lack of awareness that Perlman had ever been applied outside the grand jury context, Opposition at 6, but a quick Westlaw search demonstrates that Penman has often been applied outside the grand jury context. See, e.g., Gotham Holdings, LP v. 7 EFTA00583460 D. The United States is a Disinterested

ar. Co., 244 F.2d 158, 162 & n.5 (11th Cir. 1955), a civil case. In just the few years since Mohawk, the Fourth Circuit found jurisdiction based on Penman in a civil case, Mezu v. Morgan State University, 495 Fed. Appx. 286, 289 (4th Cir. 2012); the Ninth Circuit has applied Perlman in a case arising u

Kle uPP 444144 rep W11 N rwpi.count NNW. All trailemants and woe* meis on see *amen berg to Donnie Bank AG or its &Main of Woneetera. eaten nod pre Penman or awn swim Wee an he newly of tree neon en wows No Gen, hinder Cewleron Secede l'GCS- I wat destined and 4. ew Neckar.* Weeny ked is »WO mirk al

C, a ebony owned Every Year Since 2007 subsidiary ogles enrol New York Mellon DAMAR IM1 ID COMMUMCATICMS Corporate. (MY Mellon) nm . EXCLUENCIE Penman 4E. nerdy F liRoetioeel YU:PM-00048626 DB-SDNY-0011450 EFTA_00 159235 EFTA01290980 F2 Deutsche Bank P.O.Box 1776, Baltimore, MD 21203 THE HAZE

et <Wrenn Fattet/ µatI1n 4 nut la Mae Ind? 1 We Dunne deln KØI,JIdnuII arm One De rope lttril nett en nifron of WA" Do its aNue. ren 0 rery aata Penman' retimtwO ern* Virnttitttlatm.O$1. mrrnmOlitin n tOtlitiOn. uuch Tanis Nan not teen nclultel in Ite Mete? You, Irnorritbon. Sunman!», Or Me Anal A

t teat ectotal R We Motet babe Infonnants Sunman. a n Amel Anonon pawn's,' kt IM hilgifin, 9011116 $111510111 (»Olean/1Se »Sea wan tatty.» co othe Penman Sane med n reasmal n ahoy Or a pal note eonFrey $00" «event., nee 04Ct t<Vond »sawn roost note that yettuoysasno os ~soots n thh lebeeelel 1•

, but we decline to draw an arbitrary line. The victims' argument has an ipse dixit quality—that is, because our Court has never before applied the Penman doctrine outside of the grand jury context, we should not do so now. But we must ask instead whether applying the doctrine here makes sense. 11 E

, but we decline to draw an arbitrary line. The victims' argument has an ipse dixit quality—that is, because our Court has never before applied the Penman doctrine outside of the grand jury context, we should not do so now. But we must ask instead whether applying the doctrine here makes sense. 11 E

hat the Justice Department in other Courts of Appeals outside the Eleventh Circuit has argued that Mohawk implicitly narrows Perlman substantially. Penman is most commonly used by criminals who are targets of federal grand jury investigations, who seek to thwart and delay the Justice Department's inves

, but we decline to draw an arbitrary line. The victims' argument has an ipse dixit quality—that is, because our Court has never before applied the Penman doctrine outside of the grand jury context, we should not do so now. But we must ask instead whether applying the doctrine here makes sense. 11 E

New Zeorend with its rogistenad °ace • t 5 The Werehmice Way Nnithcoa. 0527 raw Zealand end hen maned Forrencler Sante Provider with number 4407661 Penman HZ taut (Na 5691727)a a company Incorporated kr Now Zealand war is resisterect °Oka at 5 The Weinnouse 'Nes Nommom. Auckara, 0627. Now ZaaNt2 and i

-Stied to start commercial operations at the Runatuto II Hydroelectno Plant. at the latest, on December IS, 2014 As consequence, the Company and the Penman State subscribed the correspondng supply enact In November 2014, the Company started operations at the Runahltia Ill Hydroelectric Part, which has

under its Scenish acronym) with the energy generated by its four hYdreeintee plants that ate canerni operating For the purpose. the Company and the Penman government signed RER contracts which have a 20-year period maturity, which establish that through Ire mechanism of RER Auctions, the Company receiv

%6112 NNNNNNNNNNH 000000000640000 AVILOOP LLC ASSETS Checking & Savings Chase Busmess.Select Checking Chase Business Select High Thiel Savings Penman. 01. 2012 through February 29. 2012 Primary Account. CUSTOMER SERVICE INFORMATION Web site. Chase tom Service ('enter 1400.242.7338 Hearing Im

ent and. except As otherwise agreethn wrong. these valuabonsdo not ropresentew actual terms a! warn annsactony or sonnet coufo be Gown: or sa or new Penman s coed to entatedima or too actual:tams on who* arising transactions or SOCOIWIOSCOUti be boodated as or, the dare 01 fas statement Weld not warrant

lb-4 a Oat cob ar lett pa • Si hrborg Ara • 1/4 0.1 itmilicn You ra n aVP.Sailt • OAP in.14 It. !Am 1.51,11 linsItclgon, • OPhowl.” d Nese. Os. M Penman me ce. pa a 'owes &Le la. t. I wwady M an. in • wrap In nal wants otaa.C.Sylalbata Mr CO.. maw garner las brawn,. 101.00.15. baby td ancone. tl

MOM MANUFACTURER 3 /ACM Raytheon Aircraft Company 400A QNOV 1 5 2004 "VIZ FOR FAA 118E ONLY TYRE OF REGISTRATION Ms* or Dal O I. %SLIM 0 2. Penman, O 3. °normal (14. COOMer 0 S Ora 0 L idelpted NAME a APPLICAIR (ennts) tam on prnews• 0 tromn/0. Il Vega ids NOS mu a ad didde IOW 0 14.) Fli

m does flat indepenitmly way a guarantee the waxy or vaiday f an/ -dominion Vondd by sources other than U35 Financial Smqes addlico, although 1.85 Penman Saran generalk updates this incematir as Sus received, the farm does not wand. any entrances Out the infamainon Leder "Cost bate and starmalced ge

taas wen aid*. wad yor Faunae adage • /Maw lareareems and structurial products. Pm*. -metiers taunt (nclidng dad pzapsion OrCgall aid real estate Penman an Sedated ad SWISS preduaS at genera hghly Maid Cabin savoured paLas ea» na brim attuned writhe Semmes aid ExClana Corr/moan a under any stare r