Epstein Secrets

"an express confidentiality provision." In opposing the Motion to Unseal the NPA that was filed by Jane Doe, you stated that you had informed Judge Marra of the confidentiality provision during an earlier telephonic status conference occurring on August 14, 2008 which "the United States was obligated

E DOE, et al., 6 Plaintiffs, vs. JUNE 12, 2009 7 8 JEFFREY EPSTEIN, 9 Defendant. 10 11 TRANSCRIPT OF MOTION HEARING BEFORE THE HONORABLE KENNETH A. MARRA, 12 UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE APPEARANCES: 13 14 FOR THE PLAINTIFFS: ADAM D. HOROWITZ, ESQ. Mermelstein & Horowitz 15 18205 Biscayne Bou

ed by Jane Doe, you stated that you had informed Judge Marra of the confidentiality provision during an earlie

/24/2009 Page 48 oftlj e 48 investigation 10:18 38:2 43:7 investigations 22:13 34:11 invited 27:6 involvement 6:6 irreparable 9:16 10:1 41:7 ISIDRO 1:20 issue 4:23 6:5,11,19 7:4 11:25 12:18,22 14:14 15:25 16:2 16:13,22 18:12,22 21:18 28:10,16 33:4,14,24 42:8,23 42:24 issued 14:25 issues

ng the information that you have in that regard voluntarily, as opposed to us having to conduct formal discovery to get it. As you also know, Judge Marra has recently ordered discovery to proceed in this case. We obviously would like for that process to go as smoothly as possible and want to avoid be

E DOE, et al., 6 Plaintiffs, JUNE 12, 2009 7 VS. 8 JEFFREY EPSTEIN, 9 Defendant. 10 11 TRANSCRIPT OF MOTION HEARING BEFORE THE HONORABLE KENNETH A. MARRA, 12 UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE APPEARANCES: 13 14 FOR THE PLAINTIFFS: ADAM D. HOROWITZ, ESQ. Mermelstein & Horowitz 15 18205 Biscayne Bou

ct formal discovery to get it. As you also know, Judge Marra has recently ordered discovery to proceed in this

06/24/2009 Page 48 ofd 48 investigation 10:18 38:2 43:7 investigations 22:13 34:11 invited 27:6 involvement 6:6 irreparable 9:16 10:1 41:7 ISIDRO 1:20 issue 4:23 6:5,11,19 7:4 11:25 12:18,22 14:14 15:25 16:2 16:13,22 18:12,22 21:18 28:10,16 33:4,14,24 42:8,23 42:24 issued 14:25 issues

uct formal discovery to get it As you also know, Judge Marra has recently ordered discovery to proceed in this

ing the information that you have in that regard voluntarily, as opposed to us having to conduct formal discovery to get it As you also know, Judge Marra has recently ordered discovery to proceed in this case. We obviously would like for that process to go as smoothly as possible and want to avoid be

E DOE, et al., 6 Plaintiffs, vs. JUNE 12, 2009 7 8 JEFFREY EPSTEIN, 9 Defendant. 10 11 TRANSCRIPT OF MOTION HEARING BEFORE THE HONORABLE KENNETH A. MARRA, 12 UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE APPEARANCES: 13 14 FOR THE PLAINTIFFS: ADAM D. HOROWITZ, ESQ. Mermelstein & Horowitz 15 18205 Biscayne Bou

6/24(2009 Page 48 oipJe 48 investigation 10:18 38:2 43:7 investigations 22:13 34:11 invited 27:6 involvement 6:6 irreparable 9:16 10:1 41:7 ISIDRO 120 issue 4236:5,11,19 7:4 11:25 12:18,22 14:14 15:25 16:2 limitation 25:2 limitations 36:4,7,11 41:20 limited 4:21 8:3 14:5 17:12 20:19 23:2

rcement of Crime Victim's Rights Acts (A-I)." The victim also asked the federal court to allow her to share the NPA with third parties (A-3). Judge Marra denied the motion, finding — as the U.S. Government had argued (A-4) — that the NPA was not a record of the federal court. (A-6) ("First, as respon

ORIDA JANE DOE, et al., Plaintiffs, I JUNE 12, 2009 vs. JEFFREY EPSTEIN, I Defendant. 11 TRANSCRIPT OF MOTION HEARING BEFORE THE HONORABLE KENNETH A. MARRA, 12 UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE APPEARANCES: 13 14 FOR THE PLAINTIFFS: ADAM D. HOROWITZ, ESQ. Mermelstein & Horowitz 15 16 For Jane Doe

w her to share the NPA with third parties (A-3). Judge Marra denied the motion, finding — as the U.S. Governm

:14 EFTA00233727 Page 48 investigation 10:18 38:2 43:7 investigations 22:13 34:11 Invited 27:6 Involvement 6:6 Irreparable 9:16 10:1 41:7 ISIDRO 1:20 Issue 4:23 6:5,11,19 7:4 11:25 12:18,22 14:14 15:25 16:2 16:13,22 18:12,22 21:18 28:10,16 33:4,14,24 42:8,23 42:24 issued 14:25 issues

s, vs. JEFFREY EPSTEIN, Defendant. x APPEARANCES: WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA JUNE 12, 2009 TRANSCRIPT OF MOTION HEARING BEFORE THE HONORABLE KENNETH A. MARRA, UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE FOR THE PLAINTIFFS: For Jane Doe TOTAL ACCESS COURTROOM NETWORK REALTIME TRANSCRIPTION EFTA00212053 Case 9:08-cv

