Epstein Secrets

I, Circuit Judges. Phrinifff-Appellee, 20-2413-cv v. GHISLAINE MAXWELL, Defendant-Appellant, SHARON CHURC:HER, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, Respondents, JULIE BROWN, MIAMI HERALD MEDIA COMPANY, MICHAEL CERNOVICH, DBA CERNOVICH MEDIA, Intervenors. EFTA00018289 --- PAGE BREAK --- Case 20-2413. Document 140-1,

udges. Phrinifff-Appellee, 20-2413-cv v. GHISLAINE MAXWELL, Defendant-Appellant, SHARON CHURC:HER, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, Respondents, JULIE BROWN, MIAMI HERALD MEDIA COMPANY, MICHAEL CERNOVICH, DBA CERNOVICH MEDIA, Intervenors. EFTA00018289 --- PAGE BREAK --- Case 20-2413. Document 140-1, 10/19/2020, 2955244, Page2

ere is a lower presumption of access to the deposition materials at issue in this case than to the summary judgment materials we ordered unsealed in Brown v. Atwavehc 929 F.3d 41 (2d Cir. 2019), and that her interests outweigh the public's interests. We assume the parties' familiarity with the underly

he court's factual findings for clear error, its legal determinations de novo, and its ultimate decision to seal or unseal for abuse of discretion." Brown, 929 F.3d at 47 (citing Bernstein v. Bernstein Litowitt Berger dr Grossman LLP, 814 F.3d 132, 139 (2d Cir. 2016)). A district court abuses its disc

T COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK Virginia L. Giuffre, Plaintiff, v. Ghislaine Maxwell, Defendant. Case No.: 15-cv-07433-RWS INTERVENORS' JULIE BROWN AND MIAMI HERALD MEDIA CO.'S RESPONSE TO MAXWELL'S OBJECTIONS TO UNSEALING Sanford L. Bohrer Christine N. Walz 31 West 52nd Street New York, NY

r Christine N. Walz 31 West 52nd Street New York, NY 10019 Telephone: 212.513.3200 Fax: 212.385.9010 Attorneys for Intervenors Julie Brown and Miami Herald Media Company EFTA00017074 --- PAGE BREAK --- casQac,./g%261'43g-ceg‘FenbegrrieRFA004lieif36643026'act6@f218f 10 Pursuant to this Court's Order and protocol f

nd these documents should be unsealed in their entirety. The objections mischaracterize the governing law, including the Second Circuit's ruling in Brown v. Maxwell, 929 F.3d 41 (2d. Cir. 2019); rely upon general "alleged countervailing interests" against disclosure that are not supported by the exten

n Churcher, Jeffrey Epstein, Respondents, Julie Brown, Miami Herald Media Company, Alan M. Dershowitz,

thousand twenty. Plaintiff-Appellee, ORDER v. 20-2413 Ghislaine Maxwell, Defendant-Appellant. Sharon Churcher, Jeffrey Epstein, Respondents, Julie Brown, Miami Herald Media Company, Alan M. Dershowitz, Michael Cemovich, DBA Cemovich Media, Intervenors. It is hereby ORDERED that the United States sh

ty. Plaintiff-Appellee, ORDER v. 20-2413 Ghislaine Maxwell, Defendant-Appellant. Sharon Churcher, Jeffrey Epstein, Respondents, Julie Brown, Miami Herald Media Company, Alan M. Dershowitz, Michael Cemovich, DBA Cemovich Media, Intervenors. It is hereby ORDERED that the United States shall submit an amicus letter

novich Media; Miami Herald Media Company; Julie Brown; Alan M. Dershowitz Material Witness: Miscella

Pottinger Interested Party: NYP Rings, •lmrI Daily News, L.P. Intervenor: Michael Cernovich d/b/a Cernovich Media; Miami Herald Media Company; Julie Brown; Alan M. Dershowitz Material Witness: Miscellaneous: Respondent: Sharon Churcher; Jeffrey Epstein DOCKET CASE NUMBER: 1:15cv7433 For internal

