However, we appreciate your concern that images that do not contain nudity appear to have been designated as Highly Confidential. Accordingly, I am working with the FBI to de-designate any images that do not depict genitals, breasts, or buttocks. Once those images have been de-designated, our office will produce them to you. Best, From: Laura Menninger Sent: Friday, May 7, 20214:43 PM To: Cc: (USANYS) ) < >; Jeff Pagliuca 'Bobbi Sternhei Subject: RE: US v. Maxwell - [conferral re photo and other discovery deficiencies) Thank you for your response of April 23. I haven't heard back from you last week as promised on this or my April 28 request, so I'm writing to follow up. I have responses to specific questions of yours below in blue. Additionally, I have more questions regarding your production of "highly confidential" ("HC") images and videos. When we met the week of April 13 in NY, during which time I requested to view all evidence in the government's possession, including all highly confidential material, you described for me two hard-drives that contained all of the HC images and videos from this case. • First, one of those hard-drives you said contained all of the materials extracted from the disks contained in the black binders. There were approximately 40,000 or so images (Excel spreadsheet SDNY_GM_00467567) of which 3,400 images were deemed HC and tagged "#nudity" by your team (SDNY_GM_00467568). (I still await a response regarding the problems with your metadata overlay). • Second, the other hard-drive contained images extracted from Epstein's devices which were searched pursuant to a warrant. You said the responsive image/video files were contained on that second hard-drive, and there were approximately 2,100 "nude" or HC images on that hard-drive. You did not produce the metadata for those images because it was still present on the files which had been digitally extracted. As I understood it then, there were approximately 5,500 HC images that you made available for review. However, the FBI Report dated January 27, 2021 (produced at SDNY_GM_02742399) indicates there are approximately 33,747 NC images and 895 HC videos that were identified by a digital review of CART-processed evidence; I presume based on the CART numbers that this list is the same as the images extracted from Epstein's devices, or as I understood it, the content on your hard-drive #2 above. I am completely unclear as to why you informed me that there were 2,100 nude images from Epstein's devices, but this report seems to indicate there were approximately 34,000 HC images and videos. Please let me know if I am misunderstanding what you told me and if so, what the correct information is. I reiterate my request that you provide to us hard-drives with all of the HC material minus any child pornography. I am available to discuss if that would be more convenient. Thanks, Laura Laura A. Menninger I Partner Haddon, Morgan & Foreman, P.C. EFTA00105360