07/26/17 Page 1 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

CAD040R1 CROSS REFERENCE LIST PAGE- 1 PALM BE COUNTY - CLERK OF COURT PREPARED46N-09/16/05 ************ CROSS REFERENCE I N F ORMATION**C CC07** ** DEFENDANT'S NAME ARREST CASE ** ** NUMBER NUMBER ** ** . 05023062MM A02 m* ** **CHARGE: POSSESSION OF MARIJUANA UNDER 20 GRAMS ** ****mm************************************************************************* DEFENDANT ACTIVITY REPORT CASE HISTORY : ARREST CASE KIV FILE OR PURGE NUMBER NUMBER DATE DATE 05023062MM A02 09/15/05 CHARGE: POSSESSION OF MARIJUANA UNDER 20 GRAMS CHARGE: POSSESSION OF DRUG PARAPHERNALIA STATUS: ARRAIGNMENT: 092705 COURT: KK TIME: 0800 NTA DATE: 07/26/17 Page 2 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Weeks Reset from A.S.A. P.D./Atty.: Bondsman: Case is set f /CV— at e. ()OA M In Div. /Sent/Prelim/Final/ Status Ck on a?) Gig 404, iVY IN THE COUNTY COURT IN AND FOR PALM BEp.CH COUNTY, FLORIDA (CRIMINAL DIVISION) MEMORANDUM CASE NO O • 3_0(0.„) 0-17-yela) DEFENDANT I, the Defendant, request a continuance of the arraignment for the following reason(s),: I understand that I must be tried within ninety (90) days or be discharged. I understand that I am waiving that right. I consent to the Court resetting my case at the earliest convenient time although beyond the requirements for speedy trial. U County Courthouse ,I2if Criminal Justice Complex U So. Co. Complex U No. Co. Complex D Criminal Justice Bldg 205 N. Dixie 3228 Gun Club Road 200 W. Atlantic Avenue 3188 PGA Blvd. 38844 State Road 80 Room # Courtroom # Roam # Room # 212 Courtroom West Palm Beach West Palm BeaCr' Delray Beach Palm Beach Gardens Belle Glade Date q ) r Figriature Narnt Address City Mailed To: L 202 5100 I imeordonce with the Americans Wrth Disaleithas Act. persons m need of a spacial acconvnoclatioo to participate in of promoting shalt within a eammeattes erne prior to any lareoeetherj. contact the Adminisiratimi Mice of the. Coon, 206 North [N3E6) 16011- way, Room 5.25, West Palm Beach, Flooda 33401, 10100046 (581) 355-2431. 1-800-95541771 (100) or 1-800-955-8770 (V). vie Florida Relay Stafe Zip 07/26/17 Page 3 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

VALID LICENSE SHOWN WRONG DEFENDANT CHARGED DATE: 4i 11 11 ' E. KRISCH/ ttoniey .l5sitAtutt State Attonte Florida Dar No. IN DIE COI; Nil' COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH 'DICIAI, CIRCUff, CRIMINAL DIVISION, IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COI ,N•ry, Ft oRIDA DIVISION "KK" CASE NO. Q 3 o M A/t/1 STATE OF FLORIDA IN FORMA I ION FOR: DWLS/C1R. NO VALID DiL VIO. OF DIE REST. NO V V.ID OR EXP. REG. ATI. TAG NOT ASSIGNED Defendant IMP OR EXP. TEMP TAG NO PIP POSSESSION OF MARIJUANA POSSESSION OF PARAPHERNALIA NOLLE PROSSE ALTHOUGH 'THERE WAS PROBABLE CAUSE FOR DIE CHARGE(S) THE CAS/. S ARE NOLLE PROSSED FOR THE FOLLOWING REASON(S): LICENSE OR PRIVILEGE To DRIVE REINSTATED VALID R EGISTRVIION I IOWN TEEN PLE:A.CONIPI D PLEA NEGOTIATION AGE OF CASE PROI F OF INSURANCE SHOWN OTHER C t/k.) ACF CLASS COMPLETED 07/26/17 Page 4 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

> icE = c lows .,",..„, ll! t t•i.111 7 Ai3pEsy f NCTICE TCMPPEA1-1 • Arrest 3 Request for Warren; 4 1 ...7. 1 Juvenile Reletral Report 2 N T A 4 Reobest for Clem .luvenzfe 1 I III1N/ency CRI Number '.. FE01 5 1 0 1 0 1 6 ' 0 1 0 •7- 91i ApenCy Nam! PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMEN1 Agency Report NurN.1,A.:30 , 0 &Tar. ° I. Felonr y Der Misderneanoi G 5 Orchnanco as aPPIY- 0 2. Traffic Felony 0 4. Traffic Msde-,ezinor 0 E. Other - 7 L6 119 II-1 tr, V' 1 1 - 4,- 1 _3 l(10 01) If Weapon Seized Enter Type Multiple --, Clearance Qa, I.bort d An Onokairg Name or tikainests) a) 611-146.74 ,khkii_ on of 01 (Business a 1.4q4c.. N . Adders} ANA- GrA.J6 Indcator t ^en..• c- e 171 it I t °A T.x., 4-34 , ,. S t i Li. F3COlvero Dale Booker) Time J ;I Dale Jed Tome Locum ol Vehicle I —1 . [I' *SO' S1" .... en,' ....•-•-•• IS°.: . 9ef*Wfnt34 , . . .. / •• r.,e.r..(Grly.Stale) ..„. 1 PC' r„-1 , Lit Cotrant Name (last ' . Ma3:19) /ski g i&Cet Fy")., _ Race 1•4/ Sea Al Del of rth 4%. Oslo ,e, / 02: Arrested l Larva a.i. melo a ea U5 Juvenile 0 I K Arrested a, 3 Felony 8 Co-Oeferhola Name IL.est. First. lAdolel - Race See - 02. Al Urge 04 Misdemeanor 0 5..k.ivende Laz HParent Name (Laatl f Flop (lAddle) 0 penal c.toran Ressfence Phone ( ) Address (Stara. ACS Number) !Cory) (Stain) 791 Business Phone I ) z7 t.Y.r2 TOT JAC Data Time ../ --, The above adders was Provided by 0 defendant and / or 0 Wendt/MS Parries. The chid and ler Parent was MO to keep the Juvenile Court Danes Offl•e• (Phone 355 2$28) informed of any change of addreSs 0 Yea. by: (Name) 0 No. (Nissan) School Auended Grade Property Came 0 Yes 0 No Descnpbore of Propely Value at Properly 114, 6 V Ong Activity S. Sell R. Smuggle K. prepense; M. Manufacture/ tt P&A 0. Deaver Distribute Produce/ p Possess B. Terac E Use c'. 7 Other vets Doug Type IftlarbiApato R Hallu.anogen P. Paraphernalia/ 02. Other Unknown N. WA C Cocaine M Marijuana Equ oni A Amphetamine E.Heroin a opurIvoemv. S S 2w I Is / Oomestic V e ,30,,,n4 S e Ma ' Nurrebef A I I. I I 31 1 ire;ts 1 0.). , Violation of CRO 0 C7013119N:'n Tier :.......,,,,,,, Orrsr' 'f...<5.1 0 -F ne i 44 A 0; 1 Amount /Una th•lor" •Zo Gs, "--5 Ott Warrant Warrant /Capias Number • :,,, 1.11 1 Lk rile/I-JAC:4- —_PoSS,...- / Counts / Ormeat,c ndremirN• SAJilaW ri 7 j 5 r171_541 7 tu . I.:,- ._ 1 . z_L--.., 1 of ORO II Drug rely Terpe A unt/ Unit / P ,e c- °"0,5" `r4" 1 /14 3 Warrant i apes Number ._. ,„, .( X 0 , Charge Dot:capon , Counts Domestic v,.e.,,..., 0 y 0 N Statute Violation Number i L Ui I I_ Id .1:- .1_ . 1 iolaeon of ONO ir Ong Actney Drug Type Amount I Unit °Meese r Warrant !Capin Number 111' Band , , ,, 0 ri 1 0 Charge DescrIptkon Counts Domestic 1 W klence 0 v 0 N StsiMe Molalion Number 5 e5 ... • - A 1_ U. i_ _I .V 1 I A - Moostion of ORD r 1 Drug Arson* Ong Type Amount r Unit Ottense a Warrant /Calves Number I flood NOTICE TO APPEAR I Ili Instruction No. I Mandatory Appearance In Court I.g10, Ro.. mber.Aockssal " 00' /4 Lett A -J4 Ep Ats LAX-S% air -ft, P:11;44-fr 17t 0 Instruction No. 2 You need nal appear in Coon but most comply with in:Out:POPE On Reverse Side Coed Da and Tuna Month , tA1/1- bay s9A2 Year j0}2‹.- Tune 641 P.M. I AGREE TO APP APPEAR BE • 'Ii • AT THE TIME ANC I, COURT - --'• 1„10 -LACE DESIGNATE TO • SHIER THE OFFENSE • ED BY THIS •TICE 9 PPEAR, THAT INA? AS CH ED OR TO PAY THE FINE SUBSCRIBED. I UNDERSTAND THAT • • I WILLFULLY FAIL 10 BE HELD IN CONTEMPT OF COURT LAW • RANT • • • ARREST SHALL RE ISSUED i I 0 ' ..?; nature 0104• nt or i senile st.7'arenl ustcdia p A. EMMA I ADMIN I HOLD for oMer Agency Hanle X 0 -c- Signature of Arrest.011ie((Irv( Name Verification (Printed by Arrestee) CI ()impends 0 Resisted Mrest cr.( dIr•'fr 10. s (PRINT' 0 sodow D other Name of A;tsting OQC-- iet‘aLIK (-4P-4 ebe,_r_) PAGE Intake Deputy I.0 4 Pouch Transporarc °lacer I.O. is Agency' Witness he if sublecl ppm? with an 'X' OF DISTRIBUTION WHITE - COURT COPY GREEN - STATE ATTORNEY YELLOW - AGENCY Peet - JAIL GOLD DEFENDANT pz T.As Om y) 07/26/17 Page 5 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

7 n OW '; Number 1.11 ILI) , PROBAncE CAUSE AFFIDAVIT 1 arcs. 3 Request ft" Warrani 2 N T A 4 Request to- Copvi . .1 Age:,cy CITIt Number , RC' 5 1 0 i 0 L 6 1 0 i 0 5 Agency Name PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Agency Report Number 7 1 6 -101.5-1-119ietiel k-431(101_01) Char:* type 0 I Felony the AoSdemeanor l] S Onlmance Cher), as ,MIN as a vy 0 7. Traffic Felony li 4 Traffic Misdemeanor U 6 ()gn- Special NoN•5 0 o Ch . lD:rsolptlo/ — 0.-SS VS'S/ la "-I of 1),/4-,"4-- Charge UesmM ron Desnriphan (-ICC fr. S 1 a .4 of ¢.4. P412.70,Yri,-4.6 Charge Descsohen )-: U N con's Name (LaoL Fest. Wile) Race Ses 0 e of BM 1 1 1_ t Loral Address (Surer. Apt Number) (City) (State) I/91 Phone ArbdreSe Source Bushes Address (Name. Street) lColyI (Sate( (Zip) Phone Occupation. The underseped centres and swears that he/she has lust and reasonable grounds to believe, and does beieve that the above name Defendant contemned the too ann.) 'notation of law She Person taken /Me custody ) -C.OrnMtlteol the below acts in my presence ri was observed by who told confessed to that herShe saw the arrested person commit the below acts. admahng to the below facts f] was found to have committed the below acts. resitting from my (described) investigation. On the /1 day of- ef.-de 200 rit 7_1 CI AM )61.4 iSpecifIcaRy inciutie facts constituting cause for arrest.) tfi'/V C(' W & S‘t701_igCli // clOC:c Ar, ipiaja-cei.MA-fr <.*-4,4 Avet ....7--- - a.4-5-(4-‘4G6 A- coux- Dm* kiiet.a iefr Xrs,,,,As.,,, EL- -7--; ?Cie 1.1/zY A4R-E-go 141 A ...., ,...Sirec9 21 0,4‘... tAirrili.0 41-- Cvgat /1../ t "Y/ /4cRzi_c 4.0...? 26,0 Ah.24')/ • i °cc", glti t) . As 4- lil_paz iir A eep,40 t. 14-IfieLf A ik."4,/cer z,c,--f- A 201.J, whvcie i ......) ce)„,...15,..dci CAL.2_ SZ/v0 OA/ /47E C100 A (our Of r i, AL A /wit., ii... 41,4: tith:i13 itylitoge_dem_i5 t.7z3 ..1-- eg.S£.4-i CZ /1•"( ,r", Cc .--,ja wiz / /NS, O£ 'C C(14" sq VE4er 4/6t11/ eili 4 ZDODS16)r ey es . ..7-- .#44-0 z C71-c-r•Cel "fa%) J Obo 4 -r. 14 - ii 2 : 9 (4-7,v4 -F-R_e", ,./Ais,•*_ 44-7",- 6 ^:_.5 wag OsrAz,-,,,.5 c , CAUSE STATEME -74., g£ (...i ITil occ.looLex --F "ifi.-4/ - -S- ArAfcc ,794.- 0 C.-r--,-,p ors il,E-4-e-At5 Vf<ficix /5"'6 4sre--0 Mc*/ /4 "1/61,9 / ;11;17'2? 9 t/ 91- st 4, "7: 4 tk-,C.vci slkfc- ,,.14,2,,,f., /mot g4-r-- s//,C ea> 14,"10.,,i /'- I ' / / A- c-i-f4A- p Iffir 17 € .4, C.,,IDItAl, AMI A2- ,.. 9 1., /t",# 4- Slac),./v,40-f.A. _41/5 6,./7P),yis i Of 4 O. - 9../...).)_.4 Arl) A- j 1--Aect /1/;,01- 67^41i9 A40 , A1AIRepx.Afg- Ar /0,,c - goCM -C 1) 1 MO att),/ 4 *7%1.0 1-44./e4-4- 7611.4. idar/7-7 0/t . 11-44Vie Bill( cp eyi./ yge if c'-i.,10-...f e . , 0 -,,,e,, / A/C4.9s,4- . . - 7 7 /A2-1-CS.if.c 4,ti C-1/iln-E.6 4/ipe /40.5-s-gs.A3.,, a •-r yi j ,,,$,J,f gr.s• sys, / 3(41),1„t, i cx_c .<- jr,c,,. 4 ,t) A9 f .- ' Oval.,:i A g pl, 1-114.4-409(.......00-- 1C-S--s" Pf3 • /t7 0164,j ,hekio- i•fif. jive° Af- a • 6/24....s ) )7- < lot > SWORN AND SUEISCP : • BEFORE ME I I 6 rc SIGNATURE OF ARP TiNG. VESTIGATI OFFICER / msa.A NOTA • ' RLIC i—r• OF COUP ICE- OFFICER 40 --C). 4, NAME OF OFFICE (PLEAS RINE PAGE DATE io'4- C., j /WI , OAT f J -..... DISTRIBUTION WHITE — Coon COPY GREEN — State Attorney — Agency 07/26/17 Page 6 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Date: 11/18/05 z'ALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Time: 11:36:11 Incident Report Program: CMS301L Case No 1-05-001. 263 SPECIAL NOTES : Occur To Date : 9/11/05 2344 Day Of Week . Sunday Street Number : 200 BAHAMA LN City PALM BEACH, FL Location Type : HIGHWAY/ROADWAY Beat Map Reference : 23 Dept Report Officer : CARISTO, NICHOLAS Case Case Status Dt : 9/11/05 Supervisory Dt.: Entry Date . . : OREGERO, LAURA 9/12 /05 Names? Property? . Vehicles? Offenses? . Narrative? Related Cases? : Assignment: Class . . : Status . : SHIFT 3 DRUG LAW VIOLATION CLEARED BY ARREST BURFIELD, KURT 9/11/015 Occur From Date: 9/11/05 2344 Report Date . : 9/11/05 2345 ATION# ********# PROPERTY INFORM Case number . : 1-05-001263 Category . . : **EVIDENCE/CONFISCATED Description . : MARIJUANA CIGARETTE Serial number Model Property type MISCELLANEOUS Insured by . Value 0.00 Recovered Date : 0/00/00 Street number City Drug? 1 ********************* (NOT UCR)*** Color Make NCIC number Recovered by Recovery value UCR Prop Type Insured? : MISCELLANEOUS 0.00 Document? ********* p RCPERTY INFORMATION# 2 ********************* Case number : 1-05-001263 Category . : **EVIDENCE/CONFISCATED (NOT UCR)*** Description : 2 GLASS PIPES W/MARIJ.RESIDUE Color Serial number Make UCR Prop Type : MISCELLANEOUS Insured? NCIC number Recovered by Recovery value : 0.00 Street number City Drug? ********* PROPERTY INFORM Case number : 1-05-001263 Category . . **EVIDENCE/CONFISCATED Description . : CLEAR PLASTIC BAGGY W/ Color Make UCR Prop Type : MISCELLANEOUS Insured? NCIC number Model Property type Insured by . Value Recovered Date : MISCELLANEOUS 0.00 : 0/00/00 Document? ATION# 3 ***************+***** Property type : MISCELLANEOUS Insured by . . : Value • 0.00 (NOT UCR)*** MARIJUA. Serial number Model 07/26/17 Page 7 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Date: 11/18/05 Time: 11:36:11 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: Incident Report Program: CMS3D1L Case No • 1-85-001263 Recovered by . : Recovery value : 0.00 Street number : City Drug? *********PROPERTY INFORM Case number . 1-05-001263 Category . . : **EVIDENCE/CONFISCATED Description : PAPER BAG W/MARIJUANA Serial number Model Property type MISCELLANEOUS Insured by . Value 0.00 Recovered Date : 0/00/00 Street number : City Drug? *********VEHICLE Case number . : 1-05-001263 State Veh Type : AUTO Make • MITSUBISHI Model Name . . : GALANT Style - 4 DOOR Color - Bottom : VIN 4A3AJ56G9VE196319 Disposition Insured by . Vehicle locked : Date recovered : 0/00/00 Street number : City Recovery code : Be On Look Out?: (Continued) Recovered Date : 0/00/00 Document? ATION# 4 tk******************* (NOT UCR)*** Color Make UCR Prop Type : MISCELLANEOUS Insured? NCIC number Recovered by . Recovery value 0.00 Document? 1 ********************A. : **SEARCHED** • 1997 Model GALANT Permit Number : 111076356 Color - Top : WHITE License # . : C104VY FL Stolen value : 0 Insured . . Keys in car Lein holder . Recovery value : 0 NCIC number NFORMATION Category Year ************** S USPECT/ARRE STEE INFO RMATION- # 1 ** Case Number . : 1-05-001263 Prompt valid in: BRYAN, BENJAMIN SKYLER Street Number : 5691 STONINGTON WY City LAKE WORTH, FL 33463 Birth Date . 12/29/1986 18 Maximum Age . : 18 Employer? . Occupation . . Oper Lic No. . Home Phone No. : 561/715-6303 Other Phone Nbr: Race White Sex Male Minimum Height : 603 Minimum Weight : 160 Maximum Height : 0 Maximum Weight : 0 Misc. ID# . . : 16483 Aliases? MO/Crime Spec? : Hair Color BROWN Hair Length . : Hair Style Eye Color . . : GREEN Glasses . No Complexion . : MEDIUM 07/26/17 Page 8 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Date: 11/18/05 LALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 3 Time: 11:36:11 Incident Report Program: CMS301L Case No 1-05-001263 Facial Hair Teeth NO DISCERNIBLE Speech NORMAL Coat Pants Body Marks #1 Body Marks #3 : Status • ARRESTED Additional UCR?: ************** S USPECT Case Number . : 1-05-001263 Prompt valid in: Street Number : City Birth Date Employer? Oper Lic No. . : Other Phone Nbr: Sex Minimum Weight : Maximum Weight : 0 Aliases? Hair Color : BLONDE Hair Style Glasses . : No Facial Hair Teeth Speech Coat Pants Body Marks #1 Body Marks #3 Status • ARRESTED Additional UCR?: (Continued) Build - SLIGHT FEATURES Hat Shirt Shoes Body Marks #2 Body Marks #4 : Arrest Case No.: 1-05-001418 ARRESTEE INFORMATION- Maximum Age . : 18 Occupation . . Home Phone No. • Race • White Minimum Height : 503 Maximum Height : 0 Misc. ID# . • : 16484 MO/Crime Spec? OR STRAWBERRY Hair Length . Eye Color . . : BROWN Complexion : MEDIUM Build SLIGHT NO DISCERNIBLE FEATURES NORMAL Hat Shirt Shoes Body Marks #2 Body Marks #4 Arrest Case No.: 1-05-001419 ****************************NARRATIvs # 1*************************** Original Report LO Reported By: CARISTO, NICHOLAS 9/11/05 Entered By.: OREGERO, LAURA D. 9/12/05 On Sunday, 9/11/05 at approximately 2345 hours, I effected the arrests of two individuals, identified as Benjamin Skyler Bryan, dob/122986 and on the 200 block of Bahama Lane, charging them both with possession of marijuana under 20 grams and possession of drug paraphernalia under the following circumstances: On this date at approximately 2340 hours, I observed a four door white Mitsubishi, Florida tag C104VY, parked in a safety zone along a curve in the roadway, across from 760 N. Ocean Blvd. As I drove up behind the vehicle, the vehicle left the safety zone which I then conducted a car stop on the 200 block of Bahama Lane. Upon 07/26/17 Page 9 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Date: 11/18/05 ..ALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 4 Time: 11:36:11 Incident Report Program: CMS301L Case No - 1-05-001263 (Continued) approaching the auto, I observed five occupants inside the car, several having bloodshot eyes. I also detected an odor of marijuana from inside the auto along with observing the occupants appeared very nervous. I first spoke with the operator of the vehicle, Benjamin Bryan and asked him if he had marijuana in his auto. Benjamin Bryan informed me that he did have marijuana, handing me a quantity of marijuana rolled in brown paper. I then asked the remainder of the occupants separately if they had marijuana and a female, identified as informed me that she did have marijuana, handing me from her pocketbook a clear plastic bag containing a quantity of marijuana, a brown paper bag containing a quantity of marijuana and a glass pipe containing marijuana residue. A search of the vehicle incident to the lawful arrests, I recovered a glass pipe containing marijuana from under the front seat. Both individuals were charged with possession of marijuana under 20 grams and possession of drug paraphernalia and issued NTA's, returnable to Criminal Court, 3238 Gun Club Rd., on 9/27/05 at 0800 hours without incident. The marijuana possessed by Benjamin Bryan tested positive and weighed at 1.3 grams. The marijuana possessed by -- tested positive and 3.0 grams. All recovered items were placed into evidence. I also conducted an investigation on the remaining three individuals: David A. Cruz, dob/030987, William L. Tucker, dob/032887 and Paul J. Abrams, dob/052386. Paul Abrams was found to be in possession of a suspended license, which I confiscated his license and issued him a criminal citation for such, returnable to the Criminal Justice Complex, 3228 Gun Club Rd., on 9/27/095 at 1330 hours. * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * END OF REPORT * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 07/26/17 Page 10 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Yrs. MOs. 05U.11111{P.Mttdr apeor le. pleaiq stas your hde Emu Address MOM Phone Wooer (Inducing A100 Cede) • I 1 a PERSONAL INFORMATION Lest Awed Prom erseetWitr4 r•-• Phisflous StregMaritta kre nave )4SLI Prea Owe? 4112.1f41Y041il ih re'! Mc°.- 7/17/2006 I FROM: Dell Riley Kiraly TO: 19547634856 AGE: 004 OF 007 Feb-16-2006 02:58em From- FEB 15 282E 14:57 FR vIcroRIA sECFcE"r cstzpor An equal oppottantyentpiater, Vciond& Swot S tole, c leas nuctietrimitiaie In Wile cr terms and eanditiorts otu-'60oytniant.,boevusu d dr, inaividustre moo. eoier, pn4er, national cm:a, stzertrip, age, dOstolily, atinntatirm or marital st2tUF, Viddele eareet SForeo, inc.. ode ilindirelOduals authorised tor ernpioyrnere In Inc United &l 212-2714042 T-900 P.003/006 F-063 041 DM of APPHGeLiari Stheckile Dotted: Q Fu/ Time t lg.1 Ulu U 'IN/moron r bantam* kitary Expeptpj• gje "DFIF ("41. 4. I 245c 9042784321 TO 1E1414167189 P.04/16 VICTORIA'S SECRET PosItiori Docked: Pfl-90e EDUCATION Type of attooi ...... Num., and Locedon or School Cieiree / Area of Witty .Ferrer of Veen -.:- • I' • - moto.....0..l, 457'1;743ff_ 4 -Yeti..9..:..erI .000sit t..ost te.r., 7tdx:4"r:.4 ,4liz 4 4. 4L- i -1--, - 4 ,,,t F.7:tY*Ii pl. 4,5'.7.421.-; ite.4,._ 1.,!..4,,,,,,:y.".;FiA,L f. et4:111::4:1.:Es. r ....e.ri . i7:4' /EV•Attt4 4... • HISH SCHOOL :1601_ COLLEGE INarno Cy OTHER N.9.00 Stale lig'4...Alli•••• “*It CIY WYIPLOYMENT HISTORY It you hove toss :bon tad cii2r.r of emreoymerit, Include personal refsiorrees te coniactee. May we rordaoryour condo employer' co El No List Pmpfoyrnent toreng with your moot mount posthoo. Account tar any 13111C curing (Ns patiad ttai you were unemployed by statirq tha:rtattre al aci:thettica. ..41)!:2 3.1.4 I i.. ) ,,dr. .4‘.';741 ... .. .11 .,, .1 - • • rf C roU "e!: ML r$1.11 "'"'" E Q.1 •LE..•..z.L..1 • SOporvlsoes rwirna(s), and eireurneelincoe of the If yots. please provide details. Including pluou(s) at titrKtkryment locabcm(s), dow(s). 07/26/17 Page 11 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

7/17/::006 3. 1 FROM: Dell Riley Kiraly TO: 19547634856 AGE: 005 OF 007 Feb-16--2CC 72:58om From- 212-371-8042 T-900 P.004/006 F-063 Limited brands P1interic40211azote Victoria's Secret Stores Incident Report V$S2005015582 ilarnesiminisexi Golan verified )(RR and fourrntl)eversi suspicious tenons on 10/30 and ft/2165 totabrtg•appfenciaint0Y5210.00. DurIna tt>A court' or the interview Hall clic not admit to any fratidulent refunds_ On 11/4/05 RLPM Golan apolceto. an Ikasociate by then** of ShaVna Casidorph and 'she stated that sne observed smarm items of VS& merchanrtso in Heas' tar erne day The items Wind were Hale Perfume, tank top, bras, panties and'accer.mries. cravikei tiau rigncel at the conclusion of Interview and Co Manager keyed termination as not tahireable forPolicYviciarion Lam= Diwflor6 $201.00 AnozaRogelmoll. 4209.00 1141= UK& $0.00 NolLour $0.00 Kcoarchott maw= .Thmay mi„ '10 ICAnki.lai• 12=1:60 Vij: rata unarilom tealizoom Limeades tioutLai 840.11ISMIM:. Paim pcsaigOwl Palo Anchips: Poo:, iko:ort P. WW1 POK.a0ftlaie• Marra Ripattrig mitre Nese k fokimd Ice veto* Oemr. Golan Gal. St ;1st repo +'M POPOV gr WC* eflandOindICS,MRTONICIWC1041141 It a* 11014 9441PCSIGOi Of &pcdlipUt •Tail .astei4d **xi gil+WA#S-141•0151/00. 44 F'4eirdoo 07/26/17 Page 12 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

