On 10/31/04, fight occurred between plamtiff and Preston-in back of cab. Plaintiff (age 17) had been drin

including having her head smashed into the hood of the car and the window of a car, spit upon and verbally abused by her former long term boyfriend, Preston Vineyard. Yet she kept returning to him. There is no affidavit filed by Jane Doe No. 4. So this new found, contrived emotion is just that. 20. Th