What is document Epstein_Part_04_Redacted?

This document is a redacted FBI file that seems to contain phone call logs from September 2005, potentially related to the Jeffrey Epstein investigation.

Who is mentioned in this document?

Key individuals mentioned in the document include Jeffrey Epstein, Johanna Sjoberg, David Rodgers, Daniel Beale, and Perry Bard.

What does this document reveal?

The document reveals a log of phone calls, including the date, time, phone number, and the name of the person to whom the phone number was registered. It indicates call direction (IN or OUT) for each call.

What is document Epstein_Part_04_Redacted?

This document is a redacted FBI file that seems to contain phone call logs from September 2005, potentially related to the Jeffrey Epstein investigation.

Who is mentioned in this document?

Key individuals mentioned in the document include Jeffrey Epstein, Johanna Sjoberg, David Rodgers, Daniel Beale, and Perry Bard.

What does this document reveal?

The document reveals a log of phone calls, including the date, time, phone number, and the name of the person to whom the phone number was registered. It indicates call direction (IN or OUT) for each call.

Epstein_Part_04_Redacted

This document is from the FBI Vault, labeled 'Epstein_Part_04_Redacted'.

The document consists of 82 pages and appears to be a log of phone calls. It lists dates, phone numbers, names of individuals registered to those numbers, and call times with 'OUT' or 'IN' designations. The log includes multiple entries for Jeffrey Epstein, Johanna Sjoberg, and David Rodgers, among others.

Key Highlights

•The document contains a log of phone calls from September 2005.
•Jeffrey Epstein's phone number 561-655-7626 is listed multiple times.
•Johanna Sjoberg and David Rodgers (Pilot) are mentioned multiple times in the call logs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Books for Further Reading

Perversion of Justice: The Jeffrey Epstein Story

Julie K. Brown

Investigative journalism that broke the Epstein case open

Filthy Rich: The Jeffrey Epstein Story

James Patterson

Bestselling account of Epstein's crimes and network

Relentless Pursuit: My Fight for the Victims of Jeffrey Epstein

Bradley J. Edwards

Victims' attorney's firsthand account

Document Information

Bates Range

Epstein_Part_04_Redacted

Pages

Source

FBI Vault

Document Content

Page 1 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p1

SARMA t4A 11.4 Get 1 5Al2A to-‘ tLE1 I saw CF--LLIA•ketNE USA GE gios .. to/05 • CbiSCOVS2xi of IMESTICATIoNj 4 PORPACIArtbrQS TD come_ ID Wm PR-ACM 07/26/17 Page 1 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 2 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p2

SACZMA C_ALLS wimc3FAc couNrry DATE NUMBER REGISTERED TO : TIME OUT/IN 9/3/2005 561-714-0546 Johanna Sjoberg 10:37A OUT 9/3/2005 561-714-0547 Johanna Sjoberg 10:40A OUT 9/3/2005 561-776-5679 T.A. Rofano 11:37A IN 9/3/2005 561-655-2779 Jeffrey Epstein 1:53P IN 9/3/2005 561-662-3098 Daniel Beale (Britany) 1:55P OUT 9/3/2005 561-389-6874 Christina Venero 1:57P OUT 9/4/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 10:42A OUT 9/6/2005 561-499-1718 S. Rosen 8:08A OUT 9/10/2005 — • -- 4:43P OUT 9/10/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 7:53P OUT 9/11/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 8:03A IN 9/14/2005 561-317-5844 David Rodgers(Pilot) 8:25A OUT 9/14/2005 561-317-5844 David Rodgers(Pilot) 5:98P OUT 9/14/2005 561-317-5844 David Rodgers(Pilot) 7:27P OUT 9/14/2005 561-317-5844 David Rodgers(Pilot) 7:35P IN 9/15/2005 561 10:17A OUT 9/18/2005 561-818-8361 Janusz Babasaik 9:57A OUT 9/18/2005 561-714-0546 Johanna Sjoberg 9:58A OUT 9/18/2005 — -- 9:59A OUT 9/18/2005 10:00A OUT 9/18/2005 -- 10:03A OUT 9/18/2005 561-662-3098 10:05A OUT 9/18/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 10:20A OUT 9/18/2005 561-302-1844 Dr Perry Bard 10:44A OUT 9/18/2005 561-389-6874 Christina Venero 1:10P OUT 9/18/2005 561-389-6874 Christina Venero 4:10P IN 9/18/2005 561-389-6874 Christina Venero 4:10P OUT 9/18/2005 561-302-1844 Dr Perry Bard 4:15P IN 9/18/2005 ! 5:17P OUT 9/18/2005 561-714-0546 Johanna Sjoberg 9:37P OUT 9/18/2005 561-714-0546 Johanna Sjoberg 9:45P OUT 9/19/2005 - 10:29A IN 9/19/2005 ... - . 11:45A IN 9/19/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 1:54P IN 9/19/2005 561-776-5679 T.A. Rofrano 2:01P IN 9/20/2005 561-635-3454 12:10A IN 9/20/2005 561-317-5844 David Rodgers(Pilot) 7:20P IN 9/20/2005 561-317-5844 David Rodgers(Pilot) 7:22P IN 9/20/2005 561-317-5844 David Rodgers(Pilot) 7:22P IN 9/21/2005 561-818-8361 Janusz Banasaik 1:46P IN 07/26/17 Page 2 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 3 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p3

9/21/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 1:47P IN 9/21/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 1:48P IN 9/28/2005 561-844-4112 ADVENTURE TIMES 11:29A IN 9/29/2005 561-818-8361 Janusz Banasaik 9:07A OUT 9/29/200 12:41P OUT 9/29/2005 12:43P OUT 9/29/200- 12:46P IN 9/29/2005 12:47P OUT 9/30/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 9:13A IN 9/30/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 10:29A IN 9/30/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 10:34A IN 9/30/2005 7:06P IN 10/1/2005 9:33A OUT 10/1/2005 9:35A IN 10/1/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 9:44A OUT 10/1/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 9:45A OUT 10/1/2005 561-574-0400 Tatum Miller 11:15A OUT 10/1/2005 9:12P OUT 10/1/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 9:43P OUT 10/1/2005 9:46P OUT 10/2/2005 561-776-8748 Jerry Brabon 10:31A IN 10/2/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 10:34A OUT 10/2/2005 561-856-2617 Courtney Wild 11:40A OUT 10/2/200F. 11:41A OUT 10/2/2005 11:42A OUT 10/2/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 11:43A OUT 10/2/2005 561-655-7626 10/2/2005 Jeffrey Epstein 3:03P 4:32P OUT IN 10/2/2005 4:33P OUT 10/2/2005 6:51P OUT 10/2/2005 561-662-3098 Daniel Beale (Britany) 9:38P OUT 10/2/2005 561-662-3098 Daniel Beale (Britany) 9:47P IN 10/3/2005 561-302-1844 Dr Perry Bard 9:07A OUT 10/3/2005 561-389-6874 Christina Venero 9:10A OUT 10/3/2005 561-302-1844 Dr Perry Bard 9:11A IN 10/3/2005 561-655-7629 Jeffrey Epstein 9:14A IN 10/3/2005 9:37A OUT 10/3/2005 561-655-0995 Jeffrey Epstein 9:38A IN 10/3/2005 9:52A OUT 10/3/2005 9:53A IN 10/3/2005 9:55A OUT 10/3/2005 561-655-7629 Jeffrey Epstein 9:57A OUT 10/3/20C 11:21A IN 10/3/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 7:27P OUT 10/4/2005 9:36A OUT 07/26/17 Page 3 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 4 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p4

10/4/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 9:48A OUT 10/4/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 10:33A OUT 10/4/2005 10:58A OUT 10/4/2005 561-655-7626 Jeffrey Epstein 11:08A IN 10/4/2005 11:15A IN 10/4/2005 561-655-0995 Jeffrey Epstein 11:16A OUT 10/4/2005 4:30P OUT 10/4/2005 8:35P OUT 07/26/17 Page 4 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 5 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p5

153497 12/14/2005 SUBSCRIBER INFORMATION cingular® 0043811863 7.5 Financially Liable Party Name: JEFFREY E EPSTEIN Credit Address: 457 MADISON AVE, NEW YORK NY 10022-6843 Customer Since: 04/03/2004 Photo ID Type: Photo ID State: Photo ID Number: DOB: 05/05/1950 SSN: Contact Name: SARAH KELLEN Contact Home Phone: (212) 750-9895 Contact Work Phone: (212) 750-9895 Contact Home Email: Contact Work Email: Billing Party Account Number: 0043811863 Name: JEFFREY E EPSTEIN Billing Address: 457 MADISON AVE, NEW YORK NY 10022-6843 Account Status: Active Billing Cycle: 2 User Information MSISDN: (917) 855-3363 IMSI: 310380040129624 MSISDN Active: 04/03/2004 - Current IMEI/ESN:351985009251058/ Name: SARAH KELLEN User Address: 457 MADISON AVE , NEW YORK NY 10022-6843 Service Start Date: 04/03/2004 Dealer Info: A1NBC Lakeside Center-CC Payment Type: Postpaid Contact Name: SARAH KELLEN Contact Home Phone: (212) 750-9895 Contact Work Phone: (212) 750-9895 Contact Home Email: Contact Work Email: Status Change History Status Change Reason: Status Change Date: 2G 30 Migration 04/03/2004 NAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Page 1 Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 5 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 6 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p6

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingu ar Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 1 09/03/05 07:51A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 2 09/03/05 09:18A (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 3 09/03/05 09:19A (212)696-2315 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 4 09/03/05 09:56A (718)707-9090 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 5 09/03/05 10:37A (561)714-0546 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 6 09/03/05 10:39A (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 7 09/03/05 10:40A (561)714-0546 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 8 09/03/05 11:37A (561)776-5679 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 9 09/03/05 12:54P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 10 09/03/05 01:15P (718)361-5768 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 11 09/03/05 01:53P (561)655-2779 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 12 09/03/05 01:55P (561)662-3098 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 13 09/03/05 01:57P (561)389-6874 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 14 09/03/05 01:58P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 15 09/03/05 02:26P (786)246-6607 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 16 09/03/05 02:27P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 17 09/03/05 04:04P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 18 09/03/05 04:05P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 10 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 19 09/03/05 04:17P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 1 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 6 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 7 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p7

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G , cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 09/03/05 04:17P (917)855-3363 2 Calls To Wins Used 1 Rate 0.00 Charge Description UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN Charge 20 09/03/05 04:20P (434)806-6442 CHARLOTSVL VA 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 21 09/04/05 01:07A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 ROAM MSG RETRIEVAL 1 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $2.29 22 09/04/05 10:42A (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 5 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $11.45 23 09/05/05 08:12A (505)220-5911 ALBUQURQUE NM 1 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $2.29 24 09/05/05 08:12A (505)832-2675 MORIARTY NM 1 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $2.29 25 09/05/05 08:13A (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 3 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $6.87 26 09/05/05 01:51P (513)- INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 27 09/05/05 01:54P (513)- INCOMING 2 2.29 $4.58 28 09/05/05 04:27P (917)612-2492 NEW YORK NY 1 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $2.29 29 09/05/05 09:52P (917)331-8696 NEW YORK NY 1 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $2.29 30 09/05/05 09:53P (513)- INCOMING 7 2.29 $16.03 31 09/06/05 07:32A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 ROAM MSG RETRIEVAL 2 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $4.58 32 09/06/05 07:34A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $4.58 33 09/06/05 07:54A (212)449-5341 NEW YORK NY 3 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $6.87 34 09/06/05 07:59A (917)612-2492 NEW YORK NY 1 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $2.29 35 09/06/05 08:08A (561)499-1718 DELRAY BCH FL 1 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $2.29 36 09/06/05 02:43P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 2 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $4.58 37 09/06/05 02:45P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $2.29 38 09/06/05 02:47P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 1 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $2.29 39 09/06/05 02:49P (212)879-9366 NEW YORK NY 1 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $2.29 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 2 07/26/17 Page 7 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 8 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p8

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular'" Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 40 09/06/05 05:41P (513)- INCOMING 9 2.29 $20.61 41 09/07/05 05:19A (513)- INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 42 09/07/05 05:20A (513)- INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 43 09/07/05 06:11A (513)- INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 44 09/07/05 06:50A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 ROAM MSG RETRIEVAL 1 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $2.29 45 09/07/05 07:20A (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 2 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $4.58 46 09/07/05 07:38A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $4.58 47 09/07/05 07:58A (513)- INCOMING 2 2.29 $4.58 48 09/07/05 08:38A (513)- INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 49 09/07/05 10:06A (513)- INCOMING 2 2.29 $4.58 50 09/07/05 11:35A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 ROAM MSG RETRIEVAL 2 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $4.58 51 09/07/05 12:35P (513)- INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 52 09/08/05 07:47A (513)- INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 53 09/08/05 07:47A (513)- INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 54 09/08/05 12:01P (513)- INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 55 09/08/05 12:39P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 5 2.29 INT'L ROAMING VOICE $11.45 56 09/09/05 07:12A (513)- INCOMING 2 2.29 $4.58 57 09/09/05 07:14A (513)- INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 58 09/09/05 03:10P (513)- INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 59 09/10/05 05:17A (513)- INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 60 09/10/05 08:20A (513)- INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 3 07/26/17 Page 8 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 9 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p9

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G c►nguiar Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 61 09/10/05 02:50P (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 62 09/10/05 02:52P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 63 09/10/05 03:09P (917)804-3288 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 64 09/10/05 04:14P (561)655-7626 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 65 09/10/05 04:31P (561)655-7629 INCOMING 10 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 66 09/10/05 04:41P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 67 09/10/05 04:43P (561)801-3590 WPALMBEACH FL 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 68 09/10/05 04:44P (917)520-3106 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 69 09/10/05 04:46P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 70 09/10/05 05:14P (917)520-3106 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 71 09/10/05 05:41P (917)476-9463 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 72 09/10/05 06:33P (917)476-9463 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 73 09/10/05 07:34P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 74 09/10/05 07:35P (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 75 09/10/05 10:01P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 76 09/10/05 10:16P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 77 09/10/05 10:18P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 78 09/10/05 11:34P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 79 09/11/05 08:03A (561)655-7626 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 4 07/26/17 Page 9 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 10 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p10

