c6vie 11 7L. Jeffrey E. Epstein ,41 01.4) 07/26/17 Page 2339 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Tape: PBPD & Date: October 11, 2005 Time: 4:10 p.m. Participants: Det. Joe Recarey: DETECTIVE (introduces the recording and asks most questions) Det. Dawson: DETECTIVE 2 Shayna Jasmine: FRIEND Abbreviations: UI = unintelligible II = voices overlap Transcript 1 October II, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2340 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 [Tape begins slow/warped; becomes regular speed] 2 3 DETECTIVE: October 11, 2005 UI number UI Detective Joe Recarey [ph]. 4 Present with me is detective Dawson of the Palm Beach Police 5 Department. Urn, we are at 1071 Kingsley Road in Jacksonville, 6 Florida. Uh, the time on my watch is approximately 4:10 p.m. Uh, 7 present with me is — state your name please. 8 9 10 11 DETECTIVE: And your name is? 12 13 FRIEND: Shayna Jasmine UI. 14 15 DETECTIVE: Shayna? 16 17 S FRIEND: Jasmine UI UI. 18 19 DETECTIVE: Casman [ph]. All right. I'll cut it short, I'll put Shayna Casman. 20 And you're here just for moral support. 21 22 'S FRIEND: Yes. 23 24 DETECTIVE: Okay. And, urn, Ms. can you, um, state your date of birth for 25 me? 26 27 28 29 DETECTIVE: Okay. All right. Can you raise your right hand for me? Do you 30 solemnly swear to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the 31 truth, so help you god? 32 33 I do. 34 35 DETECTIVE: Okay. Urn, you finished high school? 36 37 Excuse me? In May. 38 39 DETECTIVE: In May. Of this year, 2005? 40 41 This year. 42 43 DETECTIVE: Okay. Um, and you're going to be starting college very soon, 44 correct? 45 46 January 9th. Defense Transcript 2 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2341 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 DETECTIVE: January 9th 3 4 2006. 5 6 DETECTIVE: Okay. So you understand everything that's going on here and 7 everything that I'm asking you, correct? 8 9 Correct. 10 11 DETECTIVE: Okay. Urn. Obviously I've explained that I am investigating a 12 case, uh, involving a subject that you may know, urn, by the name 13 of Jeffrey or Jeff Epstein. Uh, he's a resident in uh, Palm Beach. 14 Um, I believe you may have some information pertaining to this 15 case. Urn, if you could in your own words, urn, can you explain 16 from the beginning, as to, uh, what happened, and 17 18 There's like a year and a half, almost two years to go over. Like, 19 do you want me to go through everything, or do you want to 20 specifically ask me stuff? 21 22 DETECTIVE: //Well, ah, start from like how you met him, and then I'll, I'll take 23 you through. 24 25 //Okay. Um, heard me over talk — we worked at 26 Hollister together in the Wellington Green Mall, and I was 27 mentioning to her how I wanted extra money to go to Maine. Urn. 28 29 DETECTIVE: Is that where you're from? 30 31 No, but I wanted to go camping. I like to go camping. 32 33 DETECTIVE: All right. 34 35 So I wanted to go camping for the summer, and I couldn't afford a 36 plane ticket. And goes 'Oh, well, you can get a plane 37 ticket in two hours.' I said, what are you talking about? Like, 38 what are you, that didn't make any sense to me a plane ticket in 39 two hours, what are you talking about? And she goes 'Oh, we can 40 go and give this guy a massage, and, urn, he'll pay two hundred 41 dollars for like forty-five minutes or an hour.' And that's all she 42 told me no details no nothing. 43 44 DETECTIVE: //Okay. 45 Defense Transcript 3 October I I, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2342 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Urn, a couple of days later, I believe it was a Saturday night. I'm almost positive it was, cause I know I didn't have to go to school the next day. Urn, and definitely wasn't a Friday. So it next Saturday night after that. She set it up, and I picked her up from the her apartment, and we drove to the island and I worked, urn, and he paid her three or four hundred dollars to bring me. Okay. And that was it. All right. Um, and this was a year and a half ago, correct? Maybe two, I'm not sure, I didn't really keep track //Okay. How old were you when you first, uh, went over there? If it was two years ago I was sixteen, if it was a year and a half, I would have been sixteen or seventeen, I don't know. Okay. Like, I really don't know. Okay. When you first went to give a massage, urn, you were explained that, it was just a massage? Just a massage. Okay. Did she explain, urn, how you would have to be dressed to give a massage? She said that he wanted cute girls, so I looked cute, did my best, I didn't — I didn't think that it was what it was. I wasn't naïve enough to think that he was gonna pay me two hundred dollars just for nothing, [stutters] I, I don't know, like I don't know what was going through my head. I absolutely don't know. And I — the back of my mind I was thinking, oh, well, it could be legitimate, but I was also thinking, you know, at the same time, is she fucking crazy? Like, this guy's not gonna pay you money for not doing anything, not letting him cop a feel or nothing. You know? So I didn't know what to think, I was like oh, I'll just go and I'll feel it out and if I don't like it, I'll leave. Like, in the middle of it, like I don't care. If he does something that I have a problem with then I'll leave. 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 DETECTIVE: 9 10 11 12 DETECTIVE: 13 14 15 16 DETECTIVE: 17 18 19 20 21 DETECTIVE: 22 23 24 25 DETECTIVE: 26 27 28 29 30 DETECTIVE: 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 Defense Transcript 4 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2343 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 DETECTIVE: Okay. When you went, how, urn. You drove? 2 3 Uh huh. 4 5 DETECTIVE: You drove with 6 7 Yes. 8 9 DETECTIVE: Okay. Urn, you pulled up to the house, 10 11 Uh huh. 12 13 DETECTIVE: Take me from there. 14 15 Pulled up to the service entrance, went up through the um, the little 16 white gate that leads to the backyard. We, I pressed or she pressed 17 the little intercom button thing, and uh, said 'It's — , I have 18 my friend with me.' And, they all knew I was coming. They knew 19 me by name, greeted me with, like, Oh, we're so happy to 20 see you. You know, Jeffrey will be ready in a second. You know. 21 22 DETECTIVE: Who were you introduced to? 23 24 One of his girlfriends. One of his, like, slaves that he has live with 25 him. And when I say slaves. like one of the girls that he bought to 26 like have sex with him. Urn, I was introduced to one of them 27 probably like... Sarah. I was introduced to Sarah. Urn, that's his 28 assistant, I think, I think they have sex, but I don't know. Urn, I 29 was introduced to his assistant Sarah and she's the one who told 30 me that he would be ready in a second. And from there I met 31 various other girls. I don't really, I didn't pay attention to who 32 they were though. But I saw Sarah all the time after that so I 33 remember her. 34 35 DETECTIVE: Okay. How were you brought, uh, to Jeffrey? 36 37 Um, let me, I'm trying to remember. I went — there's a staircase in 38 the kitchen, 39 40 DETECTIVE: Uh huh. 41 42 And I went through the staircase in the kitchen up to the master 43 suite, urn, into the, like there's two bathrooms 44 45 DETECTIVE: //Uh huh 46 Defense Transcript 5 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2344 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 One has like a steam shower and then the other one's like this, the 2 other one is like, urn, a regular, it's just a regular bathroom. But 3 then there's another bathroom with a steam shower, and like, I 4 don't know. There's two bathrooms in there, I'll just make it easy. 5 There's two bathrooms. I was brought into the one bathroom, the 6 massage bathroom with the steam shower, and was with 7 me, and Sarah was like 'Oh, just wait here, yadda yadda.' So 8 -• and me were waiting on the couch in the bathroom, and, 9 um, Jeffrey comes up and he's like 'Hey, I'm, I'm Jeffrey.' He 10 just introduced himself and, he hands — _ I remember this 11 cause I was pissed off that she got paid to bring me. Like I was 12 pissed off. He hands her a wad of hundred dollar bills and says 13 'Thank you' and she says 'I'll wait for you downstairs' and I was 14 like 'All right, I'll see you in a little while.' And that's how I was 15 brought to Jeffrey. 16 17 DETECTIVE: Okay. Take me through the massage. Uh, that first massage. 18 19 Um. Hold on, I'm remembering, I'm like picturing in my head. I 20 wore a skirt. I remember specifically what I wore, I wore a skirt 21 and just a regular t-shirt. And I was massaging his legs, and he 22 asked me to take off my skirt. And I said, I think I said no at first. 23 And he's like, 'Come on, you're not showing' — he talked me into 24 it basically, he's like 'Oh, you're not showing anything,' or did 25 something, I don't even know. So I ended up taking off my skirt, 26 and then he goes, well I think he just started touching, you know, 27 the top of me. So and then he asked me 28 29 DETECTIVE 2: When you're saying the top of you, you mean your breasts? 30 31 Yeah. And then he asked me to take off my shirt. So I took off 32 my shirt but I kept my underwear on. And I wouldn't take my 33 underwear off, I told him no. And he still paid me the same 34 amount. And that was that, I went home. 35 36 DETECTIVE: Okay. You had on your 37 38 I had my panties on. 39 40 DETECTIVE: Panties. 41 42 Nothing else. I was topless 43 44 DETECTIVE: //Okay 45 Defense Transcript 6 October II, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2345 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 I gave him the massage, I had my panties on. And he had 2 requested me to take them off but I didn't. 3 4 DETECTIVE: Okay. Were they regular panties, were they thong panties, were 5 they 6 7 I don't know. 8 9 DETECTIVE: You don't remember? Okay. 10 11 No. 12 13 DETECTIVE: Okay. During the massage, did he do anything to himself? 14 15 Yeah. [pause] What word do you want me to use, cause I already 16 told UI 17 18 DETECTIVE: //Whatever word, I know. Whatever word you feel comfortable 19 with 20 21 //I don't want to be crude. 22 23 DETECTIVE: Well, whatever word you're comfortable 24 25 //Okay, well I'll just say it, whatever. He masturbated. 26 27 DETECTIVE: Okay. 28 29 While UI the massage. And the massage was over as soon as he 30 was finished with himself. 31 32 DETECTIVE: Okay. So in other words, he 33 34 Finished with himself and that was it, yeah. He ejaculated, 35 specifically. 36 37 DETECTIVE: // Okay. Okay. That was the very first time you went there. 38 39 Uh huh. 40 41 DETECTIVE: And, I know. Take a deep breath, I know, I can see it in your eyes 42 already. Urn, from then on, you went there multiple times? 43 44 I first told him, like, I had a problem with it, what happened the 45 first time. But two hundred dollars for forty minutes, that was a lot 46 for a sixteen-year-old girl making six bucks an hour. Defense Transcript 7 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2346 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 DETECTIVE 2: So you're saying you're sure you were sixteen now? 3 4 Uh, [sigh] I don't want to say I'm sure of my age. I was under 5 seventeen a hundred percent. 6 7 DETECTIVE 2: So you were sixteen and something, you weren't, it wasn't your 8 seventeenth birthday yet. 9 10 If you give me a moment I'll recall. 11 12 DETECTIVE: Yeah, sure. Take your time. 13 14 Urn, this past summer I was 15 16 DETECTIVE 2: How old are you right now? 17 18 I'm eighteen right now. 19 20 DETECTIVE 2: Okay, so this December, 21 22 This? 23 24 DETECTIVE 2: Not this past December, the one before it, you turned seventeen. 25 So it's before 26 27 //Yeah. It was 28 29 DETECTIVE 2: Two Christmases ago. 30 31 During that summer. 32 33 DETECTIVE 2: So it was the summer before you turned seventeen. 34 35 Uh huh. As far as I remember, yeah. 36 37 DETECTIVE 2: One of those months, you don't know if it was June, July, August, 38 39 It was during the summer. I mean, my summer since I'm in school 40 is only considered like June, July, and half of August, and it was in 41 between those. Because I wanted to go to Maine for the summer. 42 43 DETECTIVE 2: //Did you go to Maine? 44 45 No. 46 Defense Transcript 8 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2347 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 DETECTIVE 2: Okay. 2 3 No I did not. 4 5 DETECTIVE 2: But you remember that that was the summer you wanted to go to 6 Maine. 7 8 Uh huh. 9 10 DETECTIVE: So that was two summers ago when you were sixteen years of age. 11 12 Yes. 13 14 FRIEND: You were, you were able to drive by yourself, so you had to be at 15 least sixteen. 16 17 Yeah, so I was sixteen. 18 19 DETECTIVE 2: Okay. Urn, when you, the first time you went, when he 20 masturbated, did you see? 21 22 [giggles] 23 24 DETECTIVE: His member? 25 26 Oh, I thought you were going to ask me if I saw, like, his come. 27 28 DETECTIVE 2: No. 29 30 I saw all of the above. 31 32 DETECTIVE 2: You saw him naked, fully naked? Fully naked? 33 34 //Yeah, a hundred percent naked. He had a towel on for some of it, 35 but that doesn't mean anything, like, he was naked. 36 37 DETECTIVE: He took off the towel? 38 39 I saw everything, yeah. 40 41 DETECTIVE: Okay. Do you know the difference between circumcised and 42 uncircumcised? Yeah. Would you say... 43 44 He's uncircumcised. 45 46 DETECTIVE: Uncircumcised? Defense Transcript 9 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2348 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 I mean, I'm sorry, he is circumcised, my bad. He's circumcised, a 3 hundred and ten percent sure. A matter of fact, he has some sort of 4 birth defect. On his thing. I don't know what it is [giggles] I've 5 never like really looked at it, because I've never done anything 6 where I had to touch it. I've never touched it out of the whole time 7 I worked for him I never touched his penis. Like, he I'm pretty 8 sure he he rubbed it against me, but I've never ever been like, okay 9 I'm letting you do this or I'm gonna do this to you. Urn, it's really 10 weirdly shaped. I don't know, do you want me to like tell you 11 this? 12 13 DETECTIVE: Yeah, please. 14 15 Is this proof? Like, 16 17 DETECTIVE: I do, I do want you to tell me. 18 19 Cause I feel like [sighs] 20 21 DETECTIVE: I know, I know. 22 23 5 FRIEND: You're talking to your girlfriends. Don't think of them as guys. 24 You're talking to your girlfriends, 25 26 [giggle] Okay [giggle]. I'm just really embarrassed. 27 28 DETECTIVE: I know, it's okay. 29 30 Urn, it's like a teardrop, like a drop of water. It's really fat at the 31 bottom and skinny at the top where its attached. And, he can never 32 get fully hard, ever. Like, I just could tell by looking at it, like, by 33 looking you can obviously tell if you're hard or not and I could tell 34 that he wasn't. 35 36 DETECTIVE: Okay. 37 38 So I don't know if that's some sort of thing that's wrong with him, 39 but it definitely was not normal. And I have, I mean it's not like I 40 sleep around, you know, but I've seen, and it was not normal. 41 42 DETECTIVE: Right, in movies and stuff. 43 44 Yeah. 45 Defense Transcript 10 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2349 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 DETECTIVE: The next time you went, or as you continued to go, did it escalate 2 more? 3 4 Uh huh. I actually, I don't remember how long it took for me to 5 start working for him regularly from the first time I went there, urn. 6 But, I started working every day. Every single day he was in the 7 country I would be there. Urn, I'm, I'm sorry, I like — can you give 8 me a second. 9 10 DETECTIVE: Sure, absolutely. 11 12 Yeah. I started working there every single day, and um, I told him 13 that I wouldn't let him put anything inside of me, that was my rule. 14 Nothing inside of me, no fingers, no, no nothing, absolutely 15 nothing inside of me. He increased my pay to three or four 16 hundred dollars as long as he could touch me. Um, I still never, I, 17 I swear I never touched him, the whole entire time I never ever 18 touched him. Urn, but he, he 19 20 DETECTIVE: //How many times would you say you went? 21 22 Hundreds. Hundreds, I was — he used to tell me I was his favorite. 23 He bought me a car. He bought me 24 25 DETECTIVE: //This Jeep that you're driving? 26 27 No. I had a brand new Dodge Neon. I got plane, I got a plane 28 ticket to New York, I got spending money whenever I wanted. 29 Like, I was in there deep. I was — he asked my parents to 30 emancipate me so I could live with him. Or he didn't ask my 31 parents, he asked me to ask my parents, I'm sorry. He act — he 32 actually wanted me to come live with him. 33 34 DETECTIVE: As like a girlfriend? 35 36 Sex slave, whatever you want to call it. Yeah. Um, but it 37 escalated — he, he just increased my pay, as long as he could touch 38 me. I wouldn't let him put anything inside of me. And then one 39 day he just did, one day he just put his hand like his fingers. And 40 urn, 41 42 DETECTIVE: How long would you say, from the very first time you went, 43 44 Months. Honestly, I never kept track, like of, of what happened 45 when. I just can tell you in which order things progressed. 46 Defense Transcript 11 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2350 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 DETECTIVE: 2 3 4 5 6 DETECTIVE: 7 8 9 10 DETECTIVE: 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 DETECTIVE: 19 20 21 22 DETECTIVE: 23 24 25 26 DETECTIVE: 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 FRIEND: 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 DETECTIVE: 45 46 Okay. But not specifically, oh, three months later he did this, three months later like, I can't do that. Okay. When he purchased the car, how far were you, urn. How old was I? Yeah. That what you mean? He bought the car in, [sigh] I gotta recall, I haven't thought about this in forever. Um. I can I can give you like four, four months that it possibly was during, but I can't specifically remember if it was before or after the New Year. Urn, November, December, January February, that just passed. Of 2004? Wait a second. So were you a senior in high school when you had the car? Yeah, it was recently. Okay. It was, it was like, towards the middle and end of my school year. But I remember that for the last like six or eight weeks of high school, I didn't have a car cause I gave it back to him. Because he, he asked me to have sex with him and like, like suck him and stuff [giggles], and I was just like, no. Definitely not. I was like, I'll let you touch me but I'm not gonna do that. This is 2005, right? Yeah, the car was a Dodge Neon 2005. He got it for me before the New Year, because I remember I got it, it was an edition that was a year before they were supposed to come out. So if I got it, I obviously didn't get a 2006 cause that's this year. I got a 2005 Neon in 2004. Seven miles on it when I got it. That car was awesome [giggles]. Okay. And that's the car that you used to drive to and from, To and from school, just out with my friends. Defense Transcript 12 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2351 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 DETECTIVE: And to his house, when he 3 4 //Oh his house all the time, yeah. 5 6 DETECTIVE: What color was it? 7 8 Like a neon blue, like a really bright bright bright blue. It was 9 really pretty. Not that that makes a difference. 10 11 DETECTIVE: And you gave it back? 12 13 Yes. 14 15 DETECTIVE: Was this after you graduated from high school, or 16 17 No, I, I gave it back before I graduated. It got too, it got too sticky 18 for me. He wanted more than I was willing to give. I didn't 19 wanna, I didn't want to urn suck his dick, I didn't want to have sex 20 with him. I never did that and I wanted to be able to walk away 21 from this saying that I, saying that I never did that. And I'm glad 22 that I did. 23 24 DETECTIVE: Okay. 25 26 So I just gave it back I said, I don't need this, I don't need a car. 27 28 DETECTIVE: Okay. 29 30 But I lied to him when I gave it back, I didn't want to burn my 31 bridges because he was a spectacular connection to have. 32 Spectacular. Even if I didn't — even when I didn't work for him, 33 until this day, he is so aw — he is so, I haven't talked to him in like 34 a couple months, but urn, as far as he can, as far as he knows, he's, 35 well, I don't know how to, I'm sorry. [stutters] So many things 36 are going through my head right now and I'm just getting a little 37 tongue-tied. Urn. If I called him today he would give me as much 38 money as I asked him for, he doesn't know that I hate him the way 39 I do. I kept that connection. I figured he used me, I'd be able to 40 use him. Urn, I hate to say that but I figured if I wanted to use him 41 I could. 42 43 DETECTIVE: Okay. Let me bring you back a little bit. 44 45 Sure. 46 Defense Transcript 13 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2352 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

I DETECTIVE: Um. When did things start to escalate as far as things happening 2 when the massages were given? 3 4 They escalated whenever he wanted, I, I don't, I don't clearly 5 understand the question. 6 7 DETECTIVE: Okay. The first time you went, you were naked, giving a massage 8 9 //Are you asking for a date? Or you're asking for how 10 11 DETECTIVE: //No no no no, how [stutters] cause I know you don't have specific 12 dates 13 14 //How far in the little steps that things progressed? 15 16 DETECTIVE: Right. 17 18 Well, I went and I wouldn't take off my panties at first, and then he 19 got me to get naked, then he got me to let him rub me, then he got 20 me to let him stick his fingers in me, then he got me to let him go 21 down on me. Then, urn... that was pretty much the, the breadth 22 [rest?] of it, except this one time where he bent me over the table 23 and put himself in me. 24 25 DETECTIVE: Okay. 26 27 Without my permission. 28 29 DETECTIVE: Okay. 30 31 And I flipped out. 32 33 DETECTIVE: All right. Let me 34 35 //And I don't — I'm sorry to interrupt you but I don't count that as 36 me having sex with him, you know he did that, I, I don't, I, cause I 37 just told you I never had sex with him. I never did. It's, you 38 know, I don't know what you'd consider that. But, he then, I go 39 'What are you doing?' He goes 'Oh, I just wanted Adrianna to see 40 this.' Or 'I just wanted um Nadia to see this.' I'm sorry, I got the 41 two confused. For Adrianna to see this, uh Nadia. 42 43 DETECTIVE: //Okay. Let me, let me back you up. 44 45 Okay. 46 Defense Transcript 14 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2353 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 DETECTIVE: That is a crime. 2 3 I don't want my family to find out about this. My family doesn't 4 know any of this, my mom thinks I was his secretary for two years. 5 Or, for however long, a year and a half. My mom thinks I made 6 phone calls for him and that's how I was making my great money. 7 That's it. I don't want her to know anything 8 9 DETECTIVE: //Well, you're an adult. You're an adult now. 10 11 Well I mean, if I... whatever, I don't know. Just, I'm sorry, go 12 ahead. 13 14 DETECTIVE: Um, when we're, when we're done with this interview, we'll 15 discuss this further and we'll decide what's the the best course. 16 17 Cause Jeffrey's gonna get me, you guys realize that right? He's 18 gonna find, he's gonna figure this out. And he's gonna, I'm not 19 safe now. You understand that, right? I'm not safe. 20 21 DETECTIVE: He, he is not this person that he's portraying himself to be. What 22 23 //UI [well he covers it up for good?]. 24 25 DETECTIVE 2: //Why, why do you say you're not safe? Has he said he's hurt 26 people before? 27 28 Well I've heard him make threats to people on the telephone, yeah, 29 of course. 30 31 DETECTIVE 2: //UI, you're gonna die, you're gonna break your legs, or 32 33 [giggles] All of the above. But that's not the point. 34 35 DETECTIVE 2: Who's he talking to? 36 37 I'm not on the other end, I don't know. I, I don't know, I heard 38 those conversations, I mean I've been in the room when he's been 39 on the phone with like Bill Clinton, like, I've witnessed lots of 40 things. I just wanna know specifically what y'all wanna know. 41 42 DETECTIVE: Everything. 43 44 I used to go there everyday, like I w — I don't, I don't know how 45 many other girls he was saying 'You're my favorite and I want you 46 to live with me' to, but I was in about as deep as you can get. So Defense Transcript 16 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2354 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 DETECTIVE: Urn, when you were completely naked, the same things happened, 2 you went in, you massaged him, 3 4 Sometimes I didn't even deal with that. Sometimes he just asked 5 me to take off my clothes and like, he would have to do work, and 6 he'd be sitting at his desk or something and I'd just be naked there 7 watching television or reading a book but I'd be naked. Or, um, 8 sometimes he wanted to just watch TV or read and he'd lay in his 9 bed and he'd ask me to just take my clothes off and lay with him. 10 And that's it, not touch him or anything and I'd get paid three 11 hundred dollars for that for twenty minutes. Urn, sometimes he'd 12 just invite me over for breakfast or dinner, or just to use the 13 swimming pool, and I'd get paid for that too. 14 15 DETECTIVE: Okay. 16 17 [sigh] I'd get paid just to hang out with him. That's it. And if, if 18 the money wasn't there, I'd not been there, I wouldn't have ever 19 been in that house. 20 21 DETECTIVE: Okay. Urn. When he started to touch you, urn. 22 23 I have a question. 24 25 DETECTIVE: Yeah. 26 27 Before I say anything else. Urn, is there a possibility that I'm 28 gonna have to go to court or anything? Like, that's a possibility, 29 right? 30 31 DETECTIVE: Well, here's the thing. When this is all said and done, we're gonna 32 sit down we're gonna discuss this. I mean, what he did to you is a 33 crime. I'm not going to lie to you. You are a victim. 34 35 //Will you consider rape? Like, will you consider that to be rape, 36 what he did? 37 38 DETECTIVE: When he put himself inside you, without permission, forcibly 39 40 //I didn't say yes or anything, he just, like I was standing up, and 41 the table is about like my hip length, he just pushed me down. 42 43 DETECTIVE: //That, that, that is a crime. 44 45 Okay. 46 Defense Transcript 15 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2355 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

