Opened 2019-12-06 13:1650 Recipient HI S. Roth Display Name lil S. Roth Email .00thtibolLgov WAD 89F05I40-19D0-0000-B770-0200000058D0 Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Delivered 2019.12-0613:10.34 DownkadedByThirdParty 2019-12-06 13:1038 Opened 2019-12-06 13:1425 Recipient James Wilk Display Name James Wills Email JWilsgthop.gov UUID 794B2E01-157F-0000-BFB5-000083202C73 Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Delivered 2019.12.0613:1034 DomiloadedByThIrdParty 2019-12-06 B:1035 Opened 2019-12-06 13:1202 Recipient Kenneth Hyle Display Name Kenneth Hyk Email [email protected] CUM 4FASEE0B0358-0000.83F5-000F500FA00 Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Delivered 2019-12-06 13:10-34 DovsnioatiedByThirdParty 2019-12-06 13:1035 Opened 2019-12-06 13:1139 Recipient Loneryl Bums Display Name LeitersI Bums Email LBum. ii buixgov UUID B2EXHI-xl-IBII-0000-9EF2-0000&3219RE Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Delivered 2019.12-0613:1034 DonnloadedByThirdParty 2019-12-06 13:11:10 Opened 2019-12-06 132034 Recipient Susan Alison Display Name Susan Albin Email SAthson@bcqxgov UUID 737B5700-16FD-0000-BF9C-000083202C73 Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Delivered 2019.12-0613:1033 DonnioadedB)ThirdParty 2019-12-06 13:11:10 Recipient Sonya 1110114:609 Display Name Sonya Thompson Email [email protected] UUID F55D4040-146D-0000-94D5-00008324673C Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Delivered 2019-12-0613:1033 DossnloadedBy'rhirdParty 2019.12.0613:11708 Opened 2019-12-06 1530:19 Expire 0 Delay delivery until 0 Delegated false Archived fake Read true Deleted false Opened true Completed fake Security Normal Box type Sent Items Return notification Ashen opened fake Return notification Ashen deleted fake Page 16778 EFTA00046289

Return notification ..hen completed take Return notification ..hen declined false Return notification %%hen accepted false Archise Version 5.3 Internal ID 5DEA5349.B0PMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E776 [email protected]. I. 4A355.1@13 Source sent Class Public Account Hugh HunvtagBOP55178.PO4.BOPMSCO Location ID 1540843449744 Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL Enclosing Folders I Folder Psychology ID 5D51394DD.BOPMSCO.PO4.I00.1316872.I.4A355 .l@13 Name Psychology Type Normal System false Share Type NotSharcd Page 16779 EFTA00046290

Audits Date Action Auditor Note 2019-12.11092138 EST Created en-Archive Agent_2-Zero Day Archive8.en-Jobs.en-GWOpenNodc.cn-archiv isg.o=nctmail Generated by Netgavem Km-Archive Agent 2-Zero Day Archi;e&en-Jobs.ert-GWOpenNode.cn-archis iigo-netmai) 2020-05-19 15:3421 EDT Tag BOP01703.8IXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive 2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged Page 16780 EFTA00046291

Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald From Loneryl Bums To Alison LeukefeldAlix McLearcnHugh Hurwitz, Jill S. Roth Date 2019/12/06 15:32 Subject: Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald Attachments: TEXT.htm Are we able to answer the last question or should we reply we are unable to respond due to ongoing litigation? In regards to PREA, are only inmates at the facility interviewed? The story references inmates who were moved out of the facility and into other facilities in advance of PREA investigators arriving. Thanks, Loneryl >> > Jill S. Roth 12/6/201912:27 PM >>> I'm working on mine now but will send it to Hugh so he can review it first. I also won't be able to break it down by male and female inmates (not accurately anyway since some locations, like Coleman have both) so I won't put that information in. Also, my numbers will be sexually abusive behavior allegations (acts, contact, and harassment). I'll send it to Hugh within the hour. Jill > » Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 12:24 PM »> Thanks Beth! >>> Beth Reese 12/6/2019 1221 PM >>> We can give numbers of cases that we have that raise sexual abuse allegations, but those would relate only to staff/inmate cases, and I would not describe them as "unwanted sexual contact" so much as impermissible sexual contact. We also don't have a breakdown of male/female facilities - this question would be complicated to answer. Coleman, for example, is generally a male facility, but females are at the camp. Here are the raw numbers of staff/inmate cases: FY 2014 - 501 FY 2015 - 372 FY 2016 - 466 FY 2017 - 377 FY 2018 - 516 FY 2019 - 439 On average, we sustain charges in fewer than 5% of cases. Beth Reese U.S. Department of Justice Federal Bureau of Prisons Office of Internal Affairs Page 16781 EFTA00046292

320 First Street, N.W., Room 600 Washington, D.C. 20534 (202) 353-2114 (direct) (202) 307-3286 (main) (202) 514-8625 (fax) > » Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 11:33 AM > » Adding Hugh and Jill. Are we able to provide the stats they are requesting? Thanks, Loneryl >>> Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:57 AM >> > Thanks Ken! >> > Kenneth Hyle 12/6/2019 10:54 AM >>> Hello Loneryl - From our end: The Federal Bureau of Prisons (Bureau) takes allegations of staff misconduct seriously and, consistent with national policy, refers all allegations for investigation. The Bureau learned of allegations of sexual abuse through initial inmate complaints, and subsequently through administrative claims filed under the Federal Torts Claim Act. All allegations brought to the Bureau's attention were investigated by the Office of Internal Affairs. > > > Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:13 AM > > > Good Morning All, Please see the below questions from OS. Can you please advise on the response? Thanks, Loneryl >>> "Lucas, Daniel (JMD)" <DanielLucas2Ousdoj.gov> 12/6/2019 8:21 AM > » Good morning all- Please see incoming below from OS this morning. Is BOP able to assist with response? Thanks, Dan OS: This is an incredibly troubling story and it's now a lawsuit. Was BOP aware of these reports in the past? It sounds like there were multiple reports. Please keep us updated. Page 16782 EFTA00046293