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 80 09/11/05 11:18A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 81 09/11/05 11:25A (212)879-9366 NEW YORK NY 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 82 09/11/05 11:55A (917)825-3694 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 83 09/11/05 11:57A (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 84 09/11/05 12:03P (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 85 09/11/05 12:41P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 86 09/11/05 01:04P (212)472-6991 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 87 09/11/05 02:47P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 88 09/11/05 04:29P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 89 09/11/05 04:32P (340)774-1611 CHTAMSTTHS VI 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 90 09/11/05 05:25P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 91 09/11/05 06:07P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 92 09/11/05 06:12P (340)774-1611 CHTAMSTTHS VI 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 93 09/11/05 08:58P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 94 09/11/05 09:09P (917)520-3106 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 95 09/11/05 09:35P (877)877-0987 Toll Free CL 14 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 5 07/26/17 Page 10 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 11 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p11

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cinguiar® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 96 09/11/05 09:55P (000)000-0000 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 97 09/12/05 08:44A (917)406-0001 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 98 09/12/05 08:46A (646)824-5679 NY ZONE 1 NY 8 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 99 09/12/05 09:14A (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 100 09/12/05 09:16A (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 14 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO WOOL 101 09/12/05 09:30A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOM., 102 09/12/05 09:52A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO NOEL 103 09/12/05 10:03A (212)249-8510 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 104 09/12/05 02:52P (212)535-5611 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 105 09/12/05 03:42P (212)750-1176 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 106 09/12/05 04:23P (212)750-1176 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 107 09/12/05 04:25P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 108 09/12/05 04:46P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 109 09/12/05 04:50P (340)774-1611 CHTAMSTTHS VI 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 110 09/12/05 04:51P (340)775-2525 CHTAMSTTHS VI 5 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 111 09/12/05 05:05P (212)449-9570 NEW YORK NY 8 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 112 09/12/05 05:15P (646)824-5679 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 113 09/12/05 05:21P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 114 09/12/05 05:23P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 115 09/12/05 05:24P (212)888-8384 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 6 07/26/17 Page 11 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 12 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p12

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 09/12/05 05:24P (212)888-8384 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 116 09/12/05 05:36P (917)957-5341 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 117 09/12/05 05:43P (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 118 09/12/05 05:44P (917)406-0001 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 119 09/12/05 05:46P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 120 09/12/05 06:09P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 121 09/12/05 06:14P (212)879-9366 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 122 09/12/05 07:49P (917)957-5341 INCOMING 1 0.00 123 09/12/05 09:42P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 124 09/12/05 09:44P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 125 09/12/05 09:48P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 1 0.00 DROP CALL CREDIT 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 126 09/12/05 10:01P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 127 09/12/05 11:32P (917)254-9726 INCOMING 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 128 09/12/05 11:37P (718)707-9090 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 129 09/13/05 09:00A (917)975-4500 BROOKLYN NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 130 09/13/05 09:04A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 131 09/13/05 11:32A (917)975-4500 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 132 09/13/05 01:16P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 133 09/13/05 01:18P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 7 07/26/17 Page 12 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 13 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p13

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G > cingular Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 134 09/13/05 03:06P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 135 09/13/05 03:25P (212)772-3853 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 136 09/13/05 05:46P (212)449-9570 NEW YORK NY 5 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 137 09/13/05 05:52P (917)806-5903 NEW YORK NY 11 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 138 09/13/05 07:21P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 139 09/13/05 08:04P (212)535-5611 INCOMING 1 0.00 140 09/13/05 08:13P (212)535-5611 INCOMING 1 0.00 141 09/13/05 08:15P (212)535-5611 INCOMING 2 0.00 142 09/13/05 08:38P (917)254-9726 NEWYORKZN1 NY 2 0.00 143 09/13/05 08:57P (917)975-4500 BROOKLYN NY 1 0.00 144 09/13/05 09:21P (917)254-9726 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 145 09/13/05 09:21P (917)254-9726 NEWYORKZN1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 146 09/13/05 10:27P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 147 09/13/05 10:45P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 148 09/13/05 11:21P (917)975-4500 BROOKLYN NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 149 09/13/05 11:23P (917)975-4500 BROOKLYN NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 150 09/13/05 11:26P (917)975-4500 BROOKLYN NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 151 09/13/05 11:50P (917)476-9463 NEWYORKZN1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 152 09/13/05 11:55P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 153 09/13/05 11:55P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 154 09/14/05 12:21A (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use Or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 8 07/26/17 Page 13 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 14 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p14

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 155 09/14/05 12:22A (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 156 09/14/05 08:25A (561)317-5844 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 157 09/14/05 08:29A (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 158 09/14/05 08:58A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 159 09/14/05 09:03A (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 160 09/14/05 09:48A (212)750-1176 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 161 09/14/05 09:56A (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 162 09/14/05 09:58A (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 163 09/14/05 11:23A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 164 09/14/05 11:24A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 165 09/14/05 11:29A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 166 09/14/05 11:30A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 167 09/14/05 11:31A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 168 09/14/05 12:16P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 169 09/14/05 12:20P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 5 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 170 09/14/05 12:25P (212)837-2375 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 171 09/14/05 12:26P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 172 09/14/05 12:28P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 173 09/14/05 12:29P (212)750-9896 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 174 09/14/05 12:30P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 9 07/26/17 Page 14 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 15 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p15

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 175 09/14/05 12:33P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 176 09/14/05 12:37P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 177 09/14/05 12:38P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 178 09/14/05 12:42P (212)319-7775 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 179 09/14/05 12:45P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 180 09/14/05 01:28P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 181 09/14/05 01:43P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM WOOL TO MOBL 182 09/14/05 01:52P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 183 09/14/05 02:02P (212)838-9514 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 184 09/14/05 02:05P (212)746-5410 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 185 09/14/05 02:14P (917)476-9463 NEWYORKZN1 NY 5 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 186 09/14/05 02:22P (917)204-9696 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 187 09/14/05 02:26P (212)956-2888 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 188 09/14/05 02:36P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 189 09/14/05 02:40P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 190 09/14/05 02:42P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 5 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 191 09/14/05 03:15P (917)204-9696 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 192 09/14/05 03:30P (212)746-5410 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 193 09/14/05 03:39P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 10 07/26/17 Page 15 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 16 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p16

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingulaC Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 09/14/05 03:39P (917)855-3363 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO NOEL 194 09/14/05 03:43P 447785770009 mobile UK 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 1 0.28 ENH DISC INT DL $0.28 195 09/14/05 04:04P (212)750-1178 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 196 09/14/05 04:05P (212)750-9791 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 197 09/14/05 04:08P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 1 0.00 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 198 09/14/05 04:18P (212)838-9514 INCOMING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 199 09/14/05 05:02P (617)495-1953 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 200 09/14/05 05:05P (212)750-1176 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 201 09/14/05 05:08P (561)317-5844 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 202 09/14/05 05:12P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 203 09/14/05 05:13P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 204 09/14/05 05:35P (212)750-9894 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 205 09/14/05 05:39P (212)744-1600 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 206 09/14/05 05:42P (917)204-9696 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 207 09/14/05 05:54P (917)204-9696 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 208 09/14/05 06:17P (310)- INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 209 09/14/05 06:24P (617)491-4204 CAMBRIDGE MA 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 210 09/14/05 06:32P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 211 09/14/05 07:07P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 11 except under written agreement. I 07/26/17 Page 16 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 17 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p17

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular' Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 212 09/14/05 07:10P (203)966-1273 INCOMING 2 0.00 213 09/14/05 07:12P (617)491-4204 CAMBRIDGE MA 2 0.00 214 09/14/05 07:17P (617)491-4204 CAMBRIDGE MA 2 0.00 215 09/14/05 07:22P (917)204-9696 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 216 09/14/05 07:25P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 217 09/14/05 07:27P (561)317-5844 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 218 09/14/05 07:35P (561)317-5844 INCOMING 2 0.00 219 09/14/05 07:38P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 220 09/14/05 07:39P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 221 09/14/05 07:40P (646)824-5679 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 222 09/14/05 07:51P (917)254-9726 NEWYORKZN1 NY 3 0.00 223 09/14/05 07:54P (917)254-9726 NEWYORKZN1 NY 1 0.00 224 09/14/05 08:02P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 2 0.00 225 09/14/05 08:04P (212)288-4844 NEW YORK NY 5 0.00 226 09/14/05 08:12P 551181358000 mobile BRA 2 0.00 1 0.26 $0.26 227 09/14/05 08:17P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 1 0.00 228 09/14/05 08:30P (617)491-4204 INCOMING 4 0.00 229 09/14/05 08:57P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 230 09/14/05 09:05P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 231 09/14/05 09:07P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 232 09/14/05 09:25P (877)357-1263 Toll Free CL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 12 07/26/17 Page 17 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 18 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p18

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cmgular Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 233 09/14/05 09:33P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 234 09/14/05 10:57P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 235 09/14/05 11:01P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 236 09/14/05 11:32P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 9 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 237 09/15/05 09:01A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 238 09/15/05 09:49A (212)750-1178 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 239 09/15/05 10:17A (561)635-3454 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIM NOEL TO MOBL• 240 09/15/05 03:06P (917)406-0001 INCOMING 4 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 241 09/15/05 03:10P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 242 09/15/05 03:13P (212)772-0939 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 243 09/15/05 03:26P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 244 09/15/05 03:41P (212)472-6991 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 245 09/15/05 03:47P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 246 09/15/05 03:53P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 247 09/15/05 04:21P (212)355-3350 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 248 09/15/05 06:00P (808)754-0079 INCOMING 5 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 249 09/15/05 06:46P (808)754-0079 INCOMING 6 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 250 09/15/05 07:06P (212)355-3350 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 251 09/15/05 07:11P (917)972-5080 QUEENS NY 1 0.00 252 09/15/05 07:12P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Page 13 Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 18 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 19 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p19

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G :;:ccingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 253 09/15/05 07:21P (917)972-5080 INCOMING 1 0.00 254 09/15/05 07:35P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 255 09/15/05 08:59P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 1 0.00 256 09/15/05 09:14P (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 257 09/15/05 09:15P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 258 09/15/05 09:15P (212)444-8021 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 259 09/15/05 09:16P (212)772-3853 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 260 09/15/05 09:35P (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 261 09/15/05 10:16P (917)520-3106 INCOMING 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 262 09/16/05 09:36A (212)533-7910 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 263 09/16/05 09:37A (212)717-4144 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 264 09/16/05 10:23A (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 265 09/16/05 11:31A (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 266 09/16/05 11:32A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 267 09/16/05 11:34A (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 268 09/16/05 11:38A (808)754-0079 INCOMING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 269 09/16/05 11:43A (917)957-5341 INCOMING 5 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 270 09/16/05 12:18P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 271 09/16/05 12:18P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 10 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 14 07/26/17 Page 19 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 20 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p20

153497 BILLED USAGE 3G Mc Li V' t 12/14/2005 Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 272 09/16/05 12:28P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 273 09/16/05 01:18P (212)772-3853 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 274 09/16/05 01:42P (646)232-3311 NWYRCY2N01 NY 5 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 275 09/16/05 01:51P (212)750-9894 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 276 09/16/05 04:13P (808)754-0079 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 277 09/16/05 04:36P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 278 09/16/05 04:36P (212)449-9570 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 279 09/16/05 04:38P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 280 09/16/05 05:07P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 281 09/16/05 05:10P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 282 09/16/05 05:13P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 283 09/16/05 05:14P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 284 09/16/05 05:16P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 285 09/16/05 06:05P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 286 09/16/05 06:25P (808)754-0079 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 287 09/16/05 06:38P (212)472-6991 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 288 09/16/05 07:51P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 289 09/16/05 08:27P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 1 0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Page 15 Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 20 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 21 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p21

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingulaC Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 290 09/16/05 08:36P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 1 0.00 291 09/16/05 09:14P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 292 09/16/05 09:21P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 293 09/16/05 10:00P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 294 09/16/05 10:01P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 295 09/16/05 11:52P (808)754-0079 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 296 09/17/05 08:57A (212)772-0754 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 297 09/17/05 09:52A (808)754-0079 INCOMING 6 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 298 09/17/05 10:06A (212)772-9416 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 299 09/17/05 10:07A (646)369-7984 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 300 09/17/05 10:08A (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 301 09/17/05 10:17A (646)552-2805 NY ZONE 1 NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 302 09/17/05 11:33A (808)754-0079 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 303 09/17/05 11:47A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 304 09/17/05 11:50A (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 305 09/17/05 12:08P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 306 09/17/05 12:09P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 307 09/17/05 02:09P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 308 09/17/05 02:11P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 309 09/17/05 02:12P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 16 07/26/17 Page 21 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 22 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p22

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 310 09/17/05 02:14P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 311 09/17/05 02:17P (646)824-5679 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 312 09/17/05 02:17P (646)824-5679 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 313 09/17/05 02:19P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 314 09/17/05 02:19P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 315 09/17/05 02:24P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 316 09/17/05 02:29P 551181358000 mobile BRA 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 317 09/17/05 02:30P 551181358000 mobile BRA 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 318 09/17/05 02:34P (212)772-0939 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 319 09/17/05 02:45P (917)520-3106 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 320 09/17/05 02:46P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 321 09/17/05 02:49P (212)308-0011 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 322 09/17/05 03:14P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 323 09/17/05 03:18P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 324 09/17/05 04:06P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 325 09/17/05 04:08P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 326 09/17/05 04:09P (212)643-1274 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Page 17 Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 22 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 23 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p23

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 327 09/17/05 04:11P (212)472-6991 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 328 09/17/05 04:14P (201)363-2336 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 329 09/17/05 04:17P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 330 09/17/05 04:20P (212)472-6991 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 331 09/17/05 05:20P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 332 09/17/05 05:25P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 333 09/17/05 05:35P (212)643-1274 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 334 09/17/05 05:38P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 335 09/17/05 05:48P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 7 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 336 09/17/05 05:55P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 337 09/17/05 05:59P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 338 09/17/05 06:01P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 339 09/17/05 06:02P (646)369-7984 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 340 09/17/05 06:04P (212)772-9416 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 341 09/17/05 06:13P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 9 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 342 09/17/05 06:38P (917)806-5903 NEW YORK NY 7 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 343 09/17/05 06:38P (212)879-2670 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 6 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 344 09/17/05 07:20P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 18 07/26/17 Page 23 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 24 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p24

153497 BILLED USAGE 3G cincular 12/14/2005 Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 345 09/17/05 03:22P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 346 09/17/05 07:23P (718)707-9090 QUEENS NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 347 09/18/05 03:16A (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 348 09/18/05 08:56A (808)754-0079 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 349 09/18/05 09:39A (212)772-9416 INCOMING 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 350 09/18/05 09:44A (212)772-9416 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 351 09/18/05 09:46A (917)254-9726 NEWYORKZN1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 352 09/18/05 09:46A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 353 09/18/05 09:49A (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 354 09/18/05 09:51A (740)802-4061 MARION OH 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 355 09/18/05 09:55A (646)552-2805 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 356 09/18/05 09:57A (561)818-8361 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 357 09/18/05 09:58A (561)714-0546 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 358 09/18/05 09:59A (561)324-7996 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 359 09/18/05 10:00A WPALMBEACH FL 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 360 09/18/05 10:01A (516)457-4608 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 361 09/18/05 10:03A (561)801-3590 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 362 09/18/05 10:05A (561)662-3098 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 363 09/18/05 10:07A (917)975-4500 BROOKLYN NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 364 09/18/05 10:07A (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 365 09/18/05 10:09A (212)879-9366 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Page 19 Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 24 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 25 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p25