7/17/2006 ; i FROM: D.11 Riley lOraly TO: 19547634851 AGE: 007 OF 007 Feb-16-2006 02:59om From- 212-371-8042 1-900 P.006/006 F-063 0 Cate Urn itec.1 brands We* wrattegiee Vistoria's.Socrotttores locideni Report VS8.005015502 a,46:a.t.m.. Sales leader-41'06ns b:id for. titercha ndlse thOft atailia (abed Yea. Ir4J ?hart 61r' Repave* 11/04105 Poir447. De4:401i .0callied ituic iterate to 1 lonocs 221 Wm Pelvic Lcimax 2.2 .219.3 NW/ total* W Mary Wrilawra amen 210 270 VS5 cao Fast. i4 11,20201* ,.,141;905 0/0120118 211717001 let1612008 3;2alwite ; F4•49.4 W SAO% 4.42016 .1.51% 3.2.0% 'SAD% •0(rf4 •;' • gamsaaa fa9AK 162,WC f..49.9K .646-7K 349.11(• Sal."' 4.momot • • On 14;1,06 RUN coop Intl:Mewed Who admitted to itiatitiandoe'ttieti toiefln#4205;00 '711:141 Mi.44Warpiiitti Robbie Lomax, 1114.arid Yanoalqatdepterroz. Werra. Hall Midteddirmiiedlateiy arils:pier-010ov* ,oitai4daw.. att4C543; itakinvagOgatioil Wag :Initiated en 1012410 'epee receipt of a mil fleet SIeciiy.TRIal 0.),Menegjer. Who an lcx Zr*tt, iacF497.1FIIdarOdOberliqrPQPE , • • It; liatt came leen* ;e 30PM bh102:1145,-dreasee atJiPtide& armee:V*4er... piart jourpeiel‘pliiistic .bag,poritairtInt; what kicked lika.e:bek.af Shoo • tiettIteip;slaied that 4.tiOttie*Inti: :i2 . •Irt thernai(tri nature 1/41:palr of shocaerxiona waild.ra ts.nit for her schedutecl.:ah?ftAt2prit : . • . AI _gf ?prpeirasjtagy.2:4$ pm, 144: itfe'store.'epeakmq)on pi)on angel-4 Wao,Wqaring 4-004.0 pelo?fg.. She aeundeft•.fel*Weisperhen pontibued .to Aap3plain'Oiat • cgatoiber aervicigTibe keCailS9:diaisig bar !Otto tha 'sive' two {nert.W0114r}igheraThaOsOrogac09,Aktd2;•:,.. " : -.11act,rnaele ibettraO.00TOttaltsAltartintifbacNtiblina Wittc bail" anti. !Ian thetealrvie.ioWiire10.kiet,Wagyersj• • 44000krOgitci fier:4fter• Vaiefthg the return. one of :the.rtal Otei.**0 the att*: sbeiracfa!*.hydi beck-W*15. ACeitproximat* 3;001; . a man Par07-40 the front. °Ulla Mato. arrdePal.kOdoi41. never 49 the aster*. Out stood ilirbottiib,frant WitlyeaLeverf ciese!bs kbe'eartsafeebroa„ mint.* Ana hot mhcsvia041er '@.11;rocti:of:p-IPer that •Ipoked like ileceipt.;Pif.micttofriVintelliOr''WEilia3dA-Oel. &!,..• 'f • startled aV`trIpthattliO map 4f9.ttad,wp4iPIne:Igicale-as.elir.tp poeF .01'41*Tri3O,Vf5. *O . lior.-a-ajoalletigAt*ihdeg-sho bad ija3.004,1**1101g 1440N-0994' #9.mOVIti.9ise..50911 atttarah9 l' eark9 tiatiifati-therailas N*40 4,Weinert M her mid lo.;ate:2Cia-O;fieiin4411'4401190.4Y40fikto - • — 4:roitinlifie front dtilie'itttottaial o.1004Oltie:Wafilaft,;.WhO ft-tanbi.earnig:tat$ei td nth-. whp elairpOhogple: herehoea wae..a(Vie•ibare ene eje:leey waOria0egefff r vzi}feen' NI** pkaaeay, 44Naelc. ago spe, loaf :pair of shoes In the malt 41o04W.baOthooa,.*: Merl a"#. that she: had cidtatr'tbaygtores she viaitect;blat day; ZelOrtrg :and was tokfihat'ix! one had ti4alyttrainl.' accused • Of ekeaiind tbaoshOes rid pip:mpg /bon: for 4brbe-Nag statable!forlie.rapg..W0i ttie!viigibat •Thar mai lOrar of *oil eibpsaikps ler114041.04Tql1000Alkirt PaPWOON' cg rrient:144..1 oa c,411:twa vnineu; tn4eAlVILS44**(tt rj(PrO11610(44111.' 07/26/17 Page 13 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Ilfew Micmac otN KMOL %INA rim Subject 441X1 rerminate C4"Ot 13410 11/04/05 Reg E.Aa: 4•VerNfl NO' 7/17/2006 3. FROM: Dell Riley Kiraly TO: 195476348., %GE: one OF 007 Feb-16-2006 32:58pm From- 212-371-8042 T-800 P 005/006 F-068 Limited brands ennieckdarl617000 Victotia's Sucratt,Skorkez Incident Report VSS2005015082 which contained hewer:edit card number. The lady lift the store very AIWA, 464 volt secur*rly officer named Sattizar, Came in the Store looking for and she began explaining to him Shot her father had sent semis shoats to her boyfriend and that they didn't fit so he gave. them to her to return so she eciukl puMitase something that ahe warted. The mall officer asked her how she had.gorten that receipt and shesaid that herboYfrisind gaselier:the bag of 'shoes with that receipt Inside entitle had ho idea how this had happened. Soon after. Sailizer teltiand another mtatI Officer =rite Into the store in• his mid 201s, black, and large butt, She began ego/eking Met heir poyfriend nad. bought shoes rat' her father and That they didn't fit so he *sired her re return tnern so, she could purcriese anything she .wanted thereby changing her ohginatstory. 7the questioning oentinut300Thfor abetat .S.More minutes: and 'ahe was then.told by-the. Officer that all the woman wanted was to getihar intirntrandiita.batok.: _ asked the 'ethos,- what ehe :should do to get the:woman's merchandise beck and the rho, juin! verge:MIS to "go away" and that "she didn't cart about her ehoca rand she would return-thane to order to retrieve Vic rnerchonstice: for the Worrian. The mall officer escierted. out al the store and a female niatl officer, Sopriesir, the wonian.whe made- the ailegations and the manager Of Journeys returned to Journeys, i ..ras not wearing the shoed tie had earlier and after the mall offrosr asked Taylor not to tell Veronica, SM what had. happened. Update: Dm:Der 28th, 20Q5: AZ approximately 71-..1.5prri, ...,.„was leaving..the store and Christina OgSland,,Clit saw knutling down on the 'Peer digging oirough her purse. As Capiano approached her, she palled tja.a.paii of black SLT-patitios that had a sensor on them. Sha talon looked up at OrpiariO and Raid ISaipeonetatryingiodiet me up.".Aeoctidlog.to her l she Said that she, had walked out of tho atom and thC Se.rili,:liMaik."41tIdlieeffrttt Oft, so she tam back in, and repeated this once again. And that is when Qrpiane approa--thad hot, Orpiann -chocked- bags and sent Miele:wile. The associated who ydorked that daywhere Shayna (12 - 4) . Reagan La:3a . and4airrtle:(2 Ott 11/4105 RLPIUI 'Colon .spoke tO an a.s.sociate by the mine of Shayna Casdorph sold-the stated 'that she' observed several teems erfV-55 mereriandlte fn . ear one day. The hems foundweret-taiaPerftirne, tarrictop., parities and occessortt* On 1 li4/05 coton interviewed and she admitted to merchendioe-thokietating 2081:;00. 3ho staled thelesSaian for stealing wsi that she understood she was 'nor g:ottino paid enough and vheWaS istruOrtng.financially,..:Stid.' agreed to nay restitution far the: amount ddS209,00, • it pallid not remember theslaieswhen sheilestaktirted: • stealing and abet:Mid not remember all the merchandise Stolen, She elated-the Merchandise was corm:Wei:lin... her ciething, The loll free 'number was provided " Land the interview was 'audio recorded. At ifiex:Opctationof • the interview, I ; was allowed to,resign and thernanager-escortedher out of the store. fair fi;rartmrdri I Pttrxggi^ Iltiarefort b Die pppoily or 9m4te413490cla.aml b aubied io staiszylcoraws tirOptron. t.mgyriotDt oupdater tetWelocel withal est, einvesA weigvi amnt-o$Ur000-e.144411 07/26/17 Page 14 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 4 of 5 morning. is funny how things seem to wokr out so well. anyway, there's really nothin mush else going on. i havc to start getting my stuff together since I'm going to be off soon!!!! well i guess i'll write more another time. love u guys! i miss all my homies back in royal palm. can't wait to have some of y'aIl visit. hey, will and i are throwing a party in two weeks. his parents are going out of town. if anyone wants to show up from back home, give will or me a call. 8:17 AM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Wednesday, August 10, 2005 rough times Current mood: sad Everything sucks right now. My best-friend's dad passed away and I had to come back to cooper city to visit her. (I grew up here.) The funeral was today. I couldnt look at him laying in the coffin. I saw the top if his head but it already looked 'not so good' so I decided not to try and see the rest. Robyn's father's family didn't console her or her younger brother at all. They're assholes. Thank God she has me. I hope everything ends up being okay. I've had a really rough week. I've been snapping at everyone I care about. I feel emotionally stressed. I'm going through a really tough time. There's been so much death around me. It's really overwhelming. 2:09 PM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Friday, August 05, 2005 Freedom!!! Current mood: drained Hey, Wow! Not living with my parents anymore is da shit! For all of you who are not aware, I moved to Jacksonville. So far everything is going well. Will and I are getting along. Not like everyone predicted,..."oh when you guys live together all of that time together will be horrible,...." the complete opposite as a matter of fact :) I went job hunting the http://blog.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseactionA3log.ListAll&friendID=20425696&Myto... 12/21/2005 07/26/17 Page 15 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Olog.myspace.corn/sublimehottie Page 5 of 5 second day that we were here but all I did was get applications. The day after that I was like "fuck this" and didn't turn them in. I was just so tired. Yesterday is when I took them. I ended up getting a job at Victoria's Secret. I only get paid $6.40 an hour but hopefully that will change soon. I also get a discount at all of the Limited stores, Express stores and Bath & Body Works. I like my boss so far, I mean I've only met her twice but she's pretty cool. Will is trying to get a job at FYE. He likes music so I think it's a good fit for him. I really hope he gets it. The boss guy called him back to set up an interview the day he came in with the application, I think that's a good sign. It starts at 4pm. He's at the mall right now. I got to call him and ask him how it went in a lir while. It's only 3:45 right now. Oh, it was so funny - I used him as one of my references for my VS job and the lady called me back and told me that William Tucker gave me such an outstanding refrence that she didn't need to call anyone else back, he got me the job! Just like that. He made me sound fucking great,..I lied and said that he was the old stock manager for Hollister. She bought it. Str8. No complaints from me. Ok,...well I'm gonna go smoke some resin (sp?) considering I have a limited supply of mary j and have to conserve. I miss everyone back home. i love you guys. Don't forget about me. 12:15 PM - 1 Comments - 2 Kudos - Add Comment About i FAQ Terms I Privacy Safety •Tips I Contact Mys_pace I Promote! I Advertise I MySpace Shop ©2003 MvSpace.com. All Riahts Reserved. http ://blog. my space. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=blog.ListAl l&friendID-20425696&My to ... 12/21/2005 07/26/17 Page 16 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

PIMP JUICE Cifog.inyspace.com/sublimeno•.-tie Page 1 ot myspace a place for friends Home Loans Capital Coe Home Equity Loans: Ai .1., Nov... home I subscribe rss I add to blog group I sign out Saturday, December 10, 2005 Biker Bitch Current mood: Q exhausted Category: Automotive I am s00000000000000000 tired. Today was the Toys For Tots bike rally. My neighbor has a Harley so I went with him. It was s00000000000 cool! There was 400 bikes. It was awesome. I even go to meet this guy that has a local tv show. He goes all around to these different bike spots. I think he's hilarious. I recognized him and went over and talked to him. He was really nice. He's having this concert to promote his show and I think I'm gonna try and talk Will into going. I was standing there in a sea of Harleys and Triumphs and Hondas and Suzukis and I was loving W 111111111111111111111111 I donated a football and a Fantastic 4 action figure set. It had two toys in it so it was pretty cool. They talked and moved and crap. Just wanted to let everyone know what I was up to. Bye! 4:18 PM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Tuesday, November 15, 2005 BUMMER MAN Current mood: Q crushed Category: School, College, Greek I'm so depressed. I'm leaving for on Jan. 5. I'm packing up Will's and my room soon and it's making me depressed thinking about it. It's going to be so weird not having my best friend with me. I don't want to be without him but it doesn't seem like I have a choice. I'm really sad, and a little scared to go. Have you been through this situation? How did u deal with it? Write me a message please. I'm feeling 20 different emotions and I have no idea how to deal with it. Last Updated: Nov 13, 2005 Send Message Instant Message Email to a Friend Subscribe Invite to My Blog Gender: Female Status: In a Relationship Age: 18 Sign: Capricorn City: Royal Palm/ State: FLORIDA Country: US Signup Date: 07/02/05 My Subscriptions: - no subscriptions - Blog Archive [ Older Newer ] 12 21 2005 Go 5:02 PM - 1 Comments - 2 Kudos - Add Comment http://blog.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=blog.ListAll&friendID=20425696&Myto... 12/21/2005 07/26/17 Page 17 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

o►ng.myspace.conusuollmenottie Page 2 of 5 ' Monday, November 0.7, 20CS GGGRRRRRR, Current mood: pissed off I forgot to let everyone know I quit my job at Victoria's Secret. They said they suspected me of "causing losses to their company." -Which by the way is bullshit! I was 'by the book' on EVERYTHING!!!!!!! I got so fed up in that office that I handed the Loss Prevention lady back my keys and walked out. GO ME! STICKIN' IT TO THE MAN! I already have another job if I want it, and it's so much more money$$$$$$. I'm going to be making more money than my old bosses at VS. Success is definately the sweetest revenge. ASSHOLES!!!!!! 10: 01 AM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Slightly Stoopid, BOH?!? Current mood: © okay I SAW SLIGHTLY STOOPID LAST NIGHTIIIIImm!!!!!!!!!! IT WAS DA SHITIIIIIIII BOH! (credit to Will for the use of 'BOH!' because if I didn't give credit he'd say I copied him.) BOH! THE SHOW WAS AWESOME! Pictures will be coming soon. Stay tuned, BOH! Currently watching: 'S. Dora the Explorer - Dora's Ultimate - '• Adventure Collection Release date: By 26 October, 2004 9:59 AM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Sunday, November 06, 2005 nole girlz do it better Current mood: ID excited I'm going to visit for the next three days!!!! as most of u know, i will attending the beginning in Jan. 2006. i'm going to have so much fun while i'm up therellmIll it's gonna be great getting a taste of college life! Currently watching: Volcano http ://b1 og.myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=blog.ListAl l&friend1D=-20425696&My to... 12/21/2005 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 07/26/17 Page 18 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

rage 3 of Release date: By 18 December, 2001 2:06 PM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment zombies and puppies Current mood: content hey, halloween was so much fun! will and i ended up going to a party. our makeup was awesome. i only have one pic of us up right now but i'll soon have more. the one i have up is of us after the make-up had been on for hours, it started to peel off in the pic but i think it still looks awesome. also, we found a red pitbull puppy a few days ago. i wrote a bulletin about her but i forgot to add that she is s000000 good with children. i have an 18 month old living with me and she is just s0000 nice to him. she loves to play with him and has not shown one sign of agression. even with another dog that is bigger than her, a cat and a baby constantly bothering her. i want to keep her s0000 bad, i just can't tho. someone please take hermitr and provide her with a good homellill thank u. <3. Currently watching: Volcano Release date: By 18 December, 2001 11:55 AM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Co rmeat Wednesday, August 17, 2005 cool things are happening Current mood: fe blah i'm just writing this blog because i'm so bored. okay,..uuummm,...something cool???? oh here we go: yesterday i was in walmart with my bf will and i got a phone call from pacific sunwear. i applied like 2 weeks ago and since then have gotten a job at Victoria's Secrets but the guy said that he wanted me to come in and talk to him about working at the store if i still want. now the cool part is that i was just talking to will about how i wanted a second job that http://blog.myspace.corn/index.cfm?fuseaction=blog.ListAll&friendlD=20425696&Myto... 12/21/2005 07/26/17 Page 19 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

"Note girls do it better!" View More Pics Contacting PIMP JUICE Send Message Add to Friends Instant Message eiga Add to Group Last Login: 11/7/2005 ,r4f- Forvard to Friend FitW Add to Favorites. CI Block User 408 Rank User PIMP JUICE's Interests General Music W W vv.iiiyNJak,c.i..k.iiiuJUULALLIGLAJLIAO tn. MySpace.com r- Home The Web MySpace Search I CONGRATULATIONS! You lie been chosen to receive a FREE MOTOROLA PINK RAZR! :See Details DK* here to cla Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music PIMP JUICE MySpace URL: http://www.myspace.com/sublimehottie PIMP JUICE is in your exterick•,-;.: PIMP JUICE's Latest Bloa Entry [Subscribe to this B GGGRRRRRR, I I Il I t t (view more) Slightly Stoopid, BOH?!? (view more) nole glitz do it better (view more) zombies and puppies (view more) cool things are happening (view more) [View All Blog Entries] PIMP JUICE's Blurbs About me: Hil My name is and I am 18. I'm Park, Fl, until January when I'm moving to Ta attend F5U. I w l I eventually moved to Cooper Cit) north of Ft. Lauderdale. In ninth grade I mov with my grandparents. (I love them.) Anyway, (GO CLASS OF 20051) I moved with my boyfri in northern Fl, near Jacksonville. to go to college that I can hardly wait) F5U is awesomel I'm really lucky because I got a sch, Otherwise, I'd have to bust my ass, and I'm . those people that like to work. Anyone who sir understand that, LOL. I love all types of musi sounds awesome to me. My favorite band is 51 BRAD.) I'm pretty laid back. I go with the fit things. I miss my friends back home but I kno move on; If I don't, then how am I supposed love my friends and I love my family. And Wil' my life. I love to party and smoke weed. Havi what being alive is all about. :) http://profile. myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseactio n=us er. vi ewp rofile&fri en dID=20425696&... 11/8/2005 07/26/17 Page 20 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

0"'• -kr You are Lou Dog. The beloved pet of Brad. It has been said that you are like the "alter ego" of Brad, and were like his best friend. You have just recently passed on. RIP Lou Dog 1978-2001 Will (ScReWEd & C hopped) Robyn gkatielif wwv.myspace.com/sublimehro-tie Which Member of Sublime are YOU? brought to you by Quizilla <3 I LOVE ALL MUSIC!!! EXCEPT COUNTRY. MY NUMBER ONE FAVORITE BAND IS SUBLIM Postal Service Qat Dashboard Confessional co ,.. Page 2 of 14 - Pimp Pimp MySpace My Chemical Romance - Helena Music Video Codes The people I had on here before: Bob Marley, Marilyn Monroe, I would still like to meet ther thinking,...this week I'd like to meet Bill Clint could be that famous for s'king his d*" k, thi how famous I could be D fuck this city in your mouth View All of PIMP Friends Comment '- then -" Brand New Taking Back Sunday , My Chemical Romance Fall Out Boy Operation Ivy , t -- ' 'n,-A°i. http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.yiewprofile&friendID=20425696&... 11/8/2005 07/26/17 Page 21 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Bob Marley Damien Marley , Jack Johnson , John Mayer Dro•kick • Isn't it Ironic • AAww.myspace.com/sublimehottie Murphy , Mike Jones (Screwed and Cho ..e Hil Snoop Dogg ,Radio Head The Smashing Pumpkin Paul Wall (Screwed and .,7----1 Chopped), White Stripe Page 3 of 14 Displaying of comments (View/Edit All Cort 51<virn Fo real fuck yo job niggaa / 2005 9:3:00 love ya babe! I miss ya...come and vis .:/2i305 8:38:00 AM pinviaire Beef Knuckles 10/13/2005 3:29:00 AM . whats up... I miss you.1 are you guys gonna be down again? M. craig's birthdays are next week so hop see you and will soon... , Cypress The Strokec Doub Weezer , The Beatles 10/4/2005 8:28:00 AM whets up momma? holla at me sometime... www.gettheammo.com Blizunts & Bizongs No Mike Chaos http://profile.myspace.corn/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendID=20425696&... 11/8/2005 07/26/17 Page 22 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

NIL and s000000000 much more that I'm forgetting. ::Smoke weed everyday!:: I haven't seen you in like a year. I hop everything's going good with you, and you're meeting lots of cool people in th place. :) "Ghostbusters" '13R SKE3 M 2r1S. , 7!30:00 PM Yo • whats upp??? 1..A \AN myspace.comisuoilmenome l'age 4 of 14 "Ni ht of the hey grl...whats the deal..when are we r ' burn one?? wb...we need to chill sometime...and get blizzy!!! wb ..... ..sk Living bead" , "28 bays Later" "The Loonies" , "Harvey" "Trainspotting" 'Big Fish" 'Nosferatu" "The Breakfast 9/2.2/2005 9:51:00 PM I love you!!! 9/21/2005 4:38:00 AM where ya been, woadie? http : //profi le. myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. vi ewprofi I e&fri endID=20425696&... 11/8/2005 ., Slightly Stoopid The Used Robyn 8Pkatielf Club". , Fight Club 0,02 rl 41.19 %ow- and "Weed." Keepin It Caucasian Since 1987 9/20/2005 1:04:00 PM 07/26/17 Page 23 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

2005 9:02:00 PM dead , "ATI-F" your GONNA LUV everybody POT up there so finding a roomate witt your "interests" shouldnt be hard. Heart < HArdy har har everyday:: "Simpson" :if, &IR , "Futurama" hey girl i dont kno u but i love ur style M that reefer to eaze my mind thats the see it i love it too we gotta toke sumtir Beef Knuckles fl /1,5 2005 12:52:013 PM , are Lullaby and "Diary" my favorites! Yo I sent those pits in a message to W account since your away message is or something. Ntww.myspace.comisuotimenothe Page 5 of 14 !i;'1 i1 ,,,,i zi ---rvc _ .. Just kidding about the last one. Oh wait, no I'm not.) ::Smoke weed ill pistol whip the shit out of you!!! and "Family Guy" EaZzY mutha `005 5:58!00 PM fuckin E BITCHEZI "Trainspotting" , "Choke" WEED! Clinically Tested, Mother approved. 9/14/2005 2:01:00 PM EY waddup partner how u been man?? seen ya in awhile...so hopefully u and still together..thats awesome babe...ur hit me back yo we'll toke..peace! i• • In a Relationship Networking, Friends Straight Hometown: Cooper City, FL. Body type: 5' 2" / Slim / Slender Ethnicity: White / Caucasian Zodiac Sign: Capricorn VinnY 9/14/2005 10:00:00 AM Damn... I just read about your near fa accident. Gad you're alright and unsca http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm? fuseaction—user. vi ewprofil e&friendID=20425696&... 11/8/2005 07/26/17 Page 24 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

vww.myspace.com/sublimehcHle Page 6 of 14 Yes / Yes Someday In college Hot chic. close calls like that that make us thanl. I'm not very religious myself, but try a the right thing. I was driving down sou on 95 and this tour bus almost tipped us so I know how you feel. The least ti driver could have done was stopped, b least you didn't hit anything and are 0 2001 to Princess Jenny 2 0 2005 "Where the hell have/ & Will been? come hang out with us soon :*:MeLiSsA:*: Hey Whats up? How have you be Haven't talked to you or seen you in s( long! Hope everything's going well for Keep in touch, ttyl! <3Melissa 9/6/ 2005 3:51:00 PM DO YOU ONLY SMOKE? OR ARE THERE OTHER THINGS YOU UKE TO DO.... SUBSTANCE-WISE I MEAN fuck this city 9/5/2005 12!18:00 PM in your mouth HEY wuddup hows erything up in el no simon and garfunkle man..keep it real It's IGGY 9/4/2005 12:09:00 AM Sup PIMP JUICE, thats making thirsty j http://profi le. myspace. com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendID=20425696&... 11/8/2005 07/26/17 Page 25 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

.w W.myspace.com/sublimehottle Page 7 of 14 k- saying that.lol, hey wuts going on wit I been lately. Im throwing a pretty big p the 23rd you should come down and cl out. Its going to be alot of fun. I hope enjoying yourself up there in.... well tl your from, lol , but i'll ttyl Take Care Of Yourself IGGY Nicole 05 7:18:00 AM We have a lot in common, we should c PEACE Shaun Nedwick 17 - ;3!00 PM hey gorgeous ! whatssupp Princess Jenny ;. 51 2.005 12:47:00 PM Maaaaaaaaaarco• AMY 8/23/2005 7:25:00 PM peekaboos was fun. an that chick was funny. v will have to meet up sometime when im in c for something. stay saf( < 3 3 i...am ... dead ,5',"22/2005 1:12:00 PM Havent said hi yet. so Howdy http://profi 1 e. myspace. com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user. viewprofile&friendID=20425696&... 11/8/2005 07/26/17 Page 26 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Amvw.myspace.com/sublimehr•ttie Page 8 of 14 'Lord of the Fire' :Ott Pt/. Hey ". what's the 411 on the party? Beef Knuckles Y00000000 just figured I'd say whats up since it sa you're online now. holla fuck this city :005 12:35:00 PM in your mouth word up nigga. Snipsnap in yo bubble Dane :'."3200512:27:00 PM vats up. Its your boy Dane, hey I, smoke soon. Alright hit me back. AMY g/9 /2005 3.2:31:00 PM hey. peekaboos was fun. when are yon leaving?? http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendla--20425696&... 11/8/2005 07/26/17 Page 27 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

www.myspace.comisunitmenome Page 9 of 14 SKE3M i just lookd at your page and you seerr dopest girl somone could meet! f real, stay original i like that!! wb if you wan. should smoke a blunt one of these day ske3m Judas -..,.:5870C. PM thanx for the comments. email me son we should chill.... cory 51<ylER ;••.1.:/2005 8:28:00 AM )1 You guys gotta keep up with these thir you know, much love see you guys so< enough. Purple Stuff 8/ 1/2005 5:42:00 PM in my Cup Yo Girl wats up...I just wanted to say t Mil gonna miss you while your gone, but I that we'll definately keep in touch. lusl care of Will and keep him out of troubl• that goes for you too. If either of you c ever need me you know my number.... aight...Make sure you smoke a bowl fo and stay safe , r11 see you guys in like weeks when your stash Is low...lol Beef Knuckles ..'31/ 2005 5:24:00 PM I'm burning the rest of the pics on CD you guys. http://profile.myspace.corn/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendID=20425696&... 11 /8/2005 07/26/17 Page 28 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

www.myspatx.eutiusuuninenottie rage I u or 14 http://p ro fi le. mys p ace. co m/i ndex. cfm?fuseaction=user.vi ewprofile&friendID-20425696&... 11 /8/2005 07/26/17 Page 29 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Am.myspace.comisublime!inttie Page 11 of 14 EARL IV 7/23/2005 9:59:00 PM hey whats up? i havent talked to you ii forfuckingever. how have you been? http ://p rofi I e. myspace. com/i ndex. cfm?fuseacti on—user. yi ewp rofi I e&friendID-20425696&... 11/8/2005 07/26/17 Page 30 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

• rilgG 14 01 141 X Rip It And Dip It X _asie so i see you like weed. Jenny V we need another girls night ... I'm mak drinks =) .. well try ... haha .. oh ye how are you doing ? Shannon :3/7.00543;04:00 PM That would be great, maybe i can have everyone come chill at my house one r 7/12/2005 6:30:00 PM Hey girl, hows your summer been? Beef Knuckles http ://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendID=20425696&... 11/8/2005 07/26/17 Page 31 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

wwv vv.lity cc.cuiwsuoumenome Page 13 of 14 you should go back to that mess: sent you with those pics. Click on the t make them BIGGER. They're thumbnai 51<ylER 7 This is bad news bears. Deus ex Machina I like country. You going to curb me? F been? I haven't seen you or Will in for( you think waiting for college is tough, should see me while I wait to ship out. going nuts. Give me a call sometime. I. -Billy AMY t 0/2005 9:56:00 PM WEED!!! Beef Knuckles 7/10/2005 9:34:00 pm WEED, , :. WEED. *Beauty In 7/9/2005 11:25:00 AM http ://profi myspace.com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. viewprofile&friendID=20425696&... 11/8/2005 07/26/17 Page 32 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Bloody Love. t-1 ' 3 . i•AWW. my sp ace. com/su b I] mehmtie Page 14 of 14 Hii!!!! Wassup CuZ!!!??? Ya... Urn.... I That you wanted to talk to me about tI pictures.... well cause it's actually incense s000 DodNt WoRRy!!!! 0 And I'm your first comment... How exc Cant wait till I get up there and you to on awesome trips and stuff cool. W <3 A A —*Gabrielle*— About I FAQ I Terms I Privacy' Safety Tips I Contact Myspace I Promote! I Advertise I MySpace Shop C2003 Myapace.com. All Rights ResgBeed. http ://p rofile. my sp ace. com/i ndex.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friend1D=20425696&... 11/8/2005 07/26/17 Page 33 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Last Login: 2/13/2006 View More Pics Contacting Pimp Juice El- Send Message F orvvard to Friend ia Add to Friends alf Add to Favorites Instant Message $3 Block User eti Add to Group '408 Rank User MySpace URL: http://www.myspace.com/sublimehottie Pimp Juice's Interests General Music , theater Music "I LOVE 8 1/2 InCh RO0 SteR$!!!" e, I Heart Garrett Stein WiLL (ScReWeD&ChOp Ped Up) isiah wvvw.myspace.com/sublimehottie ?age 1 ot MySpace.com I Home The Web ; MySpace Search Bozeman Angier A full-service Fly fishing shop located in Bozeman, Montana.... Fly Fish... Fly fish private Boulder River frontage that we have kept... Fly Fishing... Lewis & Clark Expeditii trout fishing guide... ke'ep.coni Home l Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail Blog I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games l Music Pimp Juice Pimp juice is in your extended Pimp Juice's Latest Moo Entry [Subscribe to this 131 Greetings from Tallahassee (view more) Bitching and Moaning (view more) grown up (view more) Biker Bitch (view more) BUMMER MAN (view more) [View All Blog Entries] Pimp Juice's Blurbs About me: Hil My name is _ and I am 19. I was born in I eventually moved to Cooper City, Ft. Lauderdale. In ninth grade I moved to Palm Beach wit love them.) After graduation (60 CLASS Of 2005!) I mov It's in northern Fl, near Jacksonville. I just moved to Tal F5U. My major is International Affairs. Class started fly itl I listen to all types of music. Everything sounds awesot band is SUBLIME. I'm pretty laid back. I love to party. relationship for over a year now. My boyfriend, Will, is m the most amazing person. I miss everyone back home. I k love my family. Bye! Who I'd like to meet: I'd like to meet Ewan McGregor. He is s0000 MOTT!!! Pimp Juice's Friend Space Pimp Juice has 144 friends. http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendlia=-20425696 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 34 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

then Postal Displaying •• of 5 1<YLER Romanc Fall Out Boy Sunday. My Chemical Operation Ivy Bob Marley I Heart Garrett Stein -www.myspace.com/sublimehottie Page 2 of 13 You are Lou Dog. The beloved pet of Brad. It has been said that you are like the "alter ego" of Brad, and were like his best friend. You have just recently passed on. RIP Lou Dog 1978-2001 Which Member of Sublime are YOU? brought to you by Quizilla -If it's not shit then I'll listen to it*** <3 I LOVE ALL MUSIC!!! EXCEPT COUNTRY. MY NUMBER ONE FAVORITE BAND IS SUBLIME IGGY Mandy lisa marie rill', triew Pimp Juices Friends Commie" comments (View/Edit All Con . 2.0i.;12 Whats up* ' I see you mvoed in : sound. Hope all is well and high as fl Ps: how the fuck did you hear about yea...whateva.... 2/1.0/2006 6:39 'A.f•'l just saying hi! hope all is well! Service Dashboard .. _ Confessional , Brand ♦ steph 2/9/2006 10:56 PM hey girl. whats going on? how's talla Taking Back x/9/200612:51 Pm Umm.. I was just reading your comr you came here to orlando and went cowboys!!! If you were here and did im going to MURDER you. Love you jennifer without 2/9/ 2006 7:17 AM the nifer http://profile.myspace.corn/index.cfm?firseaction=userviewprofile&friend)1)=20425696 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 35 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Strok No Doubt The linds isiah Its time for a new begining... Nick Lungs Full of Smoke Jack Johnson 1 and Chapped) 6_ The White Strip Weezer The Beatles , Slightly Stoop! The Used ert 111ffiii and s000000000 much more that I'm forgetting. ::Smoke weed , John Mayer , Dropkick Murphys Mike Jones (Screwed Cypress ,Radio Hea The Smashing Pumpkins , Paul Wall (Screwed -www.myspace.com/sublimehottie Page 3 of 13 Damien Marley how are ya717171 i havent seen veryyy longgg time! :) hope all is WE what u been up 2? 2076 1: IS N4 when are you coming back to visit o cowboys was fun! catch ya lata---i h linds t.;/ 2006 1:16 PM UR ENEMY STABS U IN DA FRONT... FRIEND STABS U IN DA BACK U GIRLFRIEND/BOYFRIEND STABS U I HEART BUT ME, UR CLOSEST FR: CARRIES A KNIFE TO STAB THOSE MUTHAFUCKAS RIGHT BACK set as many closest friends that u have know u two will stay friends always ; forever....no matter wat /6/2006 2:49 AM it was completely random BUT cool i ran into u at that kid's house. Had me up when u get down here! lata b 2/2/2006 8:00 PM Hey r— :. How's I'll be coming within the next few months so I'll co you. Doug, myself and two other bla are gonna do the full version of Com Works of Shakespear in March so yo come down and see it. If not, we'll n a dvd and send it up to you. I forgot that me Doug and one of the black c Superior for the Othello and Titus pa month. I got a blog about it so checl How is everything else goin? 2/2/2006 7:52 PM Hey weed hoe, If you were here I'd : of my weed with you, and you know miss you, be safe, and study high sc get high scores....MWAHIllil http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=userviewprofile&friendlED=20425696 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 36 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

