IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA, FOURTH DISTRICT DCA NO.4D2024-0681 L.T. NO.50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX-MB Appellant(s), VS. Appellee(s). NINA D. BOYAJIAN [email protected] [email protected] MICHAEL J. GRYGIEL [email protected] COLLIN DOERN JACKSON [email protected] JESSICA NEER MCDONALD [email protected] CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC, Publisher of THE PALM BEACH POST APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL (CIRCUIT CIVIL DIVISION) RECORD ON APPEAL DAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney of Palm Beach County, Florida and SHARON R. BOCK, as Clerk and Comptroller of Palm Beach County, Florida RECORDS ON APPEAL 000001 FILED: PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL JOSEPH ABRUZZO, CLERK 04/17/2024 03:04:47 PM NOT A CERTIFIED COPY STEPHEN ARTHUR MENDELSOHN [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] DOUGLAS ARTHUR WYLER [email protected] RECORDS ON APPEAL 000002 NOT A CERTIFIED COPY ____________________________________________________________________ IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA ____________________________________________________________________ Record on Appeal Index Wednesday, April 17, 2024 Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEAC Date Instrument Pages 04/17/24 PROGRESS DOCKET 0008-0013 11/14/19 CIVIL COVER SHEET 0014-0015 11/14/19 COMPLAINT: F/B PLT 0016-0105 11/15/19 VERIFIED MOTION: FOR ADMISSION OF MICHAEL G 0106-0111 11/19/19 ORDER: HAFELE DTD 11/19/19: MOTION TO APP 12/06/19 MOTION TO DISMISS: F/B DFT DAVE ARONBERG AS 0114-0116 12/13/19 MOTION TO DISMISS: F/B DFT SHARON R BOCK AS 0117-0120 01/16/20 ORDER SETTING HEARING: KMARZ DTD 1/16/20 O 0121-0122 01/16/20 VERIFIED MOTION: AS TO PRO HAC VICE OF NINA 0123-0127 01/17/20 COMPLAINT: FIRST AMENDED F/B PLT 0128-0221 01/17/20 NOTICE OF FILING: FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT F 0222-0317 01/21/20 ORDER: KMARX DTD 1/21/20 CANCELLING HEARIN 0318-0319 01/21/20 OBJECTION: PLAINTIFF'S OBJECTION TO DEFENDA 01/22/20 ORDER GRANTING: DHAEFELE DTD 1/22/20 MOTION 0323-0324 01/24/20 ANSWER: TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT AND MOTI 0325-0337 01/24/20 ANSWER: TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT AND MOTI 0338-0351 02/03/20 ORDER SETTING HEARING: MARTZ DTD 2/3/20: 3 0352-0353 03/12/20 NOTICE: OPPOSITION TO DFT DAVE ARONBEG STAT 03/12/20 NOTICE: OPPOSITION TO DFT SHARON R. BOCK CL 03/18/20 MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE CIVIL: PLAINTIFF'S U 0393-0395 03/20/20 ORDER OF CONTINUANCE: MARX DTD 03/19 0396-0397 04/21/20 ORDER RESETTING: ON MOTION TO DISMISS COUNT 05/22/20 ORDER SETTING HEARING: MARX DTD 05/22/20 0400-0403 05/27/20 NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE: CHANGE OF ATTY 0404-0404 06/08/20 ORDER GRANTING: MARX; DFTS MOTIONS TO D 0405-0411 06/10/20 NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE: AND DIRECTIONS 0412-0412 07/01/20 MOTION: DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG'S MOTION F 0413-0414 08/18/20 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT: DEFENDANT DAVE 0415-0423 08/18/20 AFFIDAVIT: AFFIDAVIT_OF DAVID ARONBERG 0424-0425 09/18/20 MOTION: MOTION TO SET CASE MANAGEMENT CONFE 0426-0459 10/02/20 MEMORANDUM OF LAW: IN OPPOSITION TO THE STA 0460-0473 10/14/20 RESPONSE TO:: PLAINTIFF'S MEMORANDUM OF LAW 0474-0498 10/21/20 ORDER: HAFELE DTD 10/21/20: CASE MANAGEMEN 0499-0499 10/21/20 MOTION: MOTION TO SET HEARING ON DEFENDANT, 0500-0501 10/21/20 NOTICE OF DROPPING PARTY: AS TO DFT DAVE AR 0502-0503 10/29/20 MOTION: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO DIRECT THE CL 0504-0507 000003 REDACTED REDACTED REDACTED REDACTED REDACTED NOT A CERTIFIED COPY ____________________________________________________________________ IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA ____________________________________________________________________ Record on Appeal Index Wednesday, April 17, 2024 Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEAC 11/09/20 MOTION: DEFENDANT DAVE ARONBERG'S AMENDED M 0508-0566 11/09/20 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES: AFFIDAVIT OF AT 0567-0586 11/19/20 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES: VERIFIED AFFIDA 0587-0590 01/28/21 NOTICE: OF CHANGE OF ATTORNEY OF RECORD AND 0591-0592 01/28/21 ORDER SETTING HEARING: HAFELE DTD 01/28/202 0593-0595 03/25/21 NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE: CHANGE OF COUN 0596-0596 04/22/21 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT: AND INCORPORAT 0597-0631 04/22/21 APPENDIX: TO MOTION PLTS' MOTION FOR SUMMAR 0632-1341 05/24/21 MOTION: PLAINTIFF CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC 1342-1345 05/25/21 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL: AS COUNSEL FOR 1346-1348 05/25/21 RESPONSE TO:: PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO SCHEDULE 1349-1352 06/11/21 AGREED ORDER: HAFELE; ON PLTF'S MOTION TO S 07/15/21 MEMORANDUM OF LAW: AND RESPONSE IN OPPOSITI 1355-1367 07/23/21 AFFIDAVIT: OF DAVID ARONBERG FIL 1368-1369 07/23/21 TRANSCRIPT: OF HEARING ON 6-3-20 1370-1391 07/23/21 MEMORANDUM OF LAW: IN SUPPORT OF DAVE ARONB 1392-1413 07/26/21 ORDER SETTING HEARING: D HAFELE DTD. 7/26 1414-1417 07/26/21 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL: F/B ATTY WHETST 1418-1420 07/26/21 ORDER RESETTING: DHAFELE DTD 7/26/21 HEARI 1421-1424 07/29/21 MEMORANDUM OF LAW: IN SUPPORTOF DEFENDANT D 1425-1571 08/05/21 MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE CIVIL: JOINT MOTION 1572-1574 08/09/21 ORDER: HAFELE DTD 8/5/21: JOINT MOTION TO 1575-1577 08/12/21 MEMORANDUM OF LAW: AMENDED MEMORANDUM OF LA 1578-1915 10/01/21 RESPONSE TO:: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR SUMMAR 1916-1942 10/05/21 ORDER: HAFELE: CONFIRMING HEARING ON PLAINT 1943-1946 10/13/21 REPLY/RESPONSE: IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF MOYIO 1947-1957 12/20/21 FINAL JUDGMENT: D HAFELE DTD 12/20/2021 1958-1971 01/03/22 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL: AND DESIGNATION 01/03/22 MOTION: CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTR 1975-1979 01/19/22 MOTION: CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTR 1980-1987 01/26/22 NOTICE: CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTR 1988-1989 01/27/22 NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL: ORDER RENDERED ON 1 1990-2010 02/24/22 REPLY/RESPONSE: [AMENDED] AND MEMORANDUM OF 2011-2029 03/30/22 MOTION TO WITHDRAW: F/B DFT JOSEPH ABRUZZO 03/30/22 EXHIBIT: F/B DFT JOSEPH ABRUZZO AS CLERK AN 2033-2034 04/13/22 NOTICE: DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG'S NOTICE O 2035-2036 04/13/22 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES: AMENDED & SUPPL 2037-2118 000004 REDACTED REDACTED REDACTED NOT A CERTIFIED COPY ____________________________________________________________________ IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA ____________________________________________________________________ Record on Appeal Index Wednesday, April 17, 2024 Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEAC 04/14/22 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES: AMENDED AND SUP 2119-2122 05/25/22 ORDER SETTING HEARING: D. HAFELE DTD 05/25/ 2123-2126 06/07/22 ORD SUBSTITUTION COUNSEL: HAFELE; COLIN D J 2127-2129 07/01/22 ORDER SETTING HEARING: HAFELE: (RESETTING) 2130-2132 07/22/22 MOTION: AGREED MOTION OF PLAINTIFF CA FLORI 2133-2152 09/08/22 CLERK'S NOTE: EVIDENTIARY HEARING 9/07/22 2153-2155 09/26/22 MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME: TO SUBMIT WRI 09/28/22 AGREED ORDER: DELGADO: ON JOINT MOTION FOR 2159-2159 10/04/22 EXHIBIT LIST 2160-2161 10/04/22 TRANSCRIPT: HEARING PROCEEDINGS DTD SEPTE 2162-2440 10/06/22 NOTICE: CLOSING ARGUMENT OF DEFENDANT, DAVE 2441-2469 10/06/22 NOTICE: WRITTEN CLOSING ARGUMENT OF CA FLOR 2470-2574 02/01/23 ORDER DENYING: L DELGADO DTD 1/31/23 2575-2576 02/01/23 MOTION: TO ALTER OR AMEND ORDER DENYING THE 2577-2578 02/16/23 RESPONSE TO:: IN