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 366 09/18/05 10:10A (212)472-6991 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 367 09/18/05 10:12A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 368 09/18/05 10:13A (786)246-6607 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 369 09/18/05 10:14A (718)707-9090 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 370 09/18/05 10:16A (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 371 09/18/05 10:17A (646)369-7984 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 372 09/18/05 10:19A (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 373 09/18/05 10:20A (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 374 09/18/05 10:22A (212)772-9416 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 375 09/18/05 10:25A (718)707-9090 QUEENS NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 376 09/18/05 10:26A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 377 09/18/05 10:27A (917)254-9726 NEWYORKZNI NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 378 09/18/05 10:29A (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 379 09/18/05 10:32A (212)772-3853 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 380 09/18/05 10:34A (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 381 09/18/05 10:38A (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 382 09/18/05 10:39A (917)254-9726 NEWYORKZN1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 383 09/18/05 10:40A (646)369-7984 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 384 09/18/05 10:40A (212)772-9416 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 20 07/26/17 Page 25 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 26 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p26

153497 BILLED USAGE 3G cingu ar 12/14/2005 Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 385 09/18/05 10:41A (646)369-7984 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 386 09/18/05 10:42A (646)369-7984 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 387 09/18/05 10:43A (917)254-9726 NEWYORKZN1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 388 09/18/05 10:44A (561)302-1844 BOCA RATON FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 389 09/18/05 10:46A (212)879-9366 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 390 09/18/05 10:48A (212)772-0754 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 391 09/18/05 10:48A (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 392 09/18/05 10:50A (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 393 09/18/05 10:52A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 394 09/18/05 10:54A (646)824-5679 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 395 09/18/05 11:59A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 396 09/18/05 12:02P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 397 09/18/05 12:03P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 398 09/18/05 12:05P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 399 09/18/05 12:06P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 400 09/18/05 12:19P (786)246-6607 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 401 09/18/05 12:26P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 402 09/18/05 12:28P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 9 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 403 09/18/05 12:41P (212)535-3030 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 21 07/26/17 Page 26 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 27 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p27

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 404 09/18/05 12:43P (914)669-4651 NORTHSALEM NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 405 09/18/05 12:46P (914)669-4651 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 406 09/18/05 12:48P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 407 09/18/05 12:51P (212)535-3030 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 408 09/18/05 12:53P (914)669-4651 NORTHSALEM NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 409 09/18/05 12:54P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 410 09/18/05 01:06P (212)535-3030 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 411 09/18/05 01:10P (561)389-6874 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 412 09/18/05 02:57P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 7 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 413 09/18/05 02:58P (808)754-0079 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 414 09/18/05 03:05P (646)232-3311 NWYRCY2N01 NY 17 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 415 09/18/05 03:21P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 416 09/18/05 04:03P (917)204-9696 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 417 09/18/05 04:05P (917)597-8141 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 418 09/18/05 04:10P (561)389-6874 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 419 09/18/05 04:10P (561)389-6874 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 420 09/18/05 04:15P (561)302-1844 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 421 09/18/05 04:31P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 422 09/18/05 05:10P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 423 09/18/05 05:17P (561)324-7996 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 22 07/26/17 Page 27 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 28 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p28

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 424 09/18/05 05:35P (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 425 09/18/05 05:38P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 426 09/18/05 06:28P (917)520-3106 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 427 09/18/05 09:37P (561)714-0546 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 428 09/18/05 09:37P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 429 09/18/05 09:45P (561)714-0546 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 430 09/19/05 09:13A (808)754-0079 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 431 09/19/05 09:41A (000)000-0000 INCOMING 5 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 432 09/19/05 10:29A (561)801-3590 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 433 09/19/05 10:46A (212)750-1178 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 434 09/19/05 11:45A (561)324-7996 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 435 09/19/05 12:27P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 436 09/19/05 12:41P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 437 09/19/05 01:39P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 438 09/19/05 01:43P (212)879-9366 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 439 09/19/05 01:548 (561)655-7626 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 440 09/19/05 02:01P (561)776-5679 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 441 09/19/05 02:24P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 442 09/19/05 02:55P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 23 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 28 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 29 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p29

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 09/19/05 02:55P (917)855-3363 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 443 09/19/05 05:11P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 444 09/19/05 05:42P (212)535-3030 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 445 09/19/05 06:53P (212)879-2670 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 446 09/19/05 09:09P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 447 09/19/05 09:15P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 DROP CALL CREDIT 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 448 09/20/05 12:10A (561)635-3454 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 449 09/20/05 08:59A (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 450 09/20/05 09:25A (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 451 09/20/05 09:27A (212)838-9514 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 452 09/20/05 09:39A (786)246-6607 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 453 09/20/05 09:47A (212)750-1176 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 454 09/20/05 10:41A (646)369-7984 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 455 09/20/05 10:44A (212)750-9894 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 456 09/20/05 11:18A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO NOEL 457 09/20/05 11:56A (516)759-2661 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 458 09/20/05 11:59A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 459 09/20/05 12:24P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 24 07/26/17 Page 29 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 30 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p30

153497 BILLED USAGE 3G cinoular 12/14/2005 Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 09/20/05 12:24P (917)855-3363 3 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 460 09/20/05 12:27P (212)750-1178 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 461 09/20/05 12:27P (212)750-9896 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 462 09/20/05 12:28P (212)449-9570 NEW YORK NY 12 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 463 09/20/05 12:44P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 464 09/20/05 12:45P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 465 09/20/05 12:48P (808)754-0079 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 466 09/20/05 12:49P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 467 09/20/05 01:19P (561)309-0079 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 468 09/20/05 01:57P (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 469 09/20/05 01:58P (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 470 09/20/05 02:01P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 471 09/20/05 03:19P (646)552-2805 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 472 09/20/05 03:21P (212)838-9514 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 473 09/20/05 03:34P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 474 09/20/05 03:35P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 DROP CALL CREDIT 475 09/20/05 03:42P (212)838-9514 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 476 09/20/05 03:96P (786)246-6607 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 477 09/20/05 04:01P (212)750-1178 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 478 09/20/05 05:16P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 25 07/26/17 Page 30 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 31 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p31

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Rate Charge Description Charge Used 09/20/05 05:16P (917)855-3363 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 479 09/20/05 05:16P (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 480 09/20/05 07:20P (561)317-5844 INCOMING 1 0.00 481 09/20/05 07:21P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 1 0.00 482 09/20/05 07:22P (561)317-5844 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 483 09/20/05 07:22P (561)317-5844 INCOMING 1 0.00 484 09/20/05 10:38P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 485 09/20/05 10:41P (646)552-2805 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 486 09/21/05 12:14A (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 487 09/21/05 12:19A (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 488 09/21/05 12:45A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 489 09/21/05 06:51A (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 490 09/21/05 10:47A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 491 09/21/05 10:48A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 492 09/21/05 01:24P (917)406-0001 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 493 09/21/05 01:27P (917)406-0001 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 494 09/21/05 01:46P (561)818-8361 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 495 09/21/05 01:47P (561)655-7626 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 26 07/26/17 Page 31 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 32 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p32

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 496 09/21/05 01:48P (561)655-7626 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 497 09/21/05 02:03P (617)495-3932 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 498 09/21/05 02:03P (617)495-3932 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 499 09/21/05 02:16P (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 500 09/21/05 02:18P (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 501 09/21/05 02:19P (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 502 09/21/05 02:24P (617)495-3932 INCOMING 2 3.49 $6.98 503 09/21/05 06:56P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 504 09/21/05 07:00P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 505 09/22/05 11:04A (917)868-6145 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 506 09/22/05 05:19P (000)000-0000 INCOMING 2 3.49 $6.98 507 09/22/05 05:20P (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 508 09/23/05 01:48P (390)283-7266 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 509 09/23/05 02:06P (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 510 09/23/05 02:35P (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 511 09/23/05 07:57P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 512 09/24/05 06:23A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 513 09/24/05 10:37A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/wKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 27 07/26/17 Page 32 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 33 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p33

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 514 09/24/05 10:39A (917)576-7664 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 515 09/24/05 10:40A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 516 09/24/05 10:54A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 517 09/24/05 11:06A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 518 09/24/05 11:08A (917)476-9463 NEWYORKZN1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 519 09/24/05 11:10A (917)476-9463 NEWYORKZN1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 520 09/24/05 11:11A (917)476-9463 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 521 09/24/05 11:13A (646)235-5352 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 522 09/24/05 11:39A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 523 09/24/05 11:40A (212)472-6991 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 524 09/24/05 11:41A (917)690-8794 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 525 09/24/05 11:43A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 526 09/24/05 11:43A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 527 09/24/05 11:56A (917)576-7664 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 528 09/24/05 12:08P (917)690-8794 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 529 09/24/05 12:08P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 530 09/24/05 12:09P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 28 07/26/17 Page 33 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 34 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p34

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G • ongularrz Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 531 09/24/05 12:09P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 532 09/24/05 12:22P (917)690-8794 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 533 09/24/05 12:23P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 534 09/24/05 12:28P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 535 09/24/05 12:32P (212)696-2315 INCOMING 21 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 536 09/24/05 12:54P (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 537 09/24/05 01:06P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 538 09/24/05 01:18P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 539 09/24/05 01:37P (917)806-5903 INCOMING 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 540 09/24/05 01:50P (201)555-1212 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 1.50 411 INFO $1.50 541 09/24/05 01:52P (201)555-1212 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 1.50 411 INFO $1.50 542 09/24/05 02:03P (877)877-0987 Toll Free CL 10 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 543 09/24/05 02:24P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 544 09/24/05 04:42P (212)696-2315 INCOMING 6 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 545 09/24/05 05:04P (646)286-7000 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 546 09/24/05 05:09P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 547 09/24/05 05:41P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 9 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 548 09/24/05 06:27P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 549 09/24/05 06:40P (212)772-0745 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 550 09/24/05 06:42P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 29 07/26/17 Page 34 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 35 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p35

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 551 09/24/05 06:43P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 552 09/24/05 07:31P (917)476-9463 NEWYORKZN1 NY 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 553 09/24/05 08:56P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 554 09/24/05 08:58P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 555 09/24/05 09:08P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 556 09/24/05 09:49P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 557 09/24/05 10:23P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 15 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 558 09/24/05 10:37P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 8 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WEND MIN 559 09/25/05 08:40A (917)476-9463 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 560 09/25/05 08:56A (917)476-9463 NEWYORKZN1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 561 09/25/05 12:14P (917)576-7664 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 562 09/25/05 12:19P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 563 09/25/05 12:33P (954)647-2020 FTLAUDERDL FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 564 09/25/05 12:34P (917)716-9111 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 565 09/25/05 01:19P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 566 09/25/05 02:53P (917)576-7664 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 567 09/25/05 03:25P (646)552-2805 NY ZONE 1 NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 568 09/25/05 04:05P (614)406-3737 COLUMBUS OH 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 569 09/25/05 04:05P (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 570 09/25/05 04:15P (917)520-3106 INCOMING 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 571 09/25/05 04:20P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 572 09/25/05 04:20P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 30 07/26/17 Page 35 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 36 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p36

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 573 09/25/05 04:22P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 574 09/25/05 04:23P (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 575 09/25/05 04:27P (917)975-4500 BROOKLYN NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 576 09/25/05 04:49P (614)939-3000 NEW ALBANY OH 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 577 09/25/05 05:02P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 578 09/25/05 06:11P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 579 09/25/05 06:13P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 DROP CALL CREDIT 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 580 09/25/05 06:20P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 581 09/25/05 06:21P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 582 09/25/05 06:31P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 583 09/25/05 06:53P (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 584 09/25/05 08:29P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 585 09/25/05 09:12P (212)752-8883 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 586 09/25/05 09:20P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 587 09/25/05 09:21P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 588 09/25/05 09:28P (212)752-8883 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 589 09/25/05 11:46P (212)879-2670 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 590 09/26/05 08:25A (212)772-0754 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 31 07/26/17 Page 36 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 37 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p37

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 591 09/26/05 08:26A (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 592 09/26/05 08:27A (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 593 09/26/05 08:27A (212)444-8021 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 594 09/26/05 08:28A (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 595 09/26/05 08:30A (646)552-2805 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 596 09/26/05 09:44A (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 17 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 597 09/26/05 10:07A (212)750-9894 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 598 09/26/05 10:50A (212)772-0754 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 599 09/26/05 12:34P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 600 09/26/05 12:37P (917)254-9726 NEWYORKZN1 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 601 09/26/05 12:39P 37068443002 mobile LTU 5 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 4 0.40 51.60 602 09/26/05 12:43P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 603 09/26/05 12:43P (786)246-6607 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 604 09/26/05 12:44P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 605 09/26/05 12:56P (212)746-5410 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 606 09/26/05 01:05P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 607 09/26/05 01:37P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 608 09/26/05 01:38P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 6 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 609 09/26/05 02:52P (212)750-9790 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 610 09/26/05 04:15P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 611 09/26/05 05:05P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 32 07/26/17 Page 37 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 38 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p38

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 612 09/26/05 05:07P (212)779-8800 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 613 09/26/05 05:08P (212)449-9570 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 614 09/26/05 05:22P (212)750-9894 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 615 09/26/05 06:05P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 616 09/26/05 07:41P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 617 09/26/05 07:42P (917)476-9463 NEWYORKZN1 NY 2 0.00 618 09/26/05 08:19P (917)476-9463 INCOMING 3 0.00 619 09/26/05 08:32P (212)255-2221 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 620 09/26/05 08:33P (212)677-4555 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 621 09/26/05 08:36P (212)677-4555 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 622 09/26/05 08:56P (212)677-4555 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 623 09/26/05 10:02P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 624 09/26/05 10:03P (212)444-8021 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 625 09/27/05 08:17A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 626 09/27/05 08:52A (646)824-5679 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 627 09/27/05 08:53A (646)824-5679 INCOMING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 628 09/27/05 08:57A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 629 09/27/05 08:59A (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 630 09/27/05 09:11A (212)249-1113 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 631 09/27/05 09:17A (212)272-6221 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 632 09/27/05 09:19A (212)750-1178 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 633 09/27/05 10:25A (212)838-9514 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 634 09/27/05 10:25A (212)997-0150 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAIT:NG MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENT/AL Page 33 Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 38 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 39 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p39