"The Goonies" "Harvey" Trainspotting" 'Big Fish" • "Nosferatu" , "The Breakfast Club" libby 2j how is the college life? i can assume and hope you are livin it up there... i miss our sanity trips and u come back in town or let me come v amyyyy 1/25f 2006 8:40 Pi.; -www. my space. co m/sub i mehotti e Page 4 of 13 .4•A ► everydayl:: . Get more photos on MySpace!,. Add MySpace Records as your friend! • Ar-V1 .6hostbustere. , "Night of the Living Dead" "28 Days Later" 14 4, 141 10 IL• WO.. Club 4112 - , Fight ClubCW' rt:71 f and "Weed. Just http://profi le. mysp ace. co m/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.yiewprofile&friendID=20425696 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 37 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

"Simpson? Heroes WEED! PM-0 Juice's Details "Lullaby" and "Diary" are my favorites! "Choke -vvww.myspace.com/sublimehottie Page 5 of 13 kidding about the lost one. Oh wait, no I'm not.) ::Smoke weed everyday:: and "Family buy' BITCHEZI isiah I Heart Garrett Stein Friends U Can Keep. So promise me we'll F.U.C.K 4ever! Send this to 10 back to me. To know who your true buddies are!!!* I miss you! • Chanel Bunny u5 42 PM • Beef Knuckles ex Hey girl! What's up? I'm happy to h( doing well and you're at Conc. I hope you've been doing well since You're too beautiful beyond words miss you tons and I wish you well. K Touch • Liza 1113/2006 11:52 AM 2006 to Present Status: Here for: Orientation: Hometown: Cody type: Ethnicity: Zodiac Sign: Smoke Drink: Children: Education: C),:ctipation - THA WILD CHILD Pimp ;luice's Schools Florida State University Tallahassee,Florida Graduated: N/A Degree: In Progress Major: International Affairs yo what up i miss you. how's e going? ./1I./ 20069:42 PM Watch Vick BECAUSEI GOT HIGH (Afroman) http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction—user.viewprofile&friendID-20425696 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 38 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

*vvvw.myspace.com/sublimel- 'e Page 6 of 13 2001 to 2005 • 4 4 Video Code provided by VideoCodeZone.Com hope life is treatin u well and like the toke a bowl for me peace -E 51<ylift Yo nigga hows SCHOOL? James 1/5/2006 8:09 Hey hows it going -' :? Damn i havi you in a while. What have you been Jibby 2j Hello!!! Did William come bearing gil http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendLD=20425696 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 39 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

wAivw.myspace.com/sublimehrsttie Page 7 of 13 lhe ribbon on my wrist says do not open before.... iibby 2j .1:25 .1; samatha V 11/21/2005 :3:21 PM pizza. / how's it going? listen! i haven school at all in the past 2 weeks wit! high. it's bad! 11/20/2005 6:38 PM ;till* II' haha i know what picture your talkin good luck at i just applied there out if i got in a little after december don't know where i want to go yet. c applications suck. maybe i'll be up tl have to go do hw so i'll ttyl! <3 isiah II/ 14/ 20(.) 2:39 At hey i love you too i wanna come up see you guys flows evrey thing hit rr you maffi —1— http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendID=20425696 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 40 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Nick 11/8/2005 5:13 PM I miss ou. You roll the most oh vvvvw.myspace.com/sublime1, 'tie Page 8 of 13 51<ylER Hey we're all supposed to go up to t for spring break, I know thats a long we'll probly chill before then but still fun!!!!We miss you!!!! Brandon Thanxs for the add! I though you m: this... Jibby 2j Z005 11:56 A First of all, way to go on the html all yourself!! second of all i love the vid below my comment, third of all.. it's taught me how and i am workings tc status one j at a time. haha. i hope • having fun in talli, come home soon! Beef Knuckles .11 /9/2005 9:59 PM How's it goin up there? Gettin ready p Tally soon? 51<ylER S';;;i/23; 2005 12:35 PM Fo real fuck yo job nIggaaHlfill http://profile.myspace.conilindex.cfm?fuseaction=user.vIewprofileSifriendID-20425696 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 41 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

vaivrw.myspace.com/sublimehm-tie Page 9 of 13 M-E-G..."MEG" V love ya babe! I miss ya...come and Gangsta Waita pit-Mulct' Beef Knuckles 2005 3:29 AM whats up... I miss yin are you guys gonna be down again? craig's birthdays are next week so h see you and will soon... Mike Chaos :710 8:28 AM 00766 whats up momma? holla at me sometime... http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendID=20425696 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 42 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

...xivw.myspace.corn/sublimehrolie Page 10 of 13 www.gettheammo.corn Blizunts & Bizongs Kelli I haven't seen you in like a year. I h everything's going good with you, at you're meeting lots of cool people in place. :) SKE3M t)t hey gH...whats the deal..when are v‘ burn one?? wb...we need to chill sometime...and get blizzy!!! wb I Heart Garrett 9 2 t7. (0)5 9151 PM Stein I love you!!! • ka tie, 21 2005 41.38 AM where ya been, woadie? I Only Want ty 2e• 17 0.0 PM What I Already Have yo alex whats upp??? http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendID=20425696 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 43 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

NikAmv.myspace.com/sublimeli-ie Page 11 of 13 ill pistol whip the shit out of you!!! Y=Ut • your GONNA LUV everyboc POT up there so finding a roomate your "interests" shouldnt be hard. Heart < HArdy har har and incase you forgot im the KING 005 .f.':•58 hey girl i dont kno u but i love ur sty that reefer to eaze my mind thats th see it i love it too we gotta toke sun- Beef Knuckles 15/ 2005 12:52 PM Yo I sent those pits in a message to account since your away message is ..••• ft'. something. Its time for a new begining... 9114/2005 2:01 PM EY waddup partner how u been man seen ya in awhile...so hopefully u an still together..thats awesome babe.. hit me back yo we'll toke..peace! Vinny =!1. :x / 2005 10:00 AM Damn... I just read about your near accident. Glad you're alright and um. dose calls like that that make us the I'm not very religious myself, but tr) the right thing. I was driving down s on 95 and this tour bus almost tippe us so I know how you feel. The least driver could have done was stopped, least you didn't hit anything and are http://profile.myspace.cotn/index.cfm?fuseaction—user.viewprofile&friendID=20425696 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 44 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

v.),Avv. my space. co m/subl meh e Page 12 of 13 libby 2j "Where the hell have & Will bee :*:MeLiSsA:*: come hang out with us soon :r;"2005 7:13 AM Hey ' Whets up? How have you Haven't talked to you or seen you in long! Hope everything's going well b Keep in touch, ttyl! <3Melissa -xXx- 9/6/2005 3:51 PM DO YOU ONLY SMOKE? OR ARE THEI OTHER THINGS YOU LIKE TO DO.... SUBSTANCE-WISE I MEAN fuck this city in your mouth 5/2005 12:18 PM HEY wuddup hows erything up in el simon and garfunkle man..keep it re http://profile.myspace.corn/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendID=20425696 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 45 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

City: Royal Palm/Tallahassee State: FLORIDA Country: US Signup Date: 07/02/05 Currently listening: The Score By Fugees (Refugee Camp) Release date: By 13 February, 1996 My Subscriptions: - no subscriptions - 11:58 AM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment iolcg.myspace.comisublimehr '''e Page 1 of 5 myspace a place for friends ,-97;firifet /kr/ 7/ Search Jobs InOnst,eri.„ home I subscribe I rss I add to blog group I sign out Tuesday, January 24, 2006 Greetings from Tallahassee Current mood: 0 peaceful I made it! I'm at I love it here. My dorm is so big and nice, compared to most of the other dorms on campus. I've been going to class now for three weeks and I love it. As a matter of fact, I'm doing quite well. I'm so glad! Who knew that doing good in high school would pay off?...j/k. I've totally fallen in love with The weather, most of the time is perfect. It's beautiful up here. This weekend Will is visiting and I am so excited. I'm goinna show him all over. We're going to have the best time! Hopefully, everything will continue to go well. If I keep up this pace I'll have a descent chance at the dean's list. OMG! I would just die! Wish me luck! I miss everyone! XOXO Last Updated: Feb 8, 2006 Send Message Instant Message Email to a Friend Subscribe Invite to My Blog Gender: Female Status: In a Relationship Age: 19 Sign: Capricorn Blog Archive Friday, January 06, 2006 [ Older Newer ] 2 14 2006 Go Bitching and Moaning Current mood: Q exhausted Category: Goals, Plans, Hopes So, I am officially a "college gal." The past two days have been incredibly stressful. I've been so busy; all I want to do is sleep. I moved into my dorm yesterday but I still have alot of stuff to buy to make it comfortable. My room is a suite, which is awesome. There are only 4 suite buildings and I was lucky enough to get one. I only have one roomate to deal with and the room is a decent size so I can have privacy too. I'm excited. Despite my excitement, however, I am sad also. I don't know what's going on, I miss Will,....I guess he misses me, but who knows,.... ::sigh:: I'm not used to falling asleep by myself, I'm not used to him having pictures of naked women on his wall. Everything's different. Maybe not, http://blog.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=blog.ListAll&friendID=20425696&MyTo... 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 46 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

wNJ6.111y3paLc.LAnw:-,utilillierlottie Page 2 of 5 but atleast it feels like it right now. I don't know how I'm going to adjust. I'm so scared to feel lonely. Anyway, I finished orientation today. It was s00000 boring. I tried to pick my classes and they were all full. It sucks. I have to wake up at 8am when registration opens and go on the computer and finish applying for classes because for some reason that shit will be open tomorrow. I don't know. My INTENDED major is International Affairs. I chose it this morning at 3am because I had to register today and I had no idea what I wanted to do. I'm so last minute on everything. I CAN'T WAIT TO BUY SOME I CAN'T WAITIIIIII!!!!!!!!!!!!! (Hold On: Let me say that again) I CAN't WAIT TO BUY WEED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I also want to get a vaporizer so I can smoke in my room because apparently there are 'narcs' everywhere. Well, I'm really excited about starting class and meeting people. If you've read to this point then I feel bad for you. I'll stop torturing and finish this thing up, hope everyone is having a happy new year. I'm sorry to those of you I promised to hang out with but couldn't because I had no time before I left. I was so busy guys, don't hate me. I'm sorry :( I'll be in touch to all of those who know me. Wish me luck! 4:45 PM - Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Thursday, December 22, 2005 grown up Current mood: crappy I am leaving Will to go to in three days. I am moving to Tallahassee in twelve days. I'm so sad; I can't stand it. I guess you can say I'm sulking, but I can't help the way I feel. The whole thing is so bitter-sweet. I've been crying a lot 0 7:03 PM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Saturday, December 10, 2005 Biker Bitch Current mood: B exhausted Category: Automotive I am s00000000000000000 tired. Today was the Toys For Tots bike rally. My neighbor has a Harley so I went with him. It was s00000000000 cool! There was 400 bikes. It was awesome. I even go to meet this http://blog.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction-blog.ListAll&friendID=20425696&MyTo... 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 47 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

log.myspace.com/sublimehottic Page 3 of 5 guy that has a local tv show. He goes all around to these different bike spots. I think he's hilarious. I recognized him and went over and talked to him. He was really nice. He's having this concert to promote his show and I think I'm gonna try and talk Will into going. I was standing there in a sea of Harleys and Triumphs and Hondas and Suzukis and I was loving it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I donated a football and a Fantastic 4 action figure set. It had two toys in it so it was pretty cool. They talked and moved and crap. Just wanted to let everyone know what I was up to. Bye! 4:18 PM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Tuesday, November 15, 2005 BUMMER MAN Current mood: Q crushed Category: School, College, Greek I'm so depressed. I'm leaving for on Jan. 5. I'm packing up Will's and my room soon and it's making me depressed thinking about it. It's going to be so weird not having my best friend with me. I don't want to be without him but it doesn't seem like I have a choice. I'm really sad, and a little scared to go. Have you been through this situation? How did u deal with it? Write me a message please. I'm feeling 20 different emotions and I have no idea how to deal with it. 5:02 PM - 1 Comments - 2 Kudos - Add Comment Monday, November 07, 2005 GGGRRRRRR, Current mood: 0 pissed off I forgot to let everyone know I quit my job at Victoria's Secret. They said they suspected me of "causing losses to their company." -Which by the way is bullshit! I was 'by the book' on EVERYTHING!!!!!!! I got so fed up in that office that I handed the Loss Prevention lady back my keys and walked out. GO ME! STICKIN' IT TO THE MAN! I already have another job if I want it, and it's so much more money$$$$$$. I'm going to be making more money than my old bosses at VS. Success is definately the sweetest revenge. ASSHOLES! HH! 10:01 AM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment http://blog.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=blog.ListAll&friend1D--20425696&MyTo.. . 2/14/2006 111111111111111111 07/26/17 Page 48 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

bl-og.myspace.comisublitnehotrip Page 4 of 5 Slightly Stoopid, BOH?!? Current mood: 0 okay I SAW SLIGHTLY STOOPID LAST NIGHT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! IT WAS DA SHIT!!!!!!!! BOH! (credit to Will for the use of 'BON!' because if I didn't give credit he'd say I copied him.) BOH! THE SHOW WAS AWESOME! Pictures will be coming soon. Stay tuned, BOH! Currently watching: Dora the Explorer - Dora's Ultimate Adventure Collection Release date: By 26 October, 2004 ):59 AM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Sunday, November 06, 2005 nole girlz do it better Current mood: excited i'm going to visit for the next three days!!!! as most of u know, i will attending the beginning in Jan. 2006. i'm going to have so much fun while i'm up there!!!!!!!! it's gonna be great getting a taste of college life! Currently watching: Volcano Release date: By 18 December, 2001 12:06 PM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment zombies and puppies Current mood: EV content hey, halloween was so much fun! will and i ended up going to a party. our makeup was awesome. i only have one pic of us up right now but i'll soon have more. the one i have up is of us after the make-up had been on for hours, it started to peel off in the pic but i think it still looks awesome. also, we found a red pitbull puppy a few days ago. i wrote a bulletin about her but i forgot to add that she is s000000 good with children. i have an 18 month old living with me and she is just s0000 nice to him. she loves to play with him and has not shown one sign of agression. even with another dog that is bigger than http://blog.myspace.corrilindex.cfm?fuseaction=blog.ListAll&friendID=20425696&MyTo... 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 49 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

blog.myspace.com/sublimehottie Page 5 of 5 her, a cat and a baby constantly bothering her. i want to keep her s0000 bad, i just can't tho. someone please take herillill and provide her with a good homeimi thank u. <3 MI Currently watching: Volcano ha Release date: By 18 December, 2001 11:55 AM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Wednesday, August 17, 2005 cool things are happening Current mood: C blah i'm just writing this blog because i'm so bored. okay,..uuummm,...something cool???? oh here we go: yesterday i was in walmart with my bf will and i got a phone call from pacific sunwear. i applied like 2 weeks ago and since then have gotten a job at Victoria's Secrets but the guy said that he wanted me to come in and talk to him about working at the store if i still want. now the cool part is that i was just talking to will about how i wanted a second job that morning. it's funny how things seem to wokr out so well. anyway, there's really nothin mush else going on. i have to start getting my stuff together since i'm going to be off soon!!!! well i guess i'll write more another time. love u guys! i miss all my homies back in royal palm. can't wait to have some of y'all visit. hey, will and i are throwing a party in two weeks. his parents are going out of town. if anyone wants to show up from back home, give will or me a call. 8:17 AM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment About] FAQ Terms Privacy Safety Tips I Contact M_yspace I Promote! i Advertise MySpace Shop 02003-2006 MySpace.com. All Rights Reserved. http://blog.myspace.corn/index.cfm?fuseaction=blog.ListAll&friendID=20425696&MyTo... 2/14/2006 07/26/17 Page 50 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1.1.11.•.• rage i MySpace.com [ Home The Web •4 ' MySpace • Search I Help I SIgnOut Free LeBron James Shoes Nike Shoes - Eastbay.com Max 360 $143.99 Nike Shoes New LeBron James Zoom HI Shop eastbay.com for various Save 10% on this first shoe with a Get a huge selection of Nike Basketball Sneakers. Act Now! casual & athletic Nike shoes 100% all air midsole. tennis tops, shorts, skirts, & today! shoes. Gooci Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music I Classifieds Pimp Juice is in your extends Pimp Juice's Latest Blog Entry [Subscribe to this Blog] Greetings from Tallahassee (view more) Bitching and Moaning (view more) grown up (view more) Biker Bitch (view more) BUMMER MAN (view more) [View All Blog Entries] Pimp Juice's Blurbs About me: Hil My name Is and I am 19. I was born in Ft. Lauderdale, Fl on December 30th, 1986. I eventually moved to Cooper City, Fl, 30 miles north of Ft. Lauderdale. In ninth grade I moved to Palm Beach with my grandparents. (I love them.) After graduation (60 CLASS OF 20051) I moved to It's in northern Fl, near Jacksonville. I just moved to Tallahasee to attend F5V. My major is International Affairs. Class started three weeks ago. I love itl I listen to all types of music. Everything sounds awesome to me. My favorite "I LOVE 8 1/2 InCh ROO$teR$i II" e, Last Login: 2/19/2006 View More Pics Contacting Pimp Juice IJ Send Message Fornerd to Friend arm_ ^P. Ant-en,- 07/26/17 Page 51 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

WILL (ScReWeD&ChOp Ped Up) I Heart Garrett Stein http://www.myspece.com/sublimehottie Music I , theater and WEEDI of Pimp Juice 's Friends It's IGGY Mandy www.myspace.com/sublimehottie Page 2 of 21 T Add to Favorite::: E3 Block User ft8 ;rink Lim band is SUBLIME. I'm pretty laid back. I love to party. I've been in a relationship for over a year now. My boyfriend, Will, Is my best friend. He is the most amazing person. I miss everyone back home. I love my friends and I love my family. Byel I'd like to meet Ewan McGregor. He is s0000 HOTTIII Add F ri end: iniideri Meseeide Add t o itirtoni Pimp Juice's Friend Spas MySpace URL: :ht;r- c• 148 You are Lou Dog. The beloved pet of Brad. It has been said that you are like the "alter ego" of Brad, and were like his best Displaying 49 of 84 comments (View/Edit All Comments) 2ibby 2j 2/ 2.0 t 2 http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=userviewprofile&friendID=20425696 'nn/2 o6 07/26/17 Page 52 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

then Postal a2 tae t Ramona M-E-G..."MEG" V 2/16/2006 3:26 PM Hey...you never called me back last night but head! WTF???! I love the new profile plc. You look gorgeous. Miss you babe! www.myspace.com/sublimehottie Page 3 of 21 friend. You have just recently passed on. RIP Lou Dog 1978-2001 Which Member of Sublime are YOU? brought to you by Quizilla ***If it's not shit then I'll listen to it**" <3 I LOVE ALL MUSICIII EXCEPT COUNTRY. MY NUMBER ONE FAVORITE BAND IS SUBLIME Service 611111, Dashboard Confessional , Brand Taking Back .P600' Sunday ..iscr My Chemical Fall Out Boy Operation Ivy Bob Marley • steph V I Heart Garrett Stein u know my deal. are u coming to visit william this weekend???? 2/.16/ 2006 10:10 AM lol no no. not my baby shower. phew, thank god right? robert's brother's girlfriend had a baby on december 9th. so robert's little neice. she's adorable. but yeah. no babies for me. not yet atleast. This weekend im getting my wisdom teeth out 07/26/17 Page 53 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

www. my space. com/sublimehottie Page 4 of 21 Dropkick Murphys Mike Jones (Screwed Paul Wall (Screwed The White Stripe V steph • but maybe I can come up next weekend' 2006 7:33 Afr hey , hey will, it's been a while. ok bye hey :. love the new picture up of you. you look gorgeous 51<ylER it Pfv1 Whats up A ? I see you mvoed in safe and sound. Hope all is well and high as fuck, peace. Ps: how the fuck did you hear about that shit? , Damien Morley Jack Johnson :ter_. , John Mayer Cypress and Chopped Hilt ,Radio ,Radio Heo The Smashing Pumpkins Snoop A.D.D, Am I... Dying? and Chopped)N./._rj, The 07/26/17 Page 54 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 5 of 21 wvvw.myspace.com/sublimehothe 1/1(1/1(10A htto://orofile.mvsoace com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user vi ewnrnfi 1 eRrfri en clTD=2042 564A Stroke The Beatles. No Doubt Slightly Stoopt o The Used raoied _7 gal and s000000000 much more that I'm forgetting. ::Smoke weed - everyday!:: Get more photos on MySpace!... Add MySpace Records as your friendl ,,. r. ,, to Ftittnd:s I ---------. yea...whateva.... ♦ steph • I Heart Garrett Stein jennifer without the nifer just saying hi! hope all Is well! Of: hey girl. whats going on? how's tallahassee? 2/9.12006 12:51 P Umm.. I was just reading your comments and you came here to orlando and went to cowboys!!! If you were here and didnt call me im going to MURDER you. Love you how are ya?!?!?! I havent seen u in a veryyy longgg time! :) hope all is welll what u been up 2? 07/26/17 Page 55 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

linds and "Weed ."x Just "Ghostbusters" , "Night of the Living bead' "28 bays Later" "The Goonies" "Harvey" Trainspotting" "Big Fish" Nosferatu" "The Breakfast Club" li' t;1 , Fight ClubtO ALM isiah Things change, They don't stay the same. Nick www.myspace.comisublimehottie Page 6 of 21 2/8/2006 1:15 PM when are you coming back to visit o town??? cowboys was fun! catch ya lata---i have class. linds 2/6/2006 1:16 PM UR ENEMY STABS U IN DA FRONT UR FRIEND STABS U IN DA BACK UR GIRLFRIEND/BOYFRIEND STABS U IN DA HEART BUT ME, UR CLOSEST FRIEND CARRIES A KNIFE TO STAB THOSE MUTHAFUCKAS RIGHT BACK send this to as many closest friends that u have to let them know u two will stay friends always and forever....no matter wat , t16/2006 2:49 AM it was completely random BUT cool as fuk that i ran into u at that kid's house. Had fun def hit me up when u get down here! lata buddy! 2000 1:. :0;„!' Hey ..._.<. How's I'll be coming up there within the next few months so I'll come visit you. Doug, myself and two other black dudes are gonna do the full version of Complete Works of Shakespear in March so you'll have to http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendID=20425696 2/20/2006 07/26/17 Page 56 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

and "Family Guy' BITCHEZI Jibby 2j weed everyday:: "Simpson? "ATHF" , "Futurame Lungs Full of Smoke • WEED' , "Lullaby" and "Diary" are my favorites) "Choke" • www.myspace.cotn/sublimehottie Page 7 of 21 kidding about the last one. Oh wait, no I'm not.) ::Smoke come down and see It. If not, we'll make it into a dvd and send it up to you. I forgot to tell you that me Doug and one of the black guys got a Superior for the Othello and Titus part last month. I got a blog about It so check it out. How is everything else goin? / 2/ 2.006 7:52 PM Hey weed hoe, If you were here I'd smoke all of my weed with you, and you know that...I miss you, be safe, and study high so you can get high scores....MWAHIIIII 2/ "f2001.> 2:31 PM how Is the college Ilfe? I can only assume and hope you are livin it up out there... i miss our sanity trips and u need to come back in town or let me come visit amyyyy In a Relationship Networking, Friends Straight Cooper City, FL. 5'2" / Slim / Slender http : //profile. mysp ace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. vi ewpro file& fri en dID=20425696 '/1(1P7(WIA 07/26/17 Page 57 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

www.myspace.com/sublimehottie Page 8 of 21 Florida State University 2006 to Tallahassee,Florida Present Graduated: N/A Degree: In Progress Major: International Affairs 2001 to 2005 1.11.1" , /irtrevg L. 4...•.• v.% ...... . , n r 07/26/17 Page 58 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 1:5 8 AM - 2 Comments - 2 Kudos - Add Comment Last Updated: Feb 15, 2006 Send Message Instant Message Email to a Friend Subscribe Invite to My Blog Currently listening: The Score By Fugees (Refugee Camp) Release date: By 13 February, 1996 blog.myspace.com/sublimehothe Page 1 of 6 myspace a place for friends V 'NAGE THIN PHONE BILL. home I subscribe I rss I add to blog group I sign out Tuesday, January 24, 2006 Greetings from Tallahassee Current mood: :0; peaceful I made it! I'm at I love it here. My dorm is so big and nice, compared to most of the other dorms on campus. I've been going to class now for three weeks and I love it. As a matter of fact, I'm doing quite well. I'm so glad! Who knew that doing good in high school would pay off?...j/k. I've totally fallen in love with The weather, most of the time is perfect. It's beautiful up here. This weekend Will is visiting and I am so excited. I'm goinna show him all over. We're going to have the best time! Hopefully, everything will continue to go well. If I keep up this pace I'll have a descent chance at the dean's list. OMG! I would just die! Wish me luck! I miss everyone! XOXO Friday, January 06, 2006 Bitching and Moaning Current mood: 0 exhausted Category: Goals, Plans, Hopes So, I am officially a "college gal." The past two days have been incredibly stressful. I've been so busy; all I want to do is sleep. I moved into my dorm yesterday but I still have alot of stuff to buy to make it comfortable. My room is a suite, which is Gender: Female Status: In a Relationship Age: 19 Sign: Capricorn City: Royal Palm/Tallahassee State: FLORIDA Country: US Signup Date: 07/02/05 hap: //blog. myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=blog.ListAl I &fn en dID=20425696&MyToken=01efOdd2-cc14-4480-a758-43Off.. 2/20/2006 07/26/17 Page 59 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