In general, how many instances of unwanted sexual contact are reported at BOP facilities each year FY 2014- 2019; how many of these were inmate only related and how many were inmate and BOP staff related; and how many were male institutions vs female institutions? In regards to PREA, are only inmates at the facility interviewed? The story references inmates who were moved out of the facility and into other facilities in advance of PREA investigators arriving. Thanks. https://www.miamiherald.com/article237797554.html? utm_source= The + Marshall + Project+ Newsletter&utrasampaign= a35a3b41b3- EMAIL CAMPAIGN 2019 12 05 12 36&utm medium=email&utm term=0 5e02cdad9d-a35a3b41b3- 174511049 Rape is rampant at this women's prison. Anyone who complains is punished, lawsuit says. December 04, 2019 10:47 AM A Miami Herald I-Team investigation into corruption, sexual abuse and medical neglect at the largest women's prison in the nation, Lowell Correctional. Reporting by Julie K. Brown /[email protected]. By Emily Michot For years, male officers at the women's work camp at Coleman Federal Correctional Complex sexually harassed and assaulted inmates in what amounted to a sanctuary for systemic abuse, a space where they were shielded from any consequences. If the women complained about being groped, fondled or forced to perform sex acts on officers, the inmates were the ones who were punished. Fourteen women, ranging in age from 30 to 56 and nearly all first-time offenders, have banded together to sue the United States, not under pseudonyms but under their real names, over the abuse they say they've endured at the Bureau of Prisons-operated camp. Seven of the women are still incarcerated.The lawsuit seeks compensation and an overhaul of the prison. It was filed this week. An aerial view of the sprawling Coleman complex Coleman officials did not immediately respond to a request from the Miami Herald for comment. The litigation is the latest manifestation of dysfunction in a federal prison system that seemingly hit bottom when Jeffrey Epstein, perhaps the most high-profile detainee in the nation, was found hanged Aug. 10 in his cell at another BOP facility, the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan, while officers dozed nearby. The death, which led to the summary removal of the acting director of the prison system, has been termed a suicide. It occurred despite what was described as a previous suicide attempt three weeks earlier. Although it touches on a second institution in Tallahassee, the lawsuit focuses primarily on Coleman, the largest prison complex in the federal system. Located in Sumter County near Wildwood, it houses more than 6,000 inmates in a series of compounds and camps, including roughly 500 women, the complaint says In stark, chilling detail, the lawsuit describes pervasive abuse how women were coerced and threatened, how they were lured into private offices or remote sheds with no surveillance cameras, or stalked relentlessly by corrections officers until they had no choice but to submit. The officers all of whom are identified in the lawsuit, at least by last name would at times display computer screens showing the women the exact location of their families, a pointed message that their relatives could be targeted if the women didn't cooperate. Some of the women had minor children. In some cases, officers wanted to maintain relationships with the women after they had served their time, according to the lawsuit. The lawsuit says Coleman employed no fewer than seven officers who took advantage of their authority and access to sexually abuse the women. Some of the officers had been investigated for sexual abuse in the past, with nothing coming of it, the lawsuit alleges. The Miami Herald requested personnel files on all of the named officers to see if there were telltale warnings Page 16783 EFTA00046294

in tneir oackgrounas. ine tsureau or Prisons responaea tnat absent an overnaing public interest, it wouia not provide such documents, calling the provision of such records an unwarranted invasion of their personal privacy. The male staffers maintained total control over the women's lives, safety and well-being. At least one victim said she was ordered to begin birth control to avoid the possibility of becoming pregnant and another was given a morning-after pill by an officer. Page 16784 EFTA00046295

Properties Property Value Message ID 5DEA746F.DOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E78F .1 Message Path xmICabinenRSIrsychologA5DEA746F.BOPM SCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E78F.I.xml From Loncryl Bunts Display Name Lonely' Bums Email Lliumstibortgov UUID B2E80F81-IBI I-0000-9EF2-000083219F4E Reply To LBuntsfa bop.gov Text Loneryl Bums To Jil S. Roth Cc Alum Letikefeld, Ali( McLearen: Hugh Hurwitz Subject Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, bran-moult says I Miami Herald Scheduled date 2019-12-06 155158 Creation date 2019-12-06 15:3138 Modified date 2019-12-06 162533 Delis e red date 2019-12.06153240 Message size 7275 Attachments size 9071 Total size 16357 Attachments I Attachment TEXT.htm Name TEXT.htm Content ID 5DEA746F.BOPMSCO.PO4.200.20000E7.I.E17D9 .1@45:5DEA746F.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316872.1 .4E78F.I@1:5D5B94DD.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316 872.1.4A355.1@13 Is Inline fake Type lie Size 9071 Date 2019-12-06 1031.99 ('A 024405a3e9c453(10767aa5adba37e4a Hash 19F4473F4BF433A2E0AC67630AEIC6B9BE6C62DA 6DI7CF362228A997D650AF519058FF79 Recipients 4 Recipient Alison Leuicefekl Display Name Alison Lcukcfeld Email aleukefeld(ifibop.gov UUID 48744050-140A-0000a885-2D9EDOCC804 Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Recipient Aix MeLearcn Display Name Alix McLcaren Email amclearenabap.gov UUID 6ICEBF81.0E72-000043E1&400000000000 Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Recipient Hugh litawitz Display Name Hugh Huswiz Email Filiunvi*bop.gov CUM B922A560-1581-0000-B66C•FACF6A03A5IC Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Recipient Jil S. Roth Display Name Jil S. Roth Email jsrotherbop.gov UUID 89F05l40-19DO0000•B770-0200000058D0 Distribution Tspe TO Recipient Type User Expire 0 Delay de Ils ery until 0 Delegated fake Archived fake Read RUC Deleted fare Opened MX Completed false Security Nonml Box type !Mot Return notification when opened false Page 16785 EFTA00046296

Return notification nhen deleted false Return notification yy he n completed fake Return notification 'then declined fake Return notification 'then accepted false Archive Version 5.3 Internal ID 5DEA746F.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E713F .1(a11:5O5B94OD.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.13161572.1. 4A355.1@l3 Source received Class Public Account Hugh [email protected] Location II) 1540643449744 Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL Enclosing Folders I Folder Psychology ID 5D5B94DD.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4A355 . l@13 Name Psychology Type Normal System fake Share Type NotShared Page 16786 EFTA00046297

Audits Date Action Auditor Note 2019-12-11 0921:40 EST Created cn-Archive Agent_2-Zero Day Archive8.cn-Jobs.en-GWOpcnNodc.cn-archiv isg.o=nctmail Generated by Netgavem Km-Archive Agent 2-Zem Day Archi;e&en-Jobs.cri-GWOpenNode.cn-archis iigo-netmai) 2020-05-19 15:3421 EDT Tag BOP01703.8IXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive 2020-05-191437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged Page 16787 EFTA00046298

RE: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald From Jill S. Roth To Alison LeukefeldAlix MeLearenHugh Hurwitz, Loneryl Burns Date 2019/12/06 16:17 Subject: RE: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald Attachments: TEXT.htrn Oh sorry, I meant to answer that. All allegations are investigated. Investigations include interviewing the alleged victim, the alleged perpetrator, and any possible witnesses to the alleged abusive behavior. These interviews occur regardless of location. Inmates have been interviewed at facilities other than where the event was alleged to have occurred, to include after release to halfway house. Transfers do not stop the investigative process. Jill Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone Original message From: Loneryl Burns <[email protected]> Date: 12/6/19 3:32 PM (GMT-05:00) To: "Jill S. Roth" <[email protected]> Cc Alison Leukefeld <[email protected]>, Alix McLearen <[email protected]>, Hugh Hurwitz <[email protected]> Subject: Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald >> > "Loneryl Burns" 12/06/2019 15:32 >>> Are we able to answer the last question or should we reply we are unable to respond due to ongoing litigation? In regards to PREA, are only inmates at the facility interviewed? The story references inmates who were moved out of the facility and into other facilities in advance of PREA investigators arriving. Thanks, Loneryl >> > Jill S. Roth 12/6/201912:27 PM >>> I'm working on mine now but will send it to Hugh so he can review it first. I also won't be able to break it down by male and female inmates (not accurately anyway since some locations, like Coleman have both) so I won't put that information in. Also, my numbers will be sexually abusive behavior allegations (acts, contact, and harassment). I'll send it to Hugh within the hour. Jill Page 16788 EFTA00046299

>> > Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 12:24 PM >>> Thanks Beth! >> > Beth Reese 12/6/2019 12:21 PM >>> We can give numbers of cases that we have that raise sexual abuse allegations, but those would relate only to staff/inmate cases, and I would not describe them as "unwanted sexual contact" so much as impermissible sexual contact. We also don't have a breakdown of male/female facilities - this question would be complicated to answer. Coleman, for example, is generally a male facility, but females are at the camp. Here are the raw numbers of staff/inmate cases: FY 2014 - 501 FY 2015 - 372 FY 2016 - 466 FY 2017 - 377 FY 2018 - 516 FY 2019 - 439 On average, we sustain charges in fewer than 5% of cases. Beth Reese U.S. Department of Justice Federal Bureau of Prisons Office of Internal Affairs 320 First Street, N.W., Room 600 Washington, D.C. 20534 (202) 353-2114 (direct) (202) 307-3286 (main) (202) 514-8625 (fax) > > > Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 11:33 AM > > > Adding Hugh and Jill. Are we able to provide the stats they are requesting? Thanks, Loneryl > » Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:57 AM > » Thanks Ken! >> > Kenneth Hyle 12/6/2019 10:54 AM >> > Hello Loneryl - From our end: The Federal Bureau of Prisons (Bureau) takes allegations of staff misconduct seriously and, consistent with national policy, refers all allegations for investigation. The Bureau learned of allegations of sexual abuse through initial inmate complaints, and subsequently through administrative claims filed under the Federal Torts Claim Act. All allegations brought to the Bureau's attention were investigated by the Office of Internal Affairs. Page 16789 EFTA00046300

> » Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:13 AM > » Good Morning All, Please see the below questions from OS. Can you please advise on the response? Thanks, Loneryl >> > "Lucas, Daniel (JMD)" <Daniellucas2Pusdoj.gov> 12/6/2019 8:21 AM >> > Good morning all- Please see incoming below from OS this morning. Is BOP able to assist with response? Thanks, Dan OS: This is an incredibly troubling story and it's now a lawsuit. Was BOP aware of these reports in the past? It sounds like there were multiple reports. Please keep us updated. In general, how many instances of unwanted sexual contact are reported at BOP facilities each year FY 2014- 2019; how many of these were inmate only related and how many were inmate and BOP staff related; and how many were male institutions vs female institutions? In regards to PREA, are only inmates at the facility interviewed? The story references inmates who were moved out of the facility and into other facilities in advance of PREA investigators arriving. Thanks. https://www.miamiherald.rom/article237797554.html? utrksource=The+Marshall +Project + Newsletter&utrnsampaign=a35a3b41b3- EMAIL CAMPAIGN_2019 12 05 1 36&utm medium=email&utm term=0_5e02cdad9d-a35a3b41b3- 174511049 Rape is rampant at this women's prison. Anyone who complains is punished, lawsuit says. December 04, 201910:47 AM A Miami Herald I-Team investigation into corruption, sexual abuse and medical neglect at the largest women's prison in the nation, Lowell Correctional. Reporting by Julie K. Brown /[email protected]. By Emily Michot For years, male officers at the women's work camp at Coleman Federal Correctional Complex sexually harassed and assaulted inmates in what amounted to a sanctuary for systemic abuse, a space where they were shielded from any consequences. If the women complained about being groped, fondled or forced to perform sex acts on officers, the inmates were the ones who were punished. Fourteen women, ranging in age from 30 to 56 and nearly all first-time offenders, have banded together to sue the United States, not under pseudonyms but under their real names, over the abuse they say they've Page 16790 EFTA00046301

CI IUUI CU CL LI IC UUI COU Ul rl l'up O- UWCIOLCU Leal I IV. JCV CI I Ul LI IC WVI I ICI I al C ,LIII II 'LOU LCI OLCU. I I IC IOVV,Ult rt. \ compensation and an overhaul of the prison. It was filed this week. An aerial view of the sprawling Coleman complex Coleman officials did not immediately respond to a request from the Miami Herald for comment. The litigation is the latest manifestation of dysfunction in a federal prison system that seemingly hit bottom when Jeffrey Epstein, perhaps the most high-profile detainee in the nation, was found hanged Aug. 10 in his cell at another BOP facility, the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan, while officers dozed nearby. The death, which led to the summary removal of the acting director of the prison system, has been termed a suicide. It occurred despite what was described as a previous suicide attempt three weeks earlier. Although it touches on a second institution in Tallahassee, the lawsuit focuses primarily on Coleman, the largest prison complex in the federal system. Located in Sumter County near Wildwood, it houses more than 6,000 inmates in a series of compounds and camps, including roughly 500 women, the complaint says In stark, chilling detail, the lawsuit describes pervasive abuse how women were coerced and threatened, how they were lured into private offices or remote sheds with no surveillance cameras, or stalked relentlessly by corrections officers until they had no choice but to submit. The officers all of whom are identified in the lawsuit, at least by last name would at times display computer screens showing the women the exact location of their families, a pointed message that their relatives could be targeted if the women didn't cooperate. Some of the women had minor children. In some cases, officers wanted to maintain relationships with the women after they had served their time, according to the lawsuit. The lawsuit says Coleman employed no fewer than seven officers who took advantage of their authority and access to sexually abuse the women. Some of the officers had been investigated for sexual abuse in the past, with nothing coming of it, the lawsuit alleges. The Miami Herald requested personnel files on all of the named officers to see if there were telltale warnings in their backgrounds. The Bureau of Prisons responded that absent an overriding public interest, it would not provide such documents, calling the provision of such records an unwarranted invasion of their personal privacy. The male staffers maintained total control over the women's lives, safety and well-being. At least one victim said she was ordered to begin birth control to avoid the possibility of becoming pregnant and another was given a morning-after pill by an officer. Page 16791 EFTA00046302

Properties Property Value Nlessage 1 D 5DEA7FOLDOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E79F .1 Message Path xmlCabinct \RSI3 1 PsycholoAA5DEA7FOLBOPM SCO.PO4.100.13 I6B72.I.4E79F.Lianl From JA S. Roth Display Name MI S. Roth Entail inithfigrip.gov UUID 89F05140-19D0-0OO0-B770A200000058D0 Reply To iroth at boigov Text Jil S. Roth To Loncryl Nuns Cc Alien Leukefeld, Alix McLearen: Hugh Iltirwitz Subject RE: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florkla prison was systemic, brazen, suit says [ Mimi Herald Scheduled date 2019-12-06 16:1634 Creation date 2019.12.0616:1654 Modified date 2019-12-06 162538 Delis end date 2019-12.0616:17136 Message size 8308 Attachments sin 10530 Total size 18849 Attachments I Attachment TEXT.htm Name TEXT.htm Content ID 5DEA7FOI.BOPMSCO.PO4.200.2000063.I.I6CAA 9.1 @453DEA7FOLBOPMSOO.PO4.100.1316972. [email protected] 6B72.1.4A355.l@l3 Is Inline fake Type fde Size 10530 CA 03eaaa043d7425bd126ccd453n3961b Hash 4A373358B52ED95568159C2A3D2BFI3E37366A98 9D87DCF496F6866895BC19896DBF3625 Recipients 4 Recipient Alien LeukcfcU Display Name Alison Leukefeld Email alcukcfeld@bohgov UUID 48744050-140A-0000-AB85-2D9EDOCC8C14 Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Recipient Mx McLearen Display Name Mx McLearen Email amcicarcinfibop.gov UUID 610EBF81-0E72-0O00-8E18-000000000000 Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Recipient Hugh Ihrwitz Display Name Hugh HUM*/ Email HHunvaz@boigov UM B922A560-1581-0000-966C-FACF6A00ASIC Distribution "I've CC Recipient Type User Recipient Loneryl Bums Display Name Loncryl BIM; Email [email protected] UUID B2E8DF81-1B I 1-0003-9EF2-000083219F4E Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Expire 0 Delay delivery until 0 Delegated fake Archived fake Read um Deleted fake Opened we Completed false Security Normal Box type Inbox Return notification when opened fake Return notification sshen deleted fake Page 16792 EFTA00046303

