Epstein Secrets

l Campion Miller, Michael Gerard Scavelli, Reid Weingarten, Steptoe & Johnson, LLP, Marc Allan Fernich, Law Office of Marc Fernich, New York, NY, Martin Gary Weinberg, Martin G. Weinberg, PC, Bos- ton, MA, for Defendant. DECISION & ORDER REMANDING DEFENDANT RICHARD M. BERMAN, U.S.D.J. A. Background This ruling

fice of Marc Fernich, New York, NY, Martin Gary Weinberg, Martin G. Weinberg, PC, Bos- ton, MA, for Defend

306 425 FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES t In short, the issue now before the Court has arisen only because Donziger unjustifi- ably has refused to comply with his discov- ery obligations. Had he done so — i.e., had he produced responsive documents as to which the

fice of Marc Fernich, New York, NY, Martin Gary Weinberg, Martin G. Weinberg, PC, Bos- ton, MA, for Defend

l Campion Miller, Michael Gerard Scavelli, Reid Weingarten, Steptoe & Johnson, LLP, Marc Allan Fernich, Law Office of Marc Fernich, New York, NY, Martin Gary Weinberg, Martin G. Weinberg, PC, Bos- ton, MA, for Defendant. DECISION & ORDER REMANDING DEFENDANT RICHARD M. BERMAN, U.S.D.J. A. Background This ruling

306 425 FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES t In short, the issue now before the Court has arisen only because Donziger unjustifi- ably has refused to comply with his discov- ery obligations. Had he done so — i.e., had he produced responsive documents as to which the

al abuse.' The program's design was led by Kenneth R. Feinberg, and Camille S. Biros—all nationally recognized claims-administration experts.' Mr. Feinberg is the nation's leading expert in crafting effective dispute resolution alternatives, and, with Ms. Biros, they have designed and ' Ex. A (Decl. of

. Donziger, No. 19-CR-561 (LAP), 2021 WL 1865376, at *4 (S.D.N.Y. May 10, 2021). The test set forth in Nixon "governs both varieties" of subpoenas. Donziger, 2021 WL 1865376, at *4. Under Nixon, the subpoena must "clear three hurdles: (1) relevancy; (2) admissibility; (3) specificity." Nixon, 418 U.S. a