blog.myspace.com/sublimehottie Page 2 of 6 awesome. There are only 4 suite buildings and I was lucky enough to get one. I only have one roomate to deal with and the room is a decent size so I can have privacy too. I'm excited. Despite my excitement, however, I am sad also. I don't know what's going on, I miss Will,....I guess he misses me, but who knows,.... ::sigh:: I'm not used to falling asleep by myself, I'm not used to him having pictures of naked women on his wall. Everything's different. Maybe not, but atleast it feels like it right now. I don't know how I'm going to adjust. I'm so scared to feel lonely. Anyway, I finished orientation today. It was s00000 boring. I tried to pick my classes and they were all full. It sucks. I have to wake up at 8am when registration opens and go on the computer and finish applying for classes because for some reason that shit will be open tomorrow. I don't know. My INTENDED major is International Affairs. I chose it this morning at 3am because I had to register today and I had no idea what I wanted to do. I'm so last minute on everything. I CAN'T WAIT TO BUY SOME N'EEDIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII I CAN'TWAITIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII (Hold On: Let me say that again) I CAN't WAIT TO BUY WEEDIIII III I I I II II I I I II II I I II l I also want to get a vaporizer so I can smoke in my room because apparently there are 'narcs' everywhere. Well, I'm really excited about starting class and meeting people. If you've read to this point then I feel bad for you. I'll stop torturing and finish this thing up, I hope everyone is having a happy new year. I'm sorry to those of you I promised to hang out with but couldn't because I had no time before I left. I was so busy guys, don't hate me. I'm sorry :( I'll be in touch to all of those who know me. Wish me luck! My Subscriptions: - no subscriptions - Blog Archive [ Older... Newer ] 2 20 2006 +Go 4:45 PM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Thursday, December 22, 2005 grown up Current mood: crappy I am leaving Will to go to in three days. I am moving to Tallahassee in twelve days. I'm so sad; I can't stand it. I guess you can say I'm sulking, but I can't help the way I feel. The whole thing is so bitter-sweet. I've been crying a lot a 7:03 PM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment httrt" /1-0 (Ur IrTIN,CtI•10"ea 4r.s. mr•-, 414%.,-.....-4: —1,1 T 111 0 : "IN ••••4- .- tne. n • • •-r. 07/26/17 Page 60 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

blog.myspace.com/sublimehottie Page 3 of 6 Saturday, December 10, 2005 Biker Bitch Current mood: exhausted Category: Automotive I am s00000000000000000 tired. Today was the Toys For Tots bike rally. My neighbor has a Harley so I went with him. It was s00000000000 cool! There was 400 bikes. It was awesome. I even go to meet this guy that has a local tv show. He goes all around to these different bike spots. I think he's hilarious. I recognized him and went over and talked to him. He was really nice. He's having this concert to promote his show and I think I'm gonna try and talk Will into going. I was standing there in a sea of Harleys and Triumphs and Hondas and Suzukis and I was loving itiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii I donated a football and a Fantastic 4 action figure set. It had two toys In It so It was pretty cool. They talked and moved and crap. Just wanted to let everyone know what I was up to. Bye! 4:18 PM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Tuesday, November 15, 2005 BUMMER MAN Current mood: Q crushed Category: School, College, Greek I'm so depressed. I'm leaving for on Jan. 5. I'm packing up Will's and my room soon and It's making me depressed thinking about it. It's going to be so weird not having my best friend with me. I don't want to be without him but it doesn't seem like I have a choice. I'm really sad, and a little scared to go. Have you been through this situation? How did u deal with it? Write me a message please. I'm feeling 20 different emotions and I have no idea how to deal with it. 5:02 PM - 1 Comments - 2 Kudos - Add Comment Monday, November 07, 2005 GGGRRRRRR, http ://b log. myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=bloe.ListAll&friendID=20425696&MvTok Pn=0 I efn ri (1,-r r I 4-44Rn-a75$2-410ff 1/-srionn4 1111 !!!!! 111111111 07/26/17 Page 61 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

blog.myspace.com/sublimehottie Page 4 of (1' Current mood: C) pissed off I forgot to let everyone know I quit my job at Victoria's Secret. They said they suspected me of "causing losses to their company." -Which by the way is bullshit! I was 'by the book' on EVERYTHINGllIllIl I got so fed up in that office that I handed the Loss Prevention lady back my keys and walked out. GO ME! STICKIN' IT TO THE MAN! I already have another job if I want it, and it's so much more money$$$$$$. I'm going to be making more money than my old bosses at VS. Success is definately the sweetest revenge. ASSHOLESIIIIII 10:01 AM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Slightly Stoopid, BOH?!? Current mood: 10 okay I SAW SLIGHTLY STOOPID LAST NIGHTiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii IT WAS DA SHITIIIHIll BOH! (credit to Will for the use of 'BOH!' because if I didn't give credit he'd say I copied him.) BOH! THE SHOW WAS AWESOME! Pictures will be coming soon. Stay tuned, BON! Currently watching: 4‘, Dora the Explorer - Dora's Ultimate Adventure Collection • V°, Release date: By 26 October, 2004 9:59 AM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Sunday, November 06, 2005 nole girlz do it better Current mood: um excited I'm going to visit for the next three days!!!! as most of u know, i will attending the beginning in Jan. 2006, i'm going to have so much fun while i'm up therelinim it's gonna be great getting a taste of college life! Currently watching: http://bIog.myspace.com/index.cfmffuseaction—blog.ListAll&friendID=20425696&MvToken=01eMdd2-cc I 4-4480-a758-43Off 2/20/2006 07/26/17 Page 62 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

blog.myspace.com/sublimehottie Page 5 of 6 Volcano Release date: By 18 December, 2001 12:06 PM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment zombies and puppies Current mood: 0 content hey, halloween was so much fun! will and i ended up going to a party. our makeup was awesome. i only have one pic of us up right now but i'll soon have more. the one i have up is of us after the make-up had been on for hours, it started to peel off in the pic but i think it still looks awesome, also, we found a red pitbull puppy a few days ago. i wrote a bulletin about her but i forgot to add that she is s000000 good with children. i have an 18 month old living with me and she is just s0000 nice to him. she loves to play with him and has not shown one sign of agression. even with another dog that is bigger than her, a cat and a baby constantly bothering her. i want to keep her s0000 bad, i just can't tho. someone please take her!!!!!! and provide her with a good home!!!!! thank u. <3 Currently watching: Volcano Release date: By 18 December, 2001 11:55 AM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment Wednesday, August 17, 2005 cool things are happening Current mood: k9) blah i'm just writing this blog because i'm so bored. okay,..uuummm,...something cool???? oh here we go: yesterday i was in walmart with my bf will and i got a phone http://blog.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=blog.ListAll&friendID=204256968zMyToken=01efOdd2-cc14-4480-a758-43Off 2/20/2006 07/26/17 Page 63 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

blog.myspace.com/sublimehottie Page 6 of 6 call from pacific sunwear. i applied like 2 weeks ago and since then have gotten a job at Victoria's Secrets but the guy said that he wanted me to come in and talk to him about working at the store if i still want. now the cool part is that i was just talking to will about how i wanted a second job that morning. it's funny how things seem to wokr out so well. anyway, there's really nothin mush else going on. i have to start getting my stuff together since I'm going to be off soon!!!! well i guess write more another time. love u guys! i miss all my homies back in royal palm. can't wait to have some of y'all visit. hey, will and i are throwing a party in two weeks. his parents are going out of town. if anyone wants to show up from back home, give will or me a call. - 8:17 AM - 0 Comments - 0 Kudos - Add Comment About FAQ Terms Privacy Safety Tips I Contact Myspace Promote! I Advertise I MySpace Shop 02003-2006 MySpace.com. All Rights Reserved. http://blog.mvsoace.com/index.cfm7fligeartinn=hIno T ot A 11,Prfri pririlT1=1n4 c AoARAn„7.,sien„---n ,cr) AA", 4 e 4011 nrc „1n n 07/26/17 Page 64 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Pictures of Pimp Juice: Click Picture for Full View S.. Comr—e,-ts Me In my dorm, making Will breakfast. Lisa (my roomate) and I were making Valentines <3 <3 <3 <3 »Post a Comment »E-Mail to a Friend »Report this Image 7 Comment(s) Me and my guy <3 »Post a Comment »E-Mail to a Friend ,,Report this Image »Post a Comment »E-Mail to a Friend ..Report this Image 1 Comment(s) Post a Comment •.E-Mail to a Friend Report this Image 0 Comment(s) I am too sexy Myspace.com Page 1 of 3 Search 0 Comment(s) htm://viewmoreoics.mvsnace com/inclex c.m9. f f iiceartirtn=impr ar• ATI-11141 14 10, r, 1-1 07/26/17 Page 65 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Don't F*AK with me bitchez!!! My dad's from : that should explain this picture, hehe :) »Post a Comment »E-Mail to a Friend »Report this Image 0 Comment(s) >4Post a Comment »E-Mail to a Friend »Report this Image 3 Comment(s) »Post a Comment »E-Mail to a Friend »Report this Image 1 Comment(s) 'All I need is one mic...' Myspace.corn Page 2 of 3 I don't know if you know this...but I'm kind of a big deal. >Post a Comment E-Mail to a Friend ,>Report this Image 4 Comment(s) thn • //Nil elxrninrPn i re 11,1rervirp rnmli tnricry ncrrilf17r•nn •-•44 nr• —••,•••• • • . I r1 _nn A••••e• enr 0* 4 1 n. IY• 1 1••• 07/26/17 Page 66 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

My boyfriend just got a cute, new puppy. Isn't she adorable? WHAT HEAVEN LOOKS LIKE TO ME Post a Comment »E-Mail to a Friend ',Report this Image 2 Comment(s) ;.Post a Comment ,E-Mail to a Friend ,Report this Image 0 Comment(s) Myspace .corn Page 3 of 3 Me and my friend Jenny (from »Post a Comment E-Mail to a Friend .Report this Image 1 Comment(s) About I FAQ I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips Contact Myspace I Promote! Advertise VS03-2006 MySpace.com All Rights Reserved http://viewmorepics.mvspace.com/index cfm9fuseaction=ticpr viPwPirtvIrpkfn Prl r4111=111111 cAOARA ,Tn nin —n1 raY1,1,4'1 1 A a A 01/,14's 07/26/17 Page 67 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace. corn Page 1 of 2 MySpace.com I Home Tne Web MySpace Search ( KISS BR/-0 Pi Home I Browse Search Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog I Favorites Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music Back to Picture Index Back to Profile Me and my first pipe. Post a Comment I E-Mail to a Fri < Previous I Next > Listing 1 - 2 of 2 From Comment October 15, 2005 12:04 PM +Beauty In That's a kick ass pipe. I see Will in the Bloody Love+ background. Tell him I say "hi". We need to hang hrtn.//vieWrnewrsnirc rrntervarr. r•nr•rtrimi".. ' . 07/26/17 Page 68 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 1 of 2 Search a. Get 2 FRE ^ iPor nan Oack to Picture Index 83ack. to Profile My BFF, Julie <3 Weed 4L I!! Post a Comment I E-mail ti a Friend < Previous j Next > Listing 1 - 1 of 1 From Comment Vin October 20, 2005 1:18 PM http //vi ewmo rep i cs. mysp ace. com/index.cfm?fuseaction=viewImage&friendID=2042569... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 69 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Search Back to Picture Index Back to Profile "I think I'm drunk, Post a Comment I E-Mail to a Friend < Previous f Next > h ttp ://vi e wmo rept cs. myspace. com/index. cfin?fuseaction =viewImage8cfriendID---2042569... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 70 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

r (.1) * Video- .- 4 iroas • I WO. 1.-7,•JEKMAi.l.A.1111 nee I Ot 2 Search flick to Picture Index FAck to P; ofile Weed makes me giggle. Post a Comment I E-Mail to a Friend < Previous I Next > Listing 1 - 1 of 1 From Comment July 24, 2005 8:10 PM Beef Knuckles HEY THATS WEED http ://viewmorepics. myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=viewImage&friendID=2042569... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 71 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

-‘4\E1/4( - 07/26/17 Page 72 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

r:14, C ngular National Compliance Center RESPONSE COVER SHEET PO BOX 24679 WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33416-4679 Phone 1-800-635-6840 Fammtle 1-888-9384715 To: DET JOE RECAREY File Code: 153496 PALM BEACH PI) 33480 345 SOUTH CO RD. PALM BEACH, FL 33480 From: MAT Phone Number. (561) 838-5470 Request Dated: 9/28/2005 Number of Pages: 13 Fax Number: (561) 83S-5491 Received On: 12/13/2005 Date: 12/29/2005 If you are not already doing so, please begin addressing all legal requests to Cingular Wireless. Additionally, effective immediately, please fax all legal requests to Cingular Wireless at 1-888-938-4715. - The number referenced below is a Cingular Prepaid Service. All available information has been provided. CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE This cover sheet. and any document which may accompany it, contains information from the National Compliance Caner which is intended for use only by the individual to whom it is addressed, and which may contain informanon that is privileged, confidential and/or otherwise exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient or the person responsible for delivering thin massage to the intended recipient, any review, diRclosurc, dissemination, distribution copying or other use of this message or its substance is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by telephone to arrange for the return of this communication to us at our expense. Thank you. NCC Official Uee Only U C O 153496 07/26/17 Page 73 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Dec 13 2005 3:24PM PALM BERCH POLICE 5018385491 p.4 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND, FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY,1FLORIDA (CRIMINAL DIVISION) STATE ATTORNEY SUBPOENA Ciugular Cellular Service NO, 05-595 Custodian of Records PHE'D Case #05-368 5600 Glenridge Drive, #G4 18 Atlanta, GA 30342 DUCES TECUM: Any and all substcril•,er informatiou,incorniag twit outing calls for telephone number 561-3013-0282. The time frank involreci is February 2005 through die prezent. GREETINGS: YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to be and appear before THE STATE ATTORNEY or his ,Assistant, in. and for Palm Beach County, Florida, at the State Anorney's Mee, 40! North Dixie Highway, West Palm Beach, Florida. .6 INSTANTER for interrogation and the truth to speak, in a certain mane" pending and under investitipii.. Failure to appear will subject you to conotenipt of Court_ "4" You many comply by supplying materials directly to Detective Joe Recturey, ToWba of Paha Beach Police Department, 345 South County Road, Palma Beach, Florida 33480, Fax 361413.11..54191.*I`s"'""• wirNE roy hand and seal of this Coon day of September 2005 • 9' arAti/ - tGae.. Mracar..amo = '--- _—_- ..fassrtCfrer-- as T,Se=c 1,1=iity61.6¢-9,4•MdkpCM9 12-MUM CC•II Received this subpoena on the 2,6_ day of September, 2095, and executed the same ou the IEr day of September 2005, 'cry delivering a T • Copy theleof to the within named v,itriet+s in the County of Palm Beach, State of Florida. 07/26/17 Page 74 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sworn O and subscribed befor this day of September, 200 "-- -vs Lyn Baur in WIRES '1462112 WIRE& Ort. ROC Dec 13 2005 3:25PM' PRLM BEACH POLICE 5E18385401 P • 5 OFFICE OF THE STATE ATTORNEY I, i LENTFI JUDICIAL CIRCUIT OF FLORIDA IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY September , 2005 TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: Pursuant to an official investigation of a suspected telony being conducted by the Town of Palm Beach Police Department is requested that your company furnish INSTANTER, information requested in State Attorney Subpoena # 05-595 PURSUANT TO FLORIDA STATE STATUTE 896.101(10), YOU, ARE NOT TO DISCLOSE THE EXISTENCE OF THIS REQUEST. Any such disclosure could obstruct and impede the investigation being conducted and thereby interfere with the enforcement of the law. Thank you for your cooperatioi Det arey Strron lm Barka *TazinasS47N, 0,2ld11.17 D5 AKIEIst 20ar k.1^-111 rws. e ran x,yvvoce oc 2 07/26/17 Page 75 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

