son has thrived in that environment and averaged a grade of 91 in his freshmen (~ year and from all the travel baseball experience he was able to make the JV baseball team at one of the top schools in New Jersey. This has paved the way for my son to possibly hav~ the opportunity to 12

Public Records Request No. 19-372 attend a college of his choice when the time comes. I would not have been able to [ do J this if it wasn 't for Mr. Epstein. Another example is that of a building worker named Philip Diaz whom Jeffrey is putting through vocational school in heating, refrigeration, and air conditioning. Mr. Indyke related that Jeffrey also takes time from his otherwise hectic schedule to meet with and mentor Mr. Diaz. A final education example was related by David Lambert, ~ employee: While working late, after normal business hours, I have developed a relationship with the cleaning man who details our office space. Alfredo and I reflect life's issues and family matters as best [ as] a Colombian and English speaking .friend may, but it takes us deep and a look or gesture speaks louder than words at times. One night our sign language, broken English and Spanish went to the topic of his oldest daughter attending college. Alfredo told me how proud he is of her attending college. "Me daughter, she very, very happy. " I could see the emotion in his eyes which led to the words spoken loudly, clearly, and emphatically "... because, Mister Jeffrey. " After many such conversations with Alfredo it's clear to me he was angst ridden for his children, not being able to provide the dream of a college level education, his children aware and sad of such consequence, were whisked away instantly to an ethereal place by one man. This is what my provider, Jeffrey Epstein, does for people. If he is aware of human suffering he will act quickly, generously, and without thought. Then he will walk away. His goal has been achieved and a life's crisis avoided, human suffering eliminated. Jeffrey is also aware that tragedy is a part of the landscape that people have to face and address. When he learns of employees facing such life critical events, he brings the same virtues, i.e., empathy, a determination to identify and solve the problem, and generosity, which he uses in other areas of his life, to bear on the problem. Mr. Indyke faced one such problem, and his recollection of it is worth quoting at length: Shortly after I began working for Jeffrey, I experienced a personal and unexpected tragedy. After five years of marriage, my wife and I learned that I was infertile and we could not have children in the traditional manner. The recommended treatment protocol required my wife and I to undergo prohibitively expensive in-vitro fertilization cycles, which we could not afford and which were not then covered by the company's medical insurance. I meekly approached Jeffrey and asked him if it would be possible to drop my wife and me from the company's _medical policy in exchange for a 13

Public Records Request No. 19-372 different one or cash payment. Puzzled by my request, Jeffrey naturally asked why. When I told him, he was visibly affected and without even a moment's consideration, he told me to go for treatment and send him the bills. Having been with Jeffrey only a few months, I was astounded by his generosity and hurried to my desk to call my wife to share the amazing news. In the days and weeks that followed, Jeffrey personally researched infertility issues and shared the results of his research with me. He identified the experts in the field to make sure that my wife and I were seeing the right people. He and I spoke often about these issues and the progress of our treatment cycle. Unfortunately, the first cycle ended up a failure. Though my wife and I were hesitant to ask him, Jeffrey insisted that we undergo another cycle at his expense. The second cycle resulted in a pregnancy which had to be terminated because of genetic defects in the fetus. My wife and I were devastated and once again Jeffrey offered emotional, as well as .financial, support and encouraged us to proceed. When the third cycle failed and my wife was then diagnosed with infertility problems, Jeffrey met with me to go over my wife's and my options, which now included in-vitro fertilization with donor eggs, an even costlier endeavor. Jeffrey did not blink and insisted to pay for the treatments if my wife and I decided we were willing to proceed. He also helped us explore options of private adoption through an agency. We chose the former, which Jeffrey fonded, while we also pursued the in-vitro/egg donor option at Jeffrey's expense. At the unsuccessful completion of our fourth cycle and a failed adoption attempt, my wife and I were at the end of our rope and did not want to continue. Without Jeffrey's support and stubborn daily encouragement we would not have. He even recruited his then girlfriend, Ghislaine Maxwell, to meet with us to offer assistance with local adoption and overseas adoption procedures and to encourage us to try again. Thankfully, after our fzfth cycle, my wife and I were blessed with twin daughters. Although Jeffrey was adamant that we owed him nothing, Jeffrey honored us by agreeing to be the godfather of our children. The bottom line for Jeffrey Epstein is that while he has become an improbably successfully business man, he has also been an unusually understanding and generous human being. His generosity has taken many forms and has benefited many people, but has been primarily directed to employees and others he comes in contact with, educational institutions, "bleeding edge" scientific researchers, wellness organizations, and civic groups. His aim has been to improve the lives of individuals by helping them 14

Public Records Request No. 19-372 address life problems and reach their potential; to enable educational, wellness, and civic organizations to better achieve their respective purposes; and, to foster the kind of scientific research which might potentially benefit all of mankind. Finally, in his generosity, Jeffrey has sought nothing for himself. To the extent it is possible, his giving has always been anonymous; when this has not been possible, it is clear that he does not seek the spotlight for these acts. 15