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 09/27/05 10:25A (212)997-0150 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 635 09/27/05 10:39A (617)496-4737 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 636 09/27/05 10:40A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 637 09/27/05 11:18A (212)838-9514 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 638 09/27/05 11:30A (617)496-4683 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 639 09/27/05 11:34A (718)707-9090 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 640 09/27/05 11:39A (740)802-4061 MARION OH 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 641 09/27/05 12:06P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 642 09/27/05 01:03P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 643 09/27/05 01:20P (212)449-9570 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 644 09/27/05 02:33P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 645 09/27/05 02:38P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 646 09/27/05 03:01P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 647 09/27/05 03:04P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 648 09/27/05 03:27P (212)750-1178 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 649 09/27/05 03:39P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 650 09/27/05 04:13P (786)246-6607 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 651 09/27/05 05:49P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 652 09/27/05 06:37P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 653 09/27/05 09:23P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 654 09/28/05 08:52A (212)838-9514 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 655 09/28/05 09:11A (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 656 09/28/05 09:47A (646)824-5679 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 34 07/26/17 Page 39 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 40 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p40

153497 BILLED USAGE 3G cinc ular® 12/14/2005 Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 657 09/28/05 10:50A (212)750-1176 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 658 09/28/05 11:13A (212)535-3030 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 659 09/28/05 11:29A (561)844-4112 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 660 09/28/05 11:31A (212)535-3030 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 661 09/28/05 12:06P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 662 09/28/05 12:07P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 663 09/28/05 12:11P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 664 09/28/05 12:13P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 665 09/28/05 12:47P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 666 09/28/05 12:50P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 667 09/28/05 07:08P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 668 09/28/05 07:10P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 669 09/28/05 07:36P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 670 09/28/05 08:56P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 671 09/28/05 08:57P (917)406-0001 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 672 09/28/05 09:00P (212)524-9334 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 673 09/29/05 09:OOA (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO NOEL 674 09/29/05 09:OOA (212)750-1176 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 675 09/29/05 09:03A (212)750-1176 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 676 09/29/05 09:06A (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 677 09/29/05 09:07A (561)818-8361 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 678 09/29/05 11:14A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 35 07/26/17 Page 40 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 41 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p41

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 679 09/29/05 11:22A (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 680 09/29/05 11:25A (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 681 09/29/05 11:26A (740)802-4061 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 682 09/29/05 11:30A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MuBL TO MOBL 683 09/29/05 11:35A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 684 09/29/05 11:37A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 685 09/29/05 11:50A (212)750-1178 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 686 09/29/05 11:56A (212)772-0754 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 687 09/29/05 11:58A (212)750-1178 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 688 09/29/05 12:03P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 5 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 689 09/29/05 12:08P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 690 09/29/05 12:08P (781)308-3269 RANDOLPH MA 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 691 09/29/05 12:27P (212)772-9416 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 692 09/29/05 12:39P (917)204-9696 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 693 09/29/05 12:41P WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 694 09/29/05 12:43P (561)324-7996 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 695 09/29/05 12:46P INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO NOEL 696 09/29/05 12:47P (561)324-7996 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 697 09/29/05 12:48P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 698 09/29/05 12:51P (917)520-3106 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO NOEL 699 09/29/05 01:43P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 700 09/29/05 01:47P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 36 07/26/17 Page 41 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 42 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p42

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 701 09/29/05 01:49P (646)824-5679 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 702 09/29/05 01:58P (646)824-5679 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 703 09/29/05 02:15P (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 704 09/29/05 02:16P (646)414-6627 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 9 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 705 09/29/05 02:27P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 706 09/29/05 02:30P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIM NOEL TO MOBL 707 09/29/05 02:43P (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 708 09/29/05 05:17P (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 709 09/29/05 06:41P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO NOEL 710 09/29/05 06:50P (212)772-9416 INCOMING 1 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 711 09/29/05 07:45P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 712 09/29/05 07:47P (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 713 09/29/05 07:49P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 1 0.00 714 09/29/05 07:49P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 715 09/29/05 07:50P (917)204-9696 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 716 09/29/05 07:51P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 717 09/29/05 07:52P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 718 09/29/05 07:56P (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 2 0.00 719 09/29/05 07:57P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 3 0.00 720 09/29/05 08:45P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 721 09/29/05 08:45P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 37 07/26/17 Page 42 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 43 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p43

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingu ar' Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 722 09/29/05 08:47P (917)406-0001 NEW YORK NY 9 0.00 723 09/29/05 08:53P (212)524-9334 INCOMING 1 0.00 724 09/29/05 08:54P (212)524-9334 INCOMING 2 0.00 725 09/29/05 08:57P (212)524-9334 INCOMING 3 0.00 726 09/29/05 09:11P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 727 09/29/05 10:35P (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 728 09/30/05 09:04A (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 729 09/30/05 09:13A (561)655-7629 INCOMING 2 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 730 09/30/05 09:40A (646)496-3248 NEWYORKZN1 NY 4 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 731 09/30/05 09:44A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO NOEL 732 09/30/05 09:45A (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 733 09/30/05 10:14A (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 15 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 734 09/30/05 10:29A (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 735 09/30/05 10:29A (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 736 09/30/05 10:29A (561)655-7629 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 5 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 737 09/30/05 10:34A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 738 09/30/05 10:34A (561)655-7629 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 739 09/30/05 10:35A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 740 09/30/05 12:56P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO NOEL 741 09/30/05 02:37P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 742 09/30/05 02:45P (636)980-4337 INCOMING 5 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cinguiar Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 38 07/26/17 Page 43 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 44 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p44

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingu i ar Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 743 09/30/05 02:49P (212)449-9570 NEW YORK NY 8 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 744 09/30/05 06:52P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 4 0.00 9 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 745 09/30/05 07:06P (561)324-7996 INCOMING 1 0.00 746 09/30/05 07:14P 447836747546 mobile UK 1 0.00 1 0.28 ENH DISC INT DL $0.28 747 09/30/05 07:22P (646)496-3248 INCOMING 2 0.00 748 09/30/05 07:40P (212)734-5270 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 749 09/30/05 08:04P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 1 0.00 750 09/30/05 09:18P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 751 09/30/05 09:40P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 31 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 752 10/01/05 08:23A (631)283-4600 SOUTHAMPTN NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 753 10/01/05 09:33A (561)635-3454 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 754 10/01/05 09:35A (561)635-3454 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 755 10/01/05 09:44A (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 756 10/01/05 09:45A (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 757 10/01/05 10:13A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 758 10/01/05 11:15A (561)574-0400 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 759 10/01/05 11:45A (740)802-4061 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 760 10/01/05 04:04P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 761 10/01/05 04:53P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 39 07/26/17 Page 44 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 45 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p45

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G singular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 10/01/05 04:53P (917)855-3363 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 762 10/01/05 09:12P WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 763 10/01/05 09:43P (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 764 10/01/05 09:46P (561)856-2617 PALM BEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 765 10/02/05 01:29A (917)913-6283 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 766 10/02/05 10:31A (561)776-8748 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 767 10/02/05 10:34A (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 768 10/02/05 10:35A (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 769 10/02/05 11:04A (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 770 10/02/05 11:05A 447836747546 mobile UK 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 1 0.25 ENH DISC INT DL $0.25 771 10/02/05 11:05A (917)873-9156 BROOKLYN NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 772 10/02/05 11:13A (212)753-9500 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 773 10/02/05 11:14A (917)806-5903 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 774 10/02/05 11:22A (763)442-0904 TWINCITIES MN 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 775 10/02/05 11:33A (212)645-3189 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 776 10/02/05 11:34A (212)645-3189 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 777 10/02/05 11:37A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 778 10/02/05 11:40A (561)856-2617 PALM BEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 779 10/02/05 11:41A PALM BEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN - 780 10/02/05 11:42A (561)324-7996 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 781 10/02/05 11:43A (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 40 07/26/17 Page 45 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 46 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p46

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingu a Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 782 10/02/05 11:57A 447836747546 mobile UK 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 1 0.25 ENH DISC INT DL $0.25 783 10/02/05 11:58A (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 784 10/02/05 11:58A (919)741-1869 RALEIGH NC 39 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 785 10/02/05 01:25P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 786 10/02/05 02:04P (646)496-3248 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 787 10/02/05 02:37P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 788 10/02/05 02:39P (646)496-3248 NEWYORKZN1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 789 10/02/05 02:45P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 790 10/02/05 03:03P (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 791 10/02/05 03:08P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 792 10/02/05 03:30P (561)655-7626 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 793 10/02/05 03:36P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 794 10/02/05 03:37P (310)210-9944 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 795 10/02/05 03:40P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 796 10/02/05 03:53P (917)957-5341 INCOMING 11 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 797 10/02/05 04:04P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 798 10/02/05 04:06P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 799 10/02/05 04:12P (646)232-3311 INCOMING 18 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 41 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 46 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 47 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p47

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingula Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 800 10/02/05 04:32P INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 801 10/02/05 04:33P PALM BEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 802 10/02/05 04:38P (310)210-9944 INCOMING 8 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 803 10/02/05 04:45P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 804 10/02/05 05:07P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 805 10/02/05 05:18P (212)945-7106 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 806 10/02/05 05:19P (646)496-3248 NEWYORKZN1 NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 807 10/02/05 05:26P (212)945-7106 INCOMING 7 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 808 10/02/05 05:41P (646)824-5679 NY ZONE 1 NY 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 809 10/02/05 05:50P (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 810 10/02/05 05:53P (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 811 10/02/05 05:54P (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 812 10/02/05 05:57P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 813 10/02/05 05:58P (646)207-8154 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 814 10/02/05 06:02P (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 815 10/02/05 06:51P WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 816 10/02/05 07:43P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 817 10/02/05 07:44P (646)496-3248 NEWYORKZN1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 818 10/02/05 07:46P (646)496-3248 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 819 10/02/05 08:32P (212)260-5588 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 42 07/26/17 Page 47 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 48 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p48

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingulaC Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 820 10/02/05 09:38P (561)662-3098 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 821 10/02/05 09:47P (561)662-3098 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 822 10/03/05 08:58A (212)753-9500 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 823 10/03/05 09:02A (212)750-9894 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 824 10/03/05 09:07A (561)302-1844 BOCA RATON FL 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 825 10/03/05 09:10A (561)389-6874 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 826 10/03/05 09:11A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 827 10/03/05 09:11A (561)302-1844 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 828 10/03/05 09:12A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 829 10/03/05 09:13A (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 830 10/03/05 09:14A (561)655-7629 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 831 10/03/05 09:37A WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL : 832 10/03/05 09:38A (561)655-0995 WPALMBEACH FL 7 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 833 10/03/05 09:45A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 834 10/03/05 09:52A PALM BEACH FL 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 835 10/03/05 09:53A (561)965-1574 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 836 10/03/05 09:55A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 837 10/03/05 09:55A PALM BEACH FL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 838 10/03/05 09:57A (561)655-7629 WPALMBEACH FL 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 839 10/03/05 10:00A (614)939-6005 NEW ALBANY OH 6 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 43 07/26/17 Page 48 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 49 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p49

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 840 10/03/05 10:24A (212)535-3030 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 841 10/03/05 11:21A INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 842 10/03/05 12:09P (331)401-3000 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 843 10/03/05 12:11P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 844 10/03/05 12:19P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 845 10/03/05 12:19P (917)690-8794 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 846 10/03/05 12:35P (447)836-7475 INCOMING 15 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 847 10/03/05 12:50P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 848 10/03/05 01:38P (917)406-0001 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 849 10/03/05 01:40P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 850 10/03/05 01:41P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 851 10/03/05 01:45P (561)655-7629 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 852 10/03/05 01:52P (212)249-1122 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 853 10/03/05 01:53P (917)957-5341 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 854 10/03/05 02:24P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 855 10/03/05 02:49P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 856 10/03/05 03:45P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 857 10/03/05 03:48P 33155280820 FRANCE 9 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Page 44 Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 49 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 50 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p50

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 10/03/05 03:48P 33155280820 2 Calls To Mins Used 9 Rate 0.07 Charge Description Charge 50.63 858 10/03/05 03:57P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 859 10/03/05 04:00P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 860 10/03/05 04:01P (561)324-7996 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 861 10/03/05 04:02P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 862 10/03/05 07:26P (212)941-3838 INCOMING 1 0.00 863 10/03/05 07:27P (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 864 10/03/05 07:28P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 865 10/03/05 07:29P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 866 10/03/05 07:34P (212)752-8883 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 867 10/03/05 07:36P (212)628-8419 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 868 10/03/05 09:14P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 869 10/04/05 06:59A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 870 10/04/05 08:26A (212)838-9514 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 871 10/04/05 08:50A (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 872 10/04/05 08:54A (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 873 10/04/05 08:55A (917)975-4500 BROOKLYN NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 874 10/04/05 08:56A (917)975-4500 BROOKLYN NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 875 10/04/05 09:27A (201)555-1212 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 1.50 411 INFO 51.50 876 10/04/05 09:29A (212)888-8383 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 877 10/04/05 09:36A WPALMBEACH FL 6 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 878 10/04/05 09:47A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 45 07/26/17 Page 50 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 51 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p51

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cincula Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 879 10/04/05 09:48A (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 880 10/04/05 09:54A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 881 10/04/05 10:32A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 882 10/04/05 10:33A (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 883 10/04/05 10:34A (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 884 10/04/05 10:35A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 885 10/04/05 10:37A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 4 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 886 10/04/05 10:43A (740)802-4061 MARION OH 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 887 10/04/05 10:45A (212)519-5600 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 888 10/04/05 10:53A (212)750-9896 INCOMING 9 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 889 10/04/05 10:58A LAKE WORTH FL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 890 10/04/05 11:08A (561)655-7626 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 891 10/04/05 11:14A (212)750-9895 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 892 10/04/05 11:15A ( . INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL ' 893 10/04/05 11:16A (561)655-0995 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 894 10/04/05 11:21A (212)879-9366 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 895 10/04/05 11:26A (212)327-3200 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 896 10/04/05 11:26A (914)555-1212 6 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 1.50 411 INFO $1.50 897 10/04/05 11:33A (917)406-0001 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 898 10/04/05 11:36A (917)406-0001 NEW YORE NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 899 10/04/05 11:37A (917)406-0001 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 900 10/04/05 01:48P (212)249-8510 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 46 07/26/17 Page 51 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 52 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p52