153496 22/14/2005 SUBSCRIBER INFORMATION X cingular® 0035224228 7.5 Financially Liable Party Name: HOLLY ROBSON Credit Address: 12247 72ND CT N, WEST PALM BEACH FL 33412-1460 Customer Since: 09/23/2003 Photo ID Type: Photo 10 Number: DOB: Contact Name: HOLI,.Y ROBSON Contact Home Phone:1561) 333-0180 Contact Home Email: Photo ID State: SSN: 261-33-2735 Contact Work Phone: (954) 524-1764 Contact work Email, Billing Party Account Number: 0035224228 Name: HOLLY ROBSON Billing Address: 19247 72ND CT N. WEST PALM BEACH FL 33412-1460 Account Statue: Cancel Billing Cycle: 11 User Information MSISDN: (S611 300-0282 (MSTSDN Change) IMSI: 330380037146641 MSISDN Active: 07/21/2003 - 07/05/2005 IMEI/E5N 010119501872069/ Name: HALEY E:OBSON User Address: 1!2247 72ND CT N , WEST PALM BEACH FL 33412-1460 Service Start Date:! 07/21/2003 Dealer Info: Payment Type: PrePay Contact Name: HOLLY ROBSON Contact Home Phone:!(561) 333-0180 Contact Work Phone: (954) 524-1764 Contact Home Email: Contact Work Email: Status Change History Status Change Reason: Status Change Date: Vol - Hotline PrePaY 07/05/2005 Vol - Hotline PrePay 04/05/2005 Rnstate-Hotline Prepay 03/19/2005 Vol - Hotline PrePay 02/11/2005 Rnstate-Hotline Prepay 01/12/2005 14AT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Page 1 Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 76 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED VOICE USAGE FOR (551)308-0282 Conlinued Qnty Charge Used RAW Description 1MIN UNL NAT ED N/WWND MIN 1 YIN UNLIMITED NNIKNO MIN 150N JUN INITrD NAMINII MIN 1 MIN UNLIMITED NM/KNOWN 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WILM3 KIM 1 MIN UNUMITED NOWA ND MIN 1MIN UNUMITED NANO NO MIN ?MIN UNLIMITED NIWX ND MIN N UNLIMITED NNVKNO MIN 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 'MIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN 11MIN 1 MIN UNUNTI ED N1W1IND MIN 4 MIN UNLIMITED N/WAND MIN UNLIMITED WW1( NO NUN 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 1 MIN UNUMTED NIVINNO MIN 2 NON UNUMITED WWKNO MIN 114IN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 12 MIN P NN UNUMITED MWKNOMiN UNUMITED NIWKNO MIN 1 MINN UNUMITED NIWKNO MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN UNUMITED WWKNO MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN UNUMITED NAM NO MIN UNUMITED NIWKND MIN CALL WAILING UNUMITED NANKNO liAiN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.90 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 0.09 AIRT ME MINUTES 0.09 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 009 0. 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 027 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.36 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.72 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 UNUMITED NIWKND MIN 2MIN UNUMITED HANK NO MIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN UNUMITED NIWIND MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.36 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 0.36 Number Item Dale Time Called 443 01130 444 01130 445 01130 446 0117/1 447 01/30 449 01/30 119 01/30 450 01/30 451 01/30 452 (Imo 453 01/30 454 01/30 455 01/30 456 01/30 457 01/30 458 01/30 159 01/30 480 01/30 461 01/30 462 01/30 463 01/30 464 01130 465 01/30 466 01/30 467 01/ 468 011 469 011 470 011 471 011 472 01/3 473 01131 474 01/31 475 01/31 476 01/31 477 01/31 478 01131 479 01/31 4110 01131 481 01/3 492 OM 493 OM 481 01/3 405 01/31 486 01/3 487 0113 488 0113 489 0113 490 01/31 491 0113 492 01/3 413 0113 494 01/3 495 01/3 416 01/3 497 01/3 498 01/3 199 02/0 • .05A 500 02/01 0215A (561)635.3454 501 02101 02:34P (561)30443282 502 02/01 02:34P (361)3064282 503 02/01 02:50P (561)635•3454 504 OVO 0318P 505 02/01 03:20P Charge 2MIN M 4N 5 MN i EVT 35 MIN 1 MIN 1OMIN 3MIN 1 MIN 1 MIN 1 MIN 1MIN 3MIN 1 MIN IMIN 1MIN 2MIN IMIN 2MIN 1 MIN 11413 1 MIN MAIN IMIN SINN 2MIN IMIN MAIN MAIN 9AIN 7141H 'MIN 1MIN 1 EVT 4MIN i EVT 1 MIN 1 MIN 4 MIN INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING INCOMING Xcingular MI MElf 65 Account Number 0035224228 Account Name HOLLY RCBSCN Date of Invoice-7 February 12, 2005 AT&T Wireless Page 7 of 10 DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED VOICE USAGE FOR (561)308-0282 - Continued Number Item Date Time Called Calls To Qnty Used Rate Charge Description Charge 506 02/01 03:23P INCOMING 3MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 507 02/01 03:SIP (561)889.7686 WPALMBEACH FL IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 506 02/01 03:53P INCOMING MAIN 0D9 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.63 ..509 02/01 04:00P - . .. . .- INCOMING.. 10161 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES . . .. - 0.02 - 510 02101 04:26P INCOMING 111114 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 511 02/01 05:35P INCOMING 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 512 02101 05:49P INCOMING 3 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 513 02101 06:11P INCOMING IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 514 02/01 07:57P INCOMING 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 515 02/01 08:I2P INCOMING IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 516 517 02101 08:41P 02/01 08.55117 INCOMING INCOMING 214111 11 1MIN IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 0.09 518 02101 09:21F? (561)635.3454 WPALMBEACH FL 1 UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 519 520 02/01 09.54P 02/01 10:01P (561)615.3451 INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN UN UMI TED NNI/KN 0 MIN 521 522 523 02/01 10:30P 02/0212:31A 02102 01:14A INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING 1/ 1MIN 51 MINN WKNOM UNLIMITED W IN UNUMITED WWKN 0 MIN UNLIMITED /WYNN 0 MIN 574 02102 01:19P INCOMING 8M1N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.72 525 02/02 03:59P INCOMING IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 526 02/02 04:44P INCOMING I MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 527 02/02 04:47P INCOMING %MIN 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 529 02/02 04- 55P (561)689.1686 WPALMBEACH FL IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 529 02102 0542P INCOMING 3MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 530 02102 07:53P (561)635.3154 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 531 02102 08:24P INCOMING 3MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 027 532 02102 08:55P INCOMING %MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 533 02/02 09:25P INCOMING MAIN UNUMITED NfWKNO MN 534 02/0211:11P INCOMING 2MIN UNUMITED II/WNW:1741N 535 02/02 11:13P INCOMING 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 536 02/03 10:14A (561)614.2611 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.16 531 0210310:48/3 (561)793-9291 WPALMBEACH FL I MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 538 02/03 11:01A INCOMING 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 539 540 02/03 11:57A 02/03 12:09P INCOMING INCOMING 1 MIN 1 MIN 0.04 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 00.009 .9 541 02/03 06: SIP INCOMING 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 542 02/03 09:14P INCOMING 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 543 544 02/03 08:59P (561)869-7686 02/0309:13P WPALMBEACH Fl. INCOMING 1 mI N N .1 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 0.09 545 02/03 051:21P WPALMBEACH FL UNUMITED HAWN° MIN 546 547 02/03 09:30P 01103 09:32P 561 561 1561r111.2611 313-6730 313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL LAKE WORTH FL 51 1I M r vi m1 111 N NNN UNUMITED N/WNND MIN UNUMITED NANKNO MIN 548 02/03 09:35P INCOMING UNUMITED N/WAND MIN 549 02104 12:16/3 INCOMING UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 550 02/04 12.40A 561 889.7686 WPALMBEACH FL 2MMMIIINNN UNUMTED N/WKNO MIN 551 02/04 02.01A 561 635-3454 WPALMBEACH FL 1 1 UNUMITED N/WXND MIN 552 02/04 02:01A 561 635-3454 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN DROP CALL CREDIT 553 02/04 02:23A 561 1869035 WPALMBEACH FL 17.4IN UNUMTED NANKND MIN 554 02/04 04:16P 561 889-7686 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0 09 555 02/04 04:17P INCOMING 60.4IN 0.01 AIRTIME MINUTES 054 556 02104 05:27P INCOMING 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 557 01/04 01:24P INCOMING 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 558 02/04 07:34P INCOMING 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 559 02/04 07:43P INCOMING 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 560 02/04 09:091' (561)889.76e6 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 561 562 02/01 09.25P 02/04 09:39P 561 889.7686 INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN 3 MIN NMKNO MIN UNLIMITED UNLIMITED NANKND MIN 563 564 07/04 09.59P 02/04 10.00P 561 561 641.2611 614.2611 WPALMBEACH Ft WPALMBEACH F L 1 1 N MIN 3IIN UNUMITED WWKNO MIN UNLIMITED N/WILND MIN 565 02/041001P 561 644.2611 WPALMBEACH FL 1UNUMITED N/WKND HIM 566 02/04 1002P INCOMING IMIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 567 02/0410:53P 561)308.0282 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 1 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 566 02/04 10:511P r6tr764208 WPALMBEACH Ft UNLIMITED N/WKNO Inn 569 02/04 11:05P 56? 1764208 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN 4 1 m AI I I N N UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 0 570 02/04 11:091' 561 889-7685 WPALMBEACH FL UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 07/26/17 Page 77 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Xcingular AT&T Wireless Account Number 0035224228 Account Name HOLLY ROBSON Date of Invoice February 12, 2005 Page 8 of 10 DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED 962910000'0 VOICE USAGE FOR (561)308.0282 - Continued Number Only Charge Item Date Time Called Calls To Used Rale Description Charge 571 02./01 11:10P INCOMING 4MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 1 EVT CALL WAITING l zige,t WPALMBEACH FL 573 02705 12:02A, 551 8119.76115 WPAINIBEACH f t 11AIN UNUIMITED N/WKND MIN UNUMITED NiWKNOMIN /5611676-2206 574 02/05 12:03A 561 596.4777 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 575 02/05 12:07A 561 313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL 3MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 576 02/05 12.09A INCOMING 2MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 1 EVT CALL WAITING 577 02105 12:11A (561)393.6730 LAKE WORTH FL UNUMITED NANKNO MIN 57B 02105 12:12A NCOMING 4 MIN UNUMITED NIWKND MIN 1 EVT CALL WAITING 579 02/05 12:32A NCOMING 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 590 02/05 12:424. NCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 581 02/05 12:566 NCOMING 4MIN UNLIMIT ED NIWKNO MIN 562 02105 01:09A NCOMING 3MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 583 02/05 01:26A NCOMING 2MIN UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN 584 02/05 03:35A N COMING 2MIN UNUMITED WNKND MIN 585 02/05 03:46A NCOMING 21AIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 586 02/05 10:24A (561)306-0287 WPALMBEACH FL I MIN UNUMITED WWKNO MIN I EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 587 02105 10.30A WPALMBEACH FL MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 588 02106 01:31P 561 r611889-7686 614-2611 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED WWILND MIN 569 02/05 01:15P 561 252-4753 WPALMBEACH FL 4MIN UN LIMITED N/WKND MIN 590 02105 01:56P INCOMING 7MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 591 02/05 010P 561541-2611 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UN UMITED N/WK ND MIN 592 02/05 02-11P WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 593 02/05 02:31P561644.2611 ( 1561 ) )844-2611 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND PRN 594 02/05 02:41P INCOMING 1 M1N UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 595 02)05 03:05P INCOMING 5 MIN UN LIMIT ED HANK ND MIN 596 02/05 03:20P 1541)669-7686 WPALMBEACH FL 1 ANN UNLIMIT ED WWKNO MIN 597 02/05 03:26P (551313139-7686 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED NNI/KNO MIN 598 02/05 0411P INCOMING 1IAIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 599 02/05 115:25P INCOMING 2MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 603 02/05 05:30P INCOMING 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 601 02105 07.17P INCOMING 10IAIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 602 02105 06.17P INCOMING UNLIMITED N/ WKND MIN 603 02105 136:43P WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 604 02/05 08:15P 561 r511389-7686 502.6120 LAKE WORTH FL I MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 605 0205 08:46P 911 855.3363 NEW YORK NY 1 PAIN UNUMITED NANKND MIN 606 02/05 09:13P INCOMING 3MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 607 02/05 09:18P WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 606 02/05 10:00P 561 15611889.7666 655.7626 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NIWKND MIN 609 02/06 01:10A 561 317-3348 WPALMBEACH FL 181IN UN UNITED N/WKND MIN 610 02/06 11:10A INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMIT ED NIWKND MIN 611 02/06 11:11A 561 602.5720 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNLIMIT ED NNYKNO MIN 612 02/06 11 11A 561 3634910 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 613 02/175 11:126 561 602-5720 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN 614 02/06 11:12A 561 393-6810 WPAIN BEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 615 02/06 11:11A 561 6024720 LAKE WORTH FL I MIN UNLIMITED NNYKND MIN 616 02/06 11:15A 561 602-5720 LAKE WORTH FL IMIN UNLINKED N/WKND MIN 617 02/06 11:21A 561 317.3346 WPAUABEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 618 02/06 11:22A 561 753-1604 WPALMBEACH FL WAIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 619 02/06 11:21A 561 602-5720 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 620 02/06 11:28A 561 183.6910 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN N/WKND MIN 621 02106 11:29A 561 333.9056 WPAUABEACH FL 11AIN UNUM1TED WWKND UNUMITED 622 02/06 11:33A 561 602-5720 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UN UTED N/WKO MIN 62.3 02/06 11:39A 561 317.3346 WPAUABEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 624 02/06 11.39A S61 602-5720 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 625 02/06 11:39A 561 669.7686 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN 626 02/06 11:51A INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 627 02635 11:56A INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 628 02/06 12:48P INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 629 02/06 12:50P 917 655-3363 NEW YORK 6A1 1 MIN UNLIMITED NNVKND MIN 630 02/06 12;521' 561 655-0995 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED NNVKND LAIN 631 02/06 01:01P 661 1 317-2143 WPALM BEACH FL IMIN UNLIMITED N/WIN D MIN 632 02106 01:021" 561 317-2143 WPALM BEACH F L 1MIN UNLIMITED NNVKND MIN VOICE USAGE FOR (561)308.0282 - Continued Number Only Charge Item Date Time Called 633 02106 01:0211 r 7. 6,1312143 Coils To WPALMBEACH FL Used Rate Description 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN Charge 634 02/06 01:171' 561 313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL 2MIN UNUMITED NIWKND MIN 635 02/06 0241P 917 655.3363 NEW YORK NY 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 656 02.116 Ot6IP - - • - - - - Il/COMING - -- 2 LIP: .. IIIP-9.9 TED WWIND-64/N 637 02106 02-.391' (561)502-9566 LAKE WORTH FL IMIN UN UNLIT ED NIWKND MIN 636 02106 02:531' INCOMING IMIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 639 02/06 03:02P INCOMING IMIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 640 02/06 03:031 (561)069-76116 WPALMBEACH FL MAIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 641 02/06 01:191 (561)6442611 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 642 02/0603:34P INCOMING 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 643 02/06 03:45P INCOMING 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 644 02/06 046111' 561 689-7666 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 645 02/06 04:171' 561 889.7686 WPALMBEACH FL 1611N UNUMITED NANKN 0 MIN 646 02/06 04:20P 561 313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN U NUMBED NANKN 0 MIN 647 07/06 04:22P 561 793-7719 WPAUMEACH FL 1 PAIN UNLIMITED NNI/KNO MIN 6413 02/06 04:221 561 793.7719 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NANKND MIN 6-49 021063 04:23P 561 899.7686 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN 650 02/176 04:24P 561 8139.7666 WPALMBEACH FL 4MIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN 651 02/06 04:301' 551 009-7566 WPALMBEACH FL 7IMIN UN UMIT ED NANKNO MIN 652 02/06 04:351" 561 793-7719 WPALMBEACH FL WIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 653 02106 04:40P 561 308.0262 WPALMBEACH FL IMIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 1 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 654 02/06 04:541' 561 999-7686 WPALMBEACH FL 10/11/ UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 655 02106 05:051' 561 313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 656 02/06 05:07P INCOMING IMIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 657 02/0605:06P INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 658 02106 05:34P INCOMING 4MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 659 02/05 06:11P (561)889-7696 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 660 02/06 06:131 (561)313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NANKNE1 MIN 661 02/05 06:141" INCOMING VAIN UNUMITED NIWKND MIN 662 02/06 06:22P INCOMING AMIN UNLIMITED N/WKND PAIN 463 02/06 07:341' (561)113.6730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 661 02/06 07:351' 561 313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NANKNO MIN 665 02/06 07:371' 561 313-6730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NIWKND MIN 666 02106 07:39P 561 723.7752 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 667 INCOMING 6MIN UNUMITED NAKIIND MIN 668 02/06 09•24P 561 307-2717 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 669 02106 09.271' 561 307-2717 WPALMBEACH FL MIN UNUMITED NIWKND MIN 670 . 0411 02136 0930P 56 543-9076 WPALMBEACH FL !MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 671 02/06 10•251 551 655-0995 WPALMBEACH FL ?MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 672 02/06 10:27P 561 619-7686 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 673 02/06 10:381' 561 889-7666 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 674 02/06 10:17P INCOMING 3MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 675 02/061108/' (561)859.7686 WPALMBEACH FL 1811N UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 676 02/06 11:101' INCOMING 2 MIN UNUMITED N1WKNO MIN 677 02/06 11:15P 1561)635-7454 WPALA1BEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NNIKNO MIN 678 02)06 11:19P INCOMING 2MIN UN UNITED WWKNO MIN 679 02/06 11:22P (560502.4726 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 650 02/01 12:381 INCOMING 4 MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 681 02/07 12:436 (561502.4726 WPAUABEACH FL 6MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 5E12 02/07 01:35A INCOMING 3MIN UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN 553 02/07 02:32A INCOMING IMIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MN 554 02107 02:47A INCOMING 3MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 685 02107 03:02A (561)502-4728 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MiN 696 02107 03:04A INCOMING 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 687 02/07 03:05A (561)798.3650 WPAUABEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN 686 02107 05:27A INCOMING 4MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 669 02/07 09:24A INCOMING 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 01B 690 02107 11:59A INCOMING IMIN 0.09 AI Rum E MINUTES 0 09 691 02/07 02:34P INCOMING IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 692 02/07 04:14P 561 333.9056 WPALMBEACH FL IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 693 02/07 04:15P 561 252.4753 WPAUABEACH FL 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0 18 694 02/07 04:191' 561 252.4753 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 027 69S 02/07 05:07P 561 635.3454 WPALMBEACH FL 12MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1 08 696 02107 07:07P 561 723.7752 WPALMBEACH FL 6MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.50 691 0207 07:47P INCOMING IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 07/26/17 Page 78 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Account Number 0035224228 Account Name HOLLY ROBSON acorn Date of Invoice February 12, 2005 AT&T Wireless Page 8 of 10 Number Item Date Time Called 633 02/06 01.02P 561317.2143 634 02/06 01:176' ( (561 1 13136730 635 02/06 02:016' 917855.3353 556 Gum OLDSP - • • • - 637 638 539 640 541 642 613 644 645 646 647 648 649 650 651 652 553 654 655 656 657 0210605:081 6513 02/06 05:34P 659 02/06 06* I I P (561)689-76E16 660 02/06 06:13P (561)313.6730 661 02/06 06:14P 662 02/06 06:22P I 663 02/06 07:346' 561 313.6730 661 02/06 07:356' 561 313.6730 665 02/06 07:37P 561 313.6730 666 02/06 07:396' 561 723.7752 667 02/06 09:04P 665 02/06 09:24P 561 307-2717 669 02/06 09;27P 561 307-2717 670 02/06 09:306' 561 543-9076 671 02/06 10:25P 561 655-0995 672 02/06 10:27P 561 1189.7686 673 02/06 10:381561 889.7666 674 02106 10.47P 675 02105 111)61 561)669 1686 676 02706 11:10P 677 02/06 11:15P (561 635.3454 678 02/06 11:19P 679 02636 11t22P (561)502.4726 660 02/07 12:38A 681 02107 12:4311 (561)502-4728 682 02107 01:35A 683 02107 02:32A 684 02/07 02:47A 685 02/07 03:02A (561)502.4728 686 02107 03:04A 667 02107 03:05A (561)798-3650 688 02/07 05:27A 689 02/07 09:28A 690 02/07 11-.59A 691 02/07 02:34P 692 02/07 04:14P 561 333-9056 693 02/07 04:15P 561 252-4753 694 02/07 (14:191 661 252.4753 69S 02/07 05:07P 561 635.3454 696 02/07 07:07P 561 723-7752 697 02/07 07.47P 02/06 02738P (551)602.9566 02/06 02:53P 02/06 03:0ZP 02/06 03:0W (561)889-7666 02/06 03:190 (561)644.2611 02/06 03:34P 02/06 03:45P 02106 04:0136' 561 4369-7656 02/06 04717P 561 88976136 02/06 04:20P 561 3{3.6730 02/05 04:22P 561 793.7719 02/06 04:22P 561 793-7719 02106 04:23P 561 689.7686 02/176 04:24P 561 889-7686 02106 04:30P 561 889-7686 02/06 047356' 561 793.7719 02/06 04:40P S61 308.0282 02/06 04.54P 561 869.7666 02./06 05:05P 561 313-6730 02/06 05:07P Xcingular WIR(ICTS DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED a C C a VOICE USAGE FOR (561)3080282 - Continued VOICE USAGE FOR (561)308.0282 - Continued Number Only Charge Item Date Time Called Calls To sed Rate Description Charge 571 02/04 11:10P INCOMING 4MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN I EVE CALL WAITING 41; 02/0412cnoi WPALMBEACH FL 11AIN UNLIMITED NNIKND MIN 573 .0Z/05 12:MA 561881;7686 WPALMBEACH FL' I MIN.... UNLIMITED 611WKNO MIN /561)676-2208 574 02/05 12-03A 561 596.4777 WPALMBEACH Ft. VAIN UNWIRED N/WKNO MIN 575 02105 12:07A 561 311.6730 LAKE WORTH Fl. 3MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 576 02/135 12:09A INCOMING 1 1 UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN ( M vT IN CALL WAITING, S77 02106 12:11A (56013.6730 LAKE WORTH FL ?MIN UN LIMITED N/WKNO MIN 571 02106 12:12A NCOMING 4MIN UN WAITED 10)31 100 MIN 1 EVT CALL WAITING 579 02105 12:32A NCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 580 02/05 12:42A NCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED WANK) MIN 581 02105 12:56A NCOMING 4MIN UNLIMIT ED WWKNO MIN 582 02/05 01:09/1 NCOMING 583 02/05 01:26A NCOMING 3 UNLIMITED 5110/KNO MIN 2 M NIIINN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN 584 02/05 03:35A N COMING VAIN UNLIMITED NPNKND MIN 585 02105 03:4611 NCOMING UNLIMITED NfINKNO MIN 556 02105 10:24A (561)3040282 587 02/05 10:30A r 61 588 02/06 01:3IP 5 5,18119.7686 644.2611 WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL 2 2 1 1 tf M NIWKND MIN I E VT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL A t ; I I N NN UNUMITED WAND MIN UN UNITED N/WKNO MIN 589 02105 01:15P 561 252.4753 WPALMBEACH FL 4MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 590 02/05 01:56P INCOMING IMI N UNUMITED NN/KND MIN WPALMBEACH FL UNUMITED NIWK ND MIN 591 02105 0210P 56116444611 592 02105 02724P 561 644-2611 WPALMBEACH FL ZIPAIIIINN UNLIMITED NANKND MA 593 02105 02:31P 561 644.2611 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MN 594 02105 02:41P INCOMING 110N UN UNITED N/WKNO MIN 595 02/05 03:051 INCOMING 5 MIN UNLIMIT ED N/WK ND MIN 596 02/05 03:20P (561)969-7686 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMIT ED NIWKNO MIN 597 02/05 03:2W 1561)0139-7666 WPALMBEACH FL 598 02/05 04:11P INCOMING 1 MIN 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN UNLIMITED NPA/KN 0 MIN 599 02/05 05:25P INCOMING 600 02/05 05730P INCOMING 211A MINN UNLIMITED NPAIKND MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 601 02/05 07:I7P INCOMING I OWN UNLIMITED NIWKNO RN 602 02105 08:17P INCOMING 603 02105 08:436' 56113139-7686 WPALMBEACH FL 2"MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 1 IN UNUMITEO WWICNO MIN 604 02/05 08745P LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NNYKNO MIN 605 02105 067466' 561 ) )602.6720 917855.3363 NEW YORK NY 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 606 02/05 09:13P INCOMING 607 02/05 09:18P 600 02/05 10.00P 561131394666 WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH Fl 3MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 1 MIN 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN 609 02/06 01:10A 561 ) )655-7626 561317-3348 WPAUABEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 610 07/06 11:10A INCOMING INN UNLIMIT ED N1M/KND MIN 611 02/06 11:11A 561 602.5720 LAKE WORTH FL 1PAIN UNLIMIT ED PINVKNO MIN 612 02/06 11:11A 561 3634810 WPALMBEACH FL 1 PAIN UNLIMIT ED NIWKNO PAIN 613 02/05 11:12A 561 502-5720 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 614 02/06 11:12A 561 3834810 WPALMBEACH FL I MIN UNLIMITED NPNKND MIN 615 02/06 11 ! 111* 616 02)06 11:15A 561 561 6024720 LAKE WORTH FL 602.5720 LAKE WORTH Fl. 1MIN 1MIN UNLIMITED 10)31100 MIN UNLIMITEO NIWKNO MIN 617 02/06 11:21A 561 317.3148 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 618 02/06 11:22A 619 02106 11726A 561 561 753.1604 WPALMBEACH FL 602.5720 LAKE WORTH FL SHIN I MIN UNLIMITED 101033(100 MIN UNUMITED NMAND MIN 620 02106 11:28A 561 1113.6810 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NA 10/3))100° MI N 621 02106 11:29A 622 02/06 11:31A 561 561 333.9056 WPALMBEACH FL 602.5720 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/W/IND MIN UNUMITED WWKNO PAIN 623 02106 11738A 561 317.3348 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NIWKND MIN 624 02/06 11:3871 561 602.5720 LAKE WORTH FL 1611N UNUMITED NNYKNO MIN 625 02/06 11:39A S61 869-7686 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN UNLIMITED HANKNO MIN 626 021136 11:51A INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMIT ED NIWKNO PAIN 627 02/06 11.56A INCOMING 1 1 UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 90 628 02/06 1246P INCOMING M AI I I N N UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN 0 629 02/06 12:50P 917 855-1163 NEW YORK NY 1 MIN UNLIMITED NPNKND MIN c 630 02/06 12:526' 561 655-0995 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN r. 631 02/06 01:01P 561 1 317-2143 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED WWKN 0 MIN i 632 02106 01:02P 561 317-2143 WPALMBEACH FL 'MIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN Only Charge Calls To Used Nate Description Charge WPALMBEACH FL 1111161 UNLIMITED WWK ND PAIN LAKE WORTH FL 2 MIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN NEW YORK NY 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN INCOMING - -- MO: DP P-9.11 ?SO NPNILN-D-1.4161 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN UN UNIT EC N/WKNO MIN INCOMING 1MIN UNLIMITED NNVKND MIN C. INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN C WPALMBEACH FL 31/11N UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN INCOMING 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN INCOMING 21AIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN WPALMBEACH FL 3 FAIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NIWKND MIN LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO 61114 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN WPALMBEACH FL WPAIAIBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED WWKNO 1 MIN UNUMIT T ED N/WKND MIN WPALMBEACH FL 4 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN WPALMBEACH FL 7 MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN UN UNIT ED NIWKND MIN WPALMBEACH FL !PAIN UNUMITEDN/WKNO MIN 1 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MN LAKE WORTH FL 2 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN INCOMING 11AIN UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN F INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMIT ED NIWKNO MIN I INCOMING 4MIN UNLIMITED NWKND MIN WPALAIBEACH Ft. 2 MI N UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN LAKE WORTH FL 161IN UNUMITED NIWKND MIN INCOMING INCOMING 2 MI N UNUMITED NNVKNO MIN 4MIN UNUMITED WINKND MIN C. LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NNVKNO MIN LAKE WORTH FL 1 PAIN UNLIMITED NPANNID MIN LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UN UNITED NMI( ND MIN WPALMBEACH FL 3611N UN UNIT ED NNVIC ND MIN INCOMING 6MIN UN UNITED N/WKND MIN WPALMBEACH FL !MIN UN LIMIT ED N/WK ND MIN WPALMBEACH FL UNUMITED N/WXND MIN WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN WPALMBEACH FL VAIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN WPALAIBE ACM FL 1MIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN INCOMING 3MIN UNLIMITED NnNKNO MIN WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN INCOMING 2 MIN UNUMITED NIWKNO MIN WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN 'AWAITED NANKND MIN INCOMING 2 MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN INCOMING 4MIN UNUMITED NM/KM° MIN WPALMBEACH Ft. 6MIN UN LIMIT ED WWXND MIN INCOMING 3MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN INCOMING IMIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN INCOMING 3MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN WPALMBEACH FL MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN INCOMING PAIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN WPALMBEACH FL 2 MIN UNLIMITED NNVKND MIN INCOMING 4MIN UNLIMITED NNYKNO MIN INCOMING 2 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 INCOMING 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 INCOMING 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 WPALMBEACH FL I MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN 0.09 NRTIME MINUTES 0.27 WPALMBEACH FL I2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1.08 WPALMBEACH FL SHIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.54 INCOMING 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 07/26/17 Page 79 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

.••••11• mEEMEL Account Name HOLLY ROBSON Account Number 0035224228 AT giT Wireless Xcingular Date of Invoice1 February 12. 2005 Page 9 of 10 DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED VOICE USAGE FOR (561) 308-0282 - Continued Number Only Rem Date Time Called Calls To Used Rale Charge Description Charge 698 02107 08:14P INCOMING 1M1 AI 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 699 02107 00:15P INCOMING MAIN 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.36 -700 02/07-021:29P _ . . . . .._ . 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 701 02109 11!54A (561)753-1604 IrP2MIIIPEACH L LIVI E • 1•MIN • 0.09A1RTIME WNW ES • 702 02/08 11:54A (561)7234752 WPALMBEACH Ft 2MIN 0.09 AIRTVAE MINUTES 0.18 703 02)08 01:29P INCOMING ANN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.36 704 02/08 06:37P INCOMING 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 705 02108 0540P (561)753.1604 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 706 02108 07:00P INCOMING IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 707 02108 08:49P (561)317-3348 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 703 02108 0555P INCOMING MAIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 709 02/0609:53P INCOMING 1/AIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 710 02/06 10101' 561 313-6730 LAKE WORTH Fl. 1 MIN UNUMIT ED N/WKND 1AIN 711 02/08 10:17P 561 3134730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 712 02108 10:44P Sal 3134730 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED WWKND NON 713 02/179 1945P 561 353-6730 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 714 02109 05:45P INCOMING 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 715 02109 054013 INCOMING 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 716 02109 06:57P INCOMING 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 717 02109 07:0214 INCOMING 1 MIN 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 1)09 718 02109 07:10P INCOMING 1SAIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 11.09 719 02309 07:21P (561)543.3E102 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.16 720 02109 09:12P INCOMING 1MIN UNUMITED NAMKNO MIN 721 02109 0910P INCOMING 2 MIN UNLIMITED NNVKNI3 MIN 722 02/09 0917P INCOMING I MIN UN UNITED N/WKND MIN 723 02/0909:31P INCOMING 2 MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 724 02109 09!33P 561 602-9566 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND FAIN 725 02109 0934P 561 607-5770 LAKE WORTH FL 1FAIN UNLIMITED N/WKND FAIN 726 02109 0915P 561 502-4728 WPALMBEACH FL 11AIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 727 faros 09:37P 561 602-5720 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 726 02104 09:37P 561 793-7719 WPAUABEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED NIVAKND MIN 729 02109 0916P 561 313-6730 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 730 02/09 09:39P 561 723.7752 WPALMBEACH Ft. 2 MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 731 02/09 09:43P INCOMING 5MIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN 732 02/09 09:491' 561 602.5720 LANE WORTH EL 1MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 733 02/09 09:5011 561 317-3348 WPALMBEACH FL MAIN UNLIMITED NIWXNO MIN 734 07/09 09:59P 561 602.5720 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 735 02109 1014P 561 602-5720 LAKE WORTH FL 11AIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 716 02/09 1017P 561 602-5720 LAKE WORTH Ft. 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 737 02108 10:16P 561 387-6810 WPALAIBEACH FL 1MIN UNUMITED NAA/KNO MIN 738 02109 10:19P 561 635-3454 WPALMBEACH FL 161IN UNLIMITED IIANKND MIN 739 02109 1020P INCOMING 2MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 740 02/0910:21P INCOMING 7MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 741 02109 10:29P (561)602.5720 LAKE WORTH FL 1M1N UNLIMITFO WWKND MIN 742 02/09 10:32P INCOMING 4 MIN UNLIMITED NMIKAID MIN 743 02/09 10:38P INCOMING 22MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 744 02/10 01:52P (561)644.2611 WPALMBEACH FL ?MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 745 02/10 02_33P (561)333.9056 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 746 02/10 03:5411 INCOMING 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 747 02/10 05:50P 561 796-3650 WPALN BEACH FL I MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 748 02/10 06:10P WPALA1BEACH EL 2 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 749 02110 06:42P561313.6130 (( (561 1 1 )753.1936 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 750 02/10 0701P561602.5720 LAKE WORTH FL 1/AIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 751 02/10 07:02P INCOMING I MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 752 02110 07:39P INCOMING 0 09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.72 753 02/10 07:56P 561)644.2611 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 754 02/10 116041' INCOMING 3 AUN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 755 02/10 041:12P (561)723-7752 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 756 02/10 09051' (66616259606 CUSTOMER CAR 1MiN SPECIAL NUMBER CALLS TOTAL VOICE USAGE FOR (561)30 9.0262 51.57 DATA USAGE FOR 1561)308-0282 hem Date Only Used Charge Description Charge 1 01/14 82 KB MA100E/DATA USAGE 11 8) TOTAL DATA USAGE FOR (561)308.0282 0.112 TEXTIMULTIMED4A MSGS FOR-(51)3Q9 0282 • • • _ Item Dale Time Sen TolRcvd From Charge Description Charge 101116 03:45P 561 5964777 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 2 01116 03:4W 561 96.4777 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 3 01/16 03:50P 561 5964777 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 4 01/16 03.56P 561 596.4777 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 5 01116 03:58P 561 596.4777 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 601)17 01:30A 561 596.1777 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 7 01/17 01:33A 561 596-4777 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 8 01717 01:36A 561 596.4/77 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 9 0t/17 01:37A 561 5964777 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 10 01120 07:10P $61 317.3148 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 1101120 07:12D $51 317.3348 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 12 011213 07:59P 561 117-3349 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 13 01/20 14 01120 06011, 06.0814 581 561 317.3348 317-3348 TEXT MESSAGES SENT TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 0.10 1501720 0611P 561 317-3348 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 16 02/04 06:37P 561 876.2208 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 17 02/06 12.37P 561 076.2209 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 la 02106 12:391' 561 596-4777 TEXT MESSAGES SENT O 10 TOTAL TEXTIMULTIMEDIA MSG USAGE FOR (561)308-0282 1.110 . 07/26/17 Page 80 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Date Applied/Reversed 03/18/05 Payment Amount -66.54 Charge -fifi 54 -66.54 cingular bar Account Number 0035224228 Account Name HOLLY ROBSON Date of Invoice April 12. 2005 Page 3 of 8 IMPORTANT INFORMATION FOR OUR SPANISH-SPEAKING CUSTOMERS: DESEA RECIBIR SU CUENTA EN ESPANOL? LLAMA AL 611 Y MARQUE EL 2 PARA HABLAR CON UNA OPERADORA EN ESPANOL. TRANSLATION: "WOULD YOU LIKE TO RECEIVE YOUR BILL IN SPANISH? DIAL 511 AND PRESS 2.TO SPEAK WITH-A CUSTOMER - CARE REPRESENTATIVE IN SPANISH." ACCOUNT DETAILS Detail of Payments - Thank You! Item Description 1 PAYMENT Total of Payments Detail of Account Government Fees and Taxes Item Description 1 FEDERAL TAX 2 LOCAL COMM SERVICE TAX 3 STATE COMM SERVICE TAX 4 'UNIVERSAL CONNECTIVITY CHARGE 5 911 SURCHARGE Total Account Government Fees and Taxes 12.26 ' This is nor a tat or government required charge, it is, a lee assessed on telecommunications carriers. Current Subscriber Monthly Charges and Credits Subscriber Number Subscriber Name Charge 5613080282 HOLLY ROBSON 54 55 Total Current Subscriber Monthly Charges and Credits 54.56 Total Current Monthly Charges 66.82 SUMMARY OF CURRENT ACTIVITY FOP (561)308.0282 Monthly Service Charges Item Description 1 CALL WAITING Service Dates 03/12/05. 04/11/05 Charge 0.00 2 CALLER ID 03/12/05 - 04/11/05 0.00 3 GO PHONE 353.98 REPLENISHMENT 03/12/05 • 04/11/05 0.00 4 THREE WAY CALLING 01/12/05 • 04/11/05 0.00 SUMMARY OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED Monthly Service Charges - Continued Item Description Service Dates Charge 5 GO PHONE UNLIMITED NIGHTS AND WEEKENDS 03/12/05 • 04/11/05 0.00 6 DETAIL BILLING 03/12/05 - 04111/05 0 00 Total Monthly Service Charges 0.00 . . _ _ • Monthly Usage Charges Item Description Qnty Used Charge 1 UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 851 MIN 0.00 2 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 27 EVT 0.00 3 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 15 EVT 1.50 4 AIRTIME MINUTES 596 MIN 52.74 5 CALL WAITING 12 EVT 0.00 5 MMODEADATA USAGE 32 KB n TT Total Monthly Usage Charges 54.56 F1-.024 Kilobytes (KB) = 1 Megabyte (MB) TOTAL CHARGES FOR (561)308-0282 54.56 DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY VOICE USAGE FOR (561 )308-0282 Number Qnty Charge Item Date Time Called Calls To Used Rate Description Charge 1 03119 11:46A (561)308.02132 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UN UMITED NNVKND MIN MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 03119 11:47A (561)3080282 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN DROP CALL CREDIT I EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 3 03/19 11:50A INCOMING 2MIN UN UNIT EC NNI/KNO MIN 4 03/19 03 00P (561)313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL IMIN UNLIMITED NM/KND MIN S 03119 03.06P (551)3174318 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 6 03119 03.12P INCOMING 3MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 7 03119 03.30P 561 7313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 8 03119 03.31P 561)1937719 WPALMBEACH Ft. 1 MIN UNIIMITED NANKND MIN WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 9 03119 03. 32P 561 ) )6142611 10 03/19 09 53P 561308.0282 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN 1 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 11 03119 09:54P (561)30842132 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN 1 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 12 03119 09.59P INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN 13 03119 10135P 561 313 6730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED NNVKNO MIN 14 03/19 1006P 154 2354823 POMPANOBCH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED NNVKN 0 MIN 15 03/19 10.15P 561 635.3454 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 16 03/19 1019P 561 317.3348 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN UNUMITED WWI( NO MIN 17 03/18 11:50P 561 452.8865 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED NNVKNO MIN 11 03/19 11:51P 561 23-8559 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNUMITED NANK NO MIN 19 03/20 01.10A INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 20 03/20 03:58A 561 452.8865 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NANKNO MIN 21 03/20 03:58A 561 152.8865 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO NON 22 03/20 04:01A 561 1520E165 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNUMITED NANKNO MIN 23 03/20 04:02A 561 452.8865 WPALMBEACH FL IrviN UNUMITED NANKNO MIN 24 03720 04:03A 561 723-8559 WPALMBEACH FL 2 NON UNUMITED NAA/KNO MIN 25 03/20 04-0111 26 03/20 04:08A 27 03/20 04:10A 561 561 561 152.8865 WPALMBEACH FL I MIN UNMATED NNVKNO MIN 152-8865 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN 452431365 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NIWKND MIN 4:1 8 26 0320 04:15A 561 152-8865 WPALMBEACH FL I MIN UNLIMITED N,WKNO MIN 29 03/20 0.4:19.4 561 452.8865 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED XANKND MIN 30 03/20 04:41A 561 452-8065 WPALMBEACH FL 1NON UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN Charge 1.7D 3.27 5.13 1 66 0.50 07/26/17 Page 81 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

