Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone ----- Original message ------ From: Hugh Hurwitz Date: 12/6/19 11:41 AM (GMT-05:00) To: Alison Leukefeld , Alix McLearen , "Jill S. Roth" Subject: Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald >>> "Hugh Hurwitz" 12/06/2019 11:41 >>> We should be able to provide this from the annual prea report, right? Can we do today? >>> Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 11:33 AM >>> Adding Hugh and Jill. Are we able to provide the stats they are requesting? Thanks, Loneryl >>> Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:57 AM >>> Thanks Ken! >>> Kenneth Hyle 12/6/2019 10:54 AM >>> Hello Loneryl - From our end: The Federal Bureau of Prisons (Bureau) takes allegations of staff misconduct seriously and, consistent with national policy, refers all allegations for investigation. The Bureau learned of allegations of sexual abuse through initial inmate complaints, and subsequently through administrative claims filed under the Federal Torts Claim Act. All allegations brought to the Bureau's attention were investigated by the Office of Internal Affairs. >>> Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:13 AM >>> Good Morning All, Please see the below questions from CJS. Can you please advise on the response? Thanks, Loneryl >>> "Lucas, Daniel (JMD)" 12/6/2019 8:21 AM >>> Good morning all- Please see incoming below from CJS this morning. Is BOP able to assist with response? Page 16768 EFTA00046279

Thanks, Dan CJS: This is an incredibly troubling story and it's now a lawsuit. Was BOP aware of these reports in the past? It sounds like there were multiple reports. Please keep us updated. In general, how many instances of unwanted sexual contact are reported at BOP facilities each year FY 2014-2019; how many of these were inmate only related and how many were inmate and BOP staff related; and how many were male institutions vs female institutions? In regards to PREA, are only inmates at the facility interviewed? The story references inmates who were moved out of the facility and into other facilities in advance of PREA investigators arriving. Thanks. https://www.miamiherald.conilarticle237797554.html? utm source=The+MarshalH-Project+Newsletter&utm campaign=a35a3b41b3- EMAIL_CAMPAIGN 2019_12_05_12_36&utm medium=email&utm term=0_5e02cdad9d- a35a3b41b3-174511049 Rape is rampant at this women's prison. Anyone who complains is punished, lawsuit says. December 04, 2019 10:47 AM A Miami Herald I-Team investigation into corruption, sexual abuse and medical neglect at the largest women's prison in the nation, Lowell Correctional. Reporting by Julie K. Brown / [email protected]. By Emily Michot For years, male officers at the women's work camp at Coleman Federal Correctional Complex sexually harassed and assaulted inmates in what amounted to a "sanctuary" for systemic abuse, a space where they were shielded from any consequences. If the women complained about being groped, fondled or forced to perform sex acts on officers, the inmates were the ones who were punished. Fourteen women, ranging in age from 30 to 56 and nearly all first-time offenders, have banded together to sue the United States, not under pseudonyms but under their real names, over the abuse they say they've endured at the Bureau of Prisons-operated camp. Seven of the women are still incarcerated.The lawsuit seeks compensation and an overhaul of the prison. It was filed this week. An aerial view of the sprawling Coleman complex Coleman officials did not immediately respond to a request from the Miami Herald for comment. The litigation is the latest manifestation of dysfunction in a federal prison system that seemingly hit bottom when Jeffrey Epstein, perhaps the most high-profile detainee in the nation, was found hanged Aug 10 in his cell at another BOP facility, the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan, while officers dozed nearby. The death, which led to the summary removal of the acting director of the prison system, has been termed a suicide. It occurred despite what was described as a previous suicide attempt three weeks earlier. Although it touches on a second institution in Tallahassee, the lawsuit focuses primarily on Coleman, the largest prison complex in the federal system. Located in Sumter County near Page 16769 EFTA00046280