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 901 10/04/05 02:37P (646)232-3311 NWYRCY2N01 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 902 10/04/05 02:49P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 903 10/04/05 02:49P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 904 10/04/05 02:50P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 905 10/04/05 03:22P (212)594-4800 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 906 10/04/05 03:24P (212)249-1113 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 907 10/04/05 03:37P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 908 10/04/05 03:41P (212)535-5611 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 909 10/04/05 03:56P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 910 10/04/05 03:57P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 911 10/04/05 04:30P _. WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 912 10/04/05 04:31P (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 913 10/04/05 04:44P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 914 10/04/05 07:00P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 915 10/04/05 07:02P (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 1 0.00 916 10/04/05 07:03P (212)645-3189 INCOMING 15 0.00 917 10/04/05 07:28P (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 3 0.00 918 10/04/05 07:41P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 919 10/04/05 07:53P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 2 0.00 920 10/04/05 08:13P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 921 10/04/05 08:34P (212)772-9416 INCOMING 1 0.00 922 10/04/05 08:35P (561)635-3454 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 " 923 10/04/05 08:35P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 47 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 52 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 53 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p53

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G ;N cingular° Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Wins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 924 10/05/05 09:48A (340)774-1611 CHTAMSTTHS VI 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 925 10/05/05 10:32A (212)535-3030 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 926 10/05/05 10:57A (212)319-7775 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 927 10/05/05 11:01A (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 928 10/05/05 11:01A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 7 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 929 10/05/05 11:11A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 6 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 930 10/05/05 11:17A (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 931 10/05/05 11:17A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 932 10/05/05 11:19A (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 933 10/05/05 11:20A (212)879-9366 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 934 10/05/05 11:36A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME. MIN 935 10/05/05 11:58A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 936 10/05/05 12:01P (212)535-6831 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 937 10/05/05 12:04P (212)879-9366 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 938 10/05/05 12:07P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 939 10/05/05 12:45P (212)997-1516 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 940 10/05/05 12:49P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 941 10/05/05 01:48P (212)750-9791 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 942 10/05/05 01:51P (212)746-5410 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 943 10/05/05 03:33P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 944 10/05/05 03:37P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 945 10/05/05 03:38P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 48 07/26/17 Page 53 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 54 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p54

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G ,cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To tuns Used Rate Charge Description Charge 946 10/05/05 03:42P (718)707-9090 QUEENS NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 947 10/05/05 03:56P (917)690-8794 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 948 10/05/05 03:57P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 949 10/05/05 04:02P (212)535-3030 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 950 10/05/05 04:10P (310)918-3076 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 951 10/05/05 04:31P (212)449-9570 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 952 10/05/05 04:42P (646)552-2805 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 953 10/05/05 05:13P (917)690-8794 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 954 10/05/05 05:25P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 955 10/05/05 05:28P (212)535-3030 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 956 10/05/05 05:45P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 957 10/05/05 05:46P 33155280820 FRANCE 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 1 0.07 $0.07 958 10/05/05 05:48P (917)406-0001 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 959 10/05/05 07:24P (646)232-3311 INCOMING 15 0.00 960 10/05/05 07:49P (212)879-9366 INCOMING 3 0.00 961 10/05/05 08:44P (646)286-7000 INCOMING 4 0.00 962 10/05/05 08:50P (212)367-7200 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 49 07/26/17 Page 54 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 55 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p55

153497 BILLED USAGE 3G cinc uiar® 12/14/2005 Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS GPRS Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Qty Used Charge Description Charge 1 09/22/05 57 KB NO DETAIL $0.00 2 10/01/05 1 KB INCLUDED IN PLAN MB $0.00 3 10/01/05 105 KB INCLUDED IN PLAN MB $0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Page 50 Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 55 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 56 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p56

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular' Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Text/Multimedia Msgs For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Sent To Rcvd From 2 Charge Description Charge 1 09/03/05 07:51A (646)232-3311 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 2 09/03/05 07:53A (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 3 09/03/05 08:53A (646)232-3311 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 4 09/03/05 09:10A (646)232-3311 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 5 09/11/05 11:17A (917)254-9726 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 6 09/11/05 12:00P (917)825-3694 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 7 09/11/05 12:07P (917)825-3694 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 8 09/11/05 12:08P (917)868-6145 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 9 09/11/05 04:30P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 10 09/12/05 06:03P 447836747546 (917)855-3363 INTL TEXT MSG $0.25 11 09/12/05 06:12P (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 12 09/12/05 06:28P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 13 09/12/05 06:41P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 14 09/12/05 06:44P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 15 09/12/05 07:21P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 16 09/12/05 07:26P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 17 09/12/05 07:36P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 18 09/12/05 07:42P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 19 09/12/05 09:07P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 20 09/12/05 09:41P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 21 09/12/05 11:30P (781)308-3269 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 22 09/13/05 03:16P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 23 09/13/05 08:40P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 51 07/26/17 Page 56 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 57 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p57

153497 BILLED USAGE 3G cingu ar 12/14/2005 Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Text/Multimedia Msgs For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Sent To Rcvd From 2 Charge Description Charge 24 09/13/05 08:42P (917)254-9726 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 25 09/13/05 08:43P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 26 09/13/05 08:45P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 27 09/13/05 08:59P (917)254-9726 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 28 09/13/05 09:35P (917)254-9726 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 29 09/13/05 09:39P (917)254-9726 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 30 09/13/05 09:43P (917)254-9726 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 31 09/13/05 09:51P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 32 09/13/05 10:03P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 33 09/13/05 10:47P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 34 09/13/05 10:51P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 35 09/13/05 10:52P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 36 09/13/05 10:54P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 37 09/13/05 11:01P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 38 09/13/05 11:07P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 39 09/13/05 11:17P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 40 09/13/05 11:29P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 41 09/13/05 11:51P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 42 09/14/05 05:55P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 43 09/14/05 05:57P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 44 09/14/05 06:07P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 45 09/14/05 07:07P (917)204-9696 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 46 09/14/05 07:22P (917)254-9726 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 52 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 57 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 58 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p58

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G u a r Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Text/Multimedia Msgs For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Sent To Rcvd From 2 Charge Description Charge 47 09/14/05 07:53P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 48 09/14/05 08:11P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 49 09/14/05 08:14P (917)254-9726 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 50 09/14/05 08:19P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 51 09/14/05 08:34P (917)204-9696 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 52 09/14/05 08:55P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 53 09/14/05 09:10P (917)204-9696 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 54 09/14/05 10:17P (917)204-9696 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 55 09/14/05 10:24P (917)204-9696 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 56 09/14/05 11:09P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 57 09/15/05 05:30P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 58 09/15/05 06:26P (917)806-5903 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 59 09/15/05 06:26P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 60 09/15/05 07:30P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 61 09/15/05 07:37P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 62 09/15/05 07:46P (646)232-3311 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 63 09/15/05 07:48P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 64 09/15/05 07:48P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 65 09/15/05 07:59P (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 66 09/15/05 08:53P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 67 09/15/05 08:56P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 68 09/15/05 09:03P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 69 09/15/05 09:24P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 53 07/26/17 Page 58 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 59 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p59

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingu Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Text/Multimedia Msgs For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Sent To Rcvd From 2 Charge Description Charge 70 09/16/05 06:42P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 71 09/16/05 08:39P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 72 09/16/05 10:21P (646)232-3311 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 73 09/17/05 02:13P (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 74 09/17/05 02:42P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 75 09/17/05 02:44P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 76 09/17/05 05:23P (917)406-0001 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 77 09/17/05 05:27P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 78 09/17/05 05:29P (917)406-0001 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 79 09/17/05 06:05P (917)254-9726 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 80 09/17/05 08:12P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 81 09/17/05 08:15P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 82 09/17/05 08:38P (310)210-9944 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 83 09/17/05 09:46P (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 84 09/17/05 10:10P (917)806-5903 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 85 09/18/05 08:11A (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 86 09/18/05 10:24A (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 87 09/18/05 04:26P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 88 09/18/05 04:33P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 89 09/18/05 09:39P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 90 09/18/05 09:48P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 91 09/19/05 10:51A (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 92 09/19/05 09:20P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 54 07/26/17 Page 59 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 60 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p60

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cinmiar ,) - Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Text/Multimedia Msgs For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Sent To Rcvd From 2 Charge Description Charge 93 09/19/05 09:24P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 94 09/19/05 10:52P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 95 09/19/05 11:15P (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 96 09/20/05 09:16A (646)369-7984 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 97 09/20/05 11:3IA (561)543-7513 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 98 09/20/05 10:39P (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 99 09/20/05 11:29P (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 100 09/20/05 11:37P (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 101 09/20/05 11:59P (917)855-3363 INTL ROAM TEXT MSG $0.50 102 09/21/05 12:00A (917)855-3363 INTL ROAM TEXT MSG $0.50 103 09/21/05 12:4IA (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 104 09/21/05 06:10A (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 105 09/21/05 10:25A (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 106 09/21/05 07:00P (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 107 09/21/05 09:47P (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 108 09/21/05 09:48P (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 109 09/21/05 09:50P (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 110 09/22/05 07:51P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 $0.00 111 09/24/05 10:57A (917)806-5903 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 112 09/24/05 11:14A (781)308-3269 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 113 09/24/05 11:18A (917)806-5903 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 114 09/24/05 11:21A (781)308-3269 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 115 09/24/05 11:23A (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 55 07/26/17 Page 60 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 61 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p61

153497 BILLED USAGE 3G cinc u ar 12/14/2005 Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Text/Multimedia Msgs For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Sent To Rcvd From 2 Charge Description Charge 116 09/24/05 06:42P (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 117 09/25/05 09:51A (917)214-7223 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 118 09/25/05 09:52A (917)214-7223 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 119 09/25/05 09:52A (917)214-7223 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 120 09/25/05 09:52A (917)214-7223 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 121 09/25/05 09:52A (917)214-7223 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 122 09/25/05 09:52A (917)214-7223 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 123 09/25/05 09:55A (917)214-7223 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 124 09/25/05 09:55A (917)214-7223 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 125 09/25/05 09:56A (917)214-7223 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 126 09/25/05 09:57A (917)214-7223 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 127 09/25/05 09:58A (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 128 09/25/05 10:13A (917)214-7223 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 129 09/25/05 10:15A (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 130 09/25/05 10:23A (917)214-7223 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 131 09/25/05 10:35A (561)543-7513 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 132 09/25/05 10:37A (561)543-7513 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 133 09/25/05 12:22P (561)543-7513 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 134 09/25/05 12:27P (561)543-7513 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 135 09/25/05 12:29P (561)543-7513 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 136 09/25/05 03:20P (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 137 09/25/05 03:22P (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 138 09/25/05 03:29P (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 56 07/26/17 Page 61 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 62 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p62

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingu Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Text/Multimedia Msgs For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Sent To Rcvd From 2 Charge Description Charge 139 09/25/05 04:00P (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 140 09/25/05 04:13P (310)210-9944 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 141 09/25/05 04:27P (561)543-7513 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 142 09/25/05 06:11P (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 143 09/25/05 07:28P (561)543-7513 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 144 09/25/05 08:16P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 145 09/25/05 09:20P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 146 09/26/05 07:16P (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 147 09/26/05 07:21P (561)543-7513 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 148 09/26/05 10:12P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 149 09/27/05 08:23A (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 150 09/27/05 08:24A (917)806-5903 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 151 09/27/05 11:37A (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 152 09/27/05 12:58P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 153 09/27/05 01:07P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 154 09/27/05 06:25P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 155 09/27/05 06:45P (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 156 09/27/05 07:10P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 157 09/27/05 07:14P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 158 09/27/05 07:41P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 159 09/27/05 07:42P (917)806-5903 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 160 09/28/05 07:43P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 161 09/28/05 08:27P (646)824-5679 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 57 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 62 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 63 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p63

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Text/Multimedia Msgs For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Sent To Rcvd From Charge Description Charge 162 09/29/05 09:17P (310)210-9944 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 163 09/29/05 09:40P (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 164 09/29/05 10:27P (310)210-9944 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 165 09/29/05 10:30P (310)210-9944 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 166 09/29/05 10:32P (310)210-9944 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 167 09/30/05 07:20P (646)496-3248 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 168 10/01/05 08:56A (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 169 10/01/05 09:42A (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 170 10/01/05 10:01A (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 171 10/01/05 10:50A (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 172 10/01/05 10:52A (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 173 10/01/05 10:53A (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 174 10/01/05 01:57P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 175 10/01/05 02:02P (646)232-3311 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 176 10/01/05 02:07P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 177 10/01/05 02:30P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 178 10/01/05 07:36P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 179 10/01/05 07:42P 447836747546 (917)855-3363 INTL TEXT MSG $0.25 180 10/01/05 07:53P (646)232-3311 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 181 10/01/05 09:43P (917)406-0001 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 182 10/02/05 09:58A (212)444-8021 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 183 10/02/05 09:59A (646)232-3311 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 184 10/02/05 09:59A (310)210-9944 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 58 07/26/17 Page 63 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 64 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p64

153497 BILLED USAGE 3G cingu r 12/14/2005 Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Text/Multimedia Msgs For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Sent To Rcvd From 2 Charge Description Charge 185 10/02/05 10:06A (646)496-3248 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 186 10/02/05 10:36A (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 187 10/02/05 10:59A (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 188 10/02/05 11:48A (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 189 10/02/05 04:10P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 190 10/02/05 05:36P (310)210-9944 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 191 10/02/05 05:45P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 192 10/02/05 06:50P (212)444-8021 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 193 10/02/05 06:53P (212)444-8021 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 194 10/02/05 07:53P (646)496-3248 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 195 10/02/05 09:36P (646)496-3248 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 196 10/02/05 09:43P (212)444-8021 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 197 10/02/05 09:53P (212)444-8021 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 198 10/02/05 09:57P (212)444-8021 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 199 10/02/05 09:57P 917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 200 10/03/05 02:35P (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 201 10/03/05 02:49P (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 202 10/03/05 03:15P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 203 10/04/05 07:10A (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 204 10/04/05 04:40P (917)406-0001 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 205 10/04/05 04:40P (917)406-0001 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 206 10/05/05 05:48P (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 207 10/05/05 07:03P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 59 07/26/17 Page 64 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 65 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p65

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Text/Multimedia Msgs For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Sent To Rcvd From Charge Description Charge 208 10/05/05 07:15P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 209 10/05/05 07:18P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 210 10/05/05 08:07P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 100 INCL. MSGS SENT $0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Page 60 Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 65 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 66 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p66

