Monsignor Bendik of her concerns about the relationship between Liberatore and Plaintiff. (Helen Negvesky Dep. 40:5-21, Nov. 17,2005, Doc. 80-4.) Negvesky testi- fied that she told Monsignor Bendik that Plaintiff was "around the Rectory more than [she] thought he should be, and the way Father [Libera

] looked at him, that they went places together, and just that it didn't seem right, . .. [and] it didn't look good." (Negvesky Dep. 41:22-42:3.) Negvesky also told Monsignor Bendik of an incident in which Plaintiff "put his hand down Liberatore's pants." (Negvesky Dep. 42:14-17.) Negvesky also stat

uspected that Liberatore was plying Plaintiff with alcohol. (Negvesky Dep. 43:14-22.) 751 Also in the fall of 2001, after receiving reports from Negvesky and Zongilla con- cerning suspicious behavior engaged in by Liberatore and Plaintiff, Father Williams spoke with Monsignor Bendik about the relati