3
Shared Docs
1
Same-Page
3 / 3
Mentions
l discovery regarding potentially sovereign alter ego co-defendant without further im- pinging that defendant's immunity) (quot- ing Arriba Ltd. v. Petroleos Mexicanos, 962 F.2d 528, 534 (5th Cir.1992) ("At the very least, discovery should be ordered 783 circumspectly and only to verify allega- tions of specific
wealthy Saudis to the Tali- ban and al Qaeda. Ashton Complaint 1259; Federal 1451. Additionally, the Federal Plaintiffs claim that, while Prince Turki was the head of DGI, Saudi Arabian intelligence officers allegedly trained a member of the al Qaecla Spanish cell in explosives and provided mater
the allegations concerning acts tak- en in his personal, as opposed to official, capacity. Id. Judge Robertson dismissed the complaint against Prince Turki for lack of subject matter jurisdiction as well. Id. Prince Sultan and Prince Turki both move to dismiss the complaints against them in Ashton v. Al
Page: HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017845 →nal discovery regarding potentially sovereign alter ego co-defendant without further im- pinging that defendant’s immunity) (quot- ing Arriba Ltd. v. Petroleos Mexicanos, 962 F.2d 528, 534 (th Cir.1992) (“At the very least, discovery should be ordered circumspectly and only to verify allega- tions of specific facts c
Page: HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017848 →906 F.Supp. 204, 210 (S.D.N.Y.1995) (internal quotations omitted); see also Terrorist Attacks I, 349 F.Supp.2d at 788-89 (finding Princes Sultan and Turki were foreign states for FSIA purposes to the extent Plaintiffs alleged liability for actions taken in their official capacities). 1. SHC (51 SHC co
Page: HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017916 →Court is hesitant to do unnecessarily. See First City, Texas—Houston, N.A. v. Rafidain Bank, 150 F.3d 172, 176 (2d Cir.1998); see also Arriba Ltd. v. Petroleos Mexicanos, 962 F.2d 528, 534 (Sth Cir.1992) (recommending that “discovery should be ordered circumspectly and only to verify allegations of specific facts cruc
Page: HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017932 →Entities connected to both Petroleos Mexicanos and Turki

Saudi Arabia
LOCATION
United States
LOCATION
Arabia
LOCATION
Osama bin Laden
PERSON
Bill Clinton
PERSON
Lebanon
LOCATION
General Motors
ORGANIZATIONCasey
PERSONBosnia
LOCATION
New York City
LOCATION
Sudan
LOCATION
Michael Cohen
PERSONAl Qaeda Islamic Army
ORGANIZATIONUngar
PERSON
Khalifa
PERSON
Batterjee
PERSON
Kenya
LOCATION
Philadelphia
LOCATIONKadic
PERSONArndt
PERSON