He had quite a few girls he would say that to. I know, I thought so pretty much, you know. He had quite a few girls he would say that to. But, When did you, when was the last time you saw him? Urn before la — before the summer. May or June? When you gave the car back, or sometime before you graduated? //Probably, mhm. Wh, when did that incident //Or maybe a little after I graduated. I don't remember. When did that incident happen when he bent you over the table? I don't remember. Was it recent or was it like a year ago? It was probably in like, somewhere in the middle or, of the time that I worked there. It was definitely before December, if that's what you're trying to get at. Were you seventeen when you did that too? Oh, yeah, I was definitely. Definitely. Okay, we're gonna get to that in just a minute. Getting back to when you were naked, UI And you were providing the massages. And they were — and they were legitimate massages, by the way — I don't want to be in trouble for anything I didn't //No no no, I'm telling you, you are not a suspect in this in any way, shape or form. 1 2 DETECTIVE: 3 4 5 6 DETECTIVE: 7 8 DETECTIVE 2: 9 10 11 12 DETECTIVE 2: 13 14 15 16 17 DETECTIVE 2: 18 19 20 21 DETECTIVE 2: 22 23 24 25 DETECTIVE 2: 26 27 28 29 30 31 DETECTIVE: 32 33 34 35 DETECTIVE: 36 37 38 39 40 DETECTIVE: 41 42 43 44 45 DETECTIVE: 46 Defense Transcript 17 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2356 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 So, honestly, I don't trust cops, so, I just like, I have bad — I had a 3 bad experience, so I just want to be clear on that. 4 5 DETECTIVE: Okay, well I'm telling you right now that I didn't even bring 6 handcuffs with me up here. 7 8 No, all right, I, [giggles] I don't know. And I mentioned it to 9 somebody that I didn't say anything, but I mentioned that I had to 10 go talk to police about something that was personal to my 11 boyfriend, and. He just would flip out if he knew I was talking 12 about this specific stuff with anybody. But um, [giggles] he was 13 just like 'Make sure that you're not going to get investigated.' 14 15 DETECTIVE: I can assure you you're not. 16 17 //Nah. Okay. 18 19 DETECTIVE: Urn. When the massages UI — first of all, do you have any formal 20 massage training? 21 22 [giggles] Hell no. 23 24 DETECTIVE: Okay. All right, I was just just asking. Urn, when you were 25 providing the massages and things started to escalate, urn, when he 26 started to touch you, you said earlier. Was it with his hand or with 27 something else? 28 29 With his hand. Um, I remember, he would like, he would kiss me 30 and stuff too. I remember that. Um, and when he kissed me, like 31 if he was jerking off, he would, he would like rub himself, like on 32 my breasts. I, I had no feeling, I, not, I don't [sighs]. I don't know 33 how to make it sound 34 35 DETECTIVE: //You were uncomfortable. 36 37 Yeah, I was extremely uncomfortable and I would maneuver 38 myself away from that activity. Urn, I'd like, just I'd get up and 39 I'd move somewhere else, or I'd, I'd, I don't even remember. I 40 would stop whatever was going on without saying 'Can you get the 41 fuck off me?' I would, I would stop it without saying stuff like 42 that 43 44 DETECTIVE: Okay. 45 46 Just with my actions. Defense Transcript 18 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2357 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 DETECTIVE: So he would touch you with his hands, and did he touch you with 3 anything else? 4 5 I just told you, he touched me with his penis, like, 6 7 DETECTIVE: //I know, I mean, was there any toys, or 8 9 DETECTIVE 2: //UI 10 11 Oh, yeah. Yeah. 12 13 DETECTIVE: Okay. Can you describe? 14 15 [sighs] He used to have a back massage thing that it was like a ball 16 on the end and it vibrated, and he would use that. And then, for his 17 birthday, Nadia and I went shopping. And urn, we got a bunch of 18 toys, [laughs] which — I don't know how to tell you guys all this 19 stuff without you thinking that I enjoyed this. Like, cause I had a 20 choice whether or not to go shopping with her. I made this 21 decision. I'm the one who did this stuff. But it doesn't mean that I 22 felt right about it. Urn, but yeah. We, he used lots of toys on me, 23 like I don't know what specifically y'all want to know, like. He 24 25 DETECTIVE: //Okay 26 27 He, all the time. [sigh] Everything. Like, whatever 28 29 DETECTIVE: //Vibrators? 30 31 Whatever was there. If he wanted to use something else, he would 32 use whatever was there. Like, 33 34 DETECTIVE: Okay. What kind of vi — UI what color vibrators did he use? 35 36 Like white, and like — maybe it was like this color, but like blue, 37 like you see the gray, like the grayish, on the pipe. 38 39 DETECTIVE: Right. 40 41 The pipe. Like grey, with like a little bit more blue, like that. 42 43 DETECTIVE: Okay. 44 45 And it had a white, like end, it had like a white handle and it had a 46 ball on the end of it for giving back massages. Urn and then, there Defense Transcript 19 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2358 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 was, Nadia had a red one, and that didn't vibrate. Then, strap-ons 2 and stuff were also involved. [sigh] Everything. 3 4 DETECTIVE: //Okay. 5 6 Like, any toy you can think of he used on me. 7 8 DETECTIVE: Okay. 9 10 And, I'm not, definitely not by my choice, it was like, oh it's there 11 and it's happening now. I think. 12 13 DETECTIVE: Okay. Did you ever stop him, say hey listen, I'm not, I'm not good 14 with that? 15 16 Yeah, yeah, definitely. Before I let him urn, like before things 17 progressed where I would let him touch me, I would not let him do 18 anything to me, even with stuff that wasn't attached to his body. I 19 said no for a very long time until he upped it by like a hundred or 20 two hundred dollars, you know? 21 22 DETECTIVE: Okay. 23 24 [sighs] 25 26 DETECTIVE: When you're saying strap-on, did he use the strap-on? 27 28 No, but he probably would need to. Urn, sorry, I'm just trying to 29 make myself feel a little bit better. Urn, well I don't know if you 30 would count like him, he never actually put it on, but it was him 31 me and Nadia in the bedroom, and we were all in bed together, and 32 I was messing around with her, you know, and he was watching, 33 and 34 35 DETECTIVE: At his request? 36 37 Every time except one time was at his request. The time that it 38 was not his request was on his birthday. And instead of getting 39 paid three hundred dollars, I got paid like five, six hundred dollars. 40 Urn, it was a gift, I guess you could call it a gift from me and 41 Nadia. Um, we went shopping at this like sex place on 42 Okeechobee [ph], and um we bought a bunch of stuff and then we 43 just went at it in front of him. And, I don't know. It's not like I 44 was enjoying it either, like in my mind I'm like 'Oh god, when this 45 is over, you're getting so much money.' Like that's what I would 46 think of, I'd just close my eyes and think of something else. Defense Transcript 20 October I I, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2359 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 DETECTIVE: 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 [First tape ends.] 16 17 [Second tape begins.] 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 DETECTIVE: 35 36 37 38 DETECTIVE: 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 DETECTIVE: Okay. Let's get to the point where he's actually inserting his, his fingers inside you. Urn, at what point, from when he started just touching you to the point where he actually put his fingers inside of you? He did that once in the beginning, and at the time I was, urn, dating somebody, and that person was aware of what I did. Urn, and was like — this person, by the way, who said this stuff that I'm about to tell you is like now a crack-head, like on drugs, so they're way wack, they're like crazy. And he was actually my boyfriend, he goes 'Oh I have no problem with it, as long as he's not putting anything inside of you.' I wouldn't let him put anything in me until one day he did just out of nowhere. And I said wait a second my boyfriend, you know, we had this thing, you can't do that. You know, I'm, I'm allowed to work here as long as you don't do that. And he said ok. Well, a couple months later I guess he assumed me and my boyfriend had broken up, and he just did it one day, he just did it without asking or anything. And then I said what are you doing I said you know that's not cool and he goes 'Oh I thought we did that last time.' And I said no we did not do that last time. And, then he goes, uh and then he just offered me more money. He's like, 'Well why don't I just give you something extra and we can try this out.' And I was like [sigh] all right. Very hard guy to say no to. I don't know if any of you guys ever talked to him. Persistent. Yeah. I haven't spoke with him but he is persistent from what I can tell. //Oh, yeah. Well if you talk to him I mean he straight up tries to control the situation. Every, every word that comes out of your mouth it seems like he knows what you are going to say. Like, that's his job, that's how he made his money is knowing what people are gonna say and what people are gonna do. What did he tell you he does for a living? Defense Transcript 21 October I 1, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2360 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 Well, there's a couple things, things that I found by myself, things 3 that I've looked up on the intemet. Um, what he specifically told 4 me when I asked him the first time was 'Oh I'm a brain scientist' 5 and I said what the fuck is a brain scientist? I was like that's not a 6 real job you're like tell me the truth but anyway I took that as he, 7 he told me his explanation was 'It's my job to know how people's 8 brains work' and I said, whatever the fuck that means, whatever, 9 you know you're just some old guy, and I went home. And then I 10 looked up on the internet, urn, about him and he was apparently an 11 invest an he works for a financial firm and he would invest other 12 people's money, like people sign their fortunes over to him he 13 invests it and he gets commissions off of the money that they 14 make. Umm and then he just takes, I know that he himself besides 15 investing other people's fortunes you know he's invested all his 16 money he owns tons of companies, umm sponsors sports teams, 17 does stuff like that he makes his money everywhere. 18 19 DETECTIVE: Right. 20 21 And especially, he does a lot of modeling stuff with modeling 22 agencies, and I know that he is involved in stuff like that also. 23 24 DETECTIVE: Okay. 25 26 [giggle] You know what he promised me? I think the reason I held 27 on so long is he promised me that I would get into NYU. That I 28 would get into NYU and he would pay for it. And I waited and I 29 waited and I scored great on my SATs, I got 4.0, like I did great in 30 school. I filled out my application and he told me that it wasn't 31 good enough. And, so I filled it out again and it was like three 32 times so I'm pretty sure he wasn't checking into it he was just 33 telling me that he was. But I think that has a lot to do with the 34 reason I stayed there so long. Cause my dream was like right in 35 front of me, you know. It was so close. 36 37 DETECTIVE: Aside from having been with Na, uh, Nada or Nadia um was there 38 anybody else that you brought to the house? 39 40 I brought a few people. Urn, I brought She 41 approached me actually cause it, it got out that I did this, like 42 everyone at school knew. You know, everyone talks all 43 44 DETECTIVE: //Well, it was a circle and 45 Defense Transcript 22 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2361 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 It was a little circle and then yeah one girl told oh I got Alex to do 2 this and then you know. He, not that I would want anybody to get 3 involved in this but I brought girls I didn't like and really frankly 4 did not give a shit about. Girls that I knew were skanks that would 5 do anything. Who, like, girls that would just like suck dick in the 6 bathroom at school. Like not even people that I was friends with 7 I'd just hear a rumor about a girl and be like hey I know a way you 8 can make two hundred dollars. But I would tell them before they 9 went I would tell them flat out like this is what you gotta do, are 10 you cool with this cause I am not going to take you if you're not. 11 And I told them, they all knew that I got paid to bring them. And 12 I, it was Mandy Biorklin. Mandy never did anything 13 though, she took off her shirt — she was a little overweight so he 14 didn't want anything to do with [laughs], she was my best friend so 15 I you know she was another story, I did care about her but urn she 16 lost her house and stuff and really needed money. She had, she 17 was homeless she had nowhere to go. So she did it out of 18 desperation. But um I, the only people I can think of w 19 and Mandy. I might have asked other people but I don't think I 20 ever actually brought other people. 21 22 DETECTIVE: Okay. Did anything ever happen between you and the two girls 23 that you brought there? 24 25 Mandy, she was really nervous so she wanted me to go in with her. 26 And I stayed with her, urn, I took all my clothes off and I did my 27 regular thing, and she just took her shirt off. And then he said 28 'Okay well is gonna finish up here, do you want to go wait by 29 the pool' and she went downstairs and went swimming and I was 30 still naked. 31 32 DETECTIVE: Okay. 33 34 And that was that. 35 36 DETECTIVE: Okay. 37 38 She got paid I think three, two or three hundred dollars for that, 39 probably two because it was her first time. The way it went was if 40 you worked there for the first like three times, you got paid two 41 hundred dollars. After that, if you were persistent and worked all 42 the time it was the on average three hundred dollars. Sometimes I 43 got paid a thousand. Just for the same thing. No varying in 44 activities, just sometimes I'd walk out of there with a thousand 45 dollars or I mean I got lots of gifts, like I got lots of stuff from this 46 guy. I don't know. Defense Transcript 23 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2362 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 DETECTIVE: Okay, what about 3 4 she just went up in the room and did her thing and she 5 continued to work for him afterwards. I don't know, I don't think 6 she still does, urn, she may, may not. I don't know. 7 8 DETECTIVE: Okay. Okay. Urn, you went quite a few times with the Neon. 9 And, you actually had an encounter with one of his doormen, when 10 you were coming to get an envelope. 11 12 //That was in my Riata, actually, I drove a little Riata. Um, I was 13 coming to get an envelope with two thousand dollars in it, my 14 Christmas bonus. Umm, oh my god it and the cop actually was 15 like how do you know Jeffrey and I was like all I I'm friends with 16 his girlfriend I use his pool every once in a while, or something, 17 but that was crazy. Yeah he the housekeeper just was expecting 18 me, but he didn't know, he was gone when I arrived and he came 19 home and saw that there was a car and he didn't realize that it was 20 my car. But he was expecting me urn so he called the police and I 21 was like what the fuck man I'm just coming here to pick up 22 money. [giggles] But that was that. 23 24 DETECTIVE: Okay. Let's get to the part where, urn, things escalated. Urn, I 25 have to see something. 26 27 UI 28 29 DETECTIVE: Yeah, let me go ahead and stop this tape and start another one 30 because it's almost at the end. 31 32 [to friend] You don't have anything important to go do, do you? 33 Okay. 34 35 DETECTIVE: Okay, at this point I'm gonna go ahead and stop the tape. The time 36 by my watch is approximately 5:02 p.m. [pause] Uh, 5:02, 5:03 37 p.m. Um, we're just about to get started with the, as it escalated. 38 Urn, tell me how it, how it happened. 39 40 He would just try things on occasion and if I let him do it then he 41 would at the end put in more money without even like, it was kind 42 of an unspoken thing, if it happened and I let it happen I'd get paid 43 more. If it didn't happen then obviously it was the same. But urn, 44 on a few occasions I told you, that I did say no. Um, and I let it be 45 UI and I'd say stop on my word, and he still gave me extra money 46 on that one. But then the couple of times that I said no he talked Defense Transcript 24 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2363 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 me into it and then gave me more money. He always paid me 2 more money, even if I never, even if I didn't do what he asked me 3 to do extra. 4 5 DETECTIVE: Okay. So walk me through this, and and I know this is gonna be 6 hard for you. Uh, walk me through this here. You're giving him a 7 massage, you're naked. Right? 8 9 Uh huh. 10 11 DETECTIVE: Take it from there. 12 13 He'd ask me to like, most of the time, I'd rub his lower back UI 14 15 [Cell phone interference; voices inaudible for about forty seconds.] 16 17 ...like, he didn't have to say any instructions. When I first started 18 going, I, he'd ask me to get naked, he'd ask what he could do, I 19 mean, urn, and that was like that. Towards the end, like, I just got 20 naked and, 21 22 DETECTIVE: Would he, would he perform oral, oral sex on you? 23 24 //Sometimes, sometimes. 25 26 DETECTIVE: Okay. Did you ever perform anything on him? 27 28 I've never touched him inten — intentionally. I've never laid a 29 hand on him, not a body part, nothing, not a hair on my head. I 30 never touched him. 31 32 DETECTIVE: Okay. When he did oral on you, were you still sixteen? Was this 33 towards the beginning? 34 35 Yeah, it wasn't like, at the, at the end, like all this stuff was in the 36 beginning. Like, once we broke the barriers of me like letting him 37 do stuff, all the major stuff took, took place in the beginning. Urn, 38 I never, that was only like four, five times and none of it was since 39 my birthday, since this last birthday none of it was after that. 40 41 DETECTIVE: Okay. Did he ever hurt you? 42 43 Sometimes he got violent, yeah. 44 45 DETECTIVE: Violent as in what? As in? 46 Defense Transcript 25 October II, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2364 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 He pulled my hair a lot harder than it should have been pulled, like 2 he, okay I can understand having sex, and you're all like, not, not 3 that we were having sex but I mean like if you're all into it and you 4 pull hair a little bit, like my ponytails just like a little bit, whatever. 5 But he would pull it to where it would rip my hair out. It would rip 6 my hair, and then sometimes he would pick me up and like throw 7 me whichever way he wanted me, and then he would just like use a 8 toy or like his hand or whatever. Never his penis though, ever, I 9 never had sex with him. But urn 10 11 DETECTIVE: But you're a little girl, I mean, so, 12 13 I'm little, so he could pick me up, like, if you pick me up and 14 throw me, obviously it's gonna hurt. If I get hurt, um 15 16 DETECTIVE: Did you ever tell him that hurts you? 17 18 No. 19 20 DETECTIVE: No? 21 22 No. I wasn't 23 24 DETECTIVE: //When he was doing these things for you, kissing, touching, 25 inserting his fingers, oral, did he ever hurt you down there? In 26 your vagina area? 27 28 Urn, I don't know, I'm sure he was a little rough on occasions, but 29 none specifically, nothing that really stands out. I mean, there's 30 been nights that I walked out of there barely being able to walk, 31 urn, from him being so rough but nothing really, nothing specific 32 that he really got violent with. Like, I can't really recall. 33 34 DETECTIVE: //Nothing that you'd have had to 35 36 Nothing that I would be like oh my god, this one time he did this, 37 like nothing like that. 38 39 DETECTIVE: Okay. Nothing that you'd have had to go to the doctor for, the 40 day, you know. 41 42 Nothing that I went to the doctor for, no. I mean, I remember 43 getting tore up a few times but it was nothing that 44 45 DETECTIVE: By tore up you mean? 46 Defense Transcript 26 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2365 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 Hurt, like I, he would get really rough and I'd get cut 2 3 DETECTIVE: //Making it sore 4 5 Like I'd get cut, like ripped a little bit, if that's what you're talking 6 about. 7 8 DETECTIVE: Okay. You don't have to answer this, 9 10 //Okay 11 12 DETECTIVE: This is getting real personal, but were you active before him? 13 14 What, like, had I had sex? Yeah [laughs]. 15 16 DETECTIVE: Okay. 17 18 Urn. But honest — I mean I'm not, I'm not a ho, I've had only 19 three steady boyfriends and those are the only three that I've ever 20 done anything with. And they were all with me for over a year. 21 So it's not like I just go and hook up at parties. 22 23 DETECTIVE: Okay. 24 25 //This was the most crazy, promiscuous, whatever you want to call 26 it thing that I have ever done. And it was money. Money. It was, 27 it was the money and the gifts and that's it. 28 29 DETECTIVE: What was the most you ever made from him? 30 31 Like, 32 33 DETECTIVE: Monetary wise. You mentioned you walked out with a, with a G, 34 or a thousand dollars one time. 35 36 I walked out with like, yeah a thousand dollars one time but then 37 again I walked out with a car one time. Are you talking things of 38 like, that, like are you talking about 39 40 DETECTIVE: //Okay, what was 41 42 Gift-wise or specifically cash? 43 44 DETECTIVE: //Both, let's do both 45 Defense Transcript 27 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2366 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 Like, I've gotten thousands of dollars worth of shit. Man, the 2 underwear I'm wearing right now, he gave me, like I'd, I'd go over 3 there and there'd be a bag of Victoria's Secret underwear like 4 waiting for me like, talking like fifteen hundred dollars worth of 5 stuff I got a plane ticket from him once, I got a car, I got 6 Christmas bonuses, I got movie tickets, like he'd buy me movie 7 tickets, like he'd say 'Hey, have you gone to the movies lately?' 8 I'd be like I dunno, no, not really, he goes 'Do you want to go?' 9 He'd give me like eight movie tickets. I got show tickets, I went 10 and saw like David Copperfield I had like VIP like tickets or 11 something like that. Um. 12 13 DETECTIVE 2: The car, was that under your name or was it under his name? 14 15 No, it was under his, like I didn't really care though, he'd let me 16 drive it around as much as I wanted. You know, I, I just got the 17 keys to it. And everything else was his business. He said if I ever 18 got pulled over, just to say that it was his car and whatever, that's 19 it. 20 21 DETECTIVE: Okay. Let's talk about the, urn, the time that he forced himself on 22 you. Urn, take me through that one. 23 24 We were really, I think it, it was the — Nadia was in the room. And 25 UM. 26 27 DETECTIVE: Was she naked? 28 29 I don't know, probably. Like it was, I don't remember if UI. I 30 don't remember at the time, whether or not she was — it was 31 towards the end of my session or whatever you want to call it, so 32 she was probably either getting dressed or was still naked, I don't 33 really know. She was, I think she was still naked though. Urn 34 35 DETECTIVE: Was it normal for her by this time to be upstairs with you? 36 37 If I went there, if I saw her up there I would not be surprised. I 38 wouldn't get surprised when I saw her in the room. Urn, 39 sometimes she would just, like, she liked me. Like, she would 40 hang out with me and we, like I would go to the house and we'd 41 eat breakfast together. Or like hang out by the pool or something, 42 it's not like I just went there and did my thing with her in front of 43 him. I don't know. But um. Sorry, go ahead. 44 45 DETECTIVE: Okay. So, you went upstairs and Nada was getting dressed. 46 Defense Transcript 28 October I I, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2367 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 Oh yeah. 2 3 DETECTIVE: //You were there? 4 5 Nadia was — no, we, I was, this was at the end of like what, okay it 6 was me him and Nadia and I'm pretty sure that me and Nadia, like 7 she was like sucking his dick and like fucking him and stuff. But 8 like, that was all I was like maybe kissing her, you know touching 9 her some which way or the other. And um, towards the end of this 10 I remember that I had already finished, cause I remember it being 11 really uncomfortable. So I remember specifically that I had 12 already finished. She, it was me, him 13 14 DETECTIVE: //What do you mean by you finished with? 15 16 He gave me an orgasm. With his hand. 17 18 DETECTIVE: //Right. Okay. 19 20 Urn, UI I need to show you, like what I'm talking about, like the 21 positioning that we were. It was like, okay, here's the thing, 22 there's the like little flower thing, then here's the massage table. I 23 was right here, he was right here, she was here. Urn. And, I was 24 standing up, and he just pushed me over the table, and he did his 25 thing with me. 26 27 DETECTIVE: Okay. Were you facing the table? Were you? 28 29 I was, I was face down on the table. Like face down, hands like on 30 my head, holding, I don't, I don't I mean I wasn't fighting really. 31 So I don't know if he was holding me down to kinda stop me from 32 fighting, or what he was doing. He's just a really weird, he's into 33 really weird stuff. Like, I was just bent over and my face was on 34 the table I was face down on the table. And then he did his thing. 35 So. But anyway, Nadia was right here and I'm pretty sure she was 36 naked and the couch is like right behind, but urn that's how it 37 happened. 38 39 DETECTIVE: How long was he, how long did that take? 40 41 He was only in me for like a minute or two, I don't even know if 42 you could say that long. He put it in, did a couple of pumps or 43 whatever the fuck you wanna call it, and I was like 'What are you 44 doing?' [giggles] I go 'What are you doing?' He's like, 'Oh, I just 45 wanted Nadia to see this.' Then that was that. 46 Defense Transcript 29 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2368 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 DETECTIVE: Did he ejaculate inside? 2 3 No. Not in me, not on me. I don't remember any time. I don't 4 remember specifically that time, um whether or not he finished 5 from having sex with me or whatever you wanna call it. 6 7 DETECTIVE: Okay. How much did you call — that was in the middle of the two 8 year thing? 9 10 Not so much towards the end, but definitely once I was 11 comfortable with working there once I like would go there a lot, 12 yeah. That was, it had to be towards the middle cause towards the 13 end I only worked very sporadically throughout like maybe once or 14 twice a month, not even. Urn, in the middle I was working the 15 most, I'd work every day that he was in the country. Every single 16 day. 17 18 DETECTIVE: Okay. From that moment on, that's when the car came in? After 19 that the car came? 20 21 I told him that my parents kicked me out, urn, well, oh. Okay, this 22 is how it went. Like I'm sorry, I'm remembering more and more 23 as I talk to you. I worked for him and then I, I think after like 24 things started getting like too like in like once he started going 25 further and further, urn I stopped working for him for a little while. 26 Like, Sarah left a message on my cell phone. My mom took my 27 cell phone away and she checked my messages and Sarah goes 28 'Oh, Jeffrey wants to know if you can come by and bring a friend.' 29 And my morn goes 'What the fuck are you doing? Like, are you a 30 prostitute?' And I was like, `No mom, I'm just a secretary, and 31 you know what, he has a girlfriend, Nadia urn doesn't have any 32 friends,' I'm like 'she wanted me to bring over people to hang out, 33 you know.' And my mom was like, okay, I don't know. She was 34 in denial, obviously, she, I think she knows that deep down in her 35 heart. But urn, after my morn heard that message she made me 36 phone him, she made me call Sarah, urn, and tell her right in front 37 of my— my mom made me tell Sarah right in front of her that I 38 couldn't work there anymore, that I couldn't go there anymore. 39 And then a few months went by at, no like, well I guess you could 40 say like a month or two, I don't want to say a couple, like a few 41 months cause it wasn't that long. But it was like a month or two, 42 and then I called him and urn, I told him that I, my parents kicked 43 me out and so they weren't, they weren't gonna interfere with 44 anything and then I continued to work. Towards the end, I stopped 45 working for about probably six weeks, um, cause my boyfriend 46 Will, the kid that I'm still with now. Urn, he, it like tore him up to Defense Transcript 30 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2369 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 know that I did this with somebody. Cause he, he cares a lot about 2 me and stuff, and I stopped working but then I lied to, I lied to Will 3 a couple times and I worked, but then Will found out. And that's 4 when, like he, he broke up with me, and then that once he broke up 5 with me that was what I needed to really snap me into reality and 6 quit. But there was like a few, like a, like I'd say a three month, 7 like three and a half months like during that time, 8 9 DETECTIVE: This year? 10 11 Well this year was only like, maybe six weeks that I didn't work, 12 but since the New Year, since the beginning of this New Year, 13 from January to like April, in between then was probably six 14 weeks where I didn't work. Urn, and then I don't remember when 15 my other hiatus was, like I don't really remember but that was 16 towards like the beginning. 17 18 DETECTIVE: What, what did you do with all the money that you made? 19 20 Do I have to tell you? Cause I don't think it's any of your business 21 [laughs]. 22 23 DETECTIVE: Okay, you don't have to. 24 25 I'm sorry. I'm not like involved in drugs or anything like that, but, 26 I really just don't wanna tell you. 27 28 DETECTIVE: That's fine. 29 30 Cause I don't have anything to show for any of it. I spent it all. I 31 spent it all. 32 33 DETECTIVE 2: Okay, okay. I get paid, I spend my money too. 34 35 //[laughs] 36 37 DETECTIVE 2: So I mean it happens, right? 38 39 Yeah. As a matter of fact, I just told you on, on the New Year I 40 was in New York on his dime. So, yeah. 41 42 DETECTIVE: Were you there on his plane? 43 44 No, not on his plane. He was using his plane, I think he had to do 45 something. He has, owns an island in the Caribbean, you guys all 46 know that, I'm sure. But um, I think he was flying to his island Defense Transcript 31 October II, 2005 PBPD d . 07/26/17 Page 2370 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 and he had some work to do. He was going to originally, urn, fly 2 me in his jet, but something happened with work and it just worked 3 out better, so he paid for my ticket and then, because he was, he 4 was supposed to be in New York when I went there, I was 5 supposed to stay at his home but like I said he had to use his plane 6 to go somewhere else unexpectedly. So I stayed with urn, my 7 boyfriend's family while I was up there. But while I was up there 8 he bought me like, four hundred dollar front row seats to Phantom 9 of the Opera. Like he, he set it up real nice. He gave me spending 10 money, paid for my plane ticket, he paid for everything. 11 Everything. 12 13 DETECTIVE: Okay. Have you ever been on his plane? 14 15 No, I've seen it though, I've been to the airport and I've seen it. It 16 has a JE, Julia Echo — urn sorry, that's like, I just remember that's 17 what he told me it meant. It's a black plane, there's a black one 18 and then there's like, I forget what the other one was like. I saw 19 that one, the other one from afar. He has a black plane and then 20 another plane. 21 22 DETECTIVE: Okay. Has he tried to contact you recently, or 23 24 Yeah, I could call him today and be like I need — like 25 26 DETECTIVE: //No, but I'm talking about recently like within the past couple of 27 weeks. Like from the beginning of — 28 29 //Yeah, yeah. Definitely. Urn, but only, only through email and 30 my responses have been — I haven't responded, um, recently since 31 I was contacted before but urn the last two contacts I had with him 32 was before I moved here, urn, which I moved here on August 33 Sometime before I moved here I told him or I wrote in an email 34 that somebody mysteriously — do you need to stop? 35 36 DETECTIVE: No. 37 38 I told him that somebody mysteriously called my house and told 39 my parents, excuse me and told my parents urn, what I did with 40 him, and I just was like, I made it seem like somebody called and 41 ratted me out to my mom and dad. And I was like I can't, you 42 know, work for you as of right now, urn, blah blah blah. But at 43 that point, I mean, I don't, I didn't want to work for him, I just 44 didn't want to burn my bridge, if you catch my drift. Urn, so I just 45 told him that I got ratted out, and then he answered, or actually it's Defense Transcript 32 October II, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2371 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 his assistant answered, but it's really, it's him, if you're talking to say, to his assistant //Sarah, you're talking about Sarah. //you're talking to him. Yeah, I'm talking about Sarah specifically. Sarah and Nada are not the same people. No, Nadia is urn some other chick, she's like his girlfriend or whatever you want to call it, and then is one of his girlfriends also, I, I know her and then Sarah. And Sarah she's like his main assistant, like his official assistant who really does his assistant work. Who travels with him. Who travels with him and stuff like that. He has other girls that he calls assistants but they just screw him. That's it. Urn. I don't know. I'm, I'm sorry, I like go off on a tangent and I completely forget what the original thing was. Urn. We were talking about if you ever flew in the plane, or have you recently talked to //UI Oh, I'm sorry I was talking about the emails, I hate when I do that, I apologize. No, that's all right. Um, uh, he answered me with 'That's really unfortunate, blah blah blah, well if you need any help with school, any costs, tuition, books, anything like that, just let me know.' Urn, so I wrote back and I just asked, urn, I said [cell phone interference] and UI, you know, from him wrote accounting negotiation and basic law, like I remember that [laughs], he wrote those and um. He again reminded me that if I wanted anything, any like if I needed any financial help or anything like that, that he would set it up, he would help me out. No problem. And I haven't, I haven't contacted either of them since. And that was probably four or six weeks ago, I don't really remember specifically, it was after I moved here. But not after I talked to the other //You haven't had any phone conversations with him, 2 3 4 DETECTIVE: 5 6 7 8 DETECTIVE: 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 DETECTIVE: 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 DETECTIVE: 24 25 26 DETECTIVE 2: 27 28 29 30 31 DETECTIVE: 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 DETECTIVE: Defense Transcript 33 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2372 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 //Uh-uh [no] 3 4 DETECTIVE: I mean do you still have the same cell phone number, is that how 5 6 I deleted all his numbers a long time ago. 7 8 DETECTIVE: No but I mean do you still have the same number? 9 10 //Oh, yeah. Yeah, I still have the same number. Like if she wanted 11 to call me, she could call me. Um. I forgot that urn 12 still works for him. She's in really deep and like, I really like, I'm 13 not telling you guys what to do but if you could contact her, scare 14 the shit out of her to stop talking to him, or something, something. 15 16 DETECTIVE 2: Why is she in deep, what do you mean? 17 18 She like, she has sex with him! Like that's not what, that's not 19 what it was supposed to be. It was supposed to be giving a 20 massage naked, not, not having sex with him that much, like that's 21 something else. 22 23 DETECTIVE: //How old was, how was she when she started? 24 25 Oh, after she was eighteen. 26 27 DETECTIVE: Okay, so she's 28 29 //Yeah. She's, like a year older than me, and she started recently 30 within the past like, after the New Year, I don't remember. 31 32 DETECTIVE: Are there drugs ever involved? 33 34 No, he's very, he's very urn, 35 36 DETECTIVE: Healthy? 37 38 Very healthy, very fit, he jogs every day on the beach, he does, 39 does yoga and all that stuff, he has a gym in his house, urn. Never 40 has drank, he's never urn taken a drink of alcohol, ever, not once in 41 his life. At least that's what he says, I don't really know. And he's 42 never tried any drugs, never smoked a cigarette, never nothing. 43 44 DETECTIVE 2: How about pornography, any in his house? 45 46 What do you, what type of pornography? Defense Transcript 34 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2373 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 DETECTIVE 2: Any type. 3 4 Any type. 5 6 DETECTIVE 2: Specifically children, young women, teenage girls 7 8 //I don't know if you can — oh, teenage, he's got lots of naked 9 pictures of teenage girls, like but real photographs that he took not 10 11 DETECTIVE 2: //Like [stutters] you said there was one of you, naked? 12 13 //He has pictures of me, that was 14 15 DETECTIVE 2: //And you were sixteen. 16 17 Yeah like, how else can I explain it, I was naked, I had no clothes 18 on. 19 20 DETECTIVE 2: And he would just say 'Let me take a picture of you?' 21 22 He goes, I don't really, I don't even know what he said. I don't 23 want to say something because it might be wrong, but urn. He just, 24 I guess asked me to take pictures and that's how it went. And I 25 said okay. 26 27 DETECTIVE 2: //Was it just like, just like a UI or were you doing stuff? Poses and 28 stuff? 29 30 I was just like, it was me standing in front of a big white marble 31 bathtub in the, in his, in the, he has his own bathroom and then the 32 girls that sleep over he has a second bathroom for guests or 33 whatever the hell you wanna call them, 34 35 DETECTIVE 2: //Ah 36 37 Urn and it was in the guest bathroom in his master suite. And it, it 38 wasn't like I was you know spreading my legs or anything for the 39 camera, I was like, I was standing up. I think I was standing up 40 and I just like, it was me kind of like looking over my shoulder 41 kinda smiling, and that was that. 42 43 DETECTIVE 2: And now he has that up on his wall or something? 44 45 No, he's got others. Excuse me. [yawning] 46 Defense Transcript 35 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2374 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 1 DETECTIVE 2: Uh huh. DETECTIVE: Putting her to sleep now. DETECTIVE 2: Sorry. //He has other - No, it looks like I'm putting Shayna asleep. Um, he urn, if you go in his bathroom, I mean I don't know like how — he has naked photos of other teenage girls like around his house. One thing that really bothered me though, he has a picture of his g- d-daughter like, with no like panties on, and it always grossed me out. Like it's a picture of her, like she's mooning him and I don't know if you can, I wouldn't put a picture like that in my house, honestly. Like that, that causes a little — it raises a few questions, like it can, it's questionable if it can be considered pornography. Child pornography. But I wouldn't put a picture of a little girl with her skirt pulled up on my wall. Like no. DETECTIVE: Do you know if he ever videotaped any of these, urn No, not with me there. I was just thinking, I don't remember anything with that. If he has a videotape of me, I'm, I'm, I don't know, he might. He might have videotapes, he's got photographs. He could ruin my life if he wanted to. DETECTIVE: But not that you are aware of. Not that I'm aware of, no. [Second tape ends.] [Third tape begins. Begins by repeating final seconds of second tape.] ...grossed me out. Like it's a picture of her, like she's mooning him and I don't know if you can, I wouldn't put a picture like that in my house, honestly. Like that, that causes a little — it raises a few questions, like it can, it's questionable if it can be considered pornography. Child pornography. But I wouldn't put a picture of a little girl with her skirt pulled up on my wall. Like no. DETECTIVE: Do you know if he ever videotaped any of these, urn No, not with me there. I was just thinking, I don't remember anything with that. If he has a videotape of me, I'm, I'm, I don't know, he might. He might have videotapes, he's got photographs. He could ruin my life if he wanted to. Defense Transcript 36 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2375 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 DETECTIVE: But not that you are aware of. 3 4 Not that I'm aware of, no. No videotape. 5 6 DETECTIVE: Is it 7 8 0-N 9 10 DETECTIVE: 0-N 11 12 You want her phone number? 13 14 DETECTIVE: If you have it. 15 16 Yeah I gotta, I, I know it actually, oh wait no I don't, I want to 17 make sure it's the right one. I really like I really care about her and 18 I didn't even take her to this I mentioned it and she goes oh yeah I 19 already heard from it about it from somebody else. Like I was, 20 wasn't mentioning it like do you want to do it. I was mentioning it 21 like oh I have to go, she was my friend she knew what I did, I was 22 like oh I've got to go to Jeffrey's today, she knew what that meant, 23 and she goes oh would you mind if I went there? And, I was like 24 whatever, how did, like why do you want to do it? She was like oh 25 I was talking to somebody I figured I'd do it. Her number is 561- 26 ean 27 28 DETECTIVE 2: So if there's a picture of you in the house, it's of when you were 29 sixteen? 30 31 Or seventeen. 32 33 DETECTIVE 2: //Or seventeen, but not eighteen, okay. 34 35 //Or seventeen, definitely not, no not, there wasn't much activity 36 between us since I turned eighteen. 37 38 DETECTIVE 2: //Okay 39 40 I mean I remember just about everything like I remember down to 41 the like the letter what happened since the New Year, like nothing 42 major, nothing like heavy happened. 43 44 DETECTIVE: And, what you mean by heavy you mean 45 Defense Transcript 37 October II, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2376 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 Well, I mean like he laid off with like going down on me and stuff like that, like when I went there UI dinner [cell phone rings] Hey dad, daddy I'm still at work, I gotta call you when I get home, ok, all right, ok, bye bye. Urn, okay where was I? After the New Years //Oh yea, after the New Year, //He wouldn't go down on you anymore //After the New Year, not that he wouldn't but like he just didn't, like I didn't get like nothing significant happened with us. He didn't UI it was just like it was back in the beginning, like really mild. Did he know you turned eighteen at that point? He was jumping for joy. When you turned eighteen. So there was no doubt in your mind he knew how old you were when you were originally UI //He bought my — oh a hundred percent! My Christmas no not my Christmas gift my birthday gift for being eighteen was a plane ticket to New York City. Like I left at 4:30 in the morning on my eighteenth birthday to go to New York to to be with him. And, I mean he didn't tell me he, I didn't know. He had a chauffeur pick me up from the airport urn in a bullet proof black Mercedes, I remember that specifically. I've got pictures of that too if y'all want some pictures [giggles] but um, uh, whatchamacallit. Yeah I didn't know that he wasn't going to be there until after the chauffeur picked me up and said Jeffrey's on the phone for you and he handed me a phone. And then I spoke to Jeffrey, Jeffrey's like I'm not gonna be able to be there but I set all this stuff up for you, you're going to have a great time. Like you know then I just that was that, I got someone to stay with and urn //Was he ever into the S&M type of thing? I don't even know what that is. Are you talking about whips and chains and stuff? Right, the tying up, the 2 3 4 5 6 DETECTIVE: 7 8 9 10 DETECTIVE: 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 DETECTIVE 2: 18 19 20 21 DETECTIVE 2: 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 DETECTIVE: 40 41 42 43 44 DETECTIVE: 45 Defense Transcript 38 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2377 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 I don't know what you'd call a strap-on like what you'd call that? 2 Urn he never like 3 4 DETECTIVE 2: All these toys you're mentioning, did he, he penetrated you with 5 these? 6 7 Nadia specifically with the strap-on 8 9 DETECTIVE 2 : But these other toys 10 11 He himself penetrated me with these items 12 13 DETECTIVE 2: And you, were, then again before you were eighteen? 14 15 //I swear to that, yes. 16 17 DETECTIVE 2: And Nadia's done the same with the strap-on, she penetrated you? 18 19 Yeah she's done that with other stuff too. She's gone down on me 20 like he's asked me to go down on her and when I say no he flashes 21 two hundred dollars in front of me — says do it for five minutes and 22 you get this and I said I'll do it for five minutes. It's 23 what I did for money. [giggles] Ugh 24 25 DETECTIVE 2: But that was, you once again you were way before you were 26 eighteen, when Nadia was doing this to you 27 28 Yeah, yeah 29 30 DETECTIVE: How many times would you say that that happened? 31 32 With Nadia? 33 34 DETECTIVE: Nadia and him? 35 36 Nadia and him? It could be like as little as like 5 times or as much 37 as like [interference] 8 or 9, I don't know. It's, it's UI [cell phone 38 ringing] hello, hey honey are you off of work? Urn I'm talking to 39 some people right now. Urn yeah so I I don't know. Do you know 40 do you think we're gonna be here for like another hour or 41 whatever? No what are we gonna be done pretty soon? Ok well 42 they, he says we're gonna be done pretty soon so urn, would you 43 just wait at home for me cause I'm, I'm not having a great day. Ok 44 I love you. Bye 45 46 DETECTIVE: That's your boyfriend? Defense Transcript 39 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2378 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 Uh Huh 3 4 DETECTIVE 2: I thought you said he didn't know that you mentioned, you didn't 5 tell him that you were talking to us? 6 7 I told, I didn't tell him that you guys were investigating urn Jeffrey 8 and stuff. God no. I said I had to talk to some people about a few 9 things like and that was that. 10 1I DETECTIVE 2: //Okay okay, no problem. 12 13 DETECTIVE: Okay, well 14 15 DETECTIVE 2: You said you have photographs, what kind of, just of the New 16 York trip? Do you have any photographs from inside the house or 17 anything like that? 18 19 Urn, I'm trying to think, hold on 20 21 DETECTIVE 2: //Yeah, no problem 22 23 Urn 24 25 DETECTIVE 2: So those are different, Susan's different from Nada. 26 27 Uhh I don't, I don't think I have any photographs. I mean I, I 28 think, I mean I might I could look at my house, um but I kinda 29 figured he didn't want me taking photographs in his house either. 30 So I really don't think I did that. I got, I mean I just got pictures of 31 like his car, and um like his chauffeur, and stuff, like that's it. 32 33 DETECTIVE 2: Besides Nada and Jeff was there anyone else that you 34 35 //Were involved with 36 37 DETECTIVE: //Interacted with in the house? Adrianna? 38 39 //Um, I mean I talked to Adrianna but that's about the extent of 40 that. 41 42 DETECTIVE 2: //Never, okay. 43 44 //Yeah it was just Nadia. 45 46 DETECTIVE 2: You didn't have anyone else Defense Transcript 40 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2379 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 Mmmm, it was just Nadia and now who is Susan? She's her name 3 is Susan? 4 5 DETECTIVE: //No. 6 7 //Oh, I'm sorry. 8 9 DETECTIVE 2: //We're not sure we think it's the same person. 10 11 DETECTIVE: No, it's totally different. 12 13 DETECTIVE 2: Is it? 14 15 What's Sus? I mean like if you tell me a last name I can probably 16 tell you who she is 17 18 DETECTIVE: Um all right. Come on [talking to self] 19 20 I'm sorry [talking to friend] 21 22 FRIEND: It's all right. 23 24 DETECTIVE: I'm gonna have to look for it for just one second here, just bear 25 with me. 26 27 Okay. 28 29 DETECTIVE: Who would you say that is? [showing a photograph] 30 31 That's Adrianna. 32 33 DETECTIVE: That's Adrianna right? 34 35 Uh huh [giggle] Her name's Susan? 36 37 DETECTIVE: No, no 38 39 All right 40 41 DETECTIVE: Nah, her name's Adrianna. 42 43 Okay. 44 45 ; FRIEND: Is that the girl that was sold? 46 Defense Transcript 41 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2380 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 3 4 5 DETECTIVE: 6 7 8 9 DETECTIVE: 10 11 DETECTIVE 2: 12 13 DETECTIVE: 14 15 DETECTIVE 2: 16 17 DETECTIVE: 18 19 DETECTIVE 2: 20 21 22 23 24 DETECTIVE 2: 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 DETECTIVE 2: 32 33 34 35 DETECTIVE: 36 37 38 39 40 41 DETECTIVE 2: 42 43 44 45 DETECTIVE 2: 46 Defense Transcript No I was under the impression that that was Nadia. She told me that she came from Yugoslavia when she was like fifteen with Jeffrey. So like I don't understand what the hell is going on You know that girl? [showing picture] I don't, no. I don't know, she looks like every other girl. Well, I don't have anything further do you? Did you show her the picture of the one girl or no? I did But that's not the same person she's saying No, that's not the same person. And the last time you spoke to him on the phone, was what six weeks ago? Or longer than that Probably even longer. //Did they leave you any messages recently? No one ever contacted you or anything? No, um I think I even deleted the emails, if my boyfriend found those emails he'd shoot me, I'd get kicked out of the house. Like, so I, I'm pretty sure they're gone, I deleted them. You remember his uh screen name? Uh, its Sarah's it's [email protected] J Oh wait, oh is it, I don't know I think it's one of its one of these two, JKellens, K-E-L-L-E-N-S @earthlink.net, I think Earthlink is. Um but it the other one is just k el I CIIS'a, ea ri 111 ink .1 let And that's Sarah? Or his and whatever, yeah. Who's Kellen? Who's, what is that? 42 October 11, 2005 PBPD 07/26/17 Page 2381 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 //I don't know who Kellen is, I have no idea, I didn't bother to ask, it was none of my business. Maybe that's her last name. Oh. Well I don't have anything further, um would you like to add anything else to the statement? No. What do you want to see happening to Jeffrey? I don't think anything is going to happen to him. No that's not what I asked you. What do you think should happen to Jeffrey for what he did to you? He, I don't even care if he goes to jail, I just don't want this to happen to anybody else. Whatever that means to you guys. And that's what we're trying to stop here. Yeah, that, it means a lot. Okay, I'm gonna go ahead and conclude the statement. The time by my watch is 5:40 p.m. 2 3 4 FRIEND: 5 6 DETECTIVE: 7 8 9 10 11 DETECTIVE 2: 12 13 14 15 DETECTIVE 2: 16 17 18 19 20 21 DETECTIVE: 22 23 DETECTIVE 2: 24 25 DETECTIVE: 26 Defense Transcript 43 October 11, 2005 PBPD & 07/26/17 Page 2382 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

