Epstein Secrets

st 11:44 AM 411 8/24/04 DIrAsst 11:46 AM 8/24(04 Bklyn Nyc, NY 3:12 PM (F) 8/24/04 Incoming 5:54 PM 8/24/04 Bklyn Nye, NY 6:28 PM 6/24/04 Monroe, MI 6:34 PM (A) 8/24/04 Incoming 8:35 PM (A) 8/24/04 incoming 7:39 PM (F) 8/24/04 Holyoke, MA 8:30 PM 8/24/04 Bklyn Nyc, NY 9:03 PM 824/

ye, NY 1207 AM 7/28/04 incoming 12:09 AM 1 7/28/04 Holyoke, MA 12:16 AM 7/28/04 Claw. CA 12:18 AM 1 7/28/04 Chico, CA 12:17 AM $ 7/28/04 San Fran, CA 1220 AM S 7/28/04 San Fran, CA 1220 AM (A) 23 7/28/04 incoming 1228 AM (A) 7/28/04 Bldyn Nye, NY 12:42 AM 7/28/04 incoming 12A4 AM

Number Call Type Minutes Airtime Charges Toll Charges Total 8/15/04 Bktyn Nye, NY 3:05 PM 8/15/04 Queens Nye, NY 3:06 PM $ - S 8115/04 San Fran, CA 3:07 PM 3 S 8/15/04 Incoming 4:06 PM 2 $ 8115/04 Incoming 5:12 PM 2 $ $ 8/15/04 Bklyn Nyc. NY 5:15 PM 1 8/15/04 Bklyn Nye. NY 5

1117/05 New York, NY 2:48 PM 1/17/05 Incoming 2:54 PM 1117105 Incoming 3:06 PM 1/17/05 Incoming 3:50 PM 1117106 Monroe. Ml 4:03 PM 1/17/05 Monroe, MI 4:05 PM 1/17/05 Incoming 4:28 PM 1/17/05 New York, NY 4:32 PM 1/17/05 Newark, NJ 4:41 PM 1/17/05 Brentwood, NY 6:39 PM 1/17/05 Incoming

ew Yodc, NY 7:48 PM F) 1 $ - $ $ 1/19/05 New York. NY 7:47 PM F) 3 S - S $ 1119105 New York, NY 8:08 PM F) 11 $ - S $ 1/19105 San Fran, CA 825 PM 9 $ - $ S 1/19/05 New York, NY 8:42 PM F) 1 S - $ $ 1/19/05 New York, NY 8:43 PM F) 1 S - $ - S 1/19,05 Queens Nyc

Amherst, MA 8:30 PM 1/09/05 New York, NY 9:0B PM 1/09105 New York, NY 9:09 PM 1/09/05 Newark, NJ 9:39 PM 1/09/05 Chico, CA 11:33 PM 1/09/06 San Fran, CA 11:34 PM 1/10/05 Incoming 12:09 AM 1/10/05 Incoming 12:65 ANA 1/10/05 New York, NY 2:34 AM 1/10/05 Incoming 9:25 AM 1/10/05 Incoming 1

aintiffs may "not simply plead" that the relevant requirements have been met, but must "actually prove" it. Halliburton, 134 S. Ct. at 2412; accord Monroe, 579 F.3d at 384. To meet that standard, plaintiffs must summon For internal use only SDNY_GM_00056849 CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.ctON(F ID

7739, "; 126 Fair Empl. Prac. Cas. (BNA) 1793; 99 Empl. Prac. Dec. (CCH) P45,306 is evenhandedly applied." San Remo Hotel, L.P. v. City & Cnty. of San Fran., Cal., 545 U.S. 323, 345, 125 S. Ct. 2491, 162 L. Ed. 2d 315 (2005). Evenhandedness is nowhere to be found here, so justice remains unserved. Per

ing 1:11 AM 0') 1 - $ 5/14/05 New York, NY 1:13 AM 1 $ $ 5/14/05 Amherst, MA 1:14 AM S $ 5/14/05 Newark, NJ 1:16 AM 2 - $ 5/14/05 Monroe, MI 1:27 AM - $ 5/14/05 Amherst, MA 1:28 AM 2 S S $ 5/14/05 New York, NY 1:30 AM 0') 1 $ - $ $ 5/14/05 New York, NY 1:33 AM 1 -

05 New York. NY 8:49 PM 11/28/05 New York, NY 8:50 PM 11128105 DIrAsst 8:54 PM 11/28/05 Incoming 8:56 PM 11/28/05 Incoming 9:08 PM 11/28/05 San Fran, CA 10:00 PM 11/28/05 Incoming 10:01 PM (F) (A) 1 $ - S S $ $ 2 - $ S - $ $ 2 - S $ 1 S - $ 1 - $ $ $ 2 - $ 1.25