Return notification ishe n completed take Return notification ..hen declined lake Return notification %%hen accepted false Archise Version 5.3 Internal ID 5DEA7F0LBOPMSCO.PO4.I00.1316B72.1.4E79F [email protected]. 4A355.1@l3 Source received Class Public Account Hugh [email protected] Location ID 1540843449744 Class Name G1V.MESSAGE.MAIL Enclosing Folders 1 Fokkr Psychology ID 5D5I394DD.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316872.1.4A355 .1@l3 Name Psychology Type Normal System false Share Type NotShared Page 16793 EFTA00046304

Audits Dale Action Auditor Note 2019-12-II 0921:42 EST Created en-Archive Agent2-Zero Day Archive8.en-Jobstn-GWOpenNode.en-archis hg.o=netmail Generated by Neigovem [en-Archive Agent_2-Zero Day Archivestn.jobstrecwopenNodetn_archiv logo-neural) 7070-04-07 I28)I st9 EDT Viewed Vwed EtOP0I829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM1 Viewed by BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI 2020-05-19 15:3421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Responsive 2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXFtADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged Page 16794 EFTA00046305

RE: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit From Hugh Hurwitz To Alix McLearcn, Jill S. Roth Date 2019/12/06 12:33 Subject: RE: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit Attachments: TEXT.htm I spoke to Ken...he was aware and apologized for not letting me know. But more importantly the proper reporting chain to get this to you did not work. We need to look into this and get it fixed moving forward. We can deal with that issue next week. »> Jill S. Roth <[email protected]> 12/6/2019 12:15 PM »> I guess you don't need to know either... Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone Original message From: Hugh Hurwitz <[email protected]> Date: 12/6/19 12:14 PM (GMT-05:00) To: "Jill S. Roth" <[email protected]> Cc: Alix McLearen <[email protected]> Subject: RE: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit »> "Hugh Hurwitz" 12/06/2019 12:14 »> I had not heard about it either until the article came out today. Report whatever data you have. If you don't have exactly what they want that is fine. »> Jill S. Roth <[email protected]> 12/6/2019 12:10 PM »> Are you wanting the data for all the years the person asked for? I don't think I can break it down as much as they want, but I can get close. Also, this is the first I've heard anything about this apparent rampant abuse. This is either a breakdown in communication or I am not in the need to know category. Jill Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone Original message From: Hugh Hurwitz <[email protected]> Date: 12/6/19 11:41 AM (GMT-05:00) Try Alicnn I ailleafalri enlaaileofalriahnn nnw> AIiv Mrl aaran eamrlaaranahnn nrAn. "lillc Rnth" Page 16795 EFTA00046306

•••••,*. <[email protected]> Subject: Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald >> > "Hugh Hurwitz" 12/06/2019 11:41 >>> We should be able to provide this from the annual prea report, right? Can we do today? > > > Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 11:33 AM > > > Adding Hugh and Jill. Are we able to provide the stats they are requesting? Thanks, Loneryl >>> Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:57 AM >> > Thanks Ken! >> > Kenneth Hyle 12/6/2019 10:54 AM >>> Hello Loneryl - From our end: The Federal Bureau of Prisons (Bureau) takes allegations of staff misconduct seriously and, consistent with national policy, refers all allegations for investigation. The Bureau learned of allegations of sexual abuse through initial inmate complaints, and subsequently through administrative claims filed under the Federal Torts Claim Act. All allegations brought to the Bureau's attention were investigated by the Office of Internal Affairs. > » Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:13 AM > » Good Morning All, Please see the below questions from OS. Can you please advise on the response? Thanks, Loneryl >>> "Lucas, Daniel (JMD)" <[email protected]> 12/6/2019 8:21 AM > >> Good morning all- Please see incoming below from OS this morning. Is BOP able to assist with response? Thanks, Dan OS: This is an incredibly troubling story and it's now a lawsuit. Was BOP aware of these reports in the past? It sounds like there were multiple reports. Please keep us updated. Page 16796 EFTA00046307

In general, how many instances of unwanted sexual contact are reported at BOP facilities each year FY 2014-2019; how many of these were inmate only related and how many were inmate and BOP staff related; and how many were male institutions vs female institutions? In regards to PREA, are only inmates at the fadlity interviewed? The story references inmates who were moved out of the facility and into other facilities in advance of PREA investigators arriving. Thanks. https//wwwsniamiherald.comiartirle237797554.htmP utm_source=The+Marshall +Projert+Newsletteratutrrtsampaign=a35a3b41b3- EMAIL CAMPAIGN 2019 12 05 12 36&utm medium=email&utm term=0 5e02cdad9d- a35a3h41h3-174511049 Rape is rampant at this women's prison. Anyone who complains is punished, lawsuit says. December 04, 2019 10:47 AM A Miami Herald I-Team investigation into corruption, sexual abuse and medical neglect at the largest women's prison in the nation, Lowell Correctional. Reporting by Julie K. Brown / [email protected]. By Emily Michot For years, male officers at the women's work camp at Coleman Federal Correctional Complex sexually harassed and assaulted inmates in what amounted to a "sanctuary" for systemic abuse, a space where they were shielded from any consequences. If the women complained about being groped, fondled or forced to perform sex acts on officers, the inmates were the ones who were punished. Fourteen women, ranging in age from 30 to 56 and nearly all first-time offenders, have banded together to sue the United States, not under pseudonyms but under their real names, over the abuse they say they've endured at the Bureau of Prisons- operated camp. Seven of the women are still incarcerated. The lawsuit seeks compensation and an overhaul of the prison. It was filed this week. An aerial view of the sprawling Coleman complex Coleman officials did not immediately respond to a request from the Miami Herald for comment. Page 16797 EFTA00046308

The litigation is the latest manifestation of dysfunction in a federal prison system that seemingly hit bottom when Jeffrey Epstein, perhaps the most high-profile detainee in the nation, was found hanged Aug. 10 in his cell at another BOP facility, the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan, while officers dozed nearby. The death, which led to the summary removal of the acting director of the prison system, has been termed a suicide. It occurred despite what was described as a previous suicide attempt three weeks earlier. Although it touches on a second institution in Tallahassee, the lawsuit focuses primarily on Coleman, the largest prison complex in the federal system. Located in Sumter County near Wildwood, it houses more than 6,000 inmates in a series of compounds and camps, including roughly 500 women, the complaint says In stark, chilling detail, the lawsuit describes pervasive abuse — how women were coerced and threatened, how they were lured into private offices or remote sheds with no surveillance cameras, or stalked relentlessly by corrections officers until they had no choice but to submit. The officers — all of whom are identified in the lawsuit, at least by last name — would at times display computer screens showing the women the exact location of their families, a pointed message that their relatives could be targeted if the women didn't cooperate. Some of the women had minor children. In some cases, officers wanted to maintain relationships with the women after they had served their time, according to the lawsuit. The lawsuit says Coleman employed no fewer than seven officers who took advantage of their authority and access to sexually abuse the women. Some of the officers had been investigated for sexual abuse in the past, with nothing coming of it, the lawsuit alleges. The Miami Herald requested personnel files on all of the named officers to see if there were telltale warnings in their backgrounds. The Bureau of Prisons responded that absent an "overriding public interest," it would not provide such documents, calling the provision of such records "an unwarranted invasion of their personal privacy." The male staffers maintained total control over the women's lives, safety and well- being. At least one victim said she was ordered to begin birth control to avoid the possibility of becoming pregnant and another was given a morning-after pill by an officer. Page 16798 EFTA00046309

