d alleged that Liberatore had sexually abused them. (See Bishop Martino Dep. 108:16-18.) La- ter that month, Bishop Martino hired an investigator, James Seidel ("Seidel"), to investigate these allegations. (Bishop Martino Dep. 108:8-11; see James Seidel Investigative Insert, Doc. 89-5 pp. 16-17.) In Ma