L THE STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF PALM BEACH. IN RE: PALM BEACH INVESTIGATION. SWORN STATEMENT OF JUAN P. ALESSI Monday, November 21, 2005 12:25 p.m. - 1:05 p.m. 401 N. Dixie Highway West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 Reported By: Susan Shelling, RPR Notary Public, State of Florida Consor & Associates Reporting and Transcription Phone - 561.835.'9738 J. CONSOR & ASSOCIATES REPORTING & TRANSCRIPTION 561.835.9738 07/26/17 Page 2383 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 2 1 APPEARANCES: 2 On behalf of the State: DALIAH H. WEISS, Esquire 3 ASSISTANT STATE ATTORNEY 401 North Dixie Highway 4 West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 561.355.7100 5 On behalf of the Witness: 6 DONNIE MURRELL, Esquire L.D. MURRELL, P.A. 7 400 Executive Center Drive Suite 201 8 West Palm Beach, Florida 33409 561.686.2700 9 10 ALSO PRESENT: 11 DETECTIVE JOE RECAREY Palm Beach Police Department 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 J. CONSOR & ASSOCIATES REPORTING & TRANSCRIPTION 561.835.9738 07/26/17 Page 2384 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 3 4 INDEX WITNESS: JUAN P. ALESSI EXAMINATION BY DET. RECAREY Page 3 PAGE: 4 5 NO EXHIBITS MARKED 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19" 20 21 22 23 24 25 I. CONSOR & ASSOCIATES REPORTING & TRANSCRIPTION 561.835.9738 07/26/17 Page 2385 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 9 1 girlfriend. She was our immediate superior. 2 Q. Did he have girls come over to give 3 massages? 4 A. Yes. 5 Q. How many massages would he have in a day? 6 A. Sometimes one, sometimes two, three. 7 Q. Was it the same girl that would come back 8 to do the massages? 9 A. Yeah, yeah. Not the same girl I mean 10 during eleven years, I probably saw a hundred, two 11 hundred different massage therapists. 12 Q. Did they seem young to you? 13 A. No, sir. Mostly no. We saw one or two 14 young ones in the last year. Before that, it was all 15 adults. 16 Q. During your last year when you were working 17 with him, what do you mean that they looked young? Did 18 they look like they were still in high school? 19 A. I remember one girl was young. We never 20 asked how old she was. It was not in my job. 21 Q. Right. I understand. 22 A. But I imagine she was 16, 17. In my 23 judgment, she was 16, 17. 24 Q. Where would these massages take place? 25 A. All the time it was in his room. Sometimes J. CONSOR & ASSOCIATES REPORTING & TRANSCRIPTION 561.835.9738 07/26/17 Page 2386 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 11 1 in the house -- and then there's another door going into 2 his room. So it was a long corridor. So everything was 3 closed and nobody saw anything. 4 Q. Would you clean up after? 5 A. Once in a while, yes, I did. Most of the 6 times I did. I did the cleanup. 7 Q. Did it appear as if there was going to be 8 more than one massage going on in the room? 9 A. More than one massage? I don't know. It 10 was massages. There was massages, because it was a hot 11 oil, and it was -- you know this vibrator, the neck 12 vibrators with the long handles. And towels, a lot of 13 towels. We used a lot of towels in the house. Used like 14 maybe 40, 50 towels a day, because every time he go in 15 into the pool, it was two or three towels. Everything 16 had to be cleaned up. I went most of the time to pick up 17 the room and get it ready. 18 Q. Did it ever appear to you that more went on 19 in the room other than a massage? 20 A. I just imagine. I never saw anything. But 21 I imagine there was more than I never saw anything 22 because it was closed doors. It was never done outside. 23 Based on the cleanup? 24 A. Based on the cleanup -- at the end, I 25 cannot say there was. At the end, it was a few times J. CONSOR & ASSOCIATES REPORTING & TRANSCRIPTION 561.835.9738 07/26/17 Page 2387 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 12 1 that the bed was undone. You know, we make the beds 2 three or four times a day. And sometimes we went to 3 clean up the massage to put it back, the massage table, 4 to pick up the towels, but the bed was undone again. So 5 either he took a nap or he went for a nap, I don't know. 6 Q. Or something else occurred? 7 A. Or something else. I cannot. 8 Q. Did the girls, would they bring their own 9 stuff or they would use his stuff? 10 A. No. We had everything. We had gallons of 11 stuff, different stuff. 12 Q. Different massage oils? 13 A. Different, all kinds. 14 Q. Different massagers? 15 A. Different stuff. 16 They would buy all over the world different 17 types of -- for different 18 Q. Did any of these massagers look like sex 19 toys? 20 A. At the end, at the last year that we were 21 there they had like sex toys, some of them. I can say 22 maybe three or four occasions that I saw in the sink, 23 they were left out on the sink, and just -- 24 Q. Where would he keep these massagers? 25 A. When I was there, we keep all the stuff in 3. CONSOR & ASSOCIATES REPORTING & TRANSCRIPTION 561.835.9738 07/26/17 Page 2388 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page Left Intentionally Blank 07/26/17 Page 2389 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR MR E P5-7-U N DATE / 0'14 TIME 5 PM OF PHONE/ MOBILE SW/DM gill 163 q161 TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION " -(01•11,1‘16 YOUR. CAlt MESSAGE SIGNED 1181 IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR N3 c ri----te..cy DATE A ii` 64 9- TIME /07 /17106 M OF MOBILE/ ,.;) I TELEPHONED NALEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE 1fia"1 it ILE 11v4iltietz.: 4' IA-ace:Tx Ekzo tir K10 1.-4 AN tA.e7 '-I SIGNED . a_cALsZ ' - .V _A_: ._,3,t !gc..n IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR (2) A tZ F\ . A.M. DATE A,u_ 5 . --a.... TIME 23 : (-?*(-' M t\-A . c c;it± \-k (-33- C_ I 1 OF • ... PHONE/ 1.\, ', / i , - / :. - .4 -17 7 MOBILE \I I ,-- L 1 C `i (--0"IC - .20 I -r-') r.., I TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL: CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE ? \ t- CA'S C C.. i e.._ \ \ (-:-. 1 I IT ; c:ve. ci. 4 V-N t i / pt:„.- t-V,, . 1-1c.....74...,.._-,e_ V V \ (7: ci -4`-(-7"...A. • I\. 1 - -- o-Cr i-\-(4;--( a SIGNED - 1iLs I IMPORTANT MESSAGE] FOR MR - L P61 e IN DATE 7 1 a 5 101 TIME . 48 A40. PM OF N1-3 MAXWELL PHONE/ MOBILE TELEPHONED -," PLEASE CALL .--°'` CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL 11SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE ,' i E. LL 1--V IN\ "To (A LL M E " i . a SIGNED vA 1184 07/26/17 Page 2390 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR H 0 EPSTE I K aami OF PHONE/(S61) MOBILE . TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION W IN A C / MESSAGE ALC Df...n11 ON H. tA.)/1/4"1. So c-AN No7 Corti E • 5)4 E .3UST 601 1) ACK . EP. SIGNED 1184 DATE 0.011( 0 4 TIME v .415 PM IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR (.5 ./.----,,, D AT F".,740- -nmE L..../. PM e 1, ,atr * . 46-Atri4 ,..,.....,- -if 40 OF PHONE/ MOBILE TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE a SIGNED _ _..,, .118 IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR SASkt1 DATa 1 II k Cl ".‘ TIME 84- . O) P f 1 OF GeoR6e PHONE/ 't MOBILE TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL tt SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE I Am 1Cr - LIM At v D, IQ 0 bbi tv-c, a c- . J.1.).s-c- Sit '1 641-1_1. EA') HE e • 11 SIGNED -.-, - --- 1184 IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR VvlR E R6TE 1 Nt DATE 7 1 1 71 oh TIME 6' 55 P.Nr. M OF -TA-flym PHON an '1 ) 201 0 31 MOBIL -- TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE ‘ M E -A - .0 COME T& R RNA) AN \/ --rime OK IA-ruivt A-LoniE • SIGNED f'sj1/44 11 ', 4- 07/26/17 Page 2391 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR DATE TIME PM M 4- OF PHONE/ MOBILE CS4 TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION E S D M vro),A ill Vgi& JO I II V° Lif elitA SIGNED 1184 IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR V1)-.I • \ -/S Ve i 1.-) , , DATE TIME ‘L‘.:LL.-1_71 A.M. M OF PHONE( MOBILE TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE DCWT IIA ' C (( kei1 c-ck\\ - r:c:cyc_,-,-- - a 1 SIGNED ,184 IMPORTANT MESSAGE e....---, FOR ---:-.1 1 /4.Y a IMPORTANT A M DATE TIME _ P.M. c24-icAnn on OF PHONE/ MOBILE TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH • RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE ( 0 (39 (./ 17?-1 aT. SIGNED 1184 .................--,. ..m-.........-....-...-....,..... IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR 4' A . L DATF TIME- ' Eta t -16:QX1 )._ , U ,.tip OF ..1..• fr PHONE/ • MOBILE - 1 I -f- -'- cll. 7 1 (z) , ,_t TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESS -- , 1 --- -__-, _ . ......„.........- _. . SIGNED 1184 07/26/17 Page 2392 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

