An internal DOJ email chain from July 17, 2019 showing Geoffrey Berman (US Attorney SDNY) and his public affairs team debating whether to issue a public statement about Jeffrey Epstein's bail detention, ultimately deciding against it.

This document reveals behind-the-scenes deliberations within the Southern District of New York's US Attorney's Office on the day before Judge Richard Berman denied Epstein bail. Geoffrey Berman, the US Attorney, expressed frustration that 'we are missing an opportunity' to publicize their tip line and investigation expansion, but his public affairs team recommended against making any additional statements, citing litigation risk and that they had already stated on record that 'many responses' to the tip line had 'dramatically widened' their investigation. The exchange shows internal tensions between prosecutors wanting to encourage more victims to come forward and staff concerned about optics and legal exposure.

Key Highlights

• •Geoffrey Berman wanted to issue a statement about the tip line to encourage more victims to come forward
• •Public affairs staff pushed back, citing 'misgivings' about making statements regarding detention
• •Prosecutors had already stated publicly that tip line responses 'dramatically widened' their investigation
• •This internal debate occurred July 17, 2019 - one day before Epstein was denied bail

Frequently Asked Questions