ton Legal Assistant to Robert Josefsberg Beth Williamson Paralegal RRA Bradley Edwards Attorney RRA Cara Holmes Attorney RRA Carl Linder Attorney RRA Carla Martinez Law Clerk at RRA Carolyn (Legal Asst. to Jay Howell, Co-Counsel) Carolyn Edwards (Legal Asst. to Jay Howell, Co-Counsel) Confidential Source Christin

n BATES DATE TO FROM DESCRIPTION OBJECTION to the discovery of the admissible evidence; protected by privacy rights 08157-08159 06/03/2009 Carla Martinez Bradley Edwards Vanity Fair Work product; attorney/client privilege; irrelevant and not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of the

n BATES PATE TO FROM DESCRIPTION OBJECTION to the discovery of the admissible evidence; protected by privacy rights 08157-08159 06/03/2009 Carla Martinez Bradley Edwards Vanity Fair Work product; attorney/client privilege; irrelevant and not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of the