w uawooa, a nouses more man o,uuu inmates in a series or compounas ana camps, 'limning roughly 500 women, the complaint says In stark, chilling detail, the lawsuit describes pervasive abuse — how women were coerced and threatened, how they were lured into private offices or remote sheds with no surveillance cameras, or stalked relentlessly by corrections officers until they had no choice but to submit. The officers — all of whom are identified in the lawsuit, at least by last name — would at times display computer screens showing the women the exact location of their families, a pointed message that their relatives could be targeted if the women didn't cooperate. Some of the women had minor children. In some cases, officers wanted to maintain relationships with the women after they had served their time, according to the lawsuit. The lawsuit says Coleman employed no fewer than seven officers who took advantage of their authority and access to sexually abuse the women. Some of the officers had been investigated for sexual abuse in the past, with nothing coming of it, the lawsuit alleges. The Miami Herald requested personnel files on all of the named officers to see if there were telltale warnings in their backgrounds. The Bureau of Prisons responded that absent an "overriding public interest," it would not provide such documents, calling the provision of such records "an unwarranted invasion of their personal privacy." The male staffers maintained total control over the women's lives, safety and well-being. At least one victim said she was ordered to begin birth control to avoid the possibility of becoming pregnant and another was given a morning-after pill by an officer. Page 16770 EFTA00046281

Properties Property Value Message ID 5DEA4CB3.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.B16B72.1.4E76A .1 Message Path xmlCabineARSD‘PsycholomA5DEA4C83.BOPM SCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E76A.I.xml From JA S. Roth Display Name MI S. Roth Email [email protected] UUID 891'05 140- 19D0-0000-B770-0200000058D0 Reply To [email protected] Text JA S. Roth To Hugh Hurwiz Subject RE: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic. brazon. suit Scheduled date 2019.12-06124224 Creation date 2019.12-0612:4224 Modified date 2019.12-061248:19 Delivered date 2019-12-06 12:4228 Message sire 7997 Attachments 0 Recipients I Recipient Hugh Htrwitz Display Name Hugh Hurwitz Email IlHunvitzUndlop.gov UU1D B922A560-1581.0000.666C•FACF6AODA5IC Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User Ere 0 Delay deliver, until 0 Delegated false Archived false Read true Deleted false Opened true Completed false Security Normal Box type Inbox Return notification when opened false Return notification sshen deleted false Return notification sshen completed false Return notification when declined false Return notification when accepted false Archive Version 5.3 Internal ID 5DEA4CEO.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1310372.1.4E76A .1@ 1:5D5B94DD.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316672.1. 4A355.1@13 Source received Class Public Account Hugh I [email protected] Location ID 154(1843449744 Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL Enclosing Folders 1 Folder P83(9110451 ID 5D5B94DD.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4A355 .1@l3 Name Psychology Type Normal System false Share Type NotSharcd Page 16771 EFTA00046282

Audits Dale Action Auditor Note 2019-12.11092196 EST Created en-Archive Agent_2-Zero Day Archive8.en-Jobs.en-GWOpenNodocn-archiv isgo=nctmail Generated by Neigovem Km-Archive Agent 2-Zem Day Archi;e&en-Jobs.ert-GWOpenNode.cn-archis itgo-netmai) 2020-05-19 153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.8IXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive 2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged Page 16772 EFTA00046283

Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald From Hugh Hurwitz Alison Leukefeld, Alix McLearenBradley T GrossBeth Reese, Jill S. To Roth, James Wills, Kenneth Hyle, Loneryl BumsSusan AllisonSonya Thompson Date 2019/12/06 13:10 Subject: Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic, brazen, suit says I Miami Herald Attachments: TEXT. ht m Jill provided the following info: This is just for inmate on inmate sexually abusive behavior since Beth already provided the staff on inmate totals. Like Beth, we can't accurately break down the allegations by facility gender. If they need allegation totals for female inmates, it is possible ORE may be able to pull that (Sue is copied here). These numbers are total number of allegations of inmate-on-inmate sexually abusive behavior for each calendar year requested with the exception of CY 2019 because it is not over and we have not reviewed the data yet. Sexually abusive behavior encompasses acts (penetration), contact (fondling), and harassment (non- contact offenses). I break down the substantiated cases by type. 2014 - 324 allegations; 12 Substantiated (2 ACT, 6 CON, 6 HAR) 2015 - 365 allegations; 17 Substantiated (7 ACT, 7 CON, 3 HAR) 2016 - 334 allegations; 25 Substantiated (4 ACT, 11 CON, 10 HAR) 2017 - 417 allegations; 26 Substantiated (2 ACT, 12 CON, 12 HAR) 2018 - 489 allegations; 29 Substantiated (8 ACT, 11 CON, 10 HAR) > > > Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 11:33 AM > > > Adding Hugh and Jill. Are we able to provide the stats they are requesting? Thanks, Loneryl > » Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:57 AM > » Thanks Ken! >> > Kenneth Hyle 12/6/2019 10:54 AM >>> Hello Loneryl - From our end: The Federal Bureau of Prisons (Bureau) takes allegations of staff misconduct seriously and, consistent with national policy, refers all allegations for investigation. The Bureau learned of allegations of sexual abuse through initial inmate complaints, and subsequently through administrative claims filed under the Federal Page 16773 EFTA00046284

Torts Claim Act. All allegations brought to the Bureau's attention were investigated by the Office of Internal Affairs. > » Loneryl Burns 12/6/2019 10:13 AM > » Good Morning All, Please see the below questions from OS. Can you please advise on the response? Thanks, Loneryl »> "Lucas, Daniel (JMD)" <[email protected]> 12/6/2019 8:21 AM >» Good morning all- Please see incoming below from OS this morning. Is BOP able to assist with response? Thanks, Dan OS: This is an incredibly troubling story and it's now a lawsuit. Was BOP aware of these reports in the past? It sounds like there were multiple reports. Please keep us updated. In general, how many instances of unwanted sexual contact are reported at BOP facilities each year FY 2014-2019; how many of these were inmate only related and how many were inmate and BOP staff related; and how many were male institutions vs female institutions? In regards to PREA, are only inmates at the facility interviewed? The story references inmates who were moved out of the facility and into other facilities in advance of PREA investigators arriving. Thanks. https://www.miamiherald.com/article237797554.html? utm_source=The+Marshall+Project+Newsletter&utm_campaign=a35a3b41b3- FMAILSAMPAIGN_2019 12_05 12_36&tdrn_mediom=email8tutm_term=()_Se02cdad9d- a3Sa3b41b3-174511049 Rape is rampant at this women's prison. Anyone who complains is punished, lawsuit says. December 04, 2019 10:47 AM A Miami Herald 1-Team investigation into corruption, sexual abuse and medical neglect at the largest women's prison in the nation, Lowell Correctional. Reporting by Julie K. Brown / ibrownth)tniamiherald.com. By Emily Michot Page 16774 EFTA00046285

For years, male officers at the women's work camp at Coleman Federal Correctional Complex sexually harassed and assaulted inmates in what amounted to a "sanctuary" for systemic abuse, a space where they were shielded from any consequences. If the women complained about being groped, fondled or forced to perform sex acts on officers, the inmates were the ones who were punished. Fourteen women, ranging in age from 30 to 56 and nearly all first-time offenders, have banded together to sue the United States, not under pseudonyms but under their real names, over the abuse they say they've endured at the Bureau of Prisons- operated camp. Seven of the women are still incarcerated. The lawsuit seeks compensation and an overhaul of the prison. It was filed this week. An aerial view of the sprawling Coleman complex Coleman officials did not immediately respond to a request from the Miami Herald for comment. The litigation is the latest manifestation of dysfunction in a federal prison system that seemingly hit bottom when Jeffrey Epstein, perhaps the most high-profile detainee in the nation, was found hanged Aug. 10 in his cell at another BOP facility, the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan, while officers dozed nearby. The death, which led to the summary removal of the acting director of the prison system, has been termed a suicide. It occurred despite what was described as a previous suicide attempt three weeks earlier. Although it touches on a second institution in Tallahassee, the lawsuit focuses primarily on Coleman, the largest prison complex in the federal system. Located in Sumter County near Wildwood, it houses more than 6,000 inmates in a series of compounds and camps, including roughly 500 women, the complaint says In stark, chilling detail, the lawsuit describes pervasive abuse — how women were coerced and threatened, how they were lured into private offices or remote sheds with no surveillance cameras, or stalked relentlessly by corrections officers until they had no choice but to submit. The officers — all of whom are identified in the lawsuit, at least by last name — would at times display computer screens showing the women the exact location of their families, a pointed message that their relatives could be targeted if the women Page 16775 EFTA00046286