OPPOSITION TO STATE ATTY D 2579-2585 03/01/23 NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL: ORDER RENDERED ON 1 2586-2589 03/06/23 ORDER: DELGADO DTD 3/6/23: MOTION TO ALTER 2590-2591 03/10/23 NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL: ORDER RENDERED ON 3 2592-2595 05/11/23 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL: F/B ATTY JACK S 2596-2597 06/09/23 ORDER: DELGADO; DIRECTING CLERK TO COURT TO 2598-2600 06/29/23 ORDER: DELGADO DTD 6/29/23: DIRECTING TRA 2601-2604 02/23/24 MOTION: THE ASSOCIATED PRESS' MOTION FOR LI 2605-2608 02/28/24 AGREED ORDER: L DELGADO DTD. 2/28/24 GRANT 2609-2609 02/29/24 ORDER: L. DELGADO DTD 2/29/2024 ON GRAND JU 2610-2614 03/01/24 MOTION: THE MCCLATCHY COMPANY, LLC'S MOTION 2615-2617 03/04/24 NOTICE: THE MCCLATCHY COMPANY, LLC'S NOTICE 2618-2619 03/05/24 AGREED ORDER: DELGADO DTD 3/5/24: MOTION 2620-2620 03/14/24 NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL: ORDER RENDERED ON 2 2621-2629 04/17/24 CERTIFICATE 4262-4262 000005 REDACTED NOT A CERTIFIED COPY ____________________________________________________________________ IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA ____________________________________________________________________ Record on Appeal Index Wednesday, April 17, 2024 Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEAC Party Description Pages JOINT J18 AFFIDAVIT OF DAVID ARONBERG 2630-2631 JOINT J16 LETTER TO D. WYLER FROM S MENDELSOHN JOINT J24 JACOBS SCHOLZ & WYLER INVOICE 2635-2641 JOINT J20 MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF PLAINTIFF CA HOLDI 2642-2655 JOINT J21 DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG'S RESPONSE TO 2656-2680 JOINT J13 HEARING TRANSCRIPT 2681-2685 JOINT J19 DEFENDANT DAVE ARONBERG'S MOTION FOR SU 2686-2694 JOINT J17 DEFENDANT DAVE ARONBERG'S MOTION FOR AT 2695-2696 JOINT J10 DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG AS STATE ATTOR 2697-2709 JOINT J23 PLAINTIFF CA HOLDINGS, LLC'S NOTICE OF 2710-2711 JOINT J15 ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANTS MOTION TO DIS JOINT J11 DEFENDANT ARONBERG TWITTER POST 2719-2720 JOINT J12 SAO15 PRESS RELEASE 2721-2721 JOINT J22 LETTER TO D. WYLER FROM S MENDELSOHN 2722-2723 JOINT J14 EMAIL TO S. MENDELSOHN FROM D WYLER 2724-2728 JOINT J05 LETTER TO J. HOWARD FROM D. WYLER 2729-2729 JOINT J04 SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT 2730-2821 JOINT J08 ORDER DENYING THE STATE'S MOTION FOR AN 2822-2828 JOINT J06 MOTION TO DISMISS 2829-2831 JOINT J03 LETTER TO MUSGRAVE FROM N. CRUZ JOINT J02 LETTER TO J. PACENTI FROM N. CRUZ 2835-2835 JOINT J07 MOTION FOR AN ORDER UNSEALING GRAND JUR 2836-2841 JOINT J01 LETTER TO D. ARONBERG FROM S. MENDELSOH 2842-2844 JOINT J09 FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT (PART II) 2845-2938 JOINT J09 FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT (PART I) 2939-2964 JOINT J30 FINAL JUDGMENT 2965-2978 JOINT J32 JACOBS SCHOLZ & WYLER INVOICE 2979-2987 JOINT J26 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY'S FEES 2988-3007 JOINT J31 AMENDED RESPONSE AND MEMORANDUM OF LAW 3008-3026 JOINT J28 MOTION OF PLALINTIFF CA FLORIDA HOLDING 3027-3061 JOINT J25 DEFENDANT DAVE ARONBERG'S AMENDED MOTIO 3062-3120 JOINT J37 LETTER FROM M GRYGIEL TO D. ARONBERG 3121-3123 JOINT J34 DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG'S NOTICE OF DR 3124-3125 JOINT J36 JAMES V WILLE, 480 SO.2D. 253 (1985) 3126-3128 JOINT J33 AMENDED & SUPPLEMENTAL AFFIDAVIT OF AT 3129-3210 JOINT J35 AMENDED AND SUPPLEMENTAL AFFIDAVIT OF 3211-3214 000006 REDACTED REDACTED REDACTED NOT A CERTIFIED COPY ____________________________________________________________________ IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA ____________________________________________________________________ Record on Appeal Index Wednesday, April 17, 2024 Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEAC JOINT J29 AMENDED MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT O 3215-3374 JOINT J29 AMENDED MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT