5
Shared Docs
5
Same-Page
9 / 5
Mentions
n 19 court to Fowler White for one purpose and one 20 much of the rest of the argument becomes 20 purpose only; and that was to print them out, Bates 21 irrelevant. 'here are, however, very significant 21 steep then so that they could be turned over for 22 substantive issues if the procedura
ware divided into three different 12 thin is 27,000 e-mails, they want than, they should 12 categorie➢. 13 be responsible for printing than and Bates stamping 12 THE COURT: And chat wa➢ December 102 14 them and delivering those printed and Bates stamped 14 M. SCAMLA: Decenbar Bch of 2010. IS
s. we got 12 master. They don't went to. II the original boxes and found the disk in a folder 13 THE COURT: It's Just too late. II that says J. Carney printing on it. That's it. 16 NR. LINK: But Judge, the truth is never too II That's all that's on this folder. 15 late. 14 There's no water
n 19 court to Fowler White for one purpose and one 20 much of the rest of the argument becomes 20 purpose only; and that was to print them out, Bates 21 irrelevant. 'here are, however, very significant 21 steep then so that they could be turned over for 22 substantive issues if the procedura
ware divided into three different 12 thin is 27,000 e-mails, they want than, they should 12 categorie➢. 13 be responsible for printing than and Bates stamping 12 THE COURT: And chat wa➢ December 102 14 them and delivering those printed and Bates stamped 14 M. SCAMLA: Decenbar Bch of 2010. IS
s. we got 12 master. They don't went to. II the original boxes and found the disk in a folder 13 THE COURT: It's Just too late. II that says J. Carney printing on it. That's it. 16 NR. LINK: But Judge, the truth is never too II That's all that's on this folder. 15 late. 14 There's no water
2 of 23 Epstein or his legal counsel might misappropriate these documents while in their physical possession for the limited purpose of copying and Bates numbering them, this Court specifically ordered that "Fowler White will not retain any copies of the documents contained on the discs provided to i
ad represented a number of Epstein's victims in their civil suits against Epstein. Farmer Jaffe sought to have Epstein bear the costs of copying and Bates stamping these thousands of documents [DE 1120], ultimately resulting in an order from this Court that Epstein's counsel— attorneys at the law firm
hese issues came up, we asked Fowler White to please give us the original boxes. We got the original boxes and found the disc in a folder that says J. Carney printing on it. That's it. That's all that's on this folder." Hearing Trans. at 45:11-15. Epstein's counsel then conjectured certain speculative sce
.) THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Going back on the record. The time is 1:22 p.m. BY MR. SCAROLA: Q Could you explain to us, please, the origin of documents Bates stamped FW0000183 through 215? MR. LINK: Before he does that, Mr. Scarola, I would like to see what it is Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc. 561-4
rting Service, Inc. 561-471-2995 EFTA00803744 11'1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 the Bates number? MR. SCAROLA: Yes. 110. How kind of you. MR. IANNO: Make it simple. That way you don't have to give up your copy. THE WITNESS: The answer
. MR. LINK: Mr. Scarola, can you for the record state -- I can see on the first page it says something. What does that say? MR. SCAROLA: It says, J. Carney, dash, Printing of CD Issue. BY MR. SCAROLA: Q Do you know whose handwriting that is? A I have no idea. Q Was this part of the documents insi
tein, who had agreed to pay directly all such fees and costs. It was then determined that the number of documents that would need to be printed and Bates stamped exceeded 27,000, which would have resulted in significant costs to the Farmer Jaffe law firm. Consequently, Farmer Jaffe requested the Cour
0, 2010 Order strictly precluded Fowler White from possessing, Mr. Hurley also discovered in Fowler White's possession a folder bearing the writing "J. Carney — Printing of CD issue —." This folder contained 32 printed, hard copy emails, 24 of which are currently listed on the Fanner Jaffe privilege log a
Entities connected to both Bates and J. Carney

Jeffrey Epstein
PERSON
Bradley Edwards
PERSONMaria Farmer
PERSONJane Doe
PERSON
Paul Cassell
PERSONJack Goldberger
PERSONScott Rothstein
PERSONJack Scarola
PERSON
Fowler
PERSON
Salt Lake City
LOCATIONFowler White's
ORGANIZATIONJaffe
PERSONJoseph L. Ackerman
PERSON
Donald Trump
PERSONCarney
PERSON
Weissing
PERSONPalm Beach Lakes Boulevard
LOCATION
Joe Biden
PERSON
George Mitchell
PERSON
Naomi Campbell
PERSON