OFFICE OF THE STATE ATTORNEY FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT OF FLORIDA IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY BARRY E. KRISCHER STATE ATTORNEY July 24, 2008 , FL Re: State of Florida vs. JEFFREY E EPSTEIN Court Case No: 2006CF009454AMB- 2008CF009381AMB Agency: PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Agency Case No: 05-0368 Dear M The case described above was closed on 06/26/2008 with the following result: PLED GUILTY TO CHARGES AND SENTENCED TO 12 MO IN COUNTY JAIL. FOLLOWED BY 6M0 IN DOC AND 12M0. COMMUNITY CONTROL. DESIGNATED A SEX OFFENDER If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, COPY LANNA BELOHLAVEK Assistant State Attorney cc: Evidence Custodian: evidence is no longer needed 401 N. Dixie Highway, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-4209 (561) 355-7100 07/26/17 Page 2393 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

OFFICE OF THE STATE ATTORNEY FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT OF FLORIDA IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY BARRY E. KRISCHER STATE ATTORNEY July 24, 2008 FL Re: State of Florida vs. JEFFREY E EPSTEIN Court Case No: 2006CF009454AMB- 2008CF009381AMB Agency: PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Agency Case No: 05-0368 Dear Ms. The case described above was closed on 06/26/2008 with the following result: PLED GUILTY TO CHARGES AND SENTENCED TO 12 MO IN COUNTY JAIL , FOLLOWED BY 6M0 IN DOC AND 12M0 OF COMMUNITY CONTROL. DESIGNATED A SEX OFFENDER If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, Cn 110V LANNA BELOHLAVEK Assistant State Attorney cc: Evidence Custodian: evidence is no longer needed 401 N. Dixie Highway, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-4209 (561) 355-7100 07/26/17 Page 2394 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

OFFICE OF THE STATE ATTORNEY FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT OF FLORIDA IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY BARRY E. KRISCHER STATE ATTORNEY July 24, 2008 DET JOSEPH RECAREY #7915 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 345 S. COUNTY ROAD PALM BEACH, FL 33480 Re: State of Florida vs. JEFFREY E EPSTEIN Court Case No: 2006CF009454AMB- 2008CF00938 IAMB Agency: PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Agency Case No: 05-0368 Dear Det Recarey: The case described above was closed on 06/26/2008 with the following result: PLED GUILTY TO CHARGES AND SENTENCED TO 12 MO IN COUNTY JAIL, FOLLOWED BY 6M0 DOC AND 12M0 COMMUNITY CONTROL. DESIGNATED A SEX 01+ENDER If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, COPY LANNA BELOHLAVEK Assistant State Attorney cc: Evidence Custodian: evidence is no longer needed 401 N. Dixie Highway, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-4209 (561) 355-7100 07/26/17 Page 2395 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

It: IS Ap.mM. DATE Vi i7D , TIME 6- OF 1184 1184 SIGNED SIGNED riMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR DATE of /Qv/a- TIME 6-1) (6tr( TELEPHONED ....,! PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPACIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE I IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR 6‘2"C"-c-e' 1.1 PHONE/ MOBILE TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE (Gat A.M OF PHONE/ MOBILE IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR DATE TIME a ll.) )1( \olsx,0 O pH F o MOBI N 9 \ 1-. (7530 .- ) LE C) TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESVE) di i • i 111 -11.171 v II SIGNED 1184 IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR i DATEj__ TIME __ M -t._.7 OF PHONE/ MOBILE_ TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE .-111\--(1- i AO i 0 P, 4 I do r + 10 PO ASS®[ ... i \c3(1- L SIGNED i • 07/26/17 Page 2396 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR DATE 1)2 // OS M Feti TIME ; A.M. OF PHONE/ BILE AFOOBI4LEEI t) -5-5 6 AV 013 TELEPHONED -PLEASE CALL e . . . . . 7jli CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL I SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE (fri5f -5/9e czeliQd 4 SIGNED a - 1nea IMPORTANT MESSAGE , FOR DATE TIME ?'P q ffal. M OF PHONE/ MOBILE TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE i he /2a_5 {ie. ne9( /atyucie , . Wtod 3 ( caa bo-ez, ,,,_ e (e._$ ..v/-2 7 GI_S fi2.5_5/6/C a SIGNED IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR DATE TIME / : P dAgs M OF PHONE/ MOBILE TELEPHONED 'CZ) PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE // Lsh t C-- 4,,,•4/t e c:( a SIGNED 1184 -_- ----- IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR pi' (- DATE 1/ 2 4r -5- TIME 4' .°141 M C C cA 410... OF PHONE/ MOBILE TELEPHONED ..k.<:15-- , LEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE 1 l 0 e 0{ 11 • 7 g (.14 Q 1^/ te a: SIGNED SIGNED 1184 07/26/17 Page 2397 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

AREA CODE NUMBER TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION IMPORTANT MESSAGE TIME IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR A M DATE TIME PM M OF PHONE AREA CODE NUMBER EXTENSION TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE r SIGNED 1184 IMPORTANT MESSAGE srpetn •Itt FOR cip , ' ‘'",. 1....)• DATE 0 ..,9 / 03/ 1 , / 3101W .7', 3 TIME n 104 li C, P.M. OF PHONE 1 1 7:4' () .."N .*....k - 1 AREA CODE *NUMBER EXTENSION TELEPHONED CK PLEASE CALL 42 CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MES 9E t__ It , SIGNED 1184 IMPORTANT MESSAGE 41.-:,•:-. FOR -- `,‘' - R ,,-,), A.M. DATE TIME R. s-----) PM NA L .':- \"s- I. V: -\ 4:':Z \-'• 0,...-2 OF PHONE LA n.o.6.'12 NUMBER EXTENSION & TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION MESSAGE i t %,"C"jik c.) \ \--.*:,:,Hr---/- ...-&,'"-- N SIGNED 1184 07/26/17 Page 2398 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

. - PROPERTY RECEIPT DETECTIVE BUREAU PBPD Form #52 U PROPERTY U FOUND U DECEASED (Probated) 0 PERSONAL 0 CONFISCATED U DESTROY 1,;i EVIDENCE pr TRIAL 0 LABORATORY 0 STOLEN/RECOVERED 0 OTHER INCIDENT/CITATION NUMBER t: . t! / ...._ . , ._ ... DATFJTIME RECOVERED ...„ . PROPERTY NUMBER (Leave Blank) BIN NUMBER (Leave Blank)• - ADDRESS WHERE PROPER7 IMPOUNDED DISCOVERED BY BY / D.O.B. ADDRESS Street City Zip PHONE NUMBER OWNER / VICTIM'S NAME / D.O.B. ADDRESS Street City Zip PHONE NUMBER SUSPECTS NAME / D.O.B. i..." 1:::::,i. rt.'-'2.• t.--) -.-- ADDRESS Street City Zip ......-' ..../ ( .../ PHONE NUMBER ADOTNL. SUSPECT / D.O.B. ADDRESS Street City Zip PHONE NUMBER SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS FOUND PROPERTY CLAIM U 90 DAYS NOT CLAIM U ITEM # QUANTITY VALUE DESCRIPTION i /:-.. el ... '..? TOTAL PACKAGE WEIGHT I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property taken from me and that I have received a copy of this receipt. I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded by me in the official performance of my duty as a police officer. i t SIGNATURE DATE SIGNATURE ID# UNIT RECEIVED BY REASON DATE/TIME RECEIVED 07/26/17 Page 2399 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

PROPERTY RECEIPT DETECTIVE BUREAU Ull PROPERTY ra FOUND 0 DECEASED (Probated) [a PERSONAL C:1 CONFISCATED 0 DESTROY La EVIDENCE 1:1 TRIAL 0 LABORATORY U STOLEN/RECOVERED 0 OTHER INCIDENT/CITATION NUMBER DATE/TIME RECOVERED 4 , PROPERTY NUMBER (Leave Blank) BIN NUMBER (Leave Blank) ADDRESS WHERE PROPERTY IMPOUNDED • . — , DISCOVERED BY / D.O.B. ADDRESS Street City Zip PHONE NUMBER OWNER / VICTIM'S NAME / D.O.B. ADDRESS Street City Zip PHONE NUMBER SUSPECTS NAME / D.O.B' - 26; — . I ADDRESS Street City Zip g , -"1"'i ••--1 I • .:- i A " ; i ' ''' --+-.. ..' I ' : r. ..." i ! 1 • ..." PHONE NUMBER ADDT'NL. SUSPECT/ D.O.B.. ADDRESS Street City Zip PHONE NUMBER SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS FOUND PROPERTY CLAIM 0 90 DAYS NOT CLAIM Ci ITEM # QUANTITY VALUE DESCRIPTION 6 4 , ..- r . ./. ....k,, ,..q., ..; - r ' • 1 TOTAL PACKAGE WEIGHT I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property taken from me and that I have received a copy of this receipt. I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded by me in the official performance of my duty as a police officer. ,.,. . SIGNATURE DATE SIGNATURE ID# UNIT RECEIVED BY REASON DATE/TIME RECEIVED .-ct) 1-)e PBPD Form ee2 07/26/17 Page 2400 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 boyfriend's house. 2 MP: Okay. 3 And, when I was in that guy's room, there was a like, where the drawers of lotion 4 were, there's like a shelf of pictures and he had so many pictures of girls about 5 16, 17, around that age, 17 or 18. And they were like on the walls and most 6 of....all the girls were topless or just plain naked. And they were in positions or 7 they were just standing up. 8 MP: Okay. 9 Looking at pictures. 10 MP: Okay. Well, I have to ask you. Do you know the difference between....and 11 you're a grown woman, so I'm asking you. You're pretty mature for your age. 12 Okay? Do you know the difference between right and wrong? 13 Yes. 14 MP: Do you know the difference between the truth and a lie? 15 yes. 16 MP: Can you tell me what a lie would be? 17 Urn, not saying the truth. 18 MP: Okay. So if I tell you you are wearing a blue sweater right now 19 I could tell you you're lying. 20 MP: Why? 21 Because I'm wearing a pink one. 22 MP: You got it. Is everything you've told me the truth? 23 Yes. Page 42 of 43 07/26/17 Page 2401 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 MP: Michele Pagan 2 3 HR: Haley Robson 4 5 MP: Today's date is March 30, 2005. The time now, by my watch, is approximately 6 3:35. I'm present with at Family Center. And we're 7 placing a telephone call to 8 Haley and the number is 333-0180. 9 MP: Okay. 10 (Dialing number) 11 UNK: Hello? 12 Is Haley there? 13 UNK: No, she's at work. Who's this? 14 15 UNK: 16 17 UNK: no she's at work, honey. She's working a double today. She has her cell 18 phone if you want to call her on that. 19 Yeah. 20 UNK: 308-0282. 21 Thank you. 22 UNK: Your welcome, honey. 23 Bye. Page 1 of 5 07/26/17 Page 2402 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 UNK: Bye. (Dialing number) 3 HR: Hello? 4 Hey. Haley. 5 HR: Yeah. 6 This is 7 HR: Hey. 8 Yeah. You called me on Sunday but I was..(inaudible) 9 HR: Uh, yeah, urn, I don't know...well, I'm at work right now, what are you doing? 10 I'm at home. 11 HR: You live with your dad still? 12 No. 13 HR: What happened, cause I heard so many rumors, about like Jeffery and how you 14 were going to press charges and get me arrested and everything? 15 No. 16 HR: Yeah... 17 That's totally not true. You know, like me and my dad got in a fight cause I got in 18 a fight with this girl at school because she was saying "you know that Sheena 19 girl? 20 HR: Yeah. 21 ...(inaudible) she was going around school saying that (inaudible) (Inaudible) 22 (inaudible) and I got into a fight with her because she told everybody in school all 23 this stuff. And I guess supposedly when I talked to Zack. Zack was like "oh Page 2 of 5 07/26/17 Page 2403 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 2 3 4 yeah, since you broke up with me and everything all this stuff (inaudible) and then Sheena, I guess, told her friend and her and her friend told the school. So my dad, and I got into a fight with that Sheena girl and my dad kicked me out. Now I'm living with my mom. (Inaudible) 5 HR: You live with your mom now? 6 Yeah. 7 HR: Oh, so they don't even know about Jeffery then, do they? 8 No. They just think I got into a fight at school and I got suspended. 9 HR: Oh, yeah, cause supposedly your dad found out about Jeffrey and everything. 10 No. He thinks the reason I got into a fight was because the girl pushed me. 11 (Inaudible) 12 HR: They don't know anything about Jeffrey then. 13 No. No way. I'd get in trouble if (inaudible) 14 HR: I don't know. 15 ..and then (inaudible) talk a lot of crap and everything. 16 HR: Yeah. Alright, well Jeffrey needs someone to work. I don't know if you want to 17 work or not. 18 Yeah. 19 HR: I mean, he needs someone tomorrow. 20 Okay. 21 HR: What time are you available? 22 Four. 23 HR: Four? Alright, well I'm gonna call him and if I don't call you back tonight, I'll call Page 3 of 5 07/26/17 Page 2404 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 you...is this your cell phone? 2 Yeah. 3 HR: Alright, I'll call you on this later tonight. 4 Yeah. I have a question. 5 HR: Okay. 6 I don't know if you want to, cause I remember last time how like, you said 7 something about bringing my sister or whatever? 8 HR: Yeah. 9 I talked to her about and she's like, yeah so I don't know if you want her come or 10 if you get something extra or whatever, like, I can bring her this time. 11 HR: Okay. I'll let him know. 12 Well like....okay. 13 HR: Alright? 14 Well, what time are you going to call my phone? Cause I don't have it on all the 15 time, I have, I'll have it like around like 3 or 4... 16 HR: Tomorrow? 17 Yeah. 18 HR: Alright. Well, I'll call you tomorrow then. 19 Alright. Around 3 or 4? 20 HR: I'm sorry? 21 You have to call between 3 and 4 cause I'm in school and I don't take the phone, 22 my phone. 23 HR: Yeah, that's fine. I'll call you between 3 and 4. Page 4 of 5 07/26/17 Page 2405 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1 Alrighty. 2 HR: Alright. 3 Okay. 4 HR: Bye. 5 (Hung up phone) 6 MP: This concludes. The time now of the conversation, approximately 3:40pm. Page 5 of 5 07/26/17 Page 2406 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

______________________________________________________________________________ ate: 7/19/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 64 ' ...: 15:01:37 Incident Report Program: CMS301L ase No • 1-05-000368 (Continued) Det. Recarey directed me to a second detached structure located on the South East corner of the property. This area of this structure was assigned with single letters to identify a particular part of the room. In the office area, designated as Room B, I observed a powered on Dell Dimension 2350, attached to an LCD flat panel monitor. The screen displayed an open Microsoft Internet Explorer browser with URL address of http://home.bellsouth.net/. I observed no other active windows in the Start panel window and photographed screen. The power cord was removed from the back of the Dell CPU and I disconnected the cable modem to prevent remote access. At that time, the Dell CPU, marked with Serial Number 6WTVN21, was secured and turned over the evidence custodian for future forensic analysis via property receipt. I also located several media related items within Room B, which were recorded onto a property receipt and turned over the Evidence Custodians. I then responded to a Bedroom designated as Room F, where I observed a white in color CPU marked Premio. The Premio CPU was in a computer desk which held a white CRT monitor, both of which were powered on. The CRT monitor displayed a message from Norton Antivirus software, warning of an expired subscription. I observed no other active windows in the Start panel window and photographed screen. I removed the power cable from the back of the Premio CPU and shutdown all other media. The Premio CPU, marked with Serial Number 2000091078, was secured and turned over the evidence custodian for future forensic analysis via property receipt. I also located several media related items within Room F, which were recorded onto a property receipt and turned over the Evidence Custodians. This concluded my participation in the search of the residence. **************************NARRATIVE # 28 ************************** Reported By: RECAREY, JOSEPH 12/21/05 Entered By.: ALTOMARO, NICKIE A. 12/21/05 On December 20, 2005, I contacted ASA Daliah Weiss in an attempt to subpoena the Epstein former houseman, Alfredo Rodriguez. Rodriguez, who resides in Miami, had eluded the process servers previously and was not served the investigative subpoena. a: telephone message was left as she is not available during the week of 12/19/2005i) I made contact with State Attorney Inv Theresa Wyatt and requeste the same via telephone message. I then researched the victim's cellular telephone subpoena data which had been received from a previous subpoena request. I analyzed the records which depict several calls from Haley Robson. The telephone calls start on February 6, 2005 at 12:49 pm.; the same day which the victim and the victim's father stated the incident occurred at Epstein s house. The first incoming call was from Robson's residence at 561 333-0180. The second incoming call from Robson's 07/26/17 Page 2407 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