O 3375-3552 JOINT J27 APPENDIX TO MOTION OF PLT CA FLORIDA H 3553-3725 JOINT J27 APPENDIX TO MOTION OF PLT CA FLORIDA HO 3726-3900 JOINT J27 APPENDIX TO MOTION OF PLT CA FLORIDA HO 3901-4086 JOINT J27 APPENDIX TO MOTION OF PLT CA FLORIDA HO 4087-4261 000007 NOT A CERTIFIED COPY Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB # Effective Date Count Description 1 11/14/2019 CIVIL COVER SHEET 2 11/14/2019 SUMMONS ISSUED 3 11/14/2019 SUMMONS ISSUED 4 11/14/2019 COMPLAINT 5 11/15/2019 DIVISION ASSIGNMENT 6 11/15/2019 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 7 11/15/2019 VERIFIED MOTION 8 11/15/2019 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 9 11/19/2019 ORDER 10 11/25/2019 SERVICE RETURNED (NUMBERED) 11 11/25/2019 SERVICE RETURNED (NUMBERED) 12 12/6/2019 MOTION TO DISMISS 13 12/13/2019 MOTION TO DISMISS 14 1/16/2020 ORDER SETTING HEARING 15 1/16/2020 VERIFIED MOTION 16 1/17/2020 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 17 1/17/2020 COMPLAINT 18 1/17/2020 NOTICE OF FILING 19 1/21/2020 ORDER 21 1/21/2020 OBJECTION 20 1/22/2020 ORDER GRANTING 22 1/24/2020 ANSWER 23 1/24/2020 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 24 1/24/2020 ANSWER 25 2/3/2020 ORDER SETTING HEARING 26 3/12/2020 NOTICE 27 3/12/2020 NOTICE 28 3/18/2020 MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE CIVIL 29 3/20/2020 ORDER OF CONTINUANCE 30 4/21/2020 ORDER RESETTING 31 5/22/2020 ORDER SETTING HEARING 32 5/27/2020 NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE 33 6/8/2020 ORDER GRANTING 34 6/10/2020 NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE 35 7/1/2020 MOTION Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE 000008 NOT A CERTIFIED COPY Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB # Effective Date Count Description Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE 36 7/10/2020 REQUEST TO PRODUCE 37 7/24/2020 REQUEST TO PRODUCE 38 8/18/2020 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 39 8/18/2020 AFFIDAVIT 40 9/2/2020 RESPONSE TO REQ TO PRODUCE 41 9/18/2020 MOTION 42 9/22/2020 NOTICE OF HEARING 43 10/2/2020 MEMORANDUM OF LAW 44 10/2/2020 RESPONSE TO: 45 10/14/2020 RESPONSE TO: 46 10/21/2020 ORDER 47 10/21/2020 MOTION 48 10/21/2020 NOTICE OF DROPPING PARTY 49 10/29/2020 MOTION 50 11/9/2020 MOTION 51 11/9/2020 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES 52 11/19/2020 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES 53 12/3/2020 NOTICE OF NON JURY TRIAL 54 12/10/2020 NOTICE OF NON JURY TRIAL 55 1/28/2021 NOTICE 56 1/28/2021 ORDER SETTING HEARING 57 3/25/2021 NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE 58 4/22/2021 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 59 4/22/2021 APPENDIX 60 5/24/2021 MOTION 61 5/25/2021 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL 62 5/25/2021 RESPONSE TO: 63 6/11/2021 AGREED ORDER 64 7/15/2021 MEMORANDUM OF LAW 66 7/23/2021 AFFIDAVIT 67 7/23/2021 TRANSCRIPT 68 7/23/2021 MEMORANDUM OF LAW 65 7/26/2021 ORDER SETTING HEARING 69 7/26/2021 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL 70 7/26/2021 ORDER RESETTING 000009 NOT A CERTIFIED COPY Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB # Effective Date Count Description Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE 71 7/29/2021 MEMORANDUM OF LAW 72 8/5/2021 MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE CIVIL 73 8/9/2021 ORDER 74 8/12/2021 MEMORANDUM OF LAW 75 10/1/2021 RESPONSE TO: 76 10/5/2021 ORDER 77 10/13/2021 REPLY/RESPONSE 78 12/20/2021 FINAL JUDGMENT 79 12/20/2021 DISPOSED AFTER OTHER 80 1/3/2022 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL 81 1/3/2022 MOTION 82 1/19/2022 MOTION 89 1/26/2022 NOTICE 83 1/27/2022 NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL 84 1/27/2022 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 85 1/27/2022 AUTOMATIC RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING 86 1/27/2022 ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF NEW CASE 87 1/27/2022 TRUE COPY 88 1/28/2022 TRUE COPY 90 2/24/2022 REPLY/RESPONSE 