didn't cooperate. Some of the women had minor children. In some cases, officers wanted to maintain relationships with the women after they had served their time, according to the lawsuit. The lawsuit says Coleman employed no fewer than seven officers who took advantage of their authority and access to sexually abuse the women. Some of the officers had been investigated for sexual abuse in the past, with nothing coming of it, the lawsuit alleges. The Miami Herald requested personnel files on all of the named officers to see if there were telltale warnings in their backgrounds. The Bureau of Prisons responded that absent an "overriding public interest," it would not provide such documents, calling the provision of such records "an unwarranted invasion of their personal privacy." The male staffers maintained total control over the women's lives, safety and well- being. At least one victim said she was ordered to begin birth control to avoid the possibility of becoming pregnant and another was given a morning-after pill by an officer. Page 16776 EFTA00046287

Properties Property Value Message ID 5DEA5349.BOPMSCO.PO4.103.B16B72.1.4E776 .1 Message Path xmlCabincORSD \ PsychologA5DEA5349.BOPM SCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E77C Lam] From Hugh Hurwitz Display Name Hugh Hawn Email illiunnagliop.gov UUID B922A560.1581.0000-B66C-FACF6A00A51C Reply To HHurwitzfit bop.gov Text Hugh 11111VilZ To Mix MeLcarew. Jill S. Roth; James Wik; Kemeth Hyk; Loncryl Bums Cc Alai Leukefeld: Bradley T Gross: Beth Reese: Susan Allison: Sonya Tharripsen Subject Re: Fwd: Sexual abuse at Florida prison was systemic. brazen, sui says I Mimi Herald Scheduled date 2019-12-06 13:1033 Creation date 2019.12.0613:1033 Modified date 2019-12-06 1530:19 Delis end date 2019-12.0613:1033 Message size 6660 Attachments sin 12976 Total size 19651 Attachments I Attachment TEXT.hun Name TEXT.htm Content ID 5DEA5349.BOPMSCO.PO4.200.2000000.1.3BFA00.1@453DEA5349.1lOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316872. [email protected] 6B72.1.4A355.1@13 Is Inline false Type fde Size 12976 Date 2019.12.0608:1027 CA e93046dafee89c6739bab7efe9d74863 Hash 3883324BF57D78D836247EC37E6E5FDOA79E607A 6BFA62F77638D609451:2838496846021 Recipients 10 Recipient Minn Leukefekl Display Name Alison Leukefeld Email aleukefeld(ifibop.gov UUID 487441350-140A-0000AB85-2D9EDOCC804 Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Delivered 2019-12-06 13:1034 DownloadedB IblrdP • 2019-12-06 13:1035 Opened 2019-12-06 13:12.02 Recipient Akx McLearen Display Name An McLaren Email [email protected] UUID 610EBF131-0E72-0000-8E18-000000000030 Distribution Type TO Recipient Type User _ . . Delivered 2019.12-0613:1034 DonnloadedBylliirdParty 2019-12-06 13:1035 Opened 2019-12-06 132428 Recipient Bradley T Gross Display Name Bradley T Gross Email BGross@bonov UUID F'09FC101-1656-0000.8495-0000832I9F58 Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Delivered 2019-12-06 13:1034 DownloadedByThirdParty 2019-12-06 B:11:1 I Opened 2019-12-05 133124 Recipient Beth Reese Display Name Beth Reese Email [email protected] UUID 0156B6F0BF7-0000AB85-2D9EDOCC8CI4 Distribution Type CC Recipient Type User Del:hued 2019.12.0613:1034 DownloadedBylliirdParty 2019.12.0613:1038 Page 16777 EFTA00046288