:e: 7/19/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 87 n' 15:01:37 Incident Report Program: CMS301L ;e No - 1-05-000368 (Continued) of call in seconds, inbound or outbound calls and calls made to or from one. On March 7, 2006, at 11:03 am, made a call to the victim which lasted 492 seconds (8 minutes and 2 seconds). The victim then returned the call at 11:16 am which lasted 6 seconds. The victim then made contact w 11:22 am for 877.2 seconds (14 minutes and 6 seconds). These sequences of calls were consistent with what the victim had described to me on the date of the intimidation. Immediately after speaking with the victim makes a call to Sarah Kellen, Epstein's assistant, which lasts for forty-e9ht seconds. A call is then immediately received, a telephone number registered to a Corporation affiliated with Jeffrey Epstein located at 457 Madison Ave in New York.. An extensive computer check revealed 457 Madison Ave is a business address in which Epstein has his corporations assigned to. Epstein had corporation attorney, Darren Indyke, register the businesses and register himself as an agent. I also observed Epstein has his El Zorro Ranch Corporation, New York Strategy Group, Ghislaine Corporation, J Epstein and Company and the Financial Strategy Group registered to this same address. Finally, a third call is received by at 12:02 pm from the same corporate number which lasts 12 minutes and 1 second. It should be noted that there is no further contact with either the victim during the month of March or April of 2006. I also noted that there was no further contact. with Sarah Kellen or Jeffrey Epstein during the mainder of the month of March or April 2006. COn June 1, 2006, ASA Lana Belohlavek telephoned me to inform me' of the meeting that occurred with Atty. Jack Goldberger and her reference this case. She advised she would make her determination pn whether to file on this case or not by Monday June 5, 2006 Inv Continues. -************************NARRATIVE # 46 ************************** Reported By: RECAREY, JOSEPH 7/12/06 Entered By.: ALTOMARO, NICKIE A. 7/12/06 On June 29, 2006, I had spoken to ASA Lana Belohlavic who informed me that the case would be sent to the Grand Jury for charges. She informed me that the grand jury would convene on July 19, 2006 to hear the Epstein case. Belohlavic stated State Attorney Barry Krisher made the determination to go the Grand Jury to hear the case. On July 12, 2006, I spoke with mother of the victim who inquired about the status of the case. I explained to her that I was told we would be going to the Grand Jury during the week of July 19, 2006. She stated she had not been contacted as of yet by the State Attorney's Office for any information. I provided her with the telephone numbers to the State Attorney's Office. .iestigation continues... r * * * * * * * * * * * * * END OF REPORT * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 07/26/17 Page 2408 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

ate: 7/19/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 65 im-: 15:01:37 Incident Report Program: CMS301L ase No • 1-05-000368 (Continued) cellular phone 561-308-0282 occurred at 1:02 pm. The call durations were one minute or less. The time frame was within thirteen minutes apart. It should be noted that Robson s residence was in close proximity to the victim's. The next call occurred at 5:50 pm when the victim telephoned Robson s residence. Several calls were made after the above mentioned calls both incoming and outgoing to Robson. Further analysis showed no telephone calls to either Robson's cellular telephone or Robson's residence were registered prior to February 6, 2005. Additionally, I also conducted an analysis on the telephone calls from 305-710-5165. The subscriber information confirmed that the number is registered to Paul A Lavery from Hialeah, Florida. The address was crossed referenced to the Office of Kiraly and Riley Private Investigators. I researched the web page www.rileykiraly.com which also showed various cases in which they assisted. I also located another web site under www.coralspringssparklandrotary.org in which Mr. Riley attended a Miami Rotary meeting and confirmed Atty. Roy Black is among his clientele. The telephone calls revealed Lavery had telephone contact with 11•1111 either just after I attempted to interview them, or just prior. A background was conducted on Lavery which revealed he holds a current Private Investigator License. A criminal arrest record revealed he had been previously arrested for possession of cocaine and solicitation of prostitution. also researched the girls using www.myspace.com. This web site is a new social networking service that allows members to create unique personal profiles online in order to find and communicate with old and new friends. The site allows one to establish your own myspace.com page and decorate the page any way one wishes. I found the following people have myspace sites: Haley Robson IMIMMMMO 1•11111061111ft and I received a Cingular Wireless packet which contained a CD which contained the results of the subpoena request for verbatim calls on P An analysis will be conducted in the near future on the phone numbers called. Investigation Continues. **************************NARRATIVE # 29 ************************** Reported By: RECAREY, JOSEPH 12/27/05 Entered By.: ALTOMARO, NICKIE A. 12/29/05 Upon doing research on the message books recovered in the search warrant, I located the identity of The telephone number 111,was registered to She currently is seventeen years old and is attending the 07/26/17 Page 2409 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

ate: 7/19/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 43 ime: 15:01:37 Incident Report Program: CMS301L _ _ _ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- ase No • 1-05-000368 (Continued) As we entered onto the property, we encountered the house manager, Janusz Banasiak who was in the guest portion of the house. The guesthouse section had open doors and no forced entry was made. made contact with Banasiak, Date of Birth 04-07-1953, Fl DL and informed him of the search warrant for the premises. The members of the Police Department entered the residence and announced we had a search warrant. A safety search was done and members exited the home. I read the search warrant to Banasiak as Mgr Parkinson videotaped the search warrant execution. Several interior decorators were located on the property. I spoke with Mark Zeff, of 515 W 20th Street in New York. Mr. Zeff stated he is the designer for Mr. Epstein's homes. He advised he was contacted in March of 2005 to do a complete overhaul on the house. He advised he was on the phone with Mr. Epstein when officers announced the search warrant. Mr. Epstein was then made aware of the search warrant. Mr. Zeff advised, his contact with Epstein is strictly business and he has never witnessed Epstein with any girls except for his assistants, Sara or Nada. I then interviewed Daniel Estes, of 315 East 14th Street in New York. Mr. Estes stated he has worked for Zeff for seven years. He advised he personally worked on the New York and Palm Beach home for Mr. Epstein. He has previously met with Sara and Adrianna, Epstein's assistants in New York and in Florida. Estes stated they travel with Epstein everywhere he goes. I interviewed Zara Bailey of 35 Riverside Jersey City, New Jersey. Bailey stated she just arrived from Scotland and.has worked with Zeff for only one month. She stated she has never met Epstein and has not seen him. The interview was then concluded. I then spoke with Douglas Schoettle of 243 Riverside Dr in New York City. Schoettle stated he has been Epstein's Architect for seven years. He further stated he deals with Epstein's assistants and speaks with Epstein on the phone. Schoettle stated he mainly speaks with Sara Kellen, Epstein s main assistant, who travels with Epstein. Schoettle stated he only has contact with Epstein when his services are needed. At approximA.tely 10:30 am, I was informed that the videotaping was concluded. LT entered the residence and located two covert (hidden) cameras. The first camera was a covert wall clock in the garage area. I traced the wire behind the clock and removed the RCA wire and unplugged the camera. The other covert camera was located within a desk clock beside Epstein's desk. I traced the wire behind the clock and unplugged the RCA wire] I could not locate another camera. I then began with the search of the residence for the specified evidence. My search consisted of the second floor. Det. Krauel and I began in _he master bedroom area where several items were located. They were 07/26/17 Page 2410 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Probable Cause Affidavit Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORL FLO 500600 During the course of the investigation a search warrant was executed at Jeffrey Epstein's home located at 358 El Brillo Way in Palm Beach. While in the home I observed the pink and green couch within the master bedroom area just as the girls previously mentioned. The stairway, which is located from the kitchen area to the master bedroom area, is lined with photos of naked young girls. Additionally, numerous photographs of naked young females, some of which appeared to be the girls I previously interviewed, were on display throughout the house. Also located in the house were various phone message books. The telephone message books have a duplicate copy (Carbon Copy) which, once a phone message is written into the book, the top copy is then torn on the perforated edge and the carbon copy is left in the book. First names of girls, dates and telephone numbers were on the copy of the messages. I recognized various numbers and names of girls that had already been interviewed. The body of the messages were time of the day that they called for confirmation of "work." Other names and telephone numbers were located in which the body of the messages were, "I have girls for him" or "I have 2 girls for him." These messages were taken by Sarah Kellen, who signed the bottom of the messages. During the execution of the warrant, I located a transcript for fiRlin Epstein's bedroom desk. This desk had stationary marked Jeffrey E EpsteinElocated a wood colored armoire beside Epstein's bed that contained a bottle of "Joy Jelly," which is used to provide a warm massage. Several massage tables were located throughout the second floor of the residence, including a massage table found in Epstein's bedroom. On the first floor of the residence I found two covert cameras hidden within clocks. One was located in the garage and the other located in the library area on a shelf behind Epstein's desk. A computer was located -hich was believed to contain the images from the covert cameras. The computer's hard drive was reviewed .rich showed several images of Haley Robson and other witnesses that have been interviewed. All of these images appeared to come from the camera positioned behind Epstein's desk) On December 13, 2005, Det. Dawson and I met w dob . During a sworn taped statement, stated that when she was sixteen years old she was taken to Epstein's house to provide a massage for money. Illbstated it was before Christmas last year (2004) when an associate, 11/0 approached her and asked if she needed to make money for Christmas. - made arrangements to take to the house and drove Ilk to the house to "work." They were encountered by a white female with long blond hair. fri, was unable to remember the name of the white female with blond hair but knew she was Epstein's assistant. She was led upstairs by the white female who explained that there would be lotions out already and Epstein would choose the lotion he wanted her to use. She was led through a spiral staircase which led to a master bedroom.and bathroom. The massage table was already set up in the bathroom.ii, described the bathroom as a large spacious bathroom with a steam room and shower beside it. elf was introduced to Epstein who was on the phone when she entered the room. Epstein was wearing a white towel and laid on his stomach so thaw may The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me. State of Florida County of Pal • Beach Signatur ting Officer Date: 06 Signature of Polic(Officeit(F.S.S. 117.10) 07/26/17 Page 2411 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

PERTY INFO RMATION# 2 *************** ****** : 1-03-001498 Category . . : *STOLEN/RECOVERED* : U.S.CURRENCY Color Make : CURRENCY/NEGOTIABLE UCR Prop Type : CURRENCY, NOTE, ETC. Insured? NCIC number . 2,700.00 Recovered by . : 10/13/03 Recovery value : 2,700.00 Document? . Property Seq Date: 9/01/06 Time: 13:38;06 rALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Incident Report Page: 1 Program: CMS301L Case Number . : 1-03-001498 SPECIAL NOTES : Occur From Date: 10/05/03 0824 Occur To Date : 10/05/03 0824 Report Date 10/05/03 0845 Day Of Week . : Sunday Common/Location: 358 EL BRILLO WY City • PALM BEACH, FL Location Type : RESIDENCE-SINGLE FAMILY Beat Assignment: SHIFT 2 Map Reference 10 Dept Class . . : BURGLARY RESIDENCE Report Officer : DESMARAIS, WENDY Cane Status . : EXCEPTIONALLY CLEARED Case Status Dt 10/15/03 Supervisory Dt.: FRICK, RONALD 10/05/03 Entry Date . OREGERO, LAURA 10/06/03 Names? Property? . . Vehicles? . Offenses? . . : Narrative? . Related Cases? : Interfaces? *** PROPERTY INFORMATION# 1 ********************* Case number . 1-03-001498 Category . . . : **MISC OR UNFOUNDED PROP ** Description . : PISTOL Color Serial number : Make GLOCK Model UCR Prop Type : FIREARMS Property type ; insured by . value HANDGUN Insured? NCIC number . 1,000.00 Recovered by . Recovered Date : 0/00/00 Recovery value : 0.00 Street number City Drug? Document? . Property Meg . Property Seq . : ********* p R 0 Case number . Description . Serial number Model Property type Insured by . . Value Recovered Date Street number City Drug? Property Meg . ********* P E R S O N REPO R Case Number . 1-03-001498 Street Number : 301 E 66TH ST lON City NEW YORK, NY 10021 Birth Date/Age : 5/25/1979 24 Occupation . . PERSONAL ASSISTANT Some Phone No. : 212/750-9895 Sex 3 Female weight • 0 TING N F 0 # 1 ********* Last Name . . : KELLEN, SARAH LYNNELLE Employer? . . : Oper Lic No. . : Race • White Height • 508 Other Phone Nbr: 917/855-3363 07/26/17 Page 2412 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

ICTIM INFORMATION # 1 1-03-001498 Prompt valid in: EPSTEIN, JEFFREY EDWARD 358 EL BRILLO WY PALM BEACH, FL 000033480 1/20/1953 50 Employer? . BANKER/SELF Oper Lic No. 561/655-7626 Race Male Height 0 Misc. ID# . . : Other Phone Nbr: Residency Type : File Charges . : Victim Sobriety: Injury Type 1 : Hospital ID . Phys First Name: . White 600 r - PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 2 Incident Report Program: CMS301L Date: 9/01/06 Time: 13:38:06 1-03-001498 (Continued) ********* P E R Case Number . : Street Number : City Birth Date/Age : Occupation . . : Home Phone No. : sex • Weight S 0 N REPORTING INFO 1-03-001498 Last Name . . 358 EL BRILLO WY PALM BEACH, FL 000033480 10/27/1970 32 Employer? , : HOUSE MANAGER Oper Lic No. Race Male Height 190 Other Phone Nbr: - # 2 *** ***** * FRIEDMAN, MICHAEL DAVID White 601 561/818-8361 ********* PERSON REPORTING INFO : 1-03-001498 Last Name . . : 358 EL BRILLO WY - PALM BEACH, FL 000033480 : 11/03/1974 28 Employer? . : : HOUSE MANAGER Oper Lic No. . : Race - # 3 *** ****** FRIEDMAN, ROSALIE Case Number Street Number City Birth Date/Age Occupation . Home Phone No. Sex Female Weight 135 Height Other Phone Nbr: Oriental/Asian 504 561/818-8398 ***4*****PERSO N R E P 0 Case Number . 1-03-001498 Street Number : 22 AVENUE FOCH City PARIS, Birth Date/Age 0/00/0000 0 Occupation . . Home Phone No. 561/000-0000 Sex Weight 0 V Case Number : Street Number City Birth Date/Age : Occupation . . Home Phone No. : Sex Weight Be On Look Out?: Victim Type . Residency Sts : Can Identify . : Injury Extent : Injury Type 2 : Med Treatment : Phys Last Name : RTING INFO - # 4 *** ****** Last Name . COTRIN, VALDSON VIEIRA Employer? . . : Oper Lic No. . Race Height • 0 Other Phone Nbr: 561/000-0000 ***EMPLOYER INFORMATION*** Case Number . : 1-03-001498 Employer Name Address • . . . . 07/26/17 Page 2413 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

********* OTHER PERSO N Case Number . : 1-03-001498 Street Number : 525 SO SEQUOIA APT. City WEST PALM BEACH, FL Birth Date/Age : 4/14/1975 28 : Occupation . . : Home Phone No. : 561/000-0000 White Sex Male Height 0 ( Weight 0 Person Type : OTHER PERSON Other Phone Nbr: 561/000-0000 INFORMATION - # 2 Last Name . . : ALESSI, JOHN A 33409 Employer? . Oper Lic No. Race Date: 9/01/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 3 Time: 13:38:06 Incident Report Program: CMS301L 1-03-001498 (Continued) City/State/Zip PALM BEACH, FL 000033480 Phone Number . : 212/750-9895 *********OTHER PERSON Case Number : 1-03-001498 Street Number : 1515 SO FLAGLER DR. City • WEST PALM BEACH, FL Birth Date/Age : 10/27/1946 56 Occupation . . Home Phone No. : 561/000-0000 Sex Female Weight 0 Other Phone Nbr: 561/000-0000 INFORMATION # 1 Last Name . . : ALESSI, MARIE #1901 33407 Employer? . Oper Lic No. : Race White Height 0 Person Type : OTHER PERSON ********* ********* ****************************NARRATIVE # 1 *************************** Original Report LO Reported By: DESMARAIS, WENDY D. 10/05/03 Entered By.: OREGERO, LAURA D. 10/06/03 On Sunday 10/5/03 at approximately 0824 hours, I was dispatched to a burglary at 358 El Brillo Way. Upon arrival, I met with reporting party/victim Jeffrey Epstein, white male, dob/012053. Epstein advised he and hie personal assistant Sarah Kellen, white female, dob/052579, arrived in the residence on Friday evening, 10/3/03. Epstein advised that on Saturday evening 10/4/03, he left his briefcase at his desk and went to bed at approximately 1230 am. Epstein said when he left his briefcase, it contained approximately $5000 U.S. currency. Kellen advised the case was in $100 bills and kept in a white envelope inside the briefcase. Epstein stated at approximately 0715 hours on Sunday, 10/5/03, while sitting at his desk, he noticed the briefcase had been opened and some of the cash was missing. Epstein believed approximately $3500 was taken from the briefcase. Epstein advised that he did not know if the cash was sequential or recorded. Epstein further advised a black Clock handgun was taken from the bookshelf located behind his desk. Epstein advised he suspected cash had been taken from his briefcase on two other occasions while he was in town for the weekend. The first was over Labor Day weekend Aug. 30-Sept 1, 2003. The second time was a weekend in mid September, 2003. Epstein stated he did not 07/26/17 Page 2414 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Date: 9/01/06 Time: 13:38:06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 4 Incident Report Program: CMS301L 1-03-001498 (Continued) report these incidents because he was not sure the money was accounted for. Possible footage of the incident may exist. I next met with Kellen who advised she went to bed at approximately 1130 pm on 10/4/03 and did not hear or see anything unusual through the night or on the morning of 10/5/03. Cotrin, the resident chef advised that he went to bed at approximately 1030 pm on 10/4/03 and began work at approximately 6:20 am on 10/5/03. Cotrin stated that he did not see or hear anything unusual from the staff residence locate don the east side of the property. I next spoke to Mike and Rosalie Friedman who are the house managers. Mike stated that he went to the staff residence at approximately 8:30 hours on 10/4/03 and got up at approximately 11:30 pm same night to move the Mercedes into the garage. Mike said he returned to the residence at approximately 6:20 am on 10/5/03 but did not notice anything unusual. Rosalie stated that she checked the exterior of the residence at approximately 7:30pm on 10/4/03 as part of her duties. Rosalie stated at that time, she saw no one and everything appeared in order. Rosalie stated she left the main house at approximately 11:30 pm and returned at approximately 8:30 on 10/5/03. It should be noted that Mike and Rosalie Friedman have been employed as the house managers since 9/24/03. Prior to them, the live on site house managers were Patrick and Evelyn, Epstein was unsure of the last name. Patrick Evelyn were employed at 358 El Brillo approximately 9 months. Prior to the house manager was John Alessi who was employee at 358 El Brillo approximately 10 years. Epstein signed an affidavit of prosecution, it is attached to this report. Crime Scene manager Parkinson responded and processed the scene. Det. Melnichok also responded. See Det. Melnichok's report for further information. Officer Nault responded and conducted a neighborhood canvas which is also attached to this report. It should be noted that Epstein will contact Palm Beach Police Department with the serial number of the stolen handgun so that it may be entered into FCIC. **** ****** ********** ***************** # 2 ********************* ***** * GREENE Reported By: MELNICHOK, THOMAS C. 10/06/03 Entered By.: GREENE, LINDA C. 10/06/03 On 10/05/03, at 1000 hours, I responded to 358 El Brillo Way reference a burglary that had occurred at the residence during the night. Upon my arrival, I met with the homeowner who verbally identified himself as Jeffrey Epstein, DOB 01/20/53. Epstein told me that over the last couple of months, when he has come into town, he has money he had left in his carry on bag, has turned up missing. Epstein said he wasn't sure of the amount of money in the carry on hag on any specific incident and thought that he possibly had misplaced the money. Epstein 07/26/17 Page 2415 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Date: 9/01/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: Time: 13:38:06 Incident Report Program: CMS301L 1-03-001498 (Continued) told me that he had purchased a spy camera from a store on Okeechobee Blvd. and had set up the camera which was in a clock in his office facing the briefcase with the money in it. Epstein then placed $4,000. in O.S. currency, one hundred dollar bill increments and left the bad on his desk as he always does when he is in town. Epstein said that he went to bed with the camera system monitoring the bad and desk area, only to wake up and twice to have $100. missingifrom the bag and the suspects image on his computer hard drive. It should be noted that there were thirteen one hundred dollat bills still in the white envelope and that nothing else in the hoUse appeared to be disturbed by the suspect. Epstein took me to the computerlroom where he showed me a computer monitor that was displaying a still frame of the suspect. The computer indicated a Lime of 0428 a.m., when the suspect came into the office area, walked behind the desk, opened the hand bag, and then opened the center drawer td the desk. It appeared as though the suspect was familiar with le house and the desk. Epstein told me that he did not know wh the suspect in the photo was but thought it might be his forMer houseman because of his size and shape. Epstein also pointed out that the suspect in the video was wearing moccasin type shoes like his former houseman The suspect was a white male who ., It earing tan pants, white shirt, me with the former houseman's . Alessi, DOB 02/12/50, living at 1901, West Palm Beach, Florida. C:1- advised Epstein that I would surveillance video from his corn have in hands. Epstein told me knowledge of the system but he had installed the system and have them make a copy by Monday. Epstein told me he would call wIllen he had more information. Epstein took me to the desk where the carry on bag was and told me that he believed that the suspect might have gained entry into the house from the sliding glass doors on the south side of the house but not the west s de of house because he had personally locked all the sliders on that side of the house. It is believed that the suspectlalso left the house by the same sliding door that was unlo ked as there were no pry marks or indication of forced entry into the house. Epstein also showed me the bookcase behind the desk where he kept his Glock 9 mm handgun between the books which was now missing. Epstein could not supply me with the serial number for the handgun at this time but advised he would contact Gator Gun on Okeechobee Blvd. to obtain the information did due to his back injury. was 5'10" in height, 250 lbs and a hat. Epstein provided information which was Juan P 1515 South Flagler Dr., Apt. eed to obtain a copy of the uter hard drive in order to that he had limited working ould contact the company who Crime Scene Manager Greg ParkinLn processed the crime scene and collected the envelope that the money had been taken out of. 07/26/17 Page 2416 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Probable Cause Affidavit Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORI# FLO 500600 their vaginal area. He would masturbate during the massage and upon his climaxing, the massage would end. The girls were then paid two or three hundred dollars for the massage. cDri. November 21, 2005 I interviewed Jose Alessi, a former houseman for Jeffrey Epstein. Alessi stated he was employed for eleven years with Mr. Epstein, from approximately 1993 through 2004. Alessi stated he was the house manager, driver and house maintenance person. It was his responsibility to prepare the house for Epstein s arrival. When asked about cooks or assistants, Alessi stated they traveled with Epstein on his private plane. I asked Mr. Alessi about the massages that have occurred at Epstein's home. Alessi stated Epstein receives three massages a day. Each masseuse that visited the house was different. Alessi stated that towards the end of his employment, the masseuses were younger and younger. When asked how young, Mr. Alessi stated they appeared to be sixteen or seventeen years of age at the most. The massages would occur in Epstein's bedroom or bathroom. He knew this because he often set up the massage tables. I asked if there were things going on other than a massage. Alessi stated that there were times towards the end of his employment that he would have to wash off a massager/vibrator and a long rubber penis, which were in the sink after the massage. Additionally, he stated the bed would almost always have to be made after the massage) pn January 4, 2006 I interviewed another former houseman, Mr Alfredo Rodriguez. During a sworn taped statement, Mr. Rodriguez stated he was employed by Jeffrey Epstein for approximately six months, from Tovember 2004 through May of 2005. His responsibilities as house manager included being the butler, auffeur, chef, houseman, run errands for Epstein and provide for Epstein's guests. I asked Rodriguez about masseuses coming to the house. Rodriguez stated Epstein would have two massages a day. Epstein would have one massage in the morning and one massage in the afternoon everyday he was in residence. Rodriguez stated he would be informed to expect someone and make them comfortable until either Sarah Kellen or Epstein would meet with them. Rodriguez stated once the masseuses would arrive, he would allow them entry into the kitchen area and offer them something to drink or eat. They would then be encountered by either Sarah Kellen or Epstein. They would be taken upstairs to provide the massage. I asked Rodriguez if any of the masseuses appeared young in age. Rodriguez stated the girls that would come appeared to be too young to be masseuses. He stated one time under Epstein's direction, he delivered a dozen roses to or one•of the girls that came to provide a massage. He knew the girls were still in high school and were of high school age. I asked Rodriguez about the massages. He felt there was a lot more going on than just massages. He would often clean Mr. Epstein's bedroom after the alleged massages and would discover massagers/vibrators and sex toys scattered on the floor. He also said he would wipe down the vibrators and sex toys and put them away in an armoire. He described the armoire as a small wood armoire which was on the wall close to Epstein's The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed before me this day of May, 2006 by Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me. State of Florida County f Pam Bach Signature/ g Officer Signature of Poli Office (F.S.S. 117.10) Date: 05/01 06 07/26/17 Page 2417 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