29:1,16 34:5 38:12,13 39:11 41:14 making 42:7 43:9,24 44:5 man 12:24 mandate 7:24 8:20 8:21 10:3 many 20:23 31:3 35:17 42:1 Marie 2:14 4:9 MARRA 1:11 Martin 2:17 4:16 Master 21:2 32:16 matter 20:15 37:13 44:19 matters 21:11 may 3:3 5:1 7:2,10 9:9,12 10:4,17 11:19 13:17,18 14:18 15:12

06/24/2009 Page 48 ogle 48 investigation 10:18 38:2 43:7 investigations 22:13 34:11 invited 27:6 involvement 6:6 irreparable 9:16 10:1 41:7 ISIDRO 1:20 issue 4:23 6:5,11,19 7:4 11:25 12:18,22 14:14 15:25 16:2 16:13,22 18:12,22 21.18 28:10,16 33:4,14,24 42:8,23 42:24 issued 14:25 issues

E DOE, et al., 6 Plaintiffs, vs. JUNE 12, 2009 7 8 JEFFREY EPSTEIN, 9 Defendant. 10 11 TRANSCRIPT OF MOTION HEARING BEFORE THE HONORABLE KENNETH A. MARRA, 12 UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE APPEARANCES: 13 14 FOR THE PLAINTIFFS: ADAM D. HOROWITZ, ESQ. Mermelstein & Horowitz 15 18205 Biscayne Bou

4 29:1,16 34:5 38:12,13 39:11 41:14 making 42:7 43:9,24 44:5 man 12:24 mandate 7:24 820 8:21 10:3 many 2023 31:3 35:17 42:1 Marie 2:14 4:9 MARRA 1:11 Martin 2:174:16 Master 21:2 32:16 matter 20:15 37:13 44:19 matters 21:11 may 3:3 5:172,10 99,1210:4,17 11:19 13:17,18 14:18 15:12 16:18

6/24/2009 Page 48 ot§je 48 investigation 10:18 38:2 43:7 investigations 22:13 34:11 Invited 27:6 Involvement 6:6 irreparable 9:16 10:1 41:7 ISIDRO 1:20 issue 423 6:5,11,19 7:4 11:25 12:18,22 14:14 15:25 16:2 16:13,22 18:12,22 21:18 28:10,16 33:4,14,2442:8,23 4224 issued 14:25 issues 4:2

ermelstein 6 Horowitz 18205 Biscayne Boulevard 151 Miami, FL 33160 For Jane Doe APPEARANCES: TRANSCRIPT OF MOTION HEARING BEFORE THE HONORABLE KENNETH A. MARRA, UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE 16 BRADLEY J. EDWARDS, ESQ. 17 Rothstein Rosenfeldt Adler 401 East Las Olas Boulevard 18 Fort Lauderdale, FL 33

3 4:18 35:17 42:1 213 303 3521 17:7,9,14,21,24 31:6 32:17 334 ggs 102 Mark 2:1441 38:18 32:1 35:15,20 35:14 393 41:13 legal 10:1324:10,13 MARRA 1:11 move 722 8:18 19:1 ammerom 23:21 41:1642:10,16,17 352138:12403 Mar* 2:17 4:16 192021:17,21 0 43:17 41:5439 Master 212 32:16 37:12 obj

21 KENNETH 1:11 key 32:9 wag mu 0 76:17 39:11,22 knew 27:1 41:20 Sodded 4:21 8:3 14:5 17:12 20;19 2325 30:19 limits 28:5 [email protected] ISIDRO 1:20 know 4:22 6:17 Sal 44:24 merits 22:1 none 13:25 ham 4:236:5,11,19 11:14 121 13:9,17 Nit 17:1,2,6 35:16 Mennebteb 1:14 Don-contesting 28:

f the NPA through the federal proceedings before Judge Marra (see 's response to the petition filed herewith

2,18 27:24 29:1,16 34:5 38:12,13 39:11 41:14 making 42:7 43:9,24 44:5 man 12:24 mandate 7:24 8:20 8:21 10:3 many 20:23 31:3 42:1 2:14 4:9 MARRA 1:11 Martin 2:17 4:16 Master 21:2 32:16 matter 20:15 37:13 44:19 matters 21:11 may 3:3 5:1 7:2,10 9:9,12 10:4,17 11:19 13:17,18 14:18 15:12

:14 EFTA00184080 Page 48 Investigation 10:18 38:2 43:7 Investigations 22:13 34;11 Invited 27:6 Involvement 6:6 irreparable 9:16 10:1 41:7 ISIDRO 1:20 Issue 4:23 6:5,11,19 7:4 11:25 12:18,22 14:14 15:25 16:2 16:13,22 18:12,22 21:18 28:10,16 33:4,14,24 42:8,23 42:24 issued 14:25 Issues