91 3/22/2022 INDEX TO RECORD ON APPEAL 92 3/22/2022 INVOICE 93 3/23/2022 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 94 3/25/2022 AUTOMATIC RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING 95 3/30/2022 MOTION TO WITHDRAW 96 3/30/2022 EXHIBIT 99 4/13/2022 NOTICE 100 4/13/2022 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES 97 4/14/2022 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 98 4/14/2022 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES 101 4/20/2022 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 102 4/28/2022 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 103 5/25/2022 ORDER SETTING HEARING 104 5/31/2022 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 105 6/2/2022 NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 000010 NOT A CERTIFIED COPY Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB # Effective Date Count Description Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE 106 6/7/2022 ORD SUBSTITUTION COUNSEL 107 7/1/2022 ORDER SETTING HEARING 108 7/22/2022 MOTION 109 9/1/2022 EVIDENCE/EXHIBIT LIST FILED 110 9/8/2022 CLERK'S NOTE 111 9/26/2022 MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME 112 9/28/2022 AGREED ORDER 113 10/4/2022 EXHIBIT LIST 114 10/4/2022 TRANSCRIPT 115 10/6/2022 NOTICE 116 10/6/2022 NOTICE 117 2/1/2023 ORDER DENYING 118 2/1/2023 MOTION 119 2/16/2023 RESPONSE TO: 120 3/1/2023 NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL 121 3/1/2023 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 122 3/1/2023 AUTOMATIC RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING 123 3/3/2023 ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF NEW CASE 124 3/6/2023 TRUE COPY 125 3/6/2023 ORDER 126 3/10/2023 NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL 127 3/10/2023 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 128 3/20/2023 TRUE COPY 129 3/27/2023 EXHIBIT CHECK OUT RECEIPT 130 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 131 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 132 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 133 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 134 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 135 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 136 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 137 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 138 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 139 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 140 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 000011 NOT A CERTIFIED COPY Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB # Effective Date Count Description Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE 141 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 142 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 143 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 144 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 145 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 146 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 147 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 148 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 149 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 150 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 151 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 152 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 153 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 154 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 155 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 156 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 157 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 158 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 159 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 160 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 161 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 162 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 163 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 