"If I were a teenaged abster..." . Last Login: 10,S2005 View More Pics MySpace URL: http://www.myspace.comtakingbackmicrosoft Groups: Lumbeijacks for Lyfe , The UglyHarts . SweetHarts Welcome To SIN CITY.... Military Personal Against Forsake The Troops.info Vie Groups Friend-gpase s. 44 fricndc. Virginia From Zoro Juice www.avapace.tX)11Utatuaguat1mm1usun rage I oi pacc.,-.7c.n1 Hcrn,c, The Web 'O. MySpace Search Fl,., I Brows.: Sccircri Inv I R.7ink• I I Etc.; Favoritcs Fc.rurn Croups sEvcnt:..- f Carr,cz I Mu lc is in your extended network t Elcg Entry [Subscribe to this Nog] [View All Blog Entries] luFlas Alseut-rriei I swear you'll never catch me. Wke-14.1-lika-te-revaet A runaway rodeo clown. http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendID=172831&... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2418 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Displaying of 282 comments (View/Edit All Comments) chuck yeager aint got shit on me My Name is Mud!! 2002 to Present www. myspace. con/ taiongoacx nucroson Page 2 of 12 Status: Has-for Gdestation: Hsmatowni Bady-typo: Ethnicity: Rstigioni Agnostic . Lzedbe Sign: Libra Sinetio/-DrinW, Yes " No Childrsm Someday Edusation 11/12/2005 12:47:00 AM i saw you at the movies the other night with josh everyone said hey to you guys when you were leaving....i was going to come up to you but i didn want to bother you and josh i tried calling you ri after i saw you but my ph one wasnt working....i h to see you when i come down for 11/6/2005 4:15:00 PM Where is ? Maybe The hurricane did blow I away? I hop le comes back so we can smoke i Phat Fatty?Wt In a Relationship Networking Straight Rantoul. Illinois 5 4"' Slim / Slender White / Caucasian Purple Stuff in my 11/2/2005 8:01:00 PM Cup YO I miss ya. where did you disappear too this time??? I hope the Hurricane didnt blow you awa! me up so we can smoke a blunt...peace Dont take life 2 seriously you wont get out alive 10/28/2005 6:18:00 PM Hey whats been Up? How ya been? Hope yo doing good! Peace it r1C- welcome 2 da thunderdome 10/12/2005 7:44:00 PM gettin pretty close to that b-day aren't we? Yo quero matar tu' 10/7/2005 9:13:00 AM perro!! do u even go to school anymore lol. http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofi I e&fri endiD-172831&... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2419 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

ww w. iiryspace. coin/ taiungoaCKIIIICIOSOrt Page 3 of 12 Ugly Ken Hart 10/3/2005 11:10:00 PM SKATI LIWERC LIVE LOW EV 7PM UM FRIG 1 1111 it If cl Th tug PRYING VIRY mum BRAY I PkyRuS $8.013 ADM ON LAKE WORTH RD JUST FOR MORE INFO 81. I WWW.SKAT EZO NEVI BRING IN THIS FLYER FOI chuck yeager aint 9124x20051:41:00 PM got shit on me littp://profile. my sp ace. coin/index. cfm?fuseacti on—user. viewprofile&fri endID=172831&... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2420 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

vvww.nty spaue. cony tatungoaciumcroson Page 4 a 12 i hey what is going on? i havent talked/si you in a million years. im sorry i havent called or anything i have been busy. Some best friend huh' ill make it up to you when i come clown in a couple weeks....that is if you didnt already complete yoct secret plan and move far away lol well ill talk to yz later. chuck 1 ps- your daughter says "hi!" Beef Knuckles 923/2005 8:07:00 AM yo what it is.... hope everything with the camera v. out. Eating Emo Kids 9/22/2005 7:49:00 PM For Breakfast HALLOWEEN HORROR NIGHTS rintunlyinititnituutii<3 (Yon needs to cone) fuck this city in 9/19/2005 7:13:00 PM your mouth HALLOWEEN HORROR NIGH-rs,iininuipumintinnininiumnplinuttti<3 JugGaLOFrEaK 9/19/2005 3:02:00 PM i havent talked to you in forever thanks for the adddddddd hope to see you around my shit :1 Peace. Love. and Lil Green Men. The Cyanide Psycho aka rnEh dr. jack shephard 9/18/2005 7:30:00 PM hiya hup://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=userviewprofile&firiendID-172831&... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2421 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

www.myspace.comnalungoammicroson Page 5 of 12 Teni = AMAZING!!! 9,162005 9:41:00 PM YO YO tivaddup partner...anyway how u been? tal care babe! fuck this city in 9/16/2005 12:30:00 PM your mouth GirL From Ipanema 9/1012005 10:19:00 PM .cake Eating Emo Kids 91 0/2005 11:18:00 AM For Breakfast yous a MARK. <3 fuck this city in 9/9/2005 9:21:00 PM your mouth yous a MARK. <3 http://profi1e.myspace.com/index.cfin?fijseactionuser.viewprofi1e&friendID=1 7283 1&... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2422 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

www.ntyspace.comitaKmgoackmicrosort Page 6 of 12 Mel-Y-ssa I'm pretty sure u disappeared off the face of the muffler fuckin earth...wtf? gimme a call -3 Virginia 9/7/2005 6:57:00 PM helllll000000 womannnnn!!! (c: miss youuuuu! Dont take life 2 seriously you wont get out alive 9/6f2005 11:28:00 AM hey there! -Eric- • beautiful...He Says 9/112005 12:57:00 PM I Arn :1 hello there. great...how have you been since the vacuum? ift Urdu)? /.4.:4.1! Jeff 8130/2005 5:35:00 PM that is going on there Man we should hang out i never see you in schoo Cledus McTavern 8i302005 2:57:00 AM :) who cares :P. just letting you know. http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction-user.yiewprofile&friendl D-172831&... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2423 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

www. my sp ace. corn/ taiongoacicmtcrosort Page 7 of 12 fuck this city in your mouth 8'202005 9:02:00 PM its monday night. 10:23 on the 9th of January... fuck this city in 829/2005 6:50:00 PM your mouth no. its " hey man im in the vet my dogs bout to ge shot" circle trick in yo mouf nigga Leah Jean the 8/29'2005 4:58:00 PM DANCING MACHINE that's good. i wish i was graduating in december t yessssss we should definitely hang out. i actually had a veggie burger for dinner. haha <333 Leah Jean the 8/292005 2:35:00 PM DANCING MACHINE hahha iclk i never liked royal palm. and this schoo seemed really fun and a lot of my friends go there blah blab. did you do the whole graduating early t like chuck or are you still going there? http://profi le. myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friencilD=172831&... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2424 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

www.myspace.COM/xatungoacamicroson Page 8 of 12 Cledus McTavern 8.'2_92005 3.35:00 AM i love you Leah Jean the 8/28/2005 4:38:00 PM DANCING MACHINE flItIfIfIltIII fuck this city in 8,21/2005 7:06:00 PM your mouth <333 preston77 8/11/2005 9:04:00 AM I was just on the phone with you. crrrrazy. http ://profi le. myspace. com/index. cfm?fuse action—user. vi ewprofile&fri en dID=172831&... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2425 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

www.myspace.commuungoacKmicrosolt Page 9 of 12 fuck this city in 8 7 2005 9:51:00 PM your mouth i <3 ju . MARK! KAYTLYN MARIE 8/6/2005 5:31:00 PM 'here have you BEEN!?? Ugty Ken Hart 8/2/2005 11:35:00 PM Okay. so the older link dosent work. Lest try this again... The voting for the Skatezone Battle of the Bands back on. So. I suggest you go to the Skatezone S and go vote for The UglyHarts fucking now! Skatezoneunderground.com Ugly Ken Hart 8/2/2005 10:00:00 PM The voting for the Skatezone Battle of the Bands back on. So. I suggest you go to the Skatezone S and go vote for The UglyHarts fucking now! Ugly Ken Hart 729,2005 1:00:00 AM http://profile.myspace. com/index.cfm fuseaction—user.viewprofi I e& fri en d1D-172831&... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2426 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

www.myspace.comitatungoacKnucroson Page 10 of 12 SKATE3 UNDERGE LIVE LOCAL EVERY FRIDA 7Phil - 1 WIIAJ All Dif HIM INKORI Pi RANDOM RANG110 io THE UGLY sam SR 00 ALVAISSI• ON LAKE WORTH RD JUST WES FOR MORE INFO & DIREI INWW.SKATEZONEUNOEI BRING IN THIS FLYER FOR S1.. 7126/2005 7:04:00 PM i misses me wife =1 imCORE 7262005 6:13:00 AM heey thanks for the add...whats up? V http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friend172831&... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2427 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

www.myspace.comitaxingoacmicrosott Page 11 of 12 Steven Andrew 7/25/2005 8:27:00 PM I WIN !tn Mel-Y-ssa 7/23/2005 7:36:00 PM I miss my Ugly Ken Hart 7,21,2005 11:28:00 PM CLICK HERE And vote for The UglyHarts in the b of the bands at Skatezone. 7/19/2005 6:38:00 PM Hey How's your summer goin? the traaic tale of 7.17'2005 8:01:00 PM you and me cool cool. I went with Evelyn to Barnes and Noble http://profile.myspace. com/index.cfm?fuseaction-- -user.viewprofile&friendID=172831&... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2428 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

www.myspace.comitakingbackmicrosoll Page 12 of 12 midnight. It was nuts. there was so many people there. We were like the 5th people to get it thougl- The next s2s show is this Thursday actually. but it Pompano. It should be good though. I miss our cc meetings too. We should go sometime this weekl you're not busy. Bye. the tragic tale of T 16 2005 9:55:00 AM you and me did you get the new Harry Potter book yet Virginia 7/12/2005 8:50:00 AM what's your email address these days? i have a b that i think you'd like— Cledus McTavern 710/2005 3:19:00 AM . your number one in my phone list :) About' FAQ ] Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips 1 Contact Myspace I Promote!! Advertise I MySpace Shop ©2003 MySpace.com. All Rights Reserved. http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=-user.viewprofile&friendif172831&... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2429 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

amp;hearts;'s Friends... (91) Juice Just remem.. ht,,www, flif et* matt Lisa MOREt.. Tababooya amanda samatha &h.. COLOSSUS Infelicitous 13P:a"7.tCs, 1177 51<yl.ER Mr. Johans.. Dorothy Ma.. Dont take .. Ugly Ken H.. Beef Knuck. Deus ex Ma.. Airr. Yippydooda As Autumn .. Hank China.. Simply Com.. sear A.D.°, Am .. The Basta'. Lviyoptu;e.tx..nu Page 1 of 2 MySpace.com I Home The Web MySpace _ Search Get the next genetation of IM Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank 1 Mail 1 Slog I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music Back amp;hearts;'s Profile View All Friends Listing 1-40 of 91 1 2 3 of 3 h ttp://ho me8. my sp ace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. viewfriends&friendID=172831&u... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2430 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

iviyspace.00111 Page 2 of 2 0 quer° get on you- iniCORE MIKE Listing 1-40 of 91 1 2 3 of 3 About I FAQ I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Myspace I Promote! I Advertise I MySpace Shop 02003-2005 MvSoace.com All Rights Reserved. http://home8.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewfriends&friendID=172831&u... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2431 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

r 0 WAKE UP TH.. encyclopedia My Name is.. SUPER RAD .. GirL From .. Ginger sam Dick Painter John Jeff Brian The Fight .. Christina. Be Quiet a.. )h SatirriY- Mel-Y-ssa (la otAAAVY Dat Freaki., Another Da.. Fixious Miss Nary Keith ChicaCherr.. Will (SCR.. Jenny &hea.. Shannon 1VlySpaCe.COrn Page 1 of 2 MySpace.co.m I Home The Web MySpace Search I Get the next generation of 1M Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog I Favorites Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music Back to ip;amp;hearts;'s Profile View All Friends Listing 41-80 of 91 1 2 3 of 3 tamp;amp;hearts;'s Friends... (91) http://home8.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction—user.viewfriends&UserName=ashley%... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2432 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

PIMP JUICE Cledus McT.. Jay the AZ.. Heather THIZZ OR DIE Big Chris 0fl wiysinwe.uum Page 2 of 2 Listing 41-80 of 91 1 2 3 of 3 About I FAQ I Terms Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Mvspace j Promote! I Advertise I MySpace Shop ©2003-n1/5MvSoace.com All Rights Reserved http://home8.myspace.comJindex.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewfriends&UserName—ashley%... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2433 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Corey Sed Kevin LoWeR BaCk.. KAYTLYN CRISTINA MA.. fuck this .. beautiful... Katie CaNt G.. Online Nees! myspace.com Page 1 of 1 MvSpace.com Home The Web MySpace • Search CWeight Watchers Small steps c ,a;i.d Take your first step today. ► Learn More Now Online Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog I Favorites I Forum Groups I Events I Games I Music Back t lamp;amp;hearts;'s Profile View All Friends Listing 81-91 of 91 1 2 3 of 3 amp;amp;amp;hearts;'s Friends... (91) Listing 81-91 of 91 1 2 3 of 3 About I FAQ I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Myspace I Promote! I Advertise I MySpace Shop ®2003-2005 MySpace.com All Rights Reserved. http://home8.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewfriends&UserName=ashley%... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2434 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

iviyspaee.ewn Page 1 of 17 MySpace.com I Home The Web MySpace SearchA Help I S gnOut j myspace Move services online. a place for friends Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music I Classifieds Back to Profile , View Comments Listing 1-50 of 284 1 2 3 4 5» of 6 Next > Dick Painter N Nov 23, 2005 8:25 PM Shut up! UnderCoverLovery Nov 22, 2005 4:31 PM aye girl! long time no talk. i see u around school somtimes but not lately. I LOVE YOUR HAIR !! i lost your number UGH anyways alex echiverria called me up like 10 min ago tryin to get ahold of u i guess hes at some crazy party with all kinda of alcohol and probably mary jane. call that nukka up tonite. 561 667 9991 later xoxo Kayla V chuck yeager aint got shit on me Nov 12, 2005 12:47 AM i saw you at the movies the other night with josh and everyone said hey to you guys when you were leaving....i was going to come up to you but i didnt want to bother you and josh i tried calling you right after I saw you http://www.myspace,com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&Mytoketreddb34230-1d91-40a3 -9837,, • 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2435 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

myspace.com Page 2 of 17 tlili• 4 OFINNESS ur /i but my ph one wasnt working....i hope to see you when i come down for My Name is Mud!! kii 11111 Nov 6, 2005 4:15 PM Where Is , Maybe The hurricane did blow her away? I hope she comes back so we can smoke a Big Phat Fatty!!!!! Purple Stuff in my Cup Nov 2, 2005 8:01 PM YO I miss ya, where did you disappear too this time??? I hope the Hurricane didnt blow you away. Hit me up so we can smoke a blunt...peace I I II ifil "Built 2 Spill"-, Oct 28, 2005 6:18 PM Hey vhats been Up? How ya been? Hope your doing good! Peace It Eric- welcome 2 da thunderdome Oct 12, 2005 7:44 PM gettin pretty close to that b-day aren't we? http://wwvv. my space. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. viewComments&friend1D=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423 c-1d91-40a3 -9837... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2436 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

• Oct 7, 2005 9:13 AM do u even go to school anymore lol. Ugly Ken Her Oct 3, 2005 11:10 PM http: //www: mysp ace. com/index, cfm?fuseaction=user. viewComments&friendID=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423c-1d9 I -40a3.9837::' 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2437 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

SKATIEMPE LIREERCROURE LIVE LOCAL RANDS WIRY RUDA? NIGHT 7I4M 11IPM ir14. 11 , Ci iLiR TheUg yHarts limocRAGY FRY MUCH MAYIIIPP SIRAY BOMB rRYROS MAWS WOO ADMISSION ON LAKE WORTH RD JUST WEST OF THE TURNPIKE FOR MORE I NFO & DIRECTIONS GO TO WWW SKATEZONEUND ERGROUND.COM BRING IN THIS FLYER FOR $1.0C OFF ADMISSION myspace.com Page 4 of 17 http://www.myspace.com/index.cfefuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423c-ld91-40a3-9837... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2438 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

myspace.com Page 5 of 17 chuck Yeager aint got shit on me Sep 24, 2005 1:41 PM 1 hey what is going on? i havent talked/seen you in a million years. im sorry i havent called or anything I have been busy. Some best friend huh? 101 ill make it up to you when i come down In a couple weeks....that is if you didnt already complete yoour secret plan and move far away lol well ill talk to ya later. chuck :) ps- your daughter says "hi!" i's t, INNESSi. W.W.I. „A' Beef Kul N.K. k ..f., Sep 23, 2005 8:07 AM yo what it is.... hope everything with the camera works out. AIMillai F i II gMI I I I I i n Eating Emo Kids For Breakfast ,.,.,. Sep 22, 2005 7:49 PM HALLOWEEN HORROR NIGHTS!!!!!!!Mmiiiitiwillimilitiintiniitiiiiiii !!<3 (yordan needs to come) .1:1r-i."' ,., ,A,.. 4 fuck this city in your mouth Sep 19, 2005 7:13 PM HALLOWEEN HORROR NIGHTstniinuiluniumininillipluintuilliinn JugGaL0FrEaK Sep 19, 2005 3:02 PM http://www.myspace.com/indexcfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendM=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423c-1d91-40a3-9837,., 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2439 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

myspace. corn Page 6 of 17 r r4.-,.:, i havent talked to you in forever thanks for the adddddddd hope to see you around my shit ;) Peace, Love, and Lil Green Men, The Cyanide Psycho aka mEh dr. jack shephard P4 Sep 18, 2005 7:30 PM hiya Her Smile is Amazing! Sep 16, 2005 9:41 PM YO YO waddup partner...anyway how u been? take care babe! ,., a fuck this city in your mouth Sep 16, 2005 12:30 PM http : //www. my sp ace. com/i ndex. cfm?fuseaction=user.vi ewComments&fri endD=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423 c-1d91 -40a3 -9837... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2440 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

niwspace.com Page 7 of 17 GirL From Ipanema Sep 10, 2005 10:19 PM Eating Emo Kids For Breakfast 10- Sep 10, 2005 11:18 AM yous a MARK. <3 fuck this city in your mouth • . Sep 9, 2005 9:21 PM yous a MARK. <3 http: //www. my sp ace. com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423c-1d91-400 -9837... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2441 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

rage o Mel-Y-ssa --- Llfas ar, I'm Iristi Sep 9, 2005 1:04 PM I'm pretty sure u disappeared off the face of the muther fuckin earth...wtf? gimme a call :) <3 Virginia Sep 7, 2005 6:57 PM hellIll000000 womannnnifil! (c; miss youuuuul ... "Built 2 Spill's, Sep 6, 2005 11:28 AM hey there! -Eric- Angelic One C. Sep 1, 2005 12:57 PM :) hello there. great...how have you been since the vacuum? Jeff Aug 30, 2005 5:35 PM http: //www.myspace, com/index.cfinffuseaction=user,viewComments&friendID=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423c-ld91-406 -9837, .. 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2442 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

iviyspace.com Page 9 of 17 ,e.''' - elf,:,..,,. 0 TA .;,, ,,. , 1h e a u t t i s i never there. ' Man we should seeyou in school. Cledus McTavern Aug 30, 2005 2:57 AM :) who cares :P, just letting you know. [ b= fuck this city in your mouth , — 4 b Aug 29, 2005 9:02 PM its monday night, 10:23 on the 9th of January... fuck this city in your mouth 4 w Aug 29, 2005 6:50 PM no, its " hey man im in the vet my dogs bout to get shot" circle trick in yo mouf nigga http://www. my sp ace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.vi ewC omments&fri en d1113=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423 c-1d91 -40a3 -9837... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2443 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

myspace. corn Page 10 of 17 Leah Jean the DANCING MACHINE Aug 29, 2005 4:58 PM that's good. i wish i was graduating in december haha yessssss we should definitely hang out. i actually just had a veggie burger for dinner. haha <333 F I i ' Leah Jean the DANCING MACHINE Aug 29, 2005 2:35 PM hahha idk i never liked royal palm. and this school seemed really fun and a lot of my friends go there abd blah blah. did you do the whole graduating early thing like chuck or are you still going there? ' • 14:, Cledus McTavern Aug 29, 2005 3:35 AM I love you http://vvww. mysp ace. com/index. cfefuseaction=user.vievvComments&friendLD=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423c-Id91-40a3 -9837. „ 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2444 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

iwyspace.COM Page 11 of 17 Leah Jean the DANCING MACHINE Aug 28, 2005 4:38 PM II 111!111111 11 11 11 11 11 II II 11 11 11 II IIII II II II Hp Ill 11 11 11 11 11)1111 III II I 111 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 1111 11 11 11 111$11111 II 11 II fuck this city in your mouth Aug 21, 2005 7:06 PM <333 preston77 Aug 11, 2005 9:04 AM I was just on the phone with you. crrrrazy. http://www. myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. yiewComments&friendID=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423c-1d91-40a3 -9837... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2445 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 12 of 17 ..;5 fuck this city in your mouth ..._ Aug 7, 2005 9:51 PM i <3 ju.... MARKI KAYTLYN MARIE Aug 6, 2005 5:31 PM where have you BEEN!?? - ..„ Ugly Ken Hart Aug 2, 2005 11:35 PM Okay, so the older link dosent work. Lest try this again... The voting for the Skatezone Battle of the Bands Is back on. So, I suggest you go to the Skatezone Site, and go vote for The UglyHarts fucking now! Skatezoneunderground.com i Onlir* N.,).0 Ugly Ken Hart Aug 2, 2005 10:00 PM The voting for the Skatezone Battle of the Bands is back on. So, I suggest you go to the Skatezone Site, and go vote for The http;//www,myspace.com/index,cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423c-1d91.40a3.9837,,: 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2446 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

r.1:r. ri myspace.corn Page 13 of 17 UglyHarts fucking now! Ugly Ken Hart Jul 29, 2005 1:00 AM http://www.my space. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. viewComments&friendID=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423c-1d91-40a3 -9837., • 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2447 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

SKATEZONE UNDERGROUND LIVE LOCAL RANDS EVERY FRIDAY NIGHT 7PM - 11PM 14A YAUGUS I MI HEIST INKORI RANDOM Giggst "IRANGliD 10 TM"- THE UGLY HARTS MOO ADMISSION ON LAKE WORTH RD JUST WEST. OF THE TURNPIKE OR MORE INFO & DIRECT IONS GO TO VVWW.SIUITEZONEUNDERGROUND.COM BRING IN THIS FLYER FOR S1.00 OFF ADMISSION sam Jul 26, 2005 7:04 PM http://www. my spac e. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friencilD=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423c-ld91-400-9837... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2448 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

ti 4 i misses me wife =1 imCORE .. . — 41 Jul 26, 2005 6:13 AM heey thanks for the add...whats up? • Steven Andrew IFI .4*- ..11V. .,. ;"•-,.-, 1- _ ---.0e, Jul 25, 2005 8:27 PM I WIN!!!!! Mel-Y-ssa Jul 23, 2005 7:36 PM I miss my ashley :( http://www.myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423 c-1d91-40a3 -9837... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2449 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

rage to or 1/ .. 'k 7 SC relit t Ugly Ken Hart Jul 21, 2005 11:28 PM CLICK HERE And vote for The UglyHarts in the battle of the bands at Skatezone. ...... .1N Jul 19, 2005 6:38 PM Hey How's your summer goin? the tragic tale of you and me • , 1,1 in - es60' Jul 17, 2005 8:01 PM cool cool. I went with Evelyn to Barnes and Noble at midnight. It was nuts, there was so many people there. We were like the 5th people to get it though. The next s2s show is this Thursday actually, but its in Pompano. It should be good though. I miss our coffee meetings too. We should go sometime this week? If you're not busy. Bye. the tragic tale of Jul 16, 2005 9:55 AM http://www. mysp ace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendED=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423c-1d91-40a3 -9837... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2450 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

you and me tt, Online tJcanr? _, did you get the new Harry Potter book yet?? Jul 12, 2005 8:50 AM what's your email address these days? i have a blog that i think you'd like--- Listing 1-50 of 284 1 2 3 4 5» of 6 Next > Virginia Ivry space. corn Page 17 of 17 Add Comment About l FAQ I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Myspace I Promote! I Advertise I Mypace Shop ©2003.2005 MySDace.com All Rights Reserved. http://www.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&Mytoken=ddb3423c-ld91-40a3-9837... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2451 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

