WheelTug Arfl ...IP Slower on the ground = trailing financial performance Ground Efficiency Is Critical 35% ASIA AirAsia 30% - 25% 20% AL 15% Juneyaos • Air China • Air NZ 10% • Ilfrefiainan Spring ., • ••• 5% re*/Scoot/Tiger* • Asiana 0% Thai • -5% -10% •15% Nok • 0% 110 2 million + flights: /0 f.0 14-20 Aug 2016 22-28 Nov 2016 19-26 Apr 2017 Operating Margin EUROPE El Al lwanAir• Win le easTlet, Aeroflot • IAG :'Pegasus • * Lufthansa Innair • • SAS AF-KLM 26% -, 30% N. AMERICA 20% 15% 10% Operating Margin Allegiant • Alaska Spirit • • Delta' Jetelue 7 Southwest ...'" ••• • American • • United Westlet 44AI.r Canada 0I4t, 120 1to.; 10) 120 14/ Average Narrowbody Ground Times (Min.) • Carriers reporting > 2000 flights • Excludes ground times > 180 minutes • Norrowbodies only for FY2015 and 2016 p Data From: 25% 20% 15% 10% @flightradar LIVE AIR TRAFFIC CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0067694 CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00213878 EFTA01373488