T NIESSAIM RETRIEVAL 861 0501 113IA NEW YORK NY IMIN UNLIMITE N:WIIN MIN 804 0420 01:4W NEW YORK NY I MIN UNLIM MOBL TO mom 862 0521 1122A UNCOMIC MAIN UNLIMITED N:WICND MIN I EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 863 0501 11:46.4 INCIDWINO 1 MIN UNLIMITEO NWKND MIN 805 04130 01:48P BROOKLYN NY MIN

IME MINUTES 009 347 1002 09279 INCOMNG I MIN UNLIMITED tiNNOVD MIN 288 09:27 08:22P INCOMING I MN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 0.09 348 1002 10A4P UNCOMIC I MIN UNUMTED NWKND MN 289 09.27 08:32P INCOMING 3IAIN 0.09 AIRTIME MINUTES 027 349 1002 11:22P (581)512-3087 WPALMBEACH FL MN UNLIMITED NP

1000 NIGHTMKEND MIN 370 1030 04:42P WOOING 1 MIN 000 N GHTMKENEIMIN 308 10129 09:10P WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN 1000 NIGHTMKEND MIN 371 1030 05:53P UNCOMIC 1 MIN 000 N GIRMKENI3 MIN 309 10,29 1DAOP INCOMING 2MIN 1000 NIGITIMKEND MIN 372 1040 05:58P INCOMSIG 5MIN 000 N GICTMKEM3 MIN 310 10129 1

UK --- - Cont. Charge Calls To Only Used Description Charge NEWYORKZNI NY 1 MIN DISCOUNT NT'L ROAM 0.99 INCOMNG 1 MIN NT NIL ROAM 0.99 UNCOMIC MIN INT NIL ROAM 0.99 NEW YORK NY SAC DISCOUNT NFL ROAM 1.98 INCOMING MIN DISCOUNT wri. ROAM 0.99 INCOMING 4 MIN DISCOUNT NFL ROAM 3.96

ES 746 0620 12 21P (340)774-1611 CHTMISTTHS VI i MN UNLIMITED *WM 809 0621 02 49P 310 702-0169 OARDENA CA 2,481 NCLUDEr UTES 747 0620 1225P UNCOMIC i MN UNLIMITED HINKN 810 06.21 02 51P 212502-6518 NEW YORK NY ilAN NCLUDE MINUTES 748 0620 1226P (561 136730 661 04-9849 749 0640 12273 4 L

4A moNct 1W I MIN UNLIMITED NWKND MIN 237 05116 1123A NEW YORK NY 4PAIN UNLIMITED NWKND MIN I MIN 0.26 ENH DISC NT DL 0.26 238 05116 1127A UNCOMIC 1MIN UNLIMITED NWKND MIN 82 091510:45* WPALMBEACH FL 31AIN UNLIMITED NWKND MIN 1 EVT CALL WMTING 83 0915 11:09A NEW YORK NY I MIN UNLIMIT

NLIMITED NWXND MIN 244 091606:51* NEW YORK NY 1MIN 400 AMYL ANYTME MIN 181 0813 1O2OP NEW YORK NY I MN UNLIMITED NWKND MIN 245 09 16 O9:44A UNCOMIC 1MIN 400 ADOI. ANYTME MIN 182 0913 1O22P NY ZONE I NY I MN UNLIPTED NVOCND MIN 246 0916 12:0IP INCOIMIG 1MIN 400 AMYL ANYTME MIN 183 09:13

NCLWEO MINUTES 679 01/19 0 E15P MIN M 029 EM4 DISC NT IX 1.45 NEW YORK NY I DMA' MOBL TO 140EIL 1 EVT 1.50 411 NFO ISO 5410 01/19 05 7P UNCOMIC I MIN INCLUDED MINUTES 523 01/161059A INCOMNO 1 MIN INCLUDED MINUTES 581 01/19 05 34P NEW YORK NY 2MIN UNUM MOBL TO MOBL 524 01/181059A W

10:50AM M PAIN FL 2 SRK1 P 0.00 426 09/28 11:07AM MOPES CL 3 SRN1 P 0.00 427 09/28 11z44AM W PAIN FL 2 smia P 0.00 428 09/28 02:06214 UNCOMIC CL 1 SRK1 P 0.00 429 09/28 02:12PM M PALM FL 2 SP.H1 P 0.00 410 09/28 02:14PM M PALM FL 1 snia P 0.00 EFTA01715948 Page: Billing Cycl

MN AA NYME 400 ADM WOL MIN 400 ACOL AMUR MN 191 05/10 0224P 182 0611003:369 NEW ORK NY MIN NIPSn AD _na MIN MIN ni TO Mrs, 743 05/1 0333 UNCOMIC MN EVE 400 ADM. ANYTME MN CALL WAITING VI ME SAGER( PIE A 244 OM OS 301 NWYRCY/T401 NY RI 460 ADM NOME MN Case No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA SCIN

OMING NEWYORK NY IN WILLOUGHBY ON COMING INCOMING NCOMIM NEW YORK NY QUEENS NY QUEENS NY NEW YORK NY NEW YORK NY NEW YORK NY NEW YORK NY UNCOMIC NEW YORK NY NEW YOR INCOMINGK NY NCOMNG NEW YORK NY INCOMNG QUEENS NY NEW YORK NY NEW YORK NY NEW YORK NY NEWYORKIN1 NY IN CO NEW YORK NY

LIMN MOBL TOMOBL MN uNUM MOB/ TO 04 37 OW M MW YORK NY M_OBL MN 400 AMYL AN INE MN Subscriber Government Fees and Taxes 38 04/35 0410/4 UNCOMIC MN UMW MOW TOMMIE EVT CALL WAITING kern Desaipthan Charge 39 04050611P MW YORK NY WM 403 ADO ANYTME MN 40 0405 0924P MW YORK NY MN UMW

N TM: MN INCOMNG 2MN AMAMI ANYTME MN INCOMING 6MIN 40) AMYL ANYYME MN M V•ha'ORK NY MAIN 400M7En. MINTME MN ULU.. 31014 40)ADim. Min( MN UNCOMIC INN 403ADDI ANYTME MN NEW YORK NY I N N UNLIM MODE TO MOBL SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER PARAGRAPHS 7, 8, 9, 10, 15, and 17 Charge SDNY GM_0277