Epstein Secrets

6/30/08 BSI 6/27/2008 AUSA Villafafia notifies Attorney Edwards of upcoming change of plea and urges his clients

#33, #37 (via Michael E. Dutko), #38, #44 biaJeffni Herman) 8-90 9/W2008 Victim notification letters to #36, #35 (via Brad Edwards), #42, #43 (via Brad Edwards) B-9I 9/12/2008 Notification of Identified Victim letter #39 B-92 9/15/2008 Mailed victim notification letters for #I8 and #32 15-93 9/17/2008-

77 6/27/2008 Counsel for Epstein advise USAO of Epstein state court change of plea on 6/30/08 BSI 6/27/2008 AUSA Villafafia notifies Attorney Edwards of upcoming change of plea and urges his clients to attend 6/27/2008 USAO notifies Palm Beach Police Chief Reiter of upcoming change of plea. He

9 Villafafia Roy Black Letter in response to 11/02/09 letter re Epstein's place of employment with attached Complaint against Scott Rothstein and Bradley J. Edwards 1/4/2010 Villafafia Spencer Kuvin Letter re computer seized by FBI 1/20/2010 Villafalia Roy Black Letter re attorney's fees 1/21/2010 Villaf

29/2008 Email from Jell Sloman to Marie Villafafta, Bob Senior, Karen Atkinson, E. Nesbitt KtnTkendaII, and Jason Richards informing them that l)AG Filip agreed to review matter and that grand jury presentation was canceled 13-41 8/28/2008 Letter front Michael Danchuk to Marie Villafaila regarding

Letter from Rubin Katz Law Firm to represent Zorro Ranch (May 26, 2010) Bill Riley Supervision of Bill Riley Decision Re JE Bar Complaint Against Brad Edwards EFTA00300494 Civil Cases PBL Research by DKI CASE CASE CASE (Synopsis of Case, Retention to Provide Legal Services, Notice of Change of Atto

2007 -Letter To Lilly Sanchez From Alexander Acosta, Dec. 19, 2007 -Letter to Mike Tein from July 17, 2008 -Notification of Identified Victim (to Edwards from (Victim Info 2008) -Epstein-Responses-Confidential (Final Aug. 16. 2007) -Compilation DVD Made by -Video Depositions (Could use in Brad Edw

Edwards from (Victim Info 2008) -Epstein-Responses-Confidential (Final Aug. 16. 2007) -Compilation DVD Made by -Video Depositions (Could use in Brad Edwards Case) Bill Riley Investigations Sent to Mike Tein and Roy Black MERRIE SPAETH COMMUNICATIONS, INC. MERRIE SPAETH CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT PBL INVOICE

ASSURANCE VOLUMES I & II BACKUP BINDERS PALM BEACH LITIGATION -Non-Prosecution Agreement and Addendum -June 12, 2008 Draft DOJ Letter -Letter to Filip from Starr and Whitley (5-27-08) -March 28, 2008 Letter to DOJ -DOJ Submission (Summary) -DOJ Submission (Attachment Letter) EFTA00300514 -Apri

cedures. I don't remember saying anything different in this case. I did not see any FBI letters in this case prior to collecting the FBI letters to Brad Edwards' clients in connection with the Jane Doe I United States litigation. I did not instruct the FBI to include the language about the case being under in

y Circuit Court (Exhibit B-41). I responded, acknowledging his representation (Exhibit B-42). On June 18, 2008, I liv received a call from attorney Brad ards, who told me that he represented Individual #43, who is also Jane Doe #1 in the Jane Doe United States lawsuit. Mr. Edwards expressed an interest

a call from attorney Brad ards, who told me that he represented Individual #43, who is also Jane Doe #1 in the Jane Doe United States lawsuit. Mr. Edwards expressed an interest in assisting with the case. We were still waiting to hear about whether we would be moving " On the State side, Lefkowitz has

lts of the continued investigation (Exhibit B-38). The agents continued locating and interviewing more victims (see, e.g., Exhibit B-126). When DAG Filip agreed to consider Epstein's challenges, the planned grand jury presentation was canceled (Exhibit 8-40). Even after that delay, the agents and I p

as a “kindhearted prosecutor who tried to do right,” noting that she “believ[ed] in the victims and tr[ied] . . . to bring down Jeffrey Epstein.” Bradley J. Edwards with Brittany Henderson, Relentless Pursuit at 380 (Gallery Books 2020). 233 [M]y expectation of what was going [to] happen at the plea was

ho wished to be heard were permitted to speak at the plea hearing. 346 Dean, 527 F.3d at 394. 347 Before Epstein’s state court plea hearing, Edwards also began representing the victim who became Jane Doe #2. Although OPR focuses on Villafaña’s communications with Edwards in this section, OPR not

n.” 356 Villafaña stated that she “never told Attorney Edwards that the state charges involved ‘other victims,’

uted and sent to jail too, but you know the husband’s willing to go and take the weight . . . . This is not one of those. Deputy Attorney General Filip called the provision “pretty weird.” Menchel’s successor as Criminal Chief told OPR that he had never heard of such a thing in his 33 years of exp

