What is the Curcio issue in the Epstein files?

The Curcio issue refers to a legal conflict-of-interest hearing that arose in the case of Nicholas Tartaglione, Jeffrey Epstein's former cellmate at the Metropolitan Correctional Center. Named after the 1982 case United States v. Curcio, these hearings address situations where a defendant's attorney may have a conflict of interest, often when the attorney could become a witness. Judge Karas appointed attorney Sternheim as special Curcio counsel to handle this matter for Tartaglione.

Who is Nicholas Tartaglione and why does he appear in Epstein documents?

Nicholas Tartaglione is a former Briarcliff Manor police officer who was Epstein's cellmate at MCC in July 2019. Tartaglione found Epstein on the floor with something around his neck during what officials described as an apparent suicide attempt. Epstein later accused Tartaglione of trying to kill him, though prison officials found no evidence supporting this claim. Tartaglione was facing (and later received) a life sentence for the murder of four men.

Why was there a conflict of interest with Tartaglione's attorney?

The specific nature of the conflict isn't detailed in these brief document excerpts, but Curcio hearings typically occur when defense counsel may become a witness in the case or has other conflicts that could compromise effective representation. Given that Tartaglione was a key witness to Epstein's July 2019 incident and that surveillance footage from that event was later destroyed, it's possible the conflict related to Tartaglione's potential testimony about what he witnessed.

What is the Curcio issue in the Epstein files?

The Curcio issue refers to a legal conflict-of-interest hearing that arose in the case of Nicholas Tartaglione, Jeffrey Epstein's former cellmate at the Metropolitan Correctional Center. Named after the 1982 case United States v. Curcio, these hearings address situations where a defendant's attorney may have a conflict of interest, often when the attorney could become a witness. Judge Karas appointed attorney Sternheim as special Curcio counsel to handle this matter for Tartaglione.

Who is Nicholas Tartaglione and why does he appear in Epstein documents?

Nicholas Tartaglione is a former Briarcliff Manor police officer who was Epstein's cellmate at MCC in July 2019. Tartaglione found Epstein on the floor with something around his neck during what officials described as an apparent suicide attempt. Epstein later accused Tartaglione of trying to kill him, though prison officials found no evidence supporting this claim. Tartaglione was facing (and later received) a life sentence for the murder of four men.

Why was there a conflict of interest with Tartaglione's attorney?

The specific nature of the conflict isn't detailed in these brief document excerpts, but Curcio hearings typically occur when defense counsel may become a witness in the case or has other conflicts that could compromise effective representation. Given that Tartaglione was a key witness to Epstein's July 2019 incident and that surveillance footage from that event was later destroyed, it's possible the conflict related to Tartaglione's potential testimony about what he witnessed.

Back to People & Entities

Curcio

Organization

Total Mentions

Documents

Connected Entities

"Curcio" in the Epstein files refers to a legal proceeding addressing potential conflicts of interest between Nicholas Tartaglione (Epstein's former cellmate) and his attorney Bruce A. Barket, not an organization.

All four mentions reference a "Curcio issue" or "Curcio hearing" in court documents related to Nicholas Tartaglione's case. A Curcio hearing is a federal court procedure that addresses potential attorney-client conflicts of interest, typically when defense counsel may become a witness or have other conflicts. The documents show that Judge Karas appointed attorney Sternheim as special Curcio counsel to address this conflict, and that scheduling conflicts arose because Barket needed to attend both the Curcio hearing and a status conference for Tartaglione in the Eastern District of New York (EDNY).

Key Highlights

•Curcio is a legal term (United States v. Curcio, 680 F.2d 881), not a person or organization—it was misclassified by NER as ORGANIZATION
•The Curcio issue arose in Nicholas Tartaglione's case; Tartaglione was Epstein's cellmate at MCC during the July 2019 incident where Epstein was found with something around his neck
•Attorney Bruce A. Barket represented Tartaglione and faced scheduling conflicts between the Curcio hearing and EDNY status conferences in early March (year not specified but likely 2019-2020 timeframe)

Frequently Asked Questions

Books for Further Reading

Perversion of Justice: The Jeffrey Epstein Story

Julie K. Brown

Investigative journalism that broke the Epstein case open

Filthy Rich: The Jeffrey Epstein Story

James Patterson

Bestselling account of Epstein's crimes and network

Relentless Pursuit: My Fight for the Victims of Jeffrey Epstein

Bradley J. Edwards

Victims' attorney's firsthand account

Document Mentions (4)

EFTA00019063

2 mentions

me, then I may make another request or ask Judge Karas to help. I don't think there is much else that will be done next week other than address the Curcio issue. Thank you. Bruce A. Barket, Esq. Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP 666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700 Garden City, NY 11530 (516)

Page: EFTA00019063 →

the Court (EDNY) for March 4th off so I would be able to attend the status conference for Mr. Tartaglione and I explained briefly that there was a Curcio issue. That application was denied. So, I am wondering if you will be requesting more time to continue to review material and presumably get input f

Page: EFTA00019063 →

EFTA00017109 - EFTA00017122

1 mention

25 (In open court) THE COURT: All right. So the first thing that I think we should address, sounds like it might be a brief conversation, is the Curcio issue I had alerted the government that there is -- a Curcio issue has arisen. I had appointed Ms. Sternheim to be Curcio counsel. She's here. MS.

Page: EFTA00017109 →