164 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 165 3/27/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 166 3/28/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 167 3/28/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 168 3/28/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 169 3/28/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 170 3/28/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 171 3/28/2023 JOINT EVIDENCE 172 4/5/2023 INDEX TO RECORD ON APPEAL 173 4/5/2023 INVOICE 174 4/14/2023 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 175 4/17/2023 AUTOMATIC RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING 000012 NOT A CERTIFIED COPY Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB # Effective Date Count Description Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE 176 4/20/2023 EXHIBIT CHECK IN RECEIPT 177 5/2/2023 TRUE COPY 178 5/11/2023 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL 179 5/26/2023 MANDATE REVERSED/REMANDED 188 5/26/2023 ADDITIONAL COMMENTS 180 6/9/2023 ORDER 181 6/29/2023 ORDER 182 2/23/2024 MOTION 183 2/28/2024 AGREED ORDER 184 2/29/2024 ORDER 185 3/1/2024 MOTION 186 3/4/2024 NOTICE 187 3/5/2024 AGREED ORDER 189 3/14/2024 NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL 190 3/14/2024 PAID <AMOUNT> ON RECEIPT <NUMBER> 191 3/14/2024 OPINION 192 3/15/2024 AUTOMATIC RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING 193 3/15/2024 ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF NEW CASE 194 3/15/2024 TRUE COPY 195 4/3/2024 MOTION 196 4/4/2024 MANDATE-AFFIRMED 000013 NOT A CERTIFIED COPY o Kg JOSEPH ABRUZZO CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTROLLER PALM BEACH COUNTY County Civil Division PO Box 3406 West Palm Beach, FL 33402 P: (561) 355-2500 | F: (561) 355-6211 ^£EACHCO^ s® s eEACHC^ Main Courthouse 205 N. Dixie Hwy. West Palm Beach, FL North County Courthouse 3188 PGA Blvd. Palm Beach Gardens, FL Midwestern Service Center 200 Civic Center Way, Suite 500 Royal Palm West County Courthouse 2950 State Road 15, Room S-100 Belle Glade, FL South County Courthouse 200 W. Atlantic Ave. Delray Beach, FL CERTIFICATE OF THE CLERK I, JOSEPH ABRUZZO, Clerk of the Circuit Court & Comptroller, in and for Palm Beach County, State of Florida, do hereby certify that the foregoing pages of: vs CASE NO: contains true and correct transcripts and copies of all such papers and proceedings in said cause as appears from the records and files of my office that have been directed to be included in said RECORD by the directions furnished to meZLWKDOOUHGDFWLRQVUHTXLUHGE\ODZUXOHRU DGPLQLVWUDWLYHRUGHU IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto my hand affixed the seal of the court, this JOSEPH ABRUZZO CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTROLLER Palm Beach County, FL. By: Deputy Clerk 004262 CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST DAVE ARONBERG 50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX-MB 4D2024-0681 Brent Robbins 17th of April, 2024 4th DCA NO.: NOT A CERTIFIED COPY JOSEPH ABRUZZO County Civil Division PO Box 3406 West Palm Beach, FL 33402 CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTROLLER PALM BEACH COUNTY P: (561) 355-2500 I F: (561) 355-6211 cu\TCO 6~ 'k-- f.;, t ,.,. ~ ~ i:t; .___ r Main Courthouse 205 N. Dixie Hwy. West Palm Beach, FL North County Courthouse 3188 PGA Blvd. Palm Beach Gardens, FL Midwestern Service Center 200 Civic Center Way, Suite 500 Royal Palm Beach, FL West County Courthouse 2950 State Road 15, Room S-100 Belle Glade, FL South County Courthouse 200 W. Atlantic Ave. Delray Beach, FL

No text available for this page

No text available for this page

No text available for this page

No text available for this page

No text available for this page

No text available for this page

No text available for this page

No text available for this page

No text available for this page

No text available for this page

No text available for this page

No text available for this page

No text available for this page