United States litigation, asserting that his clients wanted to 4 1 few days after Jeffrey Epstein entered his guilty plea in state court, attorney Brad Edwards filed suit on behalf of one of the victims identified in the federal investigation (later expanded to include I second victim who had been identifie

ng aside the NPA would not benefit his clients, and he sued Epstein on behalf of I number of victims under the NPA. I did what I could to assist Mr. Edwards, other attorneys, including Mr. Josefsberg, the attorney selected by the Special Master, and the Court, to locate victims, provide signed copies of

lts of the continued investigation (Exhibit B-38). The agents continued locating and interviewing more victims (see, e.g., Exhibit B-126). When DAG Filip agreed to consider Epstein's challenges, the planned grand jury presentation was canceled (Exhibit B-40). Even after that delay, the agents and I p

JOSEPH JAFFE Attorney for Defendant SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. EFTA00079746 1 2 3 J7FYEPSC APPEARANCES ( Also Present: David Boies Brad Edwards , NYPD 4 , FBI 5 6 U.S. Pretrial Services n} 7 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS

ropriate with me. I would prefer not to go into the details of that at this time. Yes. THE COURT: Thank you very much. MS. : You're welcome. MR. EDWARDS: Your Honor, may I also be heard? THE COURT: Absolutely. MR. EDWARDS: Brad Edwards. I represent who wishes to make a statement today to the Court.

ufficient discretion that should be accorded to the U.S. Attorney. An appeal was then taken to the Deputy Attorney General who at the time was Mr. Filip, F-i-l-i-p. Again, I may be butchering his name. THE COURT: That's his last name? MR. : That's his last name. Mark I think is his first name. H

JAFFE Attorney for Defendant SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. EFTA00095388 1 2 3 J7FYEPSC APPEARANCES (Cont'd) Also Present: David Boies Brad Edwards NYPD 4 , FBI 5 6 U.S. Pretrial Services n} 7 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS,

ropriate with me. I would prefer not to go into the details of that at this time. Yes. THE COURT: Thank you very much. MS. : You're welcome. MR. EDWARDS: Your Honor, may I also be heard? THE COURT: Absolutely. MR. EDWARDS: Brad Edwards. I represent who wishes to make a statement today to the Court.

ufficient discretion that should be accorded to the U.S. Attorney. An appeal was then taken to the Deputy Attorney General who at the time was Mr. Filip, F-i-l-i-p. Again, I may be butchering his name. THE COURT: That's his last name? MR. : That's his last name. Mark I think is his first name. H

Letter from Rubin Katz Law Firm to represent Zorro Ranch (May 26, 2010) Bill Riley Supervision of Bill Riley Decision Re JE Bar Complaint Against Brad Edwards FIFTH DRAWER: DKI Miscellaneous Letter of Representation for JEE Pacer Michelle Health Care Proxy Camp Medical Forms 2005 All Media Consultant

Riley Decision Re JE Bar Complaint Against Brad Edwards FIFTH DRAWER: DKI Miscellaneous Letter of Repr

LEFKOWITZ DKI RESEARCH FOURTH DRAWER: PALM BEACH LITIGATION -Non-Prosecution Agreement and Addendum -June 12, 2008 Draft DOJ Letter -Letter to Filip from Starr and Whitley (5-27-08) -March 28, 2008 Letter to DOJ -DOJ Submission (Summary) -DOJ Submission (Attachment Letter) -April 8, 2009 Submi

ents of the NPA as early as October of 2008. She was also provided pro bono counsel with the assistance of the Government prior to her retaining Mr. Edwards, see Villafana Declaration, Dkt. 14 at pg 4, Motion at 25 ("the Special Agents have said that they explained that Epstein would plead guilty to sta

after September 24, 2007. Also, appeals to the Department of Justice (to both the head of the Criminal Division and then to Deputy Attorney General Filip) by Epstein's counsel contesting whether there was a sufficient jurisdictional basis for the underlying federal investigation were ongoing, see e.g.

im's Reply to Opposition to Victim's Motion to Unseal Non-Prosecution Agreement in Jane Doe No. 1, et aL v. M., 08-80736; 2) 10/9/2008 letter from Edwards48 tee: false statements by the government; and 3) 10/15/2008 letter from Edwards to ■ re: whether Epstein violated the non-prosecution agreement 2

IVILEGED & CONFIDENTIAL 9 EFTA00296187 CHRONOLOGY OF JEFFREY EPSTEIN'S DOCUMENTS Date Document 194. 5/28/2008 Letter from Starr and Whitley to Filip it: exigency of previous request for review 195. 6/12/2008, 2:56 pm Email from Epstein to Indyke, forwarding email attaching draft letter re: i