Epstein Secrets

6/30/08 BSI 6/27/2008 AUSA Villafafia notifies Attorney Edwards of upcoming change of plea and urges his clients

#33, #37 (via Michael E. Dutko), #38, #44 biaJeffni Herman) 8-90 9/W2008 Victim notification letters to #36, #35 (via Brad Edwards), #42, #43 (via Brad Edwards) B-9I 9/12/2008 Notification of Identified Victim letter #39 B-92 9/15/2008 Mailed victim notification letters for #I8 and #32 15-93 9/17/2008-

77 6/27/2008 Counsel for Epstein advise USAO of Epstein state court change of plea on 6/30/08 BSI 6/27/2008 AUSA Villafafia notifies Attorney Edwards of upcoming change of plea and urges his clients to attend 6/27/2008 USAO notifies Palm Beach Police Chief Reiter of upcoming change of plea. He

9 Villafafia Roy Black Letter in response to 11/02/09 letter re Epstein's place of employment with attached Complaint against Scott Rothstein and Bradley J. Edwards 1/4/2010 Villafafia Spencer Kuvin Letter re computer seized by FBI 1/20/2010 Villafalia Roy Black Letter re attorney's fees 1/21/2010 Villaf

s advice on some of the issues — legal and non-legal — that arose during the case. Assistant U.S. Attorney Lynn Kirkpatrick (still at the USAO): Ms. Kirkpatrick and I are friends from my time in Miami. She was a supervisor in Miami although not in my chain of command. I would often speak or email with her j

tem 18 then is defamation litigation. And your Honor is aware that there was a separate lawsuit that's spun out of this situation where Cassell and Edwards filed a defamation action in Florida State Court against Alan Dershowitz. Alan. Dershowitz then counterclaimed. That was litigated in Florida Stat

forth because we think it's irrelevant. But if there was to be some kind of an attack launched on any of the members of the Boies Schiller Firm, of Brad Edwards, myself, we would ask that we be given leave to address that at sidebar, in-camera, or outside the presence of the jury SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS

spond to that overview. They reference Mueller and Kirkpatrick, a treatise that we think is very instructive on this particular point. Mueller and Kirkpatrick says, "It is true that in a defamation case there is more latitude to introducing reputational types of evidence. However, it's important to remem

7 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 H3V0GIU1 -1 so let meet respond to that overview. They reference Mueller and Kirkpatrick, a treatise that we think is very instructive on this particular point. Mueller and Kirkpatrick says, "It is true that in a defamation case there

tem 18 then is defamation litigation. And your Honor is aware that there was a separate lawsuit that's spun out of this situation where Cassell and Edwards filed a defamation action in Florida State Court against Alan Dershowitz. Alan Dershowitz then counterclaimed. That was litigated in Florida State

forth because we think it's irrelevant. But if there was to be some kind of an attack launched on any of the members of the Boies Schiller Firm, of Brad Edwards, myself, we would ask that we be given leave to address that at sidebar, in-camera, or outside the presence of the jury SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS

10 id. 12 13 14 L5 16 ne) 18 life) 20 21 22 23 24 25 val H3VOGIU1 so let meet respond to that overview. They reference Mueller and Kirkpatrick, a treatise that we think is very instructive on this particular point. Mueller and Kirkpatrick says, "It is true that ina defamation case there i

spond to that overview. They reference Mueller and Kirkpatrick, a treatise that we think is very instructive on this particular point. Mueller and Kirkpatrick says, "It is true that ina defamation case there is more latitude to introducing reputational types of evidence. However, it's important to rememb

hen is defamation litigation. And your Honor 10 is aware that there was a separate lawsuit that's spun out of 11 this situation where Cassell and Edwards filed a defamation 12 action in Florida State Court against Alan Dershowitz. Alan 13 Dershowitz then counterclaimed. That was litigated in Florid

that overview. 2 They reference Mueller and Kirkpatrick, a treatise 3 that we think is very instructive on this particular point. 4 Mueller and Kirkpatrick says, "It is true that in a 5 defamation case there is more latitude to introducing 6 reputational types of evidence. However, it's important to

UTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. (212) 805-0300 EFTA00794625 71 H3V0GIU1 1 so let meet respond to that overview. 2 They reference Mueller and Kirkpatrick, a treatise 3 that we think is very instructive on this particular point. 4 Mueller and Kirkpatrick says, "It is true that in a 5 defamation ca

E BRANNON Anne Cheever Jennifer Freeman , Brad Edwards „ C Trisch Steel . "James R. Marsh" , Jennife

, Sigrid McCawley , COLETTE BRANNON Anne Cheever Jennifer Freeman , Brad Edwards „ C Trisch Steel . "James R. Marsh" , Jennifer Plotkin Subject: (EXTERNAL EMAIL] - DAVID BOIES & BED WARDS have made my life a complete living h

0 . CO co CD = cD CD CD r -t- —Pt —3 CD 5 • CD CD UZI —3 7-t: CD —3 B 0 r Acel No: I :23CRi PAC ISo be a liar. Ms. nd Mr. Kirkpatrick have reported they arc fearful of Mr. Tonks sit vate emails, recorded phone calls, and other personal information about her and other alb ;tims rel

ai l Sigrid McCawley David Boics COLETTE Brad Edwards Angela Jackson BRANNON Subject: [EXTERNAL EMAI

From: To: Juliette COLETTE BRANNON C Trisch Emily Steelai l Sigrid McCawley David Boics COLETTE Brad Edwards Angela Jackson BRANNON Subject: [EXTERNAL EMAIL) Anne Chen•cr will not stop abusing us Date: Sun, 25 May 2025 16:29:15 +0000 Importance: Norma

inwir mow oor. eft • fa., P./.70. C on duo, i C4, 1 tatea, Ca.d 1 • WG ma. 0 0 V EFTA01653062 r AciNes: UDCW PACTSS: be a liar. and Mr. Kirkpatrick have reported they are fearful of Mr. Tonks sha vale emails, recorded phone calls, and other personal information about her and other alh :tims rel

Florida jail were like only from the reporting of a local newspaper." Florida Today correspondents attempted "to fill in gaps about what happened to Edwards while he was in Brevard County Sheriff's Office custody on Dec. 10, 2018. But the agency refused to publicly share the security camera footage of a

with his dad and was trying to become a firefighter. He even pulled a woman out of a car wreck and gave her CPR about two weeks before his arrest, Kirkpatrick said. Assistant Attorney General Gregory Townsend, however, portrayed Bellar as an instructor at Wolverine Watchmen training sessions who surveilled

lorida jail were like only from the reporting of a local newspaper." Florida Today correspondents attempted "to fill in gaps about what happened to Edwards while he was in Brevard County Sheriff's Office custody on Dec. 10, 2018. But the agency refused to publicly share the security camera footage of a

with his dad and was trying to become a firefighter. He even pulled a woman out of a car wreck and gave her CPR about two weeks before his arrest, Kirkpatrick said. Assistant Attorney General Gregory Townsend, however, portrayed Bellar as an instructor at Wolverine Watchmen training sessions who surveille

lorida jail were like only from the reporting of a local newspaper." Florida Today correspondents attempted "to fill in gaps about what happened to Edwards while he was in Brevard County Sheriff's Office custody on Dec. 10, 2018. But the agency refused to publicly share the security camera footage of a

with his dad and was trying to become a firefighter. He even pulled a woman out of a car wreck and gave her CPR about two weeks before his arrest, Kirkpatrick said. Assistant Attorney General Gregory Townsend, however, portrayed Bellar as an instructor at Wolverine Watchmen training sessions who surveille

lorida jail were like only from the reporting of a local newspaper." Florida Today correspondents attempted "to fill in gaps about what happened to Edwards while he was in Brevard County Sheriff's Office custody on Dec. 10, 2018. But the agency refused to publicly share the security camera footage of a

with his dad and was trying to become a firefighter. He even pulled a woman out of a car wreck and gave her CPR about two weeks before his arrest, Kirkpatrick said. Assistant Attorney General Gregory Townsend, however, portrayed Bellar as an instructor at Wolverine Watchmen training sessions who surveille