bin Mahfouz family, but Plaintiffs claim the purchase was not completed until January 2003, after the lawsuit was filed on September 4, 2002. See Fawcett Supp. Aff. at Ex. 3 & 4 (news ac- counts of sale). For the reasons that will be explained below, the Court finds it unneces- sary to resolve this dispute

ve unit of the Saudi Ministry of Finance, the Public Investment Fund ("PIF"),24 and (3) it is not a citizen of the United States Social Insurance. Fawcett Supp. Aff. at Ex. 2. Late in 2002 the PIF agreed to buy 30% of the remaining shares from the bin Mahfouz family, but Plaintiffs claim the purchase was