Cc: Caroline Kitidis; Thomas ORorke; Matt Glassman; Daniel Sabba; Michael Iaquinta; Chip Packard Subject: RE: KCP IOI: Also,now we have a 50k IOI from Hart for PGRE; follow up on Hart Acquisitions/Watson IOI 30k shares for Virgin America (VA.US) [I] Classification: For internal use only Epstein is NOT coming in for VA. Only Hart and we have managed expectations. To be determined on PGRE. From: Joshua Shoshan Sent: Thursday, November 13, 2014 3:35 PM To: Haig Ariyan; Tazia Smith; Donald Summer Cc: Caroline Kitidis; Thomas ORorke; Matt Glassman; Daniel Sabba; Michael Iaquinta; Chip Packard Subject: Re: KCP IOI: Also,now we have a 50k IOI from Hart for PGRE; follow up on Hart Acquisitions/Watson IOI 30k shares for Virgin America (VA.US) [I] Classification: For Internal Use Only Kcp, can you confirm Epstein is not coming for VA? From: Haig Ariyan Sent: Thursday, November 13, 2014 03:33 PM To: Joshua Shoshan; Tazia Smith; Donald Summer Cc: Caroline Kitidis; Thomas ORorke; Matt Glassman; Daniel Sabba; Michael Iaquinta; Chip Packard Subject: Re: KCP IOI: Also,now we have a 50k IOI from Hart for PGRE; follow up on Hart Acquisitions/Watson IOI 30k shares for Virgin America (VA.US) [I] Classification: For Internal Use Only The allocation is too small for another set of clients to carve off the top, unless Epstein is not indicating for this deal. From: Joshua Shoshan Sent: Thursday, November 13, 2014 03:32 PM To: Joshua Shoshan; Haig Ariyan; Tazia Smith; Donald Summer Cc: Caroline Kitidis; Thomas ORorke; Matt Glassman; Daniel Sabba; Michael EFTA01478976

Iaquinta; Chip Packard Subject: KCP IOI: Also,now we have a 50k I01 from Hart for PGRE; follow up on Hart Acquisitions/Watson IOI 30k shares for Virgin America (VA.US) [I] Classification: For internal use only Greetings, Haig. Have you decided about Hart and their order for VA? That deal is tonight. Also, they have an IOI in for PGRE of 50K. That deal is next week, and we are only 5%. However, that deal is 131mm shares. Mike, do you have any sense of what we can see there? Best regards, --Josh Joshua Shoshan Director Deutsche Bank Securities Inc. Private Wealth Management - Americas Private Client Services 345 Park Ave, 26th Floor New York, NY 10154 Office Cell E-Fax All trade execution information contained herein is being provided as an accommodation at your request in advance of your receipt of the official trade confirmation(s). Additional trade detail information available upon request. The terms of the trade(s) may be subject to change prior to settlement, and therefore the official trade confirmation(s) and account statements issued by Deutsche Bank shall govern. Deutsche Bank is not responsible for any discrepancy between the informal execution report and the official trade confirmation(s) or account statements. From: Joshua Shoshan Sent: Wednesday, November 12, 2014 2:38 PM To: Haig Ariyan; Tazia Smith; Donald Summer EFTA01478977

Cc: Caroline Kitidis; Thomas ORorke; Matt Glassman; Daniel Sabba; Michael Iaquinta; Chip Packard Subject: RE: KCP IOI: Hart Acquisitions/Watson IOI 30k shares for Virgin America (VA.US) [I] Classification: For internal use only Yes, this is different. Joshua Shoshan Director Deutsche Bank Securities Inc. Private Wealth Management - Americas Private Client Services 345 Park Ave, 26th Floor New York, NY 10154 Office Cell E-Fax All trade execution information contained herein is being provided as an accommodation at your request in advance of your receipt of the official trade confirmation(s). Additional trade detail information available upon request. The terms of the trade(s) may be subject to change prior to settlement, and therefore the official trade confirmation(s) and account statements issued by Deutsche Bank shall govern. Deutsche Bank is not responsible for any discrepancy between the informal execution report and the official trade confirmation(s) or account statements. From: Haig Ariyan Sent: Wednesday, November 12, 2014 2:38 PM To: Tazia Smith; Joshua Shoshan; Donald Summer Cc: Caroline Kitidis; Thomas ORorke; Matt Glassman; Daniel Sabba; Michael Iaquinta; Chip Packard Subject: RE: KCP IOI: Hart Acquisitions/Watson IOI 30k shares for Virgin America (VA.US) [I] EFTA01478978

Classification: For internal use only Let me rephrase: is this a different client than the one for whom we have previously provided this "off the top" allocation for? Who covers the client? Thanks Haig Haig Ariyan Managing Director Co-Head Wealth Management, Americas Deutsche Asset & Wealth Management 345 Park Avenue New York, NY 10154 phone From: Tazia Smith Sent: Wednesday, November 12, 2014 2:32 PM To: Haig Ariyan; Joshua Shoshan; Donald Summer Cc: Caroline Kitidis; Thomas ORorke; Matt Glassman; Daniel Sabba; Michael Iaquinta Subject: RE: KCP IOI: Hart Acquisitions/Watson IOI 30k shares for Virgin America (VA.US) [I] Classification: For internal use only This is not a new client, though not a regular retail deal participant so a new name on this exchange. Descrip: >$2bn family office, RE and operating businesses in Europe, US, and Australia. Work with DB globally. Hart EFTA01478979