Properties Property Value Message ID SDEA4A93.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1AE768 .1 Message Path xmtiCabinetaSD\PsychologA5DEA4A93.FlOPM SCO.PO4.100.1316B72.I.4E768.1.xml From Hugh Htswitz Display Name Hugh Htrwtz Email Elliurveirgbop.gov UUID 13922A56O1581.0000-B66C-FACF6A00A5IC Reply To HHunvitzSZbop.gov Text Hugh 11111VilZ To Jil S. Roth Cc Mat MeLearen Subject RE: NM: Sexual abuse at Honk prison was systemic, bran suit Scheduled date 2019-12-06 123323 Creation date 2019-12-06 123323 Modified date 2019-12-06 143036 Delis e red date 2019-12-06 123323 Message size 7349 Attachments sin 14474 Total size 21834 Attachments I Attachment TEXT.htm Name TEXT.htm Content ID SDEA4A93.BOPMSCO.PO4.200.200000D.1.3BF9C 2.I @455DEA4A93.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72. [email protected] 6B72.1AA355.1@13 Is Inline fake Type fat Size 14474 Date 2019-12-060733:18 6155856920789ckid93d1b31S2fddc267 Hash A9E2CEE6694BA4BE33478.5A72A6F3E5940E37FA6 A3BASSFEDC356F6AE8E4117945FF521A Recipients 2 Recipient Akx SleLearen Display Name Alix McLcarcn Email atnekararAbop.gov QUID 610EBF81-0E72-0000.8E18.000000000000 Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Delivered 2019-12-06 123326 Donnloadedil iThirdP • 2019-12-06 123351 Opened 2019-12-06 132735 Recipient JAS. Roth Display Name JA S. Roth Email ist011Ob0P•130v UUID 89F05 I 40-1900-0000-B770-0200C00058D0 Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Delivered 2019-12-06 123326 DonnloadedBylltirdParty 2019-12-061234:15 Opened 2019.12-06 1237,40 Expire 0 Delay delivery. until 0 Delegated false Archived fake Read MC Deleted fake Opened true Completed fake Security Normal Box type Sent Items Return notification when opened fake Return notification when deleted fake Return notification when completed fake Return notification when declined fake Return notification when accepted false Page 16799 EFTA00046310

Archive Version 5.3 Intemal ID SDEA4A93.8OPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1AE768.1@13D5B94DD.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1. 4A355.1@13 Source sat Class Public Account Hugh [email protected] Location ID 1540843449744 Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL Enclosing Folders 1 Folder Psychology ID 5D5B94DD.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316872.1.4A355 .1413 Name Psychology Type Normal System false Share Type NaShared Page 16800 EFTA00046311

Audits Dale Action Auditor Note 2019-12.11092196 EST Created en-Archive Agent_2-Zero Day Archive8.en-Jobs.en-GWOpenNodocn-archiv isgo=nctmail Generated by Neigovem Km-Archive Agent 2-Zem Day Archi;e&en-Jobs.ert-GWOpenNode.cn-archis itgo-netmai) 2020-05-19 153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.8IXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive 2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged Page 16801 EFTA00046312

Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald From Jill S. Roth To Alison Leukefeld, Alix McLearen, Hugh Hurwitz Date 2019/12/06 12:58 Subject: Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald The data I am providing is just for inmate on inmate sexually abusive behavior since Beth already provided the staff on inmate totals. Like Beth, I can't accurately break down the allegations by facility gender. If they need allegation totals for female inmates, AJ would be able to pull that pretty easily, I think. The numbers I am providing are total number of allegations of inmate-on-inmate sexually abusive behavior for each calendar year requested with the exception of CY 2019 because it is not over and we have not reviewed the data yet. Sexually abusive behavior encompasses acts (penetration), contact (fondling), and harassment (non-contact offenses). I break down the substantiated cases by type. 2014 - 324 allegations; 12 Substantiated (2 ACT, 6 CON, 6 HAR) 2015 - 365 allegations; 17 Substantiated (7 ACT, 7 CON, 3 HAR) 2016 - 334 allegations; 25 Substantiated (4 ACT, 11 CON, 10 HAR) 2017 - 417 allegations; 26 Substantiated (2 ACT, 12 CON, 12 HAR) 2018 - 489 allegations; 29 Substantiated (8 ACT, 11 CON, 10 HAR) >>> Hugh Hurwitz 12/6/2019 11:41 AM >>> We should be able to provide this from the annual prea report, right? Can we do today? >>> Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 11:33 AM >>> Adding Hugh and Jill. Are we able to provide the stats they are requesting? Thanks, Loneryl >>> Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:57 AM >>> Thanks Ken! >>> Kenneth Hyle 12/6/2019 10:54 AM >>> Hello Loneryl - From our end: The Federal Bureau of Prisons (Bureau) takes allegations of staff misconduct seriously and, consistent with national policy, refers all allegations for investigation. The Bureau learned of allegations of sexual abuse through initial inmate complaints, and subsequently through administrative claims filed under the Federal Torts Claim Act. All allegations brought to the Bureau's attention were investigated by the Office of Internal Affairs. Page 16802 EFTA00046313

>>> Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:13 AM >>> Good Morning All, Please see the below questions from CJS. Can you please advise on the response? Thanks, Loneryl >>> "Lucas, Daniel (JMD)" 12/6/2019 8:21 AM >>> Good morning all- Please see incoming below from CJS this morning. Is BOP able to assist with response? Thanks, Dan CJS: This is an incredibly troubling story and it's now a lawsuit. Was BOP aware of these reports in the past? It sounds like there were multiple reports. Please keep us updated. In general, how many instances of unwanted sexual contact are reported at BOP facilities each year FY 2014-2019; how many of these were inmate only related and how many were inmate and BOP staff related; and how many were male institutions vs female institutions? In regards to PREA, are only inmates at the facility interviewed? The story references inmates who were moved out of the facility and into other facilities in advance of PREA investigators arriving Thanks. https://wvvw.miamiherald.corn/article237797554.html? utm source=The+Marshall+Project+Newsletter&utm campaign=a35a3b41b3- EMAIL_CAMPAIGN_2019_12_05_12_36&utm_medium=email&utm term=0_5e02cdad9d- a35a3b41b3-174511049 Rape is rampant at this women's prison. Anyone who complains is punished, lawsuit says. December 04, 2019 10:47 AM A Miami Herald I-Team investigation into corruption, sexual abuse and medical neglect at the largest women's prison in the nation, Lowell Correctional. Reporting by Julie K. Brown / [email protected]. By Emily Michot For years, male officers at the women's work camp at Coleman Federal Correctional Complex sexually harassed and assaulted inmates in what amounted to a "sanctuary" for systemic abuse, a space where they were shielded from any consequences. If the women complained about being groped, fondled or forced to perform sex acts on officers, the inmates were the ones who were punished. Fourteen women, ranging in age from 30 to 56 and nearly all first-time offenders, have banded together to sue the United States, not under pseudonyms but under their real names, over the abuse they say they've endured at the Bureau of Prisons-operated camp. Seven of the women Page 16803 EFTA00046314