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G circular Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: 2 Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 1 09/03/05 11:37A * (561)776-5679 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 2 09/03/05 01:15P * (718)361-5768 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 3 09/03/05 01:53P * (561)655-2779 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 4 09/03/05 02:26P * (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 5 09/05/05 01:51P 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 6 09/05/05 01:54P 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 2.29 $4.58 7 09/05/05 09:53P 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 7 2.29 $16.03 8 09/06/05 05:41P 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 9 2.29 $20.61 9 09/07/05 05:19A 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 10 09/07/05 05:20A 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 11 09/07/05 06:11A 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 12 09/07/05 07:58A 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 2.29 $4.58 13 09/07/05 08:38A 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 14 09/07/05 10:06A 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 2.29 $4.58 15 09/07/05 12:35P 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 16 09/08/05 07:47A 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 17 09/08/05 07:47A 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 18 09/08/05 12:01P 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 19 09/09/05 07:12A 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 2.29 $4.58 20 09/09/05 07:14A 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 21 09/09/05 03:10P 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 22 09/10/05 05:17A 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 • - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 1 07/26/17 Page 66 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 67 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p67

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G */,cinguia Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: 2 Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 23 09/10/05 08:20A 513 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 2.29 $2.29 24 09/10/05 03:09P * (917)804-3288 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 25 09/10/05 04:14P * (561)655-7626 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 26 09/10/05 04:31P * (561)655-7629 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 10 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 27 09/10/05 04:44P * (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 28 09/10/05 05:14P (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 29 09/10/05 05:41P * (917)476-9463 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 30 09/10/05 06:33P (917)476-9463 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 31 09/10/05 11:34P * (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 32 09/11/05 08:03A (561)655-7626 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 33 09/11/05 09:09P (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 34 09/11/05 09:55P * (000)000-0000 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 35 09/12/05 10:03A * (212)249-8510 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 36 09/12/05 02:52P * (212)535-5611 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 37 09/12/05 03:42P * (212)750-1176 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 38 09/12/05 04:23P (212)750-1176 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 39 09/12/05 05:15P * (646)824-5679 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 40 09/12/05 05:24P * (212)888-8384 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 41 09/12/05 05:36P * (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 42 09/12/05 05:43P * (212)750-9791 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN * - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 2 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 67 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 68 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p68

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G cingular Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: 2 Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 43 09/12/05 07:49P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 44 09/12/05 11:32P * (917)254-9726 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 45 09/13/05 11:32A * (917)975-4500 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 46 09/13/05 01:16P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 47 09/13/05 01:18P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 48 09/13/05 03:25P * (212)772-3853 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 49 09/13/05 08:04P (212)535-5611 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 50 09/13/05 08:13P (212)535-5611 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 51 09/13/05 08:15P (212)535-5611 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 52 09/13/05 09:21P (917)254-9726 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 53 09/13/05 10:45P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 54 09/13/05 11:55P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 55 09/14/05 09:48A (212)750-1176 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 56 09/14/05 12:29P * (212)750-9896 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 57 09/14/05 12:42P * (212)319-7775 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 58 09/14/05 02:02P * (212)838-9514 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 59 09/14/05 02:22P * (917)204-9696 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 60 09/14/05 03:30P * (212)746-5410 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 61 09/14/05 04:04P * (212)750-1178 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 62 09/14/05 04:05P (212)750-9791 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING • - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 3 07/26/17 Page 68 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 69 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p69

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G cingular - Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Calling Number Number Called Calls To Mins Rate Charge Description Charge Used 09/14/05 04:05P (212)750-9791 (917)855-3363 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 63 09/14/05 04:18P (212)838-9514 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 64 09/14/05 05:02P * (617)495-1953 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 65 09/14/05 05:05P (212)750-1176 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 66 09/14/05 05:35P * (212)750-9894 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 67 09/14/05 05:39P * (212)744-1600 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 68 09/14/05 05:54P (917)204-9696 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 69 09/14/05 06:17P 310 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 70 09/14/05 07:10P * (203)966-1273 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 71 09/14/05 07:35P * (561)317-5844 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 72 09/14/05 08 :02P * (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 73 09/14/05 08 :30P * (617)491-4204 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 4 0.00 74 09/14/05 09 :05P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 75 09/14/05 09 :07P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 76 09/14/05 10 :57P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 77 09/14/05 11 :01P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 78 09/14/05 11 :32P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 9 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 79 09/15/05 09 :49A (212)750-1178 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 80 09/15/05 03 :06P * (917)406-0001 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 4 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 81 09/15/05 03 :13P * (212)772-0939 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 82 09/15/05 04 :21P * (212)355-3350 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 83 09/15/05 06 :00P * (808)754-0079 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 5 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN * - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT Not PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless except under written agreement. and its Affiliates Page 4 07/26/17 Page 69 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 70 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p70

153497 12/14/2005 Calls Destination 3G cingular Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: 2 Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 84 09/15/05 06:46P (808)754-0079 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 6 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 85 09/15/05 07:21P * (917)972-5080 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 86 09/15/05 09:16P (212)772-3853 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 87 09/15/05 10:16P (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 88 09/16/05 10:23A (212)750-9791 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 89 09/16/05 11:38A (808)754-0079 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 90 09/16/05 11:43A (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 5 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 91 09/16/05 12:18P (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 10 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 92 09/16/05 01:18P (212)772-3853 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 93 09/16/05 01:51P (212)750-9894 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 94 09/16/05 04:13P (808)754-0079 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 95 09/16/05 05:10P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 96 09/16/05 05:16P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 97 09/16/05 06:25P (808)754-0079 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 98 09/16/05 09:14P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 99 09/16/05 11:52P (808)754-0079 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 100 09/17/05 08:57A * (212)772-0754 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 101 09/17/05 09:52A (808)754-0079 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 6 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 102 09/17/05 10:06A * (212)772-9416 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 103 09/17/05 11:33A (808)754-0079 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN * - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 5 07/26/17 Page 70 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 71 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p71

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G cingutar® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: 2 Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 104 09/17/05 02:17P (646)824-5679 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 105 09/17/05 02:19P (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 106 09/17/05 02:24P (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 107 09/17/05 02:34P (212)772-0939 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 108 09/17/05 02:45P (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 109 09/17/05 04:06P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 110 09/17/05 04:14P * (201)363-2336 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 111 09/17/05 06:04P (212)772-9416 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 112 09/17/05 06:38P * (212)879-2670 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 6 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 113 09/17/05 07:22P (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 114 09/18/05 08:56A (808)754-0079 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 115 09/18/05 09:39A (212)772-9416 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 116 09/18/05 09:44A (212)772-9416 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 117 09/18/05 10:01A • (516)457-4608 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 118 09/18/05 10:13A (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 119 09/18/05 10:22A (212)772-9416 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 120 09/18/05 10:32A (212)772-3853 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT Not for use PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless except under written agreement. and its Affiliates Page 6 07/26/17 Page 71 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 72 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p72

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G singular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: 2 Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 121 09/18/05 10:40A (212)772-9416 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 122 09/18/05 10:48A (212)772-0754 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 123 09/18/05 12:19P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 124 09/18/05 12:41P * (212)535-3030 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 125 09/18/05 12:46P * (914)669-4651 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 126 09/18/05 12:51P (212)535-3030 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 127 09/18/05 01:06P (212)535-3030 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 128 09/18/05 02:58P (808)754-0079 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 129 09/18/05 03:21P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 130 09/18/05 04:03P (917)204-9696 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 131 09/18/05 04:05P (917)597-8141 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 132 09/18/05 04:10P (561)389-6874 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 133 09/18/05 04:15P (561)302-1844 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 134 09/18/05 06:28P (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 135 09/19/05 09:13A (808)754-0079 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 136 09/19/05 09:41A (000)000-0000 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 5 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 137 09/19/05 10:29A (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 138 09/19/05 10:46A (212)750-1178 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and s not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT Not for use PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 7 07/26/17 Page 72 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 73 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p73

Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: 2 Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 139 09/19/05 11:45A * (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 140 09/19/05 01:54P (561)655-7626 (917)655-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 141 09/19/05 02:01P (561)776-5679 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 142 09/19/05 05:42P (212)535-3030 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 143 09/19/05 06:53P (212)879-2670 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 144 09/20/05 12:10A * (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 145 09/20/05 09:25A (212)750-9791 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 146 09/20/05 09:27A (212)838-9514 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 147 09/20/05 09:39A (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 148 09/20/05 09:47A (212)750-1176 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 149 09/20/05 10:41A * (646)369-7984 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 150 09/20/05 10:44A (212)750-9894 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 151 09/20/05 11:56A * (516)759-2661 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 152 09/20/05 12:27P (212)750-1178 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 153 09/20/05 12:27P (212)750-9896 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 154 09/20/05 12:48P (808)754-0079 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 155 09/20/05 01:19P * (561)309-0079 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 156 09/20/05 03:19P * (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 157 09/20/05 03:21P (212)838-9514 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 158 09/20/05 03:42P (212)838-9514 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 159 09/20/05 03:46P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 160 09/20/05 04:01P (212)750-1178 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN * - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless except under written agreement. and its Affiliates Page 8 153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G cingutar 07/26/17 Page 73 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 74 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p74

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G w` cingular~ Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: 2 Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 161 09/20/05 07:20P (561)317-5844 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 162 09/20/05 07:22P (561)317-5844 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 163 09/20/05 07:22P (561)317-5844 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 164 09/21/05 12:14A (000)000-0000 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 165 09/21/05 12:19A (000)000-0000 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 166 09/21/05 06:51A (000)000-0000 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 167 09/21/05 01:24P (917)406-0001 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 168 09/21/05 01:27P (917)406-0001 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 169 09/21/05 01:46P * (561)818-8361 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 170 09/21/05 01:47P (561)655-7626 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 171 09/21/05 01:48P (561)655-7626 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 172 09/21/05 02:03P * (617)495-3932 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 173 09/21/05 02:03P (617)495-3932 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 174 09/21/05 02:16P (000)000-0000 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 175 09/21/05 02:18P (212)750-9791 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 176 09/21/05 02:19P (212)750-9791 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 177 09/21/05 02:24P (617)495-3932 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 3.49 $6.98 178 09/22/05 11:04A * (917)868-6145 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 179 09/22/05 05:19P (000)000-0000 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 3.49 $6.98 180 09/22/05 05:20P (000)000-0000 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 181 09/23/05 01:48P * (390)283-7266 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 * - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 9 07/26/17 Page 74 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 75 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p75

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G 'cingular ® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: 2 Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 182 09/23/05 02:06P (000)000-0000 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 183 09/23/05 02:35P (212)750-9791 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 184 09/24/05 11:11A (917)476-9463 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 185 09/24/05 11:56A * (917)576-7664 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 186 09/24/05 12:08P * (917)690-8794 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 187 09/24/05 12:22P (917)690-8794 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 188 09/24/05 12:32P * (212)696-2315 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 21 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 189 09/24/05 01:37P * (917)806-5903 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 190 09/24/05 04:42P (212)696-2315 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 6 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 191 09/24/05 05:04P * (646)286-7000 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 192 09/24/05 06:40P * (212)772-0745 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 193 09/24/05 09:49P (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 194 09/24/05 10:23P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 15 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 195 09/25/05 08:40A (917)476-9463 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 196 09/25/05 04:15P (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 197 09/25/05 11:46P (212)879-2670 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 198 09/26/05 08:25A (212)772-0754 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 199 09/26/05 10:07A (212)750-9894 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 200 09/26/05 10:50A (212)772-0754 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 201 09/26/05 12:43P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 202 09/26/05 02:52P * (212)750-9790 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN * - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless except under written agreement. and its Affiliates Page 10 07/26/17 Page 75 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 76 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p76

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G 0 C n ( g Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: 2 Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 203 09/26/05 05:22P (212)750-9894 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 204 09/26/05 08:19P (917)476-9463 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 205 09/27/05 08:52A (646)824-5679 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 206 09/27/05 08:53A (646)824-5679 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 207 09/27/05 09:11A * (212)249-1113 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 208 09/27/05 09:17A * (212)272-6221 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 209 09/27/05 09:19A (212)750-1178 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 210 09/27/05 10:25A (212)838-9514 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 211 09/27/05 10:25A * (212)997-0150 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 212 09/27/05 10:39A * (617)496-4737 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 213 09/27/05 11:18A (212)838-9514 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 214 09/27/05 11:30A * (617)496-4683 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 215 09/27/05 03:27P (212)750-1178 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 216 09/27/05 04:13P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 217 09/28/05 08:52A (212)838-9514 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 218 09/28/05 09:47A (646)824-5679 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 219 09/28/05 10:50A (212)750-1176 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 220 09/28/05 11:13A (212)535-3030 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 221 09/28/05 11:29A * (561)844-4112 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 222 09/28/05 11:31A (212)535-3030 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 223 09/28/05 09:00P * (212)524-9334 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN * - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 11 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 76 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 77 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p77

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G ono u tar Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: 2 Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 224 09/29/05 09:00A (212)750-1176 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 225 09/29/05 11:22A (212)750-9791 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 226 09/29/05 11:26A (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 227 09/29/05 11:50A (212)750-1178 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 228 09/29/05 11:56A (212)772-0754 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 229 09/29/05 11:58A (212)750-1178 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 230 09/29/05 12:27P (212)772-9416 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 231 09/29/05 12:46P (561)635-3454 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 232 09/29/05 12:48P (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 233 09/29/05 12:51P (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 234 09/29/05 01:58P (646)824-5679 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 235 09/29/05 02:16P • (646)414-6627 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 9 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 236 09/29/05 02:43P (000)000-0000 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 237 09/29/05 05:17P (212)750-9791 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 238 09/29/05 06:50P (212)772-9416 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 239 09/29/05 07:57P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 3 0.00 240 09/29/05 08:53P (212)524-9334 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 241 09/29/05 08:54? (212)524-9334 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 12 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 77 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 78 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p78

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)655-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 242 09/29/05 08:57P (212)524-9334 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 243 09/30/05 09:13A (561)655-7629 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 244 09/30/05 10:29A (561)655-7629 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 5 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 245 09/30/05 10:34A (561)655-7629 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 246 09/30/05 02:45P * (636)980-4337 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 5 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 247 09/30/05 07:06P (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 248 09/30/05 07:22P * (646)496-3248 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 249 09/30/05 09:18P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 250 10/01/05 09:35A 1 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 251 10/01/05 11:45A (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 252 10/02/05 01:29A (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 253 10/02/05 10:31A * (561)776-8748 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 254 10/02/05 11:33A * (212)645-3189 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 255 10/02/05 11:34A (212)645-3189 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 256 10/02/05 02:04P (646)496-3248 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 257 10/02/05 03:30P (561)655-7626 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND WIN 258 10/02/05 03:37P * (310)210-9944 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 259 10/02/05 03:53P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 11 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 260 10/02/05 04:12P * (646)232-3311 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 18 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 261 10/02/05 04:32P (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN • - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless except under written agreement. and its Affiliates Page 13 07/26/17 Page 78 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 79 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p79