41.51,, a SOL .I.. -Ir MySpace.com I Home The Web MySpace Search Help I SignOut amyspacefamw-iioiie services online. a place for friends I Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank Mail I Blog I Favorites I Forum Groups I Events I Games I Music I Classifieds Back to Profile , View Comments Listing 51-100 of 284 1. 2 3 4 5 >> of 6 < Previous Next > Cledus Mclavern Jul 10, 2005 3:19 AM your number one In my phone list :) 1 q k D Jul 6, 2005 10:08 PM what is up nigge its been a long time, give me a call some day — ,,, ...., ' ,...- r alwribil' ....L.F=.:.. NI 9isa geese-ah Jul 6, 2005 6:19 PM http: //www. mysp ace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. yiewCo mments&fri enclID=172831&page=1&Mytoken=09B3DE8B-B3F... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2452 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

myspace. corn Page 2 of 14 AtIP ttS DK u.6 .... Z. i hope that you have : ,:,, _a very very Very very p aril' ,:.. -..., i. 4, va ii. •,- '' , . ko COLOSSUS Jul 6, 2005 12:15 PM Suffocate X Faster xDeathstarx Too Pure To Die Our Battle plus 3 more 10 bucks july 8th. this friday ! Ginger Jul 6, 2005 10:56 AM Thanks for stopping at work to see me. ;) I went to the beach again last night with Tony Dlaz. The police picked us up though. They didn't like us swimming with the sea turtles. Juno is a 24 hour beach. We watched the sunrise. Beautiful. How's your summer? V A. :- Virginia Jul 5, 2005 1:21 PM http://www. mysp ace. co m/i ndex. cfefuse action=user. vi ewC omments&fri enclID=172831&p age=1&Mytok en=09133DE813-B3E „ 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2453 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

rage J Ul 141 - < some whores, i swear. i give you full permision to treat that female in any way you see fit. you can be my ambassador since I'm in california and you are right there where i wish i was... (c; Girl. From Ipanema Jul 2, 2005 7:19 PM so maybe you AReNt alive? 1..., " .... ., Girl From Ipanema Jul 1, 2005 10:08 PM ah I u ARE alive... i havent really talked 2 u for a while except our brief direction discussion about la mancha park.... Steven Andrew t. 111164 .,.„., ,,it .!..:•_1 Jun 29, 2005 9:50 PM so if u dont kno who this is its steven, remember me now? hows your summer been? Lisa geese-a h Jun 28, 2005 7:47 AM How is your summer going . 717117 <3 http://www. my sp ace. co miindex, cfmffuseaction=user, vi ewC onunents&fri endID=1 72 8 3 1 &p age=i&Mytok en=09B 3 DE8B-B3 F 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2454 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.corn Page 4 of 14 --1 ,-- 4 tito.-- / Virginia . . er Jun Jun 26, 2005 10:17 PM playing hide and go seek in cars, now that fucking rocks, you're so my favorite soon to be legal female. (c; MWAH! Oat Freakin' Rican Jun 24, 2005 8:18 PM My beautiful , where have u been?1?! HoW u been lately? I hope ur enjoying ur summer! Hopefully i'll talk 2 u soon...ttyl xoxo - Surge <3 ---.. --' ... '-e' kr , 51<y1£11 , . ., Jun 23, 2005 12:57 AM You check this thing all the time but you haven't changed anything in months, what gives? Virginia Jun 22, 2005 5:13 PM http://www.myspace. com/ind ex. cfm?fuseaction=user. viewComments&friendID=172831&page=1&Mytoken=09B3DE8B -B3F. „ 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2455 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 2 of 2 so when are we gonna make out an shit?<3 WAtirEtt Dorothy January 7, 2005 2:33 PM Mantooth fabulous ' \ - About I FAO I Terms I Privacy 1 Safety Tips I Contact Myspace Promote! I Advertise I MySpace Shop C2003-2005 MySpace.com All Rights Reserved. http://viewmorepics.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=viewlmage&friend172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2456 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

My space. corn Page 1 of 3 MySpace.com I Home The Web MySpace ' _ Search Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Poo I Favorites Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music Back to Picture Index Back to Profile myspace pic to the max, eh garth? Post a Comment I E-Mail to a Friend Previous I Next > Listing 1 - 8 of 8 From Comment sears September 1, 2005 5:43 PM wow fukin beautiful March 4, 2005 5:16 PM pretty girl. Dorothy Mantooth http ://vi ewmorepi cs. myspace. corn/index cfm? fuseacti on—yr ewIrnage&fri en dID= I 7283 I ... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2457 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 2 of 3 Beef Knuckles January 19, 2005 4:01 PM hey now I'm mentioned in 2 descriptions for your pics bbabbabababABABABABABABAA the tragic tale of January 15, 2005 12:48 PM you and me I like this picture :) Juice January 8, 2005 11:35 AM bowwwwwwinkles <3 HOTT WANrEV Juice January 8, 2005 11:35 AM bowwwwwwinkles <3 HOTT WAUTEC Lisa January 7, 2005 12:02 PM MOREtoWHORE http://vi ewmorepi cs. mysp ace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction—viewlmage&fri en dID=17283 I ... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2458 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 3 of 3 EVER SO SWEET chuck yeager January 6, 2005 10:24 PM aint got shit on your so freakin myspaceXcore 101 just kiddin'. nice me pits About I FAQ Terms! Privacy 1 Safety Tips Contact Myspace I Promote! I Advertise 1 MySpace Shop 11 1 - LL • 2 C • II ' • I, - k - • http://vi ewmorepics.myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=viewImage8cfriend172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2459 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 1 of 2 The Web fe, MySpace MySpace.com j Home r ... .0 0 AR*14 ea Search Connects to any checking account No monthly fees or minimums H5. hsb Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank Mail I Blog I Favorites Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music Back to Picture Index Back to Profile the things they can talk me into. Post a Comment I E-Mail b a Friend < Previous I Next > Listing 1 - 2 of 2 From Comment Dorothy March 4, 2005 5:17 PM http://viewmorepics.myspace. com/index.cfm?fuseaction=viewImage&friend172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2460 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.corn Page 2 of 2 t4antooth it don't mean a thing... preston77 February 21, 2005 7:35 PM ...if it ain't got that swing. About FAQ I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Myspace I Promote! I Advertise I MySpace Shop ©2003-2005 My$pace.com M Rights Reserved. http://viewmorepics.myspace.corn/index_cfin?fuseaction=viewlmage&friendID=172831... 1 1 /14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2461 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 1 of 2 MySpace.com I Home The Web iii) MySpace (__) Search 64.00 Connects to any checking account O' No monthly fees or minimums Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog I Favorites I Forum Groups 1 Events I Games Music Back to Picture Index Back to Profile <3 Leah. Chucks mean. Vegetarians rock. Post a Comment E-Mail to a Friend < Previous I Next > Listing 1 - 4 of 4 From Comment Dick Painter April 20, 2005 7:27 PM hap llyiewmorepi cs myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=viewlmage&friendll 72831_ 11/1 4/2005 07/26/17 Page 2462 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace. com Page 2 of 2 Vegetarians suck dick, oops thats too much meat for them tasteless I am. Leah Jean the April 19, 2005 2:27 PM DANCING " LOOOVEE YOUUU!!! wow i thought i left MACHINE a comment but i guess i didn't. look how sad/weird i look. ha. <3 Dorothy March 3, 2005 11:06 AM Mantooth you guys are so pretty. sam February 22, 2005 12:49 AM harry potter! <3likewhoa, baby. About I FAO I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Myspace I Promote! I Advertise I MySpace Shop 02003-2005 MySpace.com All Rights Reserved. http://viewmorepics.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=viewImage&friendID-172831.. I 1 /14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2463 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

MySpace.com I Home The Web MySpace Search Myspace. com Page 1 of 2 Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music Back to Picture Index Back to Protile on the way to sticking out my tongue. Post a Comment I E-Mail to a Friend < Previous I Next > Listing 1 - 2 of 2 From Comment January 8, 2005 1:36 PM http://viewmorepics.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction--viewImage&friend172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2464 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 2 of 2 so when are we gonna make out an shit?<3 NIAtfrE0 Dorothy January 7, 2005 2:33 PM Mantooth fabulous About I FAQ I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Mvspace I Promote! I Advertise r MySpace Shop C12003-2005 MySpace.com M Rights Reserved. http://viewmorepics.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=viewlmage&friendLD=172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2465 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 1 of 3 MySpace.com I Home The Web lm MySpace C) Search Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog f Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events Games Music Back to Picture Index Back to Profile myspace pic to the max, eh garth? Post a Comment I E-Mail to a Friend Previous I Next > Listing 1 - 8 of 8 From Comment sean September 1, 2005 5:43 PM wow fukin beautiful March 4, 2005 5:16 PM pretty girl. Dorothy Mantooth http ://vi ewmorepics. myspace. com/index cfm?fuseaction—viewlmage& fri en dID=172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2466 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 2 of 3 Beef Knuckles January 19, 2005 4:01 PM hey now I'm mentioned in 2 descriptions for your pics bbabbabababABABABABABABAA the tragic tale of January 15, 2005 12:48 PM you and me I like this picture :) Juice January 8, 2005 11:35 AM bowwwwwwinkles <3 HOTT VVAIITE0 Juice January 8, 2005 11:35 AM bowwwwwwinkles <3 HOTT VMN"Tco Lisa January 7, 2005 12:02 PM MOREtoWEIORE. http://viewmorepics. mysp ace. co m/in dex chit? fuseacti on—vi ewImage&fri en dID=172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2467 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 3 of 3 EVER SO SWEET chuck yeager January 6, 2005 10:24 PM aint got shit on your so freakin myspaceXcore lol just kidchn'. nice me pits About I FAO I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Myspace I Promote! i Advertise I MySpace Shop 02003-2005 MySoace.com All Rights Reserved http://viewmorepics.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=-viewlmage&friendIL172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2468 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

lvly spd. e. will Page 1 ot 1 MySpace.com I Home The Web MySpace _ Search Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music Pictures of ashley fucking davisV: Click Picture for F myspace pic to the max, eh garth? on the way to sticking out my tongue. <3 Leah. Chucks mean. Vegetarians rock. the things tl »Post a Comment »E-Mail to a Friend »Post a Comment »E-Mail to a Friend »Post a Comment »E-Mail to a Friend »Post a Cc »E-Mail to 8 Comment(s) 2 Comment(s) 4 Comment(s) 2( »Post a Comment »E-Mail to a Friend Watching the sprinting valet boys with my wife, »Post a Comment 2 Comment(s) »E-Mail to a Friend 2 Comment(s) About I FAQ I Terms' Privacy! Safety Tips I Contact Myspace I Promote! I Advertise I MvSpace Shop ©2003-2005 MySpace.com All Rights Reserved. http://vi ewmo rep i cs. myspace. coin/index. cfm?fuseacti on=user.vi ewPicture&fri en dID=17... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2469 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

• .:.WHFAig.vFn.jvliNuTEs`' $39.99 A MONTH PLUS TAXES AND FEES ..p GET MOF Myspace.com Page 1 of 2 ivlySpace.com I Home The Web Li13-, MySpace Search j Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music Back to Picture Index Back to Profile Watching the the sprinting valet boys with my wife. Post a Comment E-Mail to a Friend < Previous I Next Listing 1 - 2 of 2 From Comment Virginia April 24, 2005 6:50 PM beautiful pic ash--you look... amazing. April 24, 2005 3:54 PM crazy earings. nice. preston77 http://vi ewmo repi cs. mysp ace. com/index. cfm?faseacti ewImage&fri en dID=172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2470 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 2 of 2 About I FAO I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Mvspace j Promote! I Advertise I MvSpace Shop ©2003-2005 MvSpace.com All Rights Reserved. http://vi evvmorepics. myspace. corn/index. ant?fiseaction=viewImage&friendlE172831... 11/1 4/2005 07/26/17 Page 2471 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 1 of 2 MySpace.com I Home The Web (®• MySpace Search I a (Mini career Opmardt19 GET YOUR DEGREE IN Organizational Psychology & Development Bachelor's in 13 MONTHS:* Master's in 10 MONTHS. LEARN MORE! Home I Browse I Search Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog i Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games i Music Back to Picture Index Back to Profile Post a Comment I E-Mail to a Friend I < Previous I Next > Listing 1 - 2 of 2 From Comment sam February 22, 2005 12:48 AM are you too cool for two eyes? hmmmm missy? are you?! February 13, 2005 8:46 PM Just remember lel. Ninjas make terrible pancakes http://viewmorepics.myspace. com/index.cfm?fuseaction—viewlmage&friendID-17283 I ... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2472 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com rage Z of Z About' FAO I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Mvspace i Promote! I Advertise MySpace Shop ©2003-2005 Mvspace.com All Rights Reserved. http://viewmorepics.myspace.com/index_ cfin?fuseaction---viewlmage&frienci172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2473 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

nayspace.corn Page 5 of 14 Iri i love that "play russian roulette as we kiss"— what's it from? efr- e', Jun 19, 2005 4:21 PM well hello there my favorite next door neighbor well i havnt talked to you in a while hows everything in the boonies Yo quero meter tu' perro!! Jun 19, 2005 10:48 AM hey there, havent seen/talked to u in a while so i figured I would drop a comment. hows ur summer going? 1 • r , ... Mr. Jona kJ7 .7.-n . I 40 Jun 18, 2005 1:53 PM well hello __ .._, how r u, what did u get on mirana's exam?? Jenny e Jun 17, 2005 3:10 PM http://www mysp ace. co mfindex, cfm?fuse action=user. vi ewCo mments&fri endID=1 72 8 3 l&page-184Mytoken=09133DE8B-B311:: 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2474 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

myspace.com Page 6 of 14 ..,.: hey 11111 *waves back* .. hehe Jeff , A Jun 14, 2005 4:25 PM hello there yeah you where a pretty tight neighbor to, give me a ring This is goodbye Jun 13, 2005 11:56 PM Hey whats the deal yo tell suga foot to give me a call call him a Mark for me $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ My Name is Mud!! Jun 13, 2005 8:31 PM Where is ? I guess she has gone into Hibernation. Maybe she flew North for the summer? Well where ever she is I hope she comes around soon to smoke a Big Phat Blunt hap; //www.myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. viewComments&fri endLD=1 728 3 l&page=1 &Mytoken=09B 3 DESB -B 3 F: „ 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2475 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

rage / 01 1`F or a Big Phat Bowl... MUD!!! get on your knees now .. ,. Jun 12, 2005 8:43 AM he , hope ur summer is goin ok. better be staying out of trouble... ; ) miss ya! Purple Stuff in my Cup Jun 11, 2005 9:24 PM Hey Babe.... I MISS YOU!!!! Hit me up so we can smokey tokey, ya no wat i mean...1o' Come work with me A.s.a.p...I think were gonna need you this week... Call me on Mon. Mornin...lata i...._. ”.. Itil. Dick Painter Jun 9, 2005 12:51 PM Again I say LIARI , Fatty McPatty Jun 8, 2005 7:27 AM i give lip spliting hugs http://wwvv.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&page=1&Mytoken=09B3DE8B-B3F, „ 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2476 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

My Name is Mud!! Jun 5, 2005 9:51 PM Hits From the BONG.. Lyrics By: Cypress Hill Hits from the Bong Hits from the Bong Hits from the Bong Hits from the Bong Pick it Pack It Fire it up, come along And take a hit from the bong Put the blunt down Just for a second Don't get me wrong It's not a new method Inhale Exhale Just got an ounce in the mail I like a blunt or a big fat cone But my Double-Barrel Bong Is gettin' me stoned I'm skill it There's water inside don't spill it It smells like shit on the carpet Still It Goes down smooth when I get a clean hit Of the Skunky, Phunky, Smelly Green Shit Sing my song Puff all night long As I take hits from the Bong Hits from the Bong y'all Hits from the Bong tvryspace. COM Page 8 of 14 http://www.my space. corn/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&fri endID=172831&page=l&Mytoken=09B3DE8B-B3F... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2477 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 9 of 14 Gonna get high Hits from the Bong Gonna get high Hits from the Bong Gonna get high Hits from the Bong Gonna get high Let's smoke that bowl Hit the Bong And then take that finger off of that hole Plug it Unplug it Don't strain I love you Mary Jane She never complains When I hit mary With that flame I light up the cherry She's so good to me When I pack a fresh bowl I clean the screen Don't get me stirred up The smoke, through the bubbling water Is makin' it pure so I got to Take my hit and hold it Just like Chong I get the bowl and I reload it Get my four-footer and bring it on As I take hits from the Bong Hlts from the Bong Gonna get high Hits from the Bong Gonna get high Hits from the Bong Gonna get high Hits from the Bong Gonna get high Hits from the Bong Gonna get high Hits from the Bong Gonna get high Hits from the Bong Straighten your Dick out Hits From the Bong http : //www. space: com/index, cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&fri endID=1728318tpage=1&Mytok eri=09B3DE8B -BO 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2478 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 10 of 14 Jun 5, 2005 9:00 PM verrrrrry awesome ash--- I'm proud of you--- glad that you finally found someone worth hanging on to... that's hard to do. (c; (ps: what hair story? lol) Virginia Jun 5, 2005 6:50 PM look what i did? and this time it wasn't on accident and i wasn't running to the store 15 minutes before it closed, 2 hours before i had to be to work, in order to fix it. (c; how you beeee? preston77 Jun 5, 2005 4:21 PM well that's not exactly what I meant. You're not a letdown, but you not showing up was. That's all. I hope your night was okay. .. 1 A I -. Jun 5, 20052:15 PM You definately did not show up. Tsk tsk. . Such a letdown. Be Quiet an Drive Jun 2, 2005 8:39 PM wut up _„ how u been? U HEARD THAT PTW cd yet ? Its pretty good, we should go blaze some time 3583319, whenever u wanna blaze hit me up http: //www. my sp ace. com/index. cfm?fuse action=user. viewComments&fri endID=172831&p age=l&Myto k en=09B3DE8B-B3F. „ 12/2J2005 07/26/17 Page 2479 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

•, WAKE UP THE DEAD May 31, 2005 7:15 PM y0000 y dldnt u stay 2day ?...we started like right after u left...oh well...sorry I didnt hear u saying hi i thought i was just hearing shit...and i went into D's but derrick said u quit...hut anyways talk 2 u later Purple Stuff in my Cup May 31, 2005 11:33 AM Oh now I remember How do you like the Cd? Just remember who you heard it from first o.k....lata Purple Stuff in my CUP May 31, 2005 11:31 AM Hey beautiful...Wats goin on, I think you just called me a little bit ago but i was sleepin.srry..I was gonna ask you something but i just forgot?rmw/e I'll talk to you soon enough...lata 1111. .c .„/ II Billy Baron May 30, 2005 7:14 PM When you learn to sew you will be ready for marriage. It's not hard. I'm sure they have womens groups dedicated to teaching all the necessary skills for finding a suitable husband. http://www.myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendM=172831&page=1&Mytoken=09B3DE8B-B3F. 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2480 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Lvly N./a4.x. rage 1 z or 14 • 0: Skills like cooking, cleaning, sewing, shuting the fuck up, not talking unless spoken to, averting her eyes to the floor when a man is in the room. These will help you. WAKE UP THE DEAD ,F 11, May 30, 2005 8:37 AM hey I saw u again....0 should talk more and stuff...i/m me if u want...N0bobFX...later iGreen May 29, 2005 2:29 PM good seeing you <3 preston77 May 24, 2005 8:49 PM eh ess aytch el ee why. i At :-', 4.0i,., WAKE UP THE DEAD May 23, 2005 7:30 PM wow i didnt even think u were still in school...I never see u anymore...until 2day when u stuck ur tongue out at me lol....it was nice seeing u...later http : //www. my sp ace. co m/i ndex. cfrn? fuse action=user. vi ewComments&fri en dID=172831&p age=l&Mytok en=09B3DE8B-B3F ... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2481 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

myspace. corn Page 13 of 14 — , Purple Stuff in my Cup May 22, 2005 8:50 AM .c Hey Baby wassup. Im just gettin ready for Ill b Wills moms wedding right now, but i just wanted to say Hi, and tomm. Is my b-day.Woo hoo...ailght Babe I'll talk to ya soon. Lata Be Quiet an Drive May 15, 2005 7:14 PM hey wuts up . , how u doin? u gonna be in class tomorrow, probably not , but wte, hows that c.d. its the shit right? i jus downloaded the 4 best song from them''and i dreamt of u" u should hear it.later dawg ---. UnderCoverLoverY May 15, 2005 7:12 PM hey ..I havent called you for awhile... ehh so hews school going? TWO WEEKS LEFTS!! COUNTING DOWN THE DAYS!! excited about graduating this year?? well anyways did u go to casey's party? aka the grad bash.. lol yea there were a few fights...if u look at skyler's myspace'page u see a nice punch.. well it was fun stuff hope u got to go... w/b xoxo KaYLa Listing 51-100 of 284 1 2 3 4 5» of 6 < Previous I Next > Add Comment About FAO I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Mvspace I Promote! I Advertise I MySpace Shop http://www. my space. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&fri endID=172831&page=1&Mytoken=09B3DE8B-B3F. „ 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2482 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

