Epstein Secrets

statements, their credibility and the foundations. il' any. for claiming personal istiory. Also. Mr. Epstein would have received, pursuant to either Brady or Jencks. material in the Ponta of prior inconsistent statements made by these women before they learned of any financial benefit that may be avai

letter until after we arc able to discuss this matter with Assistant Attorney General Fisher. Yours Kenneth W. Starr la iL wi4tz cc: Honorable Alice Fisher, Assistant Attorney General OISlreFint Assistant U.S. Attorney RFP MIA 000016 EFTA00209062 U.S. Department of Justice United States Attorney

it has identified. Because the information provided by these women goes directly to the question of Mr. Epstein's guilt or innocence, it is classic Brady information. We understand that the U.S. Attorney might not want to disclose impeachment information about their witnesses prior to a charge or dur

er 27, 2007 Email from J. to J. Lefkowitz. 42. The morning of November 28, attorneys for Mr. Epstein faxed a letter to Assistant Attorney General Alice Fisher, requesting a meeting with her to discuss the impropriety of the USAO's encouraging civil lawsuits against Mr. Epstein under the guise of the terms

ed to provide the draft indictmatt. We understand that we have no statutory right to a FRI 302 that inculpates Mr. Epstein (although we believe that Brady principles would encourage the disclosure of P131 302 reports that exonerate him). We are Lammed that there is information that could be rebutted i

he notification letter until after we are able to discuss this matter with Assistant Attorney General Fisher. Kenneth W. Starr JaillAtz Honorable Alice Fisher, Assistant Attorney General , First Assistant U.S. Attorney fL 003 EFTA01718525 12/06/07 'THU 15:25 FAX UNITED STATES ATTORNEY'S OFFICE SOUTHE

statements. their, credibility and the foundations. if any. fir claiming personal injury. Also. Mr. Epstein would have received, pursuant to either Brady or Jencks. material in tlx: form of prior inconsistent statements made by these women before they learned of any financial benefit that may be avai

concerns we have raised that have not yet been addressed. wish you a very happy and a healthy new year. Sincerely. v . Lefkojitz cc : Honorable Alice Fisher. Assistant Attorney General Jeffrey II. Sloman. First Assistant U.S. Attorney RFP MIA 000047 EFTA00184930 Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 362-25

ir statements, their credibility and the foundations, if any, for claiming person! injury. Also. Mr. Epstein would have received, pursuant to either Brady or Jencks, material in the tbnn of prior inconsistent statements made by these women before they learned of any financial benefit that may be avail

US Attorney's Office 305-530-6444 305-961-9100 CC: Company: Fax #: Direct Jeffrey II. Slornan US Attorney's Office 305-530-6444 30596192/9 Alice S. Fisher Department of .1 usriee 202-5114-9412 202-514-2601 From: .1:3y P.T.elkowitz Date: Parpswitowy: Fox #: December 2 I • 2007 S IM -446-6460

npersuaded by the letter and the presentation, but I agreed that I should carefully review transcripts of the recorded statements given to PBPD for Brady issues." Since witness credibility was clearly at the fore, I undertook efforts " The requested documents and items were never provided. 15 As the

11/28/2007 A. Marie Villafaiia, A. Oosterbaan, R. Garcia A. Lourie Email re non-prosecution agreement with attached correpondence 11/28/2007 Alice S. Fisher, Assistant Attorney General Starr Letter - 3 pages re 18 U.S.C. 2255 11/28/2007 Lefkowitz, Acosta, Sloman' Lourie, Oosterbaan Villafana E

r statements, their credibility and the foundations, if any, for claiming personal injury. Also, Mr. Epstein would have received, pursuant to either Brady or Jencks, material in the form of prior inconsistent statements made by these women before they learned of any financial benefit that may be avail

indicating whether the defense team wishes to reaffirm, or to unwind, the Agreement. Sincerely, It ALEXANDER ACOSTA UNITED STATES ATTORNEY cc: Alice Fisher, Assistant Attorney General Jeffrey Sloman, First Assistant U.S. Attorney AUSA A. Marie Villafafin -7- EFTA00234597 Exhibit 5 EFTA00234598 KI

s it has identified. Because the information provided by these women goes directly to the question of Mr. Epstein’s guilt or innocence, it is classic Brady information. We understand that the U.S. Attorney might not want to disclose impeachment information about their witnesses prior to a charge or durin

er 27, 2007 Email from J. Sloman to J. Lefkowitz. The morning of November 28, attorneys for Mr. Epstein faxed a letter to Assistant Attorney General Alice Fisher, requesting a meeting with her to discuss the impropriety of the USAO’s encouraging civil lawsuits against Mr. Epstein under the guise of the terms o