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G cingular ® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: 2 Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 262 10/02/05 04:38P (310)210-9944 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 8 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 263 10/02/05 05:26P * (212)945-7106 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 7 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 264 10/02/05 05:58P * (646)207-8154 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 265 10/02/05 07:46P (646)496-3248 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 266 10/02/05 09:47P * (561)662-3098 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 267 10/03/05 09:02A (212)750-9894 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 268 10/03/05 09:11A (561)302-1844 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 269 10/03/05 09:14A (561)655-7629 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 270 10/03/05 09:53A * (561)965-1574 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 271 10/03/05 10:24A (212)535-3030 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 272 10/03/05 11:21A (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 273 10/03/05 12:09P * 33140130000 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 274 10/03/05 12:19P (917)690-8794 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 275 10/03/05 12:35P * 447836747546 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 15 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 276 10/03/05 01:45P (561)655-7629 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 277 10/03/05 01:53P (917)957-5341 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 278 10/03/05 07:26P * (212)941-3838 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 279 10/03/05 09:14P (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 280 10/04/05 08:26A (212)838-9514 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN * - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 14 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 79 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 80 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p80

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G cinguiar0 Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Item Date Time Calling Number Bill Cycle: 2 Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 281 10/04/05 10:45A * (212)519-5600 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 282 10/04/05 10:53A (212)750-9896 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 283 10/04/05 11:08A (561)655-7626 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 284 10/04/05 11:14A * (212)750-9895 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 285 10/04/05 11:15A (917)855-3363 INCOMING-- 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 286 10/04/05 11:21A * (212)879-9366 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 287 10/04/05 11:33A (917)406-0001 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 288 10/04/05 01:48P (212)249-8510 (917)655-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 289 10/04/05 03:22P • (212)594-4800 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 290 10/04/05 03:41P (212)535-5611 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 291 10/04/05 07:03P (212)645-3189 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 15 0.00 292 10/04/05 08:34P (212)772-9416 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 293 10/05/05 10:32A (212)535-3030 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 294 10/05/05 10:57A (212)319-7775 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 295 10/05/05 12:01P * (212)535-6831 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 296 10/05/05 12:45P * (212)997-1516 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 297 10/05/05 12:49P (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 298 10/05/05 01:48P (212)750-9791 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 299 10/05/05 03:56P (917)690-8794 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 300 10/05/05 04:02P (212)535-3030 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 301 10/05/05 04:10P * (310)918-3076 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL * - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 15 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 80 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 81 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p81

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Calling Number Number Called Calls To Mins Rate Used 302 10/05/05 05:25P (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 4 0.00 303 10/05/05 05:28P (212)535-3030 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 1 0.00 304 10/05/05 07:24P (646)232-3311 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 15 0.00 305 10/05/05 07:49P (212)879-9366 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 3 0.00 306 10/05/05 08:44P (646)286-7000 (917)855-3363 INCOMING 4 0.00 Charge Description Charge 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN • - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT Not for use PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 16 07/26/17 Page 81 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 82 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p82

153497 12/14/2005 Calls to Destination 3G cingu ar® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:42:59 ATLYS Text/Multimedia Msgs For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Sent To Rcvd From Charge Description Charge * - indicates the first time the calling number appears on the report All "Calls to Destination" and "Subscriber Activity" reports are recorded in Local Switch Time. This data provided may be in pre-bill format. Due to possible data losses it is not necessarily a complete record of all calls, and is not the same as an invoice received by a subscriber. MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 17 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 82 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Entities Mentioned

Courtney Wild

PERSON

1997 British biographical film directed by Brian Gilbert

City in Benton County, Arkansas, United States

Jeffrey Epstein

PERSON • 3 mentions

American sex offender and financier (1953–2019)

State of the United States of America

Statistics

Pages:82

Entities:10

Sponsored

Page 1 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p1

Page 2 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p2

Page 3 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p3

Sponsored

Page 4 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p4

Page 5 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p5

Page 6 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p6

Sponsored

Page 7 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p7

Page 8 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p8

Page 9 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p9

Sponsored

Page 10 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p10

Page 11 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p11

Page 12 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p12

Sponsored

Page 13 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p13

Page 14 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p14

Page 15 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p15

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 175 09/14/05 12:33P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 176 09/14/05 12:37P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 177 09/14/05 12:38P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 178 09/14/05 12:42P (212)319-7775 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 179 09/14/05 12:45P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 180 09/14/05 01:28P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 181 09/14/05 01:43P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM WOOL TO MOBL 182 09/14/05 01:52P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 183 09/14/05 02:02P (212)838-9514 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 184 09/14/05 02:05P (212)746-5410 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 185 09/14/05 02:14P (917)476-9463 NEWYORKZN1 NY 5 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 186 09/14/05 02:22P (917)204-9696 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 187 09/14/05 02:26P (212)956-2888 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 188 09/14/05 02:36P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 189 09/14/05 02:40P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 190 09/14/05 02:42P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 5 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 191 09/14/05 03:15P (917)204-9696 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 192 09/14/05 03:30P (212)746-5410 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 193 09/14/05 03:39P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 10 07/26/17 Page 15 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 16 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p16

Page 17 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p17

Page 18 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p18

Sponsored

Page 19 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p19

Page 20 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p20

Page 21 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p21

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingulaC Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 290 09/16/05 08:36P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 1 0.00 291 09/16/05 09:14P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 292 09/16/05 09:21P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 293 09/16/05 10:00P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 294 09/16/05 10:01P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 295 09/16/05 11:52P (808)754-0079 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 296 09/17/05 08:57A (212)772-0754 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 297 09/17/05 09:52A (808)754-0079 INCOMING 6 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 298 09/17/05 10:06A (212)772-9416 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 299 09/17/05 10:07A (646)369-7984 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 300 09/17/05 10:08A (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 301 09/17/05 10:17A (646)552-2805 NY ZONE 1 NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 302 09/17/05 11:33A (808)754-0079 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 303 09/17/05 11:47A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 304 09/17/05 11:50A (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 305 09/17/05 12:08P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 306 09/17/05 12:09P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 307 09/17/05 02:09P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 308 09/17/05 02:11P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 309 09/17/05 02:12P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 16 07/26/17 Page 21 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 22 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p22

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 310 09/17/05 02:14P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 311 09/17/05 02:17P (646)824-5679 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 312 09/17/05 02:17P (646)824-5679 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 313 09/17/05 02:19P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 314 09/17/05 02:19P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 315 09/17/05 02:24P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 316 09/17/05 02:29P 551181358000 mobile BRA 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 317 09/17/05 02:30P 551181358000 mobile BRA 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 318 09/17/05 02:34P (212)772-0939 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 319 09/17/05 02:45P (917)520-3106 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 320 09/17/05 02:46P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 321 09/17/05 02:49P (212)308-0011 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 322 09/17/05 03:14P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 323 09/17/05 03:18P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 324 09/17/05 04:06P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 325 09/17/05 04:08P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 326 09/17/05 04:09P (212)643-1274 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Page 17 Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 22 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 23 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p23

Page 24 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p24

Sponsored

Page 25 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p25

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 366 09/18/05 10:10A (212)472-6991 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 367 09/18/05 10:12A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 368 09/18/05 10:13A (786)246-6607 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 369 09/18/05 10:14A (718)707-9090 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 370 09/18/05 10:16A (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 371 09/18/05 10:17A (646)369-7984 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 372 09/18/05 10:19A (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 373 09/18/05 10:20A (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 374 09/18/05 10:22A (212)772-9416 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 375 09/18/05 10:25A (718)707-9090 QUEENS NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 376 09/18/05 10:26A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 377 09/18/05 10:27A (917)254-9726 NEWYORKZNI NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 378 09/18/05 10:29A (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 379 09/18/05 10:32A (212)772-3853 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 380 09/18/05 10:34A (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 381 09/18/05 10:38A (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 382 09/18/05 10:39A (917)254-9726 NEWYORKZN1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 383 09/18/05 10:40A (646)369-7984 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 384 09/18/05 10:40A (212)772-9416 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 20 07/26/17 Page 25 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 26 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p26

Page 27 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p27

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 404 09/18/05 12:43P (914)669-4651 NORTHSALEM NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 405 09/18/05 12:46P (914)669-4651 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 406 09/18/05 12:48P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 407 09/18/05 12:51P (212)535-3030 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 408 09/18/05 12:53P (914)669-4651 NORTHSALEM NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 409 09/18/05 12:54P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 410 09/18/05 01:06P (212)535-3030 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 411 09/18/05 01:10P (561)389-6874 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 412 09/18/05 02:57P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 7 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 413 09/18/05 02:58P (808)754-0079 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 414 09/18/05 03:05P (646)232-3311 NWYRCY2N01 NY 17 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 415 09/18/05 03:21P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 416 09/18/05 04:03P (917)204-9696 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 417 09/18/05 04:05P (917)597-8141 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 418 09/18/05 04:10P (561)389-6874 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 419 09/18/05 04:10P (561)389-6874 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 420 09/18/05 04:15P (561)302-1844 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 421 09/18/05 04:31P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 422 09/18/05 05:10P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 423 09/18/05 05:17P (561)324-7996 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 22 07/26/17 Page 27 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 28 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p28

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 424 09/18/05 05:35P (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 425 09/18/05 05:38P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 426 09/18/05 06:28P (917)520-3106 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 427 09/18/05 09:37P (561)714-0546 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 428 09/18/05 09:37P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 429 09/18/05 09:45P (561)714-0546 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 430 09/19/05 09:13A (808)754-0079 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 431 09/19/05 09:41A (000)000-0000 INCOMING 5 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 432 09/19/05 10:29A (561)801-3590 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 433 09/19/05 10:46A (212)750-1178 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 434 09/19/05 11:45A (561)324-7996 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 435 09/19/05 12:27P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 436 09/19/05 12:41P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 437 09/19/05 01:39P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 438 09/19/05 01:43P (212)879-9366 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 439 09/19/05 01:548 (561)655-7626 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 440 09/19/05 02:01P (561)776-5679 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 441 09/19/05 02:24P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 442 09/19/05 02:55P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 23 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 28 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 29 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p29

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 09/19/05 02:55P (917)855-3363 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 443 09/19/05 05:11P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 444 09/19/05 05:42P (212)535-3030 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 445 09/19/05 06:53P (212)879-2670 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 446 09/19/05 09:09P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 447 09/19/05 09:15P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 DROP CALL CREDIT 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 448 09/20/05 12:10A (561)635-3454 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 449 09/20/05 08:59A (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 450 09/20/05 09:25A (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 451 09/20/05 09:27A (212)838-9514 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 452 09/20/05 09:39A (786)246-6607 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 453 09/20/05 09:47A (212)750-1176 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 454 09/20/05 10:41A (646)369-7984 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 455 09/20/05 10:44A (212)750-9894 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 456 09/20/05 11:18A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO NOEL 457 09/20/05 11:56A (516)759-2661 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 458 09/20/05 11:59A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 459 09/20/05 12:24P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 24 07/26/17 Page 29 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 30 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p30

Sponsored

Page 31 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p31

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Rate Charge Description Charge Used 09/20/05 05:16P (917)855-3363 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 479 09/20/05 05:16P (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 480 09/20/05 07:20P (561)317-5844 INCOMING 1 0.00 481 09/20/05 07:21P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 1 0.00 482 09/20/05 07:22P (561)317-5844 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 483 09/20/05 07:22P (561)317-5844 INCOMING 1 0.00 484 09/20/05 10:38P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 485 09/20/05 10:41P (646)552-2805 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 486 09/21/05 12:14A (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 487 09/21/05 12:19A (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 488 09/21/05 12:45A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 489 09/21/05 06:51A (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 490 09/21/05 10:47A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 491 09/21/05 10:48A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 492 09/21/05 01:24P (917)406-0001 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 493 09/21/05 01:27P (917)406-0001 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 494 09/21/05 01:46P (561)818-8361 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 495 09/21/05 01:47P (561)655-7626 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 26 07/26/17 Page 31 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 32 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p32

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 496 09/21/05 01:48P (561)655-7626 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 497 09/21/05 02:03P (617)495-3932 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 498 09/21/05 02:03P (617)495-3932 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 499 09/21/05 02:16P (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 500 09/21/05 02:18P (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 501 09/21/05 02:19P (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 502 09/21/05 02:24P (617)495-3932 INCOMING 2 3.49 $6.98 503 09/21/05 06:56P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 504 09/21/05 07:00P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 505 09/22/05 11:04A (917)868-6145 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 506 09/22/05 05:19P (000)000-0000 INCOMING 2 3.49 $6.98 507 09/22/05 05:20P (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 508 09/23/05 01:48P (390)283-7266 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 509 09/23/05 02:06P (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 510 09/23/05 02:35P (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 3.49 $3.49 511 09/23/05 07:57P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 512 09/24/05 06:23A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 513 09/24/05 10:37A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/wKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 27 07/26/17 Page 32 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 33 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p33

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 514 09/24/05 10:39A (917)576-7664 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 515 09/24/05 10:40A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 516 09/24/05 10:54A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 517 09/24/05 11:06A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 518 09/24/05 11:08A (917)476-9463 NEWYORKZN1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 519 09/24/05 11:10A (917)476-9463 NEWYORKZN1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 520 09/24/05 11:11A (917)476-9463 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 521 09/24/05 11:13A (646)235-5352 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 522 09/24/05 11:39A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 523 09/24/05 11:40A (212)472-6991 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 524 09/24/05 11:41A (917)690-8794 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 525 09/24/05 11:43A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 526 09/24/05 11:43A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 527 09/24/05 11:56A (917)576-7664 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 528 09/24/05 12:08P (917)690-8794 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 529 09/24/05 12:08P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 530 09/24/05 12:09P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 28 07/26/17 Page 33 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 34 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p34

Page 35 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p35

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 551 09/24/05 06:43P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 552 09/24/05 07:31P (917)476-9463 NEWYORKZN1 NY 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 553 09/24/05 08:56P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 554 09/24/05 08:58P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 555 09/24/05 09:08P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 556 09/24/05 09:49P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 5 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 557 09/24/05 10:23P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 15 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 558 09/24/05 10:37P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 8 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WEND MIN 559 09/25/05 08:40A (917)476-9463 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 560 09/25/05 08:56A (917)476-9463 NEWYORKZN1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 561 09/25/05 12:14P (917)576-7664 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 562 09/25/05 12:19P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 563 09/25/05 12:33P (954)647-2020 FTLAUDERDL FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 564 09/25/05 12:34P (917)716-9111 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 565 09/25/05 01:19P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 566 09/25/05 02:53P (917)576-7664 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 567 09/25/05 03:25P (646)552-2805 NY ZONE 1 NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 568 09/25/05 04:05P (614)406-3737 COLUMBUS OH 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 569 09/25/05 04:05P (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 570 09/25/05 04:15P (917)520-3106 INCOMING 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 571 09/25/05 04:20P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 572 09/25/05 04:20P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 30 07/26/17 Page 35 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 36 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p36

