Internal DOJ email from March 2021 discussing a 'friendly subpoena' for settlement records from Minor Victim-4, the fourth victim added to the superseding indictment against Ghislaine Maxwell.

This is a high-value internal prosecution email from the Chief of the Public Corruption Unit at the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York. Dated March 26, 2021—just days before the superseding indictment was filed on March 29, 2021—the email reveals prosecutors seeking settlement documents from a victim who settled with Jeffrey Epstein around 2008. The prosecutors explicitly note they need these materials for trial preparation and as potential 'Giglio' material (evidence that could be used to impeach a witness's credibility). The email shows the coordination between the Maxwell prosecution team and the victim's counsel, who agreed to provide records but required a formal subpoena.

Key Highlights

• •Sent from the Chief of the Public Corruption Unit at SDNY—the unusual unit choice that sparked speculation about potential public corruption angles in the Epstein case
• •References Minor Victim-4, whose abuse formed the basis for the sex trafficking charges added in the superseding indictment filed three days later
• •Discusses seeking the victim's 2008 settlement with Epstein as potential Giglio material—impeachment evidence that could affect witness credibility at trial
• •Shows the 'friendly subpoena' process where a cooperating witness's attorney requests formal legal process to provide documents

Frequently Asked Questions