udge APPEARANCES COOPER & KIRK Attorneys for Plaintiff BY: CHARLES J. COOPER MICHAEL W. KIRK NICOLE J. MOSS HALEY N. PROCTOR TODD & WELD BY: HOWARD COOPER CHRISTIAN KIELY -and- AIDALA BERTUNA & KAMINS BY: IMRAN H. ANSARI HON. BARRY KAMINS Attorneys for Defendant SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.