are still incarcerated.The lawsuit seeks compensation and an overhaul of the prison. It was filed this week. An aerial view of the sprawling Coleman complex Coleman officials did not immediately respond to a request from the Miami Herald for comment. The litigation is the latest manifestation of dysfunction in a federal prison system that seemingly hit bottom when Jeffrey Epstein, perhaps the most high-profile detainee in the nation, was found hanged Aug 10 in his cell at another BOP facility, the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan, while officers dozed nearby. The death, which led to the summary removal of the acting director of the prison system, has been termed a suicide. It occurred despite what was described as a previous suicide attempt three weeks earlier. Although it touches on a second institution in Tallahassee, the lawsuit focuses primarily on Coleman, the largest prison complex in the federal system. Located in Sumter County near Wildwood, it houses more than 6,000 inmates in a series of compounds and camps, including roughly 500 women, the complaint says In stark, chilling detail, the lawsuit describes pervasive abuse — how women were coerced and threatened, how they were lured into private offices or remote sheds with no surveillance cameras, or stalked relentlessly by corrections officers until they had no choice but to submit. The officers — all of whom are identified in the lawsuit, at least by last name — would at times display computer screens showing the women the exact location of their families, a pointed message that their relatives could be targeted if the women didn't cooperate. Some of the women had minor children. In some cases, officers wanted to maintain relationships with the women after they had served their time, according to the lawsuit. The lawsuit says Coleman employed no fewer than seven officers who took advantage of their authority and access to sexually abuse the women. Some of the officers had been investigated for sexual abuse in the past, with nothing coming of it, the lawsuit alleges. The Miami Herald requested personnel files on all of the named officers to see if there were telltale warnings in their backgrounds. The Bureau of Prisons responded that absent an "overriding public interest," it would not provide such documents, calling the provision of such records "an unwarranted invasion of their personal privacy." The male staffers maintained total control over the women's lives, safety and well-being. At least one victim said she was ordered to begin birth control to avoid the possibility of becoming pregnant and another was given a morning-after pill by an officer. Page 16804 EFTA00046315

Properties Property Value MessagelD 5DEA507C.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E76D .1 Message Path xmlCabincARSIAPsycholoAA5DEA507C.BOPM SCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E76D.I.xml From JAS. Roth Display Name RI S. Roth Email prothdrbop.gov UUID 891:05140-19D0-0000-B770-0200000058D0 Reply To gdothrgt.cp.gov Text JA S. Roth To Alison Lcukefeld: Mix McLeareix Hugh Hintz Subject Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic. brawl. suit says I Miami Herald Scheduled date 201912-06125834 Creation date 201912-06123834 Modified date 2019-12-06 13:10:41 Delivered date 2019-12-06 123837 Message sine 6783 Attachments 0 Recipients 3 Recipient Alison Lcukefekl Display Name Alison Leukefeld Email akticefeldgbop.gov (IUD 48744D50.140A-0000•AB85-2D9EDOCC8C14 Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Recipient Ake McLearen Display Name Mix McLearen Email [email protected] UUID 610EBF81-0E72-0000-8E18-000000000000 Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Recipient Hugh Hurwin: Display Name Hugh Hurwitz Email HHursvitz@boragov UUID B922A560-1581.0000•B66C•FACF6A00A5IC Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Expire 0 Delay deli-en until 0 Delegated fake Archived fake Read true Deleted false Opened tnie Completed fake Security Normal Box hpe Inbox Return notification when opened fake Re turn notification %the n deleted fake Return notification when completed tithe Return notification when declined lake Return notification when accepted fake Archive Version 5.3 Internal ID 5DEA507C.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B711.4E76D .1@1:5D5B94DD.BOPMSCO.P04100.1316B72.1. 4A355.413 Source received Class Public Account Hugh [email protected] Location ID 1540843449744 Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL Enclosing Folders I Folder Psychology ID 5D5B941M.SOPMSCO.PO4.10013I6872.14A355 . I@13 Name Psychology TOPe Normal Page 16805 EFTA00046316

System Share Type fake NotShared Page 16806 EFTA00046317

Audits Dale Action Auditor Note 2019-12.1109213? EST Created cn-Archive Agent_2-Zero Day Archisc8.cn-Jobs.cn-GWOpcnNodocn-archiv isgo=nctmail Generated by Ncigovem Km-Archive Agent 2-Zem Day Archi;e&en-Jobs.crt-GWOpenNode.cn-archis itgo-netmai) 2020-05-19 15:3421 EDT Tag BOP01703.NIXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive 2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbggcd Page 16807 EFTA00046318

Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald From Jill S. Roth To Alison LeukefeldAlix McLearenHugh Hurwitz, Loneryl Bums Date 2019/12/06 12:27 Subject: Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald I'm working on mine now but will send it to Hugh so he can review it first. I also won't be able to break it down by male and female inmates (not accurately anyway since some locations, like Coleman have both) so I won't put that information in. Also, my numbers will be sexually abusive behavior allegations (acts, contact, and harassment). I'll send it to Hugh within the hour. Jill >>> Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 12:24 PM >>> Thanks Beth! >>> Beth Reese 12/6/2019 12:21 PM >>> We can give numbers of cases that we have that raise sexual abuse allegations, but those would relate only to staff/inmate cases, and I would not describe them as "unwanted sexual contact" so much as impermissible sexual contact. We also don't have a breakdown of male/female facilities - this question would be complicated to answer. Coleman, for example, is generally a male facility, but females are at the camp. Here are the raw numbers of staff/inmate cases: FY 2014 - 501 FY 2015 - 372 FY 2016 - 466 FY 2017 - 377 FY 2018 - 516 FY 2019 - 439 On average, we sustain charges in fewer than 5% of cases. Beth Reese U.S. Department of Justice Federal Bureau of Prisons Office of Internal Affairs 320 First Street, N.W., Room 600 Washington, D.C. 20534 (202) 353-2114 (direct) (202) 307-3286 (main) (202) 514-8625 (fax) >>> Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 11:33 AM >>> Adding Hugh and Jill. Are we able to provide the stats they are requesting? Page 16808 EFTA00046319