561 313-6730. 561 793-7719 561 152-13865 561 308-0262 615-3454 718-3650 6354451 317-3348 723-7752 644.2611 723-7752 346-1086 313-6730 61r35-3154 61 333-9056 61 4524865 12 414-0021 561 561 5 61 61 5 61 61 561 61 561 cingular rtiar the bar Account Number 0035224228 Account Name HOLLY ROBSON Date of invoice April 12. 2005 Page 4 of 8 DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED VOICE USAGE FOR (561)3080282 • Continued Charge VOICE USAGE FOR (561)308-0282 - Continued Number Item Dale Time Called 0.45 0 09 0.63 0 45 0.18 0.09 0.54 081 0 00 Number Kern Date Time Called 31 03120 12:20P 32 03120 12:18P 33 03120 01.26P ----1401120 01:1P 35 03/20 02:35P 36 03120 02:36P 37 03120 01 10P 38 03/20 0320? 39 0312003:41? 40 03120 05:25P 41 01120 0S:26P 42 03120 05:27P 43 03/2005:30P 44 03120 05:31P 45 01120 05:32P 46 03/20 05:34P 47 03/20 05:36P 48 03120 05:47P 49 03/20 05:52P SO 01/20 05:53P 51 03/20 05:56P 52 03/20 05.57P 53 03/20 06:19P 54 03/20 06:59P SS 03120 07:45P 561 56 03/20 07:46? 561 57 031200750? 561 50 03/20 07:55P 561 59 03120 08:49P 561 60 03120 08:58P 61 03/20 09:02P 62 01120 09711P 561 723-8559 63 03/20 0912P 561 635-1454 64 012009:13P 65 03/2009:14P 66 03/20 094313 5611313-6730 67 03120 01114P 561 3116730 58 03/20 10:16P 561 313-6730 69 0312010.47P 72 03/20 10:53P 561 313-6730 70 01/20 10 SOP 5611313-6730 71 03120 10:53D 661 313.6730 73 03/20 11:01P 74 03120 11:10P (561)635-3454 75 01/20 11:14P 76 03/21 12:33A 77 01/21 03:013A 561)3134730 76 01121 03:14A 19 03/21 03:29A (561)313.6730 LO 03/21 03:30A 81 03/21 03.37A 82 03/21 04:34A 561 313-6730 I 83 03121 05:11A 561 3134730 84 03121 05:15A 561 3134730 85 0321 05:23A 561 3134730 86 03121 05:25A 561 313-6730 87 01/21 05:42A 661 313-6730 68 03/21 10:34A 69 03/21 12:09P 90 03121 12:13? 91 03/21 01:08P 92 03/21 01:54P 1561)795.9549 91 07/21 02:04? 561)313.6730 94 03/21 02:05P 95 03121 02:06P Calls To INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING INCC4.004S.. • LAKE WORTH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH Fl. WPALMBEACH Ft WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH Ft. LAKE WORTH FL INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL NEW YORK NY INCOMING INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPAI.M8EACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPAUA BEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING INCOMING LAKE WORTH FL LAKE WORTH FL LAKE WORTH FL INCOMING LAKE WORTH FL LAKE WORTH FL LAKE WORTH FL INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING INCOMING LAKE WORTH FL INCOMING LAKE WORTH FL INCOMING INCOMING LAKE WORTH FL LAKE WORTH FL LAKE WORTH FL LAKE WORTH FL LAKE WORTH FL LAKE WORTH FL INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL LAKE WORTH FL INCOMING INCOMING Only Charge Used Rale Description M UNLIMITED NANKND MIN 2M I N 2N UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 2MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN I APA1.. UN UNITED IPM2C849 NR! I MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND min 1MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND IAN UNLIMITED NANKN 0 MIN 91 MM I IINN N UN UNITED NANKND MN 1 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 Y UNUMITEO N/WKND MIN 1 1 ,0 51 11 UNLIMITED NIVI/KNO MIN UNUMITED NVWKND MIN 3 MIN 1 MIN UNUMITED 14/WKNO MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN ZINN UNUMITED NANKND MIN IN UNUMITED NNVK ND MIN 2MIN MINM UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 10MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 2MIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN M UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 213AIIN N UNLMITED NM/MD MIN 1 111N IMIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKN 0 MIN 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN 1MIN U NUMIT ED N/WKN 0 MIN 3 MIN UNUMITED WWKNO MIN 3MIIN UM/6117EO NIWKNO MIN SHIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN 3 IAIN UNUMITED NANKND MIN 2MIN UNUMITED NIWKNO MIN 3MIN M UNLIMITED N/WI(M3 MIN 1 IN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN I MIN UNLIMITED NNVKND MIN 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN 2 i, m pA MI NN N UNLIMITED NI MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 1PAIN 1 MIN UN LIMITED NANKND MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN 2MIN 1 MIN UN UMI T EC NANKN El MIN UN UMI T ED NIWKNO MIN 1 NUN UN UMIT ED NIWKND MIN 1 MIN UNUMITED NIWKN 0 MIN 1141N UNUMITED NIWKNO MIN 1 1411 1 MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 1MIN UNUMITED NANKNO MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 2MIN UNUMITED NIWKNO MIN 1611 N 11 UNUMITED N1WKNO MIN 5,4 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN Zi MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN IMIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 1MIN IMIN UNLIMITED N/WICNO MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKND N/WKNDMIN 15MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 5MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES I MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES ?MIN 0.09 MRTME MINUTES MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2MIN 0.09 A RTIME MINUTES I MIN 0 09 A RTIME MINUTES MIN 009 A RTIME MINUTES 9 MIN 0.09 A RTIME MINUTES 96 03/21 OZ-.15P (561)3060212 - °I 07:21-0146P-155I.25 1.154 • 96 03/21 02-32P 561 793-1719 99 0121 02:32P 561 313-6730 100 01/21 02:33P 568 791-7719 101 01121 03:58P 102 03121 05:42P 56113171149 103 03121 06:19P 104 03121 06:31? (561)6311154 105 03/21 06:34P 106 03121 06:51P 107 01121 0724P 108 0121 07 .29P 561 333-0100 109 03/21 07:30P 561 252.4153 110 03/21 07:36P 561 252-1753 111 03121 07:18P 561 313-6/30 112 03121 07:55P 1143 00E21 OMP:033A 3P (561)602-9566 115 0322 10:19* 561793-7719 116 03/27 10:20A 561 317-3319 117 03/22 10:22A 561 3830810 118 01/22 1021A 119 03/22 10:25A 120 01122 11:20A 121 03/22 11:42A 122 03/22 11:51/1 (561)2624166 123 03/22 12:21P (661)333 OM 124 03/22 12:26P 125 01/22 12:27P (561)602-9566 126 03/22 01:08P 127 03/22 01:22P 128 03/22 01:35P 129 03122 03:08P 130 03/22 032211 131 03/22 0931P 132 0322 09 MP 561 793.7719 113 03/22 09-36P 561 333-0160 111 03/22 09:36P 561 635.3451 135 03122 09:39P 561 317.3348 1 136 03/22 09:17P 137 0312209:41? (561)333-0180 139 03/22 09:47P (561)262.6186 139 0322 09:50P 140 03172 09:63? III 03/22 10•113P 142 03/2211,05? (561)635.3454 143 03122 11:42? (561)635-3154 114 03/23 02:63A 145 03/23 10.05A ror52.11665 146 03/23 10:38A 561 452-8065 147 03/23 12:35P 561 723-7752 148 0312312.47P 119 03/2312:58P (561)317-3348 150 03123 05:03 P 151 03123 05:07? (561)635.3454 152 03123 05:11P 153 03123 05:13P 561 791-8430 151 03123 06:22? 561 317.3346 165 03/23 06:33P 561 7917719 156 03/23 0e.13P 5613452.8865 157 03123 06,52P 561308.0282 158 0323 05•51P 581)793-7719 793-7719 345.1086 317.3348 635.3154 193-7719 iEvr WPALMBEACH Fl. 1/AIN I EN? WPAAMICIEM:NFL -2:NN- WPALM BE ACH FL 1MIN LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN WPALMBEACH FL 7 MIN INCOMING 4MIN WPALMBEACH FL 21MIN INCOMING 1 MIN WPALMBEACH FL WIN INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL LAKE WORTH FL INCOMING LAKE WORTH FL INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING JUPITER FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING LAKE WORTH FL INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL JUPITER FL INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING WPAIAIBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING WPALM BEACH Fl. INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALM BEACH FL WPALM BEACH FL Only Calls To Used WPALMBEACH FL Charge Rate Description Charge CALL WAITING 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 0.03 AIRTIME•MINUW_k- - 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 AMINE MINUTES 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0,09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 6MIN 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES HAN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1MIN 0,09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES IMIN 0.09 AIREIME MINUTES MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES IMIN 0.139 AIRTIME MINUTES t MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 264/11 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 950N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES I3MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES I MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 6MIN 009 AIRTIME MINUTES IMIN r4 MIINN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1 UNLIMITED NIWYND YIN 114 MIN 111/ UNLIMITED NIWKND UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN IMIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN 3 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 2MIN I UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 154N 21 MIN N UNLIMITED NIWKND PAIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO PAIN M1 11 UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN A UNLIMITED NANKND 316MIIINN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 7MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES SMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 211111 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 3Mltl 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 4MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1611N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 11AIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 4MIN 0.09 NRTIME MINUTES INUTES AI IMIN 0.09 RTIME M 19MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1 PAIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1MlIl 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 0.15 0.09 0.09 0.63 0.36 0.18 0.09 0.27 0.54 0 09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.19 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.0s 0.T8 009 0.27 0 as 0.16 0.09 0.18 0.81 1.17 0.09 0.54 0.18 0.09 0.63 0.45 0.18 0.27 0.36 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.36 0.09 1.71 0.09 111111111111111111111111 111111111111111111111111 07/26/17 Page 82 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

cingular r.•,-;1;7a bar Account Number 0035224228 Account Name HMV ROBSON Date of Invoice April 12, 2005 Page 5 of 8 DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED VOICE USAGE FOR (561)308.0282 - Continued Number Only Charge Item Date Time Called Calls To Used Rate Description Charge 159 03123 06:54P 561 313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 160 03/23 0 6 559 561 313-6730 LAKE WORTH FL 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 161 01/23 08.37P 561 313-6730 LAKE WORTH FL IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 152.47122.04:039 INCOMING - 3/-EN - . UPIUMITEDIONKNO MN 163 03/23 09:069 (581)317-3348 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MN 164 03123 09.059 INCOMING 10 MIN UNLIMITED NN/KNO MIN EVT CALL 1 G 165 03123 09.16P (561)635.3454 WPALMBEACH FL IMIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN 166 03/23 09-26P (561)635-3454 WPALMBEACH FL I MIN UNLIMITEDNANKND IN 167 03/23 0930P INCOMING 16MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 161 03/73 09.469 (561)313-6730 LAKE WORTH FL IMIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN 169 03/23 09:46P (561)31343730 LAKE WORTH FL HAIN UN UNITED N/WK ND MN 170 03123 10:44P INCOMING IMIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MN 171 03/24 10:33A INCOMING IVAN 0.69 AIRTIME MINUTES 162 172 03/24 01:56P 561 317-3348 WPAUABEACH FL MAIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1.71 173 03124 02:15P 561 602-9566 LAKE WORTH FL 7MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 063 LAKE WORTH FL IMIN O.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 174 03124 02-359 ((561))313.6730 175 03124 02 379561644-2611 WPAUABEACH FL. IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 176 03/24 02 429 INCOMING 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 177 03/24 09549 561)3060782 WPAUABEACH FL ',MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 1 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL. 170 03124 09:569 LAKE WORTH EL I MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MN 179 03124 09:569 551 15611313-6730 317.3346 WPALM8EACH FL I MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MN 160 03174 10:00P 561 718-5794 WPALMBEACH FL 1 FAIN UNLIMITED WWKND MN 161 03124 10:049 INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 182 03124 10.069 INCOMING 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MN 103 03/21 10:09P (561)313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 184 03/24 10:139 INCOMING 2MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MN 185 03/24 10.159 INCOMING IMIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 106 03124 10:17P INCOMING WIN UNUMITED WWKND MN 187 03124 10429 (551)313-6730 LAKE WORTH FL UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN 188 03/24 11.119 (561)313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL IMIN I UN UNITED NANKND MIN 189 03124 11.459 INCOMING ;MIN UNUMITED NANKNO MN 190 03/25 12.03* (561)313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL IMIN UNUMITED NfVVKND MN 191 03/25 02-59A INCOMING 4MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MN 192 03123 02.37-9 (581)702-9357 DELRAY BCH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MN 193 03/25 02:38A (561)702.9357 DELRAY BCH Ft. IMIN UNUMITED NIWKND MN 194 03/25 02:45A INCOMING 7MIN UNUMITED NANKND MN 195 03/25 02:50A INCOMING I MIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN IEVT CALL WAITING 196 03/25 02.51A INCOMING 2MIN UNLIMITED NJWKNO MIN I EVT CALL WAITING 197 03/25 02:54A 551452-8865 WPAUABEACH FL 6MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 118 03/25 0303A 561 635.3454 WPALMBEACH FL 6 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MN 199 03/25 03:17A ((561)300-0282 WPALM8EACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN IEVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 200 03125 16.5811 (561)602-1566 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN 0.09 AIR TIME MINUTES 0.09 201 03/25 10 59A (561)543.9076 WPALMBEACH FL IMIN 0_09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 202 03/25 11.01A INCOMING 38MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 3.42 203 03/25 11:4IA INCOMING 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 /01 03/25 11:41A (561)670-6821 WPAEMBEACH FL I MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 205 01/25 11:44/4 (561)702-9357 DELRAY BCH FL IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 206 03175 11:52A INCOMING IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 207 03125 12069 INCOMING 3MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 205 03/25 12-4279 INCOMING 3MIN 0.09 AJRTIME MINUTES 0.27 1 EVT CALL WAITING 670-6128 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 210 03/25 12:279 561 635-3454 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 211 03/25 01:159 561 670-6875 WPALMBEACH FL 25401 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 212 03125 01:42P 561 713-7979 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 009 213 03/25 02239 561 723-7752 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 214 03/25 07,269 452-8165 WPALMBEACH FL 3MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 027 215 03125 07,4612 561 3136730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 216 03/25 OL489 561 723.7752 WPALM8EACH FL IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 217 0125 07489 561 723 7752 WPALM8EACH FL 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 218 03/25 0252P 561 670-6828 WPALMBEACH FL 4MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.36 DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED VOICE USAGE FOR (561)308.0282 - Continued Number Only Item Oate Time Called Calls To Used Rate Charge Description Charge 219 03/25 03 019 561 333-0180 WPAUABEACH FL 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 i WPALMBEACH FL 160N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 220 03/75 03-057 561 )) ]3330150 221 03/25 03-069 56?798-7979 222 03125.93.6/P .350 327.e120 - WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH Fd 2 MN 7 PAIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.99-A34TIME MINUTE8- 00.09 .18 - 0.13 223 03125 03:139 INCOMING 2 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.16 224 03/25 03-229 (561)670-6828 WPALMBEACH FL 2 MN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 225 03125 03:379 15.1798•3650 INCOMING 2 MIN 0.09 /URTIME MINUTES 0.18 226 03125 03:519 WPALM8EACH FL 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 227 03/25 03:529 561 635.3454 WPALMBEACH Fl 2 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.113 228 03125 03:539 561 670.6E128 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 229 03/25 03: SIP INCOMING 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 230 03/25 04:609 (581)635.3454 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 231 03/25 04-019 (561)262.61136 JUPITER FL 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 232 03/25 04:039 INCOMING 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 233 03/25 04079 INCOMING 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 234 03/25 05.029 56$ 452-8865 WPAUABEACH Fl. 2 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 235 03/25 05:529 WPALMBEACH FL 2 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.16 236 03/25 06:029561452.8865 ((561))317-3348 WPAUABEACH FL 2 MIN 0.00 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 23/ 03/25 06:049 INCOMING 3 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 238 03125 06:12P (561)155-5247 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 239 03/25 093.69 INCOMING 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0 09 240 03125 09:089 561 951.1267 WPAUABEACH Ft 1 MIN UNUMITED ILANKND MIN 241 03/25 09:069 561 951.1287 WPAUABEACH FL 1 PAIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 242 03125 09:099 561 543.9076 WPALMBEACH FL 11494 UNUMITED NIWKNI) MIN 243 03/25 09:109 561 635.3454 WPALMBEACH FL 2 MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 241 03125 09:549 561 452.8865 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN 245 03/25 09:579 INCOMING 2 MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 246 03125 10:197 INCOMING 2MIN UNUMITED WWKNO MIN 241 03/25 11:029 561 317.3348 WPALMBEACH FL 1 AIN UN UMI T ED NANKND MIN 248 03125 11:037 561 773.7752 WPALMBEACH FL 4MIN UNLIMITED NNVKND MIN 249 03/25 11:039 INCOMING 2 MIN lEVT UNUMITED WWKND MIN CALL WAITING 250 03125 11:069 (561)313.5730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 251 03125 11:139 INCOMING 2MIN UNUMITED WINKNO KUN 252 03125 11:219 WPAUABEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NNVKND MIN 253 03125 11:299 561 6353454 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NNIKND MIN 254 03126 12:04A 561 3136730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 255 03126 12:49A 561 313-5730 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN UNUMITED tlfWaND MIN 255 03/26 01:1511 561 18.5794 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNUMITED NANKND MIN 257 03126 01:25A 561 317.3348 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 258 03126 01:40A 561 317.3348 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NNVKND MIN 259 03126 01:50A 561 05.0262 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 260 03126 0112A (5613793.9291 WPALMBEACH Ft UNUMITED N/WEND MIN 261 03126 0250A INCOMING 1 MIN UNUMITED N/WEND NUN 262 03/26 02:527 561 793.9291 WPALMBEACH FL 44MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 263 03/26 02:599 561 452.8865 WPAUABEACH FL 16MIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN 264 03126 03:16P 561 635.3454 WPALMBEACH FL 2 MIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN 265 03/26 03199 561 313.5730 LAKE WORTH FL PAIN UNUMITED WWKND teIN 266 03/26 03:287 561 317-3348 WPALMBEACH FL 4MIN UNUMITED WWKNO MIN 267 03/25 03:317 561 723.7757 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NfWKND MIN 268 03126 03:S5P INCOMING SMIN UNUMITED NIWKNO MIN 269 03/26 041119 561 615.3454 WPAUABEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 270 03/26 06:439 561 204.2738 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN 271 03/26 09:349 561 635.3454 WPALMBEACH FL 6 MIN UNUMITED WINK NO MIN 272 03/26 09:409 786 473.3267 MIAMI Ft. 1 MIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN 273 03/26 09.419 561 721.7752 WPALMBEACH FL 1 PAIN UNUMITED NM( NO MIN 274 03/26 09:429 561 452.8865 WPALMBEACH Ft. 16MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 275 03/26 10:019 INCOMING 1 MIN UNUMITEO WWKND MIN 276 03/26 11:419 561 601.6113 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN UNUMITEO NANKND MIN 277 03/2511:439 561 452.8865 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NANKND MIN 278 03/26 11:47P 561 723.8559 WPALMBEACH FL 7MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 279 03/27 12:59A INCOMING 1 MI N UNUMITED MINK MD MIN 280 03/27 01:50A 561 601.6113 LAKE WORTH FL 1 PAIN UNUMITED NIWKND MIN 281 03177 01:54A 561 601.6113 LAKE WORTH FL 1 PAIN UNUMITED NNW( NO MIN 282 0127 01:57A 561 601.6113 LAKE WORTH FL 3MIN UNLIMITED NNVIIND MIN 07/26/17 Page 83 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

917 655.3363 561 7234559 561 7234559 (917 855.3363 (561 635-3451 1 917 855-3363 954 687-3791 954 687-3797 561 262.6116 cingujarthet,„ Account Number 0035224228 Account Name HOLLY ROBSON Date of Invoice April 12, 2005 Page 6 of DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED VOICE USAGE FOR (561)308-0282 • Continued DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED VOICE USAGE FOR (561)308-0282 - Continued ... Calls To WPALMBEACH FL LAKE WORTH FL JUPITER FL WPM.MeEAGH FL INCOMING LAKE WORTH FL WPALMBEACH FL IN COMIN G WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING FRAUDEROL FL INCOMING INCOMING FTLAUDEROL FL FTLAUDERDL FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL ORLANDO FL INCOMING ORLANDO FL ORLANDO FL ORLANDO FL ORLANDO FL ORLANDO FL ORLANDO FL FTLAUDERDL FL INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPAUABEACH Ft. WPAUABEACI4 FL WPALMBEACH FL WPAUABEACH FL NEW YORK NY WPAUAREACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING NEW YORK NY WPAUABEACH FL INCOMING NEW YORK NY FTLAUDERDL F L FTLAUDERDLFL JUPITER FL INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING INCOMING 400 03/30 10:57P (561)306-0282 WPALMBEACH FL Number Qnty Charge Item Dale Time Called Calls To Used Rale Description Charge 283 03/V 02:05A (561)601-6111 LAKE WORTH Ft. 2MIN UN LIMIT ED N/WKNO MN 2E14 03127 02:12A (561)601410 LAKE WORTH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 285 03/27 02:18A INCOMING IMIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN - .288 13312102:35*......... .. . !MCCRAW; . 55 MIN - UNUMITEON/WKMD INM 267 03127 03:31A 561 313-6710 LAKE WORTH FL 141151 UNLIMITED NIWKND miN 286 03127 03:31A 561 311-6710 LAKE WORTH FL 'WIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 289 0327 03:31A 561 262-6116 JUPITER FL 11AN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 790 0127 03:32A 561 3134730 LAKE WORTH FL I MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 291 03/27 11:35A 561 701-0282 WPALMBEACH FL VAIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 1 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 292 03127 11:36A 561 6014113 LAKE WORTH FL IMIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN 293 03/27 II:37A 561 3134730 LAKE WORTH FL 4 MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 294 03/27 11:4211 561 3134730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 PAIN DROP CALL CREDIT 296 (33.21 11:43A 561 3134710 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NfWKND MIN 296 03127 11:43A 561 2624186 JUPITER FL IMIN UNUMITED NANKND MIN 297 03127 11:44A 561 123.7752 WPALMBEACH FL MAIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN 296 03127 04:011P 561 6354451 WPM0.113EACH FL MAIN UNLIMITED NfWKND MIN 299 03127 04:22P INCOMING SIAN UNUMITED NNVKND MIN 300 03127 04:43P 561 3134730 LAKE WORTH FL VAIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 301 01127 04:49P 561 3134730 LAKE WORTH FL IMIN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN 302 03127 07:35P 561 641.2611 WPALMBEACH FL I MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 303 03/27 07:37P 561 313.4730 LAKE WORTH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 304 03127 07:39P INCOMING JINN UNLIMITED !WAND MIN 305 03127 09:32P 561 6414611 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNUMITED NAP/KN 0 MIN 306 03127 10.06P 561 641.2611 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNUMITED 141WKN 0 MIN 307 03127 10:11P 716 622.3921 TONAWANDA NY 1MIN UNLIMITED WWKN (3 MIN 306 03127 10:12P 716 622-3921 TONAWANDA NY 1 MIN UNLIMITED WWKN 0 MIN 309 03/27 10:16? INCOMING PAIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN 310 03127 10:19? 561 644.2611 WPMAIBEACI1 FL IMIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 311 03123 10:25P 561 635-3451 WPALMBEACH FL 2 MAIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 312 03127 10:53P INCOMING MIN UNLIMITED ILWKNO MIN 313 03/27 10:56P 561)644.2611 WPALMBEACH FL IMIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 314 03127 11:07P INCOMING MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 315 03127 11:26P INCOMING PAIN UNUMITED NANKNOMIN 316 03127 II:26P INCOMING MIN UNUMITED NANKND MIN 317 03127 11:39? WPAUABEACH F L MIN UNUMITED NNVKND MIN 318 03/27 11:40? 561 561.44.2.11 6444611 WPALMBEACH Ft. MIN UNUMITED NANKNO MIN 319 03/28 12:13P 561 723.7752 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 320 0312/1 12:46P INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 321 03128 01:39P INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 00 322 03121 02:1515 (561)31/-3348 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 9 323 03128 06.18P INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 324 03128 06:30P (561)333.0180 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 325 03/28 07:14P INCOMING 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 326 03128 08:11P INCOMING IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 327 03128 01130P (561)6354451 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 328 03/28 08:34P (561)3134730 LAKE WORTH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 329 03128 08:5713 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 330 03128 09:02 P INCOMING MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 331 03128 09:21P (561)2624184 JUPITER FL MIN UNUMIT ED WAND MIN 332 03/28 10:11P INCOMING MIN UNUMITED NANKND MIN 313 03/28 11:51P (561)3134730 LAKE WORTH FL MIN UNUMITED NIWKND MIN 334 03129 11:37A INCOMING 3MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.21 315 03129 12:09P INCOMING MIN 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 334 03129 01:09P INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 337 03129 02:51P INCOMING 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 338 03129 02:54P (661)2624186 JUPITER FL 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 339 03129 02:5611 (581)356490 WPALMBEACH Ft. IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 340 03/29 08:06P INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.36 341 03/29 08:10P 561 333-0180 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 312 03129 08:24P 561 3334180 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 343 03/29 08:30P 561 793-1711 WPALMBEACH FL 5 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.45 314 03129 08:35P 561 644-2611 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 345 03129 08:15P 561 255-91117 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUT ES 0.09 346 03129 013:19P 561 255,1781 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.16 347 03129 09.13P 561 793-7719 WPALMBEACH FL MIN UNLIM TED N/WKND MIN Number !tern Dale Time Called 348 03/29 09:14? I s. 793-7719 349 03129 09:14P 561 313.6730 350 0.3D9 09:33P 561 262-5186 1 351 orrza 10:11P „551 E4A-2611 . 352 03129 10:13? 353 03129 10:19P (561)313.6730 04 03/29 I0:29P (561)635.3454 355 0.3/29 10:31P 356 03/29 10:40P (56111611-2611 357 03/29 10:48P (511)644-2611 358 032910:51P 359 03/2911:15P (954)687-3797 360 03/29 11:16P 361 03/3013.102A 362 03/30 03:21A 03 951 667-3797 I ss 363 00 03:21* 1 617.3797 361 03130 04:03A 561 723-7752 365 03/30 04:04A 561 723-8559 366 03130 04:06A 401 /110.0986 367 03/30 04:09A 368 03/30 04:12.41 407 810-0986 369 03/30 04:15A 107 810.0986 310 03/30 01:18A 40/ 810.0986 371 03/30 04:21A 40/ 810-0986 372 0300 04:22A 1407 810.0906 373 03/30 04:29A 407 810.0986 374 03/30 04:460. 951 687.3797 375 03/30 04:18A 376 03130 10:32* 561 358-5917 377 03/30 10:13A 561 7234559 378 03/30 10:38A 561 635-3454 379 03130 1019A 561 655-0995 360 03130 02:13P 561 308-0212 381 03/30 0213P 561)308-0282 382 0300 02:17P 3133 03130 02.23P 381 03/30 02:37P 385 03/30 03:36P 386 03/30 03:10P 381 03/30 03.16P 38E1 03430 03. 48P 389 03/30 04:15P 390 03/30 08:39P 391 03130 06:1113 392 03/30 09.07P 393 03/1009:013P 394 03/3009:13? (561)723-8559 395 0313009:37? 396 03/3009:51? 397 03/3010:06? 399 03430 10:15P 399 03/3010:55? (561)308-0282 101 03/31 12:00A 102 03/31 09:56A 403 03131 10:21A (561)346-10E16 404 03/31 10:40A 405 03131 10.42A (561)317-3348 106 03131 I0:47A 107 0301 10:52A Only Charge Used Rate Description Charge 1MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 2MIN UNLIMITED N/MINCI MIN 2 MIN 1/181 - UNLIMITCCI Pawr,r.ia 1.8N- • - UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 2811N 2 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 2MIN UNLIMITED NNYIND MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 2MIN 1 MIN UN LIMIT EC N/WKNO MIN UN LIMIT EC N/WKND MIN VAIN UN UMIT ED WWKND MIN 1 MIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN 1 FAIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 1MIN UNLIMITED WWKND IAN 1MIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN 1M1N UNUMITED WWKND MIN 1111/1 UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 1N1101 UNUMITED NIWKND MIN 2MIN 1MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN UNUMITED N/WKND MIN 3MIN UNUMITED NANKN D MIN I MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN HAIN UNLIMITED WWKN D MIN IMIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 10/115: UNLIMITED NNVKNO MIN UNUMITED N/WKNO MIN 1MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1MIN 0 09 AIRTIME MINUTES 10.1IN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1M1N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1 0.01I 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1M1N 1 ENT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 3 MJN 1 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES /MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 3IAIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1M1N 009 AIRTOAE MINUTES 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 8 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 1EVT CALL WAFTING UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 2MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 3MIN UNUMITED NANKI) MIN 1 MIN 3 PAIN UNUMITED NA/AND MN IMIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 2MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 EVT DROP CALL CREDIT IMIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN 111AIN MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 EVT UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1MIN 0.09 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES IMIN 0 09 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2MIN 0.18 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2MIN 0.18 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2MIN 0.1B 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.27 0.09 0.27 0.09 0.36 0.18 009 0.72 0.18 0.09 0.18 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 III 07/26/17 Page 84 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