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 573 09/25/05 04:22P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 574 09/25/05 04:23P (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 575 09/25/05 04:27P (917)975-4500 BROOKLYN NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 576 09/25/05 04:49P (614)939-3000 NEW ALBANY OH 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 577 09/25/05 05:02P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 578 09/25/05 06:11P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 579 09/25/05 06:13P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 DROP CALL CREDIT 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 580 09/25/05 06:20P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 581 09/25/05 06:21P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 582 09/25/05 06:31P (917)520-3106 NEW YORK NY 4 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 583 09/25/05 06:53P (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 584 09/25/05 08:29P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 585 09/25/05 09:12P (212)752-8883 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 586 09/25/05 09:20P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 587 09/25/05 09:21P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 588 09/25/05 09:28P (212)752-8883 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 589 09/25/05 11:46P (212)879-2670 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 590 09/26/05 08:25A (212)772-0754 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 31 07/26/17 Page 36 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 37 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p37

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 591 09/26/05 08:26A (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 592 09/26/05 08:27A (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 593 09/26/05 08:27A (212)444-8021 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 594 09/26/05 08:28A (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 595 09/26/05 08:30A (646)552-2805 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 596 09/26/05 09:44A (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 17 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 597 09/26/05 10:07A (212)750-9894 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 598 09/26/05 10:50A (212)772-0754 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 599 09/26/05 12:34P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 600 09/26/05 12:37P (917)254-9726 NEWYORKZN1 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 601 09/26/05 12:39P 37068443002 mobile LTU 5 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 4 0.40 51.60 602 09/26/05 12:43P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 603 09/26/05 12:43P (786)246-6607 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 604 09/26/05 12:44P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 605 09/26/05 12:56P (212)746-5410 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 606 09/26/05 01:05P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 607 09/26/05 01:37P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 608 09/26/05 01:38P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 6 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 609 09/26/05 02:52P (212)750-9790 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 610 09/26/05 04:15P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 611 09/26/05 05:05P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 32 07/26/17 Page 37 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 38 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p38

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 612 09/26/05 05:07P (212)779-8800 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 613 09/26/05 05:08P (212)449-9570 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 614 09/26/05 05:22P (212)750-9894 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 615 09/26/05 06:05P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 616 09/26/05 07:41P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 617 09/26/05 07:42P (917)476-9463 NEWYORKZN1 NY 2 0.00 618 09/26/05 08:19P (917)476-9463 INCOMING 3 0.00 619 09/26/05 08:32P (212)255-2221 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 620 09/26/05 08:33P (212)677-4555 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 621 09/26/05 08:36P (212)677-4555 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 622 09/26/05 08:56P (212)677-4555 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 623 09/26/05 10:02P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 624 09/26/05 10:03P (212)444-8021 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 625 09/27/05 08:17A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 626 09/27/05 08:52A (646)824-5679 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 627 09/27/05 08:53A (646)824-5679 INCOMING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 628 09/27/05 08:57A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 629 09/27/05 08:59A (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 630 09/27/05 09:11A (212)249-1113 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 631 09/27/05 09:17A (212)272-6221 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 632 09/27/05 09:19A (212)750-1178 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 633 09/27/05 10:25A (212)838-9514 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 634 09/27/05 10:25A (212)997-0150 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAIT:NG MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENT/AL Page 33 Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 38 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 39 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p39

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 09/27/05 10:25A (212)997-0150 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 635 09/27/05 10:39A (617)496-4737 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 636 09/27/05 10:40A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 637 09/27/05 11:18A (212)838-9514 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 638 09/27/05 11:30A (617)496-4683 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 639 09/27/05 11:34A (718)707-9090 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 640 09/27/05 11:39A (740)802-4061 MARION OH 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 641 09/27/05 12:06P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 642 09/27/05 01:03P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 643 09/27/05 01:20P (212)449-9570 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 644 09/27/05 02:33P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 645 09/27/05 02:38P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 646 09/27/05 03:01P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 647 09/27/05 03:04P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 648 09/27/05 03:27P (212)750-1178 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 649 09/27/05 03:39P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 650 09/27/05 04:13P (786)246-6607 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 651 09/27/05 05:49P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 652 09/27/05 06:37P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 653 09/27/05 09:23P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 654 09/28/05 08:52A (212)838-9514 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 655 09/28/05 09:11A (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 656 09/28/05 09:47A (646)824-5679 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 34 07/26/17 Page 39 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 40 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p40

Page 41 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p41

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 679 09/29/05 11:22A (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 680 09/29/05 11:25A (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 681 09/29/05 11:26A (740)802-4061 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 682 09/29/05 11:30A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MuBL TO MOBL 683 09/29/05 11:35A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 684 09/29/05 11:37A (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 685 09/29/05 11:50A (212)750-1178 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 686 09/29/05 11:56A (212)772-0754 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 687 09/29/05 11:58A (212)750-1178 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 688 09/29/05 12:03P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 5 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 689 09/29/05 12:08P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 690 09/29/05 12:08P (781)308-3269 RANDOLPH MA 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 691 09/29/05 12:27P (212)772-9416 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 692 09/29/05 12:39P (917)204-9696 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 693 09/29/05 12:41P WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 694 09/29/05 12:43P (561)324-7996 WPALMBEACH FL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 695 09/29/05 12:46P INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO NOEL 696 09/29/05 12:47P (561)324-7996 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 697 09/29/05 12:48P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 698 09/29/05 12:51P (917)520-3106 INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO NOEL 699 09/29/05 01:43P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 700 09/29/05 01:47P (212)750-9895 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 36 07/26/17 Page 41 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 42 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p42

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 701 09/29/05 01:49P (646)824-5679 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 702 09/29/05 01:58P (646)824-5679 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 703 09/29/05 02:15P (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 704 09/29/05 02:16P (646)414-6627 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 9 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 705 09/29/05 02:27P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 706 09/29/05 02:30P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 UNLIM NOEL TO MOBL 707 09/29/05 02:43P (000)000-0000 INCOMING 1 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 708 09/29/05 05:17P (212)750-9791 INCOMING 1 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 709 09/29/05 06:41P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO NOEL 710 09/29/05 06:50P (212)772-9416 INCOMING 1 0.00 INCLUDED MINUTES 711 09/29/05 07:45P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 712 09/29/05 07:47P (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 2 0.00 713 09/29/05 07:49P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 1 0.00 714 09/29/05 07:49P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 715 09/29/05 07:50P (917)204-9696 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 716 09/29/05 07:51P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 717 09/29/05 07:52P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 718 09/29/05 07:56P (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 2 0.00 719 09/29/05 07:57P (917)913-6283 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 3 0.00 720 09/29/05 08:45P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 721 09/29/05 08:45P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 37 07/26/17 Page 42 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 43 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p43

Page 44 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p44

Page 45 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p45

Sponsored

Page 46 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p46

Page 47 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p47

Page 48 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p48

Sponsored

Page 49 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p49

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 840 10/03/05 10:24A (212)535-3030 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 841 10/03/05 11:21A INCOMING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 842 10/03/05 12:09P (331)401-3000 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 843 10/03/05 12:11P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 844 10/03/05 12:19P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 845 10/03/05 12:19P (917)690-8794 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 846 10/03/05 12:35P (447)836-7475 INCOMING 15 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 847 10/03/05 12:50P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 848 10/03/05 01:38P (917)406-0001 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 849 10/03/05 01:40P (917)957-5341 NY ZONE 1 NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 850 10/03/05 01:41P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 851 10/03/05 01:45P (561)655-7629 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 852 10/03/05 01:52P (212)249-1122 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 853 10/03/05 01:53P (917)957-5341 INCOMING 0.00 CALL WAITING 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 854 10/03/05 02:24P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 0.00 MESSAGE RETRIEVAL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 855 10/03/05 02:49P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 856 10/03/05 03:45P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 857 10/03/05 03:48P 33155280820 FRANCE 9 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Page 44 Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 49 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 50 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p50

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 10/03/05 03:48P 33155280820 2 Calls To Mins Used 9 Rate 0.07 Charge Description Charge 50.63 858 10/03/05 03:57P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 859 10/03/05 04:00P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 860 10/03/05 04:01P (561)324-7996 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 861 10/03/05 04:02P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 862 10/03/05 07:26P (212)941-3838 INCOMING 1 0.00 863 10/03/05 07:27P (561)655-7626 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 864 10/03/05 07:28P (740)802-4061 MARION OH 2 0.00 865 10/03/05 07:29P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 866 10/03/05 07:34P (212)752-8883 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 867 10/03/05 07:36P (212)628-8419 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 868 10/03/05 09:14P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN 869 10/04/05 06:59A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 870 10/04/05 08:26A (212)838-9514 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 871 10/04/05 08:50A (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 872 10/04/05 08:54A (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 873 10/04/05 08:55A (917)975-4500 BROOKLYN NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 874 10/04/05 08:56A (917)975-4500 BROOKLYN NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 875 10/04/05 09:27A (201)555-1212 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 1.50 411 INFO 51.50 876 10/04/05 09:29A (212)888-8383 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 877 10/04/05 09:36A WPALMBEACH FL 6 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 878 10/04/05 09:47A (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 45 07/26/17 Page 50 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 51 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p51

Sponsored

Page 52 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p52

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: 2 Item Date Time Number Called Calls To Mins Used Rate Charge Description Charge 901 10/04/05 02:37P (646)232-3311 NWYRCY2N01 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 902 10/04/05 02:49P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 903 10/04/05 02:49P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 904 10/04/05 02:50P (786)246-6607 MIAMI FL 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 905 10/04/05 03:22P (212)594-4800 INCOMING 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 906 10/04/05 03:24P (212)249-1113 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 907 10/04/05 03:37P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 908 10/04/05 03:41P (212)535-5611 INCOMING 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 909 10/04/05 03:56P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 910 10/04/05 03:57P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 911 10/04/05 04:30P _. WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 912 10/04/05 04:31P (212)772-3853 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 913 10/04/05 04:44P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 914 10/04/05 07:00P (917)855-3363 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 915 10/04/05 07:02P (310)210-9944 W ANGELES CA 1 0.00 916 10/04/05 07:03P (212)645-3189 INCOMING 15 0.00 917 10/04/05 07:28P (917)868-6145 QUEENS NY 3 0.00 918 10/04/05 07:41P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 919 10/04/05 07:53P (808)754-0079 HONOLULU HI 2 0.00 920 10/04/05 08:13P (917)913-6283 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 921 10/04/05 08:34P (212)772-9416 INCOMING 1 0.00 922 10/04/05 08:35P (561)635-3454 WPALMBEACH FL 1 0.00 " 923 10/04/05 08:35P (212)772-9416 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 47 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 52 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 53 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p53

Page 54 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p54

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G ,cingular® Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Voice Usage For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Number Called 2 Calls To tuns Used Rate Charge Description Charge 946 10/05/05 03:42P (718)707-9090 QUEENS NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 947 10/05/05 03:56P (917)690-8794 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 948 10/05/05 03:57P (212)535-6833 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 949 10/05/05 04:02P (212)535-3030 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 950 10/05/05 04:10P (310)918-3076 INCOMING 2 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 951 10/05/05 04:31P (212)449-9570 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 952 10/05/05 04:42P (646)552-2805 NY ZONE 1 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 953 10/05/05 05:13P (917)690-8794 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 954 10/05/05 05:25P (740)802-4061 INCOMING 4 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 955 10/05/05 05:28P (212)535-3030 INCOMING 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 956 10/05/05 05:45P (646)232-3311 NWYRCYZNO1 NY 2 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 957 10/05/05 05:46P 33155280820 FRANCE 1 0.00 400 ADD'L ANYTME MIN 1 0.07 $0.07 958 10/05/05 05:48P (917)406-0001 NEW YORK NY 3 0.00 UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL 959 10/05/05 07:24P (646)232-3311 INCOMING 15 0.00 960 10/05/05 07:49P (212)879-9366 INCOMING 3 0.00 961 10/05/05 08:44P (646)286-7000 INCOMING 4 0.00 962 10/05/05 08:50P (212)367-7200 NEW YORK NY 1 0.00 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates except under written agreement. Page 49 07/26/17 Page 54 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Sponsored

Page 55 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p55

Page 56 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p56

Page 57 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p57

Sponsored

Page 58 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p58

Page 59 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p59

Page 60 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p60

Sponsored

Page 61 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p61

Page 62 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p62

153497 12/14/2005 BILLED USAGE 3G cingu Run Date: 12/19/05 Run Time: 11:43:35 ATLYS Text/Multimedia Msgs For (917)855-3363 Account Number 0043811863 Bill Cycle: Item Date Time Sent To Rcvd From 2 Charge Description Charge 139 09/25/05 04:00P (917)520-3106 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 140 09/25/05 04:13P (310)210-9944 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 141 09/25/05 04:27P (561)543-7513 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 142 09/25/05 06:11P (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 143 09/25/05 07:28P (561)543-7513 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 144 09/25/05 08:16P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 145 09/25/05 09:20P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 146 09/26/05 07:16P (646)552-2805 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 147 09/26/05 07:21P (561)543-7513 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 148 09/26/05 10:12P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 149 09/27/05 08:23A (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 150 09/27/05 08:24A (917)806-5903 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 151 09/27/05 11:37A (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 152 09/27/05 12:58P (786)246-6607 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 153 09/27/05 01:07P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 154 09/27/05 06:25P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 155 09/27/05 06:45P (740)802-4061 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 156 09/27/05 07:10P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 157 09/27/05 07:14P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 158 09/27/05 07:41P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 159 09/27/05 07:42P (917)806-5903 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 160 09/28/05 07:43P (917)913-6283 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 161 09/28/05 08:27P (646)824-5679 (917)855-3363 TEXT MESSAGES SENT $0.10 MAT PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL Not for use or disclosure outside Cingular Wireless and its Affiliates Page 57 except under written agreement. 07/26/17 Page 62 of 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-295

Page 63 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p63

Sponsored

Page 64 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p64

Page 65 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p65

Page 66 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p66

Sponsored

Page 67 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p67

Page 68 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p68

Page 69 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p69

Sponsored

Page 70 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p70

Page 71 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p71

Page 72 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p72

Sponsored

Page 73 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p73

Page 74 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p74

Page 75 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p75

Sponsored

Page 76 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p76

Page 77 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p77

Page 78 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p78

Sponsored

Page 79 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p79

Page 80 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p80

Page 81 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p81

Sponsored

Page 82 - Epstein_Part_04_Redacted_p82