y’s favor by a vote of 9-3. Still the case was not over. The state sought a writ of certiorari from the Supreme Court which remanded the case back to the 9" Circuit for reconsideration in light of a recent Supreme Court decision. The 9" Circuit reconsidered and once again threw out Doody’s conviction on the groun

his confession involuntary and ordered him to be freed, unless the state granted him a new trial. The state then appealed the reversal to the entire 9" Circuit, which set the case down for argument before 11 judges. They also ruled in Doody’s favor by a vote of 9-3. Still the case was not over. The state sou