cingular 4--tzsc3-sikr Account Number 0035224228 Account Name HOLLY ROBSON Date of Invoice April 12, 2005 Page 7 of 8 DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED VOICE USAGE FOR (561)308-0282 - Continued VOICE USAGE FOR (561)308.0282 • Continued Number Item Date Time Called 406 03131 10:52A 409 03131 11:0311 (561)358.5947 41003131. 11.106 .. -- ---.- - 411 03/31 11:21A (551)358-5947 412 03/31 11:23A 113 03/31 11:32A 414 03131 11:41.A 415 03131 12:15P 416 03131 01:29P (561)254-6039 417 03/31 01:56P 418 03131 01:51P (561)352.5503 419 03121 01:58P (561)352.5803 420 03/31 02:31P 421 03731 02:38P (561)282.7592 422 03731 03:05P 423 03731 03:11P 424 03031 04:17P 425 03131 04:24P 426 03/31 04:26P 427 03/31 05:07P 428 03/31 05:09P (561)317.2143 429 03/31 05:17P 430 03/31 65:421' (561)333.0225 431 03131 05:45P 432 03/31 06:4371" 431 01/31 06c25P (561)635.3454 434 03131 06151" 435 03131 07:061' (561)3084262 436 03131 07.071' 561 358-5947 437 03/31 07:311' 561 317-3348 438 03/31 07:331' 561 358-5947 439 03131 07:341' 561 317-3348 I 440 03131 07:351' 561 317.3348 441 03131 07:37P 442 03/31 07:38P (561 317-3348 443 03/31 07:49P 444 03131 0761P 561 358.5947 445 03/31 07:59P 446 03/31 07:59P 447 03/31 0819P 561 333-0225 448 03/31 1:113,21P 561 358-5947 449 03/31 013:57P 561 723-8559 450 03/31 09:02P 561 313-6730 451 03/31 09:03P 561 793.7719 452 03/31 09:05P 561 793-7719 453 01/31 09:05P 561 3136730 454 03/31 10:271' 561 3136730 455 03/31 113:571' 561 123.8559 456 03731 11:131' 561 123-8559 457 03131 11:131' 561 123.8559 458 07/31 11:13P 561 723.3559 459 03/31 11:15P 4613 04101 10:31A 561 5.74-8714 461 04/01 10:32A 561 3060282 462 04/01 11:27A (561)574.8714 16] 0431 • P 464 04/01 03:17P 561 875.2208 465 04/01 03:23P 561 317.3348 466 04101 04:13P 61 856.3132 I 467 04101 04:84P 61 856.3132 468 04101 04:141' 61 156.3132 469 04101 04:15P 51 556-3132 Only Charge Calls To Used Rale Description Charge INCOMING 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 EVT CALL WAITING WPMAIBEACH FL 2MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 INCOMING .- • ...?/MIN -9 09-AIRTIME MINUTES. 0.1.2 WPALMBEACH FL MN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 INCOMING PAIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0113 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0_ . 27 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 WPALM BEACH FL MIN 0_09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 INCOMING MN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 WPALM BEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 WPALAIBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 INCOMING MIN 0.131 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.63 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 INCOMING MN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 WPALMBEACH FL MN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 009 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.45 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.36 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.15 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 EVT CALL WAITING WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.01 AIRTIME MINUTES 13.09 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL WPALMBEACH Ft. MIN 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 WPAINBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 WPAINBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 WPALMBEACH FL IAN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 N COMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 WPALMBEACH Ft PAIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 INCOMING MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 009 WPALMBEACH Fl. MIN 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.18 WPAIMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 LAKE WORTH FL MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN WPALMBEACH FL MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN WPALMBEACH FL MIN UN LIMIT ED N/WKND MIN LAKE WORTH FL MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN LAKE WORTH FL MIN UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN WPAIMBEACH FL MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN WPALMBEACH FL MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN WPALMBEACH FL MIN UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN WPAUMBEACH FL MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN INCOMING MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN WPAIMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.10 INCOMING MIN 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.16 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRT/ME MINUTES 0.64 WPALMBEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.54 PALM BEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 PALM BEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 PALM BEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 PALM BEACH FL MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 Number Only Charge Item Dale Time Called Calls To Used Rate Description Charge 470 04/01 07:19P (561)655-7629 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0 09 471 04/01 07:20P (561)308-0262 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 1EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL . 472 01101 07211'• 561 117.21.47 -- INPPLY8EA.CH EL a MIN 4.09 AIRTIME 4421.1MTES.--- - V.03 473 0001 07.251' 561 17-2143 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 009 474 04/01 09:49P 561 1134730 LAKE WORTH FL 5 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 475 01/01 10:06P 561 313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL UNLIMITED N/WKND LAIN 476 04/01 10:101' 561 3330225 WPALM BEACH Ft. 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 477 04/01 10:11P 561 602.9566 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 474 04831 10:12P 561 13-6730 LAKE WORTH FL 151IN UNLIMITED N/WKND PAN 479 04/131 10:12P 561 317.3348 WPALAIB EACH FL 3 MIN UNLIMIT ED N/WKNI) MIN 480 04/01 10:1511 561 02-9566 LAKE WORTH FL 3 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 481 04701 10:36P INCOMING 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 452 041131 10:42 P 561 798-7979 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 483 04/01 10:4311 561 798.7979 WPALM BEACH FL WIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 484 01101 11:531' INCOMING 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 485 04/02 12:06A 561 317-3348 WPALMBEACH FL 3 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 486 04/02 12:08A 561 602-9566 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 487 01/02 12:10A 561 346-1086 WPALM BEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 455 04/02 12:11A 561 346-1086 WPALM BEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 489 04/2 12:11A 561 3134730 LAKE WORTH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 490 04/02 12:101 561 7234559 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 491 04/02 12:15A 561 346.1086 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND AIIN 492 04/02 12:16A 561 644-4783 WPAINBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 493 04/02 1221/1 561 3461086 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 494 04102 12:29A 561 313-6730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED WW1040 MIN 495 04/02 12:29A INCOMING 3 MIN UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN 496 04102 12:31A INCOMING 351IN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 1EVT CALL WAITING 497 04/132 12:34A (561)313-6730 LAKE WORTH FL 111IN UNLIMITED N/W1011) MIN 498 0002 12:361 INCOMING 2MIN UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN 499 04832 01:20A (561)313-6730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 500 04/02 01:37A INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 501 0002 01:40A (561)3134730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED NPNKNO MIN 502 04/02 02:36A INCOMING 1111N UN LIMIT ED IMMO FAIN 503 04832 02:40A (561)3134730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 504 01702 12:521 (561)7624677 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 505 01/02 12:58P INCOMING 5 MIN UN LIMIT ED NIWKND MIN 506 04702 01:41P (561)317-1348 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 507 04/02 01:56P INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED WAND MIN 506 0402 01:58P (561)723.7152 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 509 04/02 02:0312 INCOMING 11MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 510 04/02 02:221' WPALM BEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 511 04 5-3454 102. 02:56P 561 63 15611635-3454 WPALM BEACH FL 111IN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 512 04/02 02:57P 561 635-3454 WPALM BEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 513 04102 03,041' INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 514 01/02 03:43P INCOMING 1511N UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN 515 01/02 04:20P (561)201.9463 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED NPNKND MIN 516 0443206.05P (561)305-0282 WPALM BEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 1EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 511 04/02 06:0713 (786)473-1267 MIAMI FL 151IN UNLIMITED NANKNO MIN 518 04/02 06:07P INCOMING UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 1EVT CALL WAITING 519 04/02 07:181" (561)308-0282 WPALM BEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN 1 (VT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 520 04/02 07:24P 561 722-5002 WPALM BEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 521 0032 01:26P 522 04/0209:4312 561 561 722-5002 317.3348 WPALM BEACH FL WPALM BEACH FL lfAIN 151IN MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND UNLIMIT ED N1WKND MIN 523 04102 09:43P 561 313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL 3 MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN 524 04102 10171' 561 117.3348 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 525 04/02 10:42P 561 317-3348 WPALM BEACH FL 961IN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 526 0002 11:19P 561 793-9291 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 527 04/02 11,441' 561 644-2611 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNLIMIT ED N/WKNO MIN 523 04/03 12:11A INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMIT ED WWKN MN 529 0033 12:19A (561)3080782 WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN UNLIMITED N1WKN M I N 1 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL - 0.000016AOS 07/26/17 Page 85 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 MIN MIN I 1 1.1 N • 731 H 1EVT 1 AdIN 1 AI N 6M N 1M N 11.1N I M N 6 MIN 1 1 MI N 1 MIN 4 MIN 1M N 2 MIN 1 Al N 1 MIN 1 MIN 11.11N 2 MIN 1MIN 1 MIN 1 MN 2 MIN 1 EVT SPAIN 614 5 AI N N 1 1 MIN N 1 MIN 2 MIN 1 M N 111401 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 5 MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1111 N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 264N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTE S 1M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 20A N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES AM N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES IMIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES I M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 2M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES I M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES INN 0-09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 20A N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 3M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1 EVE MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES I EVT CALL WAITING 3M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1 MIN 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 1EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 Mt N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 1M N 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 161 N 009 AIRTIME MINUTES 5M N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES Only Charge Used Rate Description UNLIMITED NIWKNO PAIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO PAIN UNLIMITED H./14.001112 MIN MESSAGE RETRIEVAL UNLIMITED NIWKNO PAIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN UNLIMITED WWKNO MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO PAIN UNLIMITED N(WKND MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN UNLIMITED NNVKND MIN UNLIMITED NANKND PAIN UNLIMITED N/WKFID MIN UNLIMITED NANKND MN UNLIMITED WWKAID MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND PAIN UNLIMITED WHAM° MIN UNUMITEDNIWKNO MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN UNUMITED N/WK ND MIN UNLIMITED N/WKNO MIN UNUMITED NM/KND MIN UNLIMITED N/WX ND MIN MESSAGE RETRIEVAL UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN UNUMrt E D NIWKNO MIN UNLIMITED AMINO MIN UNLIMITED NAPA ND MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN UNUM7TE0 NANKNO MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN UNLIMITED NIWKNO MIN Charge 009 0.45 009 0 18 a Is 0 18 09 018 0.09 0.18 0.27 0.09 0.10 0.09 0.18 0 09 0 .09 0 09 0.10 0.27 0.18 0.27 0.09 0 09 0.09 0.09 0 45 1111111111111111 11111111111111101111111111111111111111111110111111111 Calls To WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING FNPA././113EACH WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FI- WPAUABEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL LAKE WORTH FL INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL LAKE WORTH Fl. LAKE WORTH FL LAKE LMBE WORACH TH Fl.. FL WPA INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING LAKE WOR Fl. WPAUABEA TH CH IL INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING WPALMBEACH Ft. LAKE WORTH FL INCOMING INCOMING INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING WPAUABEACH FL WPALMBEACH Ft. LAKE WORTH FL WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL LAKE WORTH FL INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING WPALMBEACH FL WPALMBEACH FL LAKE WORTH FL LAKE WORTH FL LAKE WORTH FL WPALMBEACH F cingulaL wra, _ Account Number 0035224228 Account Name HOLLY ROBSON Date of Invoice April 12, 2005 Page 8 of 8 DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED DETAIL OF CURRENT ACTIVITY - CONTINUED VOICE USAGE FOR (551)308-0282 - Continued VOICE USAGE FOR (561)308-0282 - Continued Number Item Date Time Called 530 04/03 12:57A (561)641-4763 531 0443 04.19A (561)6442611 532 01103 04:57A 521 04:27 01 Infk cse•nne•om • 534 04(03 01:27P 561 6332703 535 04/01 01:29P 561 722-5002 536 04103 011IP 561 798.7979 537 04103 01:38P 561 723.7752 538 04103 01:38P 561 635.3454 539 04103 01:39P 561 313.6730 540 04103 0212P 541 04/03 02:16P 561 311-33413 542 04/03 02:39P 561 602.9556 543 04103 02:40P 561 602.9566 544 04103 02:41P 561 313.6730 545 04(03 03:13P 561 635.3154 546 04103 03:46? 547 04/03 04:13P 548 OM 04:29P 549 550 551 552 S53 554 555 556 557 558 559 560 561 562 04103 05:06P 04/03 06.24P (561)3136730 04103 0625P (561)317.3348 04/03 06:213P 04933 07:08P 04/03 OILIZP 04103 08:53? (561)3090292 04103 08.54P (561)833-8111 04/03 08:59P (561)317.3316 04/03 09-12P 04/03 0916P (561)317.33413 04/03 09:19P (561)3136730 04/03 09:52P 04/03 11:24P 553 04103 II:26P 564 04/04 09.21A 561 796.7979 565 04/04 01:08P 561 635.3454 566 04/04 01:14P 551 317.3349 567 04104 01:33P 551 317.3346 569 04104 01:35P 569 04104 01:45P 570 04104 02:17P (S61)628.1629 571 01671 02.17P 572 04/04 02.39P5616444783 (( (561 1) )628.1629 573 04/04 02:43P561317-3348 574 04874 02.52P 575 04/04 05:11P 561 309-3233 576 04104 05:12P 561 309.3233 577 00/01 05:16P 561 3134710 519 04/04 05:18P 561 1 317-3316 519 01104 06:26P 561 793-7719 5130 04/04 06:26P 561 3134730 58% 04(04 07:27P 582 01/04 07:2812 561 317.3348 513 04/04 06:17P 561 aoarizez 584 04104 09:18P 585 04/04 06:30? (561)635.3454 586 04104 0832P (561)109.0282 00 587 0404 06:50? 585 04104 0852P 561 313.6730 5139 04/04 00-54P 551 1 551136730 313-6730 590 04104 08,5P 561 833-9111 Number Only Charge Item Date Time Called Calls To Used Rate Description Charge 2 MIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN 591 04/04 09:01P LAKE WORTH FL 1 ANN UNLIMITED NANKND MIN 592 /56113134710 04/04 09.04P 561 313.6730 LAKE WORTH FL 1 MIN UNLIMITED WNXND MIN 551 0411 09:109. 551 312.5770 - LAKE.14/ORTI1 FL ' EV11 - UNLIMITED NA/1/K91 594 04104 09:14P 15611833-1111 WPAUAB EACH F L 1 MIN UN UNITED NIWKND MIN 595 04/04 10:03P (5611306-0282 WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UN UMI TEO NANKND MIN 1 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 596 04104 10:36P INCOMING INN UN UNITED NIWKNO MIN 597 04104 10:45P PHOENIX AI 1 MIN UN UNITED WNKND MIN 598 0004 10:4614 603 r1321321-2936 321-2939 NASHUA NH 1M7N UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 599 04/04 10:47P 603 321-2939 NASHUA NH 3 MIN UNUMITED NANKND MIN 600 04101 10:50P INCOMING 3 MIN UNUMITED WWKND MIN 601 04134 11:21P 6033214939 NASHUA NH 31A1N UNLIMITED NANKND MIN 602 WPALMBEACH Et 1 MIN UN LIMITED NIWKND MIN 603 04101 11:29P (5613316.1066 04(04 11:31P 561346-1086 WPALMBEACH Ft 1A43N UN UNITED MANKND MIN 604 0001 11:32P INCOMING 2 MIN UN LIMITED NIWKND MIN 605 04/04 11:46P INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED NIWKND MIN 606 0410501:21A INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED WINKND MIN 607 04105 01:38A INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED WWKND MIN 808 04(05 11:48A (561)793-7979 WPALMBEACH Fl 1641N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 609 0410502:59P (561)308-0282 WPAUI8EACH FL I EVT 1 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 610 04105 03:00P 561 721.7752 WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 611 04/05 03:33P 561 313.6130 LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 612 04075 03:39? 561 262.6186 JUPITER FL I MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0 09 613 04/05 03:40P 561 26243186 JUPITER FL 1MIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 614 615 04/05 03.43P 01/05 03•511I 561 543.3902 WPALMBEACH FL INCOMING M 9 3 MN IN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.27 0.11 616 04/05 04:10P 561 635.3454 WPMM8EACH FL 2M1N 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.10 617 04105 04:14P 561 262.5186 JUPITER FL 1MM 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 TOTAL VOICE USAGE FOR (561)300-0282 52.74 DATA USAGE FOR (561)308.0282 Item Data Only Used Charge Description 1 03/25 29 KB MO DE/DATA USAGE 2 03126 I KB 'ANODE/DATA USAGE TOTAL DATA USAGE FOR (581)301.0282 TEXT/MULTIMEDIA MSGS FOR (561)308-0282 Item Date Time Sent Tollacvd From Charge Description Charge 0.28 A 04 0.32 Charge 1 03/21 06.07A 561 543.9016 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 2 01/21 136.03P 551 317-3348 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 3 03121 06:07P 561 317-3348 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 1 03/21 0609P 561 317.3348 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 5 03/Z9 06:03P 561 3173348 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 6 03/29 06:04P 561 419016 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 7 03(29 06:13P 561 5439016 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 0 03/29 06:21P 561 543.9076 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 9 03130 02:25A 543.9076 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 1003/31 10-3IA 561 601.6113 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 11 03131 12:23P 561 17.3348 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 12 03/31 12:21P 561 17.3346 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 13 04103 11:06P 561 543.9076 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 14 04101 11:29P 561 76.2206 TEXT MESSAGES SENT 0.10 15 0034 09.1212 117.3316 TEXT MESSAGES SENT TOTAL TEXT/MULTIMEDIA MSG USAGE FOR (501)3011-0102 1.50 07/26/17 Page 86 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

• 'Y. z.' ' 02/10/2008 01:50 1616404420 X PAGE 01 Aileen Josephs, P.A. Attorney at Law 401(4mAii.StNet Suilv 4:100 ''e rale.' Reach, F ri 1 11401 -4.12.4110 :140.4420 loser ..414,1j,coni hrrr:iArww-iming' hni,://www.M • omit ‘.11,1 Ailed luxcl•11s Monlyr Oimrrct tg'(:1,111mbict Him!, February 10.:'008 TO: Mr. GI, v .ewis RE: Mr. Ep t( Hn FROM: AiLe Josephs, Esq. Mr. Lewis: We in our County have been watching this case with great concern. I strongly st. ;t you do not attack the victim(s). If you feel that your client has been defamed, Er u mentioned in the February 7, 2008 Palm Beach Post article, you can file a libel suit- 2.ourse, the truth is an absolute defense to libel and please keep in mind that not knom rig the age of a child is no defense to statutory rape or any sexual crime committed ag: inst a child. Sincerely, Aileen Josephs. Esq. cc. Ms. Lan: 1 elohavek, Esq. State Attorney's Office Ms. La TosLa ,owe- request to place this letter in State's file Chief of Pol - Palm Beach 07/26/17 Page 87 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

,_01?23/2008 15:06 5616404420 PAGE 01 Aileen Josephs, P.A. Attorney at Law Cie1113titi STrVcf Sttill: )000 ‘kk.xt NInk Rcnch. FI ,,;,I. ;1401 Ohl ) NO2•4119 K1,1 (5611 640.442k' Ilcrp://www.ItkonigraciktnUS.r.om J..t.phs Member n'it)ikirici .if mid Florida 1:101, January 25,2008 TO: Ms. Sanchez, Esq. RE: Mr. Epstein From Aileen Josephs, Esq. Ms. Sanchez: Women in our County have been watching this case with great concern. I strongly suggest that you do not attack the victim(s). If you feel your client is innocent, you can file a libel suit- of course, the truth is an absolute defense to libel, and please keep in mind that not knowing the age of a child is no defense to statutory rape or any sexual crime committed against a child. Sincerely, Aileen Josephs, Esq. Cc. Ms. Lana Belohavek- State Attorney's Office Ms. La Tosha Lowe- request to place this letter in State's file Chief of Police- Palm Beach 07/26/17 Page 88 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

ceivecl: 1 /25/08 8:40AM; 5616404420 STA1 5616404420 01/23/2008 15:06 111E PAN BEACH POST LEVI ERSIOIK EDITO Iduanasiee MOM', AUGUST 25, 2006 tU A Epstein oughtto shut up, be happy with 'justice' I think that Jeffrey Epstein's "camp" should be happy that money and power does buy Beach in this county ("Palm Beach chief focus of fire in Epstein case," Aug. 14). The exception: the Rush Lim- baugh case. But that was at a time when Palm Beach County State Attorney Barry Krischer was running for reelection and was not sure he would run uncontested. He received thousands of e-mails asking him to press charges against Mr. Limbaugh. It was a good political move to do so. The Epstein camp should stop attacking the victims' reputation in the media. Let's not forget — they are children. A child's reputation is sacred. Also, according to the law, lack of knowledge of the age of the victim is no defense for statu- - tory rape or any sexual crime committed against a child. If his camp feels that Jeffrey Epstein has been libeled, his high-powered attorneys. Jack Goldberger and Alan Dershow- ita can file a libel suit against the appropriate parties. Accord- ing to the law, the truth is an absolute defense against libel Other than that, the Epstein camp should be silent and con- tent with the justice obtained from the state attorney. Past cases indicate that children's rights, victim's rights and women's rights are meaningless, and often the victim is re-vic- timized. AILEEN JOSEPHS West Palm Beach Parker's off; Lieberman was too close to the GOP Kathleen Paijcefaniov To Let commissioners visit Westgate, see good work* I read with interest a recent article in The Palm Beach Post rectarding the Westgate Tab- ernacle in West Palm Beach C'Church helps homeless fu If college dreams," Aug 18). I was unaware of the exis- tence of this church or of the ' problems it reportedly has had. with Palm Beach County over code violations. Out of curios- ity, I attended a service one morning. I found it a humbling experience. The work this small church is doing to provide real help to the needy, the homeless and other unfortunate citizens, is inspiring. Regardless of whatever problems the church has. I urge all the county CommiSSiOnfil to attend at least one service at this church just to see for thernscNes the good works it is doing. I think the commis- .Sioners will be impressed and gain a new understanding of this organization. It should be encouraged and assisted, not impede Pension guarantee good, but 40i(k) proviSion not While glad to see that any company with a pension plan in place now will have to guarantee those benefits, it wor- ries me that companies will be allowed to automatically enroll workers in 401(k) programs ("President signs bill requiring employers to shore up pen- sions, Aug. 18) I dcn't believe employees should be forced to take part in any program inwhich tho:Cf would be gambling their mom' MARK L WINANS Lake Worth 07/26/17 Page 89 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

ire..giLig,611111V VW" Received: 1/25/08 8:40AM; 91)23/2008 15:06 5616404420 5616404420 -> STATE ATTY OFC ; Page 3 X PAGE 03 BARRY BERc. VP Cirodohon JARRY SIEDI VP & Treasurer JOHN KELLY. VP Advertising GALE HOWDEN. VP ( sonnounity Relations and Mara LINDA MURPHY. FP Human Resources BOB MITE. VP Operations LAURA DECK CI iNNINGHAM, Direcinr Marketaig Services DAN SHORTER. General Manager, l'a!ntlieachPostrolu How will system judge Palm Beach predator? tte TJ arm 7n. Pal,i het; 'el slot • V's Lil gie Wil :north. tens ton Fib ...ear ers by tutu the g•11 be? ' wlnrt. N 4 20A THE PALM BEACH POST • FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 16, 2007 The Palm Beach Post TOM GIUIVR1DA. l'ubl:snvr JOHN BARTI)SEK. CI ARM, (xERARDI. General 10(711(101 BILL ROSE. Managing editor RANDY SCHLI1T7. Editor of the Editorial Pagr JAN TUCICWOOD, Assorintr Editor We soon will find out whether big money can buy from the crimi- nal justice system what everyone assumes that big money can buy. The penalty news reports say part-time Palm Beach resident Jeffrey Epstein is expected to face suggests that he will plead guilty to something more than one felony count for solicitation of prostitution. A Palm Beach County grand jury indicted the Manhattan money manager on that charge in July 2006. But a guilty plea that does not recognize the age of the girls whom police say the billionaire paid for sex would be a disservice to the girls, an insult to the investigators who pressed the case and, for good measure, a general outrage. Palm Beach police have said that Jeffrey Epstein, 54., paid underage girls, one as young as 14, to come to his 7.200-square-foot waterfront. home for "massage" sessions. Police said interviews with five alleged victims and 17 witnesses under oath, phone messages, a high school transcript and other items they found in MI: Epstein's trash and• home show that he knew how young the girls were. But after Mr. EpstenA attorneys told prosecutors about the girls' MySpace pages, which mentioned marijuana and alcohol use, State Attorney Barry Krischer sent the case to s grand jury, instead of filing charges himself. Blaming these victims. however, does not make them any more de- serving of what happened. And Mr. Krischer's unnecessary handoff to a grand jury, after an 11-month police investigation. more than reinforced Jeffrey Epstein case corms to turning point. the public understanding tha.i the more money the accused hits. the bigger the break he gels. Mr I Epstein's legal team includes Wes . Palm Beach defense attorney lad: Goldberger, Harvard Law School Professor Alan Dershowitz. who worked oil the 0.1. Simpton murder case, and Kenneth Starr, who once pursued a president based on hi; lies about sex with young women. Federal authorities also stepped in, which stalled the state's case for anothor year. On Nov. 9, citing an unnamed source close to Jeffrey Epstein, ,lose Lambiet of The Its! wrote that the federal investigation is over, and Mr. Epstein is expected to serve up to 18 months and mulct be labele4 a sex offender in C1' nal recorils. The charge the grand jury returned more than a year age carries a maximum five-year prise]) term and no "sex offender" label. "This case," Mr. Goldberger tout Mr. LanNet, "is absolutely going end without a trial within the next two months." State attorney spoket-- man Michael Edmondson woe to not confirm any plea deal. But. noted: '1 he state attorney's hand are not tied by there being a single grand 'cry charge. That does net preclude additional charges." Jeffrey Epstein, like too many men in Florida, preyed on teenaged girls. Tito system should not let him buy hii-INvav out of that reality 07/26/17 Page 90 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

31 t413 A 5616404420 08/23/2006 13:41 UL'iVU1k lAr2-°vz-4iaAA- 346T '`? • Fs‘Did, AUGUST 25,2006 P—)4t THE PAN BEACH POST • 01E161 0 TM. 9110R Epstein oughtto shut mg, be happy with 'Justice" I think that Jeffrey Epstein's "camp" should be happy that money and power does buy justice in this county ("Palm Beach chief focus of fire in Epstein case," Aug 14). The exception: the Rush Lim- baugh case. But that was at a time when Palm Beach County State Attorney Barry Krischer was running for reelection and was not sure he would run uncontested. He received thousands of e-mails asking him to press charges against Mr. Limbaugh. It was a good political move to do so. The Epstein camp should stop attacking the victims' reputation in the media. Let's not forget — they are children. A childk reputation is sacred. Also, according to the law, lack' of knowledge of the age of the victim is no defense for statu- tory rape or any sexual crime committed against a child.. If his camp feels that Jeffrey Epstein has been libeled, his high-powered attorneys, Jack Goldberger and Alan Dershow- itz, can file a libel suit against the appropriate parties. Accord- ing to the law, the truth is an absolute defense against libel Other than that, the Epstein camp should be silent and con- tent with the justice obtained from the state attorney. Past cases indicate that children's rights, victim's rights and women's rights are meaningless, and often the victim is re-vic- timized. AILEEN JOSEPHS West Palm Beach Parker's off: Lieberman was too close to the OOP A. Sei Vt. wi Let commissioners visit Westgate, see good world I read with interest a recent art?....1e in The Palm Beach Poet regarding the Westgate lab- ernasle in West Palm Beach college dreams," Aug. 18). (`Church helps homeless fulfill ( t1/44,A1 I was unaware of the eras. tence of this church or of the problems it reportedly has ;ad;. with Palm Beach County &vex code violations. Out of curii0S- )ty, I attended a service one morning f found it a humbling .ecrperience. The work this mall church is doing to provide reel help to the needy, the homeless an other unfortunate Chines' is inspiring. Regardless of whatever problems fhe church has, I urge all the county commissiorcrw to attend at least one service at this ..hurch just to see for themselves the good works it is doing. Zink the comrile- Aioners wbe impressed and gain a new understanding of this organization. It should be encouraged and assisted not impedeci MARK L WINANS ., • • ' Lake Worth Pension guarantee good,';1 but 401(k) provision not While l)n glad to see that, „ any company with a pension plan in place now will have to guarantee those benefits, it wof ries me that companies will be allowed to automatically enroll', workers in 401(k) programs ("President signs bill requiring, employers In shore up pen--. sions,. Aug. 18). I don't believe emplores should be fbrved in tampion In any pew= ;in Atter,i 2:11 0.1.4 1.1N gala ttA 07/26/17 Page 91 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