02003-2005 MySpace.com All Rights Reserved http: //www, space: com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. viewComments&friendID=172831&page=1&Mytoken=09B3DE8B-B3F, 12!'2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2483 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 1 of 15 MySpace.com I Home The Web '4" MySpace '1 Search j Help I SignOut qmyspace-I a place for friends verton Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail 4 Blog I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music I Classifieds Back to Profile. View Comments Listing 101-150 of 284 1 2 3 4 5» of 6 < Previous I Next > Infelicitous ...1/4', May 14, 2005 7:27 PM Hi I never see you. You're still cool. Be Quiet an Drive t• ....-40 •••• • I , May 11, 2005 2:21 PM yo I had ur c.d. today preston77 May 9, 2005 7:52 PM peekaboo. *A ...., .,, i 7 ru•Ir , http://www. mysp ace. com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&fri endlD=172831&page=2&My to ken=74F355A 7-B649-, 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2484 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 2 of 15 WAKE UP THE DEAD May 3, 2005 1:27 PM yo wuts up...kinda said hi 2day b4 2nd hour or something.... but ya just sayin wuts up...later Purple Stuff in my Cup May 2, 2005 8:54 AM Hey Babe, well i hope to get my cell phone turned back on soon but i dunno, but as soon as I do i will call you first and let you know....k...see you at davids later. I. • tit May 1, 2005 3:55 PM i can rember thats why i dont want to go back:) EARL IV 4 1. May 1, 2005 2:23 PM i am good I love it up here, how have you been? CONFINEDw/Vivid Splender May 1, 2005 8:32 AM WHHHHHATS up I think I may have met you at jjmuggs you work with melyssa right, we http://www.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&page=2&Mytoken=74F355A7-B649-,.. 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2485 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

myspace.com Page 3 of 15 ... - -:, should hang out sometime EARL IV . **I:. , Apr 30, 2005 9:57 AM HEY! WAKE UP THE DEAD Apr 29, 2005 12:11 PM hahah ya i just never thought u would remember me...I remember one day Jose told me u thought I was "pretty"...or somethin like that...but anyways talk 2 u later '' WAKE UP THE DEAD Apr 28, 2005 12:57 PM yo wuts up...0 prob. dont remember me but along time ago in JJ mugs i had a balloon in my shirt and u rubbed It lol...weird...but ya i just didnt know if u remembered me or not...im in derricks band that u work with...later :;;;;0a,-, ,may,-, -.*.i.....4., - Apr 27, 2005 7:14 PM lol yea...we hardly work together anymore http://www.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&page=2&Mytoken=74F355A7-B649-... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2486 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

myspace. corn Page 4 of 15 UnderCoverLover, Apr 27, 2005 12:55 PM Did you read the entire book already? it was a good book, it was hard to put down, I think i might go to barnes and noble later, i will look for that sequal to the book... well got out of jail finally lol yea Its almost like jail with mr bush...well give me a call whenever, if u forgot my number i believe i still have yours If u want me to give u a call...see ya on the flip side!! o yea!! i finished that book on eating disorders it only took me two days to read!! it was good about one girl that ate alot but then threw up all the time and some other girl died because she didnt eat at all then another one who didnt eat but couldnt have sex with her boyfriend because sshe was too fajile so she decided to gain weight finally to fuck him and then some fat girl that over-ate like every day eating everything in sight!! it was remarkable how these people do this!! crazy too but anyway good book!! im on tot he next one "scribbler dreams" or somthing??! alrighty, bye doll!! xoxo *KAYLA* preston77 sr Apr 26, 2005 3:27 PM This is true, though I've called you several times. I believe that to be somewhat of a worthy effort. I could be wrong though. preston77 Apr 26, 2005 1:14 PM urn, hi. long time no nothing. http ://www. myspace. com/index. cfm?fuse action=user. viewComments&friendID=172831&page=2&Mytoken=74F355A7-B649-, 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2487 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 5 of 15 • 4.:• Online No.. UnderCoverLovery Apr 25, 2005 9:13 PM ***P.s. i hope you like that book, i enjoyed it...see ya soon!! «33 Kayla UnderCoverLoverc? Apr 25, 2005 9:11 PM hey girly!! i enjoyed our moments last week well thursday and friday, definatly give me a call if you would like to hang out anytime...o i hear u thot i was alex's girlfriend, no thats theresea's job...some girl from cardinal newman...anywho...gimme a ring and we can hang out...bye!! xoxo *Kayla* My Name is Mud!! • -1:. Apr 24, 2005 9:49 PM Hey what's up? Just wanted to say I heard you got your window up on your car.. Sweet.. See ya At Dave's.. http://www.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&page=2&Mytoken=74F355A7-B649-,_ 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2488 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

lisa geese-ah Apr 24, 2005 12:40 PM hugs can be so dangerous sometimes. i got a skinned elbow from joe. you got a busted lip from matt. i think Its something to do with that family tine. <3 „„ ,.iiin Its Callt 51<ylER Apr 22, 2005 9:15 PM Ever so cordial, you are. :) the tragic tale of you and me -ry OnlIrie Nomo Apr 18, 2005 8:19 PM porn star? HAVVT! lol 51<y1ER .--- Apr 18, 2005 7:39 PM Since he can't send it to you: http ://wwvv. myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. viewComments&fri endID=172831&page=2&Mytoken=74F355A7-B649-... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2489 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Virginia spaue.Will Page .1 of 15 Apr 17, 2005 4:07 PM FISHING TRIP A couple goes on vacation to a fishing resort in northern Saskatchewan. The husband likes to fish at the crack of dawn; the wife likes to read. One morning the husband returns after several hours of fishing and decides to take a nap. Although not familiar with the lake, the wife decides to take the boat out. She motors out a short distance, anchors, and continues to read her book. http://www.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&page=2&Mytoken=74F355A7-B649-... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2490 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

myspace.com Page zs of Along comes a game warden in his boat. He pulls up alongside the woman and says, "Good morning Ma'am. What are you doing?" Reading a book, " she replies, thinking,-'"Isn't that obvious?" You're In a restricted fishing area, " he informs her. "I'm sorry officer, but I'm not fishing, I'm reading." "Yes, but you have all the equipment. For all I know you could start at any moment. I'll have to take you in and write you up." "If you do that, I'll have to charge you with sexual assault, " says the woman. "But I haven't touched you, " says the game warden. "That's true, but you have all the equipment. For all I know you could start at any moment." "Have a nice day ma'am, " and he left. MORAL: NEVER ARGUE WITH A WOMAN WHO READS. IT'S LIKELY SHE CAN ALSO THINK. LOL, made me think of you lady!! Ugly Ken Hart - Apr 14, 2005 7:29 PM You said you were going to post prom pictures in a blog. Let me know when they are up. 51<ylER Apr 13, 2005 12:04 PM http: //www. my space. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.vi evvComments&fri en dID=172831&p age=2&Myto k en=74F355 A7-B 649-... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2491 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Lvay J}Ja1..G. VV111 rage Y or 1J We are gonna have a show down of ninja skillz and settle this once and for all. You are no match for my flying gerbil attack. Infelicitous .e Apr 11, 2005 10:02 PM _„ help me find a new addiction. 51<y1ER Apr 11, 2005 7:29 PM I think you broke the internet again. Virginia Apr 11, 2005 5:00 PM are these pictures??? 7,, 7'... pi where , ,I ';":. the tragic tale of you and me Apr 10, 2005 3:27 PM I would tell you but you would probably get upset. And making you upset is one of the last things I would like to do today. http://www.myspace. com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&page=2&Mytoken=74F355A7-B649-... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2492 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

the tragic tale of you and me Ilit . Apr 10, 2005 12:17 AM Right now you are drunk and I am sad. And bored. preston77 Apr 7, 2005 8:44 PH I am so on the internet. psh. hi. "4.W‘ prestoa77 Apr 7, 2005 5:03 PM GRRR. .,.• Apr 5, 2005 4:17 PM Whats up stud? Still slavin away at ns? :. Bobert (It's better) Apr 3, 2005 11:09 AM Ey girl! http ://www, myspace. com/index. cfm7fuseaction=user. viewComments&fri endID=172831&page=2&Mytoken=74F355A7-B649.„ : 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2493 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

W111 Page 11 of 15 rL ii. Ugly Ken Hart Mar 31, 2005 7:58 PM I hope we didnt bother you with our antics tonight. I figure we need to find something better to do with our time. Of course, you are a welcome diversion, se I figure that we didnt waste anything. . Onl ine Ncov! Just remember Ninjas make terrible pancakes I Mar 30, 2005 9:48 PM I love you! 51 <yl£11 IF- . . Mar 29, 2005 4:14 PM I listen becuase you're important to me ,, tell me if theres anything I can do to help. GirL From Ipanema Mar 26, 2005 7:52 AM http://www. my sp ac e. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&fri encilD=172831&p ag e=2&Mytoken=74F355A7-B649-... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2494 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

my pace. com rage ii. or i. i miss youllIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIHMI i am in an Internet cafe in parisii the keyboard is all sorts of fUnKeD up!! it is taking me forever to type.. only a few more days here! w00t11 miss WI preston77 Mar 25, 2005 12:54 PM 'ello. ..: sam - .$ Mar 19, 2005 12:37 AM this is part of something i saved, from you. i came across it tonight and it made me happy: "/ just want to kiss her on the forehead and tell her she's the most beautiful girl in the world" right back at you, missy. that, along with the rest of what you said, meant a lot to me then, and still does. how serendipitous that i found it tonight. (it was a crying in the back room night.) =\ i meant to call you from work, but I'm sam, thus, i didn't want to be a burden. and i have no idea where my phone even is, as usual. regardless, i hope you're having an eitey wonderful weekend... <3 x 100 Ugly Ken Hart Mar 17, 2005 4:35 PM Good evening. I am going on vacation tommorrow, and I am making my rounds. Enjoy your break, or I will hunt you down. http: //www.myspace.com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friend03=172831&page=2&Mytoken=74F355A7-B649-... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2495 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

iviyspace.com Page 13 of 15 the tragic tale of you and me Mar 16, 2005 11:01 PM I still have your heart in my closet. It got out once, but it came back. I think It likes me. Maybe. samatha I Mar 15, 2005 2:23 PM wear red tomorrow! it's red day! tell EVERYONE plzI i wanna see if it'll work! V you ashley!!! E 1 ,!+Built 2 Spill,- Mar 15, 2005 9:25 AM hey there! SO WHATS GOING ON! ,.d~ Dorothy Mantooth Mar 11, 2005 12:40 PM remember when we would get into these http://www. my space. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&page=2&Mytoken=74F355A7-B649-... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2496 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

intense political debates in photo, you, matt zelek and myself. and yours was the only opposing opinion i could actually respect. oh man. =) Xnfeiicitous ,-. ;-. Mar 8, 2005 10:47 PM Remember when the police had Ian pinned to the ground for threatening to slap you? Remember when you were crying on the bus and you used my jacket sleeve as a tissue? Remember when Kurt pulled my chair from beneath me and I didn't notice till my ass was on the floor? Remember when things weren't so difficult, when not everything had an alterior motive, when you didn't need to put time aside just to relax? This is making me feel old. Hi . Here's to good, bad and ugly times and more to come. the tragic tale of you and me -L„;-i Mar 8, 2005 7:19 PM That reflector should have been attached to the ground. And you say you're cursed, any other reflector would have been stuck there for another hundred years, but you pulled up to the one that wasn't. The sky was beautiful that night, and so were you. Virginia Mar 8, 2005 7:18 PM wait wait wait...remember when you used to want a mustang?? lol and then we continually called out colors whenever we saw one and i convinced you that YOU were not like everyone else, why should you drive a car that everyone else owned... the tragic tale of Mar 8, 2005 7:08 PM http : //www. my space. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. yiewComments&friendID=172831&page=2&Mytoken=74F355A7-B649-... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2497 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

you and me Remember when we did that thing where you called me and said "We'll race!" then we raced and you won, technically. And we bought matching shirts. Then you lit napkins on fire. That was a good day. Mar 8, 2005 3:18 PM You haven't seen it yet, but still, i saw you online and had to post first.... Remember when we stayed up for how long watching Season one of 24? when you dyed my hair blonde? when you used to climb on the counters? when you snuck out and left me a note to tell me that you had? when we washed our hair in the rain at city place? or layed on the stage and looked at I Spy books? ohmygoodness we have so many... you can remember the harder ones though-101 MWAH! Virginia Myspace.com Page 15 of 15 Listing 101-150 of 284 1 2 3 4 5» of 6 < Previous I Next > Add Comment About I FAO I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Myspace I Promote! I Advertise I MySpace Shop 02003.2006 MySpace.com All Rights Reserved. http;//www: my sp ace, com/index, cfm?fuse action—us er. vi e vvC omments &fri en dID=172831&p age=2&Myto ken=74F355A7-B 649— 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2498 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

MySpace.com I Home The Web MySpace Search Help I SignOut myspace , Move services online. ill a place for friends Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail Blog I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music I Classifieds Back to Profile . View Comments Listing 151-200 of 284 1 2 3 4 5» of 6 < Previous I Next > Ugly Ken Hart Mar 5, 2005 5:55 PM It was nice seeing you at the show today. I appreciate the pen and paper. I am sure, that sooner or later, what I began writing on your clinic pass, may become something catchy, and altogether worth hearing. — preston77 Mar 2, 2005 6:37 PM I hope you's gets to feelin' better. i ..11 11 :Z. 11 r,i!ri z I.. .0 the tragic tale of you and me 1 111 ii '12-; Mar 2, 2005 6:13 PM Feel better my dear. http://www.myspace.com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&page=3&Mytoken=3313946C-2D8A... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2499 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

1Vly J1Jill.G.L4J1/1 1-'age '2 of 13 Billy Barou Mar 2, 2005 11:25 AM I hope that by now you have learned to cook, clean, and sew. If not then you are disobeying a direct order from a man, and shll face punishment. As an inferior woman, this could Include death, or even imprisonment. I hope that you respond in a postive way. Later. -Billy F, - A" .1 4, 5'14 0 rtlin4: NpNa,, chuck yeager aint got shit on me INNESSF Feb 27, 2005 6:55 PM MY THROAT!!! I MAKE THE PAIN STOPII ill Ugly Ken Hart Feb 27, 2005 12:57 PM I appreciate the sentiment. i think I am getting better. It is taking alot of time, but I should kick the sick thing in a little. , °Hire N ,0 sam Feb 27, 2005 8:35 AM ha, you make a good point, miss. somehow i think that we're all too cool for myspace, though. or maybe just cool enough? <3 http : //www. mysp ace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. vie wComments&friend[D=172831&p age=3&Mytoken=3313946C-2D8A... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2500 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

iviy biJi2l.G.W111 Page 3 of 13 I preston77 Feb 27, 2005 8:12 AM bleh? 1 .. Odin preston77 Feb 25, 2005 1:06 PM Damnit, you sign off right as I get back. -- to . — Girl From Ipanema Feb 24, 2005 9:27 AM SO MUCH RICE... SO LITTLE TIME. the tragic tale of you and me ._. v. .:.r Online rlcr 1 Feb 23, 2005 10:27 AM I was just asking. Nevermind. the tragic tale of you and me Feb 22, 2005 10:14 PM What's your favorite kind of flower? http://www. my space. corn/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendlD=172831&page=3&Myto ken=3313946C-2D8A... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2501 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

[ASV -r S./1 V Virginia .., Feb 22, 2005 8:42 PM get out of this dismal deep dark dank hole that you're In...you shouldn't sit way down there for very long...i hear its worse than smoking...mwahl Leah Jean the DANCING MACHINE .,. Feb 22, 2005 1:13 PM 'm so sorry for not hearing you i swear i wasn't ignoring you i was just in a really important conversation with matt. and i love your accent! <3 Whitest Puerto Rican Feb 21, 2005 9:11 PM What's goin on SweetHart??? rrlia Feb 21, 2005 6:46 PM hello stranger http: //www, mysp ace, corn/ ndex.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID--172831&page=3&Mytoken=3313946C-2D8A 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2502 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

SUN CANT SHINE THE TIME ALL Feb 20, 2005 7:37 PM hey budddddddddyyyyyyyyy Ugly Ken Hart Feb 19, 2005 9:33 PM Even so, you are a SweetHart, it is a pity you had to be sad at our show. I hope that the next show will be more fun for you. Ugly Ken Hart Feb 19, 2005 7:25 PM Despair? I hope you are feeling better. And I also hope that our show had nothing to do with it. The last thing this band needs, is to cuase you to be unhappy sweethart. Online Wr,,, hnp://www,myspace,cem/index,cfm?fuseaction=user,viewComments&friendID=17283184page=3&Mytoken-=3313946C-2D8A 12/2/2D01 07/26/17 Page 2503 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

wiyspace.corn Page 6 of 13 Feb 19, 2005 1:27 PM I'm terribly sorry about last night, I hope you've found your phone. And I hope you're feeling a bit better, we should talk. — Ugh/ Ken Hart Feb 17, 2005 6:54 PM I appreciate the ride home this evening. I wish I could post some kind of witty comment, but really, I have nothing right now. Absolutely nothing...Nothing at all. Nope. Nada. A .:-. preston77 Feb 17, 2005 5:36 PM get on AIM, woman. *7.* . e II, ) preston77 Feb 16, 2005 9:56 PM I wouldn't exactly call them competitions....I guess I forgive you, this time. • ., 0:•AHve Ic.,). pmston77 Feb 16, 2005 7:22 AM I don't know....tell me why I should? http://vvww.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user,viewComments&friendID=172831&page=3&Mytoken=3313946C-2D8A.„ 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2504 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

. 1, preston77 Feb 15, 2005 3:15 PM You so weren't online last night. the tragic tale of you and me Feb 14, 2005 7:51 PM Happy <3 Day! 51<y1ER F r A Feb 14, 2005 5:35 PM I'm ache'n to see your hair. I keep hearing about It from everybody. Dorothy Mantooth Feb 14, 2005 5:23 PM for the record, i think it looks nice. http://www.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.vievvComments&friendID=172831&page=3&Mytoken=3313946C-2D8A... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2505 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Ivry spat C. LUII1 Page 8 of 13 )Green Feb 14, 2005 3:28 PM Spankys Downtown March 12, On Broken Wings Black My Heart Our Battle Point Break and more DOORS: 6pm Ili-gmea , Feb 14, 2005 2:45 PM ... • •-• Happy Valentine's Day! Dusty Wusty ♦s Candy Feb 13, 2005 10:55 PM 4 http: //www.myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user. viewComments&friendID=172831&page=3&Mytoken=3313946C-2D8A... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2506 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 9 of 13 w Y ii• Happylialeghties! 111. preston77 Feb 13, 2005 7:06 PM the pictures, but we Just did that =) samatha tc Feb 13, 2005 6:31 PM hahal ninja cops? that funny' ya, said you parked next to me one day, i didn't know you drove a neon! i,reston77 Feb 13, 2005 6:31 PM I want to see plz kthx. i . .4 http://www, mysp ace, com/index. cfm?fuse acti on—user. viewComments&fri enclID=172831&p age=3&Mytoken-3313946C-2D8A, 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2507 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

samatha V i Feb 13, 2005 2:16 PM hey _ lauren told me about you 2 LEAVING campus for lunch? good idea! i have B lunch tho so I'm not so fortunate! Leah lean the DANCING MACHINE ..: Feb 13, 2005 6:53 AM yeah steve told me im the official merch girl so ill definately be making shirts but ill make yours first :) Beef Knuckles 411111111111104 Feb 12, 2005 11:34 PM "54. If you don't like a person, how do you show it? I tell them." Untruth. mEmins - a 51<y1ER Feb 12, 2005 8:24 PM Commenting just becuase you're online. V http://www.myspace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&page=3&Mytoken=3313946C-2D8A. „ 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2508 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

rviyJp4.;c..;,,II, rage i 1 ot 13 ! T PS:Garth says "Nigger". Just remember Ninjas make terrible pancakes p Feb 12, 2005 6:56 PM I meant the poem. Just remerhi. Airrija3 make terrible pancakes it Feb 12, 2005 6:00 PM READ THE BULLETIN the tragic tale of you and me oror, F!,- .d Feb 11, 2005 10:49 PM It was definitely fun hanging out with you tonight. And RPB is not a good place to look at stars. Too many lights, too much pollution. Just remember Ninjas make terrible pancakes Feb 11, 2005 9:51 PM You know you loved it. http://wvvw. myspace, com/index. cfm?fuse action=user. vi ewComments&fri endID=172831&pag e=3&Mytoken=3313946C -2D8 A, 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2509 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

iviy Jpaue. tAnii Page 12 of 13 SUN CANT SHINE ALL THE TIME Feb 11, 2005 8:55 PM ::hhhmmmm:: looks left< looks right> Finds himself staring upwards and wanders why am i wasting my fuckin time on this piece of shit computer.... then he remembers ... I HAVE NO LIFE Leah Jean the DANCING MACHINE -,.‘ 4 . 4 Feb 8, 2005 2:21 PM is there gellatin in pudding? "Built 2 Spill,- Feb 6, 2005 9:41 PM Hey whats up ash, Remember that one time I saw you in hollister and I was like wow U In hollister! the tragic tale of you and me Feb 6, 2005 9:04 PM its ok. once u get that battery charged give me a call. http://www. mysp ace. com/index. cfm?fuseaction=user.vi ewComments&fri en dID= 1 72 8 3 l&p age=3 &Myto k en=3313946C -2D8 A... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2510 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

.31.1C4VV. rage I.) (11 13 51<y1ER , .f Feb 5, 2005 8:17 AM I wish you were with me right now. • the tragic tale of you and me Feb 5, 2005 1:19 AM hm.. some one elses huh? darn. : \ S I <yl. ER ,..—.. ri. t i .. Feb 3, 2005 8:44 PM http://www.adrenalinstudios.com/sb.html Teh link :) • Listing 151-200 of 284 1 2 3 4 5» of 6 < Previous I Next > Add Comment About I FAO I Terms I Privacy I safety Yips I Contact Myspace I Promote! I Advertise MySpace Shop e2003.2005 MySoace.com All Rights Reserved http://www.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&page=3&Mytoken=3313946C-2D8A... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2511 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

LVI, Opel. Lo. Loll 111 rage 13 01. 13 51<y1ER Feb 5, 2005 8:17 AM I wish you were with me right now. • Pr..- a Fir 1 the tragic tale of you and me til? Feb 5, 2005 1:19 AM hm some one elses huh? darn .:\ Si <ylER ' °,1a, V,. Feb 3, 2005 8:44 PM http://www adrenalinstudios com/sb.html Teh link :), Listing 151-200 of 284 1 2 3 4 5» of 6 < Previous I Next > Add Comment About I FAQ I Terms I Privacy I Safety s I Contact lAyppac.e I Promote! I Advertise I hAySpace Shop ©2003.2005 MySoace.com All Rights Reserved. http://www.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewComments&friendID=172831&page=3&Mytoken=3313946C-2D8A... 12/2/2005 07/26/17 Page 2512 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

iviy sputx. will Page 1 of 1 MySpace.com I Home The Web (.5 MySpace Search Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Gar Pictures of ashley fucking davisW: Click Picture for F myspace pic to the max, eh garth? ”Post a Comment »E-Mail to a Friend 8 Comment(s) on the way to sticking out my tongue. Post a Comment E-Mail to a Friend 2 Comment(s) <3 Leah. Chucks mean. Vegetarians rock. »Post a Comment »E-Mail to a Friend 4 Comment(s) the things tl ,Post a Co E-Mail to 2 Watching the sprinting valet boys »Post a Comment with my wife. »E-Mail to a Friend .,Post a Comment 2 Comment(s) »E-Mail to a Mend 2 Comment(s) About I FAQ I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tip I Contact Mvspace Promote! I Advertise I lAySpace Shop ©2003-2005 MApace.c-om All Rights Reserved. http://viewmorepics. myspace. com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user. viewPicture&friend1D-17... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2513 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

NATIONWIDE WHENEVER MINUTES I GET MOF My space. corn Page 1 of 2 IlvSpace.com I Home The Web MySpaa: Search Home I Bre,vse I Search I Invite I Raid I Hail j Elog I Fa I Forum I Groups I Events Gaines idusic Back to Picture Index Back to Profile Watching the sprinting valet boys with my wife. Post a Comment I bo a Friend < Previous I Next > Listing 1 - 2 of 2 From Comment Virginia April 24, 2005 6:50 PM beautiful pic ash--you look... amazing. April 24, 2005 3:54 PM crazy earings. nice. preston77 http ://viewmorepics. myspace. corn/index. cfm?fuseaction—viewlmage&friendM=172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2514 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

My space. corn Page 2 of 2 About I FAQ I Terms Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Mvspace I Promote! I Advertise MvSpace Shop ®2003-2005 ySpace.com All Rights Reserved. http: //viewmorepi cs. my sp ace. corn/index. cfm?fuseaction—viewlmage&friend1D-172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2515 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Onlin PeFf.) A' your comer, itpwardie GET YOUR DEGREE IN Organizational Psychology & Development Bachelor's in 13 MONTHS.' Master's in 10 MONTHS. LEARN MORE! Post a Comment I E-Mail to a Friend My space. com Page 1 012 MySpace.com I Home The Web ' 4i - MySpace Searcj Home I Erc.'ise Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Bloy I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music Back to Picture Index Back to Profile < Previous I Next > Listing 1 - 2 of 2 From Comment sam February 22, 2005 12:48 AM are you too cool for two eyes? hmmmm missy? are you?! February 13, 2005 8:46 PM Just remember lol. Ninjas make terrible pancakes http://viewmorepics.myspace.com/indexcfin?fuseaction=viewlmage&friendID=17283 I ... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2516 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

myspace.com rage z of About I FAQ I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tiffs I Contact Myspace I Promote! I Advertise MySpace Shop @2003-2005 MySpace.com All Rights Reserved. http://viewmorepics.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction—viewImage&friendED=172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2517 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

My space. corn Page 1 of 2 The Web "Mr CYO AP V* MySpace.com I Home MySpace Search Connects to any checking account ► No monthly fees or minimums Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music Back to Picture Index Back to Profile Post a Comment I E-Mail to a Friend < Previous I Next > Listing 1 - 2 of 2 From Comment March 4, 2005 5:17 PM http://viewmorepics.myspace. com/index cfm?fuseaction=viewImage&friendIlk 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2518 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

My space. corn Page 2 of 2 i4antooth it don't mean a thing... preston77 February 21, 2005 7:35 PM ...if it ain't got that swing. About I FAQ I Terms I Privacy! Safety Tips I Contact Mvspace I Promote! I Advertise f MvSpace Shop 02003-2005 MvSpace.com All Rights Reserved. http://viewmorepics.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=-viewlmage&friendID=172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2519 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 1 of 2 The Web 11Ir 0/ /0 APY* MySpace.com I Home V MySpace Search Connects to any checking account ► No monthly fees or minimums I-I5 hsb Home I Browse I Search I Invite I Rank I Mail I Blog I Favorites I Forum I Groups I Events I Games I Music Back to Picture Index Back to Profile <3 Leah. Chucks mean. Vegetarians rock. Post a Comment I E-Mail to a Friend < Previous I Next > Listing 1 - 4 of 4 From Comment Dick Painter April 20, 2005 7:27 PM http://viewmorepics.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=viewlmage&friendIE17283 I ... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2520 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Myspace.com Page 2 of 2 Vegetarians suck dick, oops thats too much meat for them tasteless I am. Leah Jean the April 19, 2005 2:27 PM DANCING L000VEE YOUUU!!! wow i thought i left MACHINE a comment but i guess i didn't. look how sad/weird i look. ha. <3 Dorothy March 3, 2005 11:06 AM Mantooth you guys are so pretty. sam February 22, 2005 12:49 AM harry potter! <3likewhoa, baby. About i FAQ I Terms I Privacy I Safety Tips I Contact Myspace Promote! I Advertise I MySpace Shop 62003-2005 MySoace.com All Rights Reserved. http://viewmorepics.myspace.com/index cfm?fuseaction=viewImage&friendID=172831... 11/14/2005 07/26/17 Page 2521 Public Records Request No.: 17-295