017) Applicant: John Stanley Pottinger Interested Party: NYP Rings, •lmrI Daily News, L.P. Intervenor: Michael Cernovich d/b/a Cernovich Media; Miami Herald Media Company; Julie Brown; Alan M. Dershowitz Material Witness: Miscellaneous: Respondent: Sharon Churcher; Jeffrey Epstein DOCKET CASE NUMBER: 1:15cv7433

ttinger Interested Party NYP Holdings, Inc.,: Daily News, L.P. Intervenor: Michael Cernovich d/b/a Cernovich Media; Miami Herald Media Company; Julie Brown; Alan M. Dershowitz Material Witness Miscellaneous: Respondent: Sharon Churcher; Jeffrey Epstein DOCKET CASE NUMBER: 1:15cv7433 For internal u

novich Media; Miami Herald Media Company; Julie Brown; Alan M. Dershowitz Material Witness Miscellan

) Applicant: John Stanley Pottinger Interested Party NYP Holdings, Inc.,: Daily News, L.P. Intervenor: Michael Cernovich d/b/a Cernovich Media; Miami Herald Media Company; Julie Brown; Alan M. Dershowitz Material Witness Miscellaneous: Respondent: Sharon Churcher; Jeffrey Epstein DOCKET CASE NUMBER: 1:15cv7433

n Churcher, Jeffrey Epstein, Respondents, Julie Brown, Miami Herald Media Company, Alan M. Dershowitz,

thousand twenty. Plaintiff-Appellee, ORDER v. 20-2413 Ghislaine Maxwell, Defendant-Appellant. Sharon Churcher, Jeffrey Epstein, Respondents, Julie Brown, Miami Herald Media Company, Alan M. Dershowitz, Michael Cemovich, DBA Cemovich Media, Intervenors. It is hereby ORDERED that the United States sh

ty. Plaintiff-Appellee, ORDER v. 20-2413 Ghislaine Maxwell, Defendant-Appellant. Sharon Churcher, Jeffrey Epstein, Respondents, Julie Brown, Miami Herald Media Company, Alan M. Dershowitz, Michael Cemovich, DBA Cemovich Media, Intervenors. It is hereby ORDERED that the United States shall submit an amicus letter

thousand twenty. Plaintiff-Appellee, ORDER v. 20-2413 Ghislaine Maxwell, Defendant-Appellant. Sharon Churcher, Jeffrey Epstein, Respondents, Julie Brown, Miami Herald Media Company, Alan M. Dershowitz, Michael Cemovich, DBA Cemovich Media, Intervenors. It is hereby ORDERED that the United States sh

n Churcher, Jeffrey Epstein, Respondents, Julie Brown, Miami Herald Media Company, Alan M. Dershowitz,

ty. Plaintiff-Appellee, ORDER v. 20-2413 Ghislaine Maxwell, Defendant-Appellant. Sharon Churcher, Jeffrey Epstein, Respondents, Julie Brown, Miami Herald Media Company, Alan M. Dershowitz, Michael Cemovich, DBA Cemovich Media, Intervenors. It is hereby ORDERED that the United States shall submit an amicus letter

thousand twenty. Plaintiff:Appellee, ORDER v. 20-2413 Ghislaine Maxwell, Defendant-Appellant. Sharon Churcher, Jeffrey Epstein, Respondents, Julie Brown, Miami Herald Media Company, Alan M. Dershowitz, Michael Cemovich, DBA Cemovich Media, Intervenors. It is hereby ORDERED that the United States sh

ty. Plaintiff:Appellee, ORDER v. 20-2413 Ghislaine Maxwell, Defendant-Appellant. Sharon Churcher, Jeffrey Epstein, Respondents, Julie Brown, Miami Herald Media Company, Alan M. Dershowitz, Michael Cemovich, DBA Cemovich Media, Intervenors. It is hereby ORDERED that the United States shall submit an amicus letter