'14 -5/-5da1-1 " 34trx? \ tag. 10 THE 911011 THE PAN BEACH POST • - , Tt FRIDAY, AUGUST 25.2006 Epstein ought to shut 9, be happy with 'justice"' 1 think that Jeffrey Epstein's "camp" should be happy that money and power does buy justice in this county ("Palm Beach chief focus of fire in Epstein case," Aug. 14). The exception: the Rush Lim- baugh case. But that was at a time when Palm Beach County State Attorney Barry Krischer was running for reelection and was not sure he would run uncontested. He received thousands of e-mails asking him to press charges against Mr. Limbaugh. It was a good political move to do so. The Epstein camp should stop attacking the victims' reputation in the media. Let's not forget — they are children. A child's reputation is sacred. Also, according to the law, lack of knowledge of the age of the victim is no defense for statu- tory rape or any sexual crime committed against a child. If his camp feels that Jeffrey Epstein has been libeled, his high-powered attorneys, Jack Goldberger and Alan Dershow- itz, can file a libel suit against the appropriate parties. Accord- ing to the law, the truth is an absolute defense against libel. Other than that, the Epstein camp should be silent and con- tent with the justice obtained from the state attorney. Past cases indicate that children's rights, victim's rights and women's rights are meaningless, and often the victim is re-vic- timized. AILEEN JOSEPHS West Palm Beach Parker's off: Lieberman was too close to the GOP Kathleen Parker's oluv to Let commissioners visit Westgate, see good works I read with interest a recent article in The Paim Beach Post regarding the Westgate Tab- ernacle in West Palm Beach ("Church helps homeless fulfill college dreams," Aug. 18). I was unaware of the exis- tence of this church or of the problems it reportedly has had with Palm Beach County over code violations. Out of curios- ity, I attended a service one morning. I found it a humbling experience. The work this small church is doing to provide real help to the needy, the homeless and other unfortunate citizens is inspiring. Regardless of whatever problems the church has, I urge all the county commissioners to attend at least one service at this church just to see for themselves the good works it is doing. I think the commis- sioners will be impressed and gain a new understanding of this organization. It should be encouraged and assisted, not impeded. MARK L. WINANS Lake Worth Pension guarantee good, but 401(k) provision not While I'm glad to see that any company with a pension plan in place now will have to guarantee those benefits, it wor- ries me that companies will be allowed to automatically enroll workers in 401(k) programs ("President signs bill requiring employers to shore up pen- sions," Aug. 18). I don't believe employees should be forced to take part in any program in which they would be gambling their money 07/26/17 Page 92 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

arorn Pak eay. heb;e1. rt. sior ars lb Newell a! Ray UN:t- ate %NIP im mot tit. " - ten: ion pal f !ha ramet ers hilt. by ruins, v the guns bet: of icing "We art vaw't. Mos aria Fhn pa, 5611340 420 ->• S TE •T OFC; Page 1 Received: 11/16/07 3:20PM; PAGE 01 11/14/2007 21:53 5616404420 + 20A THE PALM BEACH POST • FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 16, 2007 The Palm Beach Post TOM GIUFFRIDA. CHARLK!'. GKRARDL General Manager JOHN BARTOSEK. ,kriitor BILL ROSE, Managing Editor RANDY SCI11.11:17. Editor of Me Editonal Pew JAN nrxwool). Associati. &die°, —_--- BARRYI3EKC. 4Y Cirodation LARRY SI E K. V!' & 7)77asurer JOHN KELLY, VrAdnerrifing GALE HOWDEN, VP cincutunity Relations and Marketing UNDA MURPHY. VP Human Resources BOB itAIPE. Vi' Operations LAIIRA DECK CUNNINGHAM. Dirretor Markt:tins, Ser»icts DAN SHORTER. Goierat Manager l'aqnZieachPost root --------------- We soon will find out whether big money can buy from the crimi- nal justice system what everyone assumes that:big money can buy. 'The penalty news reports say part-time Palm Beach resident Jeffrey Epstein is expected to face suggests that he will plead guilty to something more than one felony count for solicitation of prostitution. A Palm Beach County grand jury- indicted the Manhattan money manager on that charge in July 2006. But a guilty plea that does not recognize the age of the girls whom Police say the billionaire paid for sex would be a disservice to the girls, an insult to the investigators who pressed the case and, for good measure, a general outrage. Palm Beach police have said that Jeffrey Epstein, 54, paid underage girls, one as young as 14, to come to his 7.200-square-foot waterfront home for "massage" sessions. Police said interviews with five alleged victims and 17 witnesses under oath, phone messages, a high school transcript and other items they found in Mt Epstein's trash and home show that he knew how young the girls were. But after Mr. Epstein's attorneys told prosecutors about the girls' MySpace pages, which mentioned marijuana and alcohol use, State Attorney Barry Krischer sent the case to a grand jury, instead of filinv charges himself. Blaming these victims, however, does not make them any more de- serving of what happened. And Mr. Krischer's unnecessary handoff to a grand jury, after an 11-month police investigation, more than reinforced Jeffrey Epstein case comes to turning point. the public understanding tha:- the more money the accused has. the bigger the break he gets. Mt Epstein's legal team includes Wei. Palm Beach defense attorney Jad Goldberger, Harvard Law School Professor Alan Dershowitz, wh.t: worked on the 0.3. Simpson murder case, and Kenneth Stan; who once pursue I a president based on hit! lies abouI sex with young women. Federal authorities also stepped in, which stalled the state's cast• for anti:11er year. On Nov. 9, citing an unnamed source close to Jeffrey Epstein, Jose Lambiet of The Post wrote Mot the federal investigation is over. and Mt Epstein is expected to serve up to 18 months and could be labelel a sex offender in crimi, nal records. The charge the grand jury returned more than a year ago carries a inaximum five-year prise]: term and no "sex offender" label. "This case," Mr. Goldberger tote Mr. Lamhiet, "is absolutely going ts end without a trial within the ncx: two months." State attorney spokes- man Michael Edmondson won if: not confiem any plea deal. But, noted: 'I he state attorney's hand :: are not tied by there being a single grand try charge. That does not preclude additional charges." Jeffrey Epstein, like too mair, men in Florida, preyed on teenaged girls. The system should not let him buy his way out of that reality. How will system judge Palm Beach predator? 07/26/17 Page 93 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Pill 01/11/2008 21:40 5616404420 Page 1 cv-ke 'cL`-`1 PAGE 01 Page 1 of 9 p e_C 0 h IcA4e-/1"3 Lo • PRINTTHIS c_XEWYORIc Features _U2._ -0x,t.L1 The Fantasist VI CA Accused of paying underage girls for sex, superrich money manager Jeffrey Epstein is finding that living in a dream world is dangerous—even if you can pay for it. • By Philip Weiss • Published Dec 10. 2007 Cori.. Jeffrey Epstein is under indictment for sex crimes in Palm Beach, Florida, and I'd expected that when he came into the office of PR guru Howard Rubenstein, he would be sober and reserved. Quite the opposite. He was sparkling and ingenuous, apologizing for the half-hour lateness with a charming line— "I never realized how many one-way streets and no-right-turns there are in midtown. I finally got out and walked"—and as we went down the corridor to Rubenstein's office, he asked, "Have you managed to talk to many of my friends?" Epstein had been supplying me the phone numbers of important scientists and financiers and media figures. "Do you understand what an extraordinary group of people bityl• //we,. _.• _ 07/26/17 Page 94 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Received: pis 1/13/08 3:13PM; 01/11/2006 21:40 5616404420 5616404420 -> STATE ATTY OFC; Page 2 PAGE 02 Page 2 of 9 they are, what they have accomplished in their fields?" One of the accusers—a girl of 14—had put his age at 45, not in his fifties, and you could see why. His walk was youthful, and his face was ruddy with health. He had none of the round-shouldered, burdened qualities of middle age. There was nothing in his hands, not a paper, a book, or a phone. Epstein had on his signature outfit: new blue jeans and a powder-blue sweater. "I've only ever seen him in jeans," his friend the publicist Peggy Siegal had reported, saying there was a hint of arrogance in that, Epstein's signal that he doesn't have to wear a uniform like the rest of us. 1 told Epstein and Rubenstein the sort of story New York wanted to do, and Epstein seemed to find ironic delight in every word. "A secretive genius," I'd said. "Not secretive, private," he corrected in his warm Brooklyn accent. "And if I was a genius I wouldn't be sitting here.- "A guy with sex issues." A smile formed on Epstein's bow-shaped lips. "What do you mean by sex issues?" Well ... He was 54, had never married—I didn't finish. "Are you channeling my mother?" When I said we were interested in the agony of his ordeal, Rubenstein wrote out the word agony in capital letters on his pad. But agony seemed the last thing on Epstein's soul. "It's the Icarus story, someone who flies too close to the sun," I said. "Did Icarus like massages?" Epstein asked. Two years before, he had tried to explain himself to the Palm Beach police in the same way. After they came into his mansion with a search warrant and carted off massage tables and photos of naked girls and soaps shaped like genitalia, Epstein conveyed an urgent message to the detectives through his attorney. "Mr. Epstein is very passionate about massages ... The massages are therapeutic and spiritually sound for him: that is why he has had many massages." Epstein had even given $100,000 to Ballet Florida's massage fund, so that the dancers might also be treated. I never got to interview Epstein at length. His dream team of lawyers led by Gerald Lcfcourt was negotiating a plea with Florida state prosecutors in advance of a January 7 trial date. It is expected that Epstein will plead guilty to soliciting prostitution and get an eighteen-month sentence—not that there's likely to be a shameful admission. He has always had thc confidence that comes with the power to dazzle and, though accused of "doing everything in Sodom and Gomorrah," as one friend put it. seemed to believe that he could convince any halfway sophisticated person that he wasn't the least bit tawdry. -T-Ic lives in a different environment," says Siegal. "He's of this world. But he creates this different environment. He lives like a pasha. The most magnificent townhouse I've ever been in, and I've been in everything. I've seen a model of the house in Santa Fe ... a stone fortress. A model of the house in the Caribbean—it is not to be believed. I've seen photographs of thc apartment Ln Paris ... How did he get himself into that pickle? That's the mystery of Jeffrey Epstein. He's very mysterious. Not that many people get close to him. Not that many people know him." The descriptions of Epstein's character veer between visionary and big talker_ His world seems to be at ••f.• distance from normal humanity. Ile lives in what is described as the largest private residence in About 50,000 square feel in nine stories between Fifth and Madison on 71st. Visitors report a stuffed poodle is on the piano. The house, said one visitor_ is like what Hollywood might imktine when to show the superrich. Vv-hen Epstein noticed the 1, i:iitor's astonishment at his surrotmi',itizs, !:4.5c:id against a wall with a soft smile and tapped the oa.o.cliniz. ;di fake.." 'b2 • in Coney Island, the son of a Parks Department employee. He never got a college degree_ He studied •,i l';loper Union and then .NYIJ before migrating inevitably towani wealth. For two years. math nt the Dalton School on the Upper East Side. till r's berg. a friend of the father of one of Epstein's students. offered him a iob at Bear Steams. In one ban //vvs,..-uv rve-i retthi c.1 h; I: — 07/26/17 Page 95 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Received: 1/13/08 3:14PM; 61/11/2008 21:40 5616404420 5616404420 -> STATE ATTY OFC; Page 3 PAGE 03 Page 3 of 9 of the charmingly inevitable accidents of Epstein's rise, Greenberg was a senior partner of the house; Bear Stearns CEO Jimmy Cayne later told New York that Epstein's forte was dealing with wealthier clients, helping them with their overall portfolios. Leslie Wexner, founder of Limited Brands, reportedly made Epstein his financial adviser and was instrumental in building his fortune. Epstein was no footman; he loved luxury and, in his own words, saw himself as a financial architect, someone who could show the rich how to live with their money. "I want people to understand the power, the responsibility, and the burden of their money," he once wrote. At times, his powers seemed magical. "I think it's all done with mirrors," says Michael Stroll, a Chicago businessman who sued Epstein (and lost) when an oil deal didn't work out. Next: Epstein's Icarus moment. Redux) Stroll says he could never get a straight line from Epstein. "Everybody who's his friend thinks he's so darn brilliant because he's so darn wealthy. I never saw any brilliance, I never saw him work. Anybody I know that is that wealthy works 26 hours a day. This guy plays 26 hours a day." Those who believe in Epstein say that his intelligence works in a lofty and synthetic manner. "His mind goes through a cross section of descriptions," says Joe Pagano, a financier. "He can go from mathematics to psychology to biology. He takes the smallest amount of information and gets the correct answer in the shortest period of time. That's my definition of IQ." A Columbia University geneticist says Epstein has that insight in science, too. "He has the ability to make connections that other minds can't make," says Richard Axel, a Nobel Prize winner. "He is extremely smart and probing. He can very quickly acquire information to think about a problem and also to identify biological problems without having all the data that a scientist would have ... He also has an extremely short attention span. Why?—it's not that he's bored He has enough information after fifteen httn-//www nrintthis rlirk ability rt-sm irttte.r.t90 .--rt. u_ _ I 14 OS 14 4" es eu 07/26/17 Page 96 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Received: 1/13/08 3:14PM; 5616404420 -> STATE ATTY OFC; Page 4 01/11/2008 21:40 5616404420 x PAGE 04 Page 4 of 9 minutes so that you can see his mind thrashing about, as if in a labyrinth. And even to doubt an expert's statements." Epstein has been a munificent supporter of cutting-edge research. Axel met Epstein during the early biotech days of the eighties. Vanity Fair columnist Michael Wolff met him in the Internet bubble, in the late nineties, when Epstein invited him and a group of scientists and media types to fly to a conference on the West Coast in his beautiful 727. "It was all a little giddy," Wolff says. "There's a little food out, lovely hors d'oeuvre. And then after fifteen to twenty minutes, Jeffrey arrives. This guy comes onboard: He was my age, late forties, and he had a kind of Ralph Lauren look to him, a good-looking Jewish guy in casual attire. Jeans, no socks, loafers, a button-down shirt, shirttails out. And he was followed onto the plane by—how shall I say this?—by three teenage girls not his daughters. Not adolescent girls. These are young, 18, 19, 20, who knows? They were model-like. They towered over Jeffrey. And they immediately began serving things. You didn't know what to make of this ... Who is this man with this very large airplane and these very tall girls?" Soon after, Wolff was invited to tea at the house on Fast 71st Street. He understood that there was a purpose to the cultivation. Epstein was shifting his view to media, in his Ober-way. "What does the media mean, where does he fit into it?" Then Epstein began to show up in the press. In 2002, he flew Bill Clinton and Kevin Spacey to Africa on his plane to discuss aids policy, and suddenly he was being written about. In 2003, he became a discreet confidant to Wolff during the period when Wolff was involved in a bid for New York Magazine. Sometime after that, Wolff saw the financial architect in his office at 457 Madison Avenue, the Villard House, where Random House once had its offices. "His literal office is where Bennett Cerf's was. It's an incredibly strange place. It has no corporate affect at all. It's almost European. It's old—old-fashioned, unrehabbed in its way." Nearby, Wolff went on, "the trading floor is filled with guys in yarmulkes. Who they are, I have no idea. They're like a throwback, a bunch of guys from the fifties. So here is Jeffrey in this incredibly beautiful office, with pieces of art and a view of the courtyard, and he seems like the most relaxed guy in the world. You want to say 'What's going on here?' and he gives you that Cheshire smile." Epstein likes to say he's private, but you don't fly Bill Clinton to Africa without wanting attention. One friend says the Africa trip was Epstein's Icarus moment. There was tremendous risk that the natural forces of resentment would bring the too-smart, too-rich spirit back to earth. This is the friends' theory of the Palm Beach case: an overzealous police chief battened onto a rich man because he was not living in a box like everyone else. The dazzling arc of Epstein's comet came to an end—without his knowing it—in March 2005. That was when a distraught woman called the police in Palm Beach and, after at first refusing to give her name, said that she believed her 14-year-old stepdaughter had been molested by a wealthy man. The stepmother had learned about the matter in a roundabout way. The girl lived during the week at an "involuntary-admitted juvenile educational facility" because of behavior problems. She had shown up at the school with $300 in her purse, and it became the talk of her classmates. One friend called the girl a "whore," another friend put a fist through the wall in anger, the girl left school_ The stepmother got a call from another student's mother. Soon, a policewoman was talking to the girl with a therapist present. The girl cried and dug her finger into her thigh and told the story, of going to a big house on the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway. and climbing a spiral staircase to the master bedroom, where a blonde woman of 25 who wasn't very friendly laid out sheets and lotions on a massage table and left, then Jeff came in, naked but for a towel, and sternly ordered the girl to take off her clothes. As she rubbed his chest, he touched himself, then applied a vibrator to her crotch. f11 07/26/17 Page 97 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Received: 1/13/08 3:15PM; 5616404420 -> STATE ATTY OFC; Page 5 61/11(2008_ 21•,40 5616404420 X PAGE 05 Page 5 of 9 Next: The police lock onto Epstein's sybaritic lifestyle. The lengthy police narrative in the case doesn't make clear how police connected gray-haired Jeff with Jeffrey Epstein, but when the girl identified his picture in an instant in a photo lineup, police threw themselves into an investigation of the modem and palatial house on El Brillo Way. Palm Beach Island is a 3.75-square-mile spit of land famous for towering ficus privacy hedges on Mediterranean-influenced architecture that begins at over $5 million for a single-family home. But the police did their work miles across the water, in the sprawling, drab subdivisions of West Palm Beach, where, according to police reports, high-school girls had been recruited to visit Epstein's house. The 14- year-old was used to set up her I 8-year-old go-between, Haley Robson. Robson had massaged him once and thereafter refused, but had agreed to procure girls, for $200 a head. "I'm like Heidi Fleiss," she said. The police net went wider, to malls and community colleges, and Olive Garden restaurants and trailer parks, and the story was always the same. Skinny, beautiful young girls were approached by other girls, who said they could make $200 by massaging a wealthy man, naked. Robson said Epstein had told her the younger the better—which she said meant 18 to 20. The rules were simple. Tell him you're 18. There might be some touching; you could draw the line. "The more you do, the more you are paid." A couple of the girls said they went all the way into the experience—one told police she visited 50 times, another hundreds of times, both having sex with Epstein and Nada Marcinkova, a then-19-year-old beauty who Epstein told one of them was his "sex slave"; he'd purchased her from her family back in Yugoslavia. Epstein's friends' belief that he was targeted for his big life reflects the fact that the police locked onto Epstein's sybaritic lifestyle. They made careful note of the girls' thong panties, the shape and color of the sex toys Epstein favors, and the erotic art in his home, from photos to the mural of a woman to the statue of the man with a bow. Police repeatedly pulled his trash to dig out phone messages and kept an eye on his private planes. Once, they even reported on Wexner's plane, noting the procession of Cadillac Escalades that made its way across the tarmac. After word of the investigation got back to Epstein, through his girls, police served a search warrant at the house right under the noses of New York decorator Mark Zeff and architect Douglas Schoettle, who were there planning a renovation, and seized a dozen or so photographs of naked women the girls had described as well as the penis- and vagina- shaped soaps. Those soaps were even in guest bathrooms. No wonder; Epstein didn't see his sex life as tawdry, wasn't hiding it from his circle. Wolff believes that Epstein had created an idealized world from "a deep and basic cultural moment" once epitomized by Hugh Hefner. "Jeffrey is living a life that once might have been prized and admired and valued, but its moment has passed ... I think the culture has outgrown it. You can't describe it without being held to severe account. It's not allowed. It may be allowed if you're secretive and furtive, but Jeffrey is anything but secretive and furtive. I think it represents an achievement to Jeffrey." Some girls who "worked" for Epstein—the term favored by the unfriendly assistant, Sarah Kellen, who allegedly kept the Rolodex—seem to have embraced that fantasy, too. One girl said she was "so in love with Jeff Epstein and would do anything for him." Two college girls/aspiring models were matter-of- fact about what they'd done, and surveillance reports describe a fleet of girls jogging into the house. But generally the girls' feelings as portrayed by police interviews ranged from disgust to fear. Epstein was the hairy troll under the bridge they had to pass over to get quick money. One girl "stated she was very uncomfortable during the incident but knew it was almost over." Another kept looking at the clock, and Epstein said she was ruining his massage. Other girls said they were weirded out, grossed out. They didn't like his egg-shaped penis, definitely didn't want it inside them. Some couldn't say just what httrri/www nrintthis clirkRhilitv romintient9artinn.rnt.ertitip--Th.4-r,ne.;2,..--;-. 1/11 /'11r10 07/26/17 Page 98 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Received: 1/13/08 3:16PM; 5616404420 -> STATE ATTY OFC; Page 6 /1122908. 21: 40 5616404420 X PAGE 06 rage 6 ot 9 Epstein was doing because they kept their eyes averted. Two or three girls started crying when they talked to police, one hysterically. One wanted to tell the police but knew that he was "powerful" and was afraid he would come after her family. A 17-year-old model described an uncomfortable encounter in which Epstein offered to help her get jobs, then belittled her modeling portfolio before cajoling her to model the underwear he'd bought for her. A 16-year-old who needed money for Christmas said she was so upset by Epstein's removing her underwear as she massaged him that she broke off her friendship with the girl who brought her. Another called Epstein "a pervert." Epstein clearly did not see it that way. The girls knew what they were getting into and came willingly and were well paid. He was a sexy guy who was working to give the girls pleasure. The master bedroom was a sensual place, with a mural of a naked woman and a hot-pink couch, and a wooden armoire with sex toys. The lights dimmed, music came on. Still, it is a stretch to say Epstein's love shack was like Hugh Heftier's. Playboy was state-of-the-art pornography for the sixties. Today, cutting-edge porn is men with bankrolls picking up young amateurs, say, high-school cheerleaders or college girls on break, and daring them to go further and further for more cash, all the way to sex toys and lesbian sex. At 52, Epstein was outside the demographic of the makeout artists of The Bang Bros, Girls Gone Wild, and Coeds Need Cash, but he surely saw himself in that erotic milieu, and seems to have been shocked that his activities would result in a police investigation. His claim that he'd given a total of $100,000 to Ballet Florida for massage was absolutely true. "The massage and therapy fund is excruciatingly important to us. It's part of a dancer's life to have daily massages," says the ballet's marketing director, Debbie Wemyss, who notes that Epstein's generosities preceded his public troubles. Police were not impressed. They interviewed a licensed deep-tissue masseuse whom Epstein frequently employed. She said she got $100 an hour, and there were no happy endings, Next: Epstein mounts an aggressive counterinvestigation. The 14-year-old told Epstein she was 18 and in the twelfth grade. In Florida, this is not a defense. The law protects the young by placing the burden on the adult to learn the truth. And while Epstein's girls might have fooled a lot of people—they were tall and grown-up—it's difficult to believe Epstein wouldn't have suspected some were underage. (Though Epstein later passed a lie-detector test saying that he believed the girls were 18.) Girls needed to be driven home or given rental cars. Offered whatever they wanted from Epstein's chef, they often gobbled cereal and milk. One 16-year-old told police that Epstein told her repeatedly not to tell anyone about their encounter or bad things could happen. Alfredo Rodriguez, a houseman, told police that at his boss's direction, he brought a pail of roses to a girl to congratulate her on her performance in a high-school drama. "He has never been secretive about the girls," Wolff says. "At one point, when his troubles began, he was talking to me and said, 'What can I say, I like young girls.' I said, 'Maybe you should say, 'I like young women.' " Epstein mounted an aggressive counterinvestigation. Epstein's friend Alan Dershowitz, the Harvard law professor, provided the police and the state attorney's office with a dossier on a couple of the victims gleaned from their MySpace sites—showing alcohol and drug use and lewd comments. The police complained that private investigators were harassing the family of the 14-year-old girl before she was to appear before the grand jury in spring 2006. The police said that one girl had called another to say, "Those who help [Epstein] will be compensated and those who hurt him will be dealt with." By then, the case was politicized. The Palm Beach police had brought stacks of evidence across the httriri/wwv.. nrintthic.clickahilitv lilmnno 07/26/17 Page 99 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Received: 1/13/08 3:16PM; 5616404420 -> STATE ATTY OFC; Page 7 61/1...122908 ....22.i 40 5616404420 X Of rk- (A-1 S - t " A11)1A.AAtco waterway to the Palm Beach County state attorney's office, but the state attorney apparently saw the main witnesses as weak. One had run away from home, lied about her age, and bragged about her ass on MySpace. Another had a drug arrest and had stolen from Victoria's Secret. The police wanted numerous felony charges against Epstein as well as charges against Haley Robson and Sarah Kellen. Then they heard that the state attorney was preparing a deal with Epstein giving him five years on probation and sending him for psychiatric evaluation. The police chief, Michael Reiter, accused the state attorney of bending over backward for a rich man and then turned the matter over to the FBI. Finally, in July 2006, the Palm Beach County state attorney's office handed down one indictment of Epstein on a felony count of soliciting prostitution. There is no reference to minors in the indictment. Reiter was enraged. He released a letter he had sent out to five underage girls that read "I do not feel that justice has been sufficiently served." Epstein's lawyer said that Reiter was out of control, but the police chief was having an effect. The U.S. Attorney's office began an investigation, and the dream team added another member. Kenneth Starr, the former Clinton prosecutor. One of Epstein's friends told me, "He thinks there's an anti-Semitic conspiracy against him in Palm Beach. He's convinced of that. Maybe it's a defense mechanism." Palm Beach was historically a bastion of Gentile privilege. Vanderbilt and Glendinning and Dillman and Warburton are still engraved on the public fountains, and the Everglades Club with its espaliered trees and brass plates reading private seems stuck in the time of the Gentlemen's Agreement. Yet the anti-Semitic charge disturbed Jews whom I asked about it in Palm Beach. Michael Resnick, rabbi at the oldest synagogue on the island, Temple Entanu-E1 (circa the sixties), says he strongly doubts that Epstein is a modem Dreyfus. "There's no way, shape. or form that you can say that Palm Beach is a bastion with respect to religion. Individuals, yes. And there are some places that it is not an asset to be a Jew." Once Palm Beach tried to keep synagogues from opening. There are now four on the little island, including an Orthodox shut started by Slim-Fast founder Danny Abraham. Jose Lambiet, gossip columnist for the Palm Beach Post, says, "Half r4y eei -4-.40 1'1 ipy sources on the island are Jewish socialites." no nut v e Lambiet says the case has fed rage within the community over Palm Beach rules: The rich never have toW kA) do time. William Kennedy Smith in 1991, Rush Limbaugh, lately Ann Coulter for a voting infraction. ) Maybe it was inevitable that religion would come into the case. Peggy Siegal says Epstein's two big at charitable causes are science and Israel. His Brooklyn homies Dershowitz and Rubenstein are also major/. Israel supporters. Dershowitz has written a book about lingering anti-Semitism in elite life. Now throw .1 in the the fact that the Palm Beach police asked at least three of the girls whether they had noticed whether Epstein was circumcised. "I asked if she knew what being circumcised meant,' the officer stall regard to the 14-year-old. }10 o) yeas") l014A- Of course, that might be evidence_ But other details in the police narrative seem to derive more from je 401 ) 11\ Edgar Allan Poe's psychological tragedies than from Philip Roth's sociological comedies. Epstein is licensed in Florida to carry a concealed weapon—he has a Glock—and a shower on the first floor was given over to a gun safe. One girl said his chest was so pumped up he appeared to be on steroids. He had a Harley next to the many black Mercedeses, but his Florida license was expired. Now he was licensed in the Virgin Islands and gave his -permanent residence" as the same address as Island Yachts. Notwithstanding the room on the first floor with floor-to-ceiling books, the general aura is cold and joyless and lonely, that of a man in his fifties denying death by giving himself over completely to the sensual life, with the help of Brit, Alexis, Rhiannon, Sherry, Nicole, Haley, and Joanna hrhl • '1\ MAN nrintthi' r11 r1Cah111tV rnmint/rnt7artion=rntktitlp.,-Thp-1-FrrQe;erk.r.;,,,i,...-1 1 /11/106P PAGE 07 Page / of 9 07/26/17 Page 100 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Received: 1/13/08 3:17PM; 5618404420 -> STATE ATTY OFC; Page 8 ' 1/11/2008. 21:40 5616404420 X PAGE 08 Page >t of 9 Next. Epstein maintains he's done nothing wrong. The police narrative has overtones of a man avoiding all connection or intimacy. For years, Epstein had had a companion in a woman who could take him on if any woman could: Ghislaine Maxwell, the daughter of Robert Maxwell, the British newspaper baron, a Jew born in Czechoslovakia, who died mysteriously off his yacht in 1991. The British tabloids say that Epstein reminded Maxwell of her father and that she brought him into a Continental world. The Broadway and movie producer Jonathan Farkas says he and his wife used to double-date with the couple. Maxwell spent time at the Palm Beach house, and the police narrative says that she even hired an assistant-cum-masseuse for Epstein. But that was five years ago, and the girl was 23, at a local college. Maxwell never showed up in all the surveillance, only her stationery. Epstein's activities seem to have devolved in recent years. Juan Alessi, his longtime houseman, told police that toward the end of his employment, the girls were "younger and younger," and he often had to wash off vibrators and "a long rubber penis" left in the sink. The next houseman, Alfredo Rodriguez, said that he found the sex toys he had to wash "scattered on the floor." oa No need to worry about dirty laundry, if there's someone to do it. yC tat 0 t,#1 The U.S. attorney's investigation put Epstein in a bind. If the Feds brought a case and he lost, he would be imprisoned for a mandatory minimum ten-year sentence. Given the choice, it appears that Epstein will not gamble on a trial but make a deal with the state attorney on the prostitution charge. Not that he is likely to admit that he did anything wrong. Throughout his ordeal, Epstein maintained the air that there was nothing sordid about his actions. His wealth seems to have endowed him with utter shamelessness, the emperor's new clothes with an erection. Even Alan Greenspan has lately raised the moral questions brought on by the gap between the rich and poor: The poor will begin to feel that the social contract was not made in good faith. Epstein's friends say that on this matter, he has a philosophical position. "Fundamentally," Wolff says, "it's about math. That on a macro level it inevitably happens that the rich get richer. And then at some level the rich get richer on a geometric basis. Jeffrey's point is that this whole issue is-it's just mathematics at this point. This is the nature of a successful economy. The more successful the economy is, and that would be the goal of everybody, a successful economy, the greater the discrepancy actually is." There is no better place to observe how Epstein's mathematics work than Palm Beach. The only signs of life are crews of Spanish-speaking laborers on teetering ladders clipping the high hedges, not far from Bulgari and Valentino and Tiffany. It is a few miles on the other side of the bridge to where the girls came from, the shabby sprawl of West Palm Beach, with trailer parks, boys crouched on motor scooters, and pickup trucks under sun tents. Haley Robson's house is on an unpaved road by an irrigation ditch. An attractive blonde in her forties answers the door wearing pistachio Capri pants, and promptly slams it. "We have absolutely no comment about the Epstein case." Driving home with their $500, Haley said to the 14-year-old that if they did this every Saturday they'd be rich. and it's understandable that a teenager in West Palm Beach might feel that way. The coldest stories in the police narrative are about money and service. Maria Alessi, the previous houseman's wife, said she had cleaned house and shopped for Epstein for eight years and never had a direct conversation with him. He made it clear that he did "not want to encounter the Alessis during his stay in Palm Beach.- One girl said that when she had sex with Epstein she closed her eyes and thought about cash. httn://www nrintthis clickahilitv rornint/ent9arliOn-=rntktifla=Tha-4-Pantocirt.Pre,...,;....---9.1..1 1/11/IA60 07/26/17 Page 101 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Received: 1/13/08 3:17PM; • 01/11/2008 21:40 5616404420 5616404420 -> STATE ATTY OFC; Page 9 X PAGE 09 Page 9 of 9 "In my mind, I'm like, 'Oh my God, when this is over you're getting so much money." Jose Lambiet says the case went forward in Palm Beach despite the efforts of the dream team because of community rage arising from the class issues in the case—Epstein found the girls not from his own fancy neighborhood but from the struggling suburbs. He has never shown a glimmer of understanding that a high-school girl could be damaged by a powerful 50-year-old's demands, or that some of the girls were already emotionally damaged. For someone who could dream anything, it seems a little small. Find this article at: http://www.nymag.corninewsefeaturerJ41826 E Check the box to include the list of links referenced in the article. Copynght 0 Net Yost Magazine Holdings LLC. All Rights Reserved. 1N-2!(/1E),Ric„ 1061 •0 p For the city that never sleeps The magazine " that never r..sts II Just 44c on ossu.: httiv/iwww nrintthie 1 /1 /1 /^1/1/10 07/26/17 Page 102 of 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-295