Panics, Loneryl >>> Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:57 AM >>> Thanks Ken! >>> Kenneth Hyle 12/6/2019 10:54 AM >>> Hello Loneryl - From our end: The Federal Bureau of Prisons (Bureau) takes allegations of staff misconduct seriously and, consistent with national policy, refers all allegations for investigation. The Bureau learned of allegations of sexual abuse through initial inmate complaints, and subsequently through administrative claims filed under the Federal Torts Claim Act. All allegations brought to the Bureau's attention were investigated by the Office of Internal Affairs. >>> Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:13 AM >>> Good Morning All, Please see the below questions from CJS. Can you please advise on the response? Thanks, Loneryl >>> "Lucas, Daniel (JMD)" 12/6/2019 8:21 AM >>> Good morning all- Please see incoming below from CJS this morning. Is BOP able to assist with response? Thanks, Dan CJS: This is an incredibly troubling story and it's now a lawsuit. Was BOP aware of these reports in the past? It sounds like there were multiple reports. Please keep us updated. In general, how many instances of unwanted sexual contact are reported at BOP facilities each year FY 2014-2019; how many of these were inmate only related and how many were inmate and BOP staff related; and how many were male institutions vs female institutions? In regards to PREA, are only inmates at the facility interviewed? The story references inmates who were moved out of the facility and into other facilities in advance of PREA investigators arriving. Thanks. https://www.rniamiherald.com/article237797554.html? utm source=The+Marsha1H-Project+Newsletter&utm campaign=a35a3b41b3- EMAIL CAMPAIGN 2019 12 05 12 36&utm medium=email&utm term=0 5e02cdad9d- Page 16809 EFTA00046320

a35a3b41b3-174511049 — Rape is rampant at this women's prison. Anyone who complains is punished, lawsuit says. December 04, 2019 10:47 AM A Miami Herald I-Team investigation into corruption, sexual abuse and medical neglect at the largest women's prison in the nation, Lowell Correctional. Reporting by Julie K. Brown / [email protected]. By Emily Michot For years, male officers at the women's work camp at Coleman Federal Correctional Complex sexually harassed and assaulted inmates in what amounted to a "sanctuary" for systemic abuse, a space where they were shielded from any consequences. If the women complained about being groped, fondled or forced to perform sex acts on officers, the inmates were the ones who were punished. Fourteen women, ranging in age from 30 to 56 and nearly all first-time offenders, have banded together to sue the United States, not under pseudonyms but under their real names, over the abuse they say they've endured at the Bureau of Prisons-operated camp. Seven of the women are still incarcerated.The lawsuit seeks compensation and an overhaul of the prison. It was filed this week. An aerial view of the sprawling Coleman complex Coleman officials did not immediately respond to a request from the Miami Herald for comment. The litigation is the latest manifestation of dysfunction in a federal prison system that seemingly hit bottom when Jeffrey Epstein, perhaps the most high-profile detainee in the nation, was found hanged Aug. 10 in his cell at another BOP facility, the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan, while officers dozed nearby. The death, which led to the summary removal of the acting director of the prison system, has been termed a suicide. It occurred despite what was described as a previous suicide attempt three weeks earlier. Although it touches on a second institution in Tallahassee, the lawsuit focuses primarily on Coleman, the largest prison complex in the federal system. Located in Sumter County near Wildwood, it houses more than 6,000 inmates in a series of compounds and camps, including roughly 500 women, the complaint says In stark, chilling detail, the lawsuit describes pervasive abuse — how women were coerced and threatened, how they were lured into private offices or remote sheds with no surveillance cameras, or stalked relentlessly by corrections officers until they had no choice but to submit. The officers — all of whom are identified in the lawsuit, at least by last name — would at times display computer screens showing the women the exact location of their families, a pointed message that their relatives could be targeted if the women didn't cooperate. Some of the women had minor children. In some cases, officers wanted to maintain relationships with the women after they had served their time, according to the lawsuit. The lawsuit says Coleman employed no fewer than seven officers who took advantage of their authority and access to sexually abuse the women. Some of the officers had been investigated for sexual abuse in the past, with nothing coming of it, the lawsuit alleges. The Miami Herald requested personnel files on all of the named officers to see if there were telltale warnings in their backgrounds. The Bureau of Prisons responded that absent an "overriding public interest," it would not provide such documents, calling the provision of such records "an unwarranted invasion of their personal privacy." The male staffers maintained total control over the women's lives, safety and well-being. At least one victim said she was ordered to begin birth control to avoid the possibility of becoming pregnant and another was given a morning-after pill by an officer. Page 16810 EFTA00046321

Properties Property Value Message ID 5DEA493F.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E75E .1 Message Path imiltabinet5060.5DEA493F.BOPMSCO.PO4.100 .1316B72. I.4E75E.I.unl From li S. Roth Display Name MI S. Roth Email nrothkrbop.gov UUID 89F05140-19D0-0OO0-B770A200000058D0 Reply To [email protected] Text lil S. Roth To Loneryl Bunts Cc Alison Leukefeld: Alix McLearen: Hugh Hurwitz Subject Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen. suit says I Miami Herald Scheduled date 2019.12.061227:42 Creation date 2019.12.061227:42 Modified date 2019-12-06 123400 Delis cad date 2019.12.061227:44 Message size 6923 Attachments 0 Recipients 4 Recipient Alison Leukefeld Display Name Alison Leulicfeld Email [email protected] UUID 48744D50-140A-00C13-AB85-2D9EDOCC8C14 Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Recipient Aix McLaren Display Name Mix McLaren Email [email protected] UUID 610EBF8I-0E72-0000.8EI8-000000000000 Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Recipient Hugh Ilunviz Display Name Hugh Hunviz Email lillunvitz@bongov UUID 8922M60.1581.0000-B66C-FACF6AODASIC Distribution Type CC Recipient 'fype User Recipient Loncryl Burns Display Name Lawry! Burns Email [email protected] UUID B2ESDF81-1B I I-0000-9EF2-000083219F4E Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Expire 0 Delay delivery until 0 Delegated fake Archived fake Read true Deleted false Opened trot Completed false Security Normal Box type Inbox Return notification when opened fake Return notification when deleted fake Return notification "tic ii completed false Return notification when declined fake Return notification when accepted fake Archive Version 5.3 Internal ID 5DEA493F.DOPMSCO.PO4.100.B16B72.1.4E75E .1(§168EF3AB2.B0PMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1. 2752D.1@l3 Source received Class Public Account Hugh IhrwianB0P55178.PO4.EtOPMSCO Page 16811 EFTA00046322

Location ID 1540843449744 Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL Enclosing Folders I Folder OGC ID 58EF3AB2BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.2752D.1@13 Name OGC Type Normal System false Share Type NotSharcd Page 16812 EFTA00046323

Audits Date Action Auditor Note 2019.12.1110x1820 EST Created en-Archive Agent_2-Zero Day Archivc8.cn-Jobs.cn-GWOpcnNodc.cn-archiv isg.o=nctmail Generated by Ncigavem Km-Archive Agent 2-Zem Day Archi;e&en-Jobs.cri-GWOpenNode.cn-archis iigo-netmai) 2020-05-19 153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.8IXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive 2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbggcd Page 16813 EFTA00046324

Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald From Beth Reese To Alix McLcarenBradley T Gross, Hugh Hurwitz, Jill S. Roth, James Wills, Kenneth Hyle, Loneryl BumsSusan AllisonSonya Thompson Date 2019/12/06 12:22 Subject: Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald Attachments: TEXT.htm We can give numbers of cases that we have that raise sexual abuse allegations, but those would relate only to staff/inmate cases, and I would not describe them as "unwanted sexual contact" so much as impermissible sexual contact. We also don't have a breakdown of male/female facilities - this question would be complicated to answer. Coleman, for example, is generally a male facility, but females are at the camp. Here are the raw numbers of staff/inmate cases: FY 2014 - 501 FY 2015 - 372 FY 2016 - 466 FY 2017 - 377 FY 2018 - 516 FY 2019 - 439 On average, we sustain charges in fewer than 5% of cases. Beth Reese U.S. Department of Justice Federal Bureau of Prisons Office of Internal Affairs 320 First Street, N.W., Room 600 Washington, D.C. 20534 (202) 353-2114 (direct) (202) 307-3286 (main) (202) 514-8625 (fax) > » Loneryl Burns 12/6/201911:33 AM > » Adding Hugh and Jill. Are we able to provide the stats they are requesting? Thanks, Loneryl >» Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:57 AM > » Thanks Ken! >> > Kenneth Hyle 12/6/2019 10:54 AM >>> Hello Loneryl - From our end: Page 16814 EFTA00046325

he Federal Bureau ot Prisons (Bureau) takes allegations ot start misconduct seriously and, consistent with national policy, refers all allegations for investigation. The Bureau learned of allegations of sexual abuse through initial inmate complaints, and subsequently through administrative claims filed under the Federal Torts Claim Act. All allegations brought to the Bureau's attention were investigated by the Office of Internal Affairs. > » Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:13 AM > » Good Morning All, Please see the below questions from OS. Can you please advise on the response? Thanks, Loneryl >>> "Lucas, Daniel (JMD)" <[email protected]> 12/6/2019 8:21 AM > >> Good morning all- Please see incoming below from OS this morning. Is BOP able to assist with response? Thanks, Dan OS: This is an incredibly troubling story and it's now a lawsuit. Was BOP aware of these reports in the past? It sounds like there were multiple reports. Please keep us updated. In general, how many instances of unwanted sexual contact are reported at BOP facilities each year FY 2014-2019; how many of these were inmate only related and how many were inmate and BOP staff related; and how many were male institutions vs female institutions? In regards to PREA, are only inmates at the facility interviewed? The story references inmates who were moved out of the facility and into other facilities in advance of PREA investigators arriving. Thanks. https://vvww.miamiherald.com/article237797554.html? utm source=The+Marshall+Project+Newsletter&utm campaign=a35a3b41b3- FMAII CAMPAIGN 7019 17 05 1? 368eistm medium=email&utm term=0 5e02cdad9d- a35a3b41b3-1745 11049 Rape is rampant at this women's prison. Anyone who complains is punished, lawsuit says. December 04, 2019 10:47 AM I I V vf• Page 16815 EFTA00046326

A ivnami Heraki learn investigation into corruption, sexual abuse and medical neglect at the largest women's prison in the nation, Lowell Correctional. Reporting by Julie K. Brown / [email protected]. By Emily Michot For years, male officers at the women's work camp at Coleman Federal Correctional Complex sexually harassed and assaulted inmates in what amounted to a "sanctuary" for systemic abuse, a space where they were shielded from any consequences. If the women complained about being groped, fondled or forced to perform sex acts on officers, the inmates were the ones who were punished. Fourteen women, ranging in age from 30 to 56 and nearly all first-time offenders, have banded together to sue the United States, not under pseudonyms but under their real names, over the abuse they say they've endured at the Bureau of Prisons- operated camp. Seven of the women are still incarcerated. The lawsuit seeks compensation and an overhaul of the prison. It was filed this week. An aerial view of the sprawling Coleman complex Coleman officials did not immediately respond to a request from the Miami Herald for comment. The litigation is the latest manifestation of dysfunction in a federal prison system that seemingly hit bottom when Jeffrey Epstein, perhaps the most high-profile detainee in the nation, was found hanged Aug 10 in his cell at another BOP facility, the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan, while officers dozed nearby. The death, which led to the summary removal of the acting director of the prison system, has been termed a suicide. It occurred despite what was described as a previous suicide attempt three weeks earlier. Although it touches on a second institution in Tallahassee, the lawsuit focuses primarily on Coleman, the largest prison complex in the federal system. Located in Sumter County near Wildwood, it houses more than 6,000 inmates in a series of compounds and camps, including roughly 500 women, the complaint says In stark, chilling detail, the lawsuit describes pervasive abuse — how women were coerced and threatened, how they were lured into private offices or remote sheds with no surveillance cameras, or stalked relentlessly by corrections officers until they had no choice but to submit. The officers — all of whom are identified in the lawsuit, at least by last name — Page 16816 EFTA00046327

would at times display computer screens showing the women the exact location of their families, a pointed message that their relatives could be targeted if the women didn't cooperate. Some of the women had minor children. In some cases, officers wanted to maintain relationships with the women after they had served their time, according to the lawsuit. The lawsuit says Coleman employed no fewer than seven officers who took advantage of their authority and access to sexually abuse the women. Some of the officers had been investigated for sexual abuse in the past, with nothing coming of it, the lawsuit alleges. The Miami Herald requested personnel files on all of the named officers to see if there were telltale warnings in their backgrounds. The Bureau of Prisons responded that absent an "overriding public interest," it would not provide such documents, calling the provision of such records "an unwarranted invasion of their personal privacy." The male staffers maintained total control over the women's lives, safety and well- being. At least one victim said she was ordered to begin birth control to avoid the possibility of becoming pregnant and another was given a morning-after pill by an officer. Page 16817 EFTA00046328

Properties Property Value Message ID SDEA47ES.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E759 .1 Message Path xmlCabineriOOO5DEA47E&BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E7S9.1.smil From Beth Reese Display Name Beth Reese Email [email protected] UUID 015686F0-13F7-0OO0-AB85-2D9EDOCC8Cl4 Reply To hmrcese@boragov Text Beth Reese To Mx MeLearen; Hugh Hurwitz Jill S. Roth; James Wills; Kenneth Ilyk; Lawry! Barns Cc Bradley T Gross; Susan Allison Sonya Thompson Subject Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suk says I Mimi Herald Scheduled date 2019-12-06 122139 Creation date 2019-12-06 122139 Modified date 2019-12-06 1233:43 Delis end date 2019-12-06 122201 Message size 6439 Attachments sin 12992 Total size 19742 Attachments I Attachment TEXT.htm Name TEXT.htm Content ID SDEA47E8.BOPMSCO.PO4.200.20000DD.1.12973 2.1Q435DEA4707.80PMSCO.PO4.100.1316872. [email protected] 6872.1.2752D.1@13 Is Inline false Type in Size 12992 Date 2019-12-06072156 d03e696ec I 7cc70391,159916267e20ca Hash 87A298A08A167D2CDFADFSESBCD168F6550638BC 030506DA60EF13A09C8A7FFACBBAE26DC Recipients 9 Recipient Mx SleLearen Display Name Mix McLcarcn Email [email protected] UUID 610EBF81-0E72-00O0-8E18-000000000000 Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Recipient Bradley T Gross Display Name Bradley T Gross Email BGrots@bop,gov UUID F09FC101-16560000.8495-000083219F58 Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Recipient Hugh mown Display Name Hugh Huswitz Email Filiunvi*Isop.gos llUID B922A560-1581.0000-B66C-FACF6AODA5IC Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Recipient Jil S. Roth Display Name Jil S. Roth Email [email protected] UUID 89F05l40-19DO0000•B770-0200000058D0 Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Recipient James Wills Display Name James Wills Email [email protected] UUID 79fB2E01-157F-0000-BFB5-0OO0€3202C73 Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Recipient Kenneth Hylc Display Name Kenneth Hyk Email Kliylegbop.gov UUID 4FA5EEC0-0358-0001.83F5-C300F500EA00 